THE CONSERVATION ADVISORY GROUP - Enfield

1

Contact: Andy Higham Direct: 020 8379 3848

or Ext:3848 e-mail: [email protected]

THE CONSERVATION ADVISORY GROUP

Tuesday, 30th September, 2014 at 7.00 pm in the Conference Room, Civic Centre, Silver Street, Enfield, EN1 3XA

Membership: Councillors : Dina Barry, Jason Charalambous, Daniel Pearce, Vicki Pite and Ozzie Uzoanya 1. CAG AGENDA 30TH SEPTEMBER 2014 (Pages 1 - 36)

Public Document Pack

This page is intentionally left blank

CONSERVATION ADVISORY GROUP Meeting: Tuesday 30th September 2014 at 7 PM Venue: Conference Room

Civic Centre, Silver Street, Enfield, EN1 3XA Contact: Andy Higham, Head of Development Management Direct dial: 020 8379 3848 Email: [email protected] Website: www.enfield.gov.uk MEMBERS Councillors: Barry, Pite, J Charalambous, Pearce, Uzoanya Co-opted: Mr D. Stacey - Bush Hill Park Conservation Area Study Group

Mr T Dey - Federation of Enfield Residents and Allied Associations Mr P. Fisk - Forty Hill and Bulls Cross Study Group

Ms L. Rawlings - Edmonton Study Group Dr C. Jephcott - The Enfield Society

Mrs C. Carter - Enfield Town Conservation Area Study Group Mrs A Bishop-Laggett - Federation of Enfield Residents and Allied Associations

Mrs I Stone - Southgate District Civic Trust Mr A. Hillman - Trent Park Conservation Committee Mr A Newman - Clay Hill Study Group Chris Horner - Southgate Green Study Group Mr P Hutchinson - Grange Park Conservation Area Study Group Mr T Hanrahan - Meadway Conservation Area Study Group Mr C Younger - Lakes Estate Conservation Study Group

Director - Environment

Page 1 Agenda Item 1

mailto:[email protected]

http://www.enfield.gov.uk/

AGENDA – PART 1 1. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE (if any) 2. DECLARATION OF INTERESTS

Members to identify any personal or prejudicial interests relevant to any items on the agenda. Please see attached guidance.

ATTACHMENT A

3. MINUTES

To confirm the Minutes of the meeting that took place on Tuesday 2nd September 2014.

ATTACHMENT B

4. PRESENTASTION BY THFC REGARDING PROPOSALS FOR

MYDDELTON FARM 5. LOCAL PLAN AND HERITAGE AND DESIGN PROJECTS UPDATE 6. PLANNING APPLICATIONS AND LISTED BUILDING APPLICATIONS FOR

DISCUSSION

ATTACHMENT C 7. CHAIRMAN’S FEEDBACK FROM PLANNING COMMITTEE

To receive information feedback from the CAG Chairman from Planning Committee of 23rd September 2014.

8. FEEDBACK ABOUT LAST MONTH’S CASES 9. CONSERVATION AREAS, LISTED BUILDING APPLICATIONS AND

APPEALS–DETERMINED ATTACHMENT D 10. OPEN SESSION

To enable members of the Conservation Advisory Group to bring up urgent matters not covered elsewhere on the agenda

Page 2

Minutes of the Conservation Advisory Group Meeting

2ndSeptember 2014

MEMBERS Councillors: D. Barry, P. Vicki B. Charalambous, J. Charalambous, D. Pearce &

O.Uzoanya Co-opted: Mr D. Stacey - Bush Hill Park Conservation Area Study Group

Mr T. Dey - Federation of Enfield Residents and Allied Associations Mr P. Fisk - Forty Hill and Bulls Cross Study Group

Ms L. Rawlings - Edmonton Study Group Dr C. Jephcott - The Enfield Society

Mrs C. Carter - Enfield Town Conservation Area Study Group Mrs A. Bishop-Laggatt - Federation of Enfield Residents and Allied Associations

Mrs I. Stone - Southgate District Civic Trust Mr A. Hillman - Trent Park Conservation Committee Mr A. Newman - Clay Hill Study Group Dr D. Ghandi - Southgate Green Study Group Mr C. Horner - Ditto Mr P.Hutchinson - Grange Park Conservation Area Study Group Mr T. Hanrahan - Meadway Conservation Area Study Group Mr C. Younger - Lakes Estate Conservation Study Group Officers: Andy Higham, Colin Vine & Christine White. Italics denote absence

Page 3

1. APOLOGIES FOR ABSENCE Cllr J. Charalambous

2. DECLARATION OF INTEREST

None given

3. MINUTES

The minutes of 29th July 2014 meeting were agreed as a true record with the following amendments; - Colin Younger raised the issue of a possible development adjacent to Arnos Grove Station; however Enfield has no knowledge of any such proposals. - Caroline Carter questioned the planning status of the recent application for 32 Little Park Gardens (see these minutes - section 6). - Irene Stone commented upon 18 The Green and the accuracy of the minute (Dennis Stacey commented that this matter has become so opaque and convoluted that an acceptable minute is proving difficult to formulate).

4. LOCAL PLAN AND HERITAGE AND DESIGN PROJECTS UPDATE

Christine White tabled her detailed briefing note which is attached to these minutes. Market Square

Christine White also reported on the site meeting to discuss the lighting of the Market Square (see previous minutes). As a result of the meeting the column mounted lights (of which there will be three) have been changed to a Victorian style four sided lamp. Discussions continue with CAG’s sub group as alternatives have been offered. TPCC asked for care to be taken with the type of bulb/light.

The design of the four, high mounted, replacement lights has been agreed. Town Park At CAG’s request Christine White tabled the consultation paper concerning the

works currently taking place in the Town Park. This paper had not reached CAG. It is a substantial water engineering exercise. Christine White was asked to arrange for the appropriate officer to address CAG on the technical aspects. (post meeting note - this has been arranged for the 30/9/14 meeting)

5. IDOX PLANNING SYSTEM At CAG’s request Colin Vine was invited to elucidate on the new planning system. Prior to the meeting five groups had written in with their questions. Colin Vine has produced a question and answer response (based on the points raised by each group) which will be emailed to all members.

Page 4

Members then took part in an open discussion on the new system. This seemed to relieve some of the tensions that had accumulated and was deemed useful. Regarding enforcement Dennis Stacey agreed to advise Colin Vine on the content required and report back to CAG.

6. PLANNING APPLICATIONS AND LISTED BUILDING APPLICATIONS

FOR DISCUSSION Former Council Car Park Cecil Road Enfield EN2 6TJ (14/02556/CND & 14/03275/CND) Fairview New Homes attended the meeting and were represented by Paul Lamar and Ian Howells. A presentation was made, by FNH, of the proposed materials for the elevations. The brick type and colour was deemed acceptable as was the render and mock stone. Whilst CAG has pursued Flemish bond for the elevation brickwork the group reluctantly accepted that it would be prohibitively expensive in cavity walls. The only issue that remained was the pointing. At an earlier meeting CAG had asked that the pointing be flush and closely matching the brick colour. The group considered that the pointing should “be lost” when viewing elevations. The sample offered did not meet these requirements. FNH was asked to return at the next meeting with further pointing samples. Brick sample - approved Render ditto - approved Mock stone - approved Pointing sample - not approved 38 Wades Hill London N21 1BG (14/02488/HOU) The primary concern with this proposal is the gable end and consequential loss of the balanced appearance of the property and roof scape The group noted that the terrace of properties can be clearly viewed as a whole including the shallow hip roof at either end. The group dismissed the suggestion that the adjoining property, to the south, gave any architectural justification to a gable end for No 38 (the adjoining property being of a completely different design). The roof profile of No38 is fundamental to the appearance of the terrace and a gable end would be totally inappropriate. Objection 325A Fore Street London N9 0PD (14/02663/FUL) On reflection this application was not of sufficient size to have warranted being an agenda item. However the proposal was reviewed by the group. The group were content to leave matters with the case officer. The only comments being that the deep facia be given discrete signage and reference made to the Shopfront Guide.

Page 5

Approved 18 Conical Corner Enfield EN2 6SL (14/02606/HOU) On reflection this application was not of sufficient size to have warranted being an agenda item. However the proposal was reviewed by the group. The group noted this was a rear extension that would be largely unseen from the public domain. It was noted that the proposal matches a, similar, extension to the neighbouring property. Approved 25 Lancaster Avenue Barnet EN4 0EP (14/02639/HOU) The proposal entails a large extension to an equally large house. The house being one half of a semi-detached. The group noted that the co-joined neighbour already sports a similar extension to that proposed. Further, as the ground level falls away sharply, front to back, then the visual impact of the proposal is somewhat diminished. The group was unable to support the installation of the three front roof lights. No other property, in the immediate vicinity, has roof lights. It would, therefore, set a precedent. Approved (subject to the removal of the front facing roof lights) 88 Broad Walk London N21 3BJ (14/03074/HOU) The group noted that the existing garage bears a closer relationship with the adjacent neighbour Woodside House than the applicant’s property. The garage has the appearance of a large rectangular box fronting directly on the back edge of pavement. The group welcomes its demolition. To the rear of the garage is a two storey building with a pleasing slate roof. This structure has an even closer relationship to Woodside House. The proposal seeks to replace one rectangular box with another and this is deemed unacceptable. CAG see a chance to improve this highly visible location with a building that improves the area. CAG recommended that design reference should be made to the slate clade building to the rear and introduce a pitched slate roof to the proposed granny flat. The roof should finish with a hip end at the boundary. Objection 88 Broad Walk London N21 3BJ (14/02564/HOU) The group found the rear elevation proposals extreme regarding the extent of the proposed glazing. The front dormers are acceptable providing they do not create a precedent.

Page 6

Objection 74 Vicars Moor Lane London N21 2QH (P14-02146PLA) Revised drawings were purported to have been received by Enfield but could not be located by Andy Higham. SDCY appeared to have evidence of some revised proposals. CAG re-iterated their earlier concerns namely, conservatory too large and an alien feature, irregularly positioned roof lights and interference with the historic fabric. This property along with it’s neighbours is one of the most beautiful Grade 2 listed terraces in the borough. Great care must be taken to preserve its integrity. Andy Higham offered to clarify the position regarding revised drawings and bring the application back to CAG. 32 Little Park Gardens Enfield EN2 6PQ (P14-02077PLA) There is confusion about the progress/status of this application. There are revised details circulating showing a half timber clad front elevation along with incorrectly proportioned windows. Andy Higham offered to clarify the position regarding revised drawings and bring the application back to CAG.

7. CHAIRMAN’S FEEDBACK FROM PLANNING COMMITTEE Only one item on the Planning Committee’s agenda of 19th August that had been before CAG, namely, 83 Old Park Ridings; see next section.

8. CONSERVATION OFFICER’S FEEDBACK ABOUT LAST MONTH’S CASES The Fallow Buck 226 Clay Hill Enfield EN2 9JD ((P14-02314 FUL) - Still under officer consideration (CAG objection). 1 Ellington Court High Street N14 6LB (P14-02447/CND) - Granted permission (CAG had no objection to the materials etc proposed). The Priory Hospital North London The Bourne N14 6RA (P14-01677PLA) - Refused permission (CAG objection) 83 Old Park Ridings N21 2ER (P14-01677PLA) - Granted permission (CAG

approval)

9. CONSERVATION AREAS, LISTED BUILDING APPLICATIONS AND APPEALS - DETERMINED

Noted

Page 7

10. OPEN SESSION - Dennis Stacey opened by asking groups to be specific and ensure items raised will be of relevance to all. Further, that all avenues have been exhausted (namely case officer/heritage officer/enforcement procedure etc) before bringing to Open Session. - Tony Dey once again raised the issue of banners and notices that adorn Enfield Grammar School. - Andrew Newman noted the swathes of external works taking place at Forty Hall that would, in any other circumstance, require planning permission. Christine White undertook to consult with the project officer and advise further. - Andrew Newman asked about the procedure for developing a neighbourhood plan and was referred to the Planning Policy Team. - Chris Jephcott stated that TES would make a £10k contribution for trees in the Town Park. - Chris Jephcott stated that a circular grove of Silver Birch trees, in the Town Park, in memory of Valerie Carter, has been cut down. - Dennis Stacey and Caroline Carter attended a consultative meeting regarding Enfield’s plans for the tea house in the Town Park. Other than a rear disabled access the building is not being altered externally. However it is early days and much will depend on bidder’s interest. 11. CALENDER OF MEETINGS The group was asked to note the calendar of meetings. The next meeting is on Wednesday, 30th September.

Christine White CAG BRIEFING 2nd SEPTEMBER 2014 The Crescent

• Works have now been completed, with the exception of 108 Hertford Road, where the owner has asked us to make some changes to how the works are being done.

• The contractor’s compound has been removed and outline designs have been

prepared for the reinstatement and enhancement of the Monmouth Road Open space. This will be subject of consultation with CAG soon.

• Newlon have appointed Millane Construction to undertake the parallel repair and redecoration works to the twelve Newlon properties. The front façade works were due to commence on Monday 8th August, starting with the construction of the boundary wall / railings between the front of 84 Hertford Road and the Monmouth Road Open Space. Newlon’s contractors are not

Page 8

yet on site and Newlon have been asked for an updated programme for the works to their properties.

Review of Conservation Area Appraisals / Management Proposals • The first drafts the Appraisal and Management Proposal documents for Phase

II of the CAA/CAMP Review i.e. Grange Park, Meadway Estate, Southgate Circus, The Crescent, Abbotshall Avenue and the Lakes Estate) have just been received and are currently being reviewed by officers.

• Consultation with local conservation area study groups will follow shortly, in the same way as for Phase I.

Local Heritage Review • The unexpected death of the lead consultant has led to a delayed start to this

programme. Discussion with the consultancy is ongoing, however, preparations are underway to re tender the contract for this project.

Broomfield House • Since the update given at the last meeting of CAG on 29th July the following

actions have been taken.

• Meetings have been arranged with the Portfolio Cabinet members for next week to authorise the commissioning of the Conservation Management Plan and Options Appraisal as necessary work to move towards a successful HLF funding bid.

• English Heritage has encouraged the Council to bring forward a Condition

Survey, Conservation Management Plan (CMP) and Options Appraisal. Officers have met with English Heritage, who has provided input into the project briefs. The procurement process is expected to start September / October. EH have also offered assistance with the selection of suitable consultants and input into the project delivery team.

• A Broomfield House Partnership Board has been established under the chairmanship of Cllr Bambos Charalambous, and draft terms of reference and membership for the Board have been prepared. The first meeting of the Partnership Board is expected to take place in the Autumn.

• The Council’s Property Services team, as Corporate Landlord, has commissioned a comprehensive Structural Appraisal to assess the stability and integrity of the remaining historic fabric of the House, from Conisbee, specialist heritage structural engineers. A draft of this report has been received and suggests that Broomfield House’s conservation is structurally achievable, although works to support the remaining structure and update the scaffold to comply with current regulations is required.

Page 9

• The first draft of the report from Paine and Stewart on the Lanscroon Mural has just been received and will be made available to the Trust. The report concludes that:

we have all of the walls and 10% of the ceiling (the latter in largely unuseable fragments)

the exact nature and current condition of the paint is unknown and needs testing to see how much original paint layer remains

the fragments require re packing in an updated storage system and a revised archival system.

• The report recommends the following in the Short term :

Re pack ceiling fragments in new boxes (wall fragment boxes are largely still acceptable) and record the data to proper standards.

Test safe removal of facing to assess condition Install insulation panels over the room windows Install purpose built horizontal shelving

The recommendations for the longer term are: Test nature of paint layer and full extent of original painting Reassemble pieces onto new dedicated support (dependant on

location).

Former MU Campus Trent Park • The site owner’s representative advised EH and the Council on 24th July that

she was presently in discussion with her client to finalise their aspirations for the site and will be in contact with the Council and English Heritage in due course. Officers will continue to monitor and act upon any urgent works required for the preservation of the heritage assets. We will be pleased to liaise closely with the Trent Park Conservation Committee and CAG

Grovelands Park / Priory Hospital • Officers are currently working with English Heritage (EH) and our

consultants (Land Use Consultants) on the draft Conservation Management Plan and Options Appraisal. The consultants are currently developing the documents further pursuant to EH’s input. The stakeholder consultation programme will be developed once a draft CMP has been completed.

Heritage and Design Website refresh

• Officers are currently overhauling the Heritage and Design web pages. One aspect of this is to facilitate better communication and networking between local voluntary heritage groups. Harriet Bell (Heritage Officer) would be pleased to receive e-mail contact details for local study groups for the Community Heritage Initiatives web page.

Open House London

Page 10

• This popular annual architecture event will be taking place on the weekend

of 20-21 September 2014. Enfield are as usual strongly represented with fourteen buildings and sites taking part in the event, see page 33 of the Open House brochure.

Page 11

What matters are being discussed at the

Do any relate to my interests whether already registered or

Pers

onal

inte

rest

You can participate in the meeting and vote

Prej

udic

ial i

nter

est

YE

N

N

N

YE

YE

YE

You may have a personal

Note: If in any doubt about a potential interest, members are asked to seek advice from Democratic Services in advance of the

N

YES

You may have a prejudicial

A DECLARING INTERESTS FLOWCHART - QUESTIONS TO ASK

Declare your personal interest in the matter. You can remain in meeting, speak and vote unless the interest is also prejudicial; or If your interest arises solely from your membership of, or position of control or management on any other public body or body to which you were nominated by the authority e.g. Governing Body, ALMO, you only need declare

l i t t if d h k

Does the matter affect your financial interests or relate to a licensing, planning or other regulatory matter; and Would a member of the public (knowing the relevant facts) reasonably think that your personal interest was so

Do the public have speaking rights at the meeting?

You should declare the interest but can remain in the meeting to speak. Once you have finished speaking (or the meeting decides you have finished - if earlier) you must withdraw from the

You should declare the interest and withdraw from the meeting by leaving the room. You cannot speak or vote on the matter and must not seek to

Is a particular matter close to me? Does it affect: • me or my partner; • my relatives or their partners; • my friends or close associates; • either me, my family or close associates: • job and business;

• employers, firms you or they are a partner of and companies you or they are a Director of

• or them to any position; • corporate bodies in which you or they have a

shareholding of more than £25,000 (nominal value);

Page 12

C PLANNING APPLICATION 14/03370/HOU: 14 The Green, New Southgate, London, N14 7EH Proposal: Hip to gable roof and rear dormer Case Officer: Mr Misbah Uddin The site comprises a detached dwelling located on the south side of The Green, within the Southgate Green Conservation Area.

Site location

Proposal: The proposed works include a hip to gable roof extension and the addition of rear dormers, to be undertaken as part of the proposed loft conversion works to the building. In terms of materials, the proposed windows are to be aluminium and the

Page 13

proposed new roof tiles are to match existing. A flat roof with asphalt finish is also specified in the scheme.

Existing front and rear elevations

Existing East and West elevations

Page 14

Proposed front and rear elevations

Proposed East and West elevations

Page 15

PLANNING APPLICATION

14/02634/FUL: 25 Lancaster Avenue, Barnet, EN4 0EP Conversion of single family dwelling into 4 self contained flats comprising 2 x 3-bed, 1 x 4-bed and 1 x 1-bed involving a part lower ground, part ground floor side and rear extension with balcony at first floor rear, rear dormer and rooflights to front and side. Case Officer: Mr Ray Reilly The site comprises a semi-detached, early 20th-century dwelling located on the north side of Lancaster Avenue within the Hadley Wood Conservation Area.

Site location Proposal: Consent is sought for the conversion of the existing building to four flats and the erection of single storey side and rear extensions, rear dormer with pitched roof and rooflights to the front roof slope. This is a revised submission of an earlier pre-application (Ref: P14-00724PRE).

Page 16

Proposed elevations

Existing elevations

Page 17

Existing ground floor plan

Page 18

Proposed ground floor plan

Page 19

Proposed first floor plan

Proposed second floor plan

Page 20

Site photographs

Page 21

PLANNING APPLICATION 14-02145PLA 02220LBC: 74 Vicars Moor Lane, London, N21 2QH Alterations to basement and enlargement of light well, restoration of basement access staircase, single storey rear/side extension, alterations to internal layout, replacement sash windows to ground floor at rear / side, loft conversion with rear roof light and re-build detached garage at rear. Case Officer: Kate Perry The site comprises a two storey grade II listed dwelling located on the north side of Vicars Moor Lane within the Vicars Moor Lane Conservation Area. The building forms part of a terrace.

Proposal: The proposed works include improvement to the basement rooms and enlarged light well, restoration of basement access stair to historic position and a side extension to create a family room overlooking the garden, removing WC and utility area. At first floor level, it is proposed that the front ‘box’ room will be restored and new stairs installed to provide access to loft rooms; bedroom and bathroom.

Page 22

No works are proposed to the front elevation. New timber sash and case windows are proposed to the rear wing, to replace the existing aluminium windows, in addition to a glazed conservatory with joinery to match the existing living room garden doors. The garage is to be demolished and replaced with a slate pitched roof and yellow stock brick on the existing footprint of the garage and patio. The habitable area of the house is to be enlarged through the creation of extra floor space, including an additional bedroom in the loft space, a study in the basement, shower room and services area. An extension to the ground floor kitchen is also proposed.

Proposed rear elevation

Page 23

Proposed section drawing

Proposed side elevation

Page 24

Proposed section through hall and stair

Proposed loft plan

Page 25

PLANNING APPLICATION 14/03074/HOU - 88 Broad Walk, London, N21 3BJ Part demolition of existing garage and conversion into granny annex ancillary to existing dwelling with installation of windows and entrance at side, bay window to front and erection of front wall with railings and piers. Case Officer: Maria Demetri The application site comprises a detached dwelling on the south side of Broad Walk within the Winchmore Hill Conservation Area. The site frontage is secured by gates and walls with mature trees behind.

Site location

The applicant seeks planning permission for part demolition of the existing garage building and replacement with a granny annexe. The existing walls and gates are to be extended in the front of the new annexe. The proposed building and use will remain incidental to the house.

Page 26

Proposed side elevation

Site plan and photographs

Page 27

Proposed floor plan

Page 28

D

LONDON BOROUGH OF ENFIELD

List of Decisions affecting Conservation Areas & Listed Buildings FROM: 21/08/2014 TO: 23/09/2014

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: BUSH HILL PARK REF: 14/02720/CEA

ADDRESS: 54A Wellington Road Enfield EN1 2PH

PROPOSAL: Single storey rear extension. DECISION: Granted DECISION DATE: 02/09/2014

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: CLAY HILL

REF: 14/02314/FUL ADDRESS: The Fallow Buck

226 Clay Hill Enfield EN2 9JD

PROPOSAL: Subdivision of site, demolition of part of existing public house and outbuildings and conversion to a 4 - bed single family dwelling involving 2 storey rear extension,internal alterations,hard / soft landscaping, together with erection of 1 x detached 2 storey 4 - bed single family dwelling with associated parking.

DECISION: Refused DECISION DATE: 28/08/2014 CAG INFO: Conservation Area: CLAY HILL

REF: 14/02614/NMA ADDRESS: Hill Lodge


PROPOSAL: Non material amendment to P13-02327PLA to allow changes to the external finishing materials for the redevelopment of site.

DECISION: Application Withdrawn DECISION DATE: 26/08/2014 CAG INFO: Conservation Area: ENFIELD TOWN

REF: 14/03277/CND ADDRESS: Former Council Car Park

Cecil Road Enfield EN2 6TJ

PROPOSAL: Details submitted to P13-03212PLA for assessability condition 28 for redevelopment of

Page 29

site to provide a part 3-storey, part 4-storey block of 46 self contained flats (comprising 12 x 1-bed, 26 x 2-bed and 8 x 3-bed) with balconies to front, rear and both sides at first and second floors, terraces to front and sides at third floor level, off street parking for 27 cars, new vehicle access to Cecil Road, new pedestrian access to Town Park and associated landscaping.

DECISION: Granted DECISION DATE: 22/09/2014 CAG INFO: Conservation Area: ENFIELD TOWN

REF: 14/02310/HOU ADDRESS: 79 Chase Side

Enfield EN2 6NL

PROPOSAL: Single storey ground and first floor extension and vehicular access. DECISION: Application Withdrawn DECISION DATE: 17/09/2014

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: ENFIELD TOWN



PROPOSAL: Discharge of condition 15 landscape planting scheme approved under P13-03212PLA for redevelopment of site to provide a part 3-storey, part 4-storey block of 46 self contained flats (comprising 12 x 1-bed, 26 x 2-bed and 8 x 3-bed) with balconies to front, rear and both sides at first and second floors, terraces to front and sides at third floor level, off street parking for 27 cars, new vehicle access to Cecil Road, new pedestrian access to Town Park and associated landscaping.




PROPOSAL: Details submitted to P13-03212PLA for CFSH (condition 19a) for redevelopment of site to provide a part 3-storey, part 4-storey block of 46 self contained flats (comprising 12 x 1-bed, 26 x 2-bed and 8 x 3-bed) with balconies to front, rear and both sides at first and second floors, terraces to front and sides at third floor level, off street parking for 27 cars, new vehicle access to Cecil Road, new pedestrian access to Town Park and associated landscaping.



Cecil Road

Page 30

Enfield EN2 6TJ

PROPOSAL: Discharge of condition 14 refuse storage facilities granted under P13-03212PLA for redevelopment of site to provide a part 3-storey, part 4-storey block of 46 self contained flats (comprising 12 x 1-bed, 26 x 2-bed and 8 x 3-bed) with balconies to front, rear and both sides at first and second floors, terraces to front and sides at third floor level, off street parking for 27 cars, new vehicle access to Cecil Road, new pedestrian access to Town Park and associated landscaping.




PROPOSAL: Discharge of condition 9 cycle parking granted under P13-03212PLA for redevelopment of site to provide a part 3-storey, part 4-storey block of 46 self contained flats (comprising 12 x 1-bed, 26 x 2-bed and 8 x 3-bed) with balconies to front, rear and both sides at first and second floors, terraces to front and sides at third floor level, off street parking for 27 cars, new vehicle access to Cecil Road, new pedestrian access to Town Park and associated landscaping.

DECISION: Granted DECISION DATE: 28/08/2014 CAG INFO: Conservation Area: GRANGE PARK

REF: 14/03260/NMA ADDRESS: 32 Old Park Ridings

N21 2ES

PROPOSAL: Non material amendment to 14/02269/HOU to allow the side elevation to be painted brickwork.

DECISION: Granted DECISION DATE: 17/09/2014 CAG INFO: Conservation Area: GRANGE PARK

REF: 14/02290/HOU ADDRESS: 93 Old Park Ridings

London N21 2EJ

PROPOSAL: Single storey rear extension and installation of doors to rear elevation. DECISION: Granted With Conditions DECISION DATE: 29/08/2014

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: GRANGE PARK

REF: 14/02649/FUL ADDRESS: 48A The Chine

London N21 2ED

Page 31

PROPOSAL: Rear dormer and roof light at side, installation of windows at first floor level. DECISION: Granted With Conditions DECISION DATE: 28/08/2014

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: HADLEY WOOD

REF: 14/02639/HOU ADDRESS: 25 Lancaster Avenue

Barnet EN4 0EP

PROPOSAL: Part single storey, part lower ground floor side and rear extension, rear dormer and front rooflight.

DECISION: Granted With Conditions DECISION DATE: 02/09/2014 CAG INFO: Conservation Area: HADLEY WOOD

REF: P14-02212PLA ADDRESS: 53 Crescent West

Hadley Wood Barnet EN4 0EQ

PROPOSAL: Replacement windows. DECISION: Granted With Conditions DECISION DATE: 22/08/2014

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: MEADWAY

REF: 14/02804/HOU ADDRESS: 37 Meadway

London N14 6NJ

PROPOSAL: Erection of carport at side with timber doors and tiled canopy roof over. DECISION: Granted With Conditions DECISION DATE: 03/09/2014

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: MEADWAY

REF: 14/02330/CND ADDRESS: 28 Greenway

London N14 6NN

PROPOSAL: Details of P13-00290PLA for surfacing materials and drainage (condition 5) for part single part 2 storey rear extension and extension to existing patio and new hard standing to front.

DECISION: Granted DECISION DATE: 02/09/2014 CAG INFO: Conservation Area: SOUTHGATE GREEN

REF: 14/02438/LBC ADDRESS: 52-54 Cannon Hill

London N14 6LH

PROPOSAL: Removal of part of party wall between No:52 and 54. DECISION: Application Withdrawn DECISION DATE: 23/09/2014

Page 32

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: SOUTHGATE GREEN

REF: 14/02437/FUL ADDRESS: 52-54 Cannon Hill

London N14 6LH

PROPOSAL: Removal of part of party wall between No:52 and 54. DECISION: Application Withdrawn DECISION DATE: 23/09/2014

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: THE LAKES ESTATE

REF: 14/03038/HOU ADDRESS: 46 Selborne Road

London N14 7DH

PROPOSAL: Single storey rear extension, rasied patio, and front porch. DECISION: Refused DECISION DATE: 18/09/2014

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: THE LAKES ESTATE

REF: 14/02572/FUL ADDRESS: 92 Aldermans Hill

London N13 4PP

PROPOSAL: Installation of new shop front with replacement signage, introduction of shrubs along the side garden to screen a small condenser unit required for air conditioning to the shop.

DECISION: Granted With Conditions DECISION DATE: 27/08/2014 CAG INFO: Conservation Area: THE LAKES ESTATE

REF: 14/02611/HOU ADDRESS: 89 Derwent Road

London N13 4QA

PROPOSAL: Loft conversion incorporating gable and rear dormer, first floor rear infill extension and single storey rear extension.

DECISION: Refused DECISION DATE: 27/08/2014 CAG INFO: Conservation Area: THE LAKES ESTATE

REF: 14/02568/ADV ADDRESS: 92 Aldermans Hill

London N13 4PP

PROPOSAL: Installation of 1 x internally illuminated fascia sign and 1 x externally illuminated hanging sign.

DECISION: Granted With Conditions DECISION DATE: 21/08/2014

Page 33

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: TRENT PARK

REF: 14/02535/FUL ADDRESS: 315 Cockfosters Road

Barnet EN4 0JY

PROPOSAL: Replacement of 2 no sash windows to front elevation to match existing. DECISION: Granted With Conditions DECISION DATE: 18/09/2014

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: TRENT PARK

REF: 14/02701/CND ADDRESS: Cockfosters Service Stattion

Petrol Station Cockfosters Road Barnet EN4 0DZ

PROPOSAL: Details submitted to TP/10/1552 for BREEAM post construction assessment (18b) for the redevelopment of a site to a provide petrol station with canopy, sales building, underground tanks, new vehicular access, customer parking bays, air conditioning units at rear and associated landscaping.

DECISION: Granted DECISION DATE: 28/08/2014 CAG INFO: Conservation Area: TRENT PARK

REF: 14/02253/FUL ADDRESS: Ferny Hill Farm

Ferny Hill Barnet EN4 0PZ

PROPOSAL: Change of use of agricultural building to storage facility (Retrospective). DECISION: Granted With Conditions DECISION DATE: 22/08/2014

CAG INFO: Conservation Area: WINCHMORE HILL GREEN

REF: 14/02407/HOU ADDRESS: 63A Station Road

Winchmore Hill London N21 3NB

PROPOSAL: Rear dormer, balcony and installation of new window to side elevation. DECISION: Refused DECISION DATE: 18/09/2014


REF: 14/02488/HOU ADDRESS: 38 Wades Hill

London N21 1BG

Page 34

PROPOSAL: Extension to roof at side to form a gable end with flank window. DECISION: Refused DECISION DATE: 15/09/2014


REF: 14/02564/HOU ADDRESS: 88 Broad Walk

London N21 3BJ

PROPOSAL: 2 front domers windows , one rear domer window at rear and 4 x roof light at side. DECISION: Granted With Conditions DECISION DATE: 05/09/2014

CAG INFO: LB Grade: II; Location: 79 Chase Side, Enfield

REF: 14/02310/HOU ADDRESS: 79 Chase Side

Enfield EN2 6NL

PROPOSAL: Single storey ground and first floor extension and vehicular access. DECISION: Application Withdrawn DECISION DATE: 17/09/2014

CAG INFO: LB Grade: II; Location: De Bohun Library & Health Centre GatesGreen Road

REF: 14/00033/RE4 ADDRESS: De Bohun Primary School

Green Road New Southgate London N14 4AD

PROPOSAL: Enclosure of part of school playing field with railings and welded mesh fencing. DECISION: Granted With Conditions DECISION DATE: 26/08/2014

CAG INFO: LB Grade: II; Location: Fallow Buck Inn Clay Hill

REF: 14/02314/FUL ADDRESS: The Fallow Buck


PROPOSAL: Subdivision of site, demolition of part of existing public house and outbuildings and conversion to a 4 - bed single family dwelling involving 2 storey rear extension,internal alterations,hard / soft landscaping, together with erection of 1 x detached 2 storey 4 - bed single family dwelling with associated parking.

DECISION: Refused DECISION DATE: 28/08/2014 No appeals determined during period

Page 35

This page is intentionally left blank

Page 36

THE CONSERVATION ADVISORY GROUP - Enfield

Documents

Transcript of THE CONSERVATION ADVISORY GROUP - Enfield