Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1....

31
Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for identifying flow regimes An interesting interplay of Tomography/ Tomometry Saba Mylvaganam Faculty of Technology University College of Southeast Norway 21/12/2016 1

Transcript of Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1....

Page 1: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Multiphase flow studies with

tomometric techniques for

identifying

flow regimesAn interesting interplay of Tomography/ Tomometry

Saba Mylvaganam

Faculty of Technology

University College of Southeast Norway

21/12/2016 1

Page 2: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Terminology- Technolgy

20/12/20

162

Tomography

ECT, ERT,EIT etc

Gamma, X-Ray, Tera-Hertz etc.

Tomometry

ECTm, ERTm,EITm

E – Electrical, C- Capacitance, R- Resistane

I- Impedance

Depends permittivity, conductivity,

permeability etc.

Also radiation based tomometry

Tomography and

Tomometry as

complimentary

techniques

Page 3: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Fig. 3. Illustrating the difference between in-line, online, and at-line product measurements during manufacturing.

Anneleen Burggraeve, Tinne Monteyne, Chris Vervaet, Jean Paul Remon, Thomas De Beer

Process analytical tools for monitoring, understanding, and control of pharmaceutical fluidized bed granulation: A review

European Journal of Pharmaceutics and Biopharmaceutics, Volume 83, Issue 1, 2013, 2–15

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ejpb.2012.09.008

On-line, In-Line and At-Line

INTRODUCTION

Page 4: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Anneleen Burggraeve, Tinne Monteyne, Chris Vervaet, Jean Paul Remon, Thomas De Beer

Process analytical tools for monitoring, understanding, and control of pharmaceutical fluidized bed granulation: A review

European Journal of Pharmaceutics and Biopharmaceutics, Volume 83, Issue 1, 2013, 2–15

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ejpb.2012.09.008

Real Time Process Sensors / Data Fusion

INTRODUCTION

Page 5: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Non-Invasive Techniques in

Medicine and Industries

20/12/20

165

Beginning of tomography/tomometry?

• Stethoscope - acoustic medical device

• Listening - acoustic water leakage

detection

• Empty/full vessel with «knocking» and

frequency based detection etc.

Page 6: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Oil & Gas Journal August 1990

20/12/2016 6

ACOUSTIC MEASUREMENTS DETECT SAND IN

NORTH SEA FLOW LINES08/27/1990

Trond Folkestad, Kanaga S. Mylvaganam

Chr. Michelsen Institute

Bergen, Norway

Clamp-on acoustic emission (AE) transducers have

been developed for detecting sand in flow lines on

offshore oil producing platforms.

Sand production is determined by using the

integrated value of measured noise generated by

collisions of sand particles on the pipe wall.

INTRODUCTION

Page 7: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Non-invasive Sand- detection

and monitoring with AE

20/12/2016 7

AE – Acoustic Emssion

INTRODUCTION

Courtesy – Roxar

Emersons Process Management

Page 8: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

20/12/2016 8

Sensor Data Fusion

Another Perspective

Gedanken-experiment

Page 9: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Sensor Related Matrix

Electrical Modalities:

V = IR C = QV V = L di/dt

Radiation – Modalities: dsyx,μ exp II if

S can be R - Resistance, C – Capacitance,

L – Inductance. Z – Impedance, Attenuation

RAMAN, IR, FTIR, NIR, Gamma, MR, AAS,AFS,

XRD,XPS, Terahertz), camera etc.

μ

Gedanken-experiment

Page 10: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

20/12/20

1610Courtesy : Krohne

Page 11: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

IDENTIFICATIONIMAGING

11

TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY

1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Images of two-phase flows,

with high speed cameraCategorization of fully-developed two-phase flows

into flow regimes

Adapted from D. O. Bratland, "Example of steady-state

flow regime map for a horizontal pipe," ed, 2010.

Page 12: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

On Multiphase Flow Studies

Based on

Pradeep, Chaminda; Yan, Ru; Vestøl, Sondre; Melaaen,

Morten Christian; Mylvaganam, Saba. ‘Electrical

capacitance tomography (ECT) and gamma radiation meter

for comparison with and validation and tuning of CFD

modelling of multiphase flow.' : Transactions of IOP journal

of Measurement science and technology, Vol:25, Issue: 7,

March 2014 pp: 075404-075411.

Fusion of Gamma radiation Measurement, ECT, High Speed

Camera – An interesting interplay of Tomography/

Tomometry

21/12/20

1612

Page 13: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

20/12/20

1613

Page 14: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

21/12/20

1614

Page 15: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

IDENTIFICATIONIMAGING

15

Images of two-phase flows,

with high speed cameraCategorization of fully-developed two-phase flows

into flow regimes

Page 16: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

16

Set of 72 experiments and the identified flow regimes superimposed on map by Mandhane (1974)

From Dupré A., Ricciard, G., Bourennane S., Mylvaganam S. (2016) Identification of flow regimes

using raw EIT measurements. 8th World Congress on Industrial Process Tomography, Brazil.

Transitions are fuzzy, visual assessment of flow regime is complex

Page 17: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Various Stages of Fluidisation

20/12/20

1617Crowe, C. T. (2006). Multiphase flow handbook. Boca Raton, FL, CRC Press.

Page 18: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Electrical Capacitance Tomography for

Powder Flow Studies

Axial velocity

Transverse component of velocity

Estimate the solid flowrate

Number concentration of particulate passing

through cross sectional area

Estimate the particle size to understand the

segregation phenomena.

21/12/2016 18

Page 19: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Flow High Speed Digital Camera

20/12/2016 19

Page 20: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Pneumatic transfer – Some issues

Dilute phase Vertical Pneumatic Transport System

Flow monitoring

Particle sizing

Segregation

Non intrusive Instrumentation technique

Electrical Capacitance Tomography (ECT)

Laser Doppler Anemometry(LDA)

Acoustic Emission

Computational fluid dynamic simulation(CFD)

High Speed Camera

Signal Processing

Correlation20/12/2016 20

Page 21: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Some Results from

Tomography / Tomometry

Most of the results in the following seven slides on particulate

flow are based on the following publication

Urmila Datta , Thomas Dyokowski, Saba Mylvaganam,

Estimation of Particulate Velocity Components in

Pneumatic Transport Using Pixel Based Correlation with

Dual Plane ECT, The Chemical Engineering Journal,

130(2):87-99 · June 2007 ·

21/12/20

1621

Page 22: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Axial velocity using ECT and LDA

20/12/20

1622

Velocity profile over the cross section by ECT

and LDA method with error bar for different inlet air velocity

Solid velocity distribution measured at

different air velocity by LDA method.

Solid velocity distribution measured by ECT

at different air velocity

Variation of average particulate velocity with

inlet air velocity by ECT and LDA method

Page 23: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Pixel Based Correlation Algorithm

20/12/2016 23

Interrogation window

Correlation

Correlation peak

Velocity

Tomography/Tomometry

Page 24: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Case Studies

Rotational Movement of An Object In

Sensor Plane

Flow in Horizontal Channel

Flow in Vertical Channel

20/12/2016 24

Page 25: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Flow in Horizontal Channel

20/12/2016 25

Transverse velocity vector plot of 100th frame

Magnitude of transverse velocity of 100th frame.

Page 26: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Transverse velocity using ECT and LDA

-0.05

0

0.05

0.1

0.15

0.2

-27 -25 -23 -21 -19 -17 -15 -13 -11 -9 -7 -5 -3 -1 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27

Radial position[mm]

Tra

ns

verse v

elo

cit

y c

om

po

ne

nt[

m/s

]

12.73m/s

12.48m/s

11.97m/s

11.48m/s

11.23m/s

10.98m/s

10.49m/s

10.2m/s

9.98m/s

9.48m/s

8.98m/s

8.73m/s

20/12/2016 26

Transverse component of solid velocity at different superficial

Velocity by ECT and LDA method

Transverse component of solid velocity distribution by

LDA method

Page 27: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

ECT AND OTHER MODALITIES

Some of the following results wre presentd in

University of Southeast Norway during the guest

lecture by Dr. Daniel J. Holland

21/12/20

1627

Page 28: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Three-dimensional capacitance sensor with three planes and four electrodes in each plane.

Published in: D. J. Holland; Q. Marashdeh; C. R. Müller; F. Wang; J. S. Dennis; L.-S. Fan; L. F. Gladden; Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2009, 48, 172-

181.

DOI: 10.1021/ie8002073

Copyright © 2008 American Chemical Society

Triple Plane 3D Capacitance Sensor

Page 29: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Snapshot ECVT measurements of the gas and solids distribution in the x−y plane at a superficial gas velocity of 0.04 m s−1.

The images shown were extracted from a full 3D data set and were taken for a slice located in the center of the capacitance

sensor. The field of view was 50 mm × 50 mm × 90 mm, and 20 × 20 × 20 voxels, giving an apparent resolution of 2.5 mm

× 2.5 mm × 4.5 mm. The acquisition time was 12.5 ms, and every second frame is shown such that the data may be

compared with the MR data shown in Figure 7.

Published in: D. J. Holland; Q. Marashdeh; C. R. Müller; F. Wang; J. S. Dennis; L.-S. Fan; L. F. Gladden; Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2009, 48, 172-

181.

DOI: 10.1021/ie8002073

Copyright © 2008 American Chemical Society

ECVT Snapshot of gas/solids distribution

Page 30: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Snapshot MR measurements of the gas and solids distribution in the x−y plane at a superficial gas velocity of 0.04 m s−1. The

field of view was 60 mm × 60 mm, and 32 × 16 voxels. The data were zero-filled to 32 × 32 pixels, giving an apparent

resolution of 1.9 mm × 1.9 mm. The slice thickness was 2 mm and was located 280 mm above the distributor. The acquisition

time was 26 ms.

Published in: D. J. Holland; Q. Marashdeh; C. R. Müller; F. Wang; J. S. Dennis; L.-S. Fan; L. F. Gladden; Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2009, 48, 172-

181.

DOI: 10.1021/ie8002073

Copyright © 2008 American Chemical Society

MRI Snapshot of gas/solids distribution

Page 31: Multiphase flow studies with tomometric techniques for ...TWO ROUTES FOR MULTIPHASE FLOW STUDY 1. Introduction ⇾ 2. Experiments ⇾ 3. Flow Regime Identification⇾ 4. Conclusion

Comparison of the voidage measured using ECVT (dotted lines) and MRI (solid lines) at gas velocities of 0.04 (black) and 0.10

m s−1 (gray). All four profiles were taken along a line through the center of the imaging region, 280 mm above the distributor.

Published in: D. J. Holland; Q. Marashdeh; C. R. Müller; F. Wang; J. S. Dennis; L.-S. Fan; L. F. Gladden; Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2009, 48, 172-

181.

DOI: 10.1021/ie8002073

Copyright © 2008 American Chemical Society

Voidage ECVT vs. MRI