Pipeline Management 0

download Pipeline Management 0

of 30

Transcript of Pipeline Management 0

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    1/30

    CRITICAL PATH STRATEGIES, IN

    No. 33 FM 474

    Boerne, TX 78006-8214

    800.818.7253 830.249.1977

    www.criticalpathstrategies.com

    Pipeline Managemen

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    2/30

    Pipeline Managemen

    A successful pipeline management process not only improves sales velocity

    and performance. It also helps sales teams communicate, select the right op-

    portunities to work on, enhance account strategy, and allocate resources for

    maximum effectiveness.

    Inde

    White Paper: Best Practices in Pipeline Management .......................1-26

    Trust Your Pipeline ............................................................................27-28

    Visit CPS online . . . www.criticalpathstrategies.com

    Join our L inkedIn Group . . . The Best Best Practices in Sales Effectiveness

    ABOUT CPS. Critical Path Strategies

    helps clients improve the effectiveness

    of their sales organization. Our portfolio

    of services addresses the strategic,

    organizational, and relationship issues

    that impact selling performance. Our

    powerful processes enable clients to

    transform their sales culture, enhancetheir competitive position, and accom-

    plish strategic business initiatives. Our

    clientsemerging companies and

    members of the Fortune 500 alike

    typically measure 100 to 500 times their

    CPS investment in revenue growth.

    http://www.linkedin.com/groups?mostPopular=&gid=2158190http://www.linkedin.com/groups?mostPopular=&gid=2158190http://www.linkedin.com/groups?mostPopular=&gid=2158190http://www.linkedin.com/groups?mostPopular=&gid=2158190http://www.linkedin.com/groups?mostPopular=&gid=2158190http://www.linkedin.com/groups?mostPopular=&gid=2158190
  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    3/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    December 2005

    RESEARCHSTUDYBY:

    Filigree Consultingwww.filigreeconsulting.com

    Best Practices in Pipeline Management

    A consulting practice of Critical Path Strategies, Inc.

    CPS WHITE PAPER

    -1-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    4/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Abstract

    This paper describes the current state of the

    art and best practices in Pipeline Manage-

    ment. It is based on a study of twenty-one

    organizations in North America, completed in

    the third quarter of 2005.

    According to the participants, the tangible

    benefits of pipeline management are: to opti-

    mize resource allocation, improve opportunity

    selection and focus, reduce sales cycle time,

    facilitate strategy, and drive revenue growth

    and profitability. Unfortunately, only a few

    participants, have attained these goals. Satis-

    faction with pipeline management is generally

    low, and improvement projects rampant.Pipelines are not trusted.

    Pipeline management is a blend of process,

    technology, strategy, and people intended to

    improve the yield on sales and marketing

    investments by structuring deliberate interac-

    tions that drive the quantity, quality, and ve-

    locity of selling opportunities. A strategy to

    achieve outstanding pipeline management

    outcomes, developed by Critical Path Strate-

    gies, was presented to the participants for

    their comments and input, and is reviewed in

    this paper.

    -2-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    5/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Scope of Study 4

    Executive Summary 5

    Study Introduction 6

    Key Hypotheses 7

    Key Findings 8-9

    Detailed Findings 10-23

    Trusted Pipeline: A Rarity?10

    Satisfaction with Pipeline Management: Not! 11

    Pipeline Management Vision 12

    Value of Pipeline Management Information 13-14

    Best Practices Model 15

    Pipeline Management Inhibitors 16-17

    Pipeline Management Maturity 17

    Performance Groups 18-19

    Maturity Progression 19

    Critical Path StrategiesPipeline Management 20-22

    ConclusionsLeader Best Practices 23-24

    Study Demographics 25

    About Critical Path Strategies 26

    About Filigree Consulting 26

    Table of Contents

    -3-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    6/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Scope of StudyScope

    21 high-level interviews

    Participants

    Product and service company executives

    with quota-bearing or revenue objectives.

    The participants were generally from tech-

    nology and service companies, and repre-

    sented a broad distribution of revenue

    sizes. Within their specific span of control,

    the participants were engaged in manag-

    ing from under 25 to over 500 directsales representatives, and supported or

    managed businesses from less than

    $250 million to more than $5 billion in

    revenue. The participants represented

    general management (24%), sales man-

    agement (67%), and marketing (9%).

    Partial List of Participants

    Acxiom Corporation

    ARCADIS N.V.

    Avnet, Inc.

    Bell Microproducts

    Caterpillar Logistics Services, Inc.

    ChoicePoint, Inc.

    EMCOR Group, Inc.

    GE Healthcare

    IBM.com Americas

    Industrial and Financial Systems, IFS

    AB

    Microsoft Business Solutions

    National Oilwell Varco, Inc.

    Sun Microsystems, Inc.

    Symon Communications, Inc.

    Technip USA Corporation

    TeleTech Holdings, Inc.

    TELUS Corporation

    Vignette Corporation

    -4-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    7/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Overview

    Executive Summary

    In a third quarter 2005 study, many gen-eral managers and sales and marketing

    executives told us that they did not have

    confidence in their revenue pipelines.

    And while a quarter of the study partici-

    pants were satisfied with their pipeline

    management process and execution,

    almost all of that group and over 80% of

    the total group of participants, were en-

    gaged in an improvement project.

    The leading performers recognize their

    revenue pipeline as a business asset,

    and broadly value their pipeline informa-

    tion. Their pipeline management proc-

    esses are detailed, rigorous, and sup-

    ported by effective automation. They have

    focused on disciplined execution and

    have made pipeline management part of

    their management rhythm. Most impor-

    tantly, they drive tangible business re-

    sults via effective pipeline management.

    They have experienced improved profits,

    grown revenue, penetrated accounts

    more effectively, improved alignment with

    customers, and increased stockholder

    confidence. Not only do they provide ex-

    amples of best practices, they clearly

    attribute business results to having imple-

    mented them.

    Managing the revenue pipeline in a com-

    prehensive and aggressive manner sim-

    ply makes good business sense. The con-

    sistency and quality of an organizations

    revenue pipeline should clearly be an

    item of paramount focus.

    Pipeline management is a blend of proc-

    ess, technology, strategy, and people

    intended to improve the yield on sales

    and marketing investments by structuring

    deliberate interactions that drive the

    quantity, quality, and velocity of selling

    opportunities. Effective pipeline manage-

    ment provides information useful to the

    overall business as a basis for forecast-

    ing, resource allocation, and just-in-time

    sales coaching and has spillover benefits

    in defining required inventory levels and

    engagement resource requirements. In

    general, the participants in this study

    were positively convinced that optimized

    pipeline management would help them

    achieve greater profitability, increase

    revenues, and improve alignment with

    customer needs.

    The participants in the study provided

    significant insight into the state of the art,

    key issues and inhibitors, potential andrealized benefits, and best practices. One

    of their key observations is that it all

    starts with leadership. Organizations with

    nascent pipeline management generally

    begin their improvement processes with a

    focus on helping their leadership team

    realize the need to improve. After that,

    they focus on developing a pipeline man-

    agement strategy, addressing overall

    cultural issues, and striving to gain con-

    trol of their pipelines. They then seek to

    optimize and integrate processes andtools. Their initial efforts are broad and

    sweeping. These initial projects generally

    contribute positively to business results in

    terms of revenue, profit, and customer

    satisfaction. Balanced performance,

    where process, technology, strategy, and

    people combine to provide pipeline man-

    agement that delivers extraordinary busi-

    ness results, is a matter of incremental

    improvements.

    As organizations progress on the journey

    from nascent pipeline management to

    high performance, the pipeline becomes

    increasingly valuable, and tangible bene-

    fits are achieved. Sales velocity is im-

    proved. Resource allocation is optimized.

    Alignment with customer needs positively

    impacts customer value. Revenue grows,

    profit increases, and shareholder confi-

    dence is strengthened.

    -5-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    8/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    In the third quarter of 2005, Critical Path

    Strategies and Filigree Consulting con-

    ducted a study intended to identify current

    practices, benefits, and the key elements of

    pipeline management. Twenty-one general

    management, sales, and marketing execu-

    tives contributed to the project via an in-

    depth interview of one to two hours.

    During the interview, we collected informa-

    tion on the participants role in pipeline

    management, demographics about the

    portion of business they were responsible

    for, the status and plans for their pipeline

    management processes, and their percep-tions of benefits, inhibitors, and best prac-

    tices for pipeline management.

    Study Introduction

    -6-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    9/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Key Hypotheses

    To begin the study process, we formu-

    lated a set of hypotheses regarding pipe-

    line management. As is typical in such

    studies, some were confirmed absolutely,

    some to a certain extent, and some were

    rejected. We appreciate the participation,

    forthright input, and advice of our distin-

    guished participants. The table below

    outlines some of the more interesting

    hypotheses and what we learned about

    them.

    We will delve into these and other impor-

    tant lessons learned during the study in

    the remaining body of this paper. Based

    on our findings, we must conclude that

    pipeline management is an important

    business discipline that has solid and

    tangible business results, and that most

    organizations have a long way to go to

    achieve them.

    Initial Hypothesis What We LearnedEffective pipeline managementleads to consistent sales perform-ance that meets or exceeds expecta-tions. Its greatest benefit is in im-

    proving the predictability of revenue.

    While our participants agreed that their pipeline management efforts improved theirsales velocity and performance, they saw the largest benefits of pipeline managementas: a means of communication, selecting the right opportunities to work on, enhancingstrategy, and providing for more effective resource allocation. While these all wouldeventually drive a more predictable process and results, we find the specific underlying

    drivers of predictability and velocity very informative.

    Two key vectors of pipeline manage-ment effectiveness are process and

    discipline.

    While there was little disagreement from the participants on the importance of processand discipline, we learned that strategy and especially technology have huge impact on

    the effectiveness of pipeline management.

    The right level of sales and salessupport resources are clearly under-stood for each opportunity and allo-

    cated for maximum effectiveness(and profitability).

    Resoundingly, our participants saw resource allocation (in two formsthe right trans-

    actions and the right resources) as the key benefit of advanced pipeline management.

    In general, most sales organizationsdo not trust their pipelines, and aredissatisfied with their pipeline man-

    agement process and discipline.

    This appears generally to be true based on the input from our participants. Dissatisfac-tion is common, improvement programs even more common. Even a few of the top

    performers have programs for incremental improvement.

    Most of our participants demonstrated evidence of distrust of pipeline data. Its gener-ally disconnected from forecasts, suffers from relatively low use, is not clearly valued,

    and was described (quite a few times) as fluffespecially in the early sales cycle.

    Of course, there are notable exceptions and clear signals that it should be better.

    -7-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    10/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    1. Revenue Pipelines: Not trustedDo I trust my pipeline? Sure, but not

    the data, was a common theme

    expressed by our participants. While

    not everyone interviewed agreed, the

    lack of control of input, lack of stan-

    dards, cultural impacts, and lack of

    sales skills in recognizing a real

    opportunity were frequently cited as

    the culprits.

    Most of the time, pipeline trust was

    based on personal knowledge of

    transactions or sales teams. I ad-

    just team X down by 15% and team Y

    up by 20% and get to a fairly consis-

    tent forecast. Conversely, top per-

    formers not only trust their pipelines

    but they consistently link the infor-

    mation into their forecasting proc-

    esses.

    2. State of pipeline management:Dissatisfied"Have you talked to any sales execu-

    tive who's satisfied with his or her

    pipeline management?" While in fact

    we did, it was not common, with over75% noting dissatisfaction with their

    pipeline management process or

    discipline. Even more telling is that

    over 80% of the participants were

    engaged in some active improve-

    ment initiative, with many engaged in

    sweeping reforms and a few at the

    extreme of re-building the entire

    process and discipline.

    3. Pipeline management: An importantbusiness discipline with broad busi-ness benefits.When participants where asked to

    describe the potential business

    benefits of effective pipeline man-

    agement, they described a broad set

    of benefits. A top-line view of their

    responses suggests a general con-

    sensus on the potential for pipeline

    management to improve profitability

    and grow revenues. The specifics

    defining howthese benefits will be

    achieved are focused on resource

    allocation, opportunity selection and

    focus, and improvements in strategy

    based on information.

    4. The business value of pipeline man-agement information: Consistencyand differencesIn general, the participants high-

    lighted the value of pipeline manage-

    ment information to the sales organi-zation as a basis for communica-

    tions, coaching, opportunity manage-

    ment, and strategy alignment and

    development. All of these uses were

    driving at the goal of increasing sales

    velocity by defining the best actions

    the team could take at any moment

    in time.

    Outside the sales organization, pipe-

    line management information was

    often used by marketing, develop-

    ment, supply chain management,and delivery organizations. While

    there are clear differences among

    organizations (primarily based on

    their commitment and pipeline man-

    agement process maturity), a key

    difference in the perceived business

    value of pipeline management infor-

    mation is apparent between profes-

    sional/consulting service organiza-

    tions and product organizations.

    5. Effective pipeline management re-quirement: Strategy, people, process,and technologyWhile at its core pipeline manage-

    ment is an information process with

    the primary purpose of enhancing

    decision-making, it is dependent on

    people and enabling technology. The

    Key Findings

    -8-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    11/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    correct balance of strategy, people,

    process, and technology is a key

    requirement in creating an effective

    pipeline management system.

    6. Inhibitors to effective pipeline man-agement: Tools and tool integrationThe most frequently named inhibitors

    to achieving an optimized state of

    pipeline management were the pipe-

    line tools and tool integration (44%

    of respondents), and integration with

    other business processes (44%).

    Issues with the tool set were broadly

    distributed across pipeline manage-ment maturity levels, with the most

    experienced organizations looking for

    enhancements and integration and

    the least mature seeking an initial

    toolset. The recognition that integra-

    tion with other business processes in

    an inhibitor reflects the idea that

    optimization of pipeline management

    is dependent on cross-organizational

    involvement.

    7. The state of the art of pipeline man-agement: Diverse and evenly distrib-utedIn general, respondents averaged at

    close to the midpoint of the maturity

    scale we developed from the inter-

    view process. About one-third of the

    respondents were in a very low level

    of development with undocumented,

    unpredictable, and ad hoc pipeline

    management approaches. Another

    29% were in a moderate state of

    development with some elements of

    control and defined processes. The

    top performers were split between

    those in a proactive state of maturity

    (24%) and the most mature organiza-

    tions (14%), which had pipeline man-

    agement processes that contributed

    extremely strong value to their over-

    all businesses.

    8. Some participants pipeline manage-ment approaches would benefit fromadditional process sophisticationincluding formalization of recom-mended actions across the buyingprocess.Participants reviewed the Critical

    Path Strategies two-dimensional

    model for pipeline management, and

    provided valuable input to its applica-

    bility and use. The model, called all-

    wheel traction pipeline manage-ment, describes the specific facets of

    multi-level selling across the buying

    cycle. While most participants agreed

    with the value of the approach, sev-

    eral commented on the need for

    simplification, additional integration,

    and flexibility in the selling process.

    In general, very few of the partici-

    pants had the implied level of pipe-

    line management sophistication in

    place.

    Key Findings

    -9-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    12/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Forecast Accuracy and PipelineManagement Information Use

    Organizations that provide highly cus-

    tomized or professional-service-oriented solutions tend to connect

    their pipelines more directly with their

    forecast than product companies.

    Net: Trusted pipelines and linkage to the

    organizations forecasting approach do

    appear to be an important factor revenue

    predictability.

    Trusted Pipelines: A Rarity?

    Pipeline information rarely (if ever) is the

    sole source of forecasting information.

    While we do not believe it should be the

    only input, only one-third of our partici-

    pants directly link pipeline data to fore-

    casts.

    All participants who were involved in fore-

    casting revenue indicated that they

    generally made or always made their

    forecasts. However, the reasons organiza-

    tions always made their forecasts often

    had little to do with pipeline manage-mentlarge recurring revenue streams or

    sandbagging were mentioned several

    times.

    While we found that about one-third of

    the organizations involved made a direct

    connection between their pipeline infor-

    mation and their forecasts, another third

    described it as input that was only indi-

    rectly used, and another third as not

    used at all.

    Examples of sales executives applying

    their own estimation techniques were

    frequent, and early sales cycle transac-

    tions were commonly categorized as

    fluffy.

    While our study was not rigorous from a

    quantification perspective, we did identify

    a strong relationship between forecast

    accuracy and the use of pipeline informa-

    tion.

    Organizations that directly linked their

    pipeline data to forecasts say thatthey always meet their forecasts.

    Organizations that say they generally

    meet their forecasts either connect

    pipeline management information

    indirectly or not at all.

    Detailed Findings

    Use of Pipeline Information

    Frequency of Meeting ForecastsAlways Meet57%

    Dont Forecast5%

    Generally Meet38%

    Use of Pipeline Information in ForecastingPipeline DataUsed Directly29%

    Pipeline DataIgnored

    29%

    Pipeline DataUsed Indirectly

    42%

    0%

    5%

    10%

    15%

    20%

    25%

    30%

    Always Meet Generally Meet

    Frequency of Meeting Forecast

    Directly

    Indirectly

    Not Connected

    -10-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    13/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Satisfaction with Pipeline Manage-

    ment: Not!

    Indications of lack of trust also show up

    in the participants satisfaction with pipe-

    line management, and in their willingness

    to expend resources on corrective action.

    Even a few of the satisfied participants

    are engaged in improvement projects.

    This indicates that the response to the

    question, Are we there yet? is almost

    always No.

    Thus it is not surprising that most partici-

    pants who mentioned their recent suc-cesses also described the work they had

    left to do. They seemed to recognize that

    pipeline management was an ongoing

    journey.

    And while pipeline management was not

    a priority for a couple of participants,

    only one participant believed that they

    may have gone too far, and needed to

    reassess their processes, workload impli-

    cations, and impacts on sales representa-

    tives time.

    A few in new positions in companies, or

    positions without much prior focus on

    pipeline management, will make major

    investments:

    One credits a focus on sales process

    and pipeline management as why I

    got the job.

    Another will focus on lessons learned

    by other company divisions as theyaggressively implement, and has a

    financial mandate to do it.

    Most of the incremental projects are fo-

    cused on tools and tool integration, with

    some others focusing on process stream-

    lining and refining processes.

    Indeed we are not there yet.

    Detailed Findings

    Satisfaction with Pipeline ManagementDissatisfied withBoth Process andDiscipline48%

    Dissatisfiedwith Discipline14%

    Dissatisfiedwith Process

    14%

    Satisfiedwith Both

    24%

    Improvement Projects

    IncrementalProject52%

    Big Project29%

    Not Needed19%

    -11-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    14/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Pipeline Management Vision

    Participants describe their visions of the

    impact of optimized pipeline manage-

    ment in general terms of increased reve-

    nue, reduced costs, and improved profit-

    ability. Deeper analysis of the input re-

    veals the ways these benefits will be

    achieved.

    Optimize Resource Allocation, Improve

    Focus, and Facilitate Effective Opportu-

    nity Selection

    As one participant noted: [The main

    benefit] would be more business andbetter selection of opportunities to pur-

    sue.

    Several participants indicated that good

    pipeline management would not only

    improve the selection of which opportu-

    nities to pursue (approximately 25%), but

    would also help align resources with se-

    lected opportunities (approximately 40%).

    In general, pipeline management is seen

    as a process and discipline that would

    help their organizations focus on doing

    the right things with optimal resources.

    Organizations that provide highly custom-

    ized or professional-service-oriented solu-

    tions view optimizing resource allocation

    slightly differently than product compa-

    nies. For service companies, resource

    allocation is about assigning (and in some

    cases training) people to deliver services

    and solutions. For product companies,

    optimizing resource allocation is more

    about ensuring that their supply chains

    can build the quantity of product neededor that they have sufficient quantities in

    inventory for the opportunities in the pipe-

    line.

    Reduce Sales Cycle Time, Increase Sales

    Velocity, and Drive Revenue

    Reducing the sales cycle time was a com-

    mon theme from several participants. Not

    only was pipeline management key in

    ensuring that sales activities occurred in

    a timely manner, but it provided sales

    management with the ability to catchproblems early and provided focus on

    stalled opportunities.

    Provide Important Input to Strategy

    Participants describe this in two different

    ways (and some mentioned both). First,

    pipeline data provides input to short-term

    sales strategy and facilitates coaching.

    Second, aggregated (and, in some cases,

    historical) data is used as an input to

    overall business strategy. Both uses indi-

    cate the value of pipeline information as abasis for strategy and decision-making.

    One participant noted, The pipeline has

    huge impact on planning for the delivery

    organization, both in terms of people and

    technology resources.

    Detailed Findings

    Key Elements of Vision

    0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%

    Limit Review Time

    Improve Penetration

    Increase Customer Satisfaction

    Enhance Coaching

    Increase Close Rate

    Improve Forecast Accuracy

    Drive Revenue

    Improve Market Information

    Reduce Sales Cost

    Increase Profit

    Improve Focus (Selection)

    Reduce Cycle Time, Drive Velocity

    Assist with Strategy Formulation

    Optimize Resource Utilization

    Note: Percentage of Respondents Mentioning(Multiple Responses Collected per Participant)

    -12-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    15/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Value of Pipeline Management Infor-

    mation

    Inside the Sales Organization

    In general, pipeline management informa-

    tion is used to improve communications

    within the sales structure to accelerate

    sales, make better selection and resource

    allocation decisions, and to enable a long-

    term view.

    Pipeline information provides a basis for

    early corrective action regarding revenue

    trends and allows sales executives to

    take timely action. As one participant putit, uses pipeline information to get a

    sense for where the business is short

    term relative to making the forecast, and

    long term making sure there is enough in

    the pipeline to meet objectives down the

    road.

    Coaching is facilitated by pipeline infor-

    mation. Pipeline data is used to inter-

    cede and facilitate when needed. It's

    through weekly meetings between sales

    executives and managers that issues will

    come to light.

    Regularly scheduled (weekly is most com-

    mon) meetings intended to accelerate

    sales cycles were held in almost all of the

    participants organizations. The key point

    that several participants mentioned was

    using the meetings to drive action. As one

    participant mentioned, The weekly call

    lends itself to coaching and education

    based on the issues discussed that are

    hampering a sale. This tends to occur

    when going through open points and ask-

    ing what needs to be done to move this

    forward? Even among top performers

    where just-in-time (ad hoc) coaching was

    the primary model of coaching communi-

    cations, a weekly meeting occurred. In a

    few of the participants organizations

    (generally the smaller ones) and at lower

    levels, the participants relied on their

    personal knowledge of sales opportuni-

    ties and transactions to drive communica-

    tions.

    A common theme in both service and

    product companies was using pipeline

    data to support opportunity decisions. As

    one service company participant noted,

    Using it as a basis for weekly approval/

    no approval reviews keep the information

    current and relevant.

    Outside the Sales Structure

    Outside the sales structure, pipeline infor-mation is used by some of the partici-

    pants organizations to link input to devel-

    opment, service delivery, supply chain

    management, and marketing.

    There were a few cases in which the use

    of pipeline information as a basis of de-

    velopment was cited. When prompted, a

    few participants indicated that the sales

    cycle and the development cycle were not

    in sync so the pipeline information was

    either too early or too late to assist in

    most product development efforts. One

    marketing executive mentioned that,

    [pipeline information] will be used in the

    2006 planning process to develop and

    assess services and products. Another

    described pipeline information as a

    means to assess whether a commonly

    ordered group of components should be

    packaged as a solution. The use of pipe-

    line information in supply chain manage-

    ment and service delivery management

    was significantly different based on the

    organizations business model.

    Detailed Findings

    Primary Uses of PipelineInformationby theTop-to-Bottom Sales Team:

    Communications

    Coaching

    Opportunity Selection

    Strategy Alignment

    Drive Velocity by Definingand Supporting Action

    Primary Uses of PipelineInformationby OrganizationsOutside the Sales Team:

    Product Development

    Marketing

    Supply Chain Management

    Service Delivery Manage-ment

    Inside the Sales Organization

    Outside the Sales Organization

    -13-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    16/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Differences in Value Based on Business

    Model

    Differences in the use of pipeline informa-

    tion seem strongly related to the degree

    of customization of the offering.

    Professional/Consultative Service Provid-

    ersOrganizations with a high degree of

    offer customization

    Organizations providing largely custom

    solutions rely on the pipeline manage-

    ment process as a key resource allocation

    tool for delivery resources. During the

    conversion from lead to proposal to en-gagement, these firms review pipeline

    opportunities to make go/no-go decisions

    and assign engagement, assessment,

    and site survey or proposal resources.

    Due to this important function, pipeline

    management data (at the individual op-

    portunity level) is often highly visible

    across the management team, and

    viewed as a critical business asset.

    Product ProvidersOrganizations with a

    low degree of offer customization

    At the other end of the customization

    scale, are product providers who sell off-

    the-shelf components and manufactured

    goods. They use pipeline management

    data to ensure that adequate supply ex-

    ists in inventory (or is easily acquired) to

    meet potential business needs. They link

    their pipeline data to inventory and finan-

    cial management systems. They attach

    high value to pipeline data as a tool to

    drive supply chain efficiency, and to jointly

    forecast with customers. This often oc-curs under the operational covers and

    is generally not visible to senior manage-

    ment, except in an aggregated form.

    Solutions ProvidersOrganizations with a

    moderate degree of offer customization

    In the space between the fully custom

    and the off-the-shelf providers, a num-

    ber of companies in the study were char-

    acterized by a combination of both types

    of offers, generally integrated (at least to

    some extent) in the field. Solutions provid-

    ers value pipeline management data as a

    sales tool, and for aggregated input into

    solution development. Pipeline data is

    used to access the optimum packaging

    level and the best integration point

    (development vs. field) for solutions.

    Sophisticated solutions providers inte-

    grate the process of ensuing that their

    field organizations are aligning solutions

    with customer value via their pipeline

    reviews and coaching efforts. Thus, solu-

    tions providers focus on value alignment

    between their customers and the offer

    being constructed in the field, and imbed

    this in their reviews and processes.

    Detailed Findings

    -14-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    17/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Best Practices Model

    Pipeline management is an information

    process intended to support decision-

    making and drive the most effective best

    next actions possible. Pipeline manage-

    ment is optimized via a balance of strat-

    egy, people, process, and technology.

    Strategy

    Strategy includes the engagement of top-

    level executives in the process and the

    use of pipeline information for strategic

    purposes. Alignment of pipeline manage-

    ment with other business processes andthe overall business strategy is a key best

    practice. This requires an environment

    where the business value of pipeline

    management information is understood,

    not only within sales, but also across the

    entire business.

    People

    Pipeline management is people intensive,the value of pipeline information is de-

    pendent on consistency of definitions,

    use, and execution. Individual sales per-

    sonnel must conform to a level of infor-

    mation quality that makes the data use-

    ful. This requires a focus on culture, skills,

    incentives, and accountability. Discipline

    in execution is necessary across the man-

    agement team and down to the individual

    contributor level.

    Process

    Key elements of best practices from a

    process perspective include a process for

    review that results in useful (and positive)

    feedback and action. Resource allocation

    based on pipeline management informa-

    tion reinforces the organizations appar-

    ent confidence in the process.

    Clarity in the linkage between the pipeline

    and the sales process (and sales cycle) is

    an important process-oriented best prac-

    tice. This clarity results is meaningful

    coaching, which in turn results in in-

    creased sales velocity.

    Technology

    Technology best practices enable the use

    of pipeline information. They include inte-

    gration of the technology into day-to-day

    operational sales tools and ease of use,

    at several levels. Pipeline tools must be

    natural extensions of the sales repre-

    sentatives workload and workflow. Data

    entry must be simple, while enforcing

    information quality and consistency stan-

    dards. The pipeline management technol-

    ogy must encourage the use of the infor-

    mation by providing interfaces and tools

    for business intelligence, exception re-

    porting, and root cause analysis.

    Detailed Findings

    Pipeline Management Balance

    IncreasedRevenues

    Profitability

    Align withBusinessGoals

    Objectives

    STRATEGY

    PEOPLE

    P

    R

    O

    C

    E

    S

    S

    T

    E

    C

    H

    N

    O

    L

    O

    G

    Y

    AllocateBest

    PossibleResources

    Skills

    Identify BestNext Actions

    Enable Visibility Decision-Making

    IncreasedRevenues

    Profitability

    Align withBusinessGoals

    Objectives

    STRATEGYSTRATEGY

    PEOPLEPEOPLE

    P

    R

    O

    C

    E

    S

    S

    P

    R

    O

    C

    E

    S

    S

    T

    E

    C

    H

    N

    O

    L

    O

    G

    Y

    T

    E

    C

    H

    N

    O

    L

    O

    G

    Y

    AllocateBest

    PossibleResources

    Skills

    Identify BestNext Actions

    Enable Visibility Decision-Making

    -15-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    18/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Pipeline Management Inhibitors

    The most frequently mentioned inhibitors

    to effective pipeline management were

    tools/tool integration (mentioned by 44%

    of respondents), and integration with

    other business processes (44%). These

    were followed by leadership is-

    sues (33%), deficiencies within

    sales (28% - generally these inhibitors

    described skills issues, sales manage-

    ment focus, or sales process issues), and

    sales resources constraints (22%).

    Tools and Tool Integration

    A significant amount of discussion during

    our interviews was devoted to the pipeline

    management toolset. While this ranged

    from fairly satisfied to totally broken,

    its fair to say that the majority of the par-

    ticipants are dissatisfied with their pipe-

    line management tools.

    In addition to simple dissatisfaction withthe toolset, several participants men-

    tioned that the real problem was the lack

    of pipeline management integration with

    forecasting, account planning, campaign,

    lead management, and inventory man-

    agement tools.

    These comments were more frequently

    made by service companies than product

    companies.

    Integration with other Business Processes

    Sales talking to itself is useful in terms

    of revenue acceleration, coaching, and

    tracking, but to get the maximum value

    from a pipeline management system re-

    quires multifunctional and cross-

    organizational engagement. Several par-

    ticipants mentioned that the lack of in-

    volvement of the entire business value

    creation process (e.g. development, de-

    livery, support, marketing) significantly

    limits what could be done with their pipe-

    line management process. Product com-

    panies tended to put more emphasis on

    this inhibitor than service companies.

    Leadership Issues (and Culture)

    Most frequently the leadership issues

    described the lack of senior management

    involvement and support of the pipeline

    initiative. This was generally a lack of

    senior management interest in the infor-

    mation, and most frequently occurred in

    organizations with nascent pipeline man-

    agement processes. We suspect that the

    engagement of senior management is the

    use of pipeline management data re-

    quires a certain level of maturity and con-

    fidence in the process and information,

    and is difficult to achieve until at least a

    moderate state of maturity. This, of

    course, compounds the effort in achieving

    Detailed Findings

    Inhibitors

    0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%

    Getting Reps to See Value

    Not Integrated into Sales Workflow

    Sales Resources

    Deficiencies within Sales

    Leadership Issues

    Tools/Tool Integration

    Integration with Other Business Processes

    Note: Percentage of Respondents Mentioning(Multiple Responses Collected per Participant)

    -16-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    19/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    high maturity, as the support of senior

    management is an important symbol in

    fostering the cultural environment neces-

    sary to get there.

    Generally we grouped issues regarding

    culture into the leadership inhibitor as

    they were most often expressed as a

    leadership or management issue. High-

    lighting the importance of maintaining an

    effective and non-punitive environment

    was pervasive. As one participant said,

    Culture is the biggest challenge for our

    organization. In some cases, the partici-

    pants mention the heritage of their busi-nesses as a significant contributor to

    pipeline management success, indicating

    that a lack of customer, sales, and mar-

    keting focus can be a significant impedi-

    ment.

    Pipeline Management Maturity

    As part of the interview process, we col-

    lected a series of data points intended to

    diagnose the maturity of the participants

    pipeline management approach. We

    scored the organizations pipeline matur-

    ity on a one-to-five scale (low to high)

    based on the following:

    Strategy.High maturity indicated bythe recognition of the revenue pipeline

    as a business asset. Resource alloca-

    tion and opportunity selection is facili-

    tated by quality opportunity informa-

    tion.

    Leadership. High maturity indicated bysenior management support, and the

    recognition of pipeline data as valu-

    able business information. Pipeline

    information trending shows evidence

    as instigating efforts external to sales

    (e.g. product development, packag-

    ing).

    Culture. High maturity indicated bycomplete viability of pipeline dataacross all relevant management lay-

    ers, without significant filtering. Sales

    representatives secure that pipeline

    management will not be used in a

    punitive manner, and that it repre-

    sents an important management tool

    that benefits the entire business.

    Process. High maturity organizationshave formal processes with clear stew-

    ardship. The process is supported by

    high-quality automation that enhances

    data use and is integrated into the

    sales representatives workflow and

    the sales cycle. Just-in-time coaching

    is facilitated by pipeline information

    and accelerates revenue.

    Discipline. High maturity is indicatedby consistency, accountability, and a

    broadly used metrics system. Fore-

    casts based on pipeline data are con-

    sistently met. Stakeholder value is

    optimized, via revenue velocity, cus-

    tomer value alignment, and improvednegotiation strength.

    Organization. High maturity is indi-cated by seamless execution without

    the requirement for significant staff

    support, and minimal impact on sales

    representatives workloads.

    Overall Results

    Overall, the participants organizations

    scored at just under the midpoint (2.97)

    of the five-point maturity scale. Average

    scores for individual sections (i.e. Strat-

    egy, Leadership, etc.) were also close to

    the midpoint, with Leadership the high at

    3.05, and Process the low at 2.66. Inter-

    estingly, there was little difference in ma-

    turity (on average) for service vs. product

    companies.

    Detailed Findings

    -17-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    20/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Performance Groups

    Individual organizations were widely dis-

    persed with a high score of 4.71 and a

    low score of 1.1. The respondents per-

    formance fell into four fairly clear groups

    as noted below:

    Flight School. Seven organizationswith an average overall score of 1.58

    on a five scale.

    Private Pilots. Six organizations withan average overall score of 2.81 on a

    five scale.

    Commercial Pilots. Five organizationswith an average score of 3.72 on a

    five scale.

    Top Guns. Three organizations with anaverage score of 4.62 on a five scale.

    Flight School organizations were generallynew to pipeline management as a busi-

    ness discipline. Most had active improve-

    ment programs in place. This is apparent

    from their relatively higher scores in lead-

    ership. From this we infer that the firststep in the development of an effective

    pipeline manage-

    ment approach is

    the realization by

    management that

    it needs to be a

    focus initiative. A

    few of the partici-

    pants in this

    group were spe-

    cifically brought

    in to implementsales process and

    discipline.

    Private Pilot organizations represent asignificant jump in maturity over the flight

    school organizations with a 78% increase

    in their overall average score. They are

    close to the midpoint of the scale overall

    (2.81). Their pipeline management proc-

    esses are in control but tend top be reac-

    tive in nature.

    Most of the Private Pilot organizations

    also had improvement programs in place,

    but they tended to be less sweeping than

    flight school organizations, focused on

    incremental improvement in a few key

    areas. The most significant improvement

    areas between Flight School organiza-

    tions and Private Pilot organizations are

    Strategy and Culture.

    Commercial Pilot organizations representa proactive state of pipeline manage-

    ment. They have achieved an overall ma-

    turity level of 3.72 on a five scale. Their

    pipeline management processes are well-

    managed, proactive, and contribute to

    their overall business success. Forecasts

    are consistently met. Coaching is effective

    and accelerates sales velocity.

    About half of the Commercial Pilot organi-

    zations have improvement programs in

    place that are very selective in nature,

    often representing things like next gen-eration tools and broader cross-

    organization process integration. The

    most significant improvement areas be-

    tween Private Pilot organizations and

    Commercial Pilot organizations are in the

    areas of Leadership and Process.

    Top Guns represent a world-class state ofmaturity in their pipeline management

    approaches. Their pipeline information

    adds value to their businesses, broadly

    improving decision-making across the

    organization. Consistency and stake-

    holder value are optimized. They score, on

    average, very close to the top of the scale

    at 4.62 on a five scale.

    Generally the key difference between

    Commercial Pilot organizations and Top

    Guns is in the area of Discipline. Top

    Detailed Findings

    MaturityPerformance Groups

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    Overall

    Strategy

    Leadership

    Culture

    Process

    Discipline

    Organization

    Top Guns (3) Commercial Pilot s (5)

    Private Pilot s (6) Flight School (7)

    -18-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    21/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Guns demonstrate balanced performance

    across the maturity model, and have very

    specific tuning initiatives in place to

    improve their pipeline management.

    Maturity Progression

    The comparisons between the maturity

    groups can give us some insight into how

    maturity may progress. While these

    groups describe different organizations at

    differing levels of development and are

    not a longitudinal study of the actual

    maturation process in each organization,

    they do indicate some tendencies in theprocess.

    It appears that it all starts with Leader-

    ship. Flight School organizations in a gen-

    erally chaotic state relative to pipeline

    management maturity begin the progres-

    sion by realizing that they need to im-

    prove.

    The next steps appear to be focused on

    Strategy and Culture as organizations

    seek to gain control of their pipelines and

    move to a more controlled, albeit reactive,

    state. This is followed by a focus on Proc-

    ess and further engagement of Leader-

    ship, moving organizations to a proactive,

    controlled state of pipeline maturity. And

    finally balanced performance, with a

    strong focus on Discipline, leads organiza-

    tions to a state of optimized pipeline man-

    agement.

    Through this progression, pipeline infor-

    mation becomes more valuable, and the

    contribution of the process to the busi-

    ness increases. Sales velocity is im-proved. Resource allocation is optimized.

    Just-in-time coaching, and customer align-

    ment positively impact customer value.

    Detailed Findings

    -19-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    22/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Critical Path Strategies Pipeline

    ManagementAt the end of the interviews we introduced

    the Critical Path Strategies (CPS) model

    for pipeline management execution. The

    CPS model is based on two vectorsthe

    sales cycle and a broad set of considera-

    tions that positively impact the cus-

    tomers buying cycle.

    All-Wheel Traction

    The TRUST Concept (Technology, Rela-

    tionship, Utility, Strategy, and Team) is a

    system of considerations that can posi-

    tively impact the customers buying cycle.

    When applied across the cycle, attention

    to these considerations can accelerate

    and normalize buying. Buying becomes

    a predictable process.

    CPS calls this all-wheel traction. At each

    stage of the buying cycle a different set of

    TRUST actions is defined. This matrix of

    actions becomes the basis for reviews,

    metrics, and ensuring sales velocity.

    TRUST Elements

    Technology. The Technical fit of theoffering to the customers environ-

    ment

    Relationship. Key Relationships thatmust be successfully engaged and

    nurtured

    Utility. The Utility and subsequentvalue of the offering that enables the

    client to implement the solution to

    meet their goals

    Strategy. The Strategy and tactics theselling team must deploy to create

    client-recognized value and the ur-

    gency to take action

    Team. Enrolling the selling team andpartners to execute the strategy

    The chart below is an example of the

    types of actions that correspond to the

    TRUST concept at different stages of

    the selling cycle.

    Detailed Findings

    Engage full ongoing

    support team &

    coverage model

    Evaluate deal

    trade-off & confirm

    terms

    Initiate project

    management &

    delivery processes

    Confirm

    customer & team

    understanding of

    business utility

    Provide customer

    analyst examples

    Integrate customer

    with support &

    management team

    Update solution

    based on

    evaluation

    Close

    Align team &

    support flawless

    execution of POC or

    trial

    Understand

    potential barriers &

    deliver complete

    proposal

    Engage references

    Negotiate

    Refine value

    proposition for

    competitive

    differentiation

    Complete project

    justification

    Engage relationship

    strategy & action

    plan. Focus

    communications on

    complete under-

    standing of decision

    criteria

    Develop POC or

    trialPropose

    Gain consensus

    from customer on

    solution

    Focus opportunity

    to a single solution

    Identify

    appropriate

    resources

    Understand &

    target value

    Develop relationship

    strategy & action

    plan

    Assess needs &

    confirm technical

    evaluation criteria

    Architect

    Define account

    team partners &

    jointly develop

    customer interest

    Deliver examples

    & success stories

    Scope opportunity

    & define leverage

    Understand

    impact of

    customer pain

    &/or initiative

    objectives

    Identify sponsor

    Focus on

    relationship building

    Refine solutions

    using customer

    assessments

    Discover

    Lead management

    process integrates

    team

    Demonstrate

    capability via

    briefings & sales

    materials

    Identify pain &/or

    key initiative

    Identify areas of

    common interest &

    mutual relationships

    Identify solutionsQualify

    TeamStrategyUtilityRelationshipTechnology

    Engage full ongoing

    support team &

    coverage model

    Evaluate deal

    trade-off & confirm

    terms

    Initiate project

    management &

    delivery processes

    Confirm

    customer & team

    understanding of

    business utility

    Provide customer

    analyst examples

    Integrate customer

    with support &

    management team

    Update solution

    based on

    evaluation

    Close

    Align team &

    support flawless

    execution of POC or

    trial

    Understand

    potential barriers &

    deliver complete

    proposal

    Engage references

    Negotiate

    Refine value

    proposition for

    competitive

    differentiation

    Complete project

    justification

    Engage relationship

    strategy & action

    plan. Focus

    communications on

    complete under-

    standing of decision

    criteria

    Develop POC or

    trialPropose

    Gain consensus

    from customer on

    solution

    Focus opportunity

    to a single solution

    Identify

    appropriate

    resources

    Understand &

    target value

    Develop relationship

    strategy & action

    plan

    Assess needs &

    confirm technical

    evaluation criteria

    Architect

    Define account

    team partners &

    jointly develop

    customer interest

    Deliver examples

    & success stories

    Scope opportunity

    & define leverage

    Understand

    impact of

    customer pain

    &/or initiative

    objectives

    Identify sponsor

    Focus on

    relationship building

    Refine solutions

    using customer

    assessments

    Discover

    Lead management

    process integrates

    team

    Demonstrate

    capability via

    briefings & sales

    materials

    Identify pain &/or

    key initiative

    Identify areas of

    common interest &

    mutual relationships

    Identify solutionsQualify

    TeamStrategyUtilityRelationshipTechnology

    -20-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    23/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Organizations that implement this two-

    dimensional concept in pipeline manage-

    ment tend to view selling strategy as

    multi-faceted. Alignment with customer

    value is demonstrated via clarity in the fit

    between the customers needs and the

    providers capabilities. Selling occurs at

    multiple levels within the customer, serv-

    ing the needs of complex buying units.

    The sales team and the customer are fully

    integrated to maximize the utility of the

    solution.

    Conversely, organizations that implement

    a more traditional single-dimensionalsales cycle, addressing technology in the

    early sales cycle stages and formulating

    teams during the later stages, tend to

    miss the ability to leverage the opportu-

    nity and may be exposed to surprises

    during the buying process.

    Study Participants Input

    When presented with the all-wheel trac-

    tion model, most participants agreed

    that the application of this level of proc-

    ess discipline would certainly and posi-tively impact their success. Participants

    liked the direction that such a model and

    approach would provide.

    The participants generally commented

    that the all-wheel traction model would

    fit well with their larger opportunities and

    more complex sales, but may be overly

    complex for simple transactions. Some

    simplification might be needed. Other

    concerns included the lack of flexibility

    implied by the rigid structure, and the

    potential difficulty of integration with their

    current approaches. One participant won-

    dered, Is it ever really implemented that

    way in the field? Conversely, several

    commented that the senior reps do this

    intuitively and codifying for the other

    reps would be great.

    Several participants indicated that a few

    things were missing. These included the

    integration of other processes, including

    lead generation/marketing campaign

    management, and account planning. A

    few indicated that the process could be

    enhanced with more structure and auto-

    mation, similar to a stage/gate develop-

    ment process and an automated ap-

    proach to sales coaching.

    Clearly, the raw model is not applicable

    to every situation, selling approach, or

    providers business model. Tailoring the

    model to specific situations and integra-tion of the model with the appropriate

    business processes is necessary.

    Activation

    In addition to presenting the all-wheel

    traction model, we showed the partici-

    pants an example of how it might be used

    to visualize the status of key transactions

    in a particular territory.

    One participant noted, The thought proc-

    ess works for complex saleswe are find-

    ing over time that surprises are reduced.

    When we do win/loss reviews, we are

    able to drill down and find a particular

    area where they [the reps] have skipped

    an activity/step. Another noted, I see

    great value to the dashboard...it lets you

    walk through the discipline and see what

    it is we are talking about, and we can also

    see red flags easily.

    The use of the dashboard has many

    applications and is key to activating an

    effective pipeline management process. Itcan help with root-cause analysis, under-

    standing the reasons for a win or loss. It

    also provides a clear basis for just-in-

    time coaching.

    Detailed Findings

    -21-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    24/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Envision yourself in a conversation with a

    sales rep that has just delivered the be-

    low chart. What do you want to talk to the

    rep about?

    Detailed Findings

    Oppo

    rtunity

    1

    Oppp

    ortu

    nity

    2

    Oppo

    rtunity

    3

    Oppp

    ortu

    nity

    4

    Oppp

    ortu

    nity

    5

    Oppo

    rtunity

    6

    QualifyTechnology Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Relationship Yes Yes In Process Yes Yes In Process

    Utility Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes In Process

    Strategy Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

    Team Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes In Process

    DiscoverTechnology Yes Yes Yes Yes In Process In Process

    Relationship Yes Yes In Process Yes Yes In Process

    Utility Yes In Process In Process Yes In Process In Process

    Strategy In Process In Process Yes In Process In Process In Process

    Team Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes In Process

    Architect /Al ignTechnology Yes In Process In Process Yes In Process In Process

    Relationship Yes In Process In Process In Process Yes In Process

    Utility Yes In Process In Process Yes In Process In Process

    Strategy In Process In Process In Process Yes In Process In Process

    Team Yes Yes In Pr oc es s Yes In Pr oces s No

    ProposeTechnology In Process In Process In Process Yes In Process No

    Relationship In Process In Process In Process Yes In Process No

    Utility Yes In Process No Yes In Process NoStrategy In Process In Process In Process Yes In Process No

    Team Yes Yes In Pr oc es s Yes In Pr oces s No

    CloseTechnology Yes In Process Yes Yes Yes No

    Relationship Yes In Process Yes Yes Yes No

    Utility In Process In Process No Yes In Process No

    Strategy In Process In Process No In Process In Process No

    Team In Process In Process No Yes In Process No

    -22-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    25/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Conclusions Leaders Best Practices

    State of the Art at the Top

    About 40% of the participants organiza-tions had achieved a level of solid per-

    formance in pipeline management. These

    organizations had implemented pipeline

    management approaches with sound and

    optimized processes, rigorous manage-

    ment discipline, quality technology solu-

    tions, supportive culture, and engaged

    senior management. They consistently

    met forecasts, had already achieved a

    high level of sales velocity, were able to

    select opportunities effectively, and allo-

    cate resources efficiently. Interestingly,most of these leaders had improvement

    projects in place (the journey continues).

    Leaders Best Practices

    Leaders best practices demonstrate their

    high level of sophistication. To put this in

    perspective, one participant, new to his

    position (and specifically put in place to

    instill sales process optimization), noted,

    That's high school stuff. We're in third

    grade." Indeed, but perhaps the leaders,

    representing both service and product

    companies, are in grad school. Heres

    what they said:

    Recognition of the revenue pipelineas a business assetIn general, the leaders organization

    recognized the business value of

    their revenue pipelines. They exhib-

    ited an excellent understanding of

    how pipeline (and managing the pipe-

    line better) impacts their business.

    This understanding was shared

    across (and up and down) the busi-

    ness. In short, the pipeline repre-

    sents the future of the company.

    Recognition of pipeline informationas a business information assetNot only did the leaders exhibit an

    understanding of the value of the

    pipeline itself, their organizations

    valued the information the pipeline

    management system supplied, both

    within sales and in other business

    functions. As one participant put it,

    Pipeline data is the data source

    regarding sales. They used pipeline

    data across the organization to as-

    sess internal investments in product

    development, marketing, and service

    delivery/supply chain management.

    Pipeline information was often

    viewed as an important input to stra-

    tegic decisions.

    Pipeline management is part of man-agement rhythmIn the leaders companies, pipeline

    management process and discipline

    was simply a part of day-to-day op-

    erations and decision-making. A cul-

    ture that evidences the belief that

    "this needs to be done to help us

    understand and run the business

    better" is in place. In fact, the leaders

    have implemented cultural environ-

    ments where pipeline management

    has transcended the status of not

    punitive nor optional and have

    achieved an environment where the

    activity is actually appreciated and

    (dare we say?) enjoyed. Sales repre-

    sentatives receive better coaching,

    get help when needed, and attain

    greater success. Management enjoys

    better information. And most impor-

    tantly, the business achieves in-

    creased profitability and revenue

    growth.

    Recognition of the reve-nue pipeline as a businessasset

    Recognition of pipelineinformation as a businessinformation asset

    Pipeline management ispart of managementrhythm

    Pipeline managementprocess is detailed, rigor-ous, and supported byeffective automation

    Pipeline managementdrives tangible businessresults

    Leaders Best Practices

    -23-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    26/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Conclusions Leader Best Practices

    Pipeline management process isdetailed, rigorous, and supported byeffective automationLeaders generally had formal, disci-

    plined, and rigorous pipeline man-

    agement processes. These proc-

    esses and the automation supporting

    them were integrated into the sales

    workflow and other business sys-

    tems. Their processes and informa-

    tion requirements were not burden-

    some. They were not only business

    as usual, but also facilitated opera-

    tions.

    Pipeline management drives tangiblebusiness resultsNot only do the leaders discuss pipe-

    line management in terms of commu-

    nications, coaching, intervention,

    control, and information, they discuss

    real business results. They have ex-

    perienced improved profits, grown

    revenue, penetrated accounts more

    effectively, improved alignment with

    customers, and stockholder confi-dence. They have used their compe-

    tence in internal communications

    and process to create value for them-

    selves, their customers, their employ-

    ees, and their stockholders.

    -24-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    27/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    Study Demographics

    Approximately two-thirds of the partici-

    pants were from sales management roles,

    ranging from corporate Chief Sales Officer

    to Sales Line Management. The remain-

    ing third were general management ex-

    ecutives, most of whom had sales jobs

    prior to their current assignment, and

    marketing executives with close linkages

    to their sales organizations.

    Almost all of the participants were quota-

    bearing, or had revenue and profit busi-

    ness objectives.

    All had some degree of experience and a

    good degree of visibility to their organiza-

    tions pipeline management processes

    and practices.

    The revenue associated with the partici-

    pants span of control ranged from a high

    of over $5 billion to a low of under $250

    million. We have denoted this metric as

    relevant revenue in the chart.

    The number of sales reps relevant to the

    participants span of control ranged from

    a high of over 500 direct representatives

    to under 25.

    The participants came from a diverse

    group of industries with a high concentra-tion of information technology and profes-

    sional services companies.

    Participant RoleDivision/Unit Sales

    Executive28%

    High-Level CSO14%

    Key AccountExecutive

    14%

    GeneralManagementExecutive24%

    Sales LineManagement10%

    High-Level MarketingExecutive

    10%

    < $250M19%

    Relevant Revenue$250 - $499M

    33%

    $5B

    5% $1 - $4.99B33%

    $500 - $999M10%

    Direct Reps (Relevant Count)25 - 4928%

    50 - 9929%

    100 - 24914%

    5005%

    -25-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    28/30

    WHITE PAPER: BEST PRACTICES IN PIPELINE MANAGEMENT

    www.criticalpathstrategies.c

    2005 by Critical Path Strategies,Inc. All Rights Reserv

    About Critical Path StrategiesCritical Path Strategies helps clients im-

    prove the effectiveness of their sales

    organization. Our portfolio of services

    addresses the strategic, organizational,

    and relationship issues that impact sell-

    ing performance. Our powerful processes

    enable clients to transform their sales

    culture, enhance their competitive posi-

    tion, and accomplish strategic business

    initiatives. Our clientsemerging compa-

    nies and members of the Fortune 500

    aliketypically measure 100 to 500 times

    their CPS investment in revenue growth.

    Filigree Consulting administered this

    study and performed the analysis of the

    results. Filigree provides custom re-

    search, project management, and re-

    search consulting for client projects as

    part of its focus on information-intensive

    industries. Filigree Consulting works with

    clients to help them align with key con-

    stituencies and build competitive advan-

    tage through fact-based decision-making.

    About Filigree Consulting

    -26-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    29/30

    CRITICAL PATHWAYS

    In an unfortunate era of corporate misbehavior, investors, stockholders, and customers carefully scrutinize t

    financial health of an organization and assess the risk factors of owning equity and doing business with a com

    pany that expounds their value and strength, but could be defunct tomorrow. How can credibility be assured

    Companies operate in a world that communicates current business performance in terms of key ratios: EB

    DSO; COGS; E/R; Debt to Equity. In evaluating companies, we study the balance sheet, the income sta

    ment, 10Ks, 8Ks, and analyst reports. In analyzing a companys anticipated performance, we trust tha

    combination of corporate ethics, internal governance, and reporting regulations will permit an outsider to atta

    a reasonable picture of stability. The street rewards growth and predictability intuitively, and in the simple

    terms, the true future value of any company is based upon the size, quality, and predictability of its revenu

    pipeline. While forecasting accuracy is essential when managing quarter-to-quarter shareholder expectatio

    analysis of the revenue/opportunity pipeline can provide the clearest view of marketplace strength and co

    petitive trends. The fact is, pipeline management is not a well-honed practice in many firms. One of our clien

    mused If we managed our expenses the way we manage our pipeline, we would be out of control and prob

    bly out of business.

    Amazingly, in our decades of working with the largest and most prestigious companies in business today,

    often find that the executive leadership takes little interest in the purposeful assessment of the revenue pip

    line. They miss the opportunity to address potential revenue gaps until deals have stalled in the pipeline a

    the forecast is jeopardized. Fundamentally, we believe that the pipeline of opportunities must be managed w

    the same rigor as every other asset of the enterprise. CPS believes that a managed pipeline is one that

    purposeful and is built on a principle of TRUST.

    The responsibility of predicting sales and delivering revenue with

    expectations is nothing new to sales executives. Developing forecast

    tracking key deals, and scrutinizing win ratios have always been a

    integral part in conducting trade. And while the processes o

    generating opportunities and delivering revenue have represented th

    fundamental raison detre for selling organizations, the environme

    today has become more complicated. Publicly traded companies,

    providing financial transparency as mandated by Sarbanes-Oxley, fin

    that corporate governance is a critical issue.

    The CPS theme of

    "TRUST is a recog-

    nized ingredient for

    success in building a

    sustainable pipeline

    for growth.

    Trust Your Pipeline

    by Mike Morto

    -27-

  • 8/12/2019 Pipeline Management 0

    30/30

    CRITICAL PATHWAYS

    In organizations where a trusted pipeline exists, selling is viewed as a function that orchestrates the actio

    associated with multi-faceted strategy. Progress of an opportunity is measured in how well weve demo

    strated a fit between the customers needs and our capabilities. We look at the process and approach to re

    tionship-building and how we are creating value from the utility of the fit. We view the nature of the strate

    and the teamwork required to activate the strategy. Simply put, we call this TRUST. In this use of TRUS

    consider that pipeline management needs are similar to an all-wheel drive vehicle. All facets of the sales pro

    ess need to be engaged at some level from the beginning of the process through to close.

    Our experience has shown us that when a company can trust its pipeline, the following tangible outcom

    occur:

    Sales opportunities proceed through the selling stages with a predictable velocity; opportunit

    that are stalled in a stage are identified early and proactively addressed.

    The teams win rate exceeds the average in its industry.

    When an opportunity is lost, the team knows who won and why. The organization never misses a forecast; there are no end-of-financial period surprises.

    When negotiations occur in the final selling stages, the organizations negotiating position i

    proves; margins are held.

    The bottom-line: A pipeline built on TRUST provides a reliable measurement for a companys future succes

    Technology The Technology fit of your offering to the customers environment

    Relationship Key Relationships that must be successfully engaged and nurtured

    Utility The Utility and subsequent value of your offering that enables yourclient to implement the solution to meet their goals and addresstheir pains

    Strategy The Strategy and tactics the selling team must develop and executeto create client recognized value and the urgency to take action

    Team Enrolling the Team (your companys team and its Partners) toexecute the strategy and establishing accountability to action andachievement

    ABOUT CPS. Critical Path Strategies

    helps clients improve the effectiveness

    of their sales organization. Our portfolio

    of services addresses the strategic,

    organizational, and relationship issues

    that impact selling performance. Our

    powerful processes enable clients to

    transform their sales culture, enhance

    their competitive position, and accom-

    plish strategic business initiatives. Our

    clientsemerging companies and mem-

    bers of the Fortune 500 aliketypically

    measure 100 to 500 times their CPS

    investment in revenue growth.