Election Law Reports, Vol. XXV

download Election Law Reports, Vol. XXV

of 399

  • date post

    03-Jan-2017
  • Category

    Documents

  • view

    558
  • download

    14

Embed Size (px)

Transcript of Election Law Reports, Vol. XXV

  • GOVT. OF INDIA1968

    LD. 71. XXV1060

    ELECTION LAW REPORTS

    Containing cases on election law decided by the Supreme Courtand the High Courts of India, opinions of the Election

    Commission and important decisions of the -

  • CONTENTSPAGES

    I Table of Cases Reported . . . . . (i)

    II Table of Cases Cited . . . . . (ii)(v)

    III Report ol Cases . . . . . . 1389

    IV INDKX (given separately)

  • The mode of citation of this the twenty-fifth volume of the ElectionLaw Reports is as follows:

    25 E. L. R.

    A TABLE OF THE

    NAMES OF THE CASES REPORTED IN THIS VOLUME

    *PAGE NO.

    1. Amin Lai vs. Hunna Mai (Punjab High Court) . . . 1162. Appa Rao, P. N. vs. Kumburu Suryanarayana Naidu (Andhra Pradesh

    High Court) 2203. Bhairou and another vs. Sisram and others (Rajasthan High Court

    at Jodhpur) . 2394. Bhanvvar Lai vs. Hari Prasad (Rajasthan High Court at Jodhpur) . 2655. Cheugalraya Naidu, N. P. vs. G. N. Pathabhi Reddi (Andhra

    Pradesh High Court) 1686. Chiranjeevulu Naidu, C. vs. E. S. Thyagarajan (Madras High Court) . 2017. Chittoori Indrayya vs. Mullapudi Harischandra Prasad (Andhra

    Pradesh High Court) . . . 1928. Dattaraya Naryayan Patil vs. Dattaraya Krishnaji Khanvilkar & ors.

    (Maharashtra High Court) . . . . . . . 1439. Gurucharan Banerjee vs. R. O. Burdwan, H.P. Constituency (Calcutta

    High Court) 31210. Guru Govinda Basu vs. Shankari Prosad Ghosal and others (Supreme

    Court of India) 7711. Hanji Shivanna vs. T. R. Parameswariah and others (Mysore

    High Court) 28112. Jabar Singh vs. Genda Lai (Supreme Court of India) . . . 32313. Kartik Oraon w. David Munzni and others (Patna High Court) . . 29114. Kidwai Hussain Kamil vs. Yadav Ram Scwak and others (Allahabad

    High Court at Lucknow) . . . . . . . . 3515. Koduri Krishnarao vs. Alluri Bapineedu (Andhra Pradesh High Court) 15916. Kodur Subha Ramiah vs. Annam Chanchu Subha Reddi (Member,

    Election Tribunal, Hyderabad) 9717. Madan Gopal vs. Nek Ram Sharma (Allahabad High Court) . . 6118. Manjay Lai & ors. vs. Mehesh Prasad Sinha (Patna High Court) . 13019. Mohinder Singh & another vs. Gurmit Singh (Punjab High Court) 2720. Munichinnappa, D. vs. Basavalingappa & ors. (Mysore High Court) . 24721. Namdeo Chimnaji Taprc vs. Govinddas & ors. (Maharashtra High

    Court at Nagpur) . . . . . . . . . 122. Net Ram Jat vs. The Election Commission & ors. (Punjab High Court) 8923. Rao Abhe Singh vs. Rao Nihal Singh (Punjab High Court) . . 11324. Sant Prasad Singh vs. Dasu Sinha (Patna High Court) . . . 18125. Vidya Charan Shukla vs. Khub Chand Baghel & ors. (Supreme Court of

    India) 354* Indicates the page from which the judgment starts.

    .0)

  • (ii) [VOL. XXV

    TABLE OF GASES CITED

    *PAGE N O .

    Abdul Majced vs. Bhargavan (A.I.R. 1963, Kerala p. 18 at 25) . . 35Abdul Rahimkhan vs. Radhakrishna Biswas Roy (19 E.L.R. 278) . . 143Abdul Sattar Mohammed Hussain Jumader vs. Badri Narain Bansilal

    Pallod (63 B.I.R. 563) 143Abraham vs. Abraham (9 MOO . IND. APP.199) . . . . 291Achutha Menon, C. vs. Election Tribunal, Trichur (A.I.R. 1961, Kerala 186) 281Adamala Mohan, Rcddy vs. Anug Narayan Rcddy (1963 II ANDH. W.R.

    101; 159Adityan vs. Kandasvvamy, 1958 S. C. J . 1072 (A.I.R. 1958, S.C. 856, 1958,

    ELR 394) 92, 116Aga Mohammed Hamadani . Cohen [(1886) I.L.R. 13 Cal. 221] . . 354Albridge vs. Hurst (1876 I-G.P. 420) 92Ali Mohammed vs. Islak A. Khan (I.L.R. 54, All 57) . . . . 168Amin Lai vs. Hunnc Mai, (A.I.R. 1964 Punj. 213) . . . . 113Amirchand vs. Smt. Sucheta Kripalani (18 E.L.R. 209) . . . 143Andrews in North Meath (1892) 4 O' M&H 144 97Anjancya Rcddi vs. Gangi Reddi (21 E.L.R. 247) . . . . 247Baburao Tatyaji Bhosle vs. Madlio Shrihari Aney (A.I.R. Bom. 29) . 116Balakrishna Industrial Works vs. Venkatchari, (1954,2 M.L.J. 290) . 168Balwan Singh vs. Lakshmi Narain (A.I.R. 1960, S.C. 770) . . . 168Banerji, S. M. vs. Sri Krishna, (A.I.R. 1960, S.C. 368 at p . 373, para 10) 1,116Banwarilal Agarwalla vs. State of Bihar & ors. (A.I.R. 1961, S.C. 849) 35Baru Ram vs. Smt. Prasanni & ors. (A.I.R. 1959, S.C. 9 3 ) . . . 181Basappa vs. Ayyappa, 1958 S.C.J. 953 97Basavaiah vs. Bachiah, (17 E.L.R. 293 & 1959 Mys. L.J. 916) . . 192Beharilal Chaurasiya vs. Regional Transport Authority, (A.I.R 1961 MP

    75, 77) 354Bengal Immunity Co. Ltd. vs. State of Bihar, 1955(2) ;S.C.R. 603) . 354Bhagwan Dutt Shastri vs. Ram Ratan Gupta, (II E.L.R. 448) . . 181BhikajiKeshaoJoshira. Brijlal Nandlal Bigani (A.I.R. 1955, S.C. 610) . 130Bhimrao vs. Ankush Rao (22 E.L.R. 385) 143Bhimsen vs. Gopali (22 E.L.R. 228) 35Bholanath Balbadra vs. Acchiram Puran (A.I.R. 1937 Nag. 91) . . 354Canara Bank Ltd. vs. Warden Insurance Co. Ltd., (I.L.R. 1952) BOM.

    1083 354Chandra Kumar Sen vs. Mathura Debiya (1925) I.L.R. 52 Cal. 1009 . 354Chandra Sekhar Prasad M. Ja i Prakash Singh (17 E.L.R. 126) . . 220Chaturbhuj Chunnilal vs. E. T. & others (A.I.R. 1958, All 809) . 116Chatturbhuj Vithaldas Jasani vs. Moreshwar Parasham and others 9 E.L.R.

    301 (SC) & A.I.R. 1954, S.C. 236 217, 291Chavan, Y. B. vs. K .T. Mangal Murti, (A.I.R. 1958, Bom, 397) . . 312Collector of Monghyr & Ors. w. Keshav Prasad Goenka (A.I.R. 1962 S.C.

    1694) . 3 5 , 168, 181Dantu Bhaskar Rao vs. C. V. R. Rao, Sp. App. No. 52 of 1962 . . 168Dev Kama vs. Kusharam Nath, A.I.R. 1961 S.C. 1125 . . . 1Dr. John, V. K. vs. Vasant Pai, (11 E.L.R. 278) 97Dropadi rj. Hira Lai (1912) (I.L.R. 34 All. 496) 354

    "Indicates the page from which the judgment starts.

  • E.L.R.] TABLE OF CASES CITED (iii)

    *PAGE NO.

    Durga Shankar . Raghuraj Singh (A.I.R. 1954, S.C. 520) . . . 1

    Durga Shankar Mehta vs. Returning Officer, 1955 (1) S.G.R. 267 . . 312

    Emperor vs. A. A. Alwc, (37 B.L.R. 892) 143

    Ephrayimw. Turner Morrison & Co., ( A . I . R . 1930, Bomb. 511) . . 168

    Gangi Reddy vs. N . C . Anjaneya Reddy & Ors. (22 ELR, 261) . . 143,265

    Ganpat Singh vs. Brijmohan Lai (A.I.R. 1959, Raj. 114) . . . 116

    Gulaker Ahmed vs. The Election Tribunal (A.I.R. 1958, M. P. 224) . 116

    Hari Vishnu Kamath vs. Syed Ahmed Ishaque (1955) 1 S.G.R. 1104 &

    S.C. 233 35, 323

    Harish Chandra vs. Triloki Singh, (A.I.R. 1957, S.C. 444) . . . 97,116,130

    Hobbes vs. Morey (1904) 1, K.B. 74 312

    Howard vs. Bodington (1877) 2 P.D. 203 130

    Inamati Malappa Basappa vs. Desai Basavaraj Ayvappa (A.I.R. 1958

    S.C. 698) ' . . . . 116

    Inayathullah vs. Diwanchand Mahajan & Ors. (A.I.R. 1959, M. P. 58) 281,323

    Inder Lai vs. Lai Singh, (A.I.R. 1962, (S.C.) 1156, 1159) . . . 143,265

    Jagan Nathw.Jaswant Singh & Ors. (A.I.R. 1954, S.C. 210) . . 97,116,130,

    168

    J a g a n n a t h Da la i vs. R a m a C h a n d r a N a b a t e & Ors . ( A . I . R . 1959 O r r . 26) 116

    J a g a t Dhish Bhargava vs. J a w a h a r La i Bhargava , ( A . I . R . 1961, S.C. 832) 130, 168

    J e n a U r a o n vs. J o h a n U r a o n , (S. A . N o . 1573 of 1948 da ted 17-1-1951

    P a t n a ) 291

    J u U i u s w . Bishop of Oxford (1880) 5 A C 214 35

    K a m a r a j a N a d d a r vs. Kun ju Theva r , 14 E L R 270 ( A . I . R . 1958, S C687) 61,116,130,

    181

    K a n d a s w a m i Pil lai vs. K a n n a p p a Chet ty , ( A . I . R . 1952 M a d . 186) . 354

    K a r n a i l Singh w . Elect ion T r i b u n a l , Hissar (10 E L R 189) . . . 1

    Kausha l end ra Prasad N a r a i n Singh vs. N a n d Kishore Prasad Singh (22

    E L R 484) 181

    Kausha lya R a n i w . G o p a l S ingh , 1964 (4) S .C .R . 982 . . . . 354

    Keshav L a k s h m a n Barkar vs. Deorao Lakshman A n a n d e (A . I .R . 1960, S . C .

    131 & (1960) 1 S. C . R . 902) 312

    Kr i shna K u m a r vs. K r i s h n a Gopal ( I . L . R . (1963) 13 R a j . 726) . . 265

    K u n c h u R a m a n , P . vs. V . R . K r i s h n a Iyer , ( A . I . R . 1961, K e r . 188) . 281

    Laher i Singh vs. A t t a r Singh, 3 E . L . R . 403 (Tr) 97

    I .akshmi S h a n k a r Y a d a v vs. K u n w a r Sripal Singh (22 E . L . R . 47) . . 323

    Liverpool Borough Bank vs. T u r n e r (1860) 30 L . J . C h . 397 . . . 130

    M a l l a p p a Basappa vs. Basavaraj S y y a p p a (A . I .R . 1958, S. C. 698) . . 97

    M a r u t r a o B h a u r a o & Ors . vs. V . G u l a b r a o D a d a s a h e b and ors. (5 E . L . R .

    303) 89

    M a u l a n a Abdul Shakur M . R i k h a b C h a n d (1958) S .C .R . 387 . . 77

    M e h a r S m g h vs. U m r a o Singh & Anr . , ( A . I . R . 1961 P u n . 244) . . 265

    M o h a n R e d d y vs. N a r a y a n R e d d y , 1963 I I A n . W . R . I l l . . . 192

    M o h d . B a h a d u r K h a n vs. Collector of Bareilly, 1 I . A . 167 . . . 97

    Mool C h a n d J a i n vs. R u l i a R a m ( A . I . R . 1963 P u n . 516) . . . 113

    M r . M a t h e w V. S. Mor ton vs. M r . Mi tche l (deceased) I I I Mal ley &Hardcas t l c Election Peti t ion page 19 at 23 . . . . . 61

    Mst. Abifla Khatooim. Chore Khan (A.T.R. 1956 All. 252) . . . 354

    "Indicates the page from which the judgment starts.

  • ( i v ) TABLE OF CASES CITED [VOL. XXV

    * P A G E N O .

    M u t h i a h Che t t i a r , M . A . vs. Saw Ganessan ( A . I . R . 1958 M a d . 187) . 116

    N a r a y a n a R a o vs. S ta te of A n d h r a Pradesh ( A . I . R . 1957, S. G. 737) . 35

    N a r a y a n a s w a m y vs. K r i s h n a m u r t h i ( I . L . R . 1958 M a d r a s Page 513) . 77

    N a s a r u d d i n K h a n vs. E m p e r o r (1926) ( I . L . R . 53 Cal . 827) . . . 354

    P a d m a b a t i Dasi vs. Ras ik La i D h a r ( I . L . R . 37 Ca l 259) . . . 130

    People vs D e R e n n a 2 N Y S (2) 694 130

    P e t h u R e d d i a r vs. M u t h i a h (1963)