Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project...
Transcript of Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project...
![Page 1: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness
Project Update
Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD
Water/Energy Analyst
CPUC-Energy Division
1
![Page 2: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Past and Current CPUC Proceedings on Water-
Energy
• 2007: Decision 07-12-050 authorized
comprehensive Water-Energy Studies and
directed IOUs to run pilot projects
• Energy Efficiency Proceeding R.09-11-014.
May 2012 Guidance Decision:
– Directed IOUs to expand water-energy
efficiency programs
– Directed staff to develop cost effectiveness
framework
• New Water-Energy Proceeding opened
December 2013: R.13-12-011
2
![Page 3: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Past CPUC Efforts on Water-Energy
• Three comprehensive studies on the “Water Energy Relationship”
(2009-2012)
• Water-Energy Pilot Projects (2007-2011)
– Leak/loss detection and pressure management
– Landscape irrigation efficiency
– High efficiency toilets
– Ozone laundry
– More
• All materials can be downloaded via:
http://www.cpuc.ca.gov/PUC/energy/Energy+Efficiency/Water-
Energy+Nexus+Programs.htm
3
![Page 4: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Water-Energy Efficiency Cost Effectiveness
• Commission Guidance (May 2012)
– Develop a method for analyzing cost effectiveness of
programs/measures that simultaneously save energy
& water
• Need to quantify embedded energy in water to
calculate potential energy savings
• Need to develop method for valuing avoided costs
associated with water savings
4
![Page 5: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
What is Cost Effectiveness?
• Cost Effectiveness is a Threshold and an Estimate
– Process to evaluate and compare costs and benefits
– Estimates the Avoided Costs of a given program, measure or project
– Avoided costs can be analyzed from different perspectives
• If programs are not proven to be cost effective to electric and gas
IOU ratepayers, than ratepayer funds cannot be used
• Tools:
– Standard Practice Manual
– Demand Side Avoided Cost Calculator
– E3 Cost Effectiveness Calculator
5
![Page 6: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
The Standard Practice Manual (SPM)
• Developed to measure the cost-effectiveness of
Energy Efficiency programs
• Four tests to measure cost-effectiveness from
four different perspectives:
– Society: The Total Resource Cost (TRC) test
“Society” defined as Utility + Participant
– Administrator: The Program Administrator (PAC) test
– Ratepayers: The Ratepayer Impact Measure (RIM) test
– Participant: The Participant Test
The SPM also describes the “Societal Cost Test,” a variant of the TRC that
includes externalities and uses a social discount rate.
6
![Page 7: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
0
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
35,000
40,000
45,000
50,000
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
MW
Hour
Energy Efficiency Impact on Electricity Demand
Original Load (hottest day of the year) Reduced Load due to Energy Efficiency
Avoided Capacity
Avoided
Energy
What is an Avoided Cost?
![Page 8: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Goal of CPUC Cost Effectiveness Project:
Joint Framework to analyze cost effectiveness of Water Energy Programs:
• Cost effectiveness requires proving that there are electric/gas ratepayer benefits
from saving water
• Therefore, CPUC must estimate embedded energy values for water
QUESTIONS we are asking:
• Is the program cost effective from energy ratepayer perspective?
– What are the energy avoided costs from water saving programs?
• Is the program cost effective from water ratepayer perspective?
– What are the avoided costs to the water provider from water saving programs?
• Is the program cost effective from the combined perspective?
– If each utility contributes $ = the benefit received
• Is the program cost effective from societal perspective?
8
![Page 9: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
What is Embedded Energy in Water?
The amount of energy (in kWh or therms) needed to
supply, move, and treat water
(in million gallons (MG) or acre/ft.)
delivered to a user,
and to pump & treat the water post-use (if necessary)
9
![Page 10: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
TRC\ PAC RIM Participant
Energy Water Combined Societal Energy Water Combined Energy Water End-User Water
Agency
Administrative costs
to energy utility COST COST COST COST COST COST
Administrative costs
to water agency COST COST COST COST COST COST COST
Avoided costs of
supplying electricity BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT
Avoided costs of
water capacity BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT
Avoided embedded
utility energy in
water
BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT
Avoided embedded
additional energy in
water
BENEFIT
BENEFIT
BENEFIT BENEFIT
BENEFIT
BENEFIT BENEFIT
Energy and Water
Bill Reductions BENEFIT BENEFIT
Capital (measure)
costs to participant COST COST COST COST COST COST
Capital (measure)
costs to energy
utility
COST COST COST COST COST COST
Capital (measure)
costs to water utility COST COST COST COST COST COST
Incentives paid by
energy utility COST COST COST BENEFIT BENEFIT
Incentives paid by
water utility COST COST COST BENEFIT
Increased supply
costs COST COST COST COST COST COST COST COST COST
Revenue loss from
reduced energy
sales
COST
Revenue loss from
reduced water sales COST
Tax Credits BENEFIT BENEFIT BENEFIT ? BENEFIT BENEFIT
![Page 11: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Avoided water cost/ Avoided embedded energy
They are parts of the same whole—
….But we need to separate them to evaluate them
Avoided Water
Costs
Avoided
embedded
energy
11
Avoided
Water
Capacity
![Page 12: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Task: Define Avoided Costs
Avoided Water Costs =
Avoided water capacity costs + Avoided embedded energy costs
Avoided water capacity costs are analogous to
avoided energy capacity costs (generation,
transmission, distribution system capital, operation and maintenance costs)
Avoided water capacity costs are capital & operating expenditures which include:
• Avoided incremental purchase price of next (marginal) water supply
• Avoided costs of new/expanded water conveyance, treatment and distribution (building new plants, etc.)
• Avoided cost of operation & maintenance of treatment & distribution system (reduced system wear & tear, reduced chemical use, etc)
12
![Page 13: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Next Steps for Water-Energy Cost
Effectiveness at CPUC
1) Stakeholder Process (Ongoing)
• Project Coordination Group discussion-paper with input on cost
effectiveness framework model and feasibility
• PCG members include IOUs, water agencies, water policy experts
2) Develop Cost Effectiveness Calculations (2014)
• Navigant/GEI consulting team chosen to conduct analysis/assist Staff
• Expected completion Fall 2014
3) Staff Proposes cost effectiveness framework to Commission for
consideration and potential adoption (Fall-2014)
4) Framework must include plan for periodic updates of embedded
energy calculations
13
![Page 14: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
“Beyond Cost Effectiveness” Energy Efficiency Savings must be Measured &
Verified
• Requirement: demonstrate real savings at the end of a program: for
water efficiency this will mean embedded energy savings
• Without energy intensity of supplier, wholesaler and retailer, water
savings by customers cannot be translated into energy savings
14
![Page 15: Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update 27 201… · Water-Energy Cost Effectiveness Project Update Meredith Leigh Younghein, JD Water/Energy Analyst CPUC-Energy Division 1](https://reader033.fdocuments.in/reader033/viewer/2022060219/5f06c2107e708231d419960f/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Questions?
(415) 703-5953
15