Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

116
Dennis Thomas Dennis Thomas Dunlap and Associates, Inc. Dunlap and Associates, Inc. Stamford, CT Stamford, CT Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming DVRPC October 1,2008

Transcript of Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Page 1: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Dennis ThomasDennis ThomasDunlap and Associates, Inc.Dunlap and Associates, Inc.Stamford, CTStamford, CT

Education, Enforcement and Traffic CalmingEducation, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

DVRPCOctober 1,2008

Page 2: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

The Problem

• 4,600+ pedestrian fatalities nationwide• 71,000 pedestrian injuries• Speeding associated with 1 in 3 highway

fatalities• Higher speeds cause more severe pedestrian

injury• Traditional traffic calming not applicable to

all streets

Page 3: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Motivations

• Desire to improve pedestrian safety• Neighborhoods clamoring for speed reduction

– With engineering treatments– Demanding engineering treatments

• Emergency services objecting to some engineering treatments on selected streets

• Need to have techniques that can be implemented quickly– Interim response– Rapid reaction

Page 4: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Research Approach

• Pilot study (completed)– Develop techniques– Prove concept

• Field study (ongoing)– Determine crash reduction potential of the

program– Assess the relationship between speed and

crash incidence

Page 5: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

The Ongoing Field Testin

Philadelphia

Page 6: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Expanding the Pilot Study

• Larger scale study in Philadelphia• Add crash analysis

– Pedestrian and vehicle– Multiple vehicle– Single vehicle

• More analysis of countermeasure process• Effectiveness of individual countermeasures • Persistence of any speed reductions

Page 7: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Key Players

• Department of Streets• Police Department• Street Smarts• PennDOT• Pennsylvania Bureau of Driver Licensing

Page 8: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Citywide but Focusing Enforcement in 6 Police Districts

•Largely residential

•High pedestrian crashes

•Speeding violations

•Citizen complaints

•Department of Streets interest

•Police commanders’ interest

Page 9: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Enforcement = Speed Trackers

Page 10: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Publicity

• Materials from the pilot test• New materials as needed• Involvement of Street Smarts• Earned media• Tie-in of 3-D markings to publicity

Page 11: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Data To Be Collected

• Crashes: police crash reports• Injury severity: police and hospital reports• Vehicle speeds: automated traffic counters• Exposure, knowledge, attitudes: survey• Extent of walking/quality of life: focus groups• Process: focus groups, implementation

records

Page 12: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

State-of-the-Art Speed Measurement

Radar

Pneumatic Tube

Page 13: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Status

• Already done– Baseline speed data have been collected– 3-D installed at 9200 Bluegrass Road– Speed humps installed at one site– Kickoff press conference– Signs installed in 2 Districts– Speed Trackers are installed (24 total)– Officer instructor training on trackers– Speeding tickets are being written– Baseline awareness survey (7,300 surveys)

Page 14: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming
Page 15: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming
Page 16: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming
Page 17: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Pending

• Pending– Installation of remaining 3-D– 3 more speed trackers to be installed– Signs to be installed in remaining districts– Focused education – Increased enforcement to continue

Page 18: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Contact

Dennis ThomasDunlap and Associates110 Lenox AvenueStamford, CT [email protected]

www.dunlapandassociatesinc.com

Page 19: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming
Page 20: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Gloucester County Gloucester County Emergency Medical ServiceEmergency Medical Service

The The FirstFirst County ProvidedCounty ProvidedBasic Life Support AgencyBasic Life Support Agency

In New Jersey!In New Jersey!

Page 21: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Andy LovellAndy LovellNJ MICP, NREMT/PNJ MICP, NREMT/P

EMS ChiefEMS Chief

J. Thomas ButtsJ. Thomas ButtsDirectorDirector

Emergency ResponseEmergency Response

Page 22: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Previous Service Delivery ModelPrevious Service Delivery Model

Most EMS agencies began as small Most EMS agencies began as small volunteer entities.volunteer entities.Squads were located in communities with Squads were located in communities with sufficient volunteers base and financial sufficient volunteers base and financial resources.resources.Placement was not based upon Placement was not based upon need.need.

Page 23: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Call Volume IncreaseCall Volume Increase

The number of requests for service The number of requests for service continues to rise at a rapid rate (increased continues to rise at a rapid rate (increased population, increased senior population, population, increased senior population, increased highway congestion and increased highway congestion and accidents)accidents)

Page 24: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Volunteer AvailabilityVolunteer Availability

The number of trained and available to The number of trained and available to respond volunteers is declining respond volunteers is declining (nationally).(nationally).Family and career time requirements limit Family and career time requirements limit an individualan individual’’s time available for volunteer s time available for volunteer activities.activities.Increased training and Increased training and recertification requirements.recertification requirements.

Page 25: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Increasing Call VolumeIncreasing Call Volume

Decreasing VolunteersDecreasing Volunteers

Page 26: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

The The ““Dirty Little SecretDirty Little Secret”” of EMSof EMS

Local squad is dispatched, but unable to Local squad is dispatched, but unable to respondrespond““Mutual AidMutual Aid”” squad is dispatched from squad is dispatched from another jurisdictionanother jurisdictionResults in unacceptable response timesResults in unacceptable response timesCreates potentially life Creates potentially life threatening situation for the threatening situation for the patientpatient

Page 27: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Inadvertent ConsequencesInadvertent Consequences

Resources from one community are Resources from one community are depleted to provide service in anotherdepleted to provide service in anotherFinancial implications municipality Financial implications municipality providing mutual aid into the receiving providing mutual aid into the receiving municipalitymunicipalityMutual aid becomes the Mutual aid becomes the ““normnorm””rather than the exception.rather than the exception.

Page 28: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

The Solution?The Solution?

Page 29: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

RegionalizationRegionalization

Page 30: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Benefits for the TaxpayerBenefits for the Taxpayer

Sharing scarce resources (taxpayer Sharing scarce resources (taxpayer dollars) across geographical boundariesdollars) across geographical boundariesAdministrative overhead is shared, Administrative overhead is shared, expensive duplication is eliminatedexpensive duplication is eliminatedTraining is centralized and Training is centralized and coordinated, standard of care coordinated, standard of care keeps pace with technologykeeps pace with technology

Page 31: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Benefits for the TaxpayerBenefits for the Taxpayer

Staffing and crew placement decisions can Staffing and crew placement decisions can be made based upon need, not lines on a be made based upon need, not lines on a map map –– resulting in lowered response timesresulting in lowered response timesElimination of Elimination of ““HaveHave”” and and ““Have NotHave Not””municipalitiesmunicipalitiesGrowth in size or level of service Growth in size or level of service provided more affordableprovided more affordable

Page 32: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Benefits for the TaxpayerBenefits for the Taxpayer

End result End result –– improve the improve the quality of service provided to quality of service provided to the taxpayer, at a lower per the taxpayer, at a lower per capita cost!capita cost!

Page 33: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

How Do We Get There?How Do We Get There?

We are the government! What do we do We are the government! What do we do best?best?Create a panel or committee to take a look Create a panel or committee to take a look at the problem.at the problem.

Page 34: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Steering Committee Steering Committee RepresentativesRepresentatives

Volunteer Ambulance and Rescue Volunteer Ambulance and Rescue Association (GC version of the FAC)Association (GC version of the FAC)Career EMS Chiefs AssociationCareer EMS Chiefs AssociationMayors AssociationMayors AssociationMunicipal AdministratorsMunicipal AdministratorsHospitalsHospitalsFreeholder and County AdminFreeholder and County Admin

Page 35: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Steering Committee TasksSteering Committee Tasks

Survey existing EMS agencies Survey existing EMS agencies andand municipalities municipalities to determine financial impact of current service to determine financial impact of current service delivery model delivery model –– true cost, true cost, both direct and both direct and indirect indirect (squad data and municipality)(squad data and municipality)Long term debtLong term debtSurvey same for current equipment Survey same for current equipment inventoryinventoryReview other delivery models Review other delivery models outside NJoutside NJ

Page 36: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Steering Committee TasksSteering Committee Tasks

Meet frequentlyMeet frequentlyMake public the committeeMake public the committee’’s activities s activities (web site posting and US Mail)(web site posting and US Mail)Analyze existing response dateAnalyze existing response date

Page 37: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Steering Committee TasksSteering Committee Tasks

Create and reCreate and re--create a response plan create a response plan based upon existing response data.based upon existing response data.Presentations were made to each Presentations were made to each municipalities governing body early in the municipalities governing body early in the process to solicit inputprocess to solicit input

Page 38: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Areas of ConcernAreas of Concern

Am I going to lose my job??????Am I going to lose my job??????““TheyThey”” wonwon’’t be able to find our residentst be able to find our residents’’homes (homes (MICUMICU’’ss do it everyday)do it everyday)What about the Department of Personnel What about the Department of Personnel (Civil Service?)(Civil Service?)The Training Fund (OEMS)The Training Fund (OEMS)

Page 39: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Areas of ConcernAreas of Concern

Reimbursement Reimbursement –– one of the four letter one of the four letter words in EMSwords in EMSBudget capBudget capRecruiting, screening and hiring a Recruiting, screening and hiring a workforceworkforce

Page 40: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Gloucester County EMSGloucester County EMS

Review current call volumes, determine Review current call volumes, determine what the real numbers arewhat the real numbers areCreate a recruitment program early and Create a recruitment program early and work it relentlesslywork it relentlesslyTake advantage of other countyTake advantage of other countydepartmentdepartment’’s expertise; IT,s expertise; IT,finance, B&G, fleet, risk mgtfinance, B&G, fleet, risk mgt

Page 41: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

GCEMS Service AreaGCEMS Service Area

1 service area1 service areaNot 12 individual service areasNot 12 individual service areasRegionalization erases the artificial lines Regionalization erases the artificial lines on the paper mapon the paper mapClosest crew to the incident Closest crew to the incident location respondslocation respondsGPS/AVL in 2008GPS/AVL in 2008

Page 42: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming
Page 43: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

RecruitmentRecruitment

Application package delivered to every Application package delivered to every squad and fire company, web postingssquad and fire company, web postingsRecruited employees and volunteers of Recruited employees and volunteers of existing agencies (consolidation)existing agencies (consolidation)Set up fair, equitable and Set up fair, equitable and consistent applicant evaluationconsistent applicant evaluation

Page 44: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Consolidate Existing ResourcesConsolidate Existing Resources

Inventory and evaluate current fleet, Inventory and evaluate current fleet, station facilities and suppliesstation facilities and suppliesEliminate duplication based upon Eliminate duplication based upon jurisdictional boundariesjurisdictional boundariesNegotiate with vendors for Negotiate with vendors for improved cost structureimproved cost structure

Page 45: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Improve Operating EfficienciesImprove Operating Efficiencies

Take advantage of technologies available, Take advantage of technologies available, both to reduce cost and improve patient both to reduce cost and improve patient treatmenttreatmentShare infrastructure cost with other public Share infrastructure cost with other public agenciesagenciesProvide award winning outreachProvide award winning outreach

Page 46: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming
Page 47: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Recommendations:Recommendations:

Legislation should be passed that requires local municipalities to provide EMS (or cause to be provided).All EMS providers should be regulated – All providers, regardless of operating platform, should be regulated by OEMS.

Page 48: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Recommendations:Recommendations:

The OEMS and NJSFAC should work to devise a plan that will encourage consolidation of squads in areas where geographic, human resources, or economies of scale issues make consolidation logical.The NJOEMS in conjunction with the NJ EMS Council should determine response time standards for EMS that apply to all agencies.

Page 49: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Recommendations:Recommendations:

All BLS ambulances, regardless of delivery platform, must be staffed with at least two NJ certified/licensed EMT-Bs.Encourage the development of county-level EMS oversight.

Page 50: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Recommendations:Recommendations:

The New Jersey EMS system is in need of an overhaul.

Page 51: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming
Page 52: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Danger Zones:Danger Zones:

Special interest looking to protect their Special interest looking to protect their own turf, double your expectationown turf, double your expectationWe are the government, consider our We are the government, consider our speed!speed!Change brings fear, donChange brings fear, don’’t get t get involved in the emotional aspect involved in the emotional aspect –– do what is right for the do what is right for the taxpayer and patienttaxpayer and patient

Page 53: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Danger Zones:Danger Zones:

Remember the size of the project Remember the size of the project regarding purchasing and acquisition regarding purchasing and acquisition –– bid bid thresholds and timingthresholds and timingEstablish relationships with industry Establish relationships with industry experts, NJ is not the first place experts, NJ is not the first place to take on this type of projectto take on this type of project

Page 54: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Remember:Remember:The most important person involved isnThe most important person involved isn’’t me t me

and it isnand it isn’’t the special interest groups t the special interest groups ––it is the patient.it is the patient.

Page 55: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

End Result?End Result?

Over 10000 responsesOver 10000 responses

GCEMS average response time GCEMS average response time 6:066:06Exceeds national standard of 9:59Exceeds national standard of 9:59Continual repositioning of crews to Continual repositioning of crews to maintain adequate response timesmaintain adequate response timesLives have been saved!Lives have been saved!

Page 56: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Questions?

Page 57: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Highway Safety in Pennsylvania

Gary Modi, PEChief, Safety Management Division

BHSTE

Delaware Valley Regional Planning CommissionRegional Safety Task Force MeetingOctober 1, 2008

Page 58: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

PA Annual FatalitiesPennsylvania Highway Fatality Trend

Total Traffic Related FatalitiesAccording to the historical trend line, total traff ic fatalitieshave been increasing at a rate of 1 per year since 1998.

1,486

1,5491,520 1,532

1,6171,577

1,490

1,616

1,5251,491

1,450

1,350

1,250

1,1501,100

1,200

1,300

1,400

1,500

1,600

1,700

1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Year

Fata

litie

s

Observed Trend (linear f it) Goals

Upper 95% Confidence Low er 95% Confidence Upper 67.5% Confidence

Low er 67.5% Confidence

r = 0.0714

Page 59: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

PA Annual Fatality RatePennsylvania Highway Fatality Trend

Total Traffic Related Fatality RateAccording to the historical trend line, the fatality ratehas been decreasing by 0.01 per year since 1998.

1.48

1.54

1.481.50

1.56

1.50

1.40

1.51

1.411.38

1.30

1.35

1.40

1.45

1.50

1.55

1.60

1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Fata

lity

Rat

e

Observed Upper 95% Confidence Upper 67.5% Confidence

Low er 67.5% Confidence Low er 95% Confidence Trend (linear f it)

r = -0.6136

Page 60: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

PA 2007 Highway Fatalities Summary

Lowest Number of Fatalities in 10 yearsUnrestrained FatalitiesAlcohol-Related CrashesHit Tree CrashesHit Utility Pole CrashesHead-On / Opposite Direction Side Swipe CrashesIntersection CrashesRunning Red Light Crashes Crashes Involving Drivers Age 75+

Page 61: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

PA 2007 Highway Fatalities Summary

Greatest Increase Statewide, 2006 – 2007Aggressive Driving CrashesSpeeding-related CrashesHit Guiderail CrashesMotorcycle-related Crashes

Page 62: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Comprehensive Strategic Highway Safety Improvement Plan (CSHSIP)

“Vital Six” Safety Focus AreasReducing Aggressive DrivingReducing Impaired (DUI) DrivingIncreasing Seatbelt UseSafety Infrastructure Improvements

Reducing Roadway Departure & Intersection CrashesImproving the Crash Records SystemImproving Pedestrian Safety

Emerging AreasMotorcycle SafetySenior Driver Safety

Page 63: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

2007 Fatalities per MPO/RPO03-07 Baseline Average vs. 2009 Fatality Goals

MPO and RPO Fatalities by Region

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

Erie

Shena

ngo V

alley

SW PA C

omission

John

stown

Altoon

aCen

treWillia

msport

Harrisb

urg

Scranto

n-Wilk

es B

arre

Lehig

h Valle

yRea

ding

Leba

non

YorkLa

ncas

terDVRPC

Northw

est

North C

entra

l

Northe

rn Tier

Seda-c

og

S. Alle

ghen

iesAda

ms

N. PA Allia

nce

Franklin

MPO/RPO

Fata

litie

s

03-07 Average Fatalities 2007 Actual Fatalities 2009 Goals

Page 64: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

PennDOT District 6-0

District 6-0 Total Fatalities

366

321300 313 319

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Avg 324

Page 65: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

PennDOT District 6-0Highest Fatalities in 2007

Aggressive Driving Crashes (183)Single Vehicle Run-Off-the-Road Crashes (132)Alcohol-Related Crashes (117)Hit Fixed Object Crashes (111)Intersection Crashes (100)Unrestrained Fatalities (90)Speeding Crashes (82)Local Road (only) Crashes (78)Pedestrian Crashes (62)Hit Tree Crashes (58)

Page 66: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Dist 6-0 Aggressive Driving Fatalities

195

173175

185183

160

165

170

175

180

185

190

195

200

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Avg 182

Dist 6-0 Run-Off-The-Road Fatalities

171

128 134119

132

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Avg 137

Dist 6-0 Alcohol-Related Fatalities

126

10895 97

117

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Avg 109

Dist 6-0 Hit Fixed Object Fatalities

148

109118

100111

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Avg 117

Page 67: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Dist 6-0 Intersection-Related Fatalities

120111

89

122

100

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Avg 108

Dist 6-0 Unbelted Fatalities

120

9790

8290

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Avg 96

Dist 6-0 Speeding-Related Fatalities

76

6370

80 82

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Avg 74

Dist 6-0 Local Road (Only) Fatalities

8982

49

78 78

0102030405060708090

100

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007

Avg 76

Page 68: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

PennDOT District 6-0

Greatest Decrease in District 6-0, 2006 – 2007Hit Utility Pole Crashes (39 to 27 fatalities)Stop-Controlled Intersection Crashes (37 to 17 fatalities)Intersection Crashes (122 to 100 fatalities)

Page 69: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Safety Countermeasures: Behavioral

Impaired (DUI) Driving

Ignition Interlock Program

Seat Belt UseAggressive Driving

Page 70: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Safety Countermeasures: Infrastructure

Rumble Strips

Pedestrian Countdown Signals

Advanced Curve Warning Pavement Markings

Utility Pole Relocation/Consolidation

Yield to Pedestrian Channelizing Devices

Page 71: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Significantly Reduce Fatalities

1. Centerline rumble strips on all traffic routes with greater than5,000 ADT (2,500 miles)

2. Edgeline/shoulder rumble strips on all traffic routes with greater than 5,000 ADT (2,750 miles)

3. Address Top 5% Crash Locations (4 in District 6-0)4. Local Road Low Cost Safety Improvements (2,000 locations) 5. Interstate/Expressway Median Barrier at Dual Structures (50

locations)6. Cable Median Guide Rail at High Incidence Crossover

Locations (15 miles)7. Aggressive Driving “Smooth Operator” Program

Page 72: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Future Initiatives

1. How do we make all partners/stakeholders own the safety goals?

2. How do we motivate and sustain safety efforts by all partners?

3. How do we truly combine the 4 E’s and address them at high-crash locations?

Page 73: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Future Initiatives

4. How do we track the progress towards meeting our goals by establishing leading indicators and not lagging indicators?

5. Marketing safety6. Action plan with specific times and owners

Page 74: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

Questions?

Gary Modi, PEChief, Safety Management DivisionBureau of Highway Safety and Traffic [email protected] / 717-787-6853

Page 75: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

11

Low Cost Safety SolutionsLow Cost Safety Solutions

Page 76: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

22

IntroductionIntroductionHighway Traffic Fatalities TrendHighway Traffic Fatalities Trend

05,00010,00015,00020,00025,00030,00035,00040,00045,00050,000

1988

1989

1990

1991

1992

1993

1994

1995

1996

1997

1998

1999

2000 2001

200220

0320

0420

0520

0620

07

Page 77: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

33

IntroductionIntroduction

Traffic Safety Facts 2007:Traffic Safety Facts 2007:41,059 41,059 fatalsfatals are the lowest since 1995are the lowest since 1995

2,490,000 Injuries, 2,490,000 Injuries, down 3.3% from 2006! down 3.3% from 2006! down for the 8down for the 8thth straight year!straight year!11stst time below 2.5 million! time below 2.5 million!

Areas for improvementAreas for improvementPedestrians injury collisions Pedestrians injury collisions

up 15% to 70k injuries in 2007up 15% to 70k injuries in 2007Motorcycle Motorcycle fatalsfatals 10 year increase 10 year increase continues to 5154 in 2007 continues to 5154 in 2007

Page 78: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

44

IntroductionIntroduction2006 & 2002006 & 2007 Highway Statistics:7 Highway Statistics:

+1.0%+1.0%296,410,924296,410,924293,657,924293,657,924Population***Population***

YearYear

+2.0%+2.0%230,199,000**230,199,000**225,684,815225,684,815Registered Registered VehiclesVehicles

--0.6%0.6%2,996,232M*2,996,232M*3,014,016M3,014,016MVehicle Miles Vehicle Miles TraveledTraveled

% % ChangeChange

2007200720062006Exposure Exposure MeasureMeasure

Page 79: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

55

IntroductionIntroduction

Cost of All Crashes in U.S. (Year 2007)Cost of All Crashes in U.S. (Year 2007)$300 Billion$300 Billion$1070 for every person in the U.S.$1070 for every person in the U.S.2.8% of the GDP2.8% of the GDP

Page 80: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

66

IntroductionIntroduction

•• U.S. Highway System Among WorldU.S. Highway System Among World’’s Safests Safest–– 2007 Fatality Rate decreased to 1.3 2007 Fatality Rate decreased to 1.3 fatalsfatals per 100 per 100

mvmmvm traveled!traveled!–– ButBut over over 41,000 Deaths41,000 Deaths & 2& 2,490,000 Injuries,490,000 Injuries per Yearper Year

•• US DOT Safety Goals (FHWA, NHTSA, & FMCSA)US DOT Safety Goals (FHWA, NHTSA, & FMCSA)–– National fatal rate of 1.0/100mvm traveledNational fatal rate of 1.0/100mvm traveled

Page 81: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

77

Rural NonRural Non--Interstate SafetyInterstate Safety

Page 82: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

88

Roadway/RoadsideRoadway/RoadsideRunRun--OffOff--thethe--RoadRoad IntersectionsIntersections

PedestriansPedestrians

Page 83: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

99

RunRun--OffOff--thethe--RoadRoad

ProblemProblem1/3 of all Traffic Fatalities1/3 of all Traffic Fatalities2/3 on 22/3 on 2--lane roads lane roads 1/2 at night1/2 at night

Page 84: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

1010Avoidance of Avoidance of

obstacleobstacle

RunRun--offoff--thethe--RoadRoadReasonsReasons

SpeedingSpeeding

Impaired DrivingImpaired Driving

InattentionInattention

Poor visibilityPoor visibility

Page 85: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

1111

Ditch8%

Sign Post6%

Fence4%

Conc. Barrier2%Other

10%

Tree28%

Embankment10%

Utility Pole9%

Br. Rail2%

Guardrail10%

Curb6%

Culvert5%

Roadside Hazard FatalitiesRoadside Hazard Fatalities

Page 86: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

1212

Milled-in

RUMBLE RUMBLE STRIPSSTRIPS

Concrete Formed-in

Page 87: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

1313

RunRun--offoff--thethe--Road Solutions Road Solutions Remove Remove

obstacleobstacle

BEFORE

AFTERDigitally enhanced photograph

Page 88: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

1414

RunRun--offoff--thethe--RoadRoadRelocate obstacleRelocate obstacle

BEFORE

AFTER

Page 89: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

1515

RunRun--offoff--thethe--RoadRoadReduce impact severity with Crashworthy Reduce impact severity with Crashworthy

DevicesDevices

Page 90: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

1616

RunRun--offoff--thethe--Road SolutionsRoad Solutions

Shield obstacleShield obstacle

Page 91: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

1717

RunRun--offoff--thethe--RoadRoadDelineate obstacleDelineate obstacle

Page 92: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

1818

Utility Pole9%

Embankment10%

Other10%

Sign Post6%

Guiderail/Barrier

14%

Drainage Features

19%

Fence4%Tree

28%

Roadside Hazard FatalitiesRoadside Hazard Fatalities

Page 93: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

1919

Longitudinal BarriersLongitudinal Barriers

FlexibleFlexible

RigidRigid SemiSemi--RigidRigid

TLTL--3 100 kph/62 mph3 100 kph/62 mph 820kg Car; 2000kg Pickup820kg Car; 2000kg Pickup

Page 94: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

2020

Longitudinal BarriersLongitudinal Barriers

FlexibleFlexible

RigidRigid SemiSemi--RigidRigid

TLTL--3 100 kph/62 mph3 100 kph/62 mph 820kg Car; 2000kg Pickup820kg Car; 2000kg Pickup

Page 95: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

2121

End TerminalsEnd Terminals

QuadGuardQuadGuard

Sand BarrelsSand Barrels

Adiem IIAdiem II

BCTBCT

Page 96: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

2222

Intersection SafetyIntersection Safety

25% of Fatal Crashes25% of Fatal Crashes50% of Injury crashes50% of Injury crashes

Page 97: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

2323

Intersection SafetyIntersection Safety

Page 98: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

2424

Negative 6 ft offset No offset (aligned)

Positive 6 ft offset Positive 12 ft offset

Intersection SafetyIntersection Safety

Page 99: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

2525

Intersection Safety Intersection Safety CountermeasuresCountermeasures

•• UnsignalizedUnsignalized

–– Sight distanceSight distance

–– Turn baysTurn bays

–– Flashing Flashing beacons at rural beacons at rural intersectionsintersections

–– Intersection Intersection lightinglighting

Signalized IntersectionsSignalized Intersections

––Retiming / coordinating Retiming / coordinating signals signals

»»All red clearance intervalAll red clearance interval

––CurbCurb--corner radius corner radius designdesign

––Red light camerasRed light cameras

Page 100: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

2626

Intersection Safety Intersection Safety Red Light RunningRed Light Running

Page 101: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

2727

Intersection vs. RoundaboutIntersection vs. Roundabout

# of Conflict Points: Roundabouts 8Conventional Intersection 32

Page 102: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

2828

• 4,654 Pedestrians Killed (~12 % of all traffic fatalities))–– 58% are working adults; 23% are elderly; 19% are 58% are working adults; 23% are elderly; 19% are

childrenchildren

•• A pedestrian is killed or injured every 4 minutesA pedestrian is killed or injured every 4 minutes

PedestriansPedestrians

Page 103: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

2929

CountermeasuresCountermeasures

•• Reduce Pedestrian Reduce Pedestrian Exposure to trafficExposure to traffic

•• Improve sight distanceImprove sight distance•• Reduce Vehicle SpeedReduce Vehicle Speed•• Improve Safety Improve Safety

AwarenessAwareness

Page 104: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

3030

CountermeasuresCountermeasures

•• SidewalksSidewalks•• Traffic signalsTraffic signals•• LightingLighting•• Traffic calmingTraffic calming•• Shorten crossingsShorten crossings•• MediansMedians

•• RoundaboutsRoundabouts•• Raised intersectionsRaised intersections•• EducationEducation•• EnforcementEnforcement

Page 105: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

3131

Before Seatac Washington After

CountermeasuresCountermeasures

Page 106: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

3232

CountermeasuresCountermeasures

Page 107: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

3333

CountermeasureCountermeasure

Page 108: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

3434

CountermeasuresCountermeasures

Page 109: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

3535

Pedestrian/Intersection Pedestrian/Intersection IssuesIssues

Obstructions / Sight DistanceObstructions / Sight Distance

AccessibilityAccessibility

Page 110: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

3636

Pedestrian ToolsPedestrian Tools

•• Pedestrian ProgramsPedestrian Programs–– Pedestrian Road Show Pedestrian Road Show –– Pedestrian Work Zone SafetyPedestrian Work Zone Safety–– Walk Your Child to School Walk Your Child to School

•• Other ToolsOther Tools–– Safer Journey CDSafer Journey CD

Page 111: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

3737

PedestriansPedestrians

Emerging Technologies

Count Down Count Down SignalSignal

Animated Eyes Animated Eyes DisplayDisplay

InIn--Pavement LightingPavement Lighting

Page 112: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

3838

RunRun--OffOff--thethe--RoadRoad

Reduce ImpactReduce Impact

RemoveRemove

DelineateDelineateShieldShield

WarnWarn RelocateRelocate

Page 113: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

3939

IntersectionsIntersections

Red Light RunningRed Light Running Intersection Design Intersection Design

RoundaboutsRoundabouts Conflict PointsConflict Points

Page 114: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

4040

PedestriansPedestrians

Emerging Emerging TechnologiesTechnologies

Pedestrian Road ShowPedestrian Road Show

DesignDesign

Page 115: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

4141

What Can I Do?What Can I Do?

$101

Page 116: Education, Enforcement and Traffic Calming

4242

RememberRemember

All this is done to All this is done to

SAVE LIVESSAVE LIVES