The World as a Work of Art - Nytimes
2
Click here to load reader
-
Upload
gaby-yepes -
Category
Documents
-
view
212 -
download
0
Transcript of The World as a Work of Art - Nytimes
10/3/2014 THE WORLD AS A WORK OF ART - NYTimes.com
http://www.nytimes.com/1986/01/19/books/the-world-as-a-work-of-art.html 1/2
Search All NYTimes.com
THE WORLD AS A WORK OF ARTBy Karsten Harries; Karsten Harries is a professor of philosophy at Yale University.
Published: January 19, 1986
NIETZSCHE Life as Literature. By Alexander Nehamas. 261 pp.
Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press. $17.50.
THE HUMANITIES have become uncertain of their way: recent
discourse in philosophy and literary theory suggests that reason has
undermined trust in reason; the traditional distinction between
theory and literature, between philosophy and poetry, has blurred.
Such uncertainty has renewed appreciation of Nietzsche's attempt to
replace Plato's idealized Socrates, whose life and death celebrated
confidence in reason, with his own ideal image of the philosopher, an
idealization of himself as a poet-philosopher opening doors to a post-
Socratic, postmodern culture. At issue is the future of philosophy.
Philosophers and anyone interested in philosophy ought therefore to
welcome Alexander Nehamas's elegant and challenging interpretation of this ''most
writerly of philosophers.''
Mr. Nehamas, who is a professor of philosophy at the University of Pittsburgh, uses two
related themes to give unity to his study. The first is Nietzsche's perspectivism: we know
no fact independent of interpretation; there is no vision of reality untainted by prejudice
and perspective - but that doesn't mean that one interpretation may not be better than
another. Nietzsche's perspectivism helps explain his experiments with different styles of
writing, which force us to pay attention not just to what is said but to the way it is being
said. Instead of excluding himself from his texts, Nietzsche intrudes himself; instead of the
self-effacement we have come to expect of scholarly writing, Nietzsche constantly reminds
us that his insights are very much his own. Committed to perspectivism, Mr. Nehamas
attempts something of the sort himself. Not that he resorts to Nietzschean hyperbole or
tries to match Nietzsche's masterly play with language; but like Nietzsche, he does not let
us forget that his is only one interpretation, and reminds us of others with which it invites
comparison.
The second theme of Mr. Nehamas's interpretation is Nietzsche's estheticism. Nietzsche is
said to look at the world as if it were a work of art (more precisely a literary text), at
persons and things as if they were characters or entities in some work of fiction, at our
relationship to the world as if it were textual interpretation. This literary model lets Mr.
Nehamas present Nietzsche's ''will to power'' (often understood as a theory about nature)
as an act of interpretation that gives definite shape to an indeterminate world. It also
provides him with a key to understanding Nietzsche's doctrine of the eternal recurrence,
which offers ''not a theory of the world but a view of the ideal life.'' That ideal celebrates
the person able to affirm all he has done and to re-create himself as the hero of a narrative
that, in its perfection, lets us experience every detail as inevitable.
For Mr. Nehamas, a good example of the self-creator is the narrator of Proust's
''Remembrance of Things Past.'' Not that the life of this narrator was ever Nietzsche's own
ideal. ''But,'' says Mr. Nehamas, ''the framework supplied by this perfect novel which
The ‘Boy s’ in theBunkhouse
The Fat Drug
Log In With Facebook
MOST EMAILED RECOMMENDED FOR YOU
Log in to see w hat your friends are sharingon nytimes.com. Privacy Policy | What’sThis?
What’s Popular Now
Sign up for ticket offers from Broadw ay show s and other
advertisers.
See Sample | Privacy Policy
TicketWatch: Theater Offers by Email
1 . Video: The Race for the Best PictureOscar
2. SINOSPHERE
Michelle Obama to Stress Education onChina Trip
3. MAUREEN DOWD
Frozen in a Niche?
4. FUTURE TENSE
Celebrities Behaving Well
5. OP-ED | MARK BITTMAN
Some Progress on Eating and Health
6. Just Another Great Role for What’s-Her-Name
7 . Russian Hockey Coach Out
HOME PAGE TODAY'S PAPER VIDEO MOST POPULAR
BooksWORLD U.S. N.Y. / REGION BUSINESS TECHNOLOGY SCIENCE HEA LTH SPORTS OPINION A RTS STYLE TRA V EL JOBS REAL ESTATE AUTOS
ART & DESIGN BOOKS Sunday Book Review Best Sellers DANCE MOVIES MUSIC TELEVISION THEATER VIDEO GAMES EVENTS INTERNATIONAL ARTS AWARDS SEASON
GOOGLE+
SHARE
REPRINTS
MORE IN BOOKS (1 OF 45 ARTICLES)
Revisiting a Scholar Unmasked byScandalRead More »
SUBSCRIBE NOW Log In Register Now HelpU.S. Edition
10/3/2014 THE WORLD AS A WORK OF ART - NYTimes.com
http://www.nytimes.com/1986/01/19/books/the-world-as-a-work-of-art.html 2/2
FACEBOOK TWITTER GOOGLE+ EMAIL SHARE
relates what, despite and even through its very imperfections, becomes and is seen to be a
perfect life, and which keeps turning endlessly back upon itself, is the best possible model
for the eternal recurrence.'' Such perfection, Mr. Nehamas concludes, Nietzsche strove for
and achieved. ''Nietzsche's texts therefore do not describe but, in exquisitely elaborate
detail, exemplify the perfect instance of his ideal character. And this character is none
other than the character these very texts constitute: Nietzsche himself.'' BUT this
conclusion puts into question Nietzsche's, as well as Mr. Nehamas's, esthetic view of
things. What is the relationship between ''the miserable little man'' Nietzsche was and ''the
magnificent character'' he created? Does the creation of the latter rest on a triumphant
affirmation of the former? Doesn't it presuppose quite the opposite, a need to escape from
life into art? And isn't that escape itself a manifestation of what Nietzsche's Zarathustra
calls ''the spirit of revenge,'' a rejection of all that binds us into time - body, life and reality
- in favor of their reflections in the mirror of art? To overcome the spirit of revenge, to
redeem ourselves in Nietzsche's sense, we must find the strength to accept ourselves as we
are, vulnerable and mortal, willing power, yet lacking power.
This struggle renders the German philosopher's texts profoundly ambiguous. There is no
denying Nietzsche's estheticism, but we must also hear his call for a redemption from the
spirit of revenge, a redemption that would overcome every estheticism. We should not
forget his sad end when we admire ''the magnificent character'' emerging through the
books he wrote. To trade even a miserable life for the grandest delusion is to strike a
questionable bargain. And so is to trade adequacy to the many different strands of
Nietzsche's texts for esthetic coherence. But just because it runs this risk, this unusually
engaging book demands our attention.
Ads by Google what's this?
A Donde Vivir PerúBuscador gratuito de departamentos.
Encuentra más de 10,000 inmuebles
www.adondevivir.com
Log in to discover more articlesbased on w hat you‘ve read.
What’s This? | Don’t Show
8. Video: Who Will Win Best Picture?
9. Sheila MacRae, Wife in ’60s‘Honey mooners’ Sketches, Dies at 92
10. For the Infamous, More Than 15Minutes
Following an 8-year-old toAtlantisALSO IN TRAVEL »
36 hours in Raleigh, N.C.
Shops and sweets in Portland, Ore.
© 2014 The New York Times Company Site Map Privacy Your Ad Choices Advertise Terms of Sale Terms of Service Work With Us RSS Help Contact Us Site Feedback
