The Internal Meeting of HAPUA Working Group No. 2 Dr. Suthep Chimklai (Project Coordinator) Jakarta,...

The Internal Meeting of The Internal Meeting of HAPUA Working Group No. 2HAPUA Working Group No. 2

Dr. Suthep Chimklai (Project Coordinator)

Jakarta, Indonesia25 February 2009

HAPUA Working Group No. 2HAPUA Working Group No. 2Jakarta, Indonesia 25 February 2009

Brief of the Previous Meeting

Work Undertaken in year 2007/2008- Progress on 15 ASEAN Interconnection Projects- Action Plan of ASEAN Power Grid (APG)- Updates on Sub-Working Group’s Activities

- Operation & Maintenance SWG- System Operations SWG- Planning & Interconnection SWG

Other Matters- Progress Propose TOR for WG2- New HAPUA Country Coordinator – Thailand- Next Meeting

Brief of the Previous MeetingBrief of the Previous Meeting


The 24th Meeting of the HAPUA Council in Cebu, Philippines on 19 June 2008

Adopted the cancellation of SWG on Transmission PricingEstablished System Operation Sub Working Group (SO SWG) under WG2 and lead by IndonesiaTOR of WG2 need to be revised to accommodate establishing of System Operation SWG



The 9th Meeting of the HAPUA Working Committee in Singapore during 1-2 December 2008

Follow-up Complete report on EMF Mitigation/Management, Blackout Recovery and Right-of-Way (ROW) Remark: All 3 complete reports were already submitted since 31 July 2008

All member countries to submit comments on the draft TOR for SO-SWG and assign representative to 1st Meeting of SO-SWG. All member countries to submit the request data for AIMSThe Committee agreed that the Special HAPUA Working Committee will be conducted in Feb. 2009 to endorse the final draft of the AIMS review and final report to be submitted to the next HAPUA CouncilThe 10th Meeting of WC and the 25th Meeting of HAPUA Council will be held in May 2009 in Singapore



The 3rd Meeting of APGCC in Singapore, 3 December 2008

Meeting requested HAPUA Secretariat to invite ACE and ASEC representative in future APGCC MeetingMeeting agreed HAPUA Secretariat to clarify with ACE and ASEC on the status EAEF (EC-ASEAN Energy Facility) and BIMP-EAGA (The Brunei-Indonesia-Malaysia-Philippines East ASEAN Growth Area)Chairman informed that with the endorsement of SOME/AMEM, APGCC would be the ONLY body to undertake the implementation of APGMeeting informed that under the APAEC 2010-2015 i.e. Strategy No. 2; the subject of the ASEAN Fuel Policy and security of supply will be part of the strategy to be implemented.The Meeting took note of the need for WG2 to prepare the proposal to include the Scope of work and Cost on possibility of engaging external consultant to assist WG2



The 3rd Meeting of APGCC in Singapore, 3 December 2008

WG2 to clearly define the two levels of interconnection1. Interconnection between two countries that will remain to be bilateral.2. Interconnection that formed the backbone

WG 2 role in preparing the common Grid Code of ASEAN Power Grid (Grid Code and Planning Criteria), the Code of Planning and Operation RulesThe Committee suggested WG2 look into the existing operating model of the EU or North American as well as GMS modelWG2 need to complete all engineering design and viability of the project before it can be tabled as financially viable. Next APGCC Meeting will be conducted back to back with HAPUA Council Meeting tentatively scheduled in June 2009 in Singapore


Work Undertaken in year 2007/2008Work Undertaken in year 2007/2008

Progress onProgress on15 ASEAN Interconnection Projects15 ASEAN Interconnection Projects

Progress on 15 ASEAN Interconnection ProjectsProgress on 15 ASEAN Interconnection Projects

Expected COD

1) P.Malaysia - Singapore Existing

2) Thailand - P.Malaysia • Sadao - Bukit Keteri

Existing• Khlong Ngae - Gurun

Existing• Golok - Rantau Panjang

Newly Proposed3) Sarawak - P. Malaysia

20134) P.Malaysia - Sumatra

20125) Batam - Singapore

20156) Sarawak - West Kalimantan

20127) Philippines - Sabah

20158) Sarawak - Sabah - Brunei

20159) Thailand - Lao PDR

• Roi Et - Nam Theun 22009

• Udon - Nabong2011

• Mae Moh - Hong SaUnder Negotiation

10) Lao PDR - Vietnam2010

11) Thailand - Myanmar 2014

12) Vietnam - Cambodia 2009

13) Lao PDR - Cambodia2010

14) Thailand - Cambodia Existing

15) Sabah - East Kalimantan Newly Proposed

MY

AN

MA

R

PHILIPPINES

CAMBODIA

SUMATRA

INDONESIA

SARAWAK

BRUNEI

P. MALAYSIA

PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINAYUNNAN

BATAM

VI ETNAM

WEST

KALIMANTAN

SINGAPORE

8

11

14

10

6

12

43

1

7

2

5

9

13

15


No. PROJECT DESCRIPTION UTILITIES INVOLVED

STATUS

1 PENINSULAR MALAYSIA – SINGAPORE(Short term)

TNB

SPPG • Commissioned in 1985.• The interconnection is between

Plentong 275kV Substation in Johor, Malaysia and Upper Jurong 230kV Substation in Singapore

• For year 2007, the availability of the interconnection has been at 99.82%.



STATUS

2 THAILAND – PENINSULAR MALAYSIA

a) Sadao -Bukit Keteri (Short term)

EGATTNB

• The stage I interconnection is now used as a backup interconnection.

b) HVDC Links between Khlong Ngae-Gurun(Medium term)

• The Stage II (HVDC) interconnection project (transfer capability of 300 MW) was completed in September 2001. The HVDC system comprises a 110km DC transmission line capable of transferring 300MW between a 275kV DC converter substation in Gurun, Kedah, Malaysia and a 230kV DC converter substation in Khlong Ngae, Thailand.

• Meetings have been held to study the upgrading of project from 300MW to 600MW. However based on the preliminary findings of the AIMS, the need to upgrade to 600MW is found to be feasible only in 2024.

c) 132kV Transmission Line between Golok Th - Rantau Panjang, Kelantan, PM

• Newly Proposed, The 1st Meeting between TNB and EGAT is under preparation.



STATUS

3 SARAWAK – PENINSULAR MALAYSIA(Medium term)

SESCoTNB

• Detailed technical studies are currently being undertaken in view of implementing the HVDC interconnection between Sarawak and Peninsular Malaysia for transferring 1600/2000 MW power from Bakun HEP to the TNB Grid system in Peninsular Malaysia.

• The 1st stage of the 800/1000 MW power transfer is targeted for completion in 2013.



STATUS

4 PENINSULAR MALAYSIA - SUMATRA(Medium term)

TNBPLN

• Detailed feasibility study carried out jointly by TNB and PLN in collaboration with Shaw PTI USA (now Siemens PTI USA). Study completed in December 2005. Results presented to Management of both TNB and PLN in February 2005.

• TNB and PLN have agreed to further study the financial viability of the project.

• Technical and financial studies have been done. Awaiting next level decision to steer the project forward.

• Joint Workshop between PLN, TNB and Japan Bank for International Cooperation (JBIC) held in Kuala Lumpur in September 14, 2006. There is an intention of JBIC to finance the said project.

• The detail engineering study is completed and seeking for financing support.



STATUS

5 BATAM - BINTAN - SINGAPORE - JOHOR(Long term)

PLNSPPGTNB

• PLN has conducted a preliminary study on the project and the study result has been extended to both TNB (Malaysia) and Power Grid (Singapore) in the 12th ASEAN Interconnection Meeting for review.

• The Batam-Singapore interconnection has been identified by AIMS for completion by 2014 (1st Stage)

• Due to the power market reform in Singapore, the development of this interconnection project would depend on the private sector / third party participation.




STATUS

6 SARAWAK – WEST KALIMANTAN(Medium term)

SESCoPLN

• Both PLN and SESCo have completed the Basic Design Studies on the proposed interconnection.

• Line route survey from the Mambong substation in Sarawak to the interconnection point at the town of Serikin has been completed since the last quarter of 2003.

• AIMS recommended the interconnection in 2007 with maximum capacity of 300MW as an energy exchange scheme.

• The project has been studied in detail under the “Trans-Borneo Power Grid Interconnection Study” funded by EAEF. The Study considered an interconnection by the year 2008. Between 250-350MW of power export by the year 2020 was considered.

• A follow-up meeting between SESCO-PLN was held in Jakarta in Dec 2004 to discuss the actions necessary to get the groundwork going.

• A meeting between SESCO and PLN was held in Kuching in Aug 2005 to discuss the further bilateral actions necessary to get the project going.

• As a result of the Aug 2005 meeting, SESCO developed the terms of reference for a proposed “Control and Operations of the 275kV Sarawak-West Kalimantan Interconnection” study to be jointly carried out.

• The Special Meeting of Energy Working Group of BIMP-EAGA in November 2006 in Bandung, West Java proposed an action plan for the project.




STATUS

7 PHILIPPINES – SABAH(Long term)

TRANSCO

SESB

• The result of AIMS final report indicates that the project is technically feasible but not economically viable at 500 MW Transfer capacity.

• TRANSCO will propose further study with possible funding under EAEF.

• Under reviewing the project timeline



STATUS

8 SARAWAK – SABAH –BRUNEI DARUSSALAMa) SARAWAK - SABAH

(Short term)

SESCoSESBDES

• Under study by SESB as part of the Bakun - Sabah Interconnection.

b) SABAH - BRUNEI DARUSSALAM

c) SARAWAK - BRUNEI DARUSSALAM

d) SARAWAK - BRUNEI - SABAH (Long term)

• AIMS recommended the interconnection of the Sarawak – Sabah - Brunei Darussalam systems in 2019 with maximum capacity of 300MW.

• The project has been studied in detail under the “Trans-Borneo Power Grid Interconnection Implementation Study” funded by EAEF. The Study considered an interconnection by the year 2008. Up to 250MW of power export by the year 2020 was considered.

• The Special Meeting of Energy Working Group of BIMP-EAGA in November 2006 in Bandung, West Java proposed an action plan for the project.



STATUS

9 THAILAND - LAO PDRa) Nam Theun 2 (920 MW)

EGATEDL • The Power Purchase Agreement (PPA)

Between EGAT and the developer of Nam Theun 2 Project was signed on November 8, 2003. The feasibility study of the transmission project on Thai side was submitted for approval from the Thai Government in February 2004. The interconnection project is expected to be completed in April 2009.

• COD 1 Nov. 2009

b) Udon Thani – Nabong Nam Ngum 2 (597 MW) Nam Ngum 3 (615 MW) Nam Theun 1 (523 MW) Nam Ngiep 1 (261 MW)

• COD 1 Mar. 2011• Under Negotiation• Under Negotiation• Under Negotiation

c) Mae Moh 3 (Nan) - Hong Sad) Mae Moh 3 (Nan) – Nam Ou

• Under Negotiation

c) Roi Et –Savannakhet(Medium term)

• No progress.

f) Ubol Ratchathani-Ban Sok (Medium Term)

• Pre-feasibility study completed in 2007 with ADB supports.



STATUS

10 LAO PDR – VIETNAM EDLEVN

• MOU has been signed by Vietnam and Lao PDR to carry out these projects.

• The Master Plan was approved by the Ministry of Industry of Vietnam.

a) Ban Sok-Pleiku(Medium term)

• COD 2014/15

b) Nam Theum 2 - Ha Tinh(Medium term)

• Pending

c) Nam Mo-Ban La(Medium term)

• Pending

d) Xekaman3-Thach My(Medium Term)

• COD 2009

e) Luong Prabang – Nho Quan (Long Term)

• The connection is under study now and expected to be completed in 2009



STATUS

11 THAILAND – MYANMARa) Hutgyi (7x185 MW)

EGAT• Feasibility Study completed mid 2007• Under the EIA study • COD 2014

b) Tasang • Under Negotiation for connecting lower dam (120 MW) to the Northern system of Thailand

• Under review pending financial support

12 VIETNAM - CAMBODIA(Short term)Chau Doc – Phnom Penh

EDLEVN

• Basic Design for Vietnam had been approved by EVN in 2002.

• EVN is started construction of 220 kV transmission line in mid 2003. The project of Vietnam side is completed in October 2006.

• The project is under construction and scheduled for commission in 2009



STATUS

13 LAO PDR - CAMBODIA(Short term)

EDLEDC

• MOU already signed in 1999.• Preliminary discussion and site visit has

been made in 2001 by EDC/EDL.• EDL is constructing the 115kV double

circuit transmission lines to Ban Hat substation which is 26 km from the border area and will be completed in mid 2005.

• The PPA was signed in 2007 and COD in 2010.

14 THAILAND - CAMBODIA(Short term)

EGATEDC

• Thailand and Cambodia have reacheda conclusion on the revision of tariff structure.

• Transmission on both sides have been completed and Start energized on 22 November 2007

15 Sabah - East Kalimantan PLN SESB

• Newly Proposed

Action Plan of ASEAN Power GridAction Plan of ASEAN Power Grid(2008-2015)(2008-2015)

Action Plan of ASEAN Power Grid (2008-2015) Action Plan of ASEAN Power Grid (2008-2015)

Activities Tentative Timeline

1. In accordance with the MOU on the APG, the HAPUA Council shall initiate the establishment of the ASEAN Power Grid Consultative Committee (APGCC)

1.1 Establishment of the APGCC by the 24th HAPUA Council Meeting

By June 2008 √√

1.2 Approval of the TOR by special Meeting of HAPUA Council

By June 2008 √√

1.3 Reporting of TOR to SOME/AMEM August 2008 in Bangkok, Thailand √√



2. Ratification or acceptance of MOU on ASEAN Power Grid by Member Countries

By December 2008√√

3. Review the 2003 ASEAN Interconnection Master Plan Study (AIMS)

By December 2008

3.1 Interim report to be presented at the 9th HAPUA Working Committee Meeting

By December 2008(Singapore)

4. Adoption of the revised AIMS by the 25th HAPUA Council as an updated reference document for Member Countries in implementing bilateral and/or multilateral power interconnection projects in ASEAN 2008-2015

By May 2009



5. APGCC to establish task-groups for the following studies as specified in the MOU on the APG (subject to confirmation by APGCC):

Subject to comment by Working Group 2, 5 & 6

5.1 Harmonization of legal and regulatory framework for bilateral and cross-border power interconnection and trade

WG 5 (proposed 2008-2010)

5.2 Harmonization of common Technical standards codes or guidelines of the ASEAN Interconnection Projects in the areas of:5.2.1 Planning and Design5.2.2 System Operation 5.2.3 Maintenance

WG 2 (2008-2010)

- PI SWG- SO SWG- O&M SWG



5. APGCC to establish task-groups for the following studies as specified in the MOU on the APG (subject to confirmation by APGCC):

Subject to comment by Working Group 2, 5 and 6

5.3 Formulation of institutional and contractual arrangements for cross-border electricity trade to include Taxation, Tariff and Third Party Access (Wheeling Charge)

WG 5(proposed to 2008-2010)WG 2 to assist in third party accessDraft TOR completed

5.4 Identify and recommend Financing Modalities for realizing the APG

WG 6 (proposed to 2008-2010)



6. Implementation of various bilateral and/or multilateral interconnection projects and reporting of project progress to HAPUA Council and SOME/AMEM

2008-2015

7. HAPUA Council to adopt the key findings and recommendation of the studies carried out by APGCC for submission to SOME/AMEM, with the view to implementing power interconnection and electricity trading in ASEAN

By 2014

8. Firm up the institutional and implementing arrangements to realize the ASEAN Power Grid (APG)

Starting 2015

Updates on Updates on Sub-Working Group’s ActivitiesSub-Working Group’s Activities

Updates on Sub-Working Group’s ActivitiesUpdates on Sub-Working Group’s Activities

Operation & Maintenance SWG• TNB has launched the website for sharing of the benchmarking

parameters and the benchmarking guidelines • O&M Benchmarking exercise to be concluded in the 4th Meeting of

O&M SWG during 19th – 20th August 2008, Selangor, Malaysia• The best performer will share the success story with others during

the HAPUA Technical Seminar organized by OM SWG tentatively by end of April 2009


System Operation SWG• SO SWG Leader: Indonesia

Mr. Nur Pamudji, General Manager of Java Bali Transmission and Control Center email : [email protected]

• Thailand Representative for SO SWGMr. Sompol Uthaichalanonta Assistant Director, System Control and Operation Division,Electricity Generating Authority of Thailand53 Moo 2 Charansanitwong Road,Bang Kruai, Nonthaburi 11130, ThailandTel. : +66 2436 2102Fax. :+66 2436 8390email : [email protected]


System Operation SWGTOR for SO SWG• Objectives

• To establish a common reference guide for system operation practices and standards among ASEAN utilities in preparation for the establishment of the ASEAN Power Grid (APG)

• Functions and Responsibilities • To establish a common reference guide for system operation practices and

standards among ASEAN utilities• To benchmark operation performance among ASEAN utilities• To exchange system operations experiences among members for best

practices• To exchange information on the equipment standard at the point of

interconnection• To exchange information on computer system performance (hardware and

EMS software)


System Operation SWGTOR for SO SWG• Action Plan

• Organize Power System Operators Workshop annually, every 2nd Quarter

• Annual Meeting to monitor and guide the Progress of Deliverables, every 4th Quarter

• Milestones2009. To look at other interconnected utilities guidelines, for

example NERC, EU and then determine the relevant references for ASEAN.

2010. To establish the criteria for the benchmarking of SO performance among ASEAN countries

2011. To develop the first draft of common reference guide2012. To issue the first version of common reference guide for SO

practices and standards


Planning Interconnection SWG• ASEAN Interconnection Master Plan Study (AIMS)

• Objectives • To harmonize planning criteria in transmission system planning

among ASEAN countries• To pursue AIMS and the realization of APG• To perform activities (upon its ability) in promoting the power

interconnection and trade• To identify barriers that would obstruct the implementation of

electricity trading in ASEAN countries

• Study Period: 2008-2025


Planning Interconnection SWG• ASEAN Interconnection Master Plan Study (AIMS)

Regional power development plan Objective Function (present value at 2007)

Plan without new exchange interconnections 227,476 MUSD

Plan with new interconnections 226,244 MUSDsave 1,232 MUSD

or 3,015 MW generating capacity


Planning Interconnection SWG• ASEAN Interconnection Master Plan Study (AIMS) 11 Interconnection Projects :1. Thailand - Lao PDR HVAC (PP) 5474 MW

2009-2015

2. Thailand - Lao PDR HVAC (EE) 600 MW 2014

3. Thailand - Cambodia HVAC (EE) 300 MW 2014

4. P.Malaysia - Sarawak HVDC (PP) 2000 MW 2014-2015

5. Sabah - Philippines HVDC (EE) 500 MW 2015

6. Sarawak - W. Kalimantan HVAC (EE) 100 MW 2016

7. P.Malaysia - Thailand HVDC (EE) Upgrading to 600 MW 2017

8. P.Malaysia - Sumatra HVDC (EE) 600 MW 2017

9. Thailand - Neighboring Countries PP 12890 MW2017-2024

10. Lao PDR - Neighboring Countries PP 260 MW2021-2025

11. Vietnam - Lao PDR* HVAC (PP) 1887 MW2007-2016

(* AIMS-I Study)

Other MattersOther Matters


Propose Revised TOR for WG 2

3. Scope of Work for Transmission Working Group3.2 Routine Works during the Year

3.2.8 To establish criteria for the benchmarking of system operations performance among ASEAN countries and report annually, in the form of documents

3.2.9 Exchange experiences and technology in system control and operation.

3.3 Works with Specific Schedule3.3.2 Review/update ASEAN Interconnection Master Plan (AIMS)

based on technical and economic point of view at the appropriate time frame.

3.4 Sub-working Groups3.4.2 A sub-working group on System Operations will be

established for exchanges of information, technology and experiences. The sub-working group will meet on an annual basis.


New HAPUA Country Coordinator - ThailandNew HAPUA Country Coordinator - Thailand

Mr. Sahust PratuknukulMr. Sahust PratuknukulDeputy Governor - Policy and PlanningDeputy Governor - Policy and Planning

Electricity Generating Authority of ThailandElectricity Generating Authority of Thailand

53 Moo 2 Charansanitwong Road,53 Moo 2 Charansanitwong Road,

Bang Kruai, Nonthaburi 11130, ThailandBang Kruai, Nonthaburi 11130, Thailand

Tel.Tel. +66 2436 3010+66 2436 3010

FaxFax+66 2436 3091+66 2436 3091

Email:Email: [email protected]@egat.co.th


Venue: Lao PDRTarget Date: March 2009 (to be reconfirmed by Lao PDR)

Next Meeting of WG 2

The Internal Meeting of HAPUA Working Group No. 2 Dr. Suthep Chimklai (Project Coordinator) Jakarta,...

Documents

Transcript of The Internal Meeting of HAPUA Working Group No. 2 Dr. Suthep Chimklai (Project Coordinator) Jakarta,...