Election Law Reports, Vol. XXXVIII
Embed Size (px)
Transcript of Election Law Reports, Vol. XXXVIII
GOVT. OF INDIA1971
PLD. 71. XXXVIII1000
LECTION LAW REPORTS
Containing cases on election law decided by the Supreme Conrtand the High Courts of India and opinions of the Election
EditorR. K. P. SHANKARDASS, M. A., LLB. (Cantab.)
Advocate, Supreme Court. -
38 E. L. R.
Published under the Authority of the Election Commission of Indiaby the Manager of Publications, Civil Lines, Delhi, andPrinted by the Manager, Govt. of India Press, Nasik
Price : Inland Rs. 12-50 or Foreign 29s Id or 4 $ 50 Cents.
I Table of Cases Reported (i)
II Table of Cases Cited (ii)-(vii)
III Report of Cases. 1-476
IV INDEX 477-482
The mode "of Citation of the Thirty eighth Volume of the ElectionLaw Reports i6 as follows :
38 E. L. R.
A TABLE OF THE
NAMES OF THE CASES REPORTED IN THIS VOLUME
P A G E N O .
1 Amrit Lai Ambalal Patel v. Himatbhai Gomanbhai Pate l (S .C) . 32
2 Bhanu Kumar Shastri v. Mohan Lai Sukhadia and others (Rajas-than H . C.) 119
3 Birendra Chandra Dutta V. J. K. Chaudhry (Judicial Commis-sioner of Tripura at Agartala) 381
4 Dasu Sinhav. Ram Lakhan Singh Yadav and O r s . ( P a t n a H . C ) . 177
5 Dina v. Narayan Singh (S.C.) '212
6 GulzarAhmad v. Abdul Rashid( .J .&K.H.C.) . . . . 342
7 S.Harcharan Singh v. S.MohinderSingh (S.C.) . . . . 1
8 Harish Chandra Deogam v. BagunSumbrui (Patna H.C.) . . 305
9 Jagpati Singhv. Ramanand S ingh(S .C) 25
10 Janardhan Yadhav Sakhare v. Mukund Vithoba ( S . C ) . . . 8
11 Kr ishnaKantMishrav .Banamal i Babu(Orissa H.C.) . . . 451
12 MohammadAkbar v . K . H . Lassa Wani ( J . & K . H . C . ) . . 221
13 Mohan SinghOberoi v. Alhaj-i-Ahmad (Patna H.C.) . . . 160
14 Nathu Ram Mirdha v. Gordhan Son i andAnr . (S.C.) . . . 16
15 S.Rajagopal v. C .M.Armugam and Ors. (S.C.) . . . . 38
16 Ram Dayal v.Brij Raj Singh & Ors . (M.P. H.C.) . . . . 53
17 Ram Milan Singh v. Hari Shankar Parsad G u p t a and others .
(Election Tribunal , Gorakhpur) 95
18 S.L.Saraf v. M.S.Qureshi and another (J .& K. H . C ) . . . 353
19 Sheodan Singh v. Mohan La IGautam (All .H.C.) . . . 242
20 G.Vasanta Pai v. R.M.Seshadr i and Ors. (Madras H . C ) . . . 267
*indicates the page from which the Judgment s tar ts .
(ii) IVOL XXXViii
TABLE OF CASES CITED
Abdul Hamid Chaudhury v. Naai Gopal Swami and others (22.E.L.R. 358) 452,456
Abdul JalilChaudhuryv. Rathindra Nath Sen (A.I.R. 1958 Assam 51). 383 384, 411445
Abdul Majeed(Meera Sahib) v. Bharonvas(Krishnan) Member LegislativeAssembly and others (A.I.R. 1965 Kerala 18) . . . . 448
Administrator General of Madras v. Anandachari and others (I.L.R.9 Madras 466) 39,50
Agnes Dorothy Vermaniv. Boyant David Vermani (A.I.R. 1943 Lahore 39,5051)Alamgir v. Kamrunnissa (4 C.L.J. 442). . . . . 307,340
Allam Krishnaiah v. Creppalli Venkata Subbaiah Election Petition No.10 of 1967 (A.P.H.C.) 50
Amin Lai v. Munna Mai (A.I.R. 1965 S.C. 1243) . . . . 382,390Amir Chand v. Surendra Lai Jha and ors. (10 E.L.R. 57) . . 120,129Dr. Anup Singhv. Shri AbdulGhani and anr. (A.I.R. 1965 S.C. 815) . 382,392Balwan Singhv. Lakshmi Narain and ors. (A.I.R. 1960 S.C. 770) . ,382, 393, 395,
452,456BalwantRaiTayalv. Bishan Saroop and anr. (17 F.L.R. 101) . . 120,129S.M. Banerji v. Sri Krishna Agarwal (A.I.R. 1960 S.C. 368) . . 306,337Bankabshari Das v. Chittaranjan Naik (A.I.R. 1963 Orissa 83) . . 383,420Bansi Ram Naru Ram v. Jit Ram Gebru Ram (A.I.R. 1964 Punjab
231) 222,238Baru Ram v. Srimati Prasanni and others (1959 S.C.R. 1403) . . 1 , 3 , 342, 348,
383, 413,414The Barnstable Case (2 O'M & H. 236) 268,287T.C. Basappa v. T. Nagappa and others (3 E.L.R. 197) . . . 268,291,382,
383, 411Basawaraj K. Nagur v. B.R. Shidlingappa (12 E.L.R. 168) . . 120,125The Bewdly Case (3 O'M & H. 145) 268, 288Bhagwan Datta Sastri v Ram Ratangi Gupta and others (A.I.R 1960
S.C. 200) 269,292,452,456
Bhikaji Keshao Joshi and anr. v. Brijlal Nandlal Biyani and others(A.I.R 1955 S.C. 610) 382,393,394
Bhim Sen v. Gopali and others (22 E.L.R. 288) . . . . 96,117Biresh Misra v. Ram Nath Sarma and ors. (17 E.L.R. 243/A.I.R.
1959 Assam 139) . . 54,85,90,92,120,384,438,440
R.B. Biswaswarlal Halwasyav. Basup Rang Lai Jajudia(Doabia's Elec-tion Cases Vol. I 1955-Edition, p 186) 368
The Blackburn Case (1 O'M & H 198 at 202) 268, 285,288Smt. BobbaSuramma v. Smt.PeddireddiChandramma(A.I.R.1959 A.P.
568) 243,254The Borough of Great Yarmouth Case (5 O'M & H 176) . . 268,287The Borough of Worcester Case (4 O'M & H 154) . . . . 268,289The Boston Case (2 O'M & H 61 at 167) 268,284Brij Mohan Lai v. Election Tribunal Allahabad and others (A.I.R.
1965 All. 450) 304Brij Mohan Singh v. Priya Brat Narain Sinha and others (A.I.R.1965
S.C. 282) 222, 237,239 .Indicates the page, from which the Judgment starts.
E.L-R.] TABLE OF CASES CITED (iii)
Champa Devi v. JamunaPrasad and ors. (15 E.L.R. 443) . . . 382Chandeshwar Narain v. Basu Prasad (M.J.C. No. 36 of 1954) . . 178,201Chandra Sekhar Singh v. Sarjoo Prasad Singh and another (A.I.R. 1961
Patna 189) 178,199,382,395Charter v. Mills (1874) (L.R. 9 C.R. 117) 243,251,252Chaturbhuj Vithaldas Jasani v. Moreshwar Parashram and others
(1954 S.C.R. 817/9 E.L.R. 301) 39Chudalavada Subbarao v. Kasu Brahmananda Reddy and others . . 383, 385, 410
420,451ChunilalKenv. Radhacharan Sharma and others (21 E.L.R. 320) . . 384,437Daryao and others v. State of U.P. and others (A.I.R. 1965 S.C. 1457) 222,230Devasharan v. Sheo Mahadev Prasad and ors. (10 E.L.R. 461) . . 54,70Dharanidhar Mohaptra v. Pradipata Kishore Das and ors. (17 E.L.R. 427) 269,292Dhwamvir v. Bhalaram and ors. (7 E.L.R. 64) . . . . 53,66Dina NathKaul Nadim v. Peer Mubarak Shah (A.I.R. 1962 J. & K. 28) 383,413Didar Singh Cheeda v. Sohan Singh Ram Singh and ors.(A.I.R.1966 Pun-
jab 282) 384,448Dinesh Misra v. Ram Nath Sharma and others (A.I.R. 19b9 Assam 139) . 384,422Durga Shankar Mehta v. Raghuraj Singh and others (A.I.R. 1954 S.C. 520) 306Gangadhar Maithani v. Narendra Singh Bhandari 18 E.L.R. 124 . 120,126,129GhasiRamv. Dal Singh and others (C. A. No. 1632 of 1967 (S.C.) . . 120,131,178Ghasiram Majhi v. Onkar Singh(34 C.L.T. 328) 452,455Goon Durga Prasad Rao al ias Pedda Babu and anr. v. Goona Sudarshana
Swami and 28 others (I.L.R. 1940 Madras 653) . . . 39,50Gopala Karup Samuel v. Arulappan Paul and others (Doabia's Elec-
tion Cases 1961, p. 185) 354,378GulabBai and others v. ManphoolBai (A.I.R. 1962S.C.214). . . 222,226GulabChand ChhotelalParikh v. State of Gujarat (A.I.R. 1965 S.C. 1153) 222,230Gulab Chand Palliwal v. Gobind Sahai and others (A.I.R. 1964 Rajasthan
155) 382,390T. Gulab Singh v. Rai Bahadur Kharajit Singh Misra (Case No. XXII)
Reportsoflb Election Petitions, 1927, Ahmmond Vol.HI p. 178 . 354,366,367K. N. Guruswamy v. The State of Mysore and others (A.I.R. 1954
S.C. 592) 243,250Guruswamy Nadar v. Irulappa Konar (died) and others. (67 M L.J.
Reports 389) 39,50HibibBhaiv. Pyarelal and others (A.I.R. 1964 M.P. 62) . . . 54,70Hanamant Govind Nargurdkar and others v. State of M. P. (A.I.R. 1952
S.C. 343) 383,410Har Swarup and another v. Brij Bhushan Saran and another (A.I.R.
1964 S.C. 1366) 382,390Hiriram Singh v.Kamtaprasad Sharma (A.I.R. 1966 M.P. 255) . . 120,128,382
383,406,410Harish Chandra Bajpai and another v. Triloki Singh and another (A.I.R.
1957 S.C. 444/12 E.L.R. 461) 120, 123Hegerston Case (5 O'M and H 70) . . . . . . . 54,90HukamSinghv. Banwari LaiBapra (A.I.R. 1965 All. 552) . . . 9 6 , 1 1 1 , 112
114Jabar Singh v. Genda Lai (A.I.R. 1964 S.C. 1200) . . . . 96, 115,118Jaduaandan Mehton v. Mosaheb Singh and others . . . . 305,322Jagan Nath v.Jaswant Singh and others (A.I.R 1954 S.C. 210) . . 342,389Indicates the page from which the Judgment starts.
(iv) TABLE OF CASES CITED [VOL XXXVIII
Jagdev SinghSidhanti v. Pratap Singh Daulta and others (A.l.R. 1965S.C. 183)
Jagan Prasad Rawat v. Krishna Dutt Paliwal, (20 E.L.R. 443)Dr. JagjitSinghv.Giani KartarSingh andothers (A.l.R. 1966S.C.773)
Jai Singh v. Ram Kishan and others (E.P.No 37 of 1967(Dt. 4-12-1967) .Jamuna Prasad Singh v. Shri Ramnivas and others(A.I.M.1959. P 226Janak Singh v. Mahanath Ram Kishore Das, (E.P. No. 4 of 1967
(Patna) dated 12-4-1968) .Jang Bahadur Singh v. Basant Lai and others (8 E. L. R. 429)'.Jujhar Singh v. Bhairon Lai and others (7 E.L.R. 457)Kamalnarain Sharma v. Pt. Dwarka Prasad Mishra and others (A.l.R.
1965 M. P. 15, A.l.R. 1966 S.C. 436)S. Kandaswami v. S.B. Adityan and Ors.(21 E.L.R.) . . . .Karwadav.Shambhakar(I. L.R.I 959 Bombay 229) . . . .Kataria Takandas Hemroy v. Pinto Fredrick (18 E.L.R. 403) .
Keshav Lakshman Barkar v. Deorao Lakshman Anande (A.I.rl. 1960 S.C.131)
Khader Sheriff v.Manuswami(A.l.R. 1955 S.C. 775) . . . .
Keaje Khanawar Khadaskhan Hushenkhan andanr. v. S.Najalingappaand anr. (A.l.R. 1968 Mysore 18)
Kondaveti GurunathReddy v. V. Seshaiahandothers(A.l.R.1966 A.P.331)KothepallyNarasayya v. Jammana Jogiand Pinninti Jammayya (Election
Petition No. 9 of 1957)Krishna Kumar v. Krishna Gopal (I. P.R. 1963,13 Rajasthan 726) .KrishnajiBhimrao Antrolikar v. Shanker Shantaram More and others
(7 E.L.R. 100)KuitarSingh v. Mukhtiar Singh (A.l.R. 1965 S.C. 141/24 E.L.R. 419 ) .
243, 25954,86, 96,111,113, 384,410,