Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order...

40
PLM World ‘06 Premium Partners: Engineer Engineer - - to to - - Order Automation for Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: Centrifugal Compressors: Automation from Configuration thru Detailed Part Design Automation from Configuration thru Detailed Part Design Mr. H. Allan Kidd Chief Technical Officer Dresser-Rand Corporation www.dresser-rand.com Sean Sullivan Vice President Engineering Design Automation Associates, Inc www.DAASolutions.com

Transcript of Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order...

Page 1: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

PLM World ‘06

Premium Partners:

EngineerEngineer--toto--Order Automation for Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors:Centrifugal Compressors:

Automation from Configuration thru Detailed Part DesignAutomation from Configuration thru Detailed Part Design

Mr. H. Allan KiddChief Technical OfficerDresser-Rand Corporationwww.dresser-rand.com

Sean SullivanVice President EngineeringDesign Automation Associates, Incwww.DAASolutions.com

Page 2: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

A leader in energy conversion technology, with field-proven centrifugal and reciprocating compressors, steam turbines, gas turbine packages, expanders, and control systems.

Page 3: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

The leader provider of NX/Knowledge Fusion Automation Systems in North America for Sales/Engineering/Manufacturing Automation and Engineering Services.

DAA serves the aerospace, automotive, oil & gas, industrial & commercial sectors.

Design Automation Associates, IncDesign Automation Associates, Inc

Page 4: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Development of Development of PelePele--Sol Engineered SolutionsSol Engineered Solutions

in 1995

Business Processes were not optimized

Recognized an opportunity for improvement

Page 5: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Typical Enterprise Architecture IssuesTypical Enterprise Architecture Issues

RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - GasSeals Panels Aftermarket

PaintedPost

BrokenArrow

Wellsville Olean

Proposal

Pricing

Scope of

Supply

Sizing,Selection, Analysis

Configuration

Order Pages

Certified/ Plant Dwgs

SALE

SEN

GIN

EER

ING

Validation

BOM/CostingCSS

SmartPlot

TDSProSize

PFX,DRSize

Pack

agin

g C

onfig

urat

or

WinSim, SmartPerf,

SpeedTorque

Prelim, R/D Analysis

Model Bills

Pack

agin

g C

onfig

urat

or

Supe

r98

(pro

pose

d)

FSP

STAR

PFX

Client

Manufacturing

PDI &

Gas

Sea

ls

Enterprise Architecture Plan

Proposal Generation

Page 6: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Development of Development of PelePele--Sol Engineered SolutionsSol Engineered Solutions

Results of inefficient Business Processes

Non-Integrated systems and operations

Delays in delivery of product

Opportunities for miscommunication

Costly re-work

Long cycle times

Engineering team could not always

produce what the selling team sold

Page 7: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Goals of Business Process Goals of Business Process Automation ProjectAutomation Project

Integrate proposal generation, engineering, and manufacturing systems

Facilitate collaboration in engineering from anywhere in the world

Improve speed and accuracy of information company-wide from proposal to delivery

Page 8: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Reduce engineering and production cycle times

Create consistent output company-wide

Reduce project delays and costly rework

Goals of Business ProcessGoals of Business ProcessAutomation ProjectAutomation Project

Page 9: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Finding a Solution Finding a Solution

Dresser-Rand analyzed existing software and consulting firms

Tried unsuccessfully to implement systems from a major software company

Concluded that they must develop a solution in-house

Page 10: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

What a Difference!What a Difference!

Engineering Cycle TimeEngineering Cycle Time

1995 * 2001

Proposal Engineering Cycle Time 3 Weeks 3 - 5 Days

Initial Approval (Review) 12 weeks @ ProposalDrawings & Diagrams ARO via Configurator

Final Issue of all Drawings 26 weeks 10 weeks ARO& Diagrams ARO (including client

review cycle)* still today’s industry standard!

Page 11: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

“The Pele-System is one of the best we have seen that addresses the ETO (Engineer-to-order) market.”

Aseem Mital, Tavant Technologies

“The Pele-System is one of the best we have seen that addresses the ETO (Engineer-to-order) market.”

Aseem Mital, Tavant Technologies

Page 12: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Traditional vs. New ApproachTraditional vs. New Approach

Traditional Approach:Traditional Approach:

Inquiry

Proposal

Order

Release of long leads

Issue review drawings

Receipt of long leads Shipment

3 months (conflict)

15 months (total)

12 month (order)

Design / Engrg.

Conditioning

Inquiry

New Approach:New Approach:Receipt of long leads

Shipment

6.25 months (total)

6 month (order)5 days

Order

Page 13: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Configure with ConfidenceConfigure with Confidence

Creates custom configurations within hours or days

Allows collaborative engineering from multiple geographic locations

Accurately defines the productProposal engineering is value addedMinimizes hand off issues and

miscommunicationCreates budget configurations within 1 hour

Page 14: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...
Page 15: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

PelePele--System ArchitectureSystem Architecture

•Product Structure•Client Preferences•Project Data

User Interface

Configuration Modules

Proposal

CAD

ERP

Report Generator and Commercial

Modules

Performance Selection

Tools

Page 16: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

PelePele--System Module IntegrationSystem Module Integration

CPC Questionnaire and

Specification Review

Product Performance & Configuration

Value Calculator

Diagrams &Drawings

Book PriceCalculator

Proposal Order Entry

Scope of Supplyand BOMs

Order Execution / Business Management

ERP Project Management System(Commercial - Contract Report

Technical - Job File)

Page 17: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Rules Based Product SelectionRules Based Product Selection Provides Provides Consistency Throughout the EnterpriseConsistency Throughout the Enterprise

“The Pele-System is unparalleled in its ability to store and leverage a huge knowledge base and thereby streamline the ETO process.”

Aseem Mital, Tavant Technologies

“The Pele-System is unparalleled in its ability to store and leverage a huge knowledge base and thereby streamline the ETO process.”

Aseem Mital, Tavant Technologies

PelePele--SystemSystem

Page 18: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

PelePele--SystemSystem

Automatically generates diagrams, bills of material, and client-requested data sheets

“The Pele-System is capable of building years of engineering knowledge into the collaborative process and thereby shaving significant time from the order cycle.”

Aseem Mital, Tavant Technologies

“The Pele-System is capable of building years of engineering knowledge into the collaborative process and thereby shaving significant time from the order cycle.”

Aseem Mital, Tavant Technologies

Page 19: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Case Study Case Study -- P&ID VisualizationP&ID Visualization

Financial BenefitFinancial Benefit8 hours -> 10 minutes

Automated Diagram Automated Diagram Geometry GenerationGeometry Generation

Page 20: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

OpportunityOpportunity

Multiple users from around the globe can use one software tool on one hardware system

creates consistencyimproves accuracyimproves communication and coordinationreduces cycle time

Page 21: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Project Knowledge TransferProject Knowledge Transfer

Product Eng.Product Eng.

Package Eng.Package Eng.

Application Eng.Application Eng.

Supply Chain ManagementSupply Chain Management

CAD ModelCAD Model

SelectionsSelections

O&F DrawingsO&F Drawings

Rotor Dynamic ReportsRotor Dynamic Reports

ProposalProposal

Gears

Drivers

Ancillaries

Systems

QuotationQuotation

Request For QuoteRequest For Quote

API Data SheetsAPI Data Sheets

Page 22: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...
Page 23: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

This is the File Manager

Screen. It is used to align

Sales and Contract activity with a particular

Client project

This is the File Manager

Screen. It is used to align

Sales and Contract activity with a particular

Client project

Page 24: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

ImplementationImplementation

This is a Proven Technology based on a Sophisticated ETO application

Fact NOT Theory

Appropriate for Divisional or Enterprise-Wide Application

Development Team is Available to Expedite Implementation

Page 25: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Case History: Packaging Multiple Case History: Packaging Multiple $MM Favorable Impact in 1998$MM Favorable Impact in 1998

Package Business Process RedesignPackage Business Process RedesignImplemented November 1997

Package Cell: Manufacturing & Procurement

Package Team: Engineering, Drafting, SCM

Page 26: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Packaging Interfaces - A Value Added Process

Customer

Business TeamCustomer Single Point Contact,Customer Drawing Coordinator

AftermaketTeam

Supply Chain ManagementProject Management, Planning, Project Assistants, Schedules, Source Inspection

Packaging TeamPackage Engineering, Drafting, Costing and Purchasing

Package SupplierGas, Oil, and Steam Consoles; Traps; Overheand Tanks; Rundown Tanks; Baseplates; Packaged Group Equipment

Inqu

iry

Pro

posa

l

Pur

chas

eO

rder Coordination Meeting

Pur

chas

eO

rder

Rev

iew Is

sue

Dia

gram

s

TimePert Week

Inpr

oces

s In

spec

tions

Acce

ptan

ce

Shi

p

Fina

lDia

gram

s

Prob

lem

Res

olut

ion:

Afte

rmar

k et

Sal

es

0 22 3 7 26

Fina

l O &

FDra

win

g

10Standard Schedule

New Schedule

Pipi

ngAr

rang

emen

t

522216100 6 6

CostEstimating

Prop

osal

Inse

rt

Ann

ounc

eRec

eipt

of O

rder

Cos

t Req

uest

Cos

t Est

imat

e

Cos

t Req

uest

whe

n re

quire

d

Proj

ect S

tatu

s

268

Proj

ect A

ssista

nt

Notification of InspectionWitness and Observe

Points

Proj

Eng

r; Pr

oj L

eade

rTechnical (PE)

Commercial (PL)Schedules (PL)

Purc

hasing

, Pkg

Eng

All

Dresser-Rand Co.Confidential

C

Page 27: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Bus

ines

s Pr

oces

s Sy

stem

Engineered BOMs for ManufacturingEngineered BOMs for Manufacturing

Automated Link to Model BillsAutomated Link to Model Bills

Product PerformanceProduct Performance

Engineering DataEngineering Data

Pricing AnalysisPricing Analysis

All Client DocumentationAll Client Documentation

Automated Order EntryAutomated Order Entry

CAD InterfaceCAD Interface

Automated ProposalsAutomated Proposals

Page 28: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Bulb

Box

SIGV

CAD Interface:CAD Interface:Case Study Case Study -- Bolted Diaphragm Bolted Diaphragm

Financial BenefitFinancial Benefit16 hours 10 minutes

Automated Calculation Automated Calculation of Part Boltingof Part Bolting

# boltsbolt size

bolt location

Bolting AnalysisSpreadsheet

Diaphragm MSP

Implemented in NX using Implemented in NX using Knowledge FusionKnowledge Fusion

Page 29: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

CAD Interface:CAD Interface:Case Study Case Study -- Flared ImpellerFlared Impeller

Flare Solid

Financial BenefitFinancial Benefit24 hours savings

Automated Design Automated Design of Impeller Flareof Impeller Flare

Geometry GenerationNC Tool Path Generation

Implemented in NX using Implemented in NX using Knowledge FusionKnowledge Fusion

Page 30: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Bolted Diaphragm DesignBolted Diaphragm Design

Product:Product: Bolted DiaphragmAnalysis AutomationDesign AutomationManufacturing Automation

HighlightsHighlights::• 3D Solids• Manufacturing Drawings• Bolt Hole Positioning Optimization • Bolted Analysis• Linked to Excel Spread SheetComplexity (1Complexity (1--10):10): 5

Deployment:Deployment: Client Based

Current Status:Current Status:• In Production Since December 2004

Results:Results:• Design Time Reduced 18 Hours

down to 30 minutes • Elimination Manual iteration of

Bolt Location & Analysis

Page 31: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Impeller Design Impeller Design (Centrifugal Compressors)(Centrifugal Compressors)

Product:Product: Impeller Design

Design AutomationManufacturing Automation

Highlights:Highlights:• 3D Solids• Manufacturing Drawings• Complex 3D Geometry Automation

Complexity (1Complexity (1--10):10): 5

Deployment:Deployment: Client Based

Current Status:Current Status:• In Production Since 11/05

ResultsResults::

• Design Time Reduced 30 Hours down to 60 minutes

Page 32: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Flexible Diaphragm Design Flexible Diaphragm Design (Centrifugal Compressors)(Centrifugal Compressors)

Product:Product: Flexible Diaphragms

Analysis AutomationDesign AutomationManufacturing Automation

Highlights:Highlights:• 3D Solids• Manufacturing Drawings• Complex 3D Geometry Automation

Complexity (1Complexity (1--10):10): 5

Deployment:Deployment: Client Based

Current Status:Current Status:• In Production Since 11/05

ResultsResults::• Design Time Reduced 18 Hours

down to 30 minutes • Elimination Manual iteration of

Bolt Location & Analysis

Page 33: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Stator Stages & Blades (Steam Turbines)Stator Stages & Blades (Steam Turbines)

Product:Product: Bolted Diaphragm

Analysis AutomationDesign AutomationManufacturing Automation

Highlights:Highlights:• 3D Solids• Manufacturing Drawings• Complex 3D Geometry Automation

Complexity (1Complexity (1--10):10): 4

Deployment:Deployment: Client Based

Current StatusCurrent Status: : • Targeted for Production in 6/06

ResultsResults::• Design Time Reduced 40 Hours

down to 5 hours • Elimination of Extensive Mfg.

Waste.

Page 34: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Piston Driven Compressors (Oil & Gas)Piston Driven Compressors (Oil & Gas)

Product:Product: Piston Design Automation

Design AutomationManufacturing Automation

Highlights:Highlights:• 3D Solids• Manufacturing Drawings

Complexity (1Complexity (1--10):10): 5

Deployment:Deployment: Client Based

Current Status:Current Status:• Targeted for production in 2006.

ResultsResults::• Design Time & NC Programming

Reduced from 60 Hours down to 2 hours.

• Elimination of extensive Mfg. waste.

Page 35: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Sample Solutions #1Sample Solutions #1

Proposal and Engineering Automation SystemInvestment Analysis

Page 36: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Business Assumptions #1Business Assumptions #1

Business Revenue $ 100 MM / Yr

Average Gross Margin (SVM) 30 %

Sales Growth per year 2 %

Average # proposals / year 150

Average # Man hours / Proposal 60

Avg. Cost / Engineer Man hour $ 60

Net Present Value Discount Rate 20 %

Page 37: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

PelePele--Sol Impact Assumptions #1Sol Impact Assumptions #1

Proposal Savings, Man-hours / Year 50 %(30% in first year of implementation)

Proposal Growth Factor: > # proposals / Year 10 %

# Pele-System Users 20

Margin Increase +0.5 %(Impacts year two and beyond)

Revenue Increase / Year +0.5 %(Impacts year two and beyond)

Page 38: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

Return on Investment #1Return on Investment #1

First Year 41 %

5 Years 766 %

Net Present Value-Cash Flows $ 1,882MM

Internal Rate of Return 432 %

Page 39: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

-400-200

0200400600800

1000120014001600

1 2 3 4 5

Years

Cash InCash OutNet Cash Flow

PelePele--System Cash Flow Analysis with LeaseSystem Cash Flow Analysis with Lease

Page 40: Engineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors · PDF fileEngineer-to-Order Automation for Centrifugal Compressors: ... RECIP 11P SST MST ETG EMD Datum PDI - Gas Seals ...

End of PresentationEnd of Presentation

For questions please contact:

Mr. H. Allan KiddChief Technical OfficerDresser-Rand CorporationPhone: 716-375-3218Email: [email protected]

Sean SullivanVice President EngineeringDesign Automation Associates, IncPhone: 860-749-3832 ext 203Email: [email protected]