STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless,...
Transcript of STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless,...
![Page 1: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1
STAYINGAHEADOFTHEGAME:LICENSING,SPONSORSHIP,ANDNEWTECHNOLOGYINTHEWORLDOFSPORTSANDMEDIA
PresentedbytheAssociationofMediaandEntertainmentCounsel
Moderator:RichardWirthlin
Panelists:GaryGertzog,MichaelHartman,BillOrdower,&BobbySharma
Thursday,July14,2010
HSBCPrivateBankInternational4525thAvenue
NewYork,NY10018
Registration:8:00‐8:30AMSeminar:8:30‐10:00AM
AGENDA
Time Topic Contributors8:30‐8:40 Welcome&Introduction Moderator8:40‐9:00 Howdoesbroadcasttelevisioncompetewith AllPanelists
payTVandsatellitetostaycompetitiveandrelevant?
9:00‐9:10 WhataretheimplicationsoftheAmericanNeedle, GaryGertzog
Inc.v.NFLdecision?9:15‐9:30 WhatistheimpactofAmbushMarketing? AllPanelists9:30‐9:50 Inthefaceofachangingeconomy,howhas BillOrdower
thisaffectedsportsfranchisesintermsof &Bobbysponsorships,facilities,financing? Sharma
9:50‐10:00 Q&A AllPanelists
&Moderator*ThesearetheintendedtopicsbutpleasenotethatAMECencouragesquestionsandanorganic,livelydiscussionthroughoutthepanel.
![Page 2: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
GARYGERTZOGSeniorVicePresidentBusinessAffairs&GeneralCounselNationalFootballLeagueGaryGertzogjoinedtheNFLin1994asVicePresidentandGeneralCounselofNFLProperties,Inc.Overtheyears,hisroleattheNFLhasexpandedtoincludeoveralllegalandbusinessaffairsresponsibilityfortheNFL’scommercialoperationsincludingmedia(television,radio,internet,wireless,etc.),marketing,consumerproductlicensing,corporatesponsorships,eventsandintellectual
property.Gertzoghasplayedamajorroleinawidevarietyofcomplexcommercialarrangementsincludingthoseinvolvingnewbusinessmodelsanddealstructures,includingtheNFLMasterAgreement(whichallocatesintellectualpropertyrightsbetweentheNFLandMemberClubs),theNFL’suniquesponsorshipandinternetagreementswithNFLPlayersAssociation/PlayersIncandindustrysettingdealsforapparel,videogame,creditcard,beverageandtelecommunicationproductsandservices.HehasalsoledtheNFL’seffortsinimportantlitigationmattersincludingtheprotectionoftheintellectualpropertyrightsoftheNFLandMemberClubs.Duringhiscareer,GertzoghasservedasakeyNFLseniorexecutivewithresponsibilityforactiveandretiredplayerbusinessprogramsincludingtheProFootballHallofFame,NFLAlumni,NFLPlayerAssociation/PlayersIncandtheNFLQuarterbackClub.
MICHAELHARTMANSeniorVicePresident&GeneralCounsel
DIRECTVLatinAmerica
MichaelHartman,hasbeenSeniorVicePresident&GeneralCounselofDIRECTVLatinAmericasinceApril2004.Hartmanoverseesall
legal,regulatoryandgovernmentalaffairsofthecompany.DIRECTVLatinAmericaanditssubsidiariesarethelargestpaytelevision
operatorinLatinAmerica,withover7millionsubscribersthroughouttheregion.DIRECTVLatinAmericaisanoperatingunitofDIRECTV(DTV),
whichalsohasover18millionsubscribersintheUSandownsregionalsportsnetworksinSeattle,Denver,andPittsburg.
PriortojoiningDIRECTVLatinAmerica,HartmanworkedatCycleLogic,Inc.(formerlyStarMediaNetwork,Inc.),whichhejoinedinJuly2000andofwhichhebecameGeneral
CounselinNovember2001.FromNovember1994toJune2000MichaelwasanassociateintheCorporateDepartmentofDebevoise&Plimpton,wherehefocusedintransactionsinLatinAmericaandtheIberianPeninsula.HereceivedaJ.D.fromtheColumbiaUniversity
SchoolofLaw,anM.A.inHispanicLanguagesandLiteraturesfromtheUniversityofCaliforniaatBerkeley,andaB.A.fromtheUniversityofMichigan.HartmanspeaksSpanish
andPortuguese.
![Page 3: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
BILLORDOWERSeniorVicePresidentandGeneralCounselMajorLeagueSoccer(MLS)&SoccerUnitedMarketing(SUM)Bill Ordower oversees all significant legal matters for MLS and SUMincluding the areas of sponsorship, broadcasting and new media,licensing, property rights acquisition, stadium lease agreements andinternational game promotion. His responsibilities also includedevelopingandmanagingthetrademarkstrategyfortheLeagueand itsclubs.
Recently,Ordowerhasbeenactivelyinvolvedinaflurryofexpansionactivity,withtheLeagueexpanding to Philadelphia, Vancouver, Portland andMontreal, all by 2012. He also played aleadingroleinthefinalizationofanew5‐yearcollectivebargainingagreementandaidedinthere‐launch of MLS’ new website, MLSsoccer.com. Ordower also created, and continues tomanage, the League’s Substance Abuse and Behavioral Health Program, one of the mostcomprehensiveandforward‐thinkingprogramsinprofessionalsports.Ordowerearnedhislawdegreein1996fromTheGeorgeWashingtonUniversityLawSchoolinWashington,D.C.OrdowergraduatedfromBostonUniversity,magnacumlaude,in1993withaBachelorofArtsdegreeinEnglish.
BOBBYSHARMA
VicePresident&GeneralCounselNBADevelopmentLeague
AsVicePresident&GeneralCounseloftheNBADevelopment
League,BobbySharmaservesasakeybusinessexecutiveandthechieflegalofficerfortheNationalBasketballAssociation’sminorleagueanditsvariousoperatingentities,havingjoinedtheNBAin
July2002.
Sharmamanagesallcurrentleagueandteambusinesses,aswellasexpansion.HeisresponsibleforallNBAD‐Leagueagreements,andoverseesvariousbusiness,legal,and
basketballoperationalmatters,includingadministrationofallleaguepoliciesandprocedures.Hisareasoffocusincludeteamownership&operation,arenas,sponsorship,
merchandise,marketing,intellectualproperty,broadcasting,product/digitalcontentlicensing,contests&sweepstakes,employment,anti‐doping,andsecurity.
InApril2009,Sharmawasnamedoneofthe25MostInfluentialSouthAsianExecutivesintheMedia&EntertainmentIndustrybyKorn/FerryInternational.
AfterreceivingbothhisB.A.andJ.D.fromDukeUniversity,SharmaservedonthepresidentialcampaignstaffofformerU.S.Senator,andNBAHallofFamer,BillBradley.
![Page 4: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
RICHARDL.WIRTHLIN,ModeratorPartner,Latham&WatkinsLLPRichardL.WirthlinisaCorporateDepartmentpartnerinthefirm’sLosAngelesofficeandistheGlobalChairofthefirm’sMedia&EntertainmentIndustryGroup,whichalsoincludesSportstransactions.Heisafoundingmemberofthefirm’sInternationalLawGroupandCommunicationsPracticeGroup,aswellasamemberofthefirm’sMergers&AcquisitionsPracticeGroupandEmergingCompaniesPracticeGroup.HeisalsotheformerManagingPartner
ofLatham’sMoscow,RussiaOffice.Wirthlin’spracticeinvolvesavarietyofinternationalanddomesticbusinesstransactions,withparticularexpertiseandfocusonentertainment,media,internetandnewmedia,sportsandtelecommunications.Hispracticealsoinvolveshightech,mergersandacquisitions,privateequityandemergingtechnologymatters.WirthlincurrentlyservesasprimarycounseltoboththeLosAngelesSportsCouncil(LASC)andtheSouthernCaliforniaCommitteefortheOlympicGames(SCCOG).
![Page 5: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
WhyNFL'sSupremeCourtLossIsn'tMuchofaLoss May24,2010By:KristiDoshThismorning,theUnitedStatesSupremeCourtansweredthequestionofwhethertheNFLisactingasoneentityoras32separateteamswhenitenterscontractsforproductionofitemssuchasjerseysandhats.TheunanimousconclusionwasthattheNFLis32separateentities,evenwhenenteringacontractasaunitedgroup.
ThisrulingistechnicallyalossfortheNFL,buttheNFLdidn'thavemuchtolosetobeginwith.AlthoughtheNFLwonatthelowercourtlevel,whereAmericanNeedle'scasewasthrownout,bothAmericanNeedleandtheNFLappealedtotheSupremeCourt.TheNFLwashopingforbroaderantitrustlawprotection,buttheresultisnotsurprising.
MajorLeagueBaseballremainstheonlyprofessionalsportsleaguetoenjoybroadprotectionfromthenation'santitrustlaws.Thoselawsaremeanttoencouragecompetitionandpreventunfairtradepractices.Ina1922ruling,theUnitedStatesSupremeCourt,declaredthatbaseballwasexemptfromtheantitrustlawsbecausetravelacrossstatelineswasmerelyincidentaltothegame.Inorderforantitrustlawstoapply,abusinessmustbeengagedininterstatecommerce.Yearslater,thecourtwouldrulethatbaseballdoesinvolveinterstatecommerce,butwouldchoosenottoremovebaseball'sexemptiononthegroundsthatbaseballhadoperatedundertheassumptionthatitwasexemptforoverfiftyyears.
TheNBA,NHL,NCAA,MajorLeagueSoccerandNASCARalljoinedNFLintheappealtothehighcourtinthehopesthatantitrustlawswouldbebroadenedforallprofessionalsports,butIdon'tthinkanyone,includingtheleagues,expectedthemtoprevail.
AmericanNeedlesuedtheNFLonthegroundsthatall32teamscolludedtokeepthemfrommakinglicensedhatsbyenteringintoanexclusive10‐yearlicensingdealwithReebok.TheNFL'sargumentwasthattheteamsactedasasingleentitywhenenteringlicensingagreementssuchasthis,andthuswereincapableofcolluding.
JusticeJohnPaulStevens,writingfortheunanimousCourt,said:
AlthoughNFLteamshavecommoninterestssuchaspromotingtheNFLbrand,theyarestillseparate,profit‐maximizingentities,andtheirinterestsinlicensingteamtrademarksarenotnecessarilyaligned.
TheNFLwillnowhavetoreturntothelowercourtforatrialonthemeritsofAmericanNeedle'scase.Essentially,theNFLisbackwheretheybegan.AlthoughtheytechnicallywerethelosingpartyattheSupremeCourt,therulingleavestheNFLoperatingunderthesameantitrustprovisionsasalways.AmericanNeedlewillhavetoprovethattheteams
![Page 6: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
colludedinanillegalrestraintoftrade(notallrestraintsontradeareactuallyillegal).Personally,I'dbeshockedifAmericanNeedleprevailed.Exclusiveagreementsareenteredinsports,andinbusiness,allthetime.TheNFLshouldbeabletomakeastrongcasethattheexclusiveagreementwithReebokwasenteredintowithoutviolatingantitrustlaws.
Kristiisanattorney,founderofIt'saSwingandaMiss(www.itsaswingandamiss.com),andauthoroftheforthcomingbook,"BalancingBaseball:HowCollectiveBargainingHasChangedtheMajorLeagues."
![Page 7: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
AmericanNeedlevs.NFL:LookingForward May26,2010By:KristiDoshSincewritingmylastpostonAmericanNeedlevs.NFL,Ihavereceivedseveralquestionsregardingwhatwillhappennext.First,andmostimportantly,theSupremeCourtdidnotdecidethemeritsofthematterathand,whichwaswhethertheNFLteamscolludedtoexcludeAmericanNeedlefromproducingNFLmerchandiseinviolationoftheShermanAct.TheSupremeCourtonlyruledastowhethertheNFLshouldbesubjecttotheantitrustlawsinthissituation.
InorderforthelowercourttoruleinfavorofAmericanNeedleonremand,itmustfindtheNFLviolatedSection1oftheShermanAct(aportionofournation'santitrustlaws).Section1prohibits"combinations,contracts,orconspiracies"thatareanticompetitiveinnatureandeffectcommerce.AmericanNeedleassertedinitssuitthattheNFLviolatedSection1oftheShermanActbecausetheteamscolludedtograntanexclusivelicensetoReebok,whichpreventedothervendorsfromobtaininglicensingrightsforheadwear.
TheUnitedStatesCourtofAppealsfortheSeventhCircuitruledthattheteamsintheNFLactedasasingleentitywhenlicensingteamtrademarkscollectively,basedontheirneedtoactcollectivelytocompetewiththeotherprofessionalsportsleaguesforentertainmentdollars.Essentially,becausethecourtruledthattheteamsactedasasingleentityintheirlicensingactivities,theycouldnotbefoundinviolationofSection1oftheShermanAct.TheSupremeCourt'srulingonMondaymeansthatthecasewillberemandedtothelowercourtforahearingonthemeritsofthecase.However,theSupremeCourt'sdecisiondoesnotsuggestthatAmericanNeedlewillbetheprevailingparty.AmericanNeedlestillhasacasetoprove.
InorderforthelowercourttofindtheNFLguiltyofviolatingSection1oftheShermanAct,AmericanNeedlewillhavetoovercomethe"ruleofreason"test.Theruleofreasonanalysis,firstannouncedina1911case,requiresthecourttoweighwhethertheanti‐competitivebehaviorisanunreasonablerestraintoftrade.Putsimply,theanti‐competitiveeffectsoftheactionwillbeweighedagainstthebusinessjustifications.
Inshort,itmeanstheNFLcanmakeastrongcasehere.TheNFLneedonlypresentevidencethattheygarnergreaterbargainingpowerwhenall32teamsjointogethertolicensetheirtrademarks.Infact,JusticeStevens,whowrotetheunanimousopinionoftheSupremeCourt,includedcommentsintheopinionrecognizingthattherearetimeswhenalloftheteamsmustunite,suchaswhenschedulinggames.Healsonotedthatinorderto
![Page 8: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
maintaincompetitivebalanceandsuccessforallteams,somecollectiveactionsmightbejustified.ThislanguagewillbesurelybeusedbytheNFLtomaketheircaseinfrontofthelowercourt.Thefactis,all32teamsauthorizedNFLProperties,LLCtosolicitbidsforanexclusiveheadwearlicensein2001.ThehighestbidderwasReebok,towhomtheexclusivelicensewasgrantedforaten‐yearperiod.Presumably,eachteambenefittedfrompoolingtheirtrademarkrightstogetherinordertogetthebesteconomicterms.Also,it'ssafetosaythatbyofferinganexclusivelicense,theyalsoincreasedtheirbargainingpower.Inaddition,eachteamwillpresumablyhaveequalopportunitytobenefitunderthelicensingagreement,whichwouldn'tnecessarilybethecaseifeachteamindividuallysoughttosolicitbidsforaheadwearlicense.Asadditionalammo,NFLProperties,LLCconductedabiddingprocessbywhichtheyawardedtheexclusivecontracttothehighestbidder.ThiscalculatedandseeminglyfairmaneuvershouldstrengthentheNFL'scase.Inshort,there'snoreasontobelievethattheSupremeCourt'srulingonMondaysignalsanultimatewinforAmericanNeedle.TheNFLhasacompellingargumenttojustifytheiractions,nottomentionthattheCourtofAppealshasalreadyfoundintheNFL'sfavoronce.I'dbesurprisedtofindAmericanNeedleprevailintheend,butwe'llalljusthavetostaytuned!Kristiisanattorney,founderofIt'saSwingandaMiss(www.itsaswingandamiss.com),andauthoroftheforthcomingbook,"BalancingBaseball:HowCollectiveBargainingHasChangedtheMajorLeagues."
![Page 9: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
LebronJameswouldbring$58MtoNewYorkCityifhejoinedKnicksandwonGame7andtitle:studyJune1,2010By:AdamLisbergandJoseMartinezLeBronJameswouldbea$58millioncashkingforNewYork.That'sthemassiveeconomicimpactthecityispredicting"KingJames"wouldpullinifheledtheNewYorkKnickstoanNBAtitleinadecidingGame7.TheNBA'sreigningtwo‐timeMVP,whoismust‐seeTVforhoopsdie‐hardsandthedarlingofbig‐timeadvertisers,hitstheopenmarketasafreeagentJuly1.TheKnicksandtheirfans‐fromfilmmakerSpikeLeetoMayorBloomberg‐aredesperatetolandthegame'smarqueeplayerevenashehintedthattheClevelandCavaliershavetheedgeinsigninghim.Thecity'sEconomicDevelopmentCorp.recentlyconductedasecretstudytodeterminejusthowmuchcashNewYorkwouldpullinonJames'cachet‐andpeggeditataneye‐popping$57.8million.Thestudywasbasedontwokeyfactors:‐TheJames‐ledKnickswouldmakeitthroughtheplayoffstowinhome‐courtadvantageintheNBAfinals.‐TheKnickswouldwintheirfirsttitlesince1973inGame7ofthebest‐of‐sevenchampionship,meaningfourgamesareplayedatMadisonSquareGarden.Twosourceswhohaveseenthetop‐secretstudysaidJameswouldhelppumpnearly$58millionintothecityasout‐of‐townersbookhotelroomsandfanschowdownincityrestaurants.Thosehotelsandrestaurantswouldspendcashstockinguponsuppliesandstaff‐andKnicksfanswouldgraballkindsofteamgear.Eachtransactionwouldsplashcash‐andtaxrevenue‐aroundthecity.ButNewYork'sdream‐onthecourtandthecoffers‐maybeanairball.OnTuesdaynight,KingJamestoldCNN'sLarryKingthatCleveland,ofallplaces,ishiskindofkingdom‐andhastheedgeinkeepinghisservices."Absolutely,"JamessaidintheinterviewsettoairFriday."Because,youknow,thiscity[Cleveland],thesefans,Imean,havegivenmealotinthesesevenyears."And,youknow,forme,it'scomfortable.SoI'vegotalotofmemorieshere.And‐andsoitdoeshaveanedge."
![Page 10: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
Thesitdownwiththesuspenders‐lovingserialdivorcéisthefirsttimeJameshasspokenatlengthabouthisfuturesincetheCavs'playoffouster.Akron'sfavoritesonissettobecomethemostsought‐afterfreeagentinNBAhistory‐andClevelandappearswillingtomatchanyoffers.NewYorkerscanhopethelureofswappingsomewayOff‐Broadwayoutpostfortherealthingistoomuchforthe25‐year‐oldsuperstartopasson.HehasalreadytakenashinetotheBigApple,doffingaYankeescapanddesigningasetofNikesinthefabledpinstripes.NewYorkwillbewaitingwithopenarms."WeneedLeBron,"LeetoldtheDailyNewslastmonth.
![Page 11: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
LeBrontheFinancialKingofNewYork?SportseconomistscontestLeBronJames’financialimpactonNewYorkCity.June6,2010By:KyleStackTheNewYorkKnicksareexpectedtopulloutallthestopsintheirfreeagentcourtshipofLeBronJamesandthereapparentlyisamajorfinancialincentivetodoso.NewYorkCity’sEconomicDevelopmentCorporationcompiledaLeBronJamesfinancialimpactreportwhosecontentswerefirstleakedoutbytheNewYorkDailyNewsJune1.ThereportstatesthatKingJameswouldhavea$57.8millionimpactonNewYorkCityifheledtheKnickstoaGame7winintheNBAFinalsontheKnicks’homeflooratMadisonSquareGarden.(ThestudyassumestheKnickswouldhavehome‐courtadvantageintheFinals.)Notsofast,indicatedDarrenRovell,asportsbusinessreporteratCNBC.“IdoubttheKnickswouldmake$58million,”Rovellsaid.“Normallyaplayoffgameisworth$1milliontotheteam.”AssumingthatittakesatleasttwohomewinsineachofthefourseriesinordertowinaNBAchampionship,thebenefitwouldberoughlyatleast$8million.Themaximumamountwouldberoughly$16millionsince16homegamesarethemostateamwithhome‐courtadvantagethroughtheplayoffscanplay.Thenthereisthequestionofwhereextracustomerswillcomefromduringtheregularseasonandplayoffs,accordingtoRovell.“Thelargepercentageofpeople[whogotogames]wouldbelivinginNewYork,”Rovellsaid.“IfLeBroncomeshere,theKnicksaregoingtohave14,000,15,000seasonticketholders.Wherewouldalltheseotherpeoplebecomingfrom?”AllenSanderson,aUniversityofChicagoeconomist,saidthatbasketballaudiencesarelocalbynature.Whereasbaseballseasonbenefitsfromaslewofeventsuniquetosummer—goodweather,kidsoutofschool,peopleonvacation—basketballisplayedprimarilyduringwintermonthsinwhichpeopletendtotravelmuchless.
![Page 12: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
Whileateamandticketbrokersmightbenefitfromtheabilitytoraiseticketprices,thereisn’tasmuchmoneytobemadebyteamscourtingLeBron.Oddlyenough,fouroftheteamswhohavebeenspeculatedaspossibledestinationsforhimrankedinthetopfivethispastseasoninaveragehomeattendance.TheBulls(1st,20,725avg.),Cavaliers(2nd,20,562),Mavericks(4th,19,994)andKnicks(5th,19,501)can’tdrawmanymorefansifoneofthemsignsLeBron.(TheMaverickscandanglethecarrotofplayingonceortwiceayearin100,000‐plusseatCowboysStadium.)TheNets,anotherLeBroncontender,drewanNBA‐low13,103peopletotheirgameslastseasonatIZODCenterinEastRutherford,whichhadacapacityof18,974.ThebasketballcapacityattheNewark‐locatedPrudentialCenter,wheretheNetswillplayforthenexttwoseasonsbeforemovingtoBrooklyn,islistedat18,500onthearena’swebsite.WhenreachedforconfirmationonwhetherthatfigurewouldbetheNetshomegamecapacitynextseason,theteamstatedthatnocapacityhasbeendetermined.Sowhereisasuperstar’simpact?It’sintheirabilitytoraisetheirteam’spopularityawayfromitshomecity.“TheprimarybeneficiaryofMichaelJordanandtheBullschampionshipteams[inthe'90s]wasthattheysoldoutarenasontheroad,”Sandersonsaid.“Arenasthatwereselling10,000ticketspernightwereselling20,000whentheBullscircuscametotown.IfLeBrongoestotheKnicks,itjustmeanstheKnicksaregoingtoselloutarenasontheroad.”ThebigquestionforthelastyearregardingLeBron’spendingfreeagencyhasturnedfromwherehecanbestmaximizehismarketingabilitytowhichteamwouldprovidehimthegreatestopportunitytowinanNBAchampionship.Yettheformerquestion—ofwhereLeBroncouldmaximizehismarketingvalueandpushtowardhisself‐proclaimedwishtobecomeafinancialpowerhouseamongthelikesoffriendandNetsminorityownerJay‐Z—isstillrelevant.Andthat’swhereRovellandSandersondisagree.WhenaskedaboutwhatadditionalmarketingopportunitiesNewYorkprovidesforLeBron,Rovellstatedthereis“nothingmoreinNewYorkCitythanhehasinChicagoorL.A.”RovellemphasizedLeBron’sneedtowinachampionshipandthatheshouldgotoaplacewherehecandothat.SandersoncitedLeBronasneedingNewYorkCitymorethanthecityneedingLeBron.“IfI’ma25‐year‐oldkidandhaveatonofmoney,I’dratherbeinNewYorkthanCleveland,”Sandersonsaid.“It’sawholelotmorefun.There’sthepotentialofmoreendorsementincomeinabigcity.He’sgoingtodoreallywellwhereverbutIthinkhemaxesitoutinthebiggestmarket.”OneotherfactortoconsideraboutLeBron’spotentialimpactonNewYorkCity(oranycity)iswhatteamsandstarsalreadyexistthere.InNewYork,sportsfanswouldhavetheoccasionaldilemmaofgoingtoeitheraKnicksgameoroneplayedbytheJets,Giants,YankeesandMets—allpopularteamsintheNewYorkmetropolitanarea.DerekJeter,MarkSanchezandEliManningwouldensurethatLeBronwouldn’thavetheNewYorkathleticstagealltohimself.Chicagocouldbeadifferentmatter.SandersongaveanexampleoftheprosportssceneintheWindyCity.
![Page 13: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
“MostpeopleinChicagodon’tgivearipabouthockey,”SandersonsaidinreferencetotheChicagoBlackhawks’soaringpopularityasaresultoftheircurrentspotintheStanleyCupFinals.“ThecityisBlackhawk‐crazyatthemoment.Isitbecausethey’vejustturnedintohockeyfans?It’saminorpart.What’sthealternative?TheCubsand[White]Soxsuck.TheBearsarecomingoffahorribleseason.IfitturnsoutLeBroncomestoChicago,hecanhaveafairlybigimpactbecauseofthewoefulstateofmostprofessionalsportsteamsinthecity.”Intheend,bothsportseconomistsconcludedthattheNewYorkCityEconomicDevelopmentCorp.studyisn’trealistic.(TheNYCEDCdidn’trespondtoaninterviewrequestforthisstory.)“[Thestudy]doesn’tmakeanysense,”Rovellsaid.“It’sunlikeaSuperBowl,wherepeoplearecomingfromoutoftownonbothsides.”“Theseeconomicimpactstudiesareoffby90percenttobeginwith,”Sandersonsaid.“Youhavetodiscountthem;they’repuffpieces.”AtatimewhenthereareasmanyNBAfreeagencyquestionsastherearepeoplewhohaveanopinion,thisislikelytheclosestagreementyou’llseeonatopicconcerningLeBronJames’impendingfreeagency.
![Page 14: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
Howabadeconomycouldchangeindustryforthebetter June8,2009By:ChuckWieglusForthepast20yearssportsleadershavebeenfunctioninginamarketplacewheremoreismostalwaysseenasbetter.Moregames,morebigevents,morespectators,moretelevision,morecorporatepartners,more,more,more…andmostofoursportshavethrivedquitenicely.Pastconventionalwisdomheldthattheentertainmentoptionsofferedbysportsmadetheseactivitiesrecession‐proof.Thismaynolongerbetrue.Inasportsworldgonemadwithoversaturation,allsportsleadershavetore‐evaluatethepositionoftheirpropertiesagainsttoday’sevolvingeconomicdynamics.WereadabouttheArenaFootballLeaguecancelingits2009season;golftournamentsandotherpropertieslosingcorporatesponsors;professionalteamsdiscountingticketprices.Sowhilenosanepersonwouldhopeforaglobaleconomicrecession,itjustmaybethatthecurrentfinancialcrisisisablessingforthesportsindustry.Herearefivereasonswhy:1.Peoplewillmakebettervaluebaseddecisions.Aspeopleconsiderthemicroeconomicsoftheirowncircumstancestheywilltakeaharderlookatthevaluereturnedforthemoneytheyinvestinsportsandrecreationalactivities.Whenparentsshelloutseveralhundreddollarseverymonthfortennislessons,icetime,teamtravelandtheliketheywillaskmorequestionsbeforewritingthecheck,andprogramadministratorsandcoachesbetterbereadywithgoodanswers.Privatecoachingandequipmentexpenseswillbemorecloselyscrutinized.Parentsaregoingtobelesslikelytoallowtheirkidstoshoparoundandmoreinclinedtopushforqualityexperiences.Asspectators,mostindividualswillbecomemoreprudentintheirchoices;andproteamswillneedtofindmorecreativewaystodrawindividualsandfamiliestotheirvenuestofillthegapsthatmaybeleftbycorporatecutbacksonentertainmentandhospitality.Thesecircumstanceswillresultinmorethoughtfuldecision‐making,andleadtobetterprogramsandservicesforparticipantsandspectators.2.Professionalathleteswillbevieweddifferently.Richathleteswillneedtobecomemoresensitiveandconnectedtotheregularfolks.Ostentatiousbehaviorwillbedeploredmorethaneverandextravagancewillberesented.Athleteswhocarrythemselveswithdignityandwhoshowasincerecaringforotherpeople
![Page 15: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
willfindnewopportunitiestoadvancetheirpersonalbrandthroughcause‐marketingandcommunityservice.Sportsistestingneweconomicwatersthatwillchangefans,sponsors,athletesandproperties.Agentsmustfindwaystobettersensitizetheathletestheyrepresent,andcommunityrelationsstaffmembersshouldbelookingforexpandedinvolvementopportunitiesforathletes.Companiesaregoingtobeincreasinglycarefulabouttheathletestheysignasspokespersons.Federationsandteamsmayfindthattheirathletesaremorewillingthaninthepasttobecomeinvolvedinpromotionalandcommunityactivities,andthisisaverygoodthingforoursportsandsociety.3.Sponsorcommitmentswillbecomemoresincereandlessopportunistic.Marketingandsponsorshipdollarsbecomeamongthefirstitemsputunderconsiderationforreductionoreliminationwhentougheconomictimeshit.Withmanycompaniesreducingthesizeoftheirworkforce,itispoliticallydifficulttojustifyanewsportssponsorshiptointernalconstituents.Thisisatimewhenrightsholderscanfindoutjusthowmuchasponsorvaluestherelationship,andthereisthetimeforrightsholderstoreallyoverdelivertosponsorsthatremainengagedandloyal.Neverhavelong‐termplanningandattentiontodetailbeenmoreimportant,andROImeasurementsarepremium.Currentconditionspresentasuperbopportunityforthoughtfuldiscussionsbetweencorporatemarketersandtheentitiestheysponsor.Weshouldseizeuponthisopportunitytoevaluateandrealignstrategiesandbuildstronger,“we’re‐in‐this‐together”personalrelationships.4.Propertyrightsholderswilldeliverabetterproduct.Consistentwiththenotionofoverdelivering,thisisagreattimeforadministrators,marketers,programmersandcustomerserviceproviderstolookateveryaspectoftheexperiencesweprovidetoourmembers,fans,sponsorsandmediapartnersanddeterminehowwecandoabetterjob.Everycommunication,everytouch,everyreasonableevaluationandfollow‐upshouldbecarefullyvettedandthoughtgiventohowtheexperiencecanbeimproved.Forexample,foracomingeventUSASwimmingwillbebusingpeoplefromremoteparkinglotstothefrontdoorsofthevenue.EachbuswillbehostedbyaretiredOlympianwhowillbeoutfittedwithamicrophonesothattheycanintroducethemselves,welcomepeopletotheevent,andprovidesomepersonalinsightsintothecompetition.Wewantpeopletobepleasantlysurprisedbythisextratouchandtoenterthevenuewithgreateranticipation.5.Industryprofessionalismwillrise.Becauseweallneedtoworkharderandsmarter,andbemorecreative,allstaffmemberswillbechallengedtoraisetheirowngame.Ibelievethatintheprocesswe’lluncovernewideasandstrategies,andwe’llseenewyoungstarsemerge.I’mlookingforwardtoseeingwhoonourstaffwillembracethechallengeandstepforwardwithenergyandenthusiasm,andconverselywe’llsadlyfindoutwhowillsitback,hideandplaydefensively.OnethingIalwaystellnewstaffmembersisthatifyoucanhelpusfindnewwaystogeneraterevenueand/orsolveproblems,there’llalwaysbeaplaceforyou.Theyear‐endreviewprocessthis
![Page 16: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
yearoughttobeagreatopportunityforsupervisorstomoreclearlydistinguishbetweentheA,BandCplayersonourstaffteams.Thisisnotimeforthesqueamishtobeinleadershiproles,andthosewhochoosetoembracethechallengesweallnowfacemayverywellfindthemselvesinapositiontonotonlyprotecttheirbrandandtheirsport,butmayevendiscovernewwaystogrowandexpandtheirbusiness.TedTurnermaynotbeeveryone’smodelforleadership,buthismantraof“lead,followorgetoutoftheway”neverseemedmoreaptthaninthesesomewhattroublingtimesnowfacingourindustry.ChuckWielgusisexecutivedirectorofUSASwimming.
![Page 17: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
17
GoAmbushMarketing.StayLegal.March15,2010RuthOberleitner
Theterm"AmbushMarketing"wasinventedbytheadvertisingbusinessintheUSinthe1980s.Itstandsforaspecialkindofmarketingcampaignwherecompaniescleverlyconnecttheirgoodsorbrandswithapopular,oftenathletic,event.
Ambushersoftentrytocatchafreeridebypayingnosponsorshipfeesbutmakingconsumersbelievetheyareofficialsponsors.Fromalegalpointofview,thetypesofAmbushMarketingvaryfromcreativestrategiesnotbreakinganylawstotheillegaluseoflogos,phrases,slogansandthelike.
Enhancebrandequity
Thetargetofambushersistoenhancetheirownbrandequitybylinkingtheirbrandtothepositiveequityofeventswithspecialstrategiesatlowcost.AttheOlympicGamesinBeijing2008,KFCusedtheassociativemarketingslogan"IloveBeijing".AndPepsireplaceditsusualbluecanswithredones"toshowtheirrespectfortheyearofChina"1.However,theofficialsponsorswereMcDonald's,notKFC,andCocaCola(withitsredcans),notPepsi.
InNewZealand,TelecomNewZealandLtdsucceededduringthe1996AtlantaOlympicGameswithanambushadvertisementcontainingtheword"ring"(forthesoundofaringingphone)arrangedfivetimesliketheOlympicringsandintheOlympiccolorswhilereferringtotheirnewmobilephone.
Othermajorsportingevents,suchastheFIFAWorldCup,andpubliccharacters,suchascelebratedathletes,aretargetedbyAmbushMarketingcampaigns.AMcDonald'scampaigntookaridenotonlyonthepassionsoftheFIFAWorldCup2006butalsoonthepositiveequityoftheAustrianFederalChancellor.WallpaperpostedalloverViennashowedtheFederalChancellorWolfgangSchusselholdingupared‐white‐red(thecolorsoftheAustrianfederalflag)scarfsaying"AUSTRIAISWORLDCHAMPION".
Allsuchactivitiesareconsidered"AmbushMarketing"intheadvertisementbusiness.Butfromalegalpointofview,weneedtotakeacloserlookanddifferentiate.
Directandindirectambushmarketing
Directambushmarketingactivities,suchastheunauthorized,illegaluseofaregisteredlogoonmerchandisinggoods,orafalseormisleadingclaimtobeanofficialsponsorofanevent,clearlyconstituteinfringements.
Indirectambushmarketing,ontheotherhand,ismoresubtleandfallswithinalegalgreyarea.MercedesbecamefamouswithitsindirectambushmarketingcampaignattheNewYorkCityMarathon1997.AlthoughToyotawastheofficialautomotivepartnerofthemarathon,Mercedeshaditsnamewrittenintheskyabovetheeventbyairplanes.Otherexamplesarethe"IloveBeijing"advertisementsforgrilledchickenduringtheSummerOlympicGames2008inChinaorthe"Wewillgetthetitle"campaignofMediaMarketinGermanyattheFIFAWorldCup2006.
Smartindirectambushersseektosucceedinlinkingthesponsoredactivitytotheirbrandwithoutanyintentiontoviolatetrademarkorcopyrightrightsbyusingprotectedlogosorwordsfortheiradvertisingcampaigns.However,thequestionwhetherthecampaignleads
![Page 18: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
tounlawfulandincorrectconsumersassociationsorconstitutesanyotherinfringementsneedsalsotobecheckedwithrespecttounfaircompetitionlaw.
Trademarkprotection
"Ambushingclearlybreachesintellectualpropertylawswhentrademarksareusedwithoutacontractualrightorlicenseandtrademarkrightsareinfringed."AccordingtotheAustrianTrademarkProtectionAct(Markenschutzgesetz;MSchG)notonlytheuseofanidenticalsignbutalsotheuseofasimilarsignwithalikelihoodofconfusionmaybeillegal.Theprotectionoftrademarkswithreputationisevenstronger.Theownerofatrademarkwithreputationmayrequestthirdpartiestorefrainalsofromusinganidenticalorsimilarsignforgoodsorserviceswhicharenotsimilartothoseprotectedunderthetrademark.
Unfaircompetition
Complementarytotrademarklaw,designatedregulationsoftheAustrianActagainstUnfairCompetition(GesetzgegenUnlauterenWettbewerb;UWG)supplementintellectualpropertylaw.Unfairbusinessactivitiesincludemisleadingbusinesspractices(Sec2UWG)2,imitationmarketingofcorporatebrands(Sec9UWG)andotherunfairbusinesspracticesfallingwithinthegeneralclauseofSec1UWG.Furthermore,anunfairexploitationofthegoodreputationofaneventorfalseallegationsinadvertisements,misleadingthepublicaboutthestatusoftheambusherasanofficialsponsor,maybeconsideredasunfaircompetition3.
Copyrightsandpersonalrights
Intellectualcreationsintheareaofliterature,photography,musicandartenjoy(withoutregistration)copyrightprotectionundertheAustrianCopyrightAct(Urheberrechtsgesetz;UrhG).Personalrightssuchastherighttoone'sownimagemayalsobeviolatedbyanadvertisingcampaign(seeChancellorSchusselexampleabove).
Remedies
Totheholderofintellectualpropertyrights,Austrianlawprovidesforremediessuchasanactionforpreliminaryorpermanentinjunction,compensation,ordersfordisposalanddestructionorpublicationofthejudgment.Theholderofrightsmayalsoinitiatecriminalproceedingsagainsttheinfringerinvariousintentionalcases.
Ambushmarketingactionsareusuallyshort‐livedcampaignswhichflashintoaction.Acourtdecisionorderinganinjunctionwillthereforeoftencometoolate.Evenpreliminaryinjunctionsdonotprovideformuchprotectionintheambushcompetition.Ambushmarketingcasesarethereforerarelyactionableandtheclaimantwillusuallybereferredtodamages‐onlysuchdamagesarehardtoprove.
Footnotes
1Soderman/Dolles,Strategicfitininternationalsponsorship‐thecaseoftheOlympicGamesinBeijing2008,InternationalJournalofSportsMarketing&Sponsorship(SJSMS),January2008,98.
2Anderl/ApplinWiebe/G.Kodek,UWG(2009)s.2Rz325;Duursma/Duursma‐KepplingerinGumpoldsberger/Baumann,UWGErganzungsbands.2Rz38.
3AustrianSupremeCourt(ObersterGerichtshof‐OGH)17.9.1996,4Ob2206/96g‐FootballAssociation‐OBl1997,83.SeealsoHorak,"AmbushMarketing"unddieEURO2008‐AngriffaufdasWerbemonopol!,ecolex2007,416.
![Page 19: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
Thecontentofthisarticleisintendedtoprovideageneralguidetothesubjectmatter.Specialistadviceshouldbesoughtaboutyourspecificcircumstances.(c)MondaqLtd,2010‐Tel.+44(0)2085448300‐http://www.mondaq.com
![Page 20: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
ComcastreachesdealtokeepsportseventsonfreeTVJune20,2010By:BobFernandezWithaMondaydeadlineloomingattheFederalCommunicationsCommission,ComcastCorp.hasreachedanagreementwithindependentNBCTVstationstokeeptheKentuckyDerby,SundayNightFootball,theStanleyCupFinals,andothermarqueesportingeventsonfreeover‐the‐airTV,officialswithNBCstationsandComcastsay.ThedealsidelinessomepotentialpoliticaloppositiontoComcast's$30billiondealforcontrolofNBCUniversalInc.andsettlesabigissuefor210independentNBCaffiliates.TheNBCstationsfearedthecablegiantwouldmoveblockbustersportstoComcast'spay‐to‐watchsportschannelVersustochallengeESPN.AwholesalemigrationofNBCsportscontenttocableTVwouldbeablowtotheover‐the‐airNBCbrand.NBCSportsisoneofthecrownjewelsinNBCUniversal,mostlybecauseofitsOlympicscoverage.OtherNBCSportspropertiesincludeWimbledon,thePGAtour,theRyderCup,theU.S.Opentennischampionship,andthePreakness.MichaelFiorile,previouschairmanoftheNBCAffiliateBoard,saidThursdaythattheNBCSportspackage"willnotchangesubstantially"onover‐the‐airstationsafteramerger,althoughComcastcouldbroadcastsomepartsofcompetitionsorindividualeventson"oneoftheirpaychannels."Theagreementkeepssportsonover‐the‐airNBCTVforthe"foreseeablefuture,"saidFiorile,thechiefexecutiveofficeroftheDispatchBroadcastGroup."That'snottosay,"hesaid,"thatin20years,ifallsportshasmigrated,thattheywon'tdothesamething."Eventhoughpublic‐interestgroupssayComcastshouldsellthe10NBCover‐the‐airTVstationsthatitwouldownafteramerger,whichwouldincludeNBC10inPhiladelphia,theindependentNBCstationswouldlikeComcasttoretainownershipofthem,Fiorilesaid."Wewantthemintheover‐the‐airbusinesssotheyhaveskininthegame,"hesaid.ThesportsagreementbetweentheNBCstationsandComcastcomesasthepublic‐commentperiodattheFCCoverthemergerendsMonday.
![Page 21: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
TheFCCdeniedarequestfromfinancial‐researchandmediagiantBloombergL.P.toextendthecommentperiodtoearlyAugust,andmanyindustryobserversexpectaflurryoffilings.Opponents,whichincludeotherpay‐TVoperators,theCommunicationWorkersofAmerica,andpublic‐interestgroups,sayComcastwouldgainexcessivemarketpowerthroughitscontrolofthenation'slargestcableTVnetworkandoneofthenation'slargestentertainmentcompanies,NBCUniversal.AletterexpectedtobefiledMondaywiththeFCCandsignedbyBloomberg,theCWA,andotherssaysthatComcast‐NBCU"will,toanunprecedenteddegree,havethemeansandincentivestodriveupthecostsofcableandsatelliteTVserviceforconsumers,andunderminecompetitionbetweenvideodistributors."AcopywasmadeavailabletoTheInquireronFriday.Comcasthassaidthemergeritselfshouldhavenoeffectoncableprices.DavidL.Cohen,executivevicepresidentofComcast,saidThursdaythatthecablecompanywascomfortablewiththepaceofthereviewinWashingtonandpleasedwiththeshowofsupportfortheComcast‐NBCUdeal,whichwasannouncedinDecember.MayorNutterwasamongthelatestPennsylvaniaofficialstocomeoutinfavor,sayinginaWednesdaylettertotheFCC:"HereinPhiladelphia,wesupportourown."NuttersaidintheletterthatComcast"sharesourunrelentingdrivetoensurePhiladelphiaisontopofitseconomicgameforthefuture."InMay,mostofthePennsylvaniadelegationinWashingtonsignedalettersponsoredbyRep.BobBrady(D.,Phila.)thatwaswritteninpartbyaComcastlobbyistinWashington.WhilePennsylvanialawmakersstresstheeconomic‐developmentbenefitsofthedeal,criticsviewtheeconomicpowerofthemergedentityasathreattocompetition.ComcastsaidFridaythatmorethan400lettersofsupportforthemergerhavebeenfiledwiththeFCC.TheAmericanCableAssociation,agroupofabout900cablecompanies,mostwithfewerthan5,000subscribers,saysComcast‐NBCUcouldbundleComcast‐controlledlocalsportswithNBC'sentertainmentandnewsintoa"must‐have"programmingpackageandchargepremiumprices.Pay‐TVoperatorswouldhavetobuyanddistributetheprogramming,leadingtohighercostsforsubscribers.ThemarketswhereComcast‐NBCUwouldhavethemosteconomicpowerarethosewithComcastregionalsportsnetworksandNBCTVaffiliatesownedbyNBCUniversal,theysay.Philadelphiaisoneofthosemarkets."Thethreatisthatallcableoperators‐notjustsmallcableoperators‐willpayhigherpricesforalltheprogrammingthateitherofthesetwoentitiessellseparately,"saidWilliamRogerson,aneconomicsprofessoratNorthwesternUniversityandformerFCCchiefeconomist.
![Page 22: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
RogersonsaidhewouldhavethesameconcernsifNBCUniversalhadsaiditwouldbuyComcast'sregionalsportsnetworksbecauseofthedepthofprogrammingthedealwouldgivethemergedcompanyinlocalmarkets.TellingComcasttosellitsregionalsportsnetworksinthosemajormetropolitanmarketsasaconditionofthemergerwouldbeunrealistic,Rogersonsaid.ButtheFCCcouldenactanarbitrationproceduretoleveltheplayingfieldbetweenComcast‐NBCUandcompetitorswhentheycannotagreeondistributionprices,Rogersonsaid.Cohen,thecableexecutive,calledtheideathatComcastwouldgainexcessiveeconomicpowerintheprogrammingbusiness"anacademicallyandfactuallyflawedargument."Hesaidthatafteramerger,Comcastwouldcontrolonly9percentto12percentofthenation'sprogrammingmarket.ThisarticlewasreprintedwiththepermissionofBobFernandezandthePhiladelphiaInquirer
![Page 23: STAYING AHEAD OF THE GAME: LICENSING, SPONSORSHIP, …...(television, radio, internet, wireless, etc.), marketing, consumer product licensing, corporate sponsorships, events and intellectual](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022051605/6015f3927c31c42e8e022ef3/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
WORKSCITEDKristiDosh,WhyNFL’sSupremeCourtLossIsn’tMuchofaLoss,Forbes,May24,2010,http://blogs.forbes.com/sportsmoney/2010/05/why‐nfls‐supreme‐court‐loss‐isnt‐much‐of‐aloss.KristiDosh,AmericanNeedlev.NFL:LookingForward,Forbes,May26,2010,http://blogs.forbes.com/sportsmoney/2010/05/american‐needle‐vs‐nfl‐looking‐forward/.BobFernandez,ComcastreachesdealtokeepsportseventsonfreeTV,PhiladelphiaInquirer,June20,2010,http://www.philly.com/philly/business/technology/20100620_Comcast_reaches_deal_to_keep_sports_events_on_free_TV.html#axzz0rRmLGwqU.AdamLisbergandJoseMartinez,LebronJameswouldbring$58MtoNewYorkCityifhejoinedKnicksandwonGame7andtitle:study,NewYorkDailyNews,June1,2010,http://www.nydailynews.com/ny_local/2010/06/02/2010‐06‐02_untitled__lebron02m.html.RuthOberleitner,GoAmbushMarketing.StayLegal.,MondaqBusinessBriefingMarch15,2010,http://www.mondaq.com/article.asp?articleid=95860.KyleStack,LebrontheFinancialKingofNewYork?,SlamOnline,June6,2010,http://www.slamonline.com/online/nba/2010/06/lebron‐the‐financial‐king‐of‐new‐york/.ChuckWieglus,HowaBadEconomyCouldChangeIndustryfortheBetter,SportsBusinessJournal,June8,2009,http://sportsbusinessjournal.com/article/62757.