Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

11
What proportion of basic surgical trainees continue in a surgical career?A survey of the factors which are important in influencing career decisions. Richards et al.The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

description

What proportion of basic surgical trainees continue in a surgical career?A survey of the factors which are important in influencing career decisions. Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO. UK Surgical Training. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

Page 1: Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

What proportion of basic surgical trainees continue in a surgical career?A survey of the factors which are important in influencing

career decisions.

Richards et al.The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009

Phil O’Halloran

Surgical SHO

Page 2: Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

UK Surgical Training

2007 (MMC) trainees recruited from foundation year 2 to RTT in a specific speciality.

Committing to speciality at very early stage. Pre 2007: 2-3 year core training (Ireland)

Page 3: Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

Methods

467 BST trainees in West & South East of Scotland (1996-2006)

299 had valid email addresses Invited to participate in an online survey

Page 4: Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

Survey Questions

Page 5: Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

Results

64% response rate (191/299) 72% males (137/191)

Figure 1-No.of respondents starting the BST each year

Page 6: Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

Results

I want to be a surgeon!

Figure 2- timing of decision to pursue a career in surgery

Page 7: Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

Results

Page 8: Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

Results

At the time of survey…..

78% still in surgery (149/191)

20% moved out of surgery (38/191)

2% left medicine completely (4/191)

Page 9: Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

Results

Figure 4.Current careers who have left surgery

Page 10: Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

Limitations

Biased Weak study- but topical Small number- poor uptake Not national

Page 11: Richards et al . The Surgeon; Volume 7 No.5; October 2009 Phil O’Halloran Surgical SHO

Discussion!

As of the 8th of October 2009 @ 14.23

BST is now a 3 year programme in Ireland.

- is this the way forward???