Galvanization Tour 2012

Big R Bridge

AZZ Galvanizing Services

Kevin Irving

Marketing Manager Northern Ops

[email protected]

815-693-4242

mailto:[email protected]

Tour of the City

Weathering Steel

I-69 Bridge

Ford County – 00N, 2350E

New Galvanized Bridges in

Chicago

35th Street & Dan Ryan 362 Tons

51 Street & Dan Ryan 349 Tons

Douglas Lake Connection 1444 Tons



Michigan Ave over I-94 234 Tons

91st Street & Dan Ryan 234 Tons


CTA , IL Toll Road, IDOT &

Counties

Over 50 Million Pounds of

Bridges were Galvanized

in Illinois in last 5 years.

26th Street & the Dan Ryan

Tappenzee Bridge

Michigan/MI-102 Bridge Rail

Date Galvanized 2007

Components Galvanized Guide rails

Environment Urban

Location Detroit, MI

Michigan / MI-102 Bridge Rail

Richland County Bridge

Knox County, OH - Before

Knox County, OH - After

Seneca County, OH - Before

Seneca County, OH - After

Village of Glouster County, OH - Before

Village of Glouster, OH - After

Village of Minerva, OH - Before

Village of Minerva, OH - After

Corrosion Problem – Case

Study The Williamsburg Bridge

built in 1903 in New York City

1991 inspection revealed severe corrosion direct cost of repairs was $750 million

indirect cost approximately $8.2 billion

40% of Carbon Steel Goes

to Replace Corroded Steel

At a Cost of

$350 Billion per Year

Equivalent of Building

562 Willis Towers (Sears)

Every Year

Corrosion Process

Law of Entropy

Tendency for metal, after production and shaping,

to revert back to its lower, more natural energy

state or ore

Definition of Corrosion

Corrosion (n): the chemical or

electrochemical reaction between a material

and its environment that produces a

deterioration of the material and its

properties

Return Current

Path

Electrolyte

+ Anode Cathode

Bimetallic Couple

Long-Lasting Zinc Protection

• Barrier • Cathodic • Zinc Patina • Metallurgical Bond

Barrier Protection

Cathodic Protection

Galvanic Series of Metals

This arrangement of metals

determines what metal will be the

anode and cathode when the two

are put in a electrolytic cell

(arrangement dependent on salt

water as electrolyte).

ZINC = ANODE

STEEL = CATHODE

Sacrificial Zinc Anodes

Zinc

Zinc Oxide

Zinc Hydroxide

Zinc Carbonate

Zinc Patina

Air Moisture

Carbon Dioxide

The History of Galvanizing

79 AD 1772 1829 1870 Today

Galvanizing Process

Pre-Inspection

We Protect More Than Steel

HDG Process: Surface

Preparation

Thorough cleaning is

necessary as zinc will

only adhere to clean steel

Degreasing –

removes dirt, oils,

organic residue

Degreasing Tank



Preparation

Thorough cleaning is



Degreasing –

removes dirt, oils,

organic residue

Pickling – Removes

mill scale and oxides

Pickling Tank



Preparation Thorough cleaning is



Degreasing –

removes dirt, oils,

organic residue

Pickling – Removes

mill scale and oxides

Fluxing – Mild

cleaning, provides

protective layer Flux Tank


HDG Process: Galvanizing

Steel immersed in bath

of molten zinc (~830 F)

> 98% pure zinc, up to

2% additives (Al, Bi, Ni)

Zinc reacts with iron in

steel to form coating

Reaction is complete

when steel reaches

bath temperature

Galvanizing Bath

Hot-Dip Galvanizing

FHWA Rebar Seminar –

Providence, RI, 27 March 2008

71

Hot Dip (Dry) Galvanizing

HDG Process: Inspection

Steel is inspected

after galvanizing to

verify conformance to

specs

Visual inspection to

identify any surface

defects

Magnetic thickness

gauge to check

coating thickness

Metallurgical Bond

steel

Gamma

Delta

Zeta

75% Zinc 25% Iron

90% Zinc 10% Iron

100% Zinc

94% Zinc 6% Iron

Eta

Abrasion Resistance

DPN = 159

DPN = 245

DPN = 180

DPN =70

DPN = 250

Eta Zeta Delta Gamma Steel

DPN: Diamond Pyramid Number

Edge Protection

Complete Protection

Edges

Welds & Seams

Hard to Reach Spots

Typical Spray Application Hot-Dip Galvanizing

Variety of Sizes & Shapes

Availability

It’s a Natural Element

It’s Essential

SAFE

GREEN

ESSENTIAL

FOR LIFE

HOT DIP GALVANIZING

It’s Recyclable

Sustainability: Galvanizing is

Green Zinc and steel are 100% recyclable

Properties of zinc (and steel) do not degrade with reprocessing

Zinc is a natural element in the Earth’s crust

Recycled content contributes to LEED

Galvanizing’s maintenance-free durability ensures no additional energy, materials, or emissions during use

Hot-Dip Galvanizing & LEED®

HDG contributes points under Materials &

Resources Credit 4: Recycled Content Credit 4.1: Use materials with recycled content

(10%)

sum of post consumer recycled content plus one-half of

the pre-consumer content equals 10% of the total value

of the materials in the project

Credit 4.2: Use materials with recycled content

(20%)

sum of the post consumer recycled content plus one-half

of the pre-consumer content constitutes at least an

additional 10% beyond Credit 4.1 (total of at least 20%)

of the total value of the materials in the project

Other Zinc Coatings

Metallized Hot-Dip Galvanized

Zinc-Rich Paint Galvanized

Sheet Electroplated

Zinc Coating Life Predictor

Anticipates service life

Program performs

calculations

Statistical methods

Neural network

technology

Worldwide corrosion

database

Atmospheric

categories

Rural

Suburban

Temperate marine

Tropical marine

Industrial

Estimated Service Life of

HDG

Metallurgical Bond

steel

Gamma

Delta

Zeta

75% Zinc 25% Iron

90% Zinc 10% Iron

100% Zinc

94% Zinc 6% Iron

Eta

Design & Fabrication

Liaison Between...

Design Engineer

Fabricator

Galvanizer

Avoid Combining Different Materials

Welding Procedures

and Flux Removal

Remove prior to galvanizing

Seal Welding

Viscosity of zinc

prevents it from

entering gaps less

than 3/32”

Complete seal-welding

or stitch-welding with

at least 3/32” gap

between surfaces

Galvanizing Oversized Pieces

26th Street & the Dan Ryan

Material Handling

Allowing for Proper Venting & Drainage

Improper Venting

Marking

ASTM A 123

Coatings on Iron & Steel Products

ASTM A 153

Coatings on Iron & Steel Hardware

ASTM A 385

Providing High-Quality Zinc Coatings

ASTM A 767

Zinc-coated Steel Bars for Concrete Reinforcement

133

www.galvanizedrebar.com

134

Advantages of Hot Dip

Galvanized Rebar

Corrosion resistant

Low cost

Tough

Long history of performance 1948 Royal Navy Dockyards, Bermuda

Higher bond strength

Stearns Bayou Bridge

ASTM A 780

Repair of Damaged & Uncoated Areas of Hot-Dip

Galvanized Coatings

Zinc-Based Alloys Zinc Dust Paint

Metallizing

ASTM D 6386

Standard Practice for Preparation of Zinc (Hot-Dip) Galvanized Coated Iron & Steel Product & Hardware Surfaces

for Painting

“All commonly practiced

welding and cutting

techniques can be used on

Galvanized Alloyed steel”

American Welding Society

D – 19.0

Welding Zinc Coated Steel

AZZinc Protects

Preparation of Weld Area

“weld area should be free of

Galvanizing, 1 to 4 inches

back, both sides, top and

bottom”

AZZinc Protects

Removing the Galvanizing

1) Grind it off

2) Burn it off

3) Apply Galva Stop before Galvanizing

AZZinc Protects

Preparation of Weld Area

Weathering of Galvanized Steel

Photo taken 12/18/02

Photo taken 03/28/03

Steel Chemistry Sandelin Curve

Irregular Zinc-Iron

Alloy Layers

Typical Zinc-Iron Alloy Layers

Electrochemical Corrosion Zone

Painting Over Galvanized Steel

Painting Galvanized Steel

Painting Ungalvanized Steel

Synergistic Effect

Safety Marking

Color

Coding

Stark County – Pro Football Hall of Fame Bridge

Real-world

Applications

Stears Bayou Bridge

Cost Analysis of

The Stearns Bayou Bridge


First fully galvanized bridge in the US

Built in Michigan 1966

All steel components were galvanized handrail

diaphragms

fasteners

shear connectors

beams

Stearns Bayou Bridge Options

Option 1:

Paint the steel structure

Preparation costs

were not included

Option 2:

Galvanize the structure

Cost Comparison

Initial cost

Maintenance

Maintenance

Maintenance

Maintenance

Initial cost

What $8,700.00 Bought the Specifier

46 years of:

A rust-free surface

A spangled appearance

A coating thickness of an average of

4.4 mils today

48 more years maintenance free

Spring Lake Bridge MI

Dick Vale Bridge Peru, ME

Montgomery County -Maryland


7th Avenue Light Rail Transit


Components Galvanized Columns, arms, light posts,

handrails, benches, hardware

Environment Urban

Location Calgary, AB

Fallowfield Township – Washington County PA

Bryants Bridge – Saratoga County N. Y.

Hot-Dip Galvanizing

Costs Less Lasts Longer

The Cost of Corrosion

Protection Initial cost will always factor into decision

Life-cycle cost analysis is more complete

Includes all future maintenance costs

Provides total cost of the project over its life

Life-cycle cost calculation automated

online at

www.galvanizeit.org/galvanizingcost/

Quantitative Analysis

Data Sources:

Paint – 2008 KTA Tator paper Nationwide survey of the paint industry

Presented at NACE 2009

Galvanizing – 2008 AGA Industry Survey

Project Parameters Standard mix of steel (structural, tubing, plate)

30,000 ft2 project

Moderately industrial environment

Initial Cost Parameters

Paint

Material (one- or two-

pack product, number

of coats, etc)

Shop cleaning labor

Shop/field application

Field labor

Galvanizing

Process is inclusive

of all cleaning,

material, and labor

Initial Cost

Coating System $/ft2 Total

Inorganic Zinc $1.35 $40,410

Hot-Dip Galvanizing $1.60 $48,000

Inorganic Zinc/Epoxy $2.16 $64,800

Acrylic WB Primer/ Acrylic WB

Intermediate/ Acrylic WB Topcoat $2.55 $76,620

Inorganic Zinc Primer/ Epoxy/

Polyurethane Topcoat $3.17 $94,950

Life-Cycle Cost

Maintenance costs calculated on a

practical maintenance cycle (vs. ideal)

Unique to each paint system

Manufacturer recommended cycles provided

in the KTA Tator paper

NACE model for NFV and NPV

calculations

2% inflation; 4% interest

50-year life

Maintenance repaint at 5% rust

Life-Cycle Cost ($/ft2) 60-Year

Life Coating System $/ft2

Hot-Dip Galvanizing $1.60

Inorganic Zinc $5.16

Inorganic Zinc/Epoxy $8.07

Inorganic Zinc Primer/Epoxy Intermediate/

Polyurethane Topcoat $10.04


Intermediate/ Acrylic WB Topcoat $14.82

Total Cost of 60-Year Project

Coating System Total

Hot-Dip Galvanizing $48,000

Inorganic Zinc $154,800

Inorganic Zinc/Epoxy $242,100

Inorganic Zinc Primer/ Epoxy/

Polyurethane $301,200


Intermediate/ Acrylic WB Topcoat $444,600

Kevin Irving

Marketing Manager Northern Ops

[email protected]

815-693-4242

Thank You!

mailto:[email protected]

Knox County, OH - Before

Knox County, OH - After

Seneca County, OH - Before

Seneca County, OH - After

Village of Glouster County, OH - Before

Village of Glouster, OH - After

Village of Minerva, OH - Before

Village of Minerva, OH - After

203

www.galvanizedrebar.com

204

Advantages of Hot Dip

Galvanized Rebar

• Corrosion resistant

• Low cost

• Tough

• Long history of performance – 1948 Royal Navy Dockyards, Bermuda

• Higher bond strength

Electrical Utilities

Cellular Clock Tower

Raleigh

North Carolina

Piers 1 & 21 Replacement


Components Galvanized Fenders and corner bolsters

Environment Temperate marine

Location Norfolk, WA

Texas Motor Speedway

Galvanized

Painted

Corrosion Problem – Case

Study The Williamsburg Bridge

built in 1903 in New York City

1991 inspection revealed severe corrosion direct cost of repairs was $750 million

indirect cost approximately $8.2 billion

Law of Entropy

Tendency for metal, after production and shaping,

to revert back to its lower, more natural energy

state or ore

Galvanic Series of Metals

This arrangement of metals

determines what metal will be the

anode and cathode when the two

are put in a electrolytic cell

(arrangement dependent on salt

water as electrolyte).

ZINC = ANODE

STEEL = CATHODE

Zinc is Natural

Air

Water

Soil

Sacrificial Zinc Anode

In an “Electrochemical” Corrosion Cell, Zinc

will sacrifice itself consistently and rapidly

as long as all of the Corrosion Elements

are present (i.e. Anode, Cathode,

Electrolyte & Return Current Path)

(Accelerated Corrosion Testing)

Sacrificial Zinc Anodes

Corrosion of Bare Steel

Microscopic anodic and cathodic areas exist on a

single piece of steel

As anodic areas corrode, new material of different

composition is exposed with different electrical

potential

Seal Welding

Viscosity of zinc

prevents it from

entering gaps less

than 3/32”

Complete seal-welding

or stitch-welding with

at least 3/32” gap

between surfaces

Electrochemical Corrosion Zone

Chemical Corrosion Zones

AZZinc Touch-up

Galvanization Tour 2012

Documents

Transcript of Galvanization Tour 2012