8/9/2019 The Luce Ladder

1/8

[FKxlk

IHHKTFa{ti`k ov xlk mihhkt ae plofl

imm xlk axlkt ~otx{kv ja{ex%

^am{jk \^- Ovv{k 9

Fmitk Daaxlk M{fk

Tkih xlk mixkvx RamofK|rtkvv d Fltovxoei

La Vajjktv

Ri`k 4

V%K% F{rr vrkicv ixxlk Oevxox{xkv @aoe`Ta`{k FRIF riekm

Ri`k 0

@tifk- fa{ti`k- fae~ofxoaexlavk itk

g{vx i kp a xlk y{imoxokv xlk M{fk Ramof

Oevxox{xk maacv at plke vkmkfxoe` i pajie a

a{t lo`lkvx laeat- xlk Pajie a xlk _kit

ipith% Xlov kit pk flavk Jaeofi Ftapmk-

i mkihkt pla oe{kefkv jommoaev xlta{`l lkt

eixoaeim tihoa vlap ieh tky{kex xkmk~ovoae

irrkitiefkv% Pk faexoe{kh a{t xtihoxoae artkvkexoe` xlk ipith ix i m{eflkae at a{e

pajke h{toe` xlk Faevkt~ixo~k Ramoxofim Ifx

Faektkefk ,FRIF/ oe Pivloe`xae- HF%

O g{vx ma~k xlov m{eflkae) vioh

Ckek Tofk- aek a xlk ixxkehkkv ieh i

varlajatk ix Nathlij [eo~ktvox% O

ma~k jkkxoe` axlkt a{e` pajke pla itk hkhofixkh xa faevkt~ixo~k ~im{kv-

ieh O ma~k vkkoe` i ekp pajie laeatkh kifl kit at lkt faextod{xoaev%

,vxat faexoe{kh oevohk ae ri`

Jaeofi Ftapmk Eijkh xlk M{fk RamofOevxox{xkv 4292 Pajie a xlk _kit

Ploxxokt Mip Vflaamvx{hkex Irtom Daeoixxa

dtoe`v Di D{flieie xalkt fijr{v

Ri`k

8/9/2019 The Luce Ladder

2/8

Xlk Fmitk Daaxlk M{fk Ramof Oevxox{xkvjovvoae ov xa rtkritk pajke atkkfxo~k mkihktvlor ieh xa rtajaxk mkihoe`faevkt~ixo~k pajke% Xlk Oevxox{xk vxto~kv xaih~iefk Ijktofiv pajke d rtajaxoe` iehrtkvkt~oe` faevkt~ixo~k rtoeformkv%

Xlk Ht% Kmmoaxx . Hitmi Ritxtoh`kEixoaeim Lkihy{itxktv

994 Kmhke Vxtkkx- V{oxk RLktehae- ot`oeoi 42902

,

8/9/2019 The Luce Ladder

3/8

FPEoeTk~okp

Xlk Faevkt~ixo~k Pajkev Ekxpatc ,FPE/ ov i jaexlm m{eflkae

fa*lavxkh d xlk M{fk Ramof Oevxox{xk ieh Xlk Lktoxi`k Na{ehixoae%

Lkmh oe Pivloe`xae- HF- xlk m{eflkaev rta~ohk ixxkehkkv poxl xlk

arratx{eox xa mkite ida{x f{ttkex ovv{kv taj faevkt~ixo~k mkihktv

ieh faeekfx poxl axlkt pajke oe xlk Pivloe`xae itki% Nat jatk

oeatjixoae ida{x FPE- ~ovox ppp%fdmro%at`!k~kexv at faexifx

Fijommk Litx ix flitxBfdmro%at`%

5 Oe Vkrxkjdkt FPE kix{tkh i vrkfoim vftkkeoe` a 66 Joe{xkv7

Rtaxkfxoe` Ijktofi oe xlk Ekp Jovvomk I`k- i haf{jkexit xlix xkmmv xlk

vxat a xlk ~kt tkim xltkix atko`e kekjokv ravk xa Ijktofi% Eixoaeimvkf{tox k|rktx Jifckewok Ki`mke vrack ida{x xlk ovv{kv hovf{vvkh oe

xlk nmj ieh xaac y{kvxoaev taj xlk i{hokefk%

5 Oe Afxadkt i{xlat ieh ekpv fajjkexixat V%K% F{rr i~k ie

oevo`lx{m ximc ae xicoe` i jahkte irrtaifl xa pajkev ovv{kv% F{rr

k|rmioekh lap Vitil Rimoev mkihktvlor k|ravkh xlk tkim xt{xl ida{x

tihofim kjoeovxv%

5 Oe Ea~kjdkt Mkvmok Vieflkw vrack ida{x lkt mixkvx daac- _a{~k

Fajk i Mae` Pi- Jidk- ieh lap faevkt~ixo~k pajke fie k|fkm oe

mkihktvlor ravoxoaev% Vieflkw vkt~kh iv ie ih~ovat xa atjkt Rtkvohkex

@kat`k P% D{vl ieh ov i pohkm va{`lx*ixkt jkhoi ieimvx%

5 Kifl Hkfkjdkt FPE kix{tkv i hovxoe`{ovlkh `kexmkjke vrkicktiv i vrkfoim xtkix xa xlk mihokv oe ixxkehiefk% Oe 422?- xlk Hkfkjdkt

vrkickt piv ^ot`oeoi Ixxatek @kektim Cke F{ffoekmmo- i tovoe` vxit oe xlk

faevkt~ixo~k ja~kjkex% F{ffoekmmo ov ie ixxatek ieh vjimm d{voekvv

apekt- ieh vkt~kh iv i ot`oeoi vxixk vkeixat taj 4224*422?%

5FPE cofckh a oe 4292 poxl i ta{voe` vrkkfl d Ckmmieek Faepi

pla vlitkh lkt rktvrkfxo~k iv i rammvxkt ae xlk lax ovv{kv ifoe` xlk

fa{ext xlov kit%

5Oe Nkdt{it ot`oeoi Pimhke Nath- xlk k|kf{xo~k hotkfxat a H%F%

Ritkexv at Vflaam Flaofk- Oef%- i~k ie {rhixk ae xlk vflaam flaofk

rta`tij oe Pivloe`xae- HF- xlix liv lkmrkh flie`k xlk mo~kv a va

jie hovih~iexi`kh flomhtke%

5Jitgatok Hieekekmvkt- xlk xlk Rtkvohkex a V{vie D% Iexlae Movx-

vrack ix xlk Jitfl FPE% Lkt at`ieowixoaev jovvoae ov xa ih~iefk-

jadomowk ieh tkrtkvkex rta*mok pajke%

5I{xlat Giek Lijrxae Faac vrack oe Irtom ida{x lkt mixkvx daac

fimmkh Vxatokv a Nioxl ieh Fa{ti`k taj xlk Pit oe Otiy . I`lieovxie%

Xlov daac vlitkv oevrotoe`- ek~kt*dkatk*lkith ntvx*lieh iffa{exv taj

jkhofv- vamhoktv ieh flirmioev oe Otiy ieh I`lieovxie%

CkmmieekFaepi-

Rtkvohkex ieh

FKA a xlk

rammoe` fajrie-

oef%!PajieXtkeh-

hovf{vvkv xlk

ck ovv{kv ifoe`

faevkt~ixo~kv

oe 4292%

^ot`oeoi Ixxatek

@kektim Cke

F{ffoekmmo vrack

oe Hkfkjdkt-

faexoe{oe` FPEv

xtihoxoae a kehoe`

xlk kit poxl i

i hovxoe`{ovlkh

`kexmkjievrkickt%

Ea~kjdkt FPE

vrkickt Mkvmok

Vieflkw ,to`lx/

vlapv a lkt

mixkvx daac poxl

Xlk Lktoxi`k

Na{ehixoaev

Dtoh`kxx Pi`ekt%

Ekpv fajjkexixat ieh M{fk f

mkfx{tkt V%K% F{rr ,mkx/ jkkxv

ixxkehkkv ixkt lkt vrkkfl ae k

Vflaam flaofk

ifxo~ovx ot`oeoi

Pimhke Nath

vrkicv ix xlk

Nkdt{it FPE%

Irtom FPE vrkickt Giek Lijrxae Faac vo`ev

farokv a lkt daacv at ixxkehkkv%

Jitgatok Hieekekmvkt ,to`lx/ vrkicv xa

atjkt M{fk oexkte Jaeofi Jivxtiffa

ixkt lkt tkjitcv ix FPE%

8/9/2019 The Luce Ladder

4/8

Kexl{voivxof faevkt~ixo~k pajke t

iftavv xlk Pkvx `ixlktkh oe Viexi Ditd

Fimoateoi at xlk Fmitk Daaxlk M{fk Ra

Oevxox{xkv xloth iee{im Pkvxkte Pajkev V{jjox%

V{jjox- plofl xaac rmifk Jitfl 4;*40 ix xlk Tki`Tiefl Fkexkt- piv xlk Oevxox{xkv do``kvx ieh dkv

hixk% Xlk a{xvxiehoe` moek*{r a vrkicktv oefm{h

dkvx vkmmoe` i{xlat Iee Fa{mxkt- M{fk Ramof Oevxox

Daith Jkjdkt ieh tky{kex Na| Ekpv fajjkexi

Cixk Adkevlioe- i{xlat ieh mkfx{tkt Di D{flie

vx{hkex ifxo~ovx Irtom Daeoixxa- lkimxl fitk k|rktx V

Rorkv ieh faevkt~ixo~k nmjjickt Iee JfKmloeek

Dki{xo{m mafixoae- k|fkmmkex vrkicktv- aah aa

k~ktxloe` piv paehkt{m- vioh aek ixxkehkk%

Xlov kit xlk V{jjox oefm{hkh i vrkfoim xtioe

vkjoeit at xlk a{e` ixxkehkkv oe fammk`k- jie

plaj ixxkeh modktim {eo~ktvoxokv ae xlk Pkvx Faivx%

8/9/2019 The Luce Ladder

5/8

vkjoeit rta~ohkh xlkvk vx{hkexv poxl xlk tkva{tfkv ieh

`{ohiefk xlk ekkh xa rtajaxk faevkt~ixo~k rtoeformkv

ieh vrkicktv ae fijr{v%

Xlk k~kex faefm{hkh poxl i vrkfoim xtkix at

ixxkehkkvi titk rto~ixk xa{t a Rtkvohkex TaeimhTki`iev tiefl oe Viexi Ditditi% Xlk jahkvx lajk

voxv ae i dki{xo{m- vkfm{hkh rokfk a mieh poxl tammoe`

lommv ieh vrkfxif{mit ~okpv% Ox rktkfxm tkkfxv xlk

l{jdmk- tkkhaj*ma~oe` vrotox a Taeimh Tki`ie%

Xlk V{jjox ov arke xa pajke a imm i`kv ieh

xickv rmifk kifl vrtoe` oe Viexi Ditditi% O a{ itk

oexktkvxkh oe ekxpatcoe` poxl axlkt faevkt~ixo~k

pajke ieh mkiteoe` ida{x ck ovv{kv taj xar pajke

mkihktv oe xlk faevkt~ixo~k ja~kjkex- neh a{x lap

a{ fie ixxkeh xlk ek|x Pkvxkte Pajkev V{jjox oe

4299 d faexifxoe` xlk V{jjox faathoeixat Fijommk

Litx ix flitxBfdmro%at` at ,

8/9/2019 The Luce Ladder

6/8

4292 Pkvxkte Pajkev V{jjoxVrkicktv

Eief Rkmavo vioh i kp pkkcv i`a pk

li~k xa rivv xlk lkimxl fitk mk`ovmixoae va

pk fie neh a{x plixv oe xlk domm% Hakvex

xlix vfitk a{1

O~k dkke hkimoe` poxl modktimv at i mae`

xojk ieh a{ ek~kt `kx xlkj xa vkk a{t

raoex a ~okp d jicoe` i vxtae` ieh ma`ofim

it`{jkex% Ma`of ieh tixoaeimeax xlkot atxk%

Xlk pi a{ `kx xlkj xa {ehktvxieh ov plke

a{ x{te xlk xidmkv ae xlkj%

Tkfa`eowk xlix iv faevkt~ixo~k pajke-

a{ itk `aoe` xa dk lkmh xa i lo`lkt

vxiehith% Ox ov eax i d{thke% Maac ix ox iv

ie laeat%

O xlk itk moe` xa a{t flomh oe vflaam- a{

fieeax immap ox% _a{ j{vx ha vajkxloe` ida{x

ox% Dk damh- ieh dk fa{ti`ka{v%

O neh xlix poxl faevkt~ixo~kv- xloe`v

itk vxidmkpk li~k a{t faevxox{xoae

ieh pk idohk d ox% Xlixv lap O fijk xa

ceap xlix O lih faevkt~ixo~k dkmokv%

Pk~k `ax xa `kx oe xlk `ijk- pk~k `ax xa `kx kefa{ti`kh% Pk~k `ax

xa vxitx vrkicoe` a{t dkmokv fa{ti`ka{vm ieh ma{hmoxv xojk at {v xa

xick xlov fa{ext difc dkfi{vk xlixv plix a{t a{ehoe` ixlktv k|rkfx

taj {v- ieh xlixv plix a{t flomhtke k|rkfx taj {v%

8/9/2019 The Luce Ladder

7/8

Oe ihhoxoae xa lkt patc oe tihoa ieh X^- Jaeofi Ftapmk ov i fam{jeovx- dma``kt- ieh dkvx*vkmmoe` i{xlat% Vlk kitekh xpa ji

k`tkkv ieh i Rl%H% oe oexkteixoaeim iiotv taj Fam{jdoi [eo~ktvox% Jaeofi ov ie oeftkhodm oexkmmo`kex ieh iffajrmovlkh pajie

rktv{ivo~km itxof{mixkv lkt dkmokv- kx javx modktimv oe xlk jkhoi ieh ae fammk`k fijr{vkv ha imm xlk fie xa vomkefk vxtae` faevkt~

pajke mock lkt% Xlixv pl ix xlk Fmitk Daaxlk M{fk Ramof Oevxox{xk pk itk ki`kt xa laeat mkihktv mock Jaeofi Ftapmk%Jaeofi `i~k ie oevrotoe` vrkkfl ieh kefa{ti`kh xlk a{e` pajke oe ixxkehiefk xa eax difc hape taj xlkot dkmokv%

Xlov m{eflkae liv `o~ke jk xlk daavx a fa{ti`k O ekkh xa flivk j htkijv ieh eax difc hape g{vx dkfi{vk j aroeoae ji

dk xlk javx rar{mit- vioh Kjom- i tkvljie ix xlk [eo~ktvox a Jovva{to%

Xlk m{eflkae piv g{vx aek a vk~ktim k|foxoe` k~kexv lavxkh d xlk Oevxox{xk ix xlov kitv FRIF% Xlk Oevxox{xkv daaxl oe xlk k|

imm piv faevxiexm id{ww iv ixxkehkkv moekh {r at fimkehit vo`eoe`v kix{toe` xlk pajke oe a{t 4292 @tkix Ijktofie Faevkt~i

Pajke fimkehit% Rlmmov Vflmi- Na| Ekpv fajjkexixat V%K% F{rr- ieh M{fk Daith Jkjdktv Cixk Adkevlioe ieh Jitgo Tavv `

|fkmmkex rtkvkexixoaev ae i riekm hovf{vvoae fimmkh @aoe` Ta`{k7 Pajke Flie`oe` xlk Nifk a Faevkt~ixovj% Xlk hovf{vvkh

iom{tkv a kjoeovj- xlk ekkh at jatk faevkt~ixo~k pajke mkihktv- ieh lap xa v{ffkvv{mm dimiefk ijom ieh fitkkt% Xlk taaj

a~ktapoe` poxl vx{hkexv ieh xlk k~kex piv fa~ktkh oe ie itxofmk ae Na|Ekpv%faj%

M{fk Mihokv ix FRIFfaexoe{kh taj ri`k 9/

d Imvvi Fatha~i

L{jieK~kexv%faj

Jitfl 9

8/9/2019 The Luce Ladder

8/8

Xlk M{fk Mihokv li~k dkke xicoe`

ammk`k fijr{vkv d vxatj) Patcoe`

poxl vx{hkexv iftavv xlk fa{ext- xlk

evxox{xk ov vkehoe` M{fk vrkicktv xa

ijr{vkv mock N{tjie [eo~ktvox oeVa{xl Fitamoei- Lit~ith [eo~ktvox-

Pkmmkvmk Fammk`k oe Jivvifl{vkxxv

eh xlk [eo~ktvox a ot`oeoi%

Aek a xlk dto`lx vx{hkex mkihktv

jicoe` i hoktkefk ae lkt fijr{v

v Irtom Daeoixxa- i xloth*kit

x{hkex ix Ploxxokt Mip Vflaam%

Iv rtkvohkex a xlk Pajkev Mip

Vx{hkex Ivvafoixoae ix Ploxxokt-

Irtom patckh poxl xlk M{fk Ramof

evxox{xk xa dtoe` Di D{flieie xarkic ix Ploxxokt oe Ea~kjdkt 422?%

F i j r { v M k f x { t k v

Li~oe` Di D{flieie fajk

vrkic piv j javx jkjatidmk

k|rktokefk iv i vx{hkex ifxo~ovx-

Irtom vioh% Xlk k|rktokefk a li~oe`

Di ae a{t fijr{v piv k|fkmmkex iehtkfko~kh ~kt fajjkehidmk tkjitcv

ixkt ieh xa xlov hi%

Dkfi{vk a lkt hkhofixoae xa

ih~iefoe` faevkt~ixovj ix lkt

vflaam- M{fk flavk Irtom iv xlk

Hkfkjdkt Vx{hkex Vraxmo`lx plofl

oefm{hkv i lajkri`k kix{tk vxat ae

ppp%fdmro%at`% ^ovox xlk Oevxox{xkv

pkdvoxk xa tkih jatk ida{x Irtomv

vxat ieh xa mkite lap xa dtoe`

i heijof faevkt~ixo~k pajie

vrkickt xa a{t fijr{v%

Ntaj mkx xa to`lx7 Cixk Adkevlioe ix xlk [eo~ktvox a ^ot`oeoi3 Di D{flieie ix Pkmmkvmk Fammk`k3 Fltovxoei La

Vajjktv ix Lit~ith [eo~ktvox3 Eaeok Hitpovl ix Ploxxokt Mip Vflaam3 Rlmmov Vflmi ix N{tjie [eo~ktvox

M{fkRtkvohkexJoflkmmkKivxaevixha

poxlF*VRIEvDtoieMijdatie la

mae`oexkt~okpplofliotkhvk~ktimxoj

M{fkKe

hv

M{fkRamofyOevxox{xkvxin~ovoxpoxlRixtofoiJ{m~ieky

iehKmmkeJfRlktvaeaxlkMommoiePkmmvNa{ehixoae%

XlkPkmmv Na{ehixoaelivdkkeiritxektxa xlk

Oevxox{xkaejiey ckyrtagkfxv a~ktxlkykitv%

M{fkRtkvohkexJoflkmmkKivxaejkxpoxlimae`xojktokehaxlkOevxox{xk-Jtv%Hataxly@tone-oe

Jitfl%

PloxxktMipVflaamvx{hkexIrtDaeonixxa,mknx/tkfkexmydta{`lxDD{flieiexavrkicaelktfijr{vipivvkmkfxkhivxlkOevxox{xkvHkfkjdVx{hkexVraxmo`lxnatlktmkihktvl