THE INVESTIGATION ON THE HIGH ENERGY BALL MILLING … · 2020. 10. 22. · High energy ball milling...

www.tjprc.org SCOPUS Indexed Journal [email protected]

THE INVESTIGATION ON THE HIGH ENERGY BALL MILLING EFFECT ON THE

MICROSTRUCTURE AND MECHANICAL PROPERTIESS ALLOY WITH A (AL-SI-

MG-MN-CU)

SUNDARAMOORTHY R1, JUSTIN MARIA HILLARY J2, RAJA BALAYANAN S R3,

RANGARAJAN R V4 & KALIDAS K5

1,2,4,5Assistant Professor, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Hindusthan Institute of Technology,

Coimbatore, Tamilnadu, India

3Professor, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Hindusthan Institute of Technology,

Coimbatore, Tamilnadu, India

The study on the high energy ball milling effect on the microstructure and mechanical propertiess alloy with

a (Al-Si- Mg-Mn-Cu)

ABSTRACT

Mechanical alloys are a powder-processing system for solid state processing that require repetitive welding, fracturing

and rewelding in a high-energy ball mill for powder particles. Mechanical alloy was now seen to be able to synthesise a

number of balances and phases of non-equilibrium alloying from mixed or pre-alloyed powders. Materials that do not

have a traditional shape have been shown to achieve extraordinary features in a nanolevel. As casting requirements for

automobiles and aircraft for the engine parts, Al-Si alloys containing other transition metals are used. The present

study attempts have been carried out to improve the alloy by means of mechanical alloying pathways.

KEYWORDS: Investigation, Microstructure, Alloy & Mechanical Properties

Received: Jun 15, 2020; Accepted: Jun 22, 2020; Published: Oct 22, 2020; Paper Id.: IJMPERDJUN20201534

1. INTRODUCTION

Due to their present and/or future uses in a large range of technical fields such as sensors, catalysis, ceramics,

magnetic data storage, structural components and others, nanomaterials are rapidly evolving in recent years. The

size of materials can be decreased to the nanometer scale to satisfy the technical demands in these sectors. The

miniaturisation of electronic functional instruments, for example, involves placing or assembly of components of

the nanometer in specified structures. The materials demonstrate unusual and fascinating mechanical and physical

properties as they decrease in size to the nanometer scale , e.g. improved mechanical power, improved

diffusiveness, higher specific heating and electric resistance compared with conventional grass grains. Materials

that have grain sizes of a billionth of the metre are nanomaterials (nanocrystalline materials). They demonstrate

very interesting and versatile features that can be used for a number of structural and non-structural applications

[1].

It is necessary to distinguish nanomaterials into nanocystalline materials and nanoparticles. The above are

polycrystalline coarse materials with the size of grain within the spectrum (less than 100 nm), and the latter are

ultra-fine particles of less than 100 nm of diameter nano sections are nanos. Generally used as building blocks in

Orig

ina

l Article

International Journal of Mechanical and Production

Engineering Research and Development (IJMPERD)

ISSN (P): 2249–6890; ISSN (E): 2249–8001

Vol. 10, Issue 3, Jun 2020, 16195-16208

© TJPRC Pvt. Ltd

16196 Sundaramoorthy R, Justin Maria Hillary J, Raja Balayanan S R,

Rangarajan R V & Kalidas K

Impact Factor (JCC): 8.8746 SCOPUS Indexed Journal NAAS Rating: 3.11

bulk products nanocrystalline. Nanomaterial science is a multidisciplinary endeavour involving cooperation between

physics, chemistry, mechanicals, and materials experts, including biology and medicine science in nanomaterials.The

involvement in fundamental science study and its technical implications has been promoted. nanomaterials and much of

their implementations are also at an early stage of technological growth. Many problems need to be resolved until

nanomaterials are theoretically useful in the industry. These concerns involve a synthesis of extremely clean, cost- and

environmentally efficient materials, the characterisation of modern nanophase material architectures and properties, the

manufacture of completely dense, lower-contaminant nanoparticle goods, and preservation of the ultimate grain size to

maintain the mechanical properties associated with this method. Latest nanoparticles processing technology is scalable and

involves a selection of manufacturing routes for vapour, liquid and solid state.

The available techniques for nanoparticles synthesising through vapour paths vary from deposition through

physical vapour and chemical vapour deposition to aerosol spraying. Mechanical milling and mechanochemical synthesis

is used to prepare the path for the solid state. There are advantages and disadvantages in each form. Mechanical milling for

friction and spray conversion was widely used to manufacture vast volumes of nanopowders. Synthesized nanoparticles on

various routes can include different internal frameworks and may influence the characteristics of the consolidated

materials. It is very challenging to transform nanoparticles into fully dense bulk or coating materials that maintain the

nanometer-scale grain dimension. Nanoparticles have a high reactivity and strong potential to agglomerate owing to their

high defined surface areas. In addition, quick growth of grain occurs at high temperatures during processing. It is important

to hold the nanoparticles on a nanometer scale during consolidation to form bulk materials as their special properties

extracted from their fine grain measurements. Pores are often created from large; nanocystalline materials condensed with

nanoparticles prepared using inert gas condensation. These nanopores may result in a reduction in Young's nanochristalline

consolidation module [2]. Electrodeposited samples, while free of porosity, have some impurities and texture which can

degrade their mechanical efficiency. The biggest difficulties encountered by researchers are therefore the regulation of

these properties during synthesization and eventual consolidation. The special features of nanocrystalline materials come

from their various grain limits, contrasted with the polycristalline coarse-grained equivalents. A significant fraction of

atoms (up to 49%) are boundary atoms in nanocrystalline solids. The interface configuration also plays an important role in

the physical and mechanical characteristics of nanocrystalline materials. Huang stated that the resistivity of

nanochrystalline copper is far higher than that for bulk copper. They contributed this to the increased dispersion of

electrons at the grain limit. With the recent creation of nanocrystalline materials, a great deal of study needs to be

performed in order to explain the fundamental behaviour of the deformations and fractures.

Nanostructures are a diverse variety, with microstructures in lengths of less than 100 nm modulated in zero- to

three dimensions. This compounds are atoms structured in nanosize clusters that become the material's constituents.

Standard materials produce several billion atoms and have sizes of grains varying from microns up to several millimetres.

Just approximately 900 atoms are found in nanometer grains. The volume fraction of the grain borders or interfaces has

risen significantly as grain size declines. The chemical and physical properties of this feature have a strong effect. The

yield power of nanophase metals and elastic modulus improve considerably. The other major interest in producing carbon

nanostructures that have to do with the famed Buckyball has already been seen. Furthermore, it is interesting to use nano-

sized materials as composite fillers. In the case of nanocomposites, in particular. Both materials are made of grain that

contains a large number of atoms in turn. These seeds, due to their height, are typically unseen to the naked eye.

Conventional materials have various scale grains ranging from 100 microns (μm) to mm. A nanometer (nm), which is a

The Investigation on the High Energy Ball Milling Effect on the Microstructure and 16197

Mechanical Propertiess Alloy with A (Al-Si- Mg-Mn-Cu)


billionth (10-9) metre, is much smaller than one μm. In an order of 1-100 nm a nanocrystalline substance has grains. The

atom's typical scale is approximately 1 and 2 angstroms (Å) in the radius. 1 nanometer consists of 10 Å; and in one nm,

according to the atomic radii, there can be 3-5 atoms. Nanocrystalline materials are highly strong, strong and ductile,

resistant to degradation, deterioration, corrosion and chemically very active at high temperatures. Often, nanocrystalline

materials called nanomaterials are far more formable than their widely usable generic equivalents [3].

Five widespread methods of nanomaterial processing are described as follows:

Synthesis sol-gel.

Condensing inert gas.

Mechanical alloy or ball mill.

Synthesis of the plasma.

Depositioning of electrodes.

The synthesis is predominantly metal oxides (Binary, Ternary, etc.), which have been added to non-oxid content

by hydrolysis and condensation response of sufficient precursors.

A change made of a scraper and collection mechanism makes the development, in the apparatus itself without

exposing it to air, of comparatively big amounts of nanoparticles that are agglomerated but do not shape difficult

agglomerations. This method was developed by the Birringer and Gleiter group. The added molecular weight or strain of

the inert gas contributes to an improvement of the average particle size. This so-called inert gas condensation approach is

now used for a large variety of materials on a commercial scale.

The system of producing oxide dispersion hardened nickel alloys originally developed is a high-energy milling

process in which alloys benefit from frequent cracks and cold welding of the components. The method allows for the

preparation of extremely metastable materials such as amorphous alloys and nanostructured materials. It seems easy to scal

up to industrial amounts. High energy frying will cause chemical reactions in the framing phase and the product's

properties in addition to attrition and agglomeration. This was achieved by way of mechanically caused displacement

reactions between a metal oxide and a more reactive metal to prepare magnetic-metal nanocomposites. High energy ball

milling may also affect chemical adjustments in binary structures, such as silicates, stones, ferry materials, ceramics and

organic composites, in non-metallurgical structures. To study and use these processes, the research field of

mechanochemistry has been created. As there are several chemical variations in mechanical alloying methods, the

differentiation between mechanical alloy and mechanochemistry is often subjective [4].

Plasma synthesis was extended to specialised material preparation, including modern ceramics, metal nanometric

powder, biomaterials as well as superconductors. Depending on the conditions used, the standard dimensions of the

resulting nanoparticles vary from 20 to 100 nm. Such materials exhibit peculiar properties in comparison to their broad

states (chemical, physical, electrical, optical, mechanical, magnetic etc.). The nanopowder development is one of the most

important induction plasma applications. The plasma torch has a strong flexibility and manufacturing chemistry resistance

since there are no metalic electrodes for reactants and oxidising nor reducing atmospheres can also be used.

Electrodeposition consists of electrode interactions involving a rigid metal and the dissolved ion oxidation and

reduction. e.g. if a copper metal rod is dropped into a solution containing copper sulphate, corses containing copper will be




converted to copper metal cations or copper cations can be caught anodically into copper ions. Compare the redox reaction

where oxidised and reducing species both are in solution [5]. These processes are also defined by the words

"electrodeposition" or "electrodissolution”.

But where the substrate is an arranged semiconductor crystal (e.g. silicone, gallium arsenide), this method may be

started building on the substratium in the same crystallographical emphasis, with the substrate serving as the seed for the

deposition. This technology is very close to what occurs in CVD processes. The film would therefore be an amorphous or

polycrystalline film where a polycrystalline surface is used.

2. SURVEY LITRATURE

As nanomaterials have special and advantageous chemical, physical and mechanical properties, they could be used for

various applications. The following are but are not restricted to these applications:

a) High strength implementation.

b) Electrical and magnetic appliances.

c) High sensitivity sensors.

d) Hydrogen storage.

e) Technology for biology.

f) Dielectric features semi-leading.

g) Kinetic Energy (KE) penetrators also improved their lethality.

h) High capacity batteries.

i) Long-length spacecraft.

j) To function longer on surgical devices.

k) Large electrical projection devices.

The alloy is mechanically unbalanced and can contribute, as an example, to a cluster of atoms of chromium by

repeated rinsing at low temperatures. The standard thermodynamic solution forming principle starts with the combining of

atoms. The solution is however formulated in the mechanical alloy by first combining part lumps, each of which may

comprise several millions of similar atoms. Here we look at the manner in which a solution from these broad bulbs evolves

into an intimate mix of various types of atoms without diffusion or melting, and this leads to fascinating findings that affect

our understanding of the mechanical alloying method. Find the pure A and B components of the μo A and μo B free molar

capacity. If the components are first in powder phase, the average free energy in such a powder combination is simply:

(1 — x) μoA + xμo; in x is mole fraction of a mole, the fraction B




Figure 1: Powder Production Phases for Mechanical Alloys

The powder particles are believed to be so great that the A and B atoms don't sense the presence of one another by

way of interatomic forces between separate atoms. The amount of directions in which the powder particle mixture may be

structured is often believed to not be very distinct from unit in order to allow a major contribution to mixing configuration

entropy. The energy is free and is only a unit weight of the components [6]. In comparison to a mechanical mixture, a

combination of atoms or molecules is historically represented as a solution. (Figure 1)

The extreme mechanical alloy deformation will push atoms in locations in which they might not be in order. The

atomic composition of strong solutions in mechanical alloying processes of industrial interest may be achieved using ion

microscopic field and atomic probe to be tested.

Mechanical alloys are a dynamic operation, and so a variety of variables are tailored for the ideal product step

and/or microstructure. Four of the key parameters controlling the final powder formation are:

a) Container for milling

b) Speed for milling

c) Time to mill

d) Melting medium sort, size and capacity allocation

e) Weight percentage ball to powder

f) Atmosphere of milling

g) Friction temperature.

All of these method factors are not totally distinct. The optimum milling period for example is dependent on

milling form, size of a grinding medium, framing temperature, ball-to-powder ratio, etc.

For mechanically alloying powder various forms of high-energy friction machinery are used. They vary in

capacity, milling efficiency and add'l heating, cooling, etc.

a) Mills of SPEX shaker




b) Mills of attrition

c) Mills of Commercial

d) Ball mills planetary (to be included in our tests).

Shaker machines, such as SPEX mills, that mill around 10±20 g of powder at such a period, are more widely used

for laboratory and alloy screening applications (Figure 2).

The modern ball mill consists of a horizontal spinning disc, half-filled with tiny steel spheres. When the drum

rotates, the balls falls on the metal powder that is ground (Figure 3).

Figure 2: Mills of SPEX Shaker

Figure 3: Mills of Attrition




The planetary ball mill (known as Pulverisette) in which some few hundred grammes of powder could be milled

at a time is another common mill for carrying out MA experiments. The celestial ball mill owes its name to the vials'

celestial revolution. They are arranged on a spinning support disc, and they spin along their own axis through a special

drive mechanism [7]. The centrifugal force generated by the vials 12 that revolve about their very own axes and that the

spinning support disc creates works both on the contents of the vial consisting of the ground material and the grinding

balls. The centrifuge forces alternately work in identical and opposite ways, so the vials and the supporting disc spin in

opposite directions [8]. This allows the grinding balls to flow the friction effect into the inner wall of the container,

accompanied by the ground and grinding balls, which freely raise and move the inner chamber of the container, clash with

the impact effect against the interior wall (Figure 4).

Figure 4: Ball Mills Planetary




Figure 5: Forces Acting in Ball Mills

While in the earlier models, the disc and the vial rotation velocity cannot be independently controlled, it can be

done in modern versions. Mixing vials and balls can be used in eight separate materials: agate, silicon nitride, sintered

corundum, zirconia, chrome alloy, tungsten carbide, Cr+Ni stainless steel and polyamide [9,10]. Since the linear speeds of

these mills are similar than the speeds of SPEX mills, in the SPEX mills the rate of effect is slightly higher.

a) Its cells are arranged on a revolving support disc in the planetary Ball Mill.

b) They spin about their own axis through a special drive device.

c) The impact force distorts the powder particles plastically.

d) The particles harden and fracture their job.

e) The newly engineered surfaces cause the particles to sweat jointly.

f) Particle includes substantially all original components to the degree that they have been combined.

3. EXPERIMENTAL WORK

The composition that was examined

Al- 20% Si 5 %Mg 1.1% Mn 0.8% Cu 1.0%

The powder is measured and blended in stoichiometrical quantities. Milling done in a ball mill celestial. Fricting

was set for 10 minutes in a planetary ball mill and for 15 minutes at breaktime as high energy levels were evolving while

milling and it might produce risks. This was achieved. To hold the powder mix at room temperature, the milling was done

in the medium. Total friction time for containers was 24Hr with the required friction speed of 300rpm.

After every 5 hours of friction carried out in the phillips expert method, samples have been obtained for XRD

study. The standard diffractograms are shown in Figure 6. The comparison of the diffractor graphs reveals progressing line

expansion in function of the annealing temperature; Fig- reveals the first overlapped aluminium peak.




Figure 6: Typical Mechanically Alloyed X-ray Diffractogram

By utilising the x-ray peak enlargement methods, the crystallite diameter and grid strain may be calculated in

powder crystals. Demographics in X-ray diffraction are expanded because:

Tooling impacts,

Scale of tiny particles,

The lattice strain of the material.

But this basic approach may only be acceptable if one is involved in following the pattern of the crystallite shift in

size under fraising conditions. The X-ray peak expansion is invariably proportional to cos θ regular due to its tiny

crystallite size. Table 1 indicates the reduction in particle size with a rise.

Table 1: Particle Size Reduction

S.No Milling time (Hrs) Particle Size (Angstrom)

1 6 262.13

2 12 244.34

3 18 231.14

4 24 212.46

5 30 213.12




Figure 7: As a function of Milling Period, the Particle Size.

The crystallite size is most often determined by measuring the maximum width of Bragg at half the maximum

intensity, and placing its value in the following formula of the sherrer:

d=0.9 λ/ (B cosθ)

d is the size of the crystal,

μ is the X-radiation wavelength used,

B is the maximum width at a maximum of half the maximum and Bragg is the upper half (θ).

The diagram between particle sizes vs. milling period Figure 7 indicates that with the rise in milling time, the

particle has become finer. The milling has been carried out and reports are presented for 24 hours. Green pellets with a

diameter between fifteen to twenty mm from the mechanically alloyed powder blend. By adding a pressure of four tonnes

using a hydraulic system and 10 mm in height. At four fifty degrees Celsius for half an hour, they were then sintered.

In addition, another series of tests has been arranged, as given below. A mixing machine was used to render a

powder mixture of the same composition, resulting in ordinary mixing. This powder mixture was used to manufacture

green pellets, accompanied by sintering, as shown in table number 2, following the plan.

Table 2: Values in Sintering

S.no Temperature sintering in Celsius (x1) The Compaction Pressure(Tons)

(x2)

1 350 4

2 450 4

3 350 6

4 450 6

5 400 5

After the sintering of green pellets, one load was checked for compressive strength on the INSTRON unit, while

the other set was used for optical microscopy showed the microstructure. The strengths of the compression of the




specimens are tabled along with the research plan and outlined in Table 3.

Table 3: Strength Comparisons

S.No Temperature for Sintering in Celsius (x1) The Compaction Pressure

(Tons) (x2)

Strength in

Compressive (Mpa)

1 350 4 112.2

2 450 4 122

3 400 5 162.2

4 350 6 154.6

5 450 6 178.2

The system of predictive statistics was used to formulate a regression equation experiment model. The x1 and x2

coefficients have high positive values suggesting that both temperature and pressure have a high rising effect, while

pressure has a greater influence than temperature. The experiment performed with a compaction pressure of 400 degrees

celcious and five tones resulted in a compressive strength of 162.2MPa, which is very similar to the bo value of 159.314

MPa.

The correlation seen between compressive strength of samples provided by the mixer and mechanical alloy is

shown in Table 4.

Table 4: Correlation between Compressive Strength

S.No Mixing Type Temperature Sintering in

celcius

Compaction pressure

(Tones)

Strength in compressive

(Mpa)

1 Mixing simple 400 5 162.2

2 Mechanical

Mixing 400 5 208.4

3 Mechanical

Mixing 400 6 232.2

The pellets made of mechanically alloyed powder (24 hour milling period and compaction pressure were five

tones and 400 degree sintering temperature and half an hour sintering period) were compressive strength 208.4 Mpa. This

value is greater than 162.2 MPa obtained for powder produced from standard compounds and due to the strong reactivity

arising from the processing of large surfaces, this value is related to improved bonding between particles from

mechanically alloyed samples. Another sample, mechanically alloyed but with 6 tonne of compaction pressure at the same

temperature, four hundred degrees celcious, mechanically allotted but six tones, of compaction temperature indicates a

compressive resistance of 232.2 MPa.




Figure 8: SEM Images

Figure 8 above shows the sampling semiconductors for mechanical alloys. Where such pores are less counted, as

in the mechanically alloyed sample. Furthermore, grain limits can also be observed in certain regions of the sample

mechanically alloy, suggesting that alloy forming happened in areas where such is absent as in usual mixed samples.

CONCLUSIONS

The exact composition of the XRD shall be verified between Al, Si, Mg, Cu and Fe.

The finer aspect is shown by the extension of the XRD peaks in function of the milling time.

Compaction and temperature sintering has a growing effect, whereas the regression equation has an impact on the

temperature.

REFERENCES

1. R Sundaramoorthy, R Ravindran (2018), “Amalgamation of aluminium-Mg2Si alloys in various weight percentage and study

of their tensile and wear behaviours”, International Journal of Additive and Subtractive Materials Manufacturing, vol.2, no.1,

pp.45-60.

2. Grimanelis D. and Eyre T. S, (2007) , “Wear characteristics of diffused bonded sintered steel with short term surface

treatment”, wear, vol.262 pp. 93 – 103.

3. R Sundaramoorthy, R Ravindran (2019), “Tool wear optimization in CNC milling operation of Al–Mg2Si alloys by Taguchi

method”, Springer Nature Applied Sciences, vol.1, no.9, pp.1093.

4. Michal G.M., Kahn H. and Cao Y. (2006), “Carbon super saturation due to Para equilibrium carburization: stainless steel

with greatly improved mechanical properties”, Acta materialia, vol.54, pp. 1597 – 1606.

5. R.Sundaramoorthy, J.Justin Maria Hillary, S.R.Raja Balayanan, K.Kalidas, R V Rangarajan, (2020), “Composite Wear

Actions of Glass Fiber Reinforced Titanates Filled Epoxy Resin”, International Journal of Recent Technology and

Engineering (IJRTE), vol.9, no.3, pp.642-647.

6. R Sundaramoorthy, R Ravindran (2017), “Synthesis of Aluminum-Magnesium Silicide (Al-Mg2Si) Alloys and Study of their

Mechanical Properties”, Journal of Material Science and Surface Engineering, vol.5, no.2, pp.533-536.

7. R Sundaramoorthy, R Ravindran (2016), “Experimental Investigation of Cutting Parameters in CNC end Milling Process for

Aluminum-Magnesium Silicide(Al-Mg2Si) Alloys Using Taguchi Method”, International Journal of Printing, Packaging &




Allied Sciences , vol.4, no.5, pp.3547-3551.

8. R Sundaramoorthy, R Ravindran (2016), “Wear Rate Estimation of Aluminum Magnesium Silicide (Al-Mg2Si) Alloys and

Study of their Recent Advances”, International Journal of Printing, Packaging & Allied Sciences , vol.4, no.5, pp.3407-3412.

9. R Sundaramoorthy, R Ravindran (2016), “Surface Roughness Prediction for CNC End Milling Process Using Genetic

Algorithm”, Journal of applied sciences research, vol.11, no.23, pp.236-240.

10. J Hillary, Justin Maria, R Ramamoorthi, J Joseph, Dixon Jim, C Samuel, Samson Jerold (2019), “A study on microstructural

effect and mechanical behaviour of Al6061–5% SiC–TiB2 particulates reinforced hybrid metal matrix composites”, Journal of

Composite Materials, vol.54, no.17, pp.2327-2337.

11. Rajesh Purohit, R.S. Rana, C.S.Verma (2012), “Fabrication of Al-SiC Composite through Powder Metallurgy Processing and

Testing of Properties, International Journal of Engineering Research and Application”,Vol.2, Issue.3, pp.420-437.

12. Suryanarayanank, Praveen, Raghuraman (2013), “Silicon carbide reinforced aluminium metal matrix composite for

aerospace application”, International Journal of Innovative Research in Science Engineering and Technology, vol. 2 no.11.

Pp.120-128.

13. Basvakumar K.G (2009), ‘Sliding wear Behavior of Al-Si alloys in their cast form’ Mater. Des, vol.30, pp.1258– 1267.

14. Bhaskar H B 2012, ‘Dry Sliding Wear Behavior of Aluminum/Be3Al2(SiO3)6 Composite Using Taguchi Method” Journal of

Minerals and Materials Characterization and Engineering, vol.11, pp.679-684.

15. Preciado M. and Bravo P. M., (2006), Effect of low temperature tempering prior cryogenic treatment on carburized steels,

Journal of material processing technology, 176, pp. 41 – 44.

THE INVESTIGATION ON THE HIGH ENERGY BALL MILLING … · 2020. 10. 22. · High energy ball milling...

Documents

Transcript of THE INVESTIGATION ON THE HIGH ENERGY BALL MILLING … · 2020. 10. 22. · High energy ball milling...