THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM...

23
THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League City, TX May 1, 2008

Transcript of THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM...

Page 1: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

THE LEVEES OF

DALLAS COUNTY

Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM

Walter Skipwith, P.E.

Steve Parker, P.E., CFM

TFMA 2008 Spring Conference

League City, TX

May 1, 2008

Page 2: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Introduction

• Map Modernization Program

• Certification

• Dallas County Levees

• Future Changes

Page 3: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

MapMod

• $1 Billion

• 5 Years

• Began in 2004

• Requirement – Certify Levees or Else

• Dallas County

– Also began in 2004

– 2-Year Effort

Page 4: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Source: Region VI RMC

Page 5: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

FEMA Levee Certification

Requirements

• Design Criteria– Levee Height and Freeboard

– Closures

– Embankment Erosion Protection

– Embankment and Foundation Stability

– Settlement

– Interior Drainage

– Other

• Operation Plans and Criteria

• Maintenance Plans and Criteria

Page 6: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Dallas County LeveesDallas County Levees

• History

– Ag Levees

– Federal Levees

– Municipal Levees

– State Created Levee Improvement Districts

• Inventory

• Process

Page 7: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

InventoryInventory

NoUnknownUnknownVarious- Trinity/Tenmile Creek

NoUnknownUnknownVarious- Bois D’Arc

Various� Ag. Levee Districts

Yes4.3Dallas Sanitation DeptDallas� McCommas Bluff Landfill

Yes2.7Dallas/USACEDallas� Rochester Park

Yes6.7DallasDallas� Southside WWTP

Yes2.6Dallas Water

Utilities/USACEDallas� Central WWTP

Yes22.3Dallas/USACEDallas� Dallas Floodway

Trinity River

CERTIFIEDLENGTHOWNER/OPERATORCITYLEVEE DISTRICT

Page 8: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

InventoryInventory

NoIrvingIrving� Running Bear Park Levee

Yes1.4DCFCD #1Irving� Dallas County FCD #1

(Bear Creek)

NoGrand PrairieGrand Prairie

� Grand Prairie Gun Club

Yes0.9Grand PrairieGrand Prairie

� Dorchester Levee

Yes1.9GPMURDGrand Prairie

� GPMURD

N/AGrand PrairieGrand Prairie

� City of Grand Prairie Landfill

Yes2.7TRAGrand Prairie

� TRA WWTP

YesInc.

aboveDallas/USACEDallas� Dallas Floodway

West Fork-Trinity River

CERTIFIEDLENGTHOWNER/OPERATORCITYLEVEE DISTRICT

Page 9: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

InventoryInventory

Yes3.4DCURDIrving� DCURD (Las Colinas)

Yes8.9VIAFarmers Branch /

Carrollton

� Valwood Improvement Authority

Yes3.5IFCD#3Irving� IFCD #3 (Valley Ranch)

Yes, by PAL2.8IFCD#1/USACEIrving� IFCD #1 (Northwest Levee)

YesInc.

aboveDallas/USACEDallas� Dallas Floodway

Elm Fork-Trinity River

CERTIFIEDLENGTHOWNER/OPERATORCITYLEVEE DISTRICT

Page 10: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

ProcessProcess

• FEMA Guidance

– FEMA Does Not Certify Levees

– FEMA Study Contractors Do Not Certify Levees

– Guidance is Forthcoming

– PM 34 (August 2005)

– PM 43

• October 2006, revised in March 2007

• PAL

– FEMA Region VI Levee Certification Process (Dec 2006)

• Letters to the Mayors (September 2006)

Page 11: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Certification ResultsCertification Results

• August 2006 - Preliminary DFIRMs

Submitted, 5 Levee Systems Certified

• June 2007 – Preliminary DFIRMs Published,

14 Levees Certified by Owners and Accredited

by FEMA

• One Levee granted PAL Status

• Two Levees (Ag) Insufficient in Height

• One Levee Insufficient Freeboard

Page 12: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Certification ResultsCertification Results

Page 13: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Case Study: Dallas FloodwayCase Study: Dallas Floodway

• Design Certified by the Corps in July 2006

• O&M Certified By City of Dallas

– Streets - River Levee Division

– Other COD Levees

• Dallas Water Utilities

• Sanitation

• Coordinated by

PW/T

Page 14: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Case Study: IFCD Case Study: IFCD -- 11

• Federal – part of Dallas Floodway Project

– USACE Inspects

• IFCD - 1– Created in 1971

– Constructed Flood Control Facilities in 1974

– Board has Taxing Authority

• City – Irving appoints Board Members

• PAL– Initially Rated Fair by USACE Not Qualifying

– District and City Undertook Emergency Repairs

– Rating Upgraded to Good

– PAL gives District 2 Years to get Certified

Page 15: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Case Study: IFCD Case Study: IFCD -- 11

Levee Slide at IFCD-1

Parallel Levee Channel

Wall Failure

Page 16: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Case Study: IFCD Case Study: IFCD -- 11

During repair of parallel

levee drainage channel

Parallel Levee Channel

in Better Days

Page 17: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Case Study: IFCD Case Study: IFCD -- 11

IFCD-1 Levee at Loop 12 During High Flow

Sheet Pile Wall had to

be replaced to get in to PAL program

Page 18: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Case Study: IFCD Case Study: IFCD -- 11

Drill Rig on Levee

Sampling for Geotechnical Studies

South Levee Tree

Clearing Rehab Construction

Page 19: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Levee Levee

MappingMapping

PAL Note

Page 20: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Levee MappingLevee Mapping

PAL Note

Page 21: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Levee MappingLevee Mapping• Floodway

Mapping to

landside toe of

levee

Page 22: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

Future Changes?Future Changes?

• FEMA – Interagency Levee Policy Review Committee– New Flood Zone: XL

– Inventory

– 500-Year Flood Design

– Failure-Resistant Design

– Mandatory Flood Insurance Purchase at some Level

• ASFPM White Paper – Levees: the Double-edged Sword

• ASCE – Policy Statement 511: National Levee Safety Program

Page 23: THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY · 2018. 4. 14. · THE LEVEES OF DALLAS COUNTY Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM Walter Skipwith, P.E. Steve Parker, P.E., CFM TFMA 2008 Spring Conference League

THE LEVEES OF

DALLAS COUNTY

Jessica Baker, EIT, CFM

Walter Skipwith, P.E.

Steve Parker, P.E., CFM

TFMA 2008 Spring Conference

League City, TX

May 1, 2008