Construction and Properties of Structure- and Size-controlled ...were acquired in the ratio of...
Transcript of Construction and Properties of Structure- and Size-controlled ...were acquired in the ratio of...
Available online at www.sciencedirect.com
ScienceDirect
Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79www.elsevier.com/locate/dt
Construction and Properties of Structure- and Size-controlled Micro/nano-Energetic Materials
Bing HUANG a,b,c, Min-hua CAO a,b,*, Fu-de NIE c, Hui HUANG c, Chang-wen HU a,b,*
aKey Laboratory of Cluster Science, Beijing Institute of Technology, Beijing 100081, Chinab State Key Laboratory of Explosion Science and Technology, Beijing Institute of Technology, Beijing 100081, China
c Institute of Chemical Materials, China Academy of Engineering Physics, Mianyang 621900, China
Received 10 October 2012; revised 5 December 2012; accepted 26 February 2013
Available online 2 November 2013
Abstract
This article presents a comprehensive review of recent progress of research dedicated to structure- and size-controlled micro/nano-energeticmaterials. The development of the construction strategies for achieving zero-dimensional (0D), one-dimensional (1D), two-dimensional (2D),and three-dimensional (3D) micro/nanostructures from energetic molecules is introduced. Also, an overview of the unique properties induced bymicro/nanostructures and size effects is provided. Special emphasis is focused on the size-dependent properties that are different from those ofthe conventional micro-sized energetic materials, such as thermal decomposition, sensitivity, combustion and detonation, and compaction be-haviors. A conclusion and our view of the future development of micro/nano-energetic materials and devices are given.Copyright � 2013, China Ordnance Society. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Structure; Size; Micro/nano-energetic materials; Construction technologies; Properties
1. Introduction
It is well known that size, structure and shape have signifi-cant influence on properties of inorganic/organic materials, suchas optics, electrics, optoelectronics, gas-sensor, and magneticproperties [1e9]. Similarly, micro/nano-energetic materialswith distinct structures and extremely small feature sizes alsoexhibit structure- and size-dependent properties, includingthermal decomposition, sensitivity and operational performance[10e14]. Therefore, the controllable preparation of micro/nano-
* Corresponding authors. Key Laboratory of Cluster Science, Beijing Insti-
tute of Technology, Beijing 100081, China.
E-mail addresses: [email protected] (M.H. CAO), [email protected] (C.W.
HU).
Peer review under responsibility of China Ordnance Society
Production and hosting by Elsevier
2214-9147/$ - see front matter Copyright � 2013, China Ordnance Society. Produ
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.dt.2013.10.003
energetic materials with different morphologies and sizes is ofgreat importance for achieving desirable properties.
However, it is more difficult for the synthesis of micro/nano-energetic materials than that of inorganic nano-structures because most of energetic compounds feature vander Waals or other weak intermolecular interactions amongmolecules, and they are dangerous explosives [15e17]. Up tonow, relatively few facile and simple approaches have beendeveloped to construct the micro/nanoparticles of energeticmaterials, mainly including reprecipitation [10,18], rapidexpansion of supercritical solutions [19,20], and physicalvapor deposition (PVD) techniques [21]. Moreover, to the bestof our knowledge, there have scarcely been any reports on thedetailed researches of micro/nano-energetic materials withvarious morphologies and dimensions so far. Accordingly, thedevelopment of mild and universal methods for the fabricationof micro/nano-energetic materials with novel morphologies isclearly of great urgency but a tremendous challenge.
In this review, the recent progress of the size- andstructure-controlled micro/nanomaterials based on energeticcompounds is introduced. In Section 2, the advanced
ction and hosting by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
60 B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
construction strategies developed for the fabrication of ener-getic micro/nanostructures are reviewed. The preparationmethods for energetic micro/nanostructures with diverse di-mensions and sizes are discussed in detail. In Section 3, somemore recently studied unique properties of micro/nano-energetic materials are introduced, with emphasis on thesize-dependent thermal decomposition and tunable sensitivitycharacteristics. In Section 4, a summary and our view of thefuture development trend in this area are given.
2. Construction technologies
The development of effective and universal constructiontechnologies is prerequisite to the further investigation ofmicro/nano-energetic materials. However, most current ap-proaches which have been developed to prepare the inorganicnanomaterials, are not applicable for energetic materials dueto the lower melting/sublimation points and huge potentialdanger. In the field of organic small-molecule nanomaterials,the considerable efforts have been dedicated to the control-lable synthesis of various organic nanomaterials with distinctshapes, such as nanoparticles [22e24], nanotubes [25,26],nanowires [27e29], nanorods [30,31], and nanobelts [32,33].These fruitful attempts should give a useful enlightenment forthe design and fabrication of micro/nano-energetic materialswith peculiar structures. Therefore, in this section, we justintroduce in more detail the recent successful examples ofsynthesizing micro/nano-energetic materials with the preva-lent methods which have been used extensively in other fields.
Fig. 1. (a) SEM image of spherical NTO and (b) comparison of cooling rates
on particle size at 200 and 700 rpm [38].
2.1. Re-precipitation method
2.1.1. Cooling crystallizationCooling crystallization has achieved a great success in the
synthesis of energetic materials with special structures andnarrow size distribution [34]. For this technique, the type ofco-solvent, cooling rate and solvent composition are theimportant process parameters to control the morphology andsize of the crystals. However, it is difficult to reduce the size ofthe products when the energetic compounds are used as targetsources.
Han and coworkers recently studied the solubility andrecrystallization of highly hydrogen-bonded 1,3,5-triamino-2,4,6-trinitrobenzene (TATB) in various ionic liquid solventsystems [35]. They synthesized TATB microparticles grown bythe cooling crystallization process in ionic liquidedimethylsulphoxide (DMSO) co-solvent systems. It is known that thespherical crystals of energetic materials exhibit improvedperformance over non-spherical crystals, such as insensitivityto sudden shock, processability and packing density [36,37].Vijayalakshmi et al. fabricated spherical 3-nitro-1,2,4-triazol-5-one (NTO) particles in NTO : water : N-methyl-2-pyrolidone (NMP) ternary system by using cooling crystalli-zation technique [38]. By adjusting the process parameters,such as cooling rate, agitator configuration and speed, a se-lective particle size distribution ranging from 10 to 200 mmcould be achieved (Fig. 1). Kim and his coworkers used a
similar assembly method to prepare spherical NTO particles inthe co-solvent of water and NMP [39e43]. The sphericalparticles with average diameter ranging from 30 to 300 mmwere acquired in the ratio of NTO/NMP ranging from 0.2 to0.6 and in the ratio of water/NMP ranging from 1.0 to 4.8 atthe cooling rate of 10 K/min. Besides, Kim’s group usedoctahydro-1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocine (HMX) asseed to direct the zero-dimensional (0D) coreeshell structuregrowth of HMX/NTO by two-step cooling crystallization[44,45]. The typical scanning electron microscopy (SEM)images of these energetic composites in Fig. 2 reveal that thesurface of the coreeshell HMX/NTO structures is compactand uniform. They pointed out that the agglomeration kineticfor the coating of NTO on HMX core particles was correlatedwith the 3rd power of the solution supersaturation and the 2ndpower of the number of the suspended particles.
2.1.2. Solvent/nonsolvent processSince the first use of solvent/nonsolvent method in the
preparation of organic nanocrystals by Nakanishi in 1993 [46],this technology has been extensively adopted in the field ofenergetic materials due to its facility and versatility[18,47e50]. The method mainly includes a rapid mixing ofconcentrated solution of the objective compound in a goodsolvent with excess of a poor solvent, leading to the nucleationand growth of the molecules to small-sized particles withdesired structures. The significant difference between thesolubilities of the target molecules in the good and poor
Fig. 2. (a) Diagram of experimental apparatus and (b)e(g) effect of supersaturation on coating morphology. [44].
61B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
solvents and the good compatibility of the two solvents areessential.
A series of energetic micro/nanoparticles were successfullyfabricated by using this method. For example, Liu et al. re-ported that reticular nano-sized HMX was simply constructedat room temperature [10]. SEM and transmission electronmicroscopy (TEM) show that the spherical HMX particleswith diameter of about 50 nm aggregate into reticularlystructured conglomerates, as shown in Fig. 3. Subsequently, Liet al. prepared HMX microcrystals and studied their micro-scopic morphologies [51,52]. Moore and coworkers also ob-tained submicron-sized HMX by pouring a solution of HMXin acetone into a cold nonsolvent with strong stirring [53,54].van der Heijden’s group and Arya’s group prepared hexahy-dro-1,3,5-trinitro-1,3,5-triazine (RDX) and 2,20,4,40,6,60-hex-anitrostilbene (HNS) ultrafine particles, respectively. Ourgroup fabricated 2,6-diamino-3,5-dinitropyrazine-1-oxide(LLM-105) microtubes with a distinctive rectangular cross-section architecture by using ionic liquid 1-butyl-3-methylimidazolium trifluoromethanesulfonate ([Bmim]CF3SO3) as good solvent and water as poor solvent [55]. Inaddition, other various structures and morphologies of ultra-fine RDX have also been reported, such as murphy-like, cube-like, and spherical [56]. It is found that the morphologies andsizes of the obtained structures can be controlled by adjustingthe experimental parameters.
2.1.3. Nozzle-assisted solvent/nonsolvent processThe above mentioned solvent/nonsolvent method has been
used to synthesize the energetic compounds with desired sizeand special morphology, but it suffers with an issue of processscale-up. Therefore, an instrument with high-pressure jet,which can lead to a rapid nucleation in continuous reactionand crystallization, producing the nanoscale energetic particleswith high yield and mass production, was developed in thepast few years.
Wang and his coworkers reported the fabrication of sub-micron HMX and RDX by spraying a solution of the nitr-amine explosive into water at different process parameters[57]. Recently, they also prepared the high-purity HNSnanocrystals with high specific surface area and narrow par-ticle size distribution by using a prefilming twin-fluid nozzle-
assisted precipitation method [58,59]. In our laboratory, thelarge-scale TATB nanoparticles were obtained by atomizingthe objective compound to the small droplets through a nozzleat high speed [60,61]. TEM and atomic force microscopy(AFM) images show that the resulting nano-TATB particleshave the shape of sphere or ellipsoid with size of about 60 nm(Fig. 4). Bayat and coworkers used a similar method to preparethe submicron particles of HMX and systemically investigatedthe influence of the experimental parameters, such as anti-solvent temperature, compressed air flow rate, and nozzlediameter [62], on the size of HMX particle, while Shokrolahiand coworkers obtained the crystalline nanoparticles of keto-derivative of RDX (K-6) [63].
2.1.4. Ultrasound-assisted solvent/nonsolvent processUltrasound-assisted solvent/nonsolvent is an effective and
safe technology for preparing the micro/nanoparticles of en-ergetic materials [64,65]. It is generally used to control thenucleation process [66]. Sivabalan et al. combined the ultra-sound technology with the solvent/nonsolvent method tocontrol the size and morphology of 2,4,6,8,10,12-hexanitro-2,4,6,8,10,12-hexaazaisowurtzitane (CL-20) [67]. The resultsreveal that the sonication process offers a uniform morphologywithout any agglomeration, and the particle size of sonicatedCL-20 sample obtained is about 5 mm with a narrow particlesize distribution. Bayat and his coworkers introduced thesonication into spaying-assisted precipitative crystallization toprepare the spherical or ellipsoidal CL-20 nanoparticles withan average size of 95 nm [68]. They pointed out that thenanoparticles tend to agglomerate due to their smaller size.Wang and his coworkers also demonstrated that ultrafine CL-20 was synthesized with ethyl acetate as solvent and heptaneor n-hexane as non-solvent by using an ultrasound- and spray-assisted precipitation [69].
2.2. Spray drying strategy
2.2.1. Spray dryingBesides the above re-precipitation method, a simple spay
drying technology, which has been widely used to preparethe submicrometer- or nanosized inorganic and polymericnanoparticles [70e72], is utilized to prepare the nanostructures
Fig. 3. SEM and TEM images of sample prepared by solvent/nonsolvent
method. Concentration of HMX acetone solution: (a) 2 mmol/L, (b) 5 mmol/L,
and (c) 10 mmol/L [10].
62 B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
of energetic materials. For example, Castro-Rosario and hiscoworkers prepared RDX nanoparticles with an average size of405 nm by exposing the glass substrate surfaces to an aerosoljet containing RDX [73]. Ultra-fine HNS explosive withspherical morphology was acquired with the aid of spray dryingprocess by Wang’s group, and there was no phase transition inthe process of preparation [74]. Recently, Qiu and his co-workers assessed the feasibility of single-step preparation ofHMX-based nanocomposite particles with polymeric binder byusing spray drying [75]. It was found that the microparticlesconsist of small crystals uniformly and discretely dispersed in abinder. This facile method may be suitable for the preparationof a wide range of insensitive explosive compositions. Zhigachet al. demonstrated that ultrafine nitramine (RDX, HMX andCL-20) powders with an average crystal size of about 1 mm andaluminized nanocomposites were produced [76]. Our groupextended this technology to coreeshell binary energetic system.For instance, we prepared and characterized a new type ofcomposite particles with a coreeshell structure by injecting atetrahydrofuran (THF) suspension containing NTO and HMXinto a spray dryer. After THF evaporation, NTO crystallized inthe shape of small particles on the surface of HMX micropar-ticles, and the coreeshell structure of HMX/NTO compositeparticles was obtained [77]. The surface of the composite par-ticles was “potholed”, while that of HMX particles was smooth.Moreover, the ultrafine TATB/benzotrifuroxan (BTF) coree-shell composite particles can also be synthesized by using thespay drying method [78].
2.2.2. Electrospray crystallizationElectrospray crystallization is one of the effective methods
to achieve the nano- and submicron-sized crystals [79]. Withthe aid of high potential difference, the electrostatic forcescould overcome the surface tension, and any flow arriving atthe tip of the nozzle is directly emitted as a jet of liquiddroplets. As a result, a mist of ultrafine solution droplets isgenerated, and the subsequent solvent evaporation leads to theformation of submicron-sized crystals [80]. For example,Radacsi’s group developed an electrospray crystallizationmethod (Fig. 5) to prepare the agglomerated RDX hollowspheres with the size of around 4 mm and spherical particleswith a size ranging from 200 to 600 nm under the differentpotential differences [81]. Reus and his coworkers preparedthe encapsulated RDXetrinitrotoluene (TNT) sphericalnanoparticles by using the elecrospray technique, and thecomposition of the particles needs further investigation [82].
2.2.3. Ultrasound-assisted spray dryingUltrasonic-assisted spray drying, as one of various atomi-
zation techniques, is a favored method because of its excellentenergy-efficiency and the inherently low velocity of initialdroplets [83]. Accordingly, this outstanding technique hasbeen employed for the preparation of energetic materials withmicro/nanostructures.
Spitzer and his coworkers reported the first use of the at-omization process for the continuous crystallization ofexplosive submicrometer- and nano-energetic compounds
Fig. 4. (a) TEM and (b) AFM images of nano-TATB [60].
63B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
[84,85]. More inspiringly, RDX or 2,2-bis[(nitroxy)methyl]-1,3-propanediol (PETN) nanoparticles can be produced from 1to 10 g/h by using a reactor containing one ultrasonic piezo-electric transducer, and even can be scaled up using severaltransducers. Qiu et al. reported that RDX- or CL-20-basednanocomposite consisting of explosive crystals with nano-esubmicron size range can be obtained by ultrasonic sprayfrom an explosive/polyvinyl acetate binder/acetone dilute
Fig. 5. Process scheme of electr
solution [86e88]. Recently, Koo and his coworkers also uti-lized this technology to achieve ultrafine RDX with size of0.8e2.6 mm [89,90]. It could be observed from Fig. 6 thatRDX concentration and furnace temperature play an importantrole in controlling the crystal size and habit. They alsoconcluded that a nucleation inhibitor could be utilized as ahabit modifier and the onset time of nucleation is an importantfactor to improve the crystal shape.
2.3. Spray freeze-drying technique
Spray freeze-drying (SFD) technique, which is consideredas one of the advanced ways for the fabrication of nano-particles, has been widely used for the synthesis of nano-structures of biological medicaments and inorganic materials[91e93]. The particles obtained by this method generallypossess the intriguing advantages, such as molecular scalehomogeneity because of flash freezing in the cryogen, andminimal agglomeration because of the sublimation of thewater ice in the low-temperature vacuum drying condition[94,95]. So far, this system has been used to synthesize thenanostructures of energetic materials.
In the early years, our group reported the fabrication of three-dimensional (3D) nano-network structures of NTO [96]. Sincethe formed ice limits the aggregation of small particles, theobtained NTO particles have an elongated shape and the size ofthe particles is in the range of 70e90 nm. With a similar tech-nique, 1,1-diamino-2,2-dinitroethylene (FOX-7) 3D gridnanostructures with different unit sizes were also prepared bythe freeze-drying technique mentioned above [97]. The prepa-ration process of FOX-7 3D grid nanostructures is shown inFig. 7(a). The typical SEM images in Fig. 7(b), (c) indicate thatthe resulting FOX-7 3D structures are constructed from one-dimensional nanostructures. The size and reticular structuresof the as-resulting nano-FOX-7 could be easily controlled byadjusting the concentration of the aqueous solution of raw ma-terials. The further investigation on a possible formationmechanism of this structure reveals that a high degree of super-cooling under the liquid nitrogen conditions leads to a highnucleation rate, and the small particles and ice are rapidlyformed due to the rapid heat transfer between the aqueous so-lution and the cryogen. After the sublimation of ice, the small
ospray crystallization [81].
Fig. 6. SEM images of RDX particles prepared from (a) 0.5 wt% and (b) 4.0 wt% RDX/acetone solution at the furnace temperature of 175 �C; SEM images of
RDX particles prepared from 1.0 wt% RDX/acetone solution at furnace temperatures of (c) 75 �C and (d) 175 �C [89].
64 B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
particles with a relatively high energy start to aggregate by self-assembly, leading to the formation of 3D grid structures. Ascheme of this growth process is summarized in Fig. 7(d). Moreimportantly, this facile synthesis strategy may represent a gen-eral approach for the preparation of nanostructures of otherwater-solubility energetic compounds.
2.4. Sol-gel processing
Sol-gel processing is a feasible way to prepare the inor-ganic/organic nanocomposites under mild conditions[98e102]. The stoichiometry and homogeneity of the nano-composites can be easily controlled by using this method,and therefore this method could dramatically improve currentstate-of-the-art technology. Moreover, the solegel chemistryhas the ability to construct the nanostructured materials withspecial shapes, such as uniform net-shape geometric solids,fibers, films, and powders with nanoscale size [103,104].
Tillotson’s group used the solegel processing to preparethe composite nano-energetic materials [105]. In this process,RDX or PETN was first loaded into the pores of the wetmonolithic gel and then was kept there upon supercriticalsolvent extraction drying, which helps restrain the growth ofthe explosive particle beyond the nanometer and submicronscale. Brill and his coworkers prepared various unusual ener-getic composites, in which CL-20 nanoparticles were uni-formly coated with energetic polymer gels using solegelmethod [106e108]. Ingale et al. demonstrated that the silicaxerogels incorporated with nanocrystalline PETN or PETN/TNT were synthesized, in which the content of energetic
materials ranges from 50% to 90% (w/w) [109,110]. Ourgroup used this strategy to prepare laminate-like structuredHMX/ammonium perchlorate (AP)/resorcinol-formaldehyde(RF) aerogel with uniform pores [111], as shown in Fig. 8(a),(b). The XRD results show that the mean size of HMX crystalsis less than 100 nm and the mixture of HMX and AP is uni-form in nano-scale. The specific surface area of HMX/AP/RFis 27 m2/g, which is much less than that of RF aerogel. Themesopores and micropores of HMX/AP/RF composites mainlydistribute in the range of 2e20 nm and 0.6e1.6 nm, respec-tively. Besides HMX/AP/RF, we also prepared RDX/RF gel bymeans of emulsion process and solegel technique [112]. SEMimages are given in Fig. 8(c)e(e), which clearly show that theparticle size of RDX/RF composites is controlled by adjustingthe composition of the surfactant system and the temperatureof growth solution. Recently, Luo and his coworkers reportedthe preparation of an AP/RDX/SiO2 nanocomposite energeticmaterials [113]. They found that the distance between the SiO2
colloidal particles was enlarged due to the presence of RDXand AP, which is contributed to the lower crosslinking struc-ture and the bigger pores.
2.5. Supercritical fluid precipitation processes
Supercritical fluids have been used as solvents for a widevariety of applications in the field of organic and inorganicmaterials [114e116]. On the basis of above fluids, varioussupercritical fluid-based precipitation methods have beendeveloped and have attracted extraordinary attention due tounique micronization processes compared with conventional
Fig. 7. (a) Flow chart of FOX-7 quasi-three-dimensional grids fabricated via SFD technique; (b) low magnification; (c) high magnification of SEM images of FOX-
7 nanostructures prepared with CFOX-7 ¼ 0.1 g/L; (d) a probable formation process of FOX-7 network structures under the same supercooling rate [97].
65B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
crystallization techniques, such as milling, crushing, spraydrying, and crystallization from liquid solution [117,118]. Thesupersaturation and nucleation rates, and the size andmorphology of micro/nanoparticles can be easily controlled byvarying the process parameters. To date, the supercritical fluidprocesses, mainly including rapid expansion supercritical so-lutions (RESS) process and supercritical anti-solvent (SAS)process [19,119], have been used for explosives.
Fig. 8. (a), (b) SEM micrographs of HMX/AP/RF aerogel [111]. SEM images of th
the surfactant, respectively; (c) 70 �C, 5%; (d) 90 �C, 5%; (e) 70 �C, 2% [112].
2.5.1. Rapid expansion of supercritical solutions (RESS)RESS, which is to saturate a supercritical fluid with the
objective compound and then depressurize this solution into alow pressure chamber through a heated nozzle, is a simpleprocess for explosive that enables the growth of micro/nano-particles without the need for a drying process [19]. Morrismeasured the solubility of RDX in carbon dioxide (CO2) at303e353 K and 6.9e48.3 MPa, and confirmed a maximum
e as-obtained RDX/RF composite at different temperatures and proportions of
66 B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
solubility of about 0.25 mg of RDX/g of CO2 [120]. Subse-quently, Krober et al. reported that TNT and NTO can bemicronized by the RESS process [121]. RDX was precipitatedto the ultrafine particles with spherical morphology by usingcompressed liquid dimethyl ether (DME) as a solvent [122].Krasnoperov’s group produced RDX nanocrystals by RESS[123]. The experiments were performed by expanding thesupercritical solution of RDX in carbon dioxide through sap-phire nozzles, as shown in Fig. 9(a). SEM images indicate thatthe tunable particle size of resulted RDX nanocrystal is in therange of 110e220 nm with a narrow size distribution(Fig. 9(b)e(d)). Moreover, they also further investigated theoptimized conditions and initiation sensitivity [20,124e126].The significant change of properties of nano-RDX comparedwith that of the bulk material will be discussed in Section 3.
2.5.2. Supercritical anti-solvent process (SAS)In the SAS process, a compressed gas or supercritical fluid
is used as an anti-solvent that causes the precipitation of solidraw material dissolved initially in a liquid solvent. This pro-cess offers several advantages, such as control of particle size,size distribution, crystal structure and crystal phase [127].Therefore, the SAS process is also adopted in micronization ofexplosives as a promising crystallization method.
In recent years, Lee’s group prepared micronized RDX byusing a SAS process and systemically investigated the in-fluence of different solvents on morphology, size, and sizedistribution [128]. Fig. 10 shows the SEM images of therecrystallized RDX particles obtained in different solvents. It
Fig. 9. (a) Schematic representation of the RESS setup; SEM images of RDX partic
(c) 363 K and pressure 15.0 MPa, using heatable nozzle (ID ¼ 100 mm); and (d)
can be seen from Fig. 10 that the morphology and size ofrecrystallized RDX are dependent on the used solvent. Inaddition, they proved that the SAS technique is an effectivemethod for the preparation of size- and morphology-controllable HMX particles [129,130]. Similar results werealso found by Lee and his coworkers when they tried toprepare the microparticles of nitroamine explosives (RDXand HMX) [131e133]. With the aid of the SAS process,Pourmortazavi et al. successfully synthesized HMX nano-particles by employing Taguchi robust design as a statisticaloptimization method to optimize the experimental variables[134].
2.6. Template technique
The template technique is a straight forward approach tofabricate micro/nanostructures by inducing the target materialsto grow according to the patterns of the templates. Thisstrategy provides a simple way for the synthesis of micro/nanomaterials with desired shape and size, and has beenwidely applied in the construction of different dimensionalmicro/nanostructures. The templates adopted in this methodcan be generally divided into two sorts: rigid and soft ones.
2.6.1. Rigid templateThe rigid template method for the preparation of micro/
nanostructures has been developed independently in variousfields of nanotechnology. It has become one of the mostcommon methods in the fabrication of inorganic, organic and
les produced at (b) 348 K and 28.0 MPa, using heatable nozzle (ID ¼ 100 mm);
363 K and pressure 15.0 MPa, using heatable nozzle (ID ¼ 150 mm) [123].
Fig. 10. SEM images of the recrystallized RDX particles obtained in different solvents: (a) CHN; (b) DMSO; (c) ACN; (d) AC; (e) DMF; (f) NMP [128].
67B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
polymeric micro/nanomaterials [135e138]. Now thecommonly used templates include ordered porous membranes[139], silica [140], nanochannel glass [141], monodispersecolloids [142], and iontrack-etched polymers [143].
During the past several years, this technique has alsobeenusedto prepare the energetic nanocomposites. Smeug et al. investi-gated the confinement of energetic molecules inside carbonnanostructures by molecular structure and total energy calcula-tions [144]. The calculation results predict that each energeticmolecule, including FOX-7, RDX, HMX, 3,6-di-(hydrazino)-1,2,4,5-tetrazine (DHT), 3,6-diazido-1,2,4,5-tetrazine (DiAT),3,30-azo-bis(6-amino-1,2,4,5-tetrazine) (DAAT), and N-oxidesofDAAT(DAATOn,n¼ 1e5) could be stabilizedby32e53kcal/mole if a carbon nanotube (CNT) with appropriate size isselected. Recently,Hu and his coworkers achieved the fabricationof KNO3@CNTs nano-energetic materials by combining thewetchemical-assistant electrophoretic deposition (EPD) with rigidtemplate method (Fig. 11(a)) [145]. The TEM images ofKNO3@CNTs nanocomposites are shown in Fig. 11(b)e(d). Itcan be seen that the hollow cavities of CNTs are homogeneouslyfilled with crystalline KNO3 without any impurities attached onthe outer surface.
Several host-guest nanocomposites, such as 2,4,6-trinitrophenol (PA)/mesoporous carbon FDU-15, FOX-7/FDU-15 and CL-20/mesoporous silica SBA-15, were preparedbased on self-assembly of energetic molecules in nanometer-scale channels of an ordered mesoporous material[146e148]. The design and synthesis of these kinds of mate-rials are beneficial to understand the reaction characteristics ofenergetic ordered arrays and further fabricate the micro/nano-devices with high performance and efficiency. Similarly, FOX-7 immobilized in the pores of silica MFI-type zeolite nano-crystals was fabricated by Mintova and his coworkers [149].Choosing a porous chromium (III) oxide (Cr2O3) matrix pro-duced by the combustion of ammonium dichromate as atemplate, the RDX/Cr2O3 nanocomposites were obtained via afacile solvent evaporation process by Spitzer and his co-workers [150,151]. The method may be suitable for thepreparation of a wide range of sensitive explosive composi-tions embedded in the porous materials.
2.6.2. Wet chemical-assisted soft templateSo-called soft templates can be dissolved in the liquid
phase, mainly including surfactant micelles and copolymers[152e154]. It is well-known that the surfactant micelles andinverse micelles with different shapes (spherical, rod-like, andso on) are formed in the solutions when their concentrationsreach the critical micelle concentration (CMC) [155]. Thus,these micelles can then be used as the soft templates for thefabrication of organic and inorganic micro/nanostructures.
It iswell-known that TATB is not soluble in themost commonsolvents due to significant intra- and inter-molecular hydrogenbonds [156,157], and thus most of methods commonly used inthe synthesis of organic nanomaterials, such as solvent volatil-ization, rigid template, and vapor deposition, are not suitable forthe fabrication of TATB nanostructures. In our recent work, aternary microemulsion system of water/dioctyl sulfosuccinatesodium salt (AOT)/toluenewas developed to directly synthesizeone-dimensional (1D) twinned TATB nanobelts [158]. A seriesof experiments confirm that the urea as an aminating reagentplays a key role in the formation of highly crystalline nanobeltswith perfect mirror symmetry, because the aminating reactioncould be easily controlled by adjusting the hydrolysis rate ofurea. By using this route, besides twinned nanobelts, variousTATB micro/nanostructures, such as particles, leaves, bananaleaves, and wedge-shaped ribbons with different sizes, could bedirectly prepared by changing the experimental parameters.
Subsequently, we developed a facile surfactant-assistedself-assembly technique for constructing 3D dendritic 2,6-diamino-3,5-dinitropyrazine (ANPZ) microstructures innontoxic ethanol solvent using urea as the aminating reagent(Fig. 12(a)e(d)) [159]. With the assistance of surfactantPluronic P123 block copolymer, the size and morphology ofANPZ micro/nanostructures can be easily tailored by varyingthe operating conditions. Moreover, the growth mechanism ofANPZ dendrites was also proposed on the basis of a detailedtime-dependent morphology evolution study, as illustrated inFig. 12(e). Recently, Mandal and his coworkers synthesizedthe spherical particles of FOX-7 by using the concept of amicelle-based nanoreactor [160]. The diameters of thesespherical particles are in the range of nanometer to
Fig. 11. (a) Schematic model of EPD. The Cu thin-film microbridge on the glass substrate was set as cathode and Pt plate as anode. The distance between the
cathode and the anode was adjusted to be 1 cm. (b)e(d) TEM images of the KNO3@CNTs nEMs achieved by wet chemical method [145].
68 B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
submicrometer. Significantly, the size and shape of FOX-7particles can be adjusted by varying the wateresurfactantmolar ratio in the microemulsion system.
2.7. Physical vapor deposition (PVD)
PVD is a simple and outstanding method for preparingnanomaterials, and has achieved great success in the synthesisof inorganic nanostructures and polymeric thin films[161e163]. The morphology, size, and dispersity of theproducts are easily controlled by tuning the experimentalconditions, such as saturation level, temperature, and time.
Frolov et al. reported the first synthesis of nano-RDX,nano-HMX, nano-NH4NO3, or their composites by employ-ing vacuum sublimation and condensation process[21,164e166]. The obtained energetic particles have anaverage diameter of about 50 nm. Although this technique hasa low yield, it provides useful information for the design andfabrication of energetic molecule micro/nanostructures. Zhangsynthesized PETN films with desired surface morphology in acontrollable and reproducible way by thermal evaporation ondifferent substrates [167,168]. Recently, 2D one-molecule-thick single-crystalline nanosheets of LLM-105 supported onhighly oriented pyrolytic graphites (HOPG) were prepared byvapor self-assembling method at 220 �C and atmosphericpressure (Fig. 13) [169]. The nanosheet with rectangular shapeand lateral dimension, which is very sensitive to electricity and
force stimuli, provides an opportunity to write optional pat-terns and fabricate high-sensitive force sensor.
2.8. Inkjet printing
It is noteworthy that inkjet printing technique has beenrecently extended as a low-cost processing method in the fieldof energetic materials due to its advantages of excellent ac-curacy and surface finishes. For example, this technology wasexplored as a new way to directly deposit and pattern energeticmaterials for trace explosive detection application [170,171].Lee reported the inkjet-print RDX crystals, which weredispersed in a cellulose acetate butyrate (CAB) matrix bydirect-phase transformation from organic solvent-based all-liquid inks. They found that a variety of crystal morphologiescould be obtained by changing the ink deposition parameters[172,173]. They also reported that this effective strategy isused to control the droplet coalescence during inkjet printing,and consequently to tailor the nanoscale morphology oforganic composites [174]. They found that the decrease incoalescence increased the evaporation rate of solvent, the su-persaturation of the solutes, and the nucleation density of theorganic crystals. Utilizing this method, the average size ofPETN crystals dispersed in an adhesive binder [poly(vinylacetate) or a chlorinated wax] matrix from 0.2 to 100 mm waseasily tailored (Fig. 14). In addition, the inkjet technique wasalso used to prepare other energetic samples (HMX, TNT and
Fig. 12. (a)e(c) SEM images of the as-prepared ANPZ sample; (d) TEM images of a single microrod. (e) Schematic illustration of the possible growth process of
dendritic ANPZ microstructures and their building blocks [159].
69B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
NH4NO3) with controlled size and distribution by Hernandez-Rivera and coworkers [175].
3. Properties
Besides the exploration of the construction strategies, mucheffort has also been focused on investigating the significantchange of properties of micro/nano-energetic materials ob-tained by above technologies, In this section, we give anoverview of present studies on the unique properties of micro/nano-energetic materials. First, the size-dependent thermalproperties are discussed, then more attention is paid to varioussensitive characteristics, and finally the combustion/detonationperformance and compaction behavior are also introducedbriefly.
3.1. Size-dependent thermal properties
It is well addressed that small particles in the nanometersize regime exhibit unique physical and chemical propertiesthat differ markedly from those of the bulk material. The size-dependent properties of nanomaterials were establishedinitially from inorganic materials [176,177]. Subsequently, thesize-dependent properties can also be observed in micro/nano-energetic compounds, such as HMX [10,52,179], HNS [18],TATB [60,178], RDX [63,123], CL-20 [69], and nitrocellulose(NC) [180]. In our previous work, FOX-7 nanoparticles withaverage diameters ranging from 100 to 800 nm were obtainedby SFD technique [97]. We systematically investigated thethermal properties of prepared FOX-7 nanostructures. Asshown in Fig. 15(a), the differential scanning calorimetry(DSC) patterns of both the FOX-7 nanostructures and the
Fig. 13. (a) Topographical image of a LLM-105 nanosheet in contact mode. (b) High-magnification current image of LLM-105 nanosheet with size of
20 nm � 20 nm under the conductive AFM mode with load of 0.2 nN, bias of 0.2 V, and scanning rate of 0.5 Hz. (c) The logo pattern of our institute, ICM, wrote
on an explosive nanosheet of LLM-105. (d) Dynamic force microscope (DFM) topographical of LLM-105 nanosheet on HOPG, the dark squares in nanosheet in
regions of 50 nm � 50 nm and 200 nm � 200 nm were scanned at bias value of 5 V with conductive AFM [169].
70 B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
micro-sized raw material display two exothermal peaks withthe maximum in the range of 240e256 �C and 280e298 �C,respectively. It can be clearly seen that the first exothermalpeak shifts to higher temperature with the decrease in FOX-7particle size. This phenomenon can be explained by the theoryof topochemical reactions that the small-sized FOX-7 particle
Fig. 14. (a) Surface morphology of a single layer deposition printed under maximum
multilayer deposition printed under minimum coalescence-like conditions using
morphology in areas labeled “c” and “d”, respectively, in (b) [174].
generally requires a higher decomposition temperature due toits less lattice defects and smaller internal stress [181]. For thesecond exothermal peak, it shifts to lower temperature with thedecrease in the particle size, and there is a shift of approximate13 �C to lower temperature compared to FOX-7 raw material.This regular shift is considered to result from the increased
coalescence-like conditions using a d1,2 of 5 mm; (b) surface morphology of a
a d1,2 of 100 mm (c) and (d) higher magnification images of characteristic
Fig. 15. DSC (a) and TGA (b) curves of FOX-7 nanostructures prepared with
different CFOX-7 (a: 0.1 g/L; b: 0.2 g/L; c: 1 g/L; d: 2 g/L) and FOX-7 raw
material (e) between 40 �C and 500 �C at a heating rate of 10 �C/min [97].
71B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
ratio of surface atoms to interior atoms when the particle sizedecreases. Thermogravimetry (TG) curves in Fig. 15(b)exhibit a distinct weight loss and no evident inflexion fornanoparticles. It is suggested that nano-sized FOX-7 has amuch higher decomposition rate, which is in accordance withthe results of DSC.
In addition, our group also reported the thermal propertiesof other micro/nano-energetic materials [159]. We preparedANPZ micro/nanoparticles with different morphologies via afacile surfactant-assisted solvothermal process. It is interestingto note that the morphology evolution from 2D nanosheets to3D hierarchically self-assembled dendrites was accompaniedby a regular change in decomposition temperature, whichexhibited a unique morphology-dependent thermal effect. Thatmay be due to the fact that the size changes from nanometer tomicrometer as the morphology evolves from nanosheets todendrites. Therefore, the ratio of surface atoms to interioratoms significantly decreases as the particle size increases.The ANPZ dendritic microstructures have a lower surface
energy and are more difficult to be stimulated under thermalinitiation than small-sized nanostructures. On the basis ofabove analysis, the ANPZ micro-/nanostructures exhibited aseeming morphology-dependent thermal effect that is actuallysize-dependent.
Very recently, Mohammadi and coworkers studied thethermal decomposition of RDX nanoparticles with varioussizes produced by a wet ball milling technique in hexanesolvent [182]. The results show that the thermal decompositiontemperature of RDX and its decomposition activation energyare significantly enhanced as the particle size of RDX isincreased. The activation energy for micro-RDX is 1.5 timeshigher than that for nano-RDX, which was ascribed to thedecrease in reactivity and localized hotspots. Furthermore,based on calculated kinetic data, the gradual increase in thecritical ignition temperature of RDX samples was also foundin the order: 180 nm RDX < 250 nm RDX < 300 nmRDX < 50 mm RDX, which is in good accordance with theDSC results.
Furthermore, the catalytic behavior of inorganic nano-materials on the thermal decomposition of high-energy ex-plosives attracted some attention in the past years because ofimproved thermal efficiency. As a consequence, the consid-erable efforts have been devoted to the controllable con-struction of inorganic nanoparticles, such as metals [183,184]and metal oxides [185e189], in order to obtain higher cata-lytic activity, in which micro-sized explosives are selected ascatalytic targets. However, there has been scarcely any reportso far on the catalytic thermal decomposition of ultrafine ex-plosives. Zhigach and coworkers developed a convenientapproach for preparing the alumined nanocomposites by spraydrying of a suspension of Al nanoparticles in as solution ofnitramine (RDX, HMX and CL-20) [76]. SEM images revealthat the nitramine powders with an average crystal size ofabout 1 mm were obtained and nano-sized Al particles wereuniformly distributed in the energetic matrix of compositematerials. Unfortunately, there is no report on the catalyticthermal decomposition of alumined nanocomposites.
3.2. Tunable sensitivity characteristics
3.2.1. Impact sensitivityThe impact sensitivity of energetic materials to unintended
initiation is an important safety factor during their uses. Ingeneral, the reduction in particle size leads to the decrease inimpact sensitivity. For instance, NTO nanoparticles with a sizeof 70e90 nm were prepared by spray freezing drying tech-nology [96], and the mechanical sensitivity measurement showthat the determined H50 for micro-NTO and nano-NTO are26.2 and 35.5 cm, respectively. This result shows that the as-synthesized ultrafine powder has lower impact sensitivitythan that of the NTO raw material. It was proposed that theaverage pore diameter of ultrafine particles was too small tobecome a hot spot under the impact stimulus, thus leading tothe decrease in impact sensitivity. Wang and his coworkersalso investigated the effect of particle size on the impactsensitivity of energetic materials. As mentioned above, a
Fig. 16. Shock sensitivity of uncoated samples of Class 1, 4.8 micron, Type A
nano-RDX (a specific surface area around 15e20 m2/g), and Type B nano-
RDX (a specific surface area around 5e6 m2/g) [125].
72 B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
nozzle-assisted solvent/nonsolvent method was developed forthe preparation of nanoparticles from HNS and CL-20 [58,69].The impact test indicates that both nano-HNS and nano-CL-20are less sensitive than that of their raw material. In particular,the impact sensitivity of composite energetic materials wasalso studied by Brill’s group and Luo’s group [107,113]. Thetunable impact sensitivity characteristics of these nano-composites were confirmed.
3.2.2. Friction sensitivityAs expected, the particle size of energetic materials has an
important effect on friction sensitivity, but the reported resultsare controversial. Recently, Robmann et al. reported that theultrafine HMX particles were synthesized by using a beadmilling technology [190]. It was revealed that the frictionsensitivity of HMX decreased greatly as the crystal size wasreduced from 4.5 mm to 171 nm. Radacsi and his coworkersalso performed the friction sensitivity tests at the highestpossible load (360 N) and found that the friction sensitivity ofthe submicron-sized RDX particles is much lower than that ofthe conventional RDX crystals [81]. The author assumed thatthe decrease in the friction sensitivity was mainly attributed tothe defect and internal quality of the energetic crystals. Li andhis coworkers fabricated three kinds of HMX samples with
Fig. 17. Burning rate dependency on the pressure of the RDX monopropellant.
RDX particle sizes: A 50 nm; : 5 mm and - 50 mm [166].
spherical, needle-like and polyhedral microstructures by wetmilling, solvent/nonsolvent and riddling methods, respectively[52]. It is interesting to note that the friction sensitivity in-creases gradually as particle size decreases for spherical b-HMX particles, but the friction sensitivity of needle-like g-HMX linearly increases with the increase in particle size from2.98 to 16.1 mm. However, for polyhedral b-HMX sample, itsfriction sensitivity did not display some rule as a function ofparticle size. The above results show that the safety of HMX isdependent strongly on the size and structure of HMX particles.This phenomenon can be explained by the “hot spot” growthmechanism [191].
3.2.3. Electrostatic spark sensitivityIt was mentioned in Section 2 that our group presented a
facile strategy for the construction of 3D FOX-7 nano-structures and investigated the response of nanoparticles toignition stimulus under the electrostatic discharge conditions[97]. The results of electrostatic spark sensitivity of nano-FOX-7 indicate that its 50% critical ignition voltage (V50)and 50% critical ignition energy (E50) are 13.19 kVand 2.65 J,respectively, which are lower than those of FOX-7 raw ma-terial, 16.42 kV and 4.11 J. The decrease in ignition energymay be explained by the fact that the FOX-7 nanostructureswith higher surface energy are easy to be stimulated.
3.2.4. Shock sensitivityIn order to produce the safe munitions which are capable of
withstanding the unwanted mechanical stimuli, such as shocksfrom explosions, it is necessary to substantially reduce theinitiation sensitivity of energetic materials. A great number ofexperimental data prove that energetic materials withdecreased particle size have great changes in safety under thecondition of shock initiation stimuli. The prior studies havedemonstrated that the shock initiation sensitivity of some ex-plosives, such as HNS, HMX, RDX and TATB, has beeneffectively lowered [192e195]. In the case of RDX, thenanoparticles generated by the RESS process show differentshock behaviors compared to the bulk material [125], asillustrated in Fig. 16. The RDX with the size of 4.8 mm showsthat the small scale gap test result is 19.6 kbar, while the bulkmaterial exhibits higher sensitivity. However, the shocksensitivity results of Types A nano-RDX and Types B nano-RDX are 20.6 and 26.1 kbar, respectively. The above dataclearly show that the shock sensitivity decreases as the crystalsize is reduced down to the nano-scale, meaning that long-pulse shock sensitivity can be tuned by changing the particlesize. Similarly, Stepanov and Qiu also found that the RDX-based nanocomposites exhibited lower shock sensitivity,which is attributed to small crystal size as well as small voidsize. [87,88] Additionally, Wang and his coworkers developeda novel technique to prepare the ellipsoidal HNS nanocrystalswith high specific surface and narrow particle size distribution[58]. The obtained HNS samples were subjected to small scalegap test, and the results indicate that crystalline HNS nano-particles are less sensitive to shock stimuli than micro-sizedHNS (50 mm).
73B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
It is worth noting that a completely opposite result can beobtained if the test of shock sensitivity is carried out under theslapper initiation stimuli. Gifford and coworkers studied thebehavior of short duration shock of PETN with different sizesand found that there were no changes when PETN micropar-ticles were initiated using laser-driven flyer though somelimited reaction. In contrast the ultrafine PETN particle wasreadily initiated at flyer velocities of around 5 mm ms�1 [196].Wang et al. also reported that the ultrafine HNS is more sen-sitive to short duration shock wave than its conventionalcounterpart [74]. These studies show that the initiation formplays an important role in determining test results of small-sized explosives. For the small scale gap test, its shock waveis low pressure-long pulse, and the relative shock sensitivity iscontrolled by ignition process [197], but oppositely, the shockwave is high pressure-burst pulse and the sensitivity iscontrolled by detonation buildup for the slapper initiation test[198].
3.3. Improved combustion and detonation performance
Nano-scaled energetic materials have attracted wide in-terest by virtue of their unusual combustion and detonationperformance. Therefore, there have been a number ofexperimental and theoretical studies on these properties ofnano-energetic materials and nanocomposite propellants[199,200]. Pivkina’s work shows that there was a significantdifference in burning rate of pure RDX nanopowders incomparison to micron-sized component [166]. As shown inFig. 17, a monopropellant of RDX nanoparticles with thesize of about 50 nm, prepared by a vacuum condensationtechnique, exhibits burning rate twice greater than conven-tional powder at an elevated pressure of 10 MPa, indicatingthat the size has considerably important influence on themechanism of RDX combustion. Muravyev and coworkersalso investigated the combustion parameters of HMX as amonopropellant [201]. It was shown that although combus-tion velocity is almost same for micro-HMX and ultrafineHMX, the combustion of the ultrafine HMX is more com-plete than that of micro-HMX. To fulfill the control of thecombustion performance of high explosives, the solidifica-tion of energetic phases in a porous matrix (Cr2O3) is used tofabricate and stabilize the nano-scale explosive particles(RDX) [151]. The studies show that the combustion rate isremarkably increased by decreasing the size of the reactants,and the highest rates can be obtained with the mixtures inwhich each reactant is structured at nano-scale.
Additionally, Wang et al. tested the detonation performanceof each formulation by probe method and found that thedetonation velocity of superfine explosives (HMX and RDX)is obvious higher than that of the coarse particles [57]. This isprobably because the superfine particles with high specificsurface area can burn faster than the conventional counterpartand hence more energy is transferred to the detonation reac-tion zone. Gogulya’s group achieved the similar result whenthey used a pulverization drying method to synthesize theultrafine HMX particles [202].
3.4. Unique compaction behavior
In addition to the properties mentioned above, thecompaction behavior of small-sized energetic materials hasalso been reported in the past few years. For example, Loweet al. investigated the relationship between particle size andcompaction behavior of granular bed [203,204]. Theydesigned a modeling and experimental method to study thecompaction behaviors of two types of granular HMX: coarseHMX (mean diameter of 40 mm) and microfine HMX (meandiameter of less than 5 mm). The results show that the granularbed of the microfine HMX with the particulate structure ismore strength than the coarse bed. Agarwal and coworkersprepared fine TATB particles (2�5 mm) with the assistance ofreprecipitation and found that its mechanical strength/com-pressed strength was significantly improved in comparison tocoarse TATB (55 mm) alone in plastic bonded explosive (PBX)formulations [47].
4. Conclusions and future perspective
In this paper, a review of recent research on controllablepreparation of micro/nano-energetic materials with specialstructures and sizes was presented. We introduced variousadvanced strategies for the construction of structure- and size-controlled micro/nano-energetic materials. Besides the prep-aration of 0D energetic nanoparticles, we focused on theconstruction of 1D twinned nanobelts, 2D nanosheets andbanana-like nanoleaves, 3D nanogrids, dendritic micro/nano-structures and hierarchical microspheres. The structures andsizes of energetic materials are easily controlled by means ofmolecular design and synthetic strategies. More emphasis isplaced on the unique properties of structure- and size-controlled micro/nano-energetic materials. The size-dependent thermal properties of several kinds of high-energyexplosives are first introduced, and then the sensitive proper-ties, such as impact sensitivity, friction sensitivity, shocksensitivity, and electrostatic spark sensitivity, are reviewed,and finally the combustion, detonation, and compaction be-haviors are also briefly presented.
Currently, the research on micro/nanomaterials based onenergetic compounds is still in its infancy, and there is a lot ofwork to do in this area. In our opinion, several research di-rections should be paid more attention in the future. Firstly, itis still necessary to develop the methods for the design andcontrollable construction of micro/nano-energetic materialswith large scale, special dimensions, desired structures andsizes [190,205e207], although some progress has been madeto date. At the same time, the development of better charac-terization methods is equally important to further understandthe nature of the nano-energetic materials at the molecularlevel. Secondly, we think that the systematic study, especiallyfor relationship between detailed structures/shapes and variousfundamental properties, should be carried out [169]. Thirdly, itis necessary to explore and improve the stability, safety andreliability of micro/nano-energetic materials [208,209]. Inaddition, as to the great potential application of micro/nano-
74 B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
energetic materials, the micro-electromechanical systems(MEMS) has proved to be a promising direction for micro/nano-scale energetic materials with specific structures [210],and the fabrication of thin films and patterns composing of thenanostructured building blocks on solid substrates, such asglass, ceramic, and crystalline silicon, is essential for therealization of practical devices [211e214].
Acknowledgment
This work was supported by National Natural ScienceFoundation of China (21231002, 21276026, 21271023,21173021, 91022006, 11202193, 11172276, and 11072225),the 111 Project (B07012), the Program of Cooperation of theBeijing Education Commission (20091739006), and Special-ized Research Fund for the Doctoral Program of Higher Ed-ucation (SRFDP, 20101101110031).
References
[1] Jenekhe SA, Chen XL. Self-assembly of ordered microporous materials
from rod-coil block copolymers. Science 1998;279:1903e8.
[2] Whitesides GM, Grzybowski B. Self-assembly at all scales. Science
2002;295:2418e21.
[3] Tian ZR, Voigt JA, Liu J, Mckenzie B, Mcdermott MJ, Rodriguez MA,
et al. Complex and oriented ZnO nanostructures. Nat Mater
2003;2:821e6.
[4] Park S, Lim JH, Chung SW, Mirkin CA. Self-assembly of mesoscopic
metal-polymer amphiphiles. Science 2004;303:348e51.
[5] Colfen H, Mann S. Higher-order organization by mesoscale self-
assembly and transformation of hybrid nanostructures. Angew Chem
Int Ed 2003;42(21):2350e65.
[6] Yamamoto Y, Fukushima T, Suna Y, Ishii N, Saeki A, Seki S, et al.
Photoconductive coaxial nanotubes of molecularly connected electron
donor and acceptor layers. Science 2006;314:1761e4.
[7] Fardy M, Yang PD. Materials science: lilliputian light sticks. Nature
2008;451:408e9.
[8] Heo JS, Park NH, Ryu JH, Suh KD. Novel light-emitting diodes using
organic electroluminescent nanocapsules. Adv Mater 2005;17(7):822e6.
[9] Schwab AD, Smith DE, Bond-Watts B, Johnston DE, Hone J,
Johnson AT, et al. Photoconductivity of self-assembled porphyrin
nanorods. Nano Lett 2004;4(7):1261e5.
[10] Zhang YX, Liu DB, Lv CX. Preparation and characterization of retic-
ular nano-HMX. Propellants Explos Pyrotech 2005;30(6):438e41.
[11] Gagliardi FJ, Chambers RD, Tran TD. Small-scale performance testing
for studying new explosives. In: 6th VACENT technical international
conference, Milpitas, CA, United States June 4, 2005.
UCRLeCONFe212196.[12] Saw CK. Kinetics of HMX and phase transitions: effects of grain size
at elevated temperature. In: Proceedings of the 12th international
detonation symposium, San Diego, CA August 11–16, 2002.
UCRLeJCe145228.[13] Gash A, Barbee T, Cervantes O. Stab sensitivity of energetic nano-
laminates. In: 33rd international pyrotechnic seminar, Fort Collins, Co,
United States July 16e21, 2006. UCRLePROCe221604.
[14] Khasainov BA, Ermolaev BS, Presles HN, Vidal P. On the effect of
grain size on shock sensitivity of heterogeneous high explosives. Shock
Waves 1997;7:89e105.
[15] Manaa MR, Reed EJ, Fried LE, Goldman N. Nitrogen-rich heterocycles
as reactivity retardants in shocked insensitive explosives. J Am Chem
Soc 2009;131(15):5483e7.
[16] Zhang CY, Wang XC, Huang H. p-stacked interactions in explosive
crystals: buffers against external mechanical stimuli. J Am Chem Soc
2008;130(26):8359e65.
[17] Gokcınar E, Klapotke TM, Bellamy AJ. Computational study on 2,6-
diamino-3,5-dinitropyrazine and its 1-oxide and 1,4-dioxide de-
rivatives. J Mol Struct Theochem 2010;953(1e3):18e23.
[18] Kaur J, Arya VP, Kaur G, Gupta YP, Verma MM, Lata P. Determination
of solvent contamination and characterization of ultrafine HNS particles
after solvent recrystallization. Propellants Explos Pyrotech
2010;35(5):487e93.
[19] Prourmortazavi SM, Hajimirsadeghi SS. Application of supercritical
carbon dioxide in energetic materials processes: a review. Ind Eng
Chem Res 2005;44(17):6523e33.
[20] Matsunaga T, Chernyshev AV, Chesnokov EN, Krasnoperov LN. In situ
optical monitoring of RDX nanoparticles formation during rapid
expansion of supercritical CO2 solutions. Phys Chem Chem Phys
2007;9:5249e59.
[21] Frolov Y, Pivkina A, Ulyanova P, Zavyalov S. Nanomaterials and
nanostructures as components for high-energy condensed Systems. In:
Proceedings of 28th international pyrotechnic seminar, Adelaide,
Australia November 4e9, 2001. p. 311e4.
[22] Gong XC, Milic T, Xu C, Batteas JD, Drain CM. Preparation and
characterization of porphyrin nanoparticles. J Am Chem Soc
2002;124(48):14290e1.
[23] Kasai H, Kamatani H, Okada S, Oikawa H, Matsuda H, Nakanishi H.
Size-dependent colors and luminescences of organic microcrystals. Jpn
J Appl Phys 1996;35:L221e3.
[24] Li SY, He LM, Xiong F, Li Y, Yang GQ. Enhanced fluorescent emission
of organic nanoparticles of an intramolecular proton transfer compound
and spontaneous formation of one-dimensional nanostructures. J Phys
Chem B 2004;108(30):10887e92.
[25] Hu JS, Guo YG, Liang HP, Wan LJ, Jiang L. Three-dimensional self-
organization of supramolecular self-assembled porphyrin hollow hex-
agonal nanoprisms. J Am Chem Soc 2005;127(48):17090e5.
[26] Zhang XJ, Zhang XH, Shi WS, Meng XM, Lee CS, Lee ST. Single-
crystal organic microtubes with a rectangular cross section. Angew
Chem Int Ed 2007;46(9):1525e8.[27] Chaudhuri D, Li DB, Che YK, Shafran E, Gerton JM, Zang L, et al.
Enhancing long-range exciton guiding in molecular nanowires by H-
aggregation lifetime engineering. Nano Lett 2011;11(2):488e92.
[28] Chiu JJ, Kei CC, Perng TP, Wang WS. Organic semiconductor nano-
wires for field emission. Adv Mater 2003;15(16):1361e4.
[29] Al-Kaysi RO, Bardeen CJ. General method for the synthesis of crys-
talline organic nanorods using porous alumina templates. Chem Com-
mun 2006:1224e6.[30] Zhao YS, Fu HB, Peng AD, Ma Y, Liao Q, Yao JN. Construction and
optoelectronic properties of organic one-dimensional nanostructures.
Acc Chem Res 2010;43(3):409e18.[31] Cui QH, Jiang L, Zhang C, Zhao YS, Hu WP, Yao JN. Coaxial organic
p-n heterojunction nanowire arrays: one-step synthesis and photoelec-
tric properties. Adv Mater 2012;24(17):2332e6.
[32] Zhang XJ, Zhang XH, Zou K, Lee CS, Lee ST. Single-crystal nano-
ribbons, nanotubes, and nanowires from intramolecular charge-transfer
organic molecules. J Am Chem Soc 2007;129(12):3527e32.
[33] Zhang CY, Zhang XJ, Zhang XH, Fan X, Jie JS, Chang JC, et al.
Facile one-step growth and patterning of aligned squaraine nano-
wires via evaporation-induced self-assembly. Adv Mater
2008;20(9):1716e20.
[34] Kim JW, Kim JK, Kim HS, Koo KK. Application of internal
seeding and temperature cycling for reduction of liquid inclusion in
the crystallization of RDX. Org Process Res Dev 2011;15(3):602e9.
[35] Han TYJ, Pagoria PF, Gash AE, Maiti A, Orme CA, Mitchell AR, et al.
The solubility and recrystallization of 1,3,5-triamino-2,4,6-
trinitrobenzene in a 3-ethyl-1-methylimidazolium acetateeDMSO co-
solvent system. New J Chem 2009;33:50e6.
[36] Daniel MA, Davies PJ, Lochert IJ. FOX-7 for insensitive boosters.
Weapons Systems Division Defence Science and Technology Organi-
sation; August, 2010. DSTOeTRe2449.
[37] vander Heijden AEDM, Bouma RHB, vander Steen AC. Physico-
chemical parameters of nitramines influencing shock sensitivity. Pro-
pellants Explos Pyrotech 2004;29(5):304e13.
75B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
[38] Vijayalakshmi R, Radhakrishnan S, Rajendra PS, Girish GM, Arun SK.
Particle size management studies on spherical 3-nitro-1,2,4-triazol-5-
one. Part Part Syst Charact 2012;28(3e4):57e63.
[39] Kim KJ, Kim KM. Growth kinetics in seeded cooling crystallization of
3-nitro-1,2,4-triazol-5-one in watereN-methylpyrrolidone. Powder
Technol 2002;122(1):46e53.
[40] Kim KJ, Kim KM. Nucleation kinetics in spherulitic crystallization of
explosive compound: 3-nitro-1,2,4-triazol-5-one. [J] Powder Technol
2001;119(2e3):109e16.
[41] Kim KJ. Spherulitic crystallization of 3-nitro-1,2,4-triazol-5-one in
water þ N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone. J Cryst Growth 2000;208:569e78.
[42] Kim KJ, Kim KM, Lee JM, Kim HS, Park BS, Lee JW. Scale-up of
crystallizer for producing spherical crystals of NTO. In: 31st interna-
tional annual conference of ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of Ger-
many June 27e30, 2000. p. 121/1–5.
[43] Kim KJ, Lee JM, Kim HS, Park BS. Seeded batch cooling crystalli-
zation of 3-nitro-1,2,4-triazol-5-one. In: 32nd international annual
conference of ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of Germany July 3e6,
2001. p. 125/1–7.
[44] Jung JW, Kim KJ. Effect of supersaturation on the morphology of
coated surface in coating by solution crystallization. Ind Eng Chem Res
2011;50(6):3475e82.
[45] Kim KJ, Kim HS. Agglomeration of NTO on the surface of HMX
particles in watereNMP solvent. Cryst Res Technol 2008;43(1):87e92.
[46] Nalwa HS, Kasai H, Kamatani H, Okada S, Oikawa H, Matsuda H, et al.
Fabrication of organic nanocrystals for electronics and photonics. Adv
Mater 1993;5(10):758e60.[47] Talawar MB, Agarwal AP, Anniyappan M, Gore GM, Asthana SN,
Venugopalan S. Method for preparation of fine TATB (2e5 mm) and its
evaluation in plastic bonded explosive (PBX) formulations. J Hazard
Mater 2006;137(3):1848e52.
[48] Nandi AK, Kasar SM, Thanigaivelan U, Ghosh M, Mandal AK,
Bhattacharyya SC. Synthesis and characterization of ultrafine TATB. J
Energ Mater 2007;25(4):213e31.[49] Yang L, Ren XT, Li TC, Wang SW, Zhang TL. Preparation of ultrafine
TATB and the technology for crystal morphology control. Chin J Chem
2012;30(2):293e8.
[50] Xu JJ, Tian Y, Liu Y, Zhang HB, Shu YJ, Sun J. Polymorphism in
hexanitrohexaazaisowurtzitane crystallized from solution. J Cryst
Growth 2012;354(1):13e9.
[51] Wang Y, Song XL, Song D, Jiang W, Liu HY, Li FS. Dependence of the
mechanical sensitivity on the fractal characteristics of octahydro-
1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocine particles. Propellants Explos
Pyrotech 2011;36(6):505e12.
[52] Song XL, Wang Y, An CW, Guo XD, Li FS. Dependence of particle
morphology and size on the mechanical sensitivity and thermal stability
of octahydro-1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocine. J Hazard Mater
2008;159(2e3):222e9.
[53] Lee KY, Moore DS, Asay BW, Llobet A. Submicron-sized gamma-
HMX: 1. Preparation and initial characterization. J Energ Mater
2007;25(3):161e71.
[54] Moore DS, Lee KY, Hagelberg SI. Submicron-sized gamma-HMX: II.
Effect of pressing on phase transition. J Energ Mater 2008;26(1):70e8.[55] Chen J, Qiao ZQ, Wang LL, Nie FD, Yang GC, Huang H. Fabrication of
rectangular 2,6-diamino-3,5-dinitropyrazine-1-oxide microtubes. Mater
Lett 2011;65(6):1018e21.[56] Qiao ZQ, Tang YP, Zeng GY. Study of preparation of different crystal
shape fine particle size RDX. Chin J Energ Mater 2004;12:116e8.
[57] Zhang SH, Zhang JL, Wang JY. Preparation and properties of sub-
micron nitramine explosives. In: 35th international annual conference
of ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of Germany June 29eJuly 2, 2004.
p. 100/1e4.
[58] Wang JY, Huang H, Xu WZ, Zhang YR, Lu B, Xie RZ, et al. Prefilming
twin-fluid nozzle assisted precipitation method for preparing nano-
crystalline HNS and its characterization. J Hazard Mater
2009;162(2e3):842e7.
[59] Huang H, Wang JY, Xu WZ, Xie RZ. Effect of habit modifiers on
morphology and properties of nano-HNS explosive in prefilming twin-
fluid nozzle-assisted precipitation. Propellants Explos Pyrotech
2009;34(1):78e83.
[60] Yang GC, Nie FD, Huang H, Zhao L, Pang WT. Preparation and
characterization of nano-TATB explosive. Propellants Explos Pyrotech
2006;31(5):390e4.[61] Nie FD, Yang GC, Zeng GY, Qiao ZQ, Huang H. Preparation and
properties of ultrafine TATB particles. In: 10th international semi-
nardnew trends in research of energetic materials, Pardubice, Czech
Republic April 25e27, 2007. p. 452e7.
[62] Bayat Y, Eghdamtalab M, Zeynali V. Control of the particle size of
submicron HMX explosive by spraying in non-solvent. J Energ Mater
2010;28(4):273e84.[63] Shokrolahi A, Zali A, Mousaviazar A, Keshavarz MH,
Hajhashemi H. Preparation of nano-K-6 (nano-Keto RDX) and
determination of its characterization and thermolysis. J Energ Mater
2011;29(2):115e26.[64] Teipel U, Mikonsaari I. Size reduction of particulate energetic material.
Propellants Explos Pyrotech 2002;27(3):168e74.
[65] Patil MN, Gore GM, Pandit AB. Ultrasonically controlled particle size
distribution of explosives: a safe method. Ultrason Sonochem
2008;15(3):177e87.
[66] Koo KJ, Kim KM, Lee JM. Microparticle formation of 1,3,5,7-tetranitro-
1,3,5,7-tetraazacyclooctane by crystallizations with ultrasound. In: 32nd
international annual conference of ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of
Germany July 3e6, 2001. p. 124/1–5.
[67] Sivabalan R, Gore GM, Nair UR, Saikia A, Venugopalan S, Gandhe BR.
Study on ultrasound assisted precipitation of CL-20 and its effect on
morphology and sensitivity. J Hazard Mater 2007;139(2):199e203.
[68] Bayat Y, Zeynali V. Preparation and characterization of nano-CL-20
explosive. J Energ Mater 2011;29(4):281e91.[69] Wang JY, Li JL, An CW, Hou CH, Xu WZ, Li XD. Study on ultrasound-
and spray-assisted precipitation of CL-20. Propellants Explos Pyrotech
2012;37(6):670e5.
[70] Ma CA, Sheng JF, Brandon N, Zhang C, Li GH. Preparation of tungsten
carbide-supported nano platinum catalyst and its electrocatalytic ac-
tivity for hydrogen evolution. Int J Hydrog Energy
2007;32(14):2824e9.
[71] Anal AK, Stevens WF, Remunan-Lopez C. Ionotropic cross-linked
chitosan microspheres for controlled release of ampicillin. Int J
Pharm 2006;312(1e2):166e73.
[72] Freitas C, Muller RH. Spray-drying of solid lipid nanoparticles
(SLNTM). Eur J Pharm Biopharm 1998;46(2):145e51.
[73] Mercado L, Torres PM, Gomez LM, Mina N, Hernandez SP, Lareau R,
et al. Synthesis and characterization of high-energy nanoparticles. J
Phys Chem B 2004;108(33):12314e7.[74] Wang JY, Huang H, Jiao QJ, Lei L, Hua J, Yun N, et al. Modification of
ultrafine HNS explosive by spray drying process. In: 40th international
annual conference of ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of Germany
June 23e26, 2009. p. 59/1–12.[75] Qiu HW, Stepanov V, Chou T, Surapaneni A, Di Stasio AR, Lee WY.
Single-step production and formulation of HMX nanocrystals. Powder
Technol 2012;226:235e8.
[76] Zhigach AN, Leipunskii IO, Berezkina NG, Pshechenkov PA,
Zotova ES, Kudrov BV, et al. Aluminized nitramine-based nano-
composites: manufacturing technique and structure study. Combust
Explo Shock Waves 2009;45(6):666e77.[77] Yang GC, Nie FD. Preparation and characterization of core/shell
structure of HMX/NTO composite particles. Sci Tech Energ Mater
2006;67(2):77e81.
[78] Yang GC, Nie FD, Zeng GY. Preparation of fine TATB-BTF core-shell
composite particles. Chin J Explos Propellants 2005;28(2):72e4.
[79] Jaworek A. Micro- and nanoparticle production by electrospraying.
Powder Technol 2007;176(1):18e35.
[80] Taylor GI. Disintegration of water drops in an electric field. Proc R Soc
Lond Ser A 1964;280(1382):383e97.
[81] Radacsi N, Stankiewicz AI, Creyghton YLM, van der Heijden AEDM,
ter Horst JH. Electrospray crystallization for high-quality submicron-
sized crystals. Chem Eng Technol 2011;34(4):624e30.
76 B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
[82] Reus M, Stankiewicz A, ter Horst J, van der Heijden A. Electrospray
crystallization of encapsulated sub-micro particles of energetic mate-
rials. In: 43rd international annual conference of the Fraunhofer ICT,
Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of Germany June 23e29, 2012. p. 37/1–12.
[83] Bang JH, Suslick KS. Applications of ultrasound to the synthesis of
nanostructured materials. Adv Mater 2010;22(10):1039e59.
[84] Spitzer D, Baras C, Schafer MR, Ciszek F, Siegert B. Continuous
crystallization of submicrometer energetic compounds. Propellants
Explos Pyrotech 2011;36(1):65e74.
[85] Spitzer D, Baras C, Ciszek F, Schafer MR. Continuous crystallization of
submicron energetic compounds. In: 37th international annual confer-
ence of ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of Germany June 27e30,2006. p. 144/1e13.
[86] Stepanov V, Qiu HW, Di Stasio AR, Lee WY. Preparation and prop-
erties of nanostructured RDX/polymer compositions. In: 41st interna-
tional annual conference of ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of
Germany June 29eJuly 2, 2010. p. 26/1–6.
[87] Stepanov V, Qiu HW, Surapaneni A. Production and characterization of
novel energetic compositions by spray drying. In: 43rd international
annual conference of the Fraunhofer ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic
of Germany June 23e29, 2012. p. 38/1e6.
[88] Qiu HW, Stepanov V, Di Stasio AR, Chou T, Lee WY. RDX-based
nanocomposite microparticles for significantly reduced shock sensi-
tivity. J Hazard Mater 2011;185(1):489e93.
[89] Kim JW, Shin MS, Kim JK, Kim HS, Koo KK. Evaporation crystalli-
zation of RDX by ultrasonic spray. Ind Eng Chem Res
2011;50(21):12186e93.[90] Kim JK, Jo CH, Kim JW, Kim HS, Koo KK. Preparation of RDX
particles by ultrasonic atomization. In: 13th international seminardnew
trends in research of energetic materials, Pardubice, Czech Republic
April 21e23, 2010. p. 513e7.
[91] Maa YF, Nguyen PA, Sweeney T, Shire SJ, Hsu CC. Protein inhalation
powders: spray drying vs spray freeze drying. Pharm Res
1999;16(2):249e54.[92] Kaluza S, Muhler M. On the precipitation mechanism and the role of
the post-precipitation steps during the synthesis of binary ZnOeAl2O3
composites with high specific surface area. J Mater Chem
2009;19:3914e22.[93] Engstrom JD, Simpson DT, Lai ES, Williams III RO, Johnston KP.
Morphology of protein particles produced by spray freezing of
concentrated solutions. Eur J Pharm Biopharm 2007;65(2):149e62.
[94] McGrath PJ, Laine RM. Theoretical process development for freeze-
drying spray-frozen aerosols. J Am Ceram Soc 1992;75(5):1223e8.
[95] Rigterink MD. Advances in technology of the cryochemical process.
Am Ceram Soc Bull 1972;51(2):158e61.[96] Yang GC, Nie FD, Li JS, Guo QX, Qiao ZQ. Preparation and charac-
terization of nano-NTO explosive. J Energ Mater 2007;25(1):35e47.
[97] Huang B, Qiao ZQ, Nie FD, Cao MH, Su J, Huang H, et al. Fabrication
of FOX-7 quasi-three-dimensional grids of one-dimensional nano-
structures via a spray freeze-drying technique and size-dependence of
thermal properties. J Hazard Mater 2010;184(1e3):561e6.
[98] Morel A, Nikitenko SI, Gionnet K, Wattiaux A, Lai-Kee-Him J,
Labrugere C, et al. Sonochemical approach to the synthesis of
Fe3O4@SiO2 core-shell nanoparticles with tunable properties. ACS
Nano 2008;2(5):847e56.
[99] Yi DK, Lee SS, Papaefthymiou GC, Ying JY. Nanoparticle architectures
templated by SiO2/Fe2O3 nanocomposites. Chem Mater
2006;18(3):614e9.
[100] Scheubert U, Husing N, Lorenz A. Hybrid inorganic-organic materials
by sol-gel processing of organofunctional metal alkoxides. Chem Mater
1995;7(11):2010e27.
[101] Tillotson TM, Gash AE, Simpson RL, Hrubesh LW, Satcher Jr JH,
Poco JF. Nanostructured energetic materials using sol-gel methodolo-
gies. J Non-Cryst Solids 2001;285(1e3):338e45.[102] Tappan BC, Brill TB. Very sensitive energetic materials highly loaded
into RF matrices by the sol-gel method. In: 33rd international annual
conference of ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of Germany June
25e28, 2002. p. 38/1e10.
[103] Tappan BC, Brill TB. Thermal decomposition of energetic materials 85:
cryogels of nanoscale hydrazinium diperchlorate in resorcinol-formal-
dehyde. Propellants Explos Pyrotech 2003;28(2):72e6.
[104] Clapsaddle BJ, Zhao LH, Prentice D, Pantoya ML, Gash AE,
Satcher Jr JH, et al. Formulation and performance of novel energetic
nanocomposites and gas generators prepared by sol-gel methods. In:
36th international annual conference of ICT & 32nd international py-
rotechnics seminar, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of Germany June
28eJuly 1, 2005. p. 39/1–11.
[105] Tillotson TM, Hrubesh LW, Simpson RL, Lee RS, Swansiger RW,
Simpson LR. Sol-gel processing of energetic materials. J Non-Cryst
Solids 1998;225:358e63.[106] Tappan BC, Brill TB. Thermal decomposition of energetic materials 86.
Cryogel synthesis of nanocrystalline CL-20 coated with cured nitro-
cellulose. Propellants Explos Pyrotech 2003;28(5):223e30.
[107] Li J, Brill TB. Nanostructured energetic composites of CL-20 and
binders synthesized by sol gel methods. Propellants Explos Pyrotech
2006;31(1):61e9.
[108] Tappan BC, Brill TB. Cryogel synthesis of nanocrystalline CL-20
coated with cured nitrocellulose. In: 34th international annual confer-
ence of ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of Germany June 24e27,
2003. p. 29/1e10.
[109] Ingale SV, Sastry PU, Patra AK, Tewari R, Wagh PB, Gupta SC. Micro
structural investigations on TNT and PETN incorporated silica xerogels.
J Sol-Gel Sci Technol 2010;54(2):238e42.
[110] Ingale SV, Wagh PB, Sastry PU, Patra AK, Tewari R, Singh IK, et al.
Nanocrystalline pentaerythritoltetranitrate using sol-gel process.
Defence Sci J 2011;61(6):534e9.
[111] Nie FD, Zhang J, Guo QX, Qiao ZQ, Zeng GY. Sol-gel synthesis of
nanocomposite crystalline HMX/AP coated by resorci-
noleformaldehyde. J Phys Chem Solids 2010;71(2):109e13.
[112] Zhang J, Yang GC, Nie FD. Preparation of RDX/RF nanocomposite
energetic particles by emulsion-sol-gel technique. Chin J Energ Mater
2010;18(6):643e7.[113] Chen RJ, Luo YJ, Sun J, Li GP. Preparation and properties of an AP/
RDX/SiO2 nanocomposite energetic material by the sol-gel method.
Propellants Explos Pyrotech 2012;37(4):422e6.
[114] Pourmortazavi SM, Sefidkon F, Hosseini SG. Supercritical carbon di-
oxide extraction of essential oils from Perovskia atriplicifolia benth. J
Agric Food Chem 2003;51(18):5414e9.
[115] Pourmortazavi SM, Ghadiri M, Hajimirsadeghi SS. Supercritical fluid
extraction of volatile components from Bunium persicum Boiss. (black
cumin) and Mespilus germanica L. (medlar) seeds. J Food Compos
Anal 2005;18(5):439e46.
[116] Pourmortazavi SM, Baghaee P, Mirhosseini MA. Extraction of volatile
compounds from Juniperus communis L. leaves with supercritical fiuid
carbon dioxide: comparison with hydrodistillation. Flavour Fragrane J
2004;19(5):417e20.
[117] Miranda S, Yaeger S. Homing on the best size reduction method. Chem
Eng 1998;105(12):102e10.
[118] Svensson L, Nyqvist JO, Westling L. Crystallization of HMX from g-
butyrolactone. J Hazard Mater 1986;13(1):103e8.
[119] Teipel U, Forter-Barth U, Krause HH. Crystallization of HMX-particles
by using the gas anti-solvent-process. Propellants Explos Pyrotech
1999;24(3):195e8.
[120] Morris JB. Solubility of RDX in dense carbon dioxide at tempera-
tures between 303 K and 353 K. J Chem Eng Data
1998;43(2):269e73.
[121] Krober H, Reinhard W, Teipel U. Supercritical fluid technology: a new
process on formation of energetic materials. In: 32nd international
annual conference of ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of Germany July
3e6, 2001. p. 48/1e13.
[122] Lee BM, Kim DS, Lee YH, Lee BC, Kim HS, Kim H, et al. Preparation
of submicron-sized RDX particles by rapid expansion of solution using
compressed liquid dimethyl ether. J Supercrit Fluids 2011;57(3):251e8.
[123] Stepanov V, Krasnoperov LN, Elkina IB, Zhang X. Production of
nanocrystalline RDX by rapid expansion of supercritical solutions.
Propellants Explos Pyrotech 2005;30(3):178e83.
77B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
[124] Stepanov V, Samuels P, Elkina IB, Zhang X, Lavrik NL,
Krasnoperov LN. Recrystallization of RDX by rapid expansion of su-
percritical solutions (RESS). In: 36th international annual conference of
ICT & 32nd international pyrotechnics seminar, Karlsruhe, Federal
Republic of Germany June 28eJuly 1, 2005. p. 189/1e8.[125] Stepanov V, Anglade V, Balas W, Bezmelnitsyn A, Krasnoperov LN.
Processing and characterization of nanocrystalline RDX. In: 39th in-
ternational annual conference of ICT, Karlsruhe, Karlsruhe, Federal
Republic of Germany June 24e27, 2008. p. 54/1e15.
[126] Stepanov V, Anglade V, Balas Hummers WA, Bezmelnitsyn AV,
Krasnoperov LN. Production and sensitivity evaluation of nano-
crystalline RDX-based explosive compositions. Propellants Explos
Pyrotech 2011;36(3):240e6.
[127] Muller M, Meier U, Kesseler A, Mazzotti M. Experimental study of the
effect of process parameters in the recrystallization of an organic
compound using compressed carbon dioxide as antisolvent. Ind Eng
Chem Res 2000;39(7):2260e8.
[128] Lee BM, Jeong JS, Lee YH, Lee BC, Kim HS, Kim H, et al. Supercritical
antisolvent micronization of cyclotrimethylenetrinitramin: influence of
the organic solvent. Ind Eng Chem Res 2009;48(24):11162e7.
[129] Lee BM, Kim SJ, Lee BC, Kim HS, Kim H, Lee YW. Preparation of
micronized b-HMX using supercritical carbon dioxide as antisolvent.
Ind Eng Chem Res 2011;50(15):9107e15.[130] Kim SJ, Lee BM, Lee BC, Kim HS, Kim H, Lee YW. Recrystallization
of cyclotetramethylenetetranitramine (HMX) using gas anti-solvent
(GAS) process. J Supercrit Fluids 2011;59:108e16.
[131] Dou H, Kim KH, Lee BC, Choe J, Kim HS, Lee S. Preparation and
characterization of cyclo-1,3,5-trimethylene-2,4,6-trinitramine (RDX)
powder: comparison of microscopy, dynamic light scattering and field-
flow fractionation for size characterization. Powder Technol
2013;235:814e22.
[132] Dou H, Kim KH, Kim ST, Lee BC, Kim HS, Jung EC, et al. Asym-
metrical flow field-flow fractionation for characterization of cyclotri-
methylene trinitramine (RDX) particles prepared by supercritical anti-
solvent recrystallization. Chromatographia 2012;75(15e16):903e11.
[133] Kim CK, Lee BC, Lee YW, Lee YW, Kim HS. Solvent effect on particle
morphology in recrystallization of HMX (cyclo-
tetramethylenetetranitramine) using supercritical carbon dioxide as
antisolvent. Korean J Chem Eng 2009;26(4):1125e9.
[134] Bayat Y, Pourmortazavi SM, Iravani H, Ahadi H. Statistical optimiza-
tion of supercritical carbon dioxide antisolvent process for preparation
of HMX nanoparticles. J Supercrit Fluids 2012;72:248e54.[135] Al-Kaysi RO, Muller AM, Bardeen CJ. Photochemically driven shape
changes of crystalline organic nanorods. J Am Chem Soc
2006;128(50):15938e9.[136] Wang KX, Zhang WH, Phelan R, Morris MA, Holmes JD. Direct
fabrication of well-aligned free-standing mesoporous carbon nano-
fiber arrays on silicon substrates. J Am Chem Soc 2007;129(44):
13388e9.
[137] Shi YF, Wan Y, Liu RL, Tu B, Zhao DY. Synthesis of highly ordered
mesoporous crystalline WS2 and MoS2 via a high-temperature reductive
sulfuration route. J Am Chem Soc 2007;129(30):9522e31.
[138] Yu AM, Meiser F, Cassagneau T, Caruso F. Fabrication of polymer-
�nanoparticle composite inverse opals by a one-step electrochemical
co-deposition process. Nano Lett 2004;4(1):177e81.
[139] Murakami H, Kobayashi M, Takeuchi H, Kawashima Y. Preparation of
poly(DL-lactide-co-glycolide) nanoparticles by modified spontaneous
emulsification solvent diffusionmethod. Int J Pharm 1999;187(2):143e52.
[140] Kim TW, Park IS, Ryoo R. A synthetic route to ordered mesoporous
carbon materials with graphitic pore walls. Angew Chem Int Ed
2003;42(36):4375e9.
[141] Berry AD, Tonucci RJ, Fatemi M. Fabrication of GaAs and InAs wires
in nanochannel glass. Appl Phys Lett 1996;69(19):2846e8.
[142] Jiang P, Bertone JF, Colvin VL. A lost-wax approach to monodisperse
colloids and their crystals. Science 2001;291:453e7.
[143] Chakarvarti SK, Vetter J. Template synthesisda membrane based
technology for generation of nano-/micro materials: a review. Radiat
Meas 1998;29(2):149e59.
[144] Smeu M, Zahid F, Ji W, Guo H, Jaidann M, Abou-Rachid H. En-
ergetic molecules encapsulated inside carbon nanotubes and between
graphene layers: DFT calculations. J Phys Chem C
2011;115(22):10985e9.
[145] Guo R, Hu Y, Shen RQ, Ye YH, Wu LZ. A micro initiator realized by
integrating KNO3@CNTs nanoenergetic materials with a Cu micro-
bridge. Chem Eng J 2012;211e212:31e6.
[146] Cai HQ, Tian L, Huang H, Li JS, Deng JG, Yang GC. The formation of
energetic composites by embedding multi-nitro organic molecules in an
ordered mesoporous carbon. Micropor Mesopor Mater
2012;163:110e4.
[147] CaiI HQ, Tian L, Huang B, Yang GC, Guan DB, Huang H. 1,1-
Diamino-2,2-dintroethene (FOX-7) nanocrystals embedded in meso-
porous carbon FDU-15. Micropor Mesopor Mater 2013;170:20e5.
[148] Cai HQ, Yang RJ, Yang GC, Huang H, Nie FD. Hosteguest energetic
nanocomposites based on self-assembly of multi-nitro organic mole-
cules in nanochannels of mesoporous materials. Nanotechnology
2011;22:305602.
[149] Majano G, Mintova S, Bein T, Klapotke TM. Confined detection of
high-energy-density materials. J Phys Chem C 2007;111(18):6694e9.
[150] Comet M, Siegert B, Pichot V, Gibot P, Spitzer D. Preparation of
explosive nanoparticles in a porous chromium(III) oxide matrix: a first
attempt to control the reactivity of explosives. Nanotechnology
2008;19:285716.
[151] Spitzer D, Comet M, Baras C, Pichot V, Piazzon N. Energetic nano-
materials: opportunities for enhanced performances. J Phys Chem
Solids 2010;71(2):100e8.[152] Cao MH, Hu CW, Wang EB. The first fluoride one-dimensional nano-
structures: microemulsion-mediated hydrothermal synthesis of BaF2whiskers. J Am Chem Soc 2003;125(37):11196e7.
[153] Wang L, Yamauchi Y. Block copolymer mediated synthesis of den-
dritic platinum nanoparticles. J Am Chem Soc 2009;131(26):9152e3.
[154] Kadam Y, Ganguly R, Kumbhakar M, Aswal VK, Hassan PA,
Bahadur P. Time dependent sphere-to-rod growth of the pluronic
micelles: investigating the role of core and corona solvation in
determining the micellar growth rate. J Phys Chem B
2009;113(51):16296e302.
[155] Fu HB, Xiao DB, Yao JN, Yang GQ. Nanofibers of 1,3-diphenyl-2-
pyrazoline induced by cetyltrimethylammonium bromide micelles.
Angew Chem Int Ed 2003;42(25):2883e6.
[156] Cady HH, Larson AC. The crystal structure of 1,3,5-triamino-2,4,6-
trinitrobenzene. Acta Crystallogr 1965;18:485e96.[157] Badgujar DM, Talawar MB, Asthana SN, Mahulikar PP. Advances in
science and technology of modern energetic materials: an overview. J
Hazard Mater 2008;151(2e3):289e305.[158] Huang B, Cao MH, Wu XL, Nie FD, Huang H, Hu CW. Twinned TATB
nanobelts: synthesis, characterization, and formation mechanism.
CrystEngComm 2011;13:6658e64.
[159] Huang B, Cao MH, Cheng BB, Sun J, Li N, Nie FD, et al. Self-as-
sembly of 2D nanosheets into 3D dendrites based on the organic small
molecule ANPZ and their size-dependent thermal properties. Cryst
Growth Des 2012;12(7):3418e25.
[160] Mandal AK, Thanigaivelan U, Pandey RK, Asthana S, Khomane RB,
Kulkarni BD. Preparation of spherical particles of 1,1-diamino-2,2-
dinitroethene (FOX-7) using a micellar nanoreactor. Org Process Res
Dev 2012;16(11):1711e6.[161] Hao YF, Meng GW, Wang ZL, Ye CH, Zhang LD. Periodically twinned
nanowires and polytypic nanobelts of ZnS: the role of mass diffusion in
vapor-liquid-solid growth. Nano Lett 2006;6(8):1650e5.
[162] Li Q, Gong XG, Wang CR, Wang J, Ip K, Hark S. Size-dependent
periodically twinned ZnSe nanowires. Adv Mater
2004;16(16):1436e40.
[163] Zhao YS, Di CA, Yang WS, Yu G, Liu YQ, Yao JN. Photoluminescence
and electroluminescence from tris(8-hydroxyquinoline)aluminum
nanowires prepared by adsorbent-assisted physical vapor deposition.
Adv Funct Mater 2006;16(15):1985e91.
[164] Frolov YV, Pivkina AN, Zav’yalov SA. Preparation of nanosized par-
ticles of energetic substances. Dokl Phys Chem 2002;383(1e3):81e3.
78 B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
[165] Frolov YV, Pivkina AN, Ulyanova PA, Zav’yalov SA. Synthesis of
energy-rich nanomaterials. Combust Explo Shock Waves
2002;38(6):709e13.
[166] Pivkina A, Ulyanova P, Frolov Y, Zavyalov S, Schoonman J. Nano-
materials for heterogeneous combustion. Propellants Explos Pyrotech
2004;29(1):39e48.
[167] Zhang GX, Weeks BL. Surface morphology of organic thin films at
various vapor flux. Appl Surf Sci 2010;256(8):2363e6.[168] Zhang GX, Weeks BL, Holtz M. Application of dynamic scaling to the
surface properties of organic thin films: energetic materials. Surf Sci
2011;605(3e4):463e7.
[169] Yang GC, Hu HL, Zhou Y, Hu YJ, Huang H, Nie FD, et al. Synthesis of
one-molecule-thick single-crystalline nanosheets of energetic material
for high-sensitive force sensor. Sci Rep 2012;2:698.
[170] Windsor E, Najarro M, Bloom A, Benner Jr B, Fletcher R, Lareau R,
et al. Application of inkjet printing technology to produce test materials
of 1,3,5-trinitro-1,3,5 triazcyclohexane for trace explosive analysis.
Anal Chem 2010;82(20):8519e24.
[171] Primera-Pedrozo OM, Pacheco-LondoNo L, Ruiz O, Ramirez M, Soto-
Feliciano YM, De La Torre-Quintana LF, et al. Characterization of
thermal inkjet technology TNT deposits by fiber optic-grazing angle
probe FTIR spectroscopy. In: Proceedings of SPIEdthe international
society for optical engineering, part II August 5, 2005. p. 543e52.[172] Ihnen AC, Fuchs BE, Petrock A, Samuels PJ, Stepanov V, Di Stasio AR,
et al. Inkjet printing of nanocomposites high-explosive materials. In:
Proceedings of the 14th international detonation symposium, Couer
d’Alene Resort, Idaho, CA April 11�16, 2010. p. 37e40.[173] Ihnen AC, Petrock AM, Chou T, Samuels PJ, Fuchs BE, Lee WY.
Crystal morphology variation in inkjet-printed organic materials. Appl
Surf Sci 2011;258(2):827e33.
[174] Ihnen AC, Petrock AM, Chou T, Fuchs BE, Lee WY. Organic nano-
composite structure tailored by controlling droplet coalescence during
inkjet printing. ACS Appl Mater Interfaces 2012;4(9):4691e9.
[175] Wrable-Rose M, Primera-Pedrozo OM, Pacheco-Londo�no LC, Her-
nandez-Rivera SP. Preparation of TNT, RDX and ammonium nitrate
standards on gold-on-silicon surfaces by thermal inkjet technology.
Sens Imaging 2010;11(4):147e69.
[176] Son JS, Park K, Han MK, Kang C, Park SG, Kim JH, et al. Large-scale
synthesis and characterization of the size-dependent thermoelectric
properties of uniformly sized bismuth nanocrystals. Angew Chem Int
Ed 2011;50(6):1363e6.
[177] Norberg NS, Arthur TS, Fredrick SJ, Prieto AL. Size-dependent
hydrogen storage properties of Mg nanocrystals prepared from solution.
J Am Chem Soc 2011;133(28):10679e81.
[178] Boddu VM, Viswanath DS, Ghosh TK, Damavarapu R. 2,4,6-Triamino-
1,3,5-trinitrobenzene (TATB) and TATB-based formulationsda review.
J Hazard Mater 2010;181(1e3):1e8.
[179] Fathollahi M, Pourmortazavi SM, Hosseini SG. Particle size effects on
thermal decomposition of energetic material. J Energ Mater
2007;26(1):52e69.
[180] Sovizi MR, Hajimirsadeghi SS, Naderizadeh B. Effect of particle size
on thermal decomposition of nitrocellulose. J Hazard Mater
2009;168(2e3):1134e9.[181] Prodan EA. Localization phenomena of topochemical reactions. J
Therm Anal 1984;29(5):941e8.
[182] Fathollahi M, Mohammadi B, Mohammadi J. Kinetic investigation on
thermal decomposition of hexahydro-1,3,5-trinitro-1,3,5-triazine (RDX)
nanoparticles. Fuel 2013;104:95e100.
[183] Gromov A, Strokova Y, Kabardin A, Vorozhtsov A, Teipel U. Experi-
mental study of the effect of metal nanopowders on the decomposition
of HMX, AP and AN. Propellants Explos Pyrotech 2009;34(6):506e12.
[184] Dubey R, Srivastava P, Kapoor IPS, Singh G. Synthesis, characteriza-
tion and catalytic behavior of Cu nanoparticles on the thermal
decomposition of AP, HMX, NTO and composite solid propellants,
Part-83. Thermochim Acta 2012;549:102e9.
[185] Wei ZX, Chi YN, Hu CW, Liu HY. Combustion synthesis and catalytic
activity of LaCoO3 for HMX thermal decomposition. Propellants
Explos Pyrotech 2009;34(5):394e9.
[186] Wei ZX, Xu YQ, Liu HY, Hu CW. Preparation and catalytic activities of
LaFeO3 and Fe2O3 for HMX thermal decomposition. J Hazard Mater
2009;165(1e3):1056e61.
[187] Wei ZX, Wei L, Gong L, Wang Y, Hu CW. Combustion synthesis and
effect of LaMnO3 and La0.8Sr0.2MnO3 on RDX thermal decomposition.
J Hazard Mater 2010;177(1e3):554e9.
[188] Wei ZX, Wang Y, Zhang XJ, Hu CW. Combustion synthesis and effect
of LaMnO3 and LaOCl powder mixture on HMX thermal decomposi-
tion. Thermochim Acta 2010;499(1e2):111e6.
[189] Li N, Geng ZF, Cao MH, Ren L, Zhao XY, Liu B, et al. Well-dispersed
ultrafine Mn3O4 nanoparticles on graphene as a promising catalyst for
the thermal decomposition of ammonium perchlorate. Carbon
2013;54:124e32.
[190] Roßmann C, Heintz T, Herrmann M. Production of ultrafine explosive
particles by bead milling technology. In: 43rd international annual
conference of the Fraunhofer ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of
Germany June 23e29, 2012. p. 93/1e12.
[191] Armstrong RW, Ammon HL, Elban WL. Investigation of hot spot
characteristics in energetic crystals. Thermochim Acta
2002;384(1e2):303e13.
[192] Setchell RE. Grain-size effects on the shock sensitivity of
hexanitrostilbene (HNS) explosive. Combust Flame 1984;56(3):
343e5.[193] Spear RJ, Nanut V. Reversal of particle size/shock sensitivity relation-
ship at small particle size for pressed heterogeneous explosives under
sustained shock loading. J Energ Mater 1989;7(1e2):77e114.
[194] Mader CL, Kershner JD. Numerical modeling of the effect of temper-
ature and particle size on shock initiation properties of HMX and TATB.
J Energ Mater 1992;10(2e3):69e95.
[195] Lee R, Bloom G, Von Holle W, Weingart W, Erickson L, Sanders S,
et al. The relationship between the shock sensitivity and the solid pore
sizes of TATB powders pressed to various densities. In: Proceedings of
the 8th symposium (international) on detonation, Albuquerque, new
Mexico, CA July 15e19, 1985. p. 3e14.[196] Gifford MJ, Chakravarty A, Greenaway M, Watson S, Proud W, Field J.
Unconventional properties of ultrafine energetic materials. In: 32nd
international annual conference of ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of
Germany July 3e6, 2001. p. 100/1e14.[197] Khasainov BA, Borisov AA, Ermolaev BS, Korotkov AI. Two-phase
visco-plastic model of shock initiation of detonation in high density
pressed explosives. In: Proceedings of the 7th symposium (interna-
tional) on detonation, Annapolis, Maryland, CA June 16e19, 1981.p. 435e47.
[198] Honodel CA, Humphrey JR, Weingart RC. Shock initiation of TATB
formulations. In: Proceedings of the 7th symposium (international)
on detonation, Annapolis, Maryland, CA June 16e19, 1981.
p. 425e34.
[199] Muravyev N, Frolov Y, Pivkina A, Ivanov D, Meerov D, Monogarov K.
Ballistic properties of energetic condensed systems with nanosized
high-energy materials. In: Abstracts IV international workshop HEMs,
Biysk, Russia September 3e9, 2008.
[200] Tarver CM. Modeling detonation experiments on triaminotrini-
trobenzene (TATB)-based explosives LX17, PBX 9502, and ultrafine
TATB. J Energ Mater 2012;30(3):220e51.
[201] Muravyev N, Frolov Y, Pivkina A, Monogarov K, Ordzhonikidze O,
Bushmarinov I, et al. Influence of particle size and mixing technology
on combustion of HMX/Al compositions. Propellants Explos Pyrotech
2010;35(3):226e32.
[202] Gogulya MF, Mackhov MN, Dolgoborodov AY, Brazhnikov MA,
Leipunsky IO, Jigatch AN, et al. Nanocomposites based on HMX and
aluminium: synthesis and detonation properties. In: Proceedings of in-
ternational conference “VII Khariton topical scientific readings”, Sarov,
Russia March 11e18, 2005.
[203] Lowe CA, Longbottom AW. Effect of particle distribution on the
compaction behavior of granular beds. Phys Fluids 2006;18:066101.
[204] Lowe CA, Greenaway MW. Compaction processes in granular
beds composed of different particle sizes. J Appl Phys 2005;98:
123519.
79B. HUANG et al. / Defence Technology 9 (2013) 59e79
[205] Nafday OA, Pitchimani R, Weeks BL. Patterning high explosives at the
nanoscale. Propellants Explos Pyrotech 2006;31(5):376e81.
[206] Zhang X, Zhang GX, Liao YC, Weeks BL, Zhang Z. Embossing of
organic thin films using a surfactant assisted lift-off technique. J Colloid
Interface Sci 2012;387(1):175e9.
[207] Roberts CW,Hira SM,MasonBP, StrouseGF, Stoltz CA. Controlling RDX
explosive crystallite morphology and inclusion content via simple ultra-
sonic agitation and solvent evaporation. CrystEngComm2011;13:1074e6.[208] Akkbarzadea H, Parsafar GA, Bayat Y. Structural stability of nano-sized
crystals of HMX: a molecular dynamics simulation study. Appl Surf Sci
2012;258(7):2226e30.
[209] Chen Y, Xin F, Qiao ZQ, Zeng GY. Influence of the storage conditions
on the specific surface area of nano-TATB. In: 42nd international annual
conference of the Fraunhofer ICT, Karlsruhe, Federal Republic of
Germany June 28eJuly 1, 2011. p. 42/1e8.
[210] Rossi C, Zhang KL, Esteve D, Alphonse P, Tailhades P, Vahlas C.
Nanoenergetic materials for MEMS: a review. J Microelectromech Syst
2007;16(4):919e31.
[211] Pezous H, Rossi C, Sanchez M, Mathieu F, Dollat X, Charlot S, et al.
Integration of a MEMS based safe arm and fire device. Sens Actuators
A 2010;159(2):157e67.
[212] Pezous H, Rossi C, Sanchez M, Mathieu F, Dollat X, Charlot S, et al.
Fabrication, assembly and tests of a MEMS-based safe, arm and fire
device. J Phys Chem Solids 2010;71(2):75e9.
[213] Pennarun P, Rossi C, Esteve D, Colin RD. Single use, robust, MEMS
based electro-thermal microswitches for redundancy and system
reconfiguration. Sens Actuators A 2007;136(1):273e81.[214] Rossi C, Briand D, Dumonteuil M, Camps T, Pham PQ, de Rooij NF.
Matrix of 10 � 10 addressed solid propellant microthrusters: review of
the technologies. Sens Actuators A 2006;126(1):241e52.