Tulic Sadbera- Seminarski Rad (CB ANALIZA)

7/23/2019 Tulic Sadbera- Seminarski Rad (CB ANALIZA)

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/tulic-sadbera-seminarski-rad-cb-analiza 1/32

UNIVERZITET U SARAJEVUFAKULTET ZA SAOBRAĆAJ I KOMUNIKACIJE

SEMINARSKI RAD IZ PREDMETA:Višekriterijumske analize odlučivanja kod

saobraćajnih projekata

Temarada:

COST-BENEFIT ANALIZA U PROCJENI UTJECAJAINFRASTRUKTURE NA OKOLIŠ

Sarajevo,decembar 2015

SADRŽAJ

Predmetninata!ni": !ro"dr #adila $iso

Aitent: %&'diplin( Samira)abanovićSt#dent: Sadbera *ulić+roj indeksa-smjerenje .estovni saobraćaj/odina studija dru(i ciklus

Re$#%tat rada:



UVOD................................................................................................................................3

1.NASTANAK I RAZVOJ COST – BENEFIT ANALIZE..............................................4

2.OSNOVNA NAČELA COST-BENEFIT ANALIZE.....................................................5

2.1.Pri!"r #$%& '"(")i& *(*+i," i,r*/(!i %*0r""(" #"%&"........................................

2.2. Pri!"r #$%& '"(")i& *(*+i," – i(#i i,r*/(!" *&$#"%&".......................................

2.3.Z*/*&* i #i+! CBA.................................................................................................14

2.4."&$/$+$%i 6ri%&(6 6ri!"(i CBA....................................................................1

3.UTVR7IVANJE TRO8KOVA I KORISTI INVESTICIONO9 PROJEKTA.............1

3.1.Vr"/($0*(!" &r$:$0* i $ri%&i i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&*..........................................1;

4. POSTUPAK PROVO7ENJA CBA.............................................................................2<

5.KRITERIJUI KOJI SE KORISTE U COST – BENEFIT ANALIZI.......................23

5.1. Kri&"ri! %*/*:(!" ("&$ $ri%&i............................................................................24

5.2. Kri&"ri! i(&"r(" %&$6" r"(&*'i+($%&i =ISR>.........................................................25

5.3. K$")i#i!"(& $/($%* $ri%&i i &r$:$0*....................................................................25

5.4. Kri&"ri! r$* 0r*?*(!* i(0"%&i#i!*.....................................................................2

.PROCEDURA PRIJENE COST – BENEFIT ANALIZE........................................2@

ZAKLJUČAK..................................................................................................................31

LITERATURA................................................................................................................32

2



UVOD

Cost benefit n!i" !" 6$%"'(* )i(*(#i!%* &"(i* $/($%($ r*(%i 6$%&6*

6$%+!"/i#* +**(!* ("i 6$/,"&(ii i+i i()r*%&r&r(i 6$&0*&. S !"/(" %&r*("

,'r*!*! %" %0i 6ri$/i i $ri%&i 6$&0*&* * % /r" %&r*(" %0i &r$:$0i i 'i#i 6$&0*&*.S0i 6ri$/i i $ri%&i &r$:$0i i 'i#i $r*! 'i&i 0*(&i)i#ir*(i i %0"/"(i (* !"/(*$

!"r+!i0 !"/i(i# (*!":?" i6* ($0*#. U$+i$ !" $!"r 6ri$/* i $ri%&i i &r$:$0* i

'i&** $/($%($ $")i#i!"(& 0"?i $/ !"/*( /*+" $+i$ 6ri$/i i $ri%&i (*/*:!

&r$:$0" i 'i&" ri!" !" $ )i(*(#i!%i i%6+*&i0$ 6$&0*&. N*r*0($ 0ri!"/i i $'r*&($.

C$%& '"(")i& *(*+i,* ":?" %" 6ri!"(!!" 6ri $#!"(i i(** !*0(i i()r*%&r&r(i

6r$!"*&* #"%&" :$+" '$+(i#" $/+**+i:&* %"?* ,*:&i&* $$+i:* i %+. '/?i /* %

(!i* ,* r*,+i $/ 6$/,"&(ii 6r$!"*&* 6ri$/i * $%$'i&$ $ri%&i 6$%r"/(i i

/$r$(i i i*! i(" (* /r" %"&$r" 6* i 6$/,"&(ii.

Tr$:$0i i 'i&#i $!i % 6$%+!"/i#* +**(!* ("i 6$/,"&(ii i+i i()r*%&r&r(i

6$&0*& % !"/($r*&(i i i,0!"%(i /$ % 6ri$/i i $ri%&i /$r$(i i ("i,0!"%(i. T$

$6+i#ir* 6$%&6* #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i," 6$%"'($ */ %" %$*0*$ %*$ % $ri%&i*

$!" % 6$%r"/(" i $!" 6ri/$($%" i(#i* $ri%(i* 6ri!"r* #"%&* 0$/$$6%r'(i

$'!"*&* i %+. Pri!"r !"/($%&*0($ !" &0r/i&i &r$:$0" i 'i&" i,r*/(!" ("" *&$-

#"%&" *+i (i*+$ (i!" !"/($%&*0($ &0r/i&i "$($%" $ri%&i ,* 'r$!(" $ri%(i" &"

*&$#"%&" $!i 6r$i,+*," i, 6$'$+!:*(i 6r$"&(i 0",*. A * !" i ("$?" i (" &r"'*

0*(&i)i#ir*&i &r$:$0" i 'i&" $!i 6r$i,+*," i, /"0*%&*#i!" $$+i:* *&$-#"%&" (i&i

6ri$/" i $ri%&i $!i 6r$i,+*," i, 'r" i !"/($%&*0(i!" 6ri!"0$,*.

U %0*$ %+*! $+i$ % +**(!* 0"?* &$ !" i $6+i#ir*(i!* #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,*

!"r !" iri i 0"?i 'r$! 0*ri!*'+i / !" "$($%i 0i!" i ("i,0!"%($%& $/($%($ri,i !" 0"?i.

3



#$NASTANAK I RAZVOJ COST % BENEFIT ANALIZE

T"$ri!* #$%& – '"(")i& *(*+i," 0" $r!"(" !$: i, 1. 0i!"* i ($i &"$r"&i*ri !" 0",!

,* "$($i! '+*$%&*(!*1. Z* &""+!i0** CB *(*+i," %" %*&r* J+"% D6$i& $!i !"

!$: 1;44. $/i(" $0$ri$ $ CB *(*+i,i i $ $ri%&i* i &r$:$0i* !*0(i i(0"%&i#i!*.

Pr*&i(* 6ri"(* CB *(*+i," 6$i(!" /$%&* *%(i!" i 0",!" %" ,* &ri/"%"&" $/i("

0i!"* */* !" SAD /$:+$ /$ r*,0$!* !*0i 6r$!"*&* 'i+* !" 0",*(* ,* 6r$!"&"

$ri:&"(!* 0$/(i r"%r%* &*$ /* !" 13. $/i(" %0$!"( Z*$( $ $(&r$+i 6$6+*0*

$!i !" 6r$6i%i0*$ $/r"G"(" %&*(/*r/" i 6ri(#i6" $#"(i 6r$!"*&* 0$/(i r"%r*.

D$ II S0!"&%$ r*&* i (*$( (!"* SAD %" /$%&* r*/i+$ (* r*,0$! &"$ri!" i 6ri!"("

CB *(*+i,". T$$ 15<. !"/*( 6$%"'*( $i&"& i,/*$ !" &,0. Z"+"( (!i $!* %"

$/($%i+* (* %&*(/*r/" i ri&"ri!" $#!"(i 6r$!"*&* 0",*(i ,* r*,0$! i r"G"(!"

ri!"*. S+i(" 6r$'+"" $'r*Gi0*$ !" i /$"(& 6$/ (*,i0$ B/"& Cir#+*r A – 4@

$!i !" i,/*& 152. $/i(". V"$* !" i(&"r"%*(&*( i i,0":&*! r6" $(%+&*(*&* 6$,0*(i

$/ %&r*(" (*#i$(*+($ 'ir$* ,* %&*(/*r/" i ri&"ri!" $#!"(i 6r$!"*&* r*,0$!* ri!"* i

0$/(i r"%r%* $!i !" (*,0*( $(%+&*(&%i i,0":&*! i i,/*& !" 11. $/i(".

U V"+i$! Bri&*(i!i CB *(*+i,* !" 6$"+* /* %" 6ri"(!!" ,(*&($ *%(i!" i &$ 6ri!" %0"*

,* &r*(%6$r&(" 6r$!"&". P$,(*&* !" %&/i!* $!* !" r*G"(* ,* i,r*/(! ($0$ "&r$*

L$(/$( /" !" $ri:&"(* CB *(*+i,*. T*$G" i $/ *(*+i," i &0rGi0*(!* +$*#i!" &r"?"

*"r$/r$* L$(/$( &,0. R$%i++ $i%i!* !" $ri%&i+* CB *(*+i,. U Fr*(#%$! !" CB

*(*+i,* $ri:&"(* $/ +**(!* 6&"0" i $/ 6r$!"*&* 0$/$6ri0r"/".

Kr*!" :",/"%"&i $/i(* 6$!*0+!! %" SAD r*/$0i $!i 6$0",! CB *(*+i, %*

&"$ri!$ '+*$%&*(!*. O0$ 6$0",i0*(!" $+"/* %" H1. S0*&*(! $ri%&i *$ 'i+$ $!" /$'i&i '+*$%&*(!* i &r$:$0* *$ 'i&*

'+*$%&*(!*

2. K$(#"6& $6$r&(i&"&(i &r$:$0* &*$ /* %" *$ 6$%"'($ 6r*0i+$ CB *(*+i,"

,i* *%ii,ir*(!" r*,+i" i,"G $ri%&i i i,'+!"(i $ri%&i !"/($

6r$!"&*

3. N*+*"(!* $%($0* ,* i/"! *%ii,ir*(!* ("&$ $ri%&i P*r"&$0$ 6r*0i+.

1 Ni$+i? . i P*($0i? B. Ekonomika preduzeća E$($%i )*+&"& B"$r*/ 1@.

4



P*r"&$0$ 6r*0i+$ $0$ri /* /r:&0"($ '+*$%&*(!" 6r"/%&*0+!* ,'ir '+*$%&*(!*

6$!"/i(*#* $/($%($ /* %" /r:&0"($ '+*$%&*(!" 6$0"?*0* *$ %" 6$0"?*0* '+*$%&*(!"

("$ 6$!"/i(#* * (i!"/($ 6$!"/i(# %" (" %*(!!".

O/ :",/"%"&i $/i(* 6ri!"(* CB *(*+i," !" %&*+($ %6$(. Pri"( CB *(*+i,"

6$i(! /* 6ri0*&*! i $ri%&" 6$,(*&" )i(*(%i!%" i(%&i&#i!" *$ :&$ !" S0"&%* '*(*.

P$%"'*( ,(**! 6ri"(i CB *(*+i," i* 6$!*0* 6rir(i* $/ /0* *&$r* Li&&+" i

irr+""% *(*+ $) I(/%&ri*+ Pr$!"#&% A(*+%i% )$r D"0"+$6i( C$(&ri"% i, 1.

$/i(" i,/*& $/ %&r*(" OECD =Or*(i,*#i!* ,* "$($% %*r*/(! i r*,0$!>. O0*!

6rir(i !" *%(i!" i($0ir*( i $( !" 6$,(*& *$ Li&&+" – irr+""% i+i OECD "&$/.

UNIDO =Or*(i,*#i!* U!"/i(!"(i (*#i!* ,* i(/%&ri!%i r*,0$!> !" 1@2. $/i(" $'!*0i$

%0$! 6rir(i 9i/"+i("% )$r Pr$!"#& E0*+*&i$( S0"&%* '*(* &*$G" i,/*!" %0$!

6rir(i 1@5. $/i(" $!i %" /$%&* $%+*(!* (* r*(" r*/$0" Li&&+" i irr+""% – * i $0*!

6rir(i % 6i%*+i L. Sir" i V*( /"r T* i /*& !" (!i,i E#$($i# A(*+%i% $/

Pr$!"#& 2.

&$OSNOVNA NA'ELA COST-BENEFIT ANALIZEK*$ 'i %" $+* r"*+($ %*+"/*&i i $#!"(i&i $6r*0/*($%&i r"*+i,*#i!" !"/($

i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&* ("$6$/($ !" &0r/i&i i *(*+i,ir*&i 6(" ")"&" $!" $"

/$(i!"&i r"*+i,*#i!* $/r"G"(i i(0"%&i#i!*.

2.%#ri'/.#$/$#12;@11@C$%&-B"(")i&-*(*+i,* =/*& 6ri%&6* 2.11.2<15.>

5

Fi+$,$)i! cost – benefit *(*+i," $/* (*!'$+!" /")i(i:" &,0. P*r"&$0 (*6r"/* (*,0*( 6r"* i&*+i!*(%$ "$($i%&i Vi+)r"/ P*r"&. N*"+$ P*r"&$0$ (*6r"&*,*%(i0* %" (* 6r"&6$%&*0#i /* /*(*:(!"%*0r""($ /r:&0 (i!" $?"r"*+i,$0*&i 'i+$ **0 6r$!"& $!i (i$" ("?"(*(i!"&i :&"&. S&$* % "$($i%&i ,*

6r$!"&" $!i % 'i+i 6r"/"& #$%& – '"(")i& *(*+i," * +*0($ i !" 6r$0$/i+* 0+*/*0"+i 6$!* 6$&"(#i!*+($ P*r"&$0$(*6r"&* 6r"* $!" %" i%6+*&i +**&i %0*i

6r$!"& $/ $!" % $ri%&i$(i* $!i i i0*! 0"?" $/ &r$:$0* $(i $!i* % &i&r$:$0i6r$,r$$0*(i.Z* 6r$!"&" $!i $%&0*r! $ri%&i i $6"(,! &r$:$0" $!"

,r$!$" %" r"?i /* % $%&0*ri+i 6$&6(i P*r"&$0 (*6r"/*.Ti %" &r$:$0i i $ri%&i$ $ i%*&i *$ $(* 0r%&* $ri%&i i &r$:$0* $ i&"r"&" :ir i+i /r:&0"(



Pr"/,"?" *$ i(0"(%&i&$ri (*!0"?$! !"ri ,*i&"r"%i0*(* % %*$ ,* /ir"&("

"$($%" ")"&" $/ i(0"%&i#i!*$!i %" $ /$0$+!($ ",*&($ !"ri&i i 0*(&i&*&i0($

$,r**0*&i. S* /r" %&r*(" ,* i(/ir"&(" (""$($%" ")"&" $/ i(0"%&i#i!" $!" !"

0"$* &":$ !"ri&i i 0*(&i&*&i0($ i,r**0*&i 6r"/,"?* (i% 6$%"'($ ,*i(&"r"%$0*(*.

"G&i 6ri+i$ $#!"(" $6r*0/*($%&i r"*+i,*#i!" !"/($ i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&* &r"'*

0i!" i*&i 0i/ ")"&" $!" 6r$!"*& /$($%i /ri 6ri0r"/(i %'!"&i* i+i :ir$$!

/r:&0"($! ,*!"/(i#i. U &$ $(&"%& #$%& – '"(")i& *(*+i,* i+i *(*+i,* &r$:$0* i $ri%&i

6$r"/%&*0+!* &"(i $!$ %" &0rG! *(*+i,ir*! i 6$r"G! 6(" $ri%&i &r$:$0i

$/ $(r"&(" i(0"%&i#i!".

N*!6ri!" &r"'* r"?i /* &$ (i!" (i**0 ($0i i, "$($%" ,(*($%&i 0"? r"+*&i0($ %&*ri

6$%&6* $!i %" 0"? /*0($ 6ri!"(!!" 6r*%i r*,0i!"(i ,*6*/(i ,"*+!* 6ri $#!"(i 4

"G%$'($ r*,+ii&i 6r$!"*&* * i (*:$! +i&"r*&ri 6$!*0i$ %" *$ 6$!* 0"? 3<.-&i

$/i(* 6r$:+$ %&$+!"?* i*$ %" &*0" *(*+i," (i% '*: "%&$ r*/i+". N!"(* 6ri!"(*

$ri%&i+* %" 6ri!" %0"* $/ +**(!* !*0(" i i()r*%&r&r(" $'!"&" *+i %" %0" ":?"

$ri%&i i $/ $%&*+i 6r$!"*&* %+*! 6$%&$!*(!* ,(*&(i!" /r:&0"(" $ri%&i i :&"&".

Fi+$,$)i! #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i," $/* (*!'$+!" /")i(ir* &,0. P*r"&$0 (*6r"/*(*,0*(

6r"* &*+i!*(%$ "$($i%& Vi+)r"/ P*r"&. N*"+$ P*r"&$0$ (*6r"&* ,*%(i0* %"

(* 6r"&6$%&*0#iH/* /*(*:(!" %0r""($ /r:&0 (i!" $?" r"*+i,ir*&i 'i+$ **0

6r$!"& $!i (i$" ("?" (*(i!"&i :&"&. S&$* % "$($i%&i ,* 6r$!"&" $!i % 'i+i

6r"/"& #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i," 0"+i 6$!* 6$&"(#i!*+($ P*r"&$0$ (*6r"&* 6r"*

$!" %" i%6+*&i +**&i %0*i 6r$!"& $/ $!" % $ri%&i $(i* $!i i i0*! 0"?"

$/ &r$:$0* $(i $!i* % &i &r$:$0i 6r$,r$$0*(i. Z* 6r$!"&" $!i $%&0*r!" $ri%&i

i $6"(,ir*! &r$:$0" $!" ,r$! $" %" r"?i /* % $%&0*ri+i 6$&6(i P*r"&$0

(*6r"/*. Ti %" &r$:$0i i $ri%&i $ $6i%*&i *$ $(* 0r%&* $ri%&i i &r$:$0* $!" ("

&"r"&" ($%i&"+!* ,*0*&* 0"? :ir i+i /r:&0"( ,*!"/(i# 6* i '/?" "("r*#i!". T$%" $" %*&r*&i 6r0$ /")i(i#i!$ &,0.O/ri0$ r*,0i&*.

2.1.Primjer cost benefit analize u izgradnji savremene ceste

Pri!"rH I,r*/(!$ !"/(" %*0r""(" #"%&" $!* 'i &r"'*+* ,*i!"(i&i 6$%&$!"? %&*r

#"%& ("6ri+*/( ,* 6$0"?*(i 6r$"& &r"'* %*+"/*&i $+i$ ?" i,($%i&i ("6$%r"/(i



&r$:$0i i,r*/(!" &" #"%&" *+i i $+i$ ?" :&"&*M i $ri%&iM ,* /r:&0$ i,*,0*&i i,r*/(!*

($0" #"%&".

K*$ :&"&"M %+i!"/ i,r*/(!" #"%&" $ %" %*&r*&iH

1> &r$:$0i i,r*/(!" #"%&"

2> &r$:$0i $/r*0*(!* #"%&"

3> 'i&* :*r%$! ii+i 6$+!$6ri0r"/($! /!"+*&($%&i ,'$ &$* :&$ ?" %" %&*($0i&"

6$0r:i(" :* ii+i 6$+!$6ri0r"/($ ,"+!i:&* $r*&i 6r"(*i!"(i& #"%&

4> *$ ($0* #"%&* ("?" 0i:" 6r$+*,i&i r$, ("* !"%&* /$?i ?" /$ %*(!"(!*

6ri$/* &r$0i(" $%&i&"+!%&0* i /ri /!"+*&($%&i &i !"%&i* !"r ?" i 6r$"& 6&(i* ,*$'i?i

5> "$+$:" 6$%+!"/i#" /$ $!i ?" /$?i (* 6r$%&$r r$, $!" ?" 6r$+*,i&i ($0*

#"%&* i,*,0*(" '$ i%6:(i 6+i($0i* ,**Gi0*(!" $&6*/$ $!i ?"

6&(i#i $%&*0+!*&i ,* %$'$ i&/.

> (",*/$0$+!%&0$ /i!"+* %&*($0(i:&0* r$, i!" ?" 6$/r!" 6r$+*,i&i ($0* #"%&*

,'$ (*r:*0*(!* (!i$0$ ir* *+i &*$G"r i (",*/$0$+!%&0$ %&*($0(i:&0* ,

%&*r #"%& !"r ?" %" %*/* $%!"?*&i (*6:&"(i* i ,*6$%&*0+!"(i*.

K*$ $ri%&iM $/ ($0" #"%&" !*0i& ?" %"H

1. :&"/* (* 0r""( 6&(i* ,'$ 0"?i 'r,i(* 0$(!" $!" ?" ($0* #"%&* /$,0$+i&i

%6$r"/'i %* %&*r$ #"%&$

2. :&"/* (* $ri0 ** i &r$:$0i* $/r*0*(!* 0$,i+* ,'$ '$+!" 0*+i&"&"

($0" #"%&"

3. *(!" :&"&" (* 0$,i+i* 6r$"&(i /"%i* ,'$ '$+!i 6r$"&(i

*r*&"ri%&i* ($0" #"%&" i 0"?" %ir($%&i 0$(!"

4. *(!i 'r$! $,+i!"G"(i 6r$"&(i ("%r"?** * %* &i 0",i i *(!i &r$:$0i

+i!""(!* =i, r*,+$* *$ 6$/ #>

@



5. *(!i 'r$! %r&($ %&r*/*+i 6r$"&(i ("%r"?** =i, r*,+$* *$ 6$/ #> )>

6$0"?*(i 6ri$/i $%6$/*r%&0* i %&*($0(i:&0* !"%&i* r$, $!* ?" i+i '+i,

$!i ?" 6r$+*,i&i ($0* #"%&*

. 6$%r"/(" $ri%&i $/ ,*6$:+!*0*(!* 0"?" 'r$!* +!/i (* $/r*0*(! ($0" #"%&",'$ "* /$+*,i /$ 6$0"?*(!* 6$0(" $?i %&*($0(i:&0* r*!* r$, $!i

6r$+*,i ($0* #"%&* "0"(&*+(" $ri%&i %0i 0r%&* /$ $!i $" /$?i *$ %"

i,r*/(!$ ($0" #"%&" $$?i +*:i 6ri%&6 ("$ /$ %*/* *(!" r*,0i!"($

6$/r! i &i" 6$&*(" r*,0$! &$ 6$/r!*.

I, $0$ %*"&$ 6ri*,* $" %" %*+"/*&i $%($0(* )i+$,$)i!* #$%& '"(")i& *(*+i," *$ i

%0" :&$ $0* *(*+i,* &r"'* $'0*&i&i. Z* r*,+i $/ *++*#i!* $!" % $'i*!"(" $/

r*,*&r*(!* )i(*(#i!%i i(** !"/($ $%6$/*r%$ ,*0*&* $!" %" r*,*&r*!

$"i0*(i &r$:$0i i 6ri$/i 6$%+$0*(!* &$ ,*0*&* #$%& '"(")i& *(*+i,* 6$ri0* ,(*&($

:ir" 6$/r!" i r*,*&r* 6$%+!"/i#" i,r*/(!" $/($%($ 6$%+$0*(!* !"/($ ,*0*&* (*

i :ir $$+i( ,i*!?i $',ir (i, /ri $%6$/*r%i i ("$%6$/*r%i *&i0($%&i i

,*0*&* ="G&!"#*!i % /ri ,*0*&i*>. O0* *(*+i,* (*!":?" !" 6$%&6* $!i %"

6r$%G! /r:&0"(i 6ri$/i =$ri%&i> i /r:&0"(i &r$:$0i =:&"&"> $!" ?" %" 6r"/0i/i0$

6$!*0i&i $%&0*r"(!" ("$ ,*0*&* =6r$!"&*>. N*,i0*! %" i "%&"r(i $ri%&i* i

&r$:$0i*. Z* r*,+i $/ *(*+i&ii "&$/* $!i* %" 6r$%G!" i(/i0i/*+(*

")i*%($%& %*$ 6r$!"&* =i(0"%&i#i!%" %&/i!"> $0* *(*+i,* r*,*&r* 6(" /r:&0"("

")"&" ,*0*&*.

U &$ $(&"%& *(*+i,* $ri%&i i &r$:$0* 0**( !" /i$ 6r$#"%* 6r$#!"(" &!"#*!* (*

$$+i: i &$ (* r*,i(i 6$!"/i(*(i 6r$!"*&* i ("$6$/(* 6$/r:* $/+i0*(! 6$%&6

6r$#!"(" &!"#*!* ,*0*&* (* $$+i:. I%&$/$'($ &$ !" "&$/* i,'$r* i,"G 0i:" 0*ri!*(&i

,*0*&* *$ i i* i+i *+&"r(*&i0* i,"G !"/i(" 6r"/+$"(" =i,0"/'"("> 0*ri!*(&"

,*0*&* i (+&$ %&*(!* =*/* %" ,*0*& (" 'i r"*+i,ir*$>. T*! %" i,'$r 6r$0$/i

$6&ii,*#i!$ ("&$ $ri%&i ='"(")i&*> $/($%($H

N"&$ B B-C

;



2.2. Primjer cost benefit analize – učinci izgradnje autoceste

U &*'"+i 1. 6ri*,*(" % $ri%&i $!" $ri%(i#i i*! $/ i,r*/(!" '/?" %*$'r*?*!(i#"

*+i i "$($%" $ri%&i $/ i,r*/(!" i%&".

Ko(isti " )o(isni)e E)ono*s)e )o(isti

KORISTI K$ri%&i ,* $ri%(i"H K$ri%&i ,* $ri%(i" - :&"/" 0r""( 6&$0*(!* - :&"/" 0r""( 6&$0*(!*

- 6$0"?*(* %ir($%& - 6$0"?*(* %ir($%&

- $6"r*&i0(i &r$:$0i 0$,i+* - $6"r*&i0(i &r$:$0i 0$,i+*

U&!"#*!i (* 6$%+$0( "%6*(,i!

U&!"#*!i (* 6$%+$0( *&r*&i0($%&

U&!"#*!i (* &ri%&i 6$(/

TROŠKOVI I,r*/(!" I,r*/(!" U6r*0+!*(!*$/r*0*(!* U6r*0+!*(!*$/r*0*(!*

Tabela 1. oristi i tro!kovi od izgradnje autocesta"

D"&*+!(i! 6$/!"+ /r:&0"($-"$($%i i(** i,r*/(!" *&$#"%&* (* r"i$(*+(i

r*,0$! /*$ !" C"( =Er$6"*( C$i%%i$( 1> i 6r"* (!" r*,+i! %"H

1. i,r*0(i i(#i

2. i(/#ir*(i i(#i

3. *&*+i,ir*(i i(#i.

U %+i!"/"?i T*'"+** 2. 3. i 4. 6ri*,*(i % i(#i i,r*/(!" *&$#"%&" % $',ir$ (*

r*,+ii&" 6r$%&$r(" r*,i(" 0ri!"" 6$!*0+!i0*(!* i(** &" % $',ir$ (* (!i$0 &!"#*!

(&*r 6$!"/i($ %"&$r*.

I,0$rH $r+/ B*(H Economic #mpacts of .$.%. "1 &orridor #mprovementsM.$r+/'*(.$r&r*(%6$r&r$*/%r6+-/$#%i(/i*(*.6/)



Lo)!n ("in Re+ion!n ("in N,ion!n ("in

I"(ni ./in,i P$0"?*(* ,*6$%+"($%&

%"&$r r*G"0i(*r%&0*

+&i6+i*&i0(i i($

6$0"?*(* ,*6$%+"($%&

%+($ %"&$r

In0.,i(ni ./in,i P$0"?*(* #i!"(*

("r"&(i(* '+i,i(i

6r$"&(i#" $!* !"

i,r*/(!i

R*,!":&*! /$*?i(%&*0*

6$/r!* % 6$0"?*($

6ri%&6*($:?

P$0"?*(*

$(r"(&($%& 6$/,"?*

r*/i %*(!"(!*

6r$"&(i &r$:$0*

Kt!i"i(ni ./in,i P$0"?*(* ,*6$%+"($%&

6r$i,0$/($ %"&$r* r*/i

6$0"?*(" 6"r#"6#i!"

6$/r!*

Tabela 2. Primjer dru!tveno'ekonomski( učinaka izgradnje autoceste na različite prostorne razine)

K(t)o(o/ni ./in,i Srednjoročni učinci

D.+o(o/ni ./in,i

I"(ni ./in,i P$0"?*(* ,*6$%+"($%&

%"&$r r*G"0i(*r%&0*

In0.,i(ni ./in,i A(&i#i6ir*(i r*,!":&*!

/$*?i(%&*0* 6$/r!*

% 6$0"?*($

6ri%&6*($:?

A+$"r*#i!* 6$/,"?* $!*

% %!":&"(* '+i,i(i

r*%ri!*

D*+!(!* r"&*(!*

6$/,"?* i ?*(%&*0*

/*+!" $/ 6$/r!*

$!" r*%&" #i!"(*

("r"&(i(* i $!"

%" $%!"?* ,*:"(!"

r*/i i,r*/(!" ($0"

6r$"&(i#"

Kt!i"i(ni ./in,i D$/*&(* ,*6$%+"($%& (*

6r$!"&i* $!i %" $/($%"

(* $$+i:

Tabela ". Primjer dru!tveno'ekonomski( učinaka izgradnje autoceste s obzirom na vrijeme pojavljivanjaučinaka*

K.1nst snis)i*

0o2ot)o*

K.1nst siso)i*

0o2ot)o*

P(oi"o0n3

Uslužni sektor

3 I,0$rH Er$6"*( C$i%%i$( 1 +P+% ' ,et(odologies for transport impact assesment O))i#" )$rO))i#i*+ P'+i#*&i$(% $) &" Er$6"*( C$(i&i"% L"'$r


1<



I$ra!ni#&in'i

P$0"?*(*

$?($%& ,*

,*6$%+"(!"

%"&$r

r*G"0i(*r%&0*

Or"&*(!" 6$%+$0(i

%'!"*&* 6r"*

%+($ %"&$r r*/i

6$0"?*(i i,/*&** ,*

+$*+( i,r*/(!

Ind#'irani#&in'i

R"*+$*#i!*

6r"* 6$/r!

i,r*/(!" $/

$(i ?*(%&*0*

$!* 6$%!"/!

*&$$'i+

P$0"?*(* /$'i&

%+i!"/ %*(!"(!*

&r*(%6$r&(i

&r$:$0* ,* i(6&" i

$&6&"

R"*+$*#i!* 6r"*

($0i /$%&6(i

%r"/i:&i*

Kata%i$irani#&in'i

E0"(&*+($

6$0"?*(*

,*6$%+"($%&

E0"(&*+($ 6$0"?*(*

,*6$%+"($%& ,'$

6$'$+!:*(!" 6"r#"6#i!" 6$/r!*

Tabela ). Primjer dru!tveno'ekonomski( učinaka izgradnje autoceste s obzirom na učinke koje izgradnja

ima na različite sektore-

U$'i*!"(* 6$/!"+* i(** !" i (* =B*(i%&"r *(/ B"r"#*( 2<<<>H

i,r*0(" i

("i,r*0(" i(".

K*$ :&$ i %* (*,i0 $0$ri $/ i,r*0(i i(** i,r*/(!* *&$#"%&* i,r*0($ &!"" (*

6r$!"( *&i0($%&i r"i!i. S6r$&($ &$ ("i,r*0(i i(#i 6r$i,+*," i, 6r$!"(*

r"+*&i0($! $(r"(&($%&i r"i!" ,r$$0*(" i,r*/(!$ *&$#"%&*.@

D0i!" (*!":?" $ri:&"(" "&$/" 6r$#!"(" &!"#*!* i,r*/(!" *&$#"%&* (* r"i$(*+(i

r*,0$! !"% Analiza utjecaja na regionalni ekonomski razvoj =engl. egional Economic

#mpact +ssesment'E#+> i Analiza troškova i koristi =engl. &ost'/enefit +nal0sis'&/+>.

+naliza utjecaja na regionalni ekonomski razvoj 'E#+


D"&*+!(i!" %i%&"*&i,*#i!" $?i i(** i,r*/(!" *&$#"%&* (* r"i$(*+(i r*,0$! 0i/!"&i r*/$0i* Vi#"r*(* &" B*(i%&"r *(/ B"r"#*(*.

11



REIA %" ,*%(i0* (* 6$r*'i i(6&-$&6& &*'"+* * %* 6$%&6* !" %+i!"/"?iH 6r0$

$r* i/"(&i)i#ir* %" ,*6$%+"($%& i /$$/* $!i % 6$0",*(i % 6r$!"&$ $!i %"

$#!"(!!". E$($%i i(#i (* ,*6$%+"($%& i /$$/* $'i*!"($ %" /i!"+" (* /0i!"

*&"$ri!"H ("i,r*0(" i(" (*%&*+i 6(!$ /$'*r* i %+* $/ %&r*(" 6r$!"&* &"

i(/#ir*(" i(" (*%&*+" 6$&r$:(!$ 6$&r$:** $!i % ,*6$%+"(i (* 6r$!"&. O'*

i(* %" 6r$#!"(!! 6r"$ +&i6+i*&$r* * $!i %" i,r*(*0*! $ri:&"(!" i(6&-

$&6& &*'"+*. E$($%i i(#i 6r$#!"(!! %" (* $/i:(!$! r*,i(i i 6r$%&$r($

/",*r"ir*! ,'$ i/"(&i)i*#i!" r"i$(*+(i i +$*+(i i(**.

Pr*&i(* 6$r*'* "&$/" REIA %$"(* !" % ($$ 6r*&i(i i &"$ri!%i 6$&":$?*.

K*$ 6r0$ 6$/*#i $!i % 6$&r"'(i ,* 6$r*' "&$/" REIA % &":$ /$%&6(i i" % i

i,r*(*&" 0ri!"/($%&i +&i6+i*&$r* 6i&(" ,'$ ("/$%&6($%& 6$/*&**. N*/*+!"6$r*'* "&$/" REIA (i!" 6ri+*/*( ri&"ri!i ,* /$($:"(!" $/+" $ 6ri0*?*(!

6r$!"&* !"r %" (!$" !"ri *(i&/* ,*6$%+"($%&i * (" (!",i( 0ri!"/($%&. U R"6'+i#i

Qr0*&%$! % $',ir$ /* %" (" i,r*G! i(6&-$&6& &*'"+" (i!" $?" 6rii!"(i&i

"&$/ REIA ,* 6r$#!"( i(** i,r*/(!" i()r*%&r&r" (* r"i$(*+(i r*,0$!.

+naliza tro!kova i koristi ' &/+

P$/r!" 6r$"&* !" !"/($ $/ 6r0i 6$/r!* $!" %" *(*+i,* &r$:$0* i $ri%&i

%%&*0($ $ri%&i *$ /i$ 6r$#"%* $/+i0*(!*.; R*,+$,i &$ % 0i:"%&ri * "G i(i*

i%&i %" %+!"/"?* /0*H 1. 6$%&$!i i&*0 (i, %+i(i 6r$!"*&* $!" &r"'* %6$r"Gi0*&i &*$

/* %" 6r0"(%&0$ /*!" )$r*+i,ir*($ 6$%&6 $/+i0*(!* (*%6r* %'!"&i0(i

6r$#!"(** i 2. (*!0"?* $ri%& $/ 6r$"&($ 6r$!"&* !" :&"/* 0r""( 6&$0*(!*

$!* !" !"r+!i0*.

CBA ,*6$i(!" % $6i%$ *+&"r(*&i0(i 6r$!"*&* $!i %" r*,*&r*!. S0i %" $%($0(i

i(#i i/"(&i)i#ir*! i &*$ /!" !" &$ $?" i%*,! $("&*r($. K0*(&i)i*#i!*$ri%&i $/ 6r$!"*&* ,*%(i0* %" (* 0$+!i 6$&r$:** ,* 6+*?*(!" /$'*r* i %+* $!"

6r$i,0$/i 6r$!"&. Tr$:$0i 6r"/%&*0+!*! $6$r&(i&"&(" &r$:$0" $/($%($ $(" $ri%&i

$!" 'i "("rir*$ *+&"r(*&i0(i 6r$!"&. N*$( :&$ % %0" $ri%&i i %0i &r$:$0i i%*,*(i

($0*(i !"/i(i#** $ri%&" %" r*,+ii&" "&$/" $#!"(" i(0"%&i#i!%i 6r$!"*&* r*/i

/$($:"(!* $/+" $ 6ri0*?*(! 6$!"/i($ 6r$!"&*.

6 Pr0 6r*&i( 6ri!"( CBA $/ i,r*/(!" *&$#"%&* 6r"/%&*0+!* %&/i!* $ *(*+i,i &r$:$0* i

$ri%&i *&$#"%&" 1 i,r*G"(* V"+i$! Bri&*(i!i.

7 N"&$ %*/*:(!* 0ri!"/($%& i(&"r(* %&$6* r"(&*'i+($%&i i %+i($.

12



Tr*/i#i$(*+(i 6ri%&6 *(*+i,i &r$:$0* i $ri%&i $/ i,r*/(!" *&$#"%&* %r"/$&$"( !" (*

$ri%&i $!" *&$#"%&* 6r* (!",i(i $ri%(i#i* * &$ %H :&"/" 0r""( 6&$0*(!* i

6$0"?*(* %ir($%& 6&$0*(!*.

U 6$%+!"/(!i ("$+i$ $/i(* r*,*&r*! %" (" %*$ i,r*0(i i(#i $!" i,r*/(!**&$#"%&* i* ,* $ri%(i" 0"? i :iri &!"#*! $!" i,r*/(!* i* (* r"i$(*+($

$%6$/*r%&0$. U &$ %i%+ i,r*/(!* *&$#"%&" $" 6$+i&i 6"& 0r%&* "$($%i

i(**H

1. #zravne koristi za korisnike.

O(" +!! $ri%&i $!" $ri%(i#i =6&(i#i> i*! 0i/ 0r""(* 6&$0*(!*

%ir($%&i 6&$0*(!* i &r$:$0* $/r*0*(!* 0$,i+*.

2. #zravne ekonomske koristi.

P$%&$!"?i 6$%+$0(i %'!"&i $ i*&i $ri%&i r*/i %*(!"(!* &r$:$0* i 6$0"?*(!*

6r$/&i0($%&i. N*/*+!" 6r$!"(" 6ri%&6*($%&i &ri:& r*/(" %(*" 0"+ii(i &ri:&* &"

0",** % $%&*+i &ri:&i* i % &i" 6$0",*(i &r*(%6$r&(i &r$:$0i* $ 6ri0?i

($0" 6$%+$0(" %'!"&". Z'$ &i 6r$!"(* 6r$*&r*($ 6$/r!" $" 6$%&*&i

$%6$/*r%i *&r*&i0($ =6$%"'($ ,* /!"+*&($%& &ri,*>.

". eizravne sekundarne3 ekonomske koristi.

O/($%" %" (* 6$0"?*( i(&"r"/i!*r( 6$&r$:(! $ri%(i* $/ +**(!*. K*/* %" %+i!"/

r"*+i,*#i!" i,r*/(!" i()r*%&r&r($ 6r$!"&* 6$0"?* ,*6$%+"($%& r"i!i - (6r.

6r$i,0$G** $&$r(i 0$,i+* - &i %" i(#i :ir" (* #i!"+$ $%6$/*r%&0$ 6$(*!6ri!" (*

6r$i,0$G*" i /$'*0+!*" /i!"+$0* * ,*&i i (* 6$%+$0(" %'!"&" $!i 6r*! %+"

6r"r*(" $/i!"0*(!* i %+i($ ,* ,*6$%+"(i" *&$$'i+%$! i(/%&ri!i.

). $činci na tro!kove izgradnje.

9$%6$/*r%&0$ ("" r"i!" $" r*&$r$($ &!"#*&i (* 6r"%!"r*0*(!" %r"/%&*0* (*

i,r*/(! 6r*&"?i $'!"*&*.

*. egionalni lokalni3 ekonomski učinci.

P$("*/ %" % i,r*/(!$ 6r$"&(" i()r*%&r&r" !*0+!*! i ("(*!"r(i i(#i 6$6&

$&0*r*(!* *+$6r$/*!(i +*(*#* '"(,i(%i #r6i i %+. "G&i &i i(#i $ 'i&i i

("*&i0(i */* %" %+i!"/ $r*(i"($ 6ri+*,* *&$#"%&i (* 6ri!"r ,*&0*r*!

*+$6r$/*!(i +*(#i i %+. L$*+(i "$($%i i(#i 6$*,! &"(/"(#i! "G%$'($i%+!"(!* 6* %" %&$* i%+!! i, *(*+i," &r$:$0* i $ri%&i.

13



2.".4adatak i cilj &/+

C$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* 0*(&i)i!" i 6ri/$/*!" ($0*(" 0ri!"/($%&i %0i ")"&i* =*$

"$($%i &*$ i (""$($%i> i &r$:#i* 0",*(i ,* r"*+i,*#i! 6r$!"&* (*

$%($0 "* %" 0r:i 6r$r*( ("&$ =/r:&0"("> $ri%&i. Dri ri!"i* #$%&-'"(")i&

*(*+i,*6r"/%&*0+!* "&$/ $#!"(" 6$+i&i" i(0"%&i#i$(i +**(!* $!i 0*(&i)i!"

6$%+!"/i#" i &!"#*!i,*'r*(" i(0"%&i#i$(" 6$+i&i" (* %0" +*($0" !"/(" /r:&0"("

,*!"/(i#" i &r"'* !" r*,+i$0*&i$/ *(*+i," ")"&i0($%&i &r$%$0* =CEA - #$%& "))"#&i0"("%%

*(*+%i%>.

Z0t) CEA *(*+i," !" &r$:$0($ i/"(&i)i$0*(!" (*!i%6+*&i0i!" %$+#i!" ,* /*&i

i(0"%&i#i$(i#i+!. D*+" )$% !" i,'$r (*!6$0$+!(i!" i(0"%&i#i$(" 0*ri!*(&". Pri &$"

$(* %" %0$/i (*$6&ii,ir*(!" (*6ri!"/ 6$%&*0+!"($ )i%($ #i+!* , ri&"ri!

i(ii,ir*(!* %*/*:(!"0ri!"/($%&i &r$%$0* i,0$/"(!* i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&*. U 6ri!"(i

*(*+i," &r$%$0i-")"&i0($%&%&$!i 6r"&6$%&*0* /* !" #i+! i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&* (*6ri!"/

/*& i /* !" i/"(&i*( ,* %0"*+&"r(*&i0".

U #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,i &r$:$0i i r",+&*&i i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&* (i% (*6ri!"/

$/r"G"(i 0"? %" i,'$r 6r$!"*&* 6r$0$/i %* &0r/"(ir( 0"+ii(** &r$%$0* i r",+&*&*.

Pri &$" 6$%&$!i $?($%& /* %0" *+&"r(*&i0" $%&0*r"(!* !"/($ r*,0$!($ #i+!* '/

$/'*"(" *$ (",*/$0$+!*0*!?".N*ir(" #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* 6$+*,i $/ i/"!" /* !"/*(

i%&i ")"*& (" $r* 'i&i 6$,i&i0*( i ,* 6r"/,"?" i ,* /r%&0$ #!"+i(i %&$ ,(*#i /* #i+!"0i

6$!"/i(i 6r"/,"?* i /r:&0* #!"+i(i ("$r*! 0i!" 'i&i 6$&6($ %+*G"(i. J"/*(

i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*& $" /$(i!"&i i(0"%&i&$r ,(**!(" 6$,i&i0(" "$($%" ")"&" *

i%&$0r""($ =(6r. ,'$ ,**Gi0*(!* $$+i(" i %1.> $" 'i&i :&"&*( ,* /r:&0$ #!"+i(i.

Z'$ $?i $0*0i r*,+i* $/($% (* 6$!"/i(*(" i 6(" /r:&0"(" #i+!"0"

#$%&'"(")i& *(*+i,* i(,i%&ir* (* /r:&0"(i ")"&i* i(0"%&i#i!* $/($%($ (*

%*+"/*0*(! i

6r$#!"(!i0*(! (!i$0i ")"*&* %* *%6"&* /r:&0"(" ,*!"/(i#" #!"+i(i * &$ !" 6r*0$

$($ :&$ 6r"/%&*0+!* +*0($ $'i+!"!" $0" "&$/".

14



U $(&"%& (*0"/"($ #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* (*!0i:"%" $ri%&i $/ $#!"(" i(0"%&i#i$(i

6r$!"*&* $!i ,*&i!"0*! 0"+i* +**(!* )*(%i!%i%r"/%&*0* i /$($%" ")"&" $/

,(**!* ,* ($* 6$/r!* /r:&0"(" i 6ri0r"/(" /!"+*&($%&i.T %6*/*! 6ri!" %0"*

i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"&i %*$'r*"*! =6&(i ,"+!",(i#i ,r*#(i 0$/(i>,*&i i(0"%&i#i$(i

6r$!"&i r6(" "("r"&%" $'!"&" 0$/$6ri0r"/ 6$+!$6ri0r"/ *$ i0*(6ri0r"/

=$'r*,$0*(!" ,/r*0%&0$ i%+.>.

O%($0(i $(#"6& #$%&-'"(")i& *(*Ii," !" /* %" , $',ir i i,r*(*! iIi 6r$#i!"("

%0" /r:&0"(" $ri%&i i &r$%$0i !"/($ i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&* &" /* %" (* $%($0

6$r"G"(!* =0**(!*> 6(i $ri%&i i &r$:$0* $#i!"(i (!"$0* r"(&*'i+($%&. Pri &$"

%*r($ $(i 6r$!"&i $/ $!i 6(" $ri%&i (*/*:! 6(" &r$:$0" $ 'i&i

$#i!"(!"(i 6$,i&i0($ %&$ ,(*?i /* % 6ri0*&+!i0i ,* r"*+i,*#i!. S&$* '", $',ir* $!i !"

$/ (!i 6i&*(! #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* ,*&i!"0* /* %" , $',ir 6(i &r$:$0i i

6(" $ri%&i $!" /r:&0"(* ,*!"/(i#* $" i*&i $/ $(r"&($ i(0"%&i#i$($

6r$!"&*.

O%($0(i 6ri(#i6i CB *(*+i," %1<H

1. CB *(*+i,* %*&r* /* 6$%&$!i r*,+i* /$6ri($% 6r$!"&* 6$!"/(i*(i i

6(i /r:&0"(i #i+!"0i* $/($%($ 6$%&$!i r*,+i* ")"&i* $/ 6r$!"*&*

%* 6$!"/i(*($ i 6($ /r:&0"($ %&*($0i:&*

2. K$/ CB *(*+i," ,"&i $',ir %0" $ri%&i i &r$:$0" '", $',ir* $ i i0*

3. K*$ &r$:$0" ,"&i $',ir i i,'+!"(" $ri%&i * *$ $ri%&i i %*(!"(!"

&r$:$0*

4. S0" $ri%&i i &r$:$0" &r"'* &0r/i&i i,"ri&i i ($0*($ i,r*,i&i

5. U 6ri"(i CB *(*+i," $/ ("%*0r:"(i &ri:&* &r"'* $ri%&i&i i%6r*0+!"(" &ri:("

#"(" =$'r*(%" #"(">. CB *(*+i,* !" 6$$/(* $/ 6r$!"*&* $!i /$($%" 0i:"%&r" ")"&" $!" i0*

:iri r $ri%(i*

@. CB *(*+i,* /$6ri($%i $6&i*+($! *+$*#i!i $r*(i"(i r"%r%*.

2.).,etodoloski pristup u primjeni &/+

10."))"#&.ri(/".66133A#$%&-'"(")i&-*(*+i,* =/*& 6ri%&6* 2.11.2<15.>

15



C$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* %" i,0$/i (* 0r+$ $6+"%*( (*i 6$$? 6$%&6** $!i

6$/r*,i!"0*! &0rGi0*(!" 0"+i$ 'r$!* 6$+*,(i 6r"&6$%&*0i 0",i %* $6%"$ i

",*&($: $#!"(* $ri%&i i &r$:$0* 0r""(%$ $0ir* (*?i(* !"r"(!* i&/.

"G&i &r"'* (*+*%i&i /* /$'i!"(i r",+&*&i ,*0i%" $/ &i6* #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,".

E5 ante #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* !" %&*(/*r/(i &i6 *(*+i," &r:$0* i $ri%&i. O(* %" i,0$/i *$

%*%&*0(i /i$ i(0"%&i#i$(" %&/i!" 6r$#"% *(*+i," $6r*0/*($%&i i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&*

6ri!" (!"$0" i6+""(&*#i!".

E5 post #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* %" i,0$/i (*$( ,*0r%"(" r"*+i,*#i!" 6r$!"&* */* &r$%$0*

0i:" ("* (i&i $r"&i0(" *&i0($%&i $/ %&r*(" i(0"%&i&$r* i+i /r*0". O(* %" $+"/*

6r*(! i()$r*#i!* !*0(i %+.'** =/r*0i> i i(0"%&i&$ri* $ r"*+($! 0ri!"/($%&i

%6"#i)i#(i r6* 6r$!"*&* %i%+ (!i$0" $6r*0/*($%&i '/?($%&i.

+,,"&(* $6+"%($%& 6r$'+"*&i" #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i," *$ i (!"(" */"0*&("

6ri!"(" 6r*%i ,*&i!"0* 6r$0$G"(!" $6%"($ *(*+i&i$ 6$%&6* $!i $'0*&*

6ri!" %0"* &0rGi0*(!" i 0r"/($0*(!" &r$:$0* i $ri%&i i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&* ,*&i

6r$#"/r 6r$0$G"(!* %*" *(*+i," *$ i $/*'ir ri&"ri!* ,* 0r"/($0*(!".

4$UTVR5IVANJE TROŠKOVA I KORISTI INVESTICIONO6PROJEKTA

C$%& – '"(")i& *(*+i,* ,*%&6* i/"! /* &r"'* ,"&i $',ir &0r/i&i 0*(&i&*&i0($

6r$#"(i&i i ($0*($ i,r*,i&i %0" &r$:$0" i $ri%&i $!" !"/*( i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*& /$($%i

#!"+$6($! /r:&0"($! ,*!"/(i#i.

CB *(*+i,* %" $ri%&i $/ "$($%" *(*+i," 6r$!"&* $!$ %" &0rG! /$6ri($%i

6r$!"&* 6(i /r:&0"(i #i+!"0i* ,* r*,+i $/ )i(*(%i!%" *(*+i," $!* &0rG!"

")"&" (*%&*+" "%6+$*&*#i!i 6r$!"&* ,* i(0"%&i&$r*11. Pri!"( CB *(*+i,"

"$($%$! *(*+i,i 6r$!"*&* 6$%"'($ 6r"6$r!" S0!"&%* '*(*.

11P"r$0i? . i Ki%i? S.H Ekonomika preduzeća S*0r""(* */i(i%&r*#i!* B"$r*/ 13.

1



O0*! $(#"6& S0!"&%" '*(" 6r"6$r!" /* %" 6ri &0rGi0*(! &r$:$0* i $ri%&i ,*

#i!"+$ /r:&0$ = "$($%* *(*+i,* > 6$G $/ i(/i0i/*+($ i(* = )i(*(%i!%*

*(*+i,* > i /* %" +!i0*(!" i+i i%+!i0*(!" $/r"G"(i r6* $ri%&i i &r$:$0* /$G"

/$ 6(i ")"*&* %* %&*($0i:&* ,"+!" #!"+i(i.

1> Transferna plaćanja – U $0ir )i(*(%i!%" *(*+i," *$ &r$:$0i %" 6$!*0+!!

("* 6+*?*(!* $!* (" 6r"/%&*0+!*! %&0*r($ $ri:&"(!" r"%r%* 0"? %*$ &r*(%)"r

r"%r%* i, !"/($ %"&$r* /r:&0* /ri. S0* 6+*?*(!* $!* (" ,(*" %&0*r($

$ri:&"(!" r"%r%* 6r"/%&*0+!*! &r*(%)"r(* 6+*?*(!*. Tr*(%)"r(* 6+*?*(!* ("

6r"/%&*0+!*! "$($%i &r$:* 0"? %*$ )i(*(%i!% &r*(%*#i!. U &r*(%)"r(*

6+*?*(!* %6*/*! $&6+*&" i **&" (* /$*?" r"/i&" 6$r",i i %'0"(#i!".

2> epredvi6eni tro!kovi – U r"*+i,*#i!i 6r$!"&* 6$%&$!" $?($%&i 6$!*0"

("6r"/0iG"(i &r$:$0* i 6$&r"'($ !" i%&r*i&i (* $!i (*i( ?" %" ("6r"/0iG"(i

&r$:$0i &r"&ir*&i "$($%$! $#"(i 6r$!"&*.

3> Pret(odni tro!kovi – Pr"&$/(i &r$:$0i % $(i &r$:$0i $!i % (*%&*+i 6r" $#"("

6r$!"&* &" %" (" $ i,'"?i. O0" &r$:$0" &r"'* i%+!i&i i, 6(i &r$:$0*

6ri+i$ $/+i0*(!* /* +i (*%&*0i&i 6r$!"*& i+i (" !"r %" (" $ i,'"?i.

4> Eksterni efekti – T$ % $(i ")"&i $!i i,+*," i, $0ir* %*$ 6r$!"&*. O0" ")"&"

&r"'* +!i&i "$($% *(*+i, */* !" (!i 6$("*/ &":$ i/"(&i)i$0*&i *

!$: &"" i,!"ri&i. O0" ")"&" &r"'* ,"&i $',ir i i,0r:i&i 0*+i&*&i0( *(*+i,. U

&i6i(" "%&"r(" ")"&" %6*/*! r*,+ii&i $'+i#i ,**Gi0*(!* $$+i(" &i#*!

iri*#i$(i 6+*($0* (* ,/r*0+!" 6$0"?*(!" #i!"(* $!" !" i,*,0*($ %*i

6r$!"&$.

5> ,ultiplikacioni efekti – *r*&"ri%&i(i % ,* 6ri0r"/ $!* 6*&i $/ 0i:*

*6*#i&"&* i $!$! i(0"%&ir*(!" $" /$0"%&i /$ r*%&* 6ri$/* !"r r"*+i,*#i!*

i(0"%&i#i!* i,*,i0* /$/*&( 6$&r$:(! i %*(!!" 0i:* *6*#i&"&*. O0$ 6* (i!"

*r*&"ri%&i($ ,* ,"+!" r*,0$! '/?i /* $(" (*!#"%?" ("*! 0i:*

*6*#i&"&*. +&i6Ii*#i$(" ")"&" &r"'* +!i&i *(*+i, i*$ i !" &":$

6r$#i!"(i&i.

1@



> ,e6unarodni efekti – /($%" %" (* r",+&*&" 6r$!"*&* i,0*( r*(i#* 6$%*&r*("

,"+!" &" %" &r"&ir*! *$ "G(*r$/(i. Pri!"r* r*/i *$ r"*+i,*#i!* ("$

i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&* !"/($! ,"+!i ("6$0$+!($ &!"" (* 6rir$/( %r"/i(

/r" ,"+!" =,**Gi0*(!" ri!"*> $(/* &$ i(i "G(*r$/(" ")"&". O(i &r"'*

/* '/ +!"(i *(*+i, $/ $/r"/"(i 6r$!"*&* */* i !" &":$

6r$#i!"(i&i.

".1.7rednovanje tro!kova i koristi investicionog projekta

N*$( &0rGi0*(!* %0i /r:&0"(i &r$:$0* i $ri%&i $!" !"/*( i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&

/$($%i 6$&r"'($ i !" 0r"/($0*&i i i,r*,i&i ($0*($ $'+i.12

S&ir( 0",i 6ri'!"*0*%" 6ri!"(i $/$0*r*!?" %i%&"* #i!"(* $!i $$?*0* 6r"0$G"(!" r*,($0r%(i

")"*&* ($0*(" i,r*,".Z* !"r"(!" /r:&0"(i ")"*&* $!" /$($%" 6r$!"&i #$%&-

'"(")i& *(*+i,* $ri%&i i%6r*0+!"(" &r,i:(" #i!"(" $!" %" (*!#":?" ,$0 $'r*(%"

#i!"(". O(" %" $'i($ ,(*&($ r*,+i! $/ &r,i:(i #i!"(* $!" %" $ri%&" )i(*(%i!%$!

$#!"(i 6r$!"&* i (i% $?($%&i /* i,r*," %0" (!i$0" /r:&0"(" ")"&" 6* ,*&$ (i%

6$$/(" ,* 6ri!"( #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,i.

Tr,i:(" #i!"(" % 0*+!*( 6$*,*&"+! 0*+$ri,$0*(!* r",+&*&* %*$ %+$0i* %*0r:"($

&ri:&*. U ("%*0r:"(i &ri:(i %+$0i* &r,i:(" #i!"(" (" 6r"/%&*0+!*! 6$,/*( !"r

/!"+$0*(!* 6r$!"*&* (* #i+!"0" r*,0$!* 6* i !" 6$&r"'($ $ri$0*&i i ,*i!"(i&i %*

$'r*(%i #i!"(**. U $(&"%& (*0"/"($ $'r*(%" #i!"(" 6r"/%&*0+!*! (*?i(

i%6r*0+!*(!* /i%&$r,i!* i ("6r*0iI($%&i $!" 6$%&$!" $/ &r,i:(i #i!"(* ,'$ ("%*0r:"($

&ri:&* %+*'i!" "$($%" 6$+i&i" ,"+!" 6$%&$!*(!* $($6$+* i /ri r*,+$*.

9"("r*+($ +"/*($ $'r*(%" #i!"(" 6r"/%&*0+!*! 6ri(#i6i!"+*( 6ri%&6 !"r"(! i

0r"/($0*(! ")"*&* $/ 6r$!"*&* /$ %* (*?i( (!i$0$ i,r*(*0*(!* $" 'i&i

r*,+ii& i /$%&* %+$"(.

12."))"#&.ri(/".66133A#$%&-'"(")i&-*(*+i,* =/*& 6ri%&6* 2.11.2<15.>

1;



O%($0($ 6i&*(!" $!" &r"'* r*,ri!":i&i $/r"/i0*(! $'r*(%i #i!"(* !" /* +i %

6i&*(! &,0. r*,!"+!i0* =&ri:(*> i ("r*,!"+!i0* =("&ri:(*> /$'r* * &$ ,*0i%i 6ri!"

%0"* $/ i(!"(i#" /* +i %" &* /$'r* r$'" i+i %+" $ i,0$,i&i i+i 0$,i&i.

R*,!"+!i0* =&ri:(*> /$'r* % $(* $!* %" $ r"*+($ 0$,i&i i i,0$,i&i *

("r*,!"+!i0* =("&ri:(*> /$'r* % 6* $(* i!i % /$*?i &r$:$0i 6r$i,0$/(!"

=+!#!?i i &r$:$0" &r*(%6$r&*> %0i:" 0i%$i /* 'i $$?i+i $(r"(&*( i,0$, i+i

6* %0i:" (i%i /* 'i $$i+i $(r"(&*( 0$,.K*/* % 6i&*(! %0!"&%" #i!"("

r*,!"+!i0* /$'r* %" 6r"0$/" %* %0!"&%i /"0i,(i #i!"(* (* %0!"&%" #i!"(" /$*?$!

0*+&i 6&" ,0*(i($ /"0i,($ r%* * 6r"0$G"(!" ("r*,!"+!i0i /$'*r* %*

/$*?" (* %0!"&%i %i%&" #i!"(* = /$*?$! 0*+&i> 0r%i %" 6&"&,0. %&*(/*r/($

$(0"r,i$($ )*&$r*.

Pr"* UNIDO "&$/$+$i!i r"+"0*(&(i ")"&i 6r$!"&* $ %" 6$/i!"+i&i &ri

$%($0(" r6"H

*> Dir"&(i /r:&0"(i "$($%i r",+&*&i i ("&$ $&6&i 6r$!"&*

'> Dir"&(i /r:&0"(i "$($%i &r$:$0i *$ i(6&i 6r$!"&*

#> I(/ir"&(i /r:&0"(i "$($%i r",+&*&i i &r$:$0i $!i %" 6r","(&! *$

"%&"i ")"&i

U $(&"%& (*0"/"($ &r"'* i*&i 0i/ i #i(!"(i# /* *(*+i,* &r$%$0i-r",+&*&i

,*&i!"0* i r*,r!":"(!" 6r$'+"* 0r""(%$ *:(!"(!* ")"*&* %* *%6"&* /*(*:(!"

$"(&*. T*$ %" !*0+!* i 6$&r"'* ,* /i%$(&$0*(!". Pri &$" /i%$(&(* %&$6* %"

(*!":?" /")i(i:" *$ 'r,i(* 6*/* 0ri!"/($%&i !"/i(i#" !"r" 0r""(.

S&ir( 0",i UNIDO 6ri%&6 /i%$(&( %&$6 i(i &,0. /i%$(&(* %&$6* 6$&r$%(!" /$ %" /r$ L 6ri%&6 /i%$(&(* %&$6* %0$/i (* &,0. $'r*(% **&( %&$6

$!* %" 6$ 6r*0i+ r*,+i!" $/ /i%$(&(" %&$6" 6$&r$:(!".

R"%6"&!#i 6r"&$/($ $+$ 'i %" )$ri ,*+!* r"#i i&$ /* 6r$% ($i

("/$i#** i $6r*0/*(i 6ri$0$ri* 0",i %&ir( /* +i !" 6$!"/i(" i(0"%&i#i$("

6r$!"&" $6:&" $#" 0*(&i&*&i0($ $#!"(!i0*&i %* *r$ *%6"&* $/($%($ /* +i %"/r:&0"(" $ri%&i i &r$:$0i $ 6r"#i,($ i 6$,/*($ $#i!"(i&i /* 'i %" $6r*0/*$ (*6$r

1



,* (!i$0$ &0rGi0*(!" i6* !" i(!"(i#* /* %" #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* /*(*% /$%&* $ri%&i

%0i!"&.

D*+" 6$r"/ %0i 6r$'+"* i *(!*0$%&i $(* i6* $%&*!" (*!6ri0*&+!i0i!i "&$/ ,*

$/r"G"(" 0r%&" i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* $!i /$($%" r*,($0r%(" /r%&0"(" $ri%&i i

&r$:$0" ,* r*,(" $ri%(i".

7$ POSTUPAK PROVO5ENJA CBA

C$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* 6r"/%&*0+!* 0"$* %+$"( i (*!":?" /$%&* $'i*( 6r$#"% %* ($$

6r$#!"(* i,r*(*0*(!* 6r"/0iG*(!* i 6$r"G"(!*. Z'$ &$* 6ri!"(* #$%&-'"(")i&

*(*+i," $#!"(i i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* ,*&i!"0* /* %" 6$:&!" $/r"G"(* 6r$#"/r*

,*%($0*(* (*("$+i$ $%($0(i )*,* iIi $r**.

9"("r*+($ +"/*($ $(* !" 0"$* %+i(* $6?$! 6r$#"/ri i(0"%&i#i$($ $/+i0*(!*

i,"G 0i:" *+&"r(*&i0* i r"*+i,!" %" %+!"/"?i /"%"& )*,*H

1> D")i%*(!" 6r$!"*&* ,* *(*+i,

2> D")i%*(!" 0r""(%$ 6"ri$/* (* $!i %" *(*+i,* $/($%i

3> U&0rGi0*(!" %0i $ri%&i i &r$:$0* ,* 6$!"/i(" 6r$!"&"

4> I,r*(*0*(!" %0i $ri%&i i &r$:$0* ($0*($ $'+i ,* 6$!"/i(" 6r$!"&"

5> O/r"Gi0*(!" ri&"ri!* ,* *(*+i,

> O/r"Gi0*(!" /i%$(&(" %&$6" $!* ?" %" $ri%&i&i

@> I,r*(*0*(!" 0ri!"/($%&i 6$!"/i(i ri&"ri!* ,* %0*i 6r$!"*&

;> U6$r"/i0*(!" 0ri!"/($%&i ri&"ri!* ,* 6$!"/i(" 6r$!"&" %* $/r"G"($

!"r$

> O/r"Gi0*(!" /$/*&(i ri&"ri!* *(*+i,"

1<> K$(**( i,'$r - /$($:"(!" i(0"%&i#i$(i $/+*.

U prvoj fazi i/"(&i)i!" %" 'r$! i 0r%&* i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* #i! $6r*0/*($%& &r"'*

i%6i&*&i.T$ $ 'i&i *+&"r(*&i0(* r!":"(!* !"/($ 6r$!"&* =A B iIi C> iIi ("$+i$

r*,+ii&i 6r$!"*&*$!i $%&0*r! i%&i r*,0$!(i #i+!. "/&i #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* i6*

i(,i%&ir* (* 0i%" $?i6r$!"*&* i i,'$r (*!'$+!" i (*+*,i /* &r"'* 6$?i $/ ,*/*&$

r*,0$!($ #iI!* i &0r/i&i6r$!"&" $/($%($ *+&"r(*&i0" $!" $$*0*! (!"$0$

/$%&i,*(!".

2<



U drugoj fazi 0r:i %" /")i(i%*(!" 0r""(%$ 6"ri$/* (* $!i %" *(*+i,* $/($%i. Z* &$

&r"'*,"&i $($ 0ri!"" $!" %" $%&0*r! $/r"/"(i &r$:$0i i $ri%&i. Pri *(*+i,i 0i:"

6r$!"*&* ,i* %" 0i!" (*!/i 0i!" &r*!*(!* ("$ $/ (!i. "G&i &*/* $

(*%&*&i 6r$'+"i i, i(!"(i#" /* ,* &*! 6r$!"*& 6$%&$!" %"(/*r(i ")"&i $!i $

(*%&*&i 6$%+i!" i%&"*(!"$0$ 0i!"* &r*!*(!*. A(*+$($ &$" *$ %" $/*'"r" 0"$*

/ 6"ri$/ $!" %" 0r:i#$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* 6$%&$!i $($%& /* /i%$(&$0*(!"

6$&6($%&i /"r*/ir* ")"&" $!i&r"'* /* %+i!"/" '/#($%&i. Z'$ &$* (" &r"'*

$ri%&i&i 0"$* / 0r""(%i 6"ri$/ ,*6r$!"*&.

U trečoj fazi &0rG! %" &r$:$0i i $ri%&i %0*$ 6r$!"&* &" (!i$0i /ir"&(i i

i(/ir"&(i6ri*r(i i %"(/*r(i *$ i !"r+!i0i i ("!"r+!i0i ")"&i. O0$ !" 0"$*

,(**!*( i 0"$* %+$"( 6$%*$. I*!?i 0i/ /* % ")"&i $/ 6r$!"*&* 0"$* r*,+ii&i

+$i($ !" /* #" i $ri%&i i &r$:$0i 'i&i r*,+ii&i. I%%&0* $0$r" /* &r"'* r*,r*/i&i

6$%"'(" 6r$#"/r" ,*&0r/i0*(!" $ri%&i i &r$%$0* ,* %0* r6 i%&$0!"&(i 6r$!"*&*.

K$/ $0" )*," (*!'i&(i!" !" &$ /* %" , $',ir %0i ")"&i $/($%($ %0" $ri%&i i

&r$%$0i $!" !"/*( 6r$!"*& /$($%i.

U cetvrtoj fazi !"r" %" &r$:$0i i $ri%&i * ,*&i %" i,r**0*! ($0*($ $'+i. O0$

!" 0"$* ,(**!(* i %+$"(* )*,* $!$! %" !*0+!*! 'r$!(i 6r$'+"i. O/ (!i$0$

r!":*0*(!* ,*0i%i i $(**( i%$/ #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,". Pri!" %0"* +!(i 6r$'+" !"

&$" $!" #" %" #i!"(" $ri%&i&i /* 'i %" ")"&i i,r*,i+i ($0#*($ $'+i. S &i 0",i

6r$% r*,(i 6ri!"/+$,i* i $?($%&i* i(i %" /* !" (*!6ri0*&+!i0i!" r!":"(!" /*

%" $ri%&" $'r*(%" #i!"(". T*$/" $0/" !" 6ri%&*( i 6r$'+" *$ !"ri&i i ($0*($

i,r*,i&i ("" (*i,+"/ ("!"r+!i0" ")"&" *$ %&$ %H ,*%&i&* $0!"$0" $$+i(" ,*:&i&*

i%&$ri!%i %6$"(i* i %+.B/?i /* #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* i(,i%&ir* (* !"r"(! i($0*($ i,r**0*(! %0i ")"*&* &$ (*"?" 6$&r"' /* %" $0*0" $ri%&i i &r$:$0i

$r*! 6$%"'(i 6$%&6#i* *(*+i,ir*&i 6r$#!"(!i0*&i i ($0*($ i,r**0*&i.

P$%"'($ &r"'* i%&*#i /* treča i četvrta faza#i(" +*0(i /i$ #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,". O("

$/r**0*! $%($0(" (!"(" i/"!" i 6ri(#i6" 6* !" ("$6$/($ /* '/ 0"$* /$'r$

r*G"(" /* 'i #!"+$6(* *(*+i,* $+* 'i&i 0*+i/(*. Z'$ 6ri%&($%&i ($i 6r$'+"*

$0" /0i!" )*," % &":" i 0"$* %+$"(" *+i i !" ("$6$/($ $'*0i&i i &$ (* (*!'$+!i(*?i( !"r '", (!i ("*(i 0*+i&"&(" #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,".

21



U petoj fazi $/r"/! %" ri&"ri!i ,* $ri:&"(!" #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,". N* r*%6$+**(! i

i* 0i:" * &$ %H ("&$ %*/*:(!* 0ri!"/($%& $ri%&i $/($% $ri%&i i &r$:$0* i(&"r(* %&$6*

r"(&*'i+($%&i i r$ 0r**(!* i(0"%&i#i!". D* +i #" %" $ri%&i&i %0* "&iri ri&"ri!* iIi

%*r($!"/*( $/ (!i ,*0i%i $/ $(r"&($ %+?*!* $/($%($ $/ $(r"&($ 6r$!"&* i

%*$ 6ri%&6*#$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,i.

U sestoj fazi $/r"G!" %" 0"+ii(* /i%$(&(" %&$6" $!* %" $ri%&i 6ri %0$G"(! '/?i

0"+ii(* (* %*/*:(! 0ri!"/($%&. O0* )*,* !" 0"$* ,(**!(* i*!?i 0i/ 0"+ii

&!"#*!/i%$(&(" %&$6" (* 0ri!"/($%& 6$!"/i(i ri&"ri!* $/+i0*(!* 6* &i" i (*

$(*( $/+$ 6r$!"&. I,'$r /i%$(&(" %&$6" ,*0i%i $/ 0i%" )*&$r* *$ %&$ %H 0r%&*

6r$!"&* $!i %" *(*+i,ir* %&*(!" (* &ri:& *6i&*+* =0i%i(* **&(" %&$6"> (*?i(

$'",'!"G"(!*)i(*(%i!%i %r"/%&*0* ,* r"*+i,*#i! 6$!"/i(i 6+*($0* r*,0$!(* 6$+i&i*

,"+!" #":?"0+*/" iii ("" "/(*r$/(" i(%&i&#i!" r"*+i,*#i!i 6r$!"*&* i&/.

U sedmoj fazi r*(*! %" $(r"&(" 0ri!"/($%&i 6$!"/i(i ri&"ri!* ,* %0*i 6r$!"*&.

I*!?i 0i/ r*%6$+$i0$%& *&"*&i" *6*r*&r" i *&"*&i#i i,r*,* ,* $/*'r*("

ri&"ri!" i r*%6$+$i0$%& %0i ("$6$/(i 6$+*,(i 6*r*"&*r* 6r$i,i+*,i ,*+!#* /*

i,r*(*0*(!" 0ri!"/($%&i 6$!"/i(i ri&"ri!* $0$! )*,i *(*+i," (" 'i &r"'*+$ /* '/"

6r$'+"*&i($.

U osmoj fazi 6$r"G! %" i,r*(*&" 0ri!"/($%&i ri&"ri!* ,* 6$!"/i(" 6r$!"&" %*

(*6ri!"/ $/r"/"(i ($r*&i0(i 0"+ii(** * 0r:i %" i "/%$'($ 6$r"Gi0*(!".

S0r* $0" )*," *(*+i," !" /* %" 6r$(*G" $!i 6r$!"*& i* (*!0"? 0ri!"/($%& 6$!"/i(i

ri&"ri!* i &0r/i /* Ii (!i$0" 0ri!"/($%&i ,*/$0$+!*0*! &r*"(" ($r*&i0(" 0"+i#i(".

O0* 6$r"/(* *(*+i,* %+i ,* 6r$(*+*"(!" 6r$!"*&* $!i 6r"* $/*'r*(i

ri&"ri!i* /*! (*!'$+!" r",+&*&".

U devetoj fazi 6$&r"'($ !" i,0r:i&i /$/*&(" *(*+i," $+i$ %" 6r$#i!"(i /* 6r"/$/(*

)*,* (i!" /$0$+!(* /* %" $/*'"r" (*!'$+!" r!":"(!". U $0$! )*,i ("$6$/($ !" r*/i&i

($0" 6r$r*(" 6$%&$!"#i iIi /$6(%i ri&"ri!* *$ i i,0r:i&i $/r"G"(" 6r$!"("

,* ($0" *(*+i,". S&ir( 0",i ("$6$/($ !" i,0r%i&i &,0. *(*+i, $%!"&+!i0$%&i *$ %"

%*&r* /* % $/r"/"(i &i6$0i &r$:$0* =$ri%&i> i,+$"(i 0"" %&"6"( 0*ri!*#i!*.

22



U desetoj fazi 8 $!* 6r"/%&*0+!* 6$%+!"/(! )*, #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i," 0r:i %" $(**(

i,'$r (*!'$+!" 6r$!"&* $/($%($ /$($:"(!" i(0"%&i#i$(" $/+" $ i,'$r (*!'$+!" $/

%0i $!i % 'i+i (* r*%6$+**(!.

I*!?i 0i/ %0" (*0"/"($ $+$ 'i %" )$ri ,*+!* (* r*! r"?i /* !" #$%&

'"(")i& *(*+i,* 0"$* %+$"(* "&$/* $#!"(!i0*(!* i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&*. N!"(*

$%($0(* 6r"/($%& $+"/* %" &$" %&$ %*+"/*0* i $#!"(!!" ")"&" $/ :ir" /r:&0"($

,(**!*. Pri!"(* #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i," /$($%i i r(($$'r$!(" &":$?". "/&i '",

$',ir* (* ($* $r*(i"(!* $(* i6* $%&*!" !"/i(* 6r*0* "&$/* $! &r"'* $ri%&i&i

$/ $#!"(" i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* %* *r$*%6"&*.

8$KRITERIJU9I KOJI SE KORISTE U COST % BENEFITANALIZI

O%($0(i 6ri(#i6 #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i," (*+*,i /* !" 6r$!"*& ,* r"*+i,*#i! $6r*0/*( !"/i($

*$ !" 6(* $ri%& $! $( /$($%i 0"* $/ $#"i0*(i &r$:$0*. O0*! 6ri(#i6 %"

$ri%&i i 6ri /")i(i%*(! $/$0*r*!?i ri&"ri!* ,* $#!"( ")i*%($%&i i(0"%&i#i$(i

6r$!"*&* (*r*0($ , r"%6"&$0*(!" i $%&*+i "+""(*&* $!" !" ("$6$/($ &i

%+*!"0i* ,"&i $',ir.

Pri $#"(!i0*(! i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* 6ri"($ C$%& – '"(")i& *(*+i," $?" !"

$ri%&i&i 0"?i 'r$! ri&"ri!* ,* $#"(. O0/" ?" 'i&i 6r","(&$0*(* "&iri $?*

ri&"ri!*H

1. Kri&"ri! %*/*:(!" ("&$ $ri%&i

2. Kri&"ri! i(&"r(" %&$6" r"(&*'i+($%&i

3. K$")i#i!"(& $/($%* $ri%&i i &r$:$0*

4. Kri&"ri! r$* 0r*?*(!* i(0"%&i#i!*.

*.1. riterijum sada!nje neto koristi

P$/ ri&"ri!$ %*/*:(!" 0ri!"/($%&i ("&$ $ri%&i 6$/r*,i!"0*$ r*,+i i,"G

6(i /i%$(&$0*(i $ri%&i i 6(i /i%$(&$0*(i &r$:$0* $!" $%&0*ri !"/*(

i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&

13

.1R$/i? J.H T"$ri!* i *(*+i,* 'i+*(%* B"$r*/ 1<.

23



Kns : Ks % Ts

/!" %H

Kns – ri&"ri! %*/*:(!" 0ri!"/($%&i ("&$ $ri%&i

Ks – 6(" /i%$(&$0*(" $ri%&i

Ts – 6(i /i%$(&$0*(i &r$:$0i.

O#!"(!i0*(!" i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* $ri:&"(!" $0$ ri&"ri!* 0r:i %" (* &*! (*i(

:&$ %" %0*i 6r$!"*& $/ $!" !" 0r"/($%& ri&"ri!* %*/*:(!" 0r"/($%&i ("&$ $ri%&i

6$,i&i0(* = K(% < > %*&r* %" "$($%i ")i*%(i i 6$ &$! $%($0i $6r*0/*(i ,*

r"*+i,*#i!. A$ 0r:i$ $#!"( i,"G 0i:" 6r$!"*&* (*!'$+!i ?" 'i&i $(*! 6r$!"*& $!i

i* (*!0"? 6$,i&i0( 0r"/($%& $0$ ri&"ri!*.

K*$ 6$*,*&"+! $!i $6"ri:" %* *6%$+&(i 0"+ii(** $ri%&i i &r$:$0* $!" /$($%i

!"/*( i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*& $0*! ri&"ri! %" 6ri $#!"(i i%+!i0$ $%+*(!* (* 0"+ii(

%*/*:(!" 0ri!"/($%&i ("&$ $ri%&i */* (* %*$ i,r*(*0*(!" $0$ ri&"ri!*

,(**!($ &i 6*r*"&ri *$ :&$ !" 0" "%6+$*&*#i!" 0"+ii(* 6(i i(0"%&i#i!*

/i%$(&(* %&$6*.

K*$ *6%$+&(i 6$*,*&"+! ri&"ri! %*/*:(!" 0ri!"/($%&i ("&$ $ri%&i !" 6$$/(i!i ,*

$#!"( 0*+!*($%&i !"/($ 6r$!"&* ("$ ,* i,'$r i,"G 0i:" 6r$!"*&*.

*.2. riterijum interne stope rentabilnosti #%3

I(&"r(* %&$6* r"(&*'i+($%&i 6r"/%&*0+!* $( /i%$(&( %&$6 6ri $!$! !" %*

/i%$(&$0*(i $ri%&i !"/(** %i /i%$(&$0*(i &r$:$0* $/($%($ 6ri $!$! !"

%*/*:(!* 0ri!"/($%& ("&$ $ri%&i !"/(** (+i. I,r*(*0* %" i, %+"/"?" $'r*%#*H

Kns : Ks % Ts : ;

24



O#!"(!i0*(!" i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* , 6$$? ri&"ri!* ISR 0r:i %" (* &*! (*i( :&$ %"

%0*i 6r$!"*& $/ $* !" 0"+ii(* ISR 0"?* $/ **&(" %&$6" $!* 0+*/* (* &ri:&

*6i&*+* =i+i $/ %0$!"(" /i%$(&(" %&$6"> %*&r* 6$0$+!(i i "$($%i $6r*0/*(i ,*

r"*+i,*#i!14. K*/* !" 6i&*(! i,'$r i,"G 0i:" i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* %*&r* %" /* !"

6$0$+!(i!i $(*! 6r$!"*& $!i i* 0"? ISR.

I,r*(*0*(!" ISR !" /$%&* $6+i$0*(* $6"r*#i!*. S*$ (*!!"/($%&*0(i!" %+*!

i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&* $/ $* %" 0r:i +**(!" $/!"/($ * $ri%&i i &r$:$0i %

$(%&*(&i 6$ $/i(** i,r*(*0*(!" ISR !" !"/($%&*0($ i 0r:i %" 6$$? *(i&"&(i

&*'+i#*.

K$6+i$0*($%& i,r*(*0*(!* ISR !" i (*!0"?* 6r"6r"* $0$ ri&"ri!* "G&i

ri&"ri! 6$%"/!" i (i, 6$,i&i0(i $%$'i(* "G $!i* %" 6$%"'($ i%&i" i,'"*0*(!"

%'!"&i0($ $/r"Gi0*(!* /i%$(&(" %&$6".

*.". oeficijent odnosa koristi i tro!kova

O0*! ri&"ri! 6r"/%&*0+!"( !" $/($%$ 6(i /i%$(&$0*(i $ri%&i i 6(i

/i%$(&$0*(i &r$:$0* $!" /$($%i !"/*( i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&15. P$*,!" $+i$

!"/i(i#* $ri%&i /$($%i %0** !"/i(i#* &r$:"(i %r"/%&*0*. I,r*(*0* %" 6$$? %+"/"?"

)$r+"H

K = Ks

Ts

Pr$!"*& %" %*&r* 6$0$+!(i i "$($%i $6r*0/*(i ,* r"*+i,*#i! $+i$ i*

0r"/($%& $0$ ri&"ri!* 0"? $/ 1. U$+i$ %" 0r:i $#"(* i i,'$r i,"G 0i:"

r*%6$+$i0i 6r$!"*&* *$ (*!6$$/(i!i %*&r* %" $(*! 6r$!"*& $!i i* (*!0"?

0r"/($%& $0$ $")i#i!"(&* , i%6(!"( %+$0. O0*! ri&"ri! %" %*&r* 6$ %0$!i

*r*&"ri%&i** i()"ri$r(i $/($% (* ri&"ri! %*/*:(!" 0r"/($%&i ("&$ $ri%&i.

13.%#ri'/.#$/$#12;@11@C$%&-B"(")i&-*(*+i,* =/*& 6ri%&6* [email protected]<15.>

15.&6r.rU%"rD$#%I*"%CBA-PREZ.6/) =/*& 6ri%&6* [email protected]<15.>

25



P$r"/ $")i#i!"(&* $/($%* 6(i $ri%&i i &r$:$0* $ %" $ri%&i&i i /ri

$")i#i!"(&i *$ :&$ %H

• K$")i#i!"(& %*/*:(!" 0r"/($%&i ("&$ $ri%&i i 6(i i(0"%&i#i!*

k = Kns

Is

• K$")i#i!"(& %*/*:(!" 0r"/($%&i ("&$ $ri%&i i 6(i /i%$(&$0*(i &r$:$0*.

k = Kns

Ts

*.). riterijum roka vraćanja investicija

R$ 0r*?*(!* 6r"/%&*0+!* 6"ri$/ i,r*"( $/i(** ,* $!i ?" %*/*:(!* 0r"/($%& ("&$

$ri%&i $/ i(0"%&i#i!" /* $&6+*&i +$"(* %r"/%&0*. I,r*(*0* %" 6$$? )$r+"H

∑k =0

n

Ik ∗ak =∑k =0

n

Kk ∗ak

/!" %H

I) – +**(!* – &$! $/i(i 6"ri$/* +**(!*

K) – $ri%&i $/ i(0"%&i#i!" – &$! $/i(i 6"ri$/* "%6+$*&*#i!".

Pr$!"*& $"$ %*&r*&i /* !" 6$0$+!*( i "$($%i $6r*0/*( ,* r"*+i,*#i! */* !"

(!"$0 r$ 0r*?*(!* *(!i $/ ("$ (*6r"/ ,*/*&$ ($r*&i0($ r$* 0r*?*(!*. K*$

($r*&i0(i r$ 0r*?*(!* $" %" 6ri'+i($ ,"&i "$($%i 0" &r*!*(!* $6r"". Z*

$#"( 0i:" 6r$!"*&* 0*i 6r*0i+$ /* !" (*!'$+!i $(*! 6r$!"*& $!i i* (*!r*?i r$

0r*?*(!*. O0*! ri&"ri! %" $" $ri%&i&i ,* $#"( 0i:" 6r$!"*&* !"/i($ %+*!

i%&$0r%(i 6r$!"*&* i+i $/ i,'$r* i,"G 0i:" 0*ri!*(&i !"/($ 6r$!"&*.

2



O0*! ri&"ri! %" $'i($ $ri%&i %+*!"0i* i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* $/ $!i !" 'r,$

&"($+$:$ i "$($%$ ,*%&*r"0*(!" $6r"" &" !" &"(!* i(0"%&i&$r* /* :&$ 6r" $&6+*&i

+$"(* %r"/%&0* *$ 'i 6$($0$ $*$ /* /$G" /$ $/"r(i!" $6r"".

R$ 0r*?*(!* i(0"%&i#i!* !" 0"$* +* ,* i,r*(*0*(!" i 6ri"(. O%($0(i ("/$%&*&*

$0$ ri&"ri!* !" :&$ (" ,i* $',ir $ri%&i i &r$:$0" 6r$!"&* #"+$6($

6"ri$/ "%6+$*&*#i!" i(0"%&i#i!" 0"? %*$ /$ &r"(&* 6$0r*&* 6(i +$"(i

%r"/%&*0*.

<$PROCEDURA PRI9JENE COST % BENEFIT ANALIZE

CB *(*+i,* 6r"/%&*0+!* /$%&* %+$"( i (*!":?" /$%&* $'i( *(*+i, %* 6($

6r$#i!"(* i,r*(*0*(!* 6r"/0iG*(!* i 6$r"G"(!*. Z'$ &$* 6ri"(* CB *(*+i,"

$#i!"(i 0*+!*($%&i !"/($ i+i ":?" 6ri i,'$r i,"G 0i:" i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* ,*&"0*

/* %" 6$:&!" $/r"G"(* 6r$#"/r* $!* %" ,*%(i0* (* ("$+i$ $%($0(i )*,* i+i $r**.

9efinisanje projekata koji će biti analizirani – U 6r0$! )*,ii/"(&i)i!" %" 'r$! i

0r%&* i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* i! $6r*0/*($%& &r"'* i%6i&*&i. T$ $ 'i&i

*+&"r(*&i0(* r":"(!* !"/($ 6r$!"&* =A B i+i C> i+i ("$+i$ r*,+ii&i 6r$!"*&*

$!i $%&0*r! i%&i r*,0$!(i #i+!. "G&i #$%& – '"(")i& *(*+i,* i6* i(%i%&ir* (*

0i:" $?i 6r$!"*&* i i,'$r (*!'$+!" i (*+*,i /* &r"'* 6$?i $/ ,*/*&$

r*,0$!($ #i+!* i &0r/i&i 6r$!"&" $/($%($ *+&"r(*&i0" $!" $$?*0*!

(!"$0$ /$%&i,*(!". Vr:i %" $/*'ir*(!" r6" "G%$'($ i%+!i0i 6r$!"*&*

i,"G $!i , 6$$? CB *(*+i," &r"'* i,*'r*&i (*!'$+!i. T$ $ /* '/

*+&"r(*&i0(* r":"(!* !"/($ 6r$!"&* i+i ("$+i$ r*,+ii&i 6r$!"*&* $!i

$%&0*r! i%&i #i+!. U %0*$ %+*! CB *(*+i,* i(%i%&ir* (* 0i:" $?i

6r$!"*&* i i,'$r (*!'$+!".

K$/ definisanja vremenskog perioda (* $!i ?" %" $/($%i&i *(*+i,* – &r"'* ,"&i

$(*! 0r""(%i 6"ri$/ $!" %" $%&0*r! $/r"G"(i &r$:$0i i $ri%&i. K$/

*(*+i," 0i:" 6r$!"*&* $" %" ,"&i 0" &r*!*(!* (*!/" 6r$!"&* %*

"0"(&*+(i 6r$'+"i* $!i 6r$i%&i i, i(!"(i#" /* ,* &*! 6r$!"*& 6$%&$!"

%"(/*r(i ")"&i $!i (*%&*! 6$%+" i%&"* 0"* &r*!*(!* 6r$!"&*. K*/* %"

$/*'"r" 0"$* / 0r""(%i 6"ri$/ $!" %" 0r:i CB *(*+i,* 6$%&$!i

6r$'+" /* ?" /i%$(&$0*(!" /* 6$&6($ /"r*/ir* ")"&" $!i %" /$'i!*!

2@



/*+!$! '/?($%&i. T$ *,!" (* 6$&r"' /* $0" ")"&" (" &r"'* ,"&i $',ir &!.

/* (" &r"'* $ri%&i&i 0"$* / 6"ri$/.

K$/ utvr6ivanja svi( koristi i tro!kova za pojedine projekte – $0/" !" 6$&r"'($

&0r/i&i %0" &r$:$0" i $ri%&i $!" /$($%i %0*i 6r$!"*& r*(*!?i & /ir"&(" i

i(/ir"&(" ")"&" 6ri*r(" i %"(/*r(" "r+!i0" i (""r+!i0". T*$G" &r"'*

0i/"&i /* +i 6$%&$!" i $!" % i,'+!"(" $ri%&i i (* $!i (*i( %" $%&0*r! i

$+ii % %*(!"(i &r$:$0i $!i 6r"/%&*0+!*! $/r"G"(" $ri%&i $/ 6r$!"&*. O0$

!" 0"$* ,(**!*( 6$%*$ CB *(*+i,i i 0"$* %+$"(.

#zračunavanje svi( koristi i tro!kova u novčanom obliku za pojedine projekte.' $

četvrtoj fazi "r" %" &r$:$0i i $ri%&i* ,*&i %" i,r**0*! ($0*($

$'+i.O0$ !" 0"$* ,(**!(* i %+$"(* )*,* $!$! %" !*0+!*! 'r$!(i 6r$'+"i.

O/ (!i$0$r":*0*(!* ,*0i%i i $(**( i%$/#$%& – '"(")i& *(*+i,". Pr" %0"*

+!(i6r$'+" !" &$" $!" ?" %" #"(" $ri%&i&i/* 'i %" ")"&i i,r*,i+i

($0*($ $'+i.S &i 0",i 6r$% r*,(i 6r"/+$,i* i$?($%&i* i(i

%" /* !" (*!6ri0*&+!i0i!"r":"(!" /* %" $ri%&" $'r*(%" #"(".T*$G" $0/" !"

6ri%&*( i 6r$'+" *$"ri&i i ($0*($ i,r*,i&i ("" (*i,+"/

(""r+!i0"")"&" *$ :&$ %H ,*:&i&* $0"$0"$$+i(" ,*:&i&* i%&$ri!%i

%6$"(i* i %+.B/?i /* #$%& – '"(")i& *(*+i,* i(%i%&ir* (*"r"(! i ($0*($

i,r**0*(! %0i ")"*&*&$ (*"?" 6$&r"' /* %" $0*0" $ri%&i i&r$:$0i $r*!

6$%"'(i 6$%&6#i* *(*+i,ir*&i6r$#"(!i0*&i i ($0*($ i,r**0*&i.P$%"'($ &r"'*

i%&*?i /* treća ičetvrta faza i(" +*0(i /"$ #$%& – '"(")i&*(*+i,". O(" $/r**0*!

$%($0(" (!"("i/"!" i 6ri(#i6" 6* !" ("$6$/($ /* '/0"$* /$'r$ r*G"(" /*

'i #"+$6(**(*+i,* $+* 'i&i 0*+i/(*. Z'$ 6ri%&($%&i($i 6r$'+"* $0"

/0" )*," % &":" i0"$* %+$"(" *+i i !" ("$6$/($ $'*0i&ii &$ (* (*!'$+!i

(*i( !"r '", (!i ("* (i 0*+i&"&(" #$%& – '"(")i& *(*+i,".

K$/ odre6ivanja kriterijuma $!i ?" %" $ri%&i&i *(*+i,i (* r*%6$+**(! !" 0i:"

ri&"ri!* * 6r" %0"* %*/*:(!* 0r"/($%& ("&$ $ri%&i $/($% $ri%&i i &r$:$0*

i(&"r(* %&$6* r"(&*'i+($%&i i r$ 0r*?*(!*. D* +i ?"$ $ri%&i&i %0* "&iri

ri&"ri!* i+i %*$ !"/*( ,*0i%i $/ $(r"&($ %+*!* $/($%($ $/ $(r"&($

6r$!"&* i $/ $(r"&($ 6ri%&6* $'r*Gi0** CB *(*+i,".

2;



:dre6ivanje diskontne stope $!* ?" %" $ri%&i&i – $ !estoj fazi $/r"G!" %"

0"+ii(* /i%$(&("%&$6" $!* %" $ri%&i 6ri %0$G"(!'/?i 0"+ii(* (* %*/*:(!

0r"/($%&.O0* )*,* !" 0"$* ,(**!(* i*!?i 0i/ 0"+ii &i#*! /i%$(&("

%&$6" (* 0r"/($%&6$!"/i(i ri&"ri!* $/+i0*(!* 6*&i" i (* $(*( $/+

$ 6r$!"&. I,'$r/i%$(&(" %&$6" ,*0i%i $/ 0i:" )*&$r**$ :&$ %H 0r%&* 6r$!"&*

$!i %" *(*+i,ir*%&*(!" (* &ri:& *6i&*+* =0i%i(* **&("%&$6"> (*i(

$'",'"G"(!* )i(*(%i!%i%r"/%&*0* ,* r"*+i,*#i! 6$!"/i(i 6+*($0*r*,0$!(*

6$+i&i* ,"+!" ":?" 0+*/" i+i("" "G(*r$/(" i(%&i&#i!" r"*+i,*#i!i

6r$!"*&* i&/.

#zračunavanje vrednosti pojedini( kriterijuma za svaki projekat – (* $%($0 %0i

6r"&$/($ 6ri6r"+!"(i 6r$!"*&* 0r:i %" $(*($ i,r*(*0*(!" 6$!"/i(i

ri&"ri!* ,* %0*i 6r$!"*&.

$pore6ivanje vrednosti kriterijuma za pojedine projekte sa odre6enom mjerom i

me6usobno – $ osmoj fazi 6$r"G! %" i,r*(*&"0r"/($%&i ri&"ri!* ,*

6$!"/i(" 6r$!"&"%* (*6r"/ $/r"G"(i ($r*&i0(i0"+ii(** * 0r:i %" i

"G%$'($6$r"Gi0*(!". S0r* $0" )*," *(*+i," !"/* %" 6r$(*G" $!i 6r$!"*&

i* (*!0"?0r"/($%& 6$!"/i(i ri&"ri!* i &0r/i /*+i (!i$0" 0r"/($%&i

,*/$0$+!*0*! &r*"("($r*&i0(" 0"+ii(". O0* 6$r"/(* *(*+i,*%+i ,*

6r$(*+*"(!" 6r$!"*&* $!i 6r"* $/*'r*(i ri&"ri!i* /*! (*!'$+!"

r",+&*&"

9odatni kriterijumi i analize – $+i$ %*&r*$ /* i, 6r"&$/(" )*," *(*+i,*

(i!"/$0$+!(* /* %" $/*'"r" (*!'$+!" r":"(!" $?" !" $0$! )*,i i,0r:i&i

/$/*&(" *(*+i,"($0" 6r$r*(" 6$%&$!"?i i+i /$6(%i ri&"ri!* i+i i,0r:i&i

("" 6r$"(" $!"$$?*0*! ($0" 6r$r*(" i *(*+i,".

onačan izbor8 dono!enje odluke – $0/" %" 0r:i $(**( i,'$r (*!'$+!"

6r$!"&* $/($%($ /$($:"(!" i(0"%&i#i$(" $/+" $ i,'$r (*!'$+!" 6r$!"&* i,

%6* r*%6$+$i0i 6r$!"*&*.

2



ZAKLJU'AK

Pri+i$ $#!"(" $6r*0/*($%&i r"*+i,*#i!" !"/($ i(0"%&i#i$($ 6r$!"&* &r"'* 0" i*&i

0i/ i ")"&" $!" 6r$!"*& /$($%i /ri $r*(i,*#i!** i+i :ir$$! ,*!"/(i#i.

P$!"/i(" i(0"%&i#i!" % 6$ %0$!$! 6rir$/i &*0" /* %" $r*! 6$%*&r*&i i $#"(!i0*&i 6ri!"

%0"* %* :ir" /r:&0"($ *%6"&* – %*$'r*?*!($ "("r"&%$ $/'r*'"($ 6rir$/($ /r:&0"($ i %+ ,'$ %0$ 0"+i$ /$6ri($%* $!i /*! ,"+!i #!"+i(i.

3<



O0*0i 6r$!"&i %" (* (*!'$+!i (*i( $ $#!"(!i0*&i *$ %" *(*+i,ir*! i , $',ir

6(i ")"&i $!" /$($%i 6$%*&r*(i i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&. C$%& – '"(")i& *(*+i,* !"

"&$/* "$($%" *(*+i," $!$ %" 6$r"G! i 0r"/(! %0" 6r"/($%&i i %0i ("/$%&*#i

("$ 6ri0r"/($ 6$/0*&* i+i 6r$!"&* *(*+i,$ &r$:$0* = #$%& > i $ri%&i = '"(")i& >.

O0* *(*+i,* %" (" $ri%&i ,* i(0"%&i#i$(" 6r$!"&" $!i /$($%" %*$ /ir"&("

$"r#i!*+(" ")"&" $!i %" $ "ri&i i 0*(&i&i0($ i,r*,i&i 0"? 6ri!" %0"* ,*

6r$!"&" $!i /$($%" i ,(**!(" i(/ir"&(" i (""r+!i0" ")"&".

I*!?i 0i/ %0" (*0"/"($ $+$ 'i %" )$ri ,*+!* (* r*! r"?i /* !" #$%&

'"(")i& *(*+i,* 0"$* %+$"(* "&$/* $#!"(!i0*(!* i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&*. N!"(*

$%($0(* 6r"/($%& $+"/* %" &$" %&$ %*+"/*0* i $#!"(!!" ")"&" $/ :ir" /r:&0"($

,(**!*. Pri!"(* #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i," /$($%i i r(($$'r$!(" &":$?". "/&i '",

$',ir* (* ($* $r*(i"(!* $(* i6* $%&*!" !"/i(* 6r*0* "&$/* $! &r"'* $ri%&i&i

$/ $#!"(" i(0"%&i#i$(i 6r$!"*&* %* *r$*%6"&*.

I6* (*:$! %" 6r*%i #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* 0r+$ ri!"&$ 6ri!"(!!" !"r !" ri!" $

6r$!"&i* $!i* 6r"%G!" 6$+i&i*. "G&i %* %&*!*+i:&* &0rGi0*(!* r*,0$!(i

6ri$ri&"&* i()r*%&r&ri #$%&-'"(")i& *(*+i,* !" (",*!"(!i0*.

LITERATURA

1. Ni$+i? . i P*($0i? B. 1@ Ekonomika preduzeća E$($%i )*+&"&

B"$r*/

2. P"r$0i? . i Ki%i? S. 13 Ekonomika preduzeća S*0r""(* */i(i%&r*#i!*

B"$r*/

3. R$/i? J. 1< Teorija i analiza bilansa B"$r*/

31



4. $r+/ B*(H Economic #mpacts of .$.%. "1 &orridor #mprovementsM

I(&"r("& i,0$riH

1. .$r+/'*(.$r&r*(%6$r&r$*/%r6+-/$#%i(/i*(*.6/) 2. .%#ri'/.#$/$#12;@11@C$%&-B"(")i&-*(*+i,*3. .&6r.rU%"rD$#%I*"%CBA-PREZ.6/)4. .%#ri'/.#$/$#12;@11@C$%&-B"(")i&-*(*+i,*5. ."))"#&.ri(/".66133A#$%&-'"(")i&-*(*+i,*. ."))"#&.ri(/".66133A#$%&-'"(")i&-*(*+i,*@. &&6Hr/*r.r(.r/r*!$0i(i/%/*irr*!$0i#%ri6&*C$%&'"(")i&*(*+i,*-

%ri6&*.6/) ;. &&6H.($0ir*/.r/$#"(&%Pr$"&(*

2<%&/i!*<2%&/i!*i,0$/+!i0$%&iN9.6/) . &&6H6$.,$i6.rU%"rD$#%I*"%Pr","(&*#i!*22<<.6/) 1<. &&6H.%$.$r',/*&*52<*(*+%2<2<V$/i#iSERPrir#(i2<,*

2<)i(*(%ir*(!"2<*6.2<i(0"%&.2<6r$!"*&*.6/) 11. &&6H*6).6)%&.(i%&.r&/*/i#I()$r*&i#iPr$!"&#'*.&12. &&6Hi).r#$%&-'"(")i&-*(*+i,*-#'*-6r"*-($0$!-"&$/$+$i!i-"13. &&6H.06%.(%.*#.r%*&"ri!*+*&134;3.6/) 13&&6H.6"6$+"/i.$rAri0*2<13<1<12<*r$2<I0*(i%2<S+$'$/*(

2<S+$0i#2<2<U+$*2<i2<,(*#*!2<#$%&'"(")i&2<*(*+i,"2<

2<i(0"%&i#i$($2<"(*/,"(&.6/)

http://www.worldbank.org/transport/roads/rpl-docs/indiana.pdf

http://www.scribd.com/doc/12897117/Cost-Benefit-analiza

http://rudar.rgn.hr/~drajkovi/nids_damirrajkovic/skripta/Cost_benefit_analiza-skripta.pdf


http://www.novigrad.hr/documents/Prometna%20studija/02_studija_izvodljivosti_NG.pdf


http://puo.mzoip.hr/UserDocsImages/Prezentacija2_2009.pdf

http://www.skgo.org/bz/data/5%20Manuals%20%20Vodici/SER/Prirucnik%20za%20finansiranje%20kap.%20invest.%20projekata.pdf


http://mapmf.pmfst.unist.hr/~tdadic/InformatickiProjekt/cba.htm

http://hif.hr/cost-benefit-analiza-cba-prema-novoj-metodologiji-eu/

http://www.vps.ns.ac.rs/Materijal/mat13483.pdf

http://www.worldbank.org/transport/roads/rpl-docs/indiana.pdf

http://www.scribd.com/doc/12897117/Cost-Benefit-analiza





http://puo.mzoip.hr/UserDocsImages/Prezentacija2_2009.pdf



http://mapmf.pmfst.unist.hr/~tdadic/InformatickiProjekt/cba.htm

http://hif.hr/cost-benefit-analiza-cba-prema-novoj-metodologiji-eu/

http://www.vps.ns.ac.rs/Materijal/mat13483.pdf

Tulic Sadbera- Seminarski Rad (CB ANALIZA)

Documents

Transcript of Tulic Sadbera- Seminarski Rad (CB ANALIZA)