PAS February Subgroup Chairs Meeting - nerc.com Analysis Subcommittee PAS D… · •Clyde Melton...

PAS February Subgroup Chairs Meeting

February 14, 2012

2 RELIABILITY | ACCOUNTABILITY

Participants

• Bill Adams • Jeff Schaller • Jake Langthorn • Gary Brinkworth • Sharon Bauer • Mike Curley • Jessica Bian • Clyde Melton • James Powell • Matthew Varghese


Anti-Trust Notice

• It is NERC’s policy and practice to obey the antitrust laws and to avoid all conduct that unreasonably restrains competition.

• This policy requires the avoidance of any conduct that violates, or that might appear to violate, the antitrust laws.

• Among other things, the antitrust laws forbid any agreement between or among competitors regarding: prices, availability of service, product design, terms of sale, division of markets, allocation of customers, or any other activity that unreasonably restrains competition.


Draft Agenda

• TADSWG Update • GADSWG Update • DADSWG Update • PAS Update • Annual Report Outline and Work Plan • PAS Status Report for March 6-7 OC/PC (Phoenix) Meeting

TADSWG 100-199 kV data request comments (In PAS Status Report) EIA recommendations (In PAS Status Report) Voluntary data request for common/dependent mode outages (In PAS

Status Report) Mandatory webE-GADS online April 1, 2012 Preliminary DADS Data Summary (In PAS Status Report) Event Driven Index (EDI) approval?

• Adjourn


TADSWG Update

• TADSWG 100-199 kV Comments Comments due 2/24/2012

Letter sent to June OC/PC Meeting

• Endorsed one of EIA recommended analysis methods Unpaired Poisson

All conclusions should be substantiated with statistical methods

• Sent voluntary data request to TOs with common/dependent mode outages on February 5. Survey Due Date: March 6

• March OC/PC status report included in PAS status report


GADSWG Update

• GADSWG Still organizing after December meeting approval by PC

Identifying members o Bulk of GADS membership are Regional representatives

o Sent slate of candidates to Regional Entities

o Critical mass of members recruited, and can start a work plan

• First meeting – March 14-15, 2012, in Atlanta at NERC Offices

• Kick-off conference call February 24, 2012 10:30am ET

• GADS Coordinator Training Session Atlanta, 3/13-3/14 before GADSWG meeting


DADSWG Update

• All data received for 2011 Summer

• Two Reports Individual DADs Report

1st Draft of DADS Section of PAS Report

• Face to Face Meeting in 2/29-3/1 (Atlanta NERC Offices) Review the first data set from webDADS

1st Draft of PAS Annual Report DADS Section


Forum Update

• NATF – Heide Caswell (Chris Johnson at TADSWG)

• Focused on metrics to provide members in the form of dashboards

• Adopting PAS metrics and developing at a lower level to help owners measure themselves

• Positive about PAS progress

• NATF is working toward a customer impact metric


CIGRE

• CIGRE asked for permission to use material from 2011 Annual Report

• Jessica will share CIGRE material once published.


Report Outline

• Introduction (Bill Adams) • Executive Summary (Bill Adams) • Key Findings/Conclusions (PAS fun meeting)

The “meat” of the report Trends and Recommendations Link, based on each ALR characteristic Tie together into overall State of Reliability

• PAS Overview (Bill Adams) • PAS Indicators (Ed Pfeiffer) • TADS Analysis (Jake Langthorn) • GADS Analysis (Gary Brinkworth) • DADS Analysis (Sharon Bauer) • Events Analysis (Jacquie Smith) • Post Seasonal Assessments for 2011 (Bits and pieces) (Kevin/Curtis) • Future Advancements (KISS)

Changes to the ALR due to ALRTF (Jessica, John) SDI, CDI (Index Team) Risk-Initiating Events (Index Team)


Analysis Section Structure

• Ways DADS/GADS/TADS supports ALR and High Level Connection to Reliability More depth than in Key Findings/Conclusions

• Details in separate section Measure Description

Formula

Chart/Table (Will depend on whether Table/Chart is appropriate)

Conclusions on Analysis o Mathematically, makes sense?

o Practically, makes sense?


TADS Analysis Section

• Consensus on starting with last year’s section Added some changes

• Will work with template to incorporate information


Overall Theme of Report

• Have more of a linkage between sections with ALR/Risks/etc?


Need from Subgroups

• What will the data look like?

• How will your group’s data fit into the goals of the report?

• Relevant Data

• What is the story behind the data? ALR Metrics Trends/Other statistics over time (Trends)

Identify any changes from prior trends based on new data

Identify any risks or concerns from the data/story


Action Items

• Template for subgroup sections (Andy) Discuss/send comments on template as needed

• OC/PC Update Chairs send status report for PAS update by 2/20/2012

• Continue to send meeting announcements for PAS calendar

• Review previous slide (Need from Subgroups) in each subgroup

PAS February Subgroup Chairs Meeting - nerc.com Analysis Subcommittee PAS D… · •Clyde Melton...

Documents

Transcript of PAS February Subgroup Chairs Meeting - nerc.com Analysis Subcommittee PAS D… · •Clyde Melton...