Medical Board of California · 7/28/2016 · Overview of . Medical Aid in Dying Review ORS 127.8...

Agenda Item

4B

RD

4 - 1

Medical Board of

California

July 28, 2016

compassion & choices /

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 1

Agenda Item 4

Care and Choice at the End of Life

DAVID R. GRUBE MD NATIONAL MEDICAL DIRECTOR

COMPASSION AND CHOICES


BRD 4 - 2

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 2


Goals

Agenda Item 4

Goals Overview of Medical Aid in Dying Review ORS 127.8 Review CA EOLO Act (ABX2 – 15) Compare the two State Laws Discuss the experience of the Oregon Health

Authority and the Oregon Medical Board Consider future implications for MBC Q&A

BRD 4 - 3

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 3


Sources

Agenda Item 4

Sources

Personal Experience State Epidemiologist – Oregon Health Authority Katrina Hedberg MD

Oregon Medical Board Joseph Thaler MD – Medical Director Kathleen Haley JD – Executive Director

National Death With Dignity Center George Eighmey JD - President

BRD 4 - 4

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 4

“my hats….”

Agenda Item 4

“my hats….”

DRG – Personal Experience Rural Family Practice (Philomath, OR - 38 years)

- DWD: ~ 30 patients (~ 15 Attending ; ~ 15 Consulting)

Oregon Medical Board (7 years) (2 years as Chair / Interim Pro Tem Med. Dir.)

C&C National Medical Director (2 years) compassion & choices

BR

D 4 - 5

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 5

Agenda Item 4

THE ART OF MEDICINETHE ART OF MEDICINE

To cure sometimes, to relieve often,

to comfort always… HIPPOCRATES


BRD 4 - 6

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 6

End of Life Care:What is the Licensee’s role?

Agenda Item 4

End of Life Care: What is the Licensee’s role?

To Care for the patient To Teach the patient/family

To Respect the wishes of the patient To Comfort and Alleviate Suffering


BRD 4 - 7

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 7

Agenda Item 4

compassion & choices

BRD 4 - 8

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 8

End of life options:

Agenda Item 4

End of life options:

Full treatment Decline (some or all) treatments Unwanted medical care

Hospice/Palliative Care VSED (“terminal fasting”) Terminal Sedation (in hospice) Medical Aid in Dying


BRD 4 - 9

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 9

Agenda Item 4

Not an EOL option….Not an EOL option….


BRD 4 - 10

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 10


The Art and Scienceof Medicine include:

Agenda Item 4

The Art and Science of Medicine include:

Patient Autonomy Shared Medical Decision Making Professionalism (Integrity VS Personal Beliefs)

BRD 4 - 11

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 11

Medical Aid in Dying - USA

Agenda Item 4

Medical Aid in Dying - USA

Oregon – (referendum) 1997 Washington – (referendum) 2009 Montana (Supreme Court) 2009 Vermont – (leg. vote) 2013 California – (leg. Vote) 2016


BRD 4 - 12

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 12

EOLO Act in California:Patient Requests for Information

Agenda Item 4

EOLO Act in California: Patient Requests for Information

~ 250,000 deaths each year in California ~ 34,000/yr in Oregon

~ 3,500 requests for information each year about Death with Dignity in OR Projection ?: 30,000-50,000/yr in CA


BRD 4 - 13

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 13

Oregon: Death with Dignity(ORS 127.8)

California: End of Life Option Act(ABX – 15)

Agenda Item 4

Oregon: Death with Dignity (ORS 127.8)

California: End of Life Option Act (ABX – 15)

Laws are very similar Oregon has 18 years of data and

experience California - ???


BRD 4 - 14

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 14

Agenda Item 4

THE OREGON EXPERIENCETHE OREGON EXPERIENCE 1997-20161997-2016

Death with Dignity

ORS 127.800-897


BRD 4 - 15

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 15

n &choices

ORS 127.800 – .897“Death With Dignity:”

caveats…

Agenda Item 4

ORS 127.800 – .897 “Death With Dignity:”

caveats… Dignity is defined by the dying patient. (Dignity is not defined by the doctor, the hospice nurse,

legislators, ethicists, medical boards, etc.) A person with a terminal illness may have a

dignified death in many ways: Choosing all or some treatments Choosing no treatments Choosing to have control of the “timing” of death

BRD 4 - 16

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 16

ORS 127 .800 - .897Death With Dignity Act (DWD)

Agenda Item 4

ORS 127 .800 - .897 Death With Dignity Act (DWD)

An adult who is capable, is a resident of Oregon, and has been determined by the

attending physician and consulting physician to be suffering from a terminal disease, and who

has voluntarily expressed his or her wish to die, may make a written request for medication for

the purpose of ending his or her life in a humane and dignified manner in accordance with ORS

127.800 - 127.897.


BRD 4 - 17

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 17

ORS 127Physician Components

Agenda Item 4

ORS 127 Physician Components

Two physicians #1: Attending #2: Consulting Referral if psychiatric diagnosis uncovered Both must affirm patient eligibility

(Not PA / NP / DC / ND)


BRD 4 - 18

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 18

n &choices

Attending Physician Responsibilities

Agenda Item 4

Attending Physician Responsibilities

Two oral requests from patient (not necessarily in person)

At least 15 days apart Written request (after both doctor’s eval.) Signed by two witnesses

Prescription may not be written until 48 hours after second oral request

BRD 4 - 19

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 19


Physician Responsibilities

Agenda Item 4


Inform patient of feasible alternatives: Hospice Care / Palliative Care / Pain

Control Must request (but may not require)

patient notify next of kin of Rx request

BRD 4 - 20

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 20



Agenda Item 4

Physician Responsibilities Both Prescribing and Consulting Physicians

must complete Dept. of Human Services’ (DHS) forms Prescribing Physician must inform DHS only

if prescription is written Pharmacy must be informed of medication’s

intended use (1999) Follow-up form w/in 10 days of patient’s death

(rev. 2010)

BRD 4 - 21

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 21


Statistics (ORE. PUBLIC HEALTH DIV. ANNUAL REPORT 2/2016)

Agenda Item 4

Statistics (ORE. PUBLIC HEALTH DIV. ANNUAL REPORT 2/2016)

2015: 218 DWDA prescriptions written 132 DWDA deaths (61%) (2014 = 155 / 105) (67%)

Since 1997: 1,545 DWDA prescriptions written 991 DWDA deaths (64%)

(38.6/10,000 deaths)

BRD 4 - 22

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 22

240

220

200

180

160

ai 140 .Jl

E 120 ::, z

100

80

60

DWDA prescription recipients

D DWDA deaths

58 68 65 65

40 33 39 2

44

20

0

218

155

95 85 88

com ssion & choic s

DWDA prescription recipients and deathsby year, Oregon, 1998-2016

Agenda Item 4

DWDA prescription recipients and deaths by year, Oregon, 1998-2016

BRD 4 - 23

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 23


2015 - OR DWD

Agenda Item 4

2015 - OR DWD

218 prescriptions by 106 physicians 1 – 27 prescriptions 5 referrals for mental health evaluation

92.2% in hospice 90% died at home 99% had health insurance

BRD 4 - 24

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 24


Since 2010, Follow-up Questionnaire:to determine circumstances at death

Agenda Item 4

Since 2010, Follow-up Questionnaire: to determine circumstances at death

Only when physician or nurse present Voluntary Time to death (5 min – 34 hours) 2015 data: 27 cases 14 physician 13 nurse

BRD 4 - 25

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 25

ch

Agenda Item 4

The Oregon Death with Dignity Act: A Guidebook for Health Care

Professionals (March 1998; 4th Revision December 2008)

https://www.ohsu.edu/xd/education/continuing-education/center-for-ethics/ethics-

outreach/upload/Oregon-Death-with-Dignity-Act-Guidebook.pdf

BRD 4 - 26

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 26

https://www.ohsu.edu/xd/education/continuing


The Oregon Death with Dignity Act: A Guidebook for Health Care Professionals

Chapter 12Responding to Professional Non-

Compliance ----------

Guidelines

Agenda Item 4

The Oregon Death with Dignity Act: A Guidebook for Health Care Professionals

Chapter 12 Responding to Professional Non-

Compliance

Guidelines

BRD 4 - 27

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 27


GuidelinesGuidelines

Agenda Item 4

12.1 - Health professionals must report to the appropriate licensing and certifying board professionals who engage in medical incompetence or unprofessional conduct. 12.2 - If there is a concern about the conduct of

a professional in another health care discipline, there is an ethical obligation to act. There may be a requirement for institutional or professional board reporting.

BRD 4 - 28

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 28


Guidelines - 2

Agenda Item 4

Guidelines - 2

12.3 - If a health professional has questions about the appropriateness of a practice relative to comfort care or participation in the Oregon Death with Dignity Act, he/she should consult the staff of the appropriate licensing board for guidance.

BRD 4 - 29

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 29


Guidelines - 3

Agenda Item 4

Guidelines - 3 12.4 - Physicians and other health care

providers with prescriptive authority need to ensure that patients receive sufficient dosages of appropriate medications for the relief of pain and suffering. The Oregon Medical Board encourages physicians to employ skillful and compassionate pain control for dying patients. The Oregon Medical Board investigates allegations of under prescribing for pain in the same manner as over-prescribing.

BRD 4 - 30

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 30


Guidelines - 4

Agenda Item 4

Guidelines - 4

12.5 - Licensees should not report another professional to the licensing board simply because the other professional has cooperated with the request for a prescription under the Oregon Act. The Oregon Medical Board does not consider good faith compliance with the Oregon Act unprofessional conduct.

BRD 4 - 31

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 31


Oregon Health Authority

Agenda Item 4

Oregon Health Authority Types of concerns ‘Pure paperwork’ (vast majority) Investigate and have Licensee correct Refer to OMB if non-compliance

Possible violation of ORS 127.8 Refer to OMB

Approximately 2/year No increase over last ten years in spite of increase in

DWD cases

BRD 4 - 32

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 32

n &choices

Oregon Medical Board

Agenda Item 4

Oregon Medical Board Review all OHA referrals “Letter of Concern” to Licensee if apropos 1 - 2 per year

Med. Dir. may request information/charts (rare) Open investigation for cases with concerns No cases opened in last five years (more?)

No disciplinary actions by OMB in 18 years of ORS 127.8

BRD 4 - 33

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 33


EOLO Act – CA (vs.) DWD Act – OR

Agenda Item 4

EOLO Act – CA (vs.) DWD Act – OR Residency (specific*) Attending Physician Responsible for checklists Must see patient alone

Consulting Physician “Independent” (sic)

48 Hour Attestation Form Language Interpreter (forms) Death Certificate ?

(10 YEAR SUNSET)

Residency (non-specific**) Attending Physician Forms

Consulting Physician Forms

Prescription Not electronic or FAX

Death Certificate Cannot list DWD

BRD 4 - 34

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 34


California EOLO Act

Agenda Item 4

California EOLO Act

443.5 (a) Before prescribing an aid-in-dying drug, the attending physician shall do … the following: …Confirm that the individual is making an

informed decision … by discussing with him or her … the feasible alternatives or additional treatment options including, but not limited to, … hospice care, (and) palliative care ...

BRD 4 - 35

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 35


California EOLO Act

Agenda Item 4

California EOLO Act

443.5 (cont’d) (5) Counsel the qualified individual about the importance of … the

following: (A) Having another person present when he or she ingests the aid-in-

dying drug prescribed …. (B) Not ingesting the aid-in-dying drug in a public place. (C) Notifying the next of kin of his or her request for an aid-in-dying

drug. (A qualified individual who declines or is unable to notify next of kin shall not have his or her request denied for that reason).

(D) Participating in a hospice program. (E) Maintaining the aid-in-dying drug in a safe … location

BRD 4 - 36

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 36


Agenda Item 4

443.14. … a person shall not be subject to civil, criminal, administrative, employment, or contractual liability or professional disciplinary action for participating in good faith compliance with this part, including an individual who is present when a qualified individual self-administers the prescribed aid-in-dying drug.

BRD 4 - 37

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 37


Attending Physician –Definitions:

Agenda Item 4

Attending Physician – Definitions:

Oregon: "Attending physician" means the physician who has primary responsibility for the care of the patient and treatment of the patient's terminal disease. California: “Attending physician” means the

physician who has primary responsibility for the health care of an individual and treatment of the individual’s terminal disease.

BRD 4 - 38

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 38


Consultant –Definition

Agenda Item 4

Consultant – Definition

Oregon: "Consulting physician" means a physician who is qualified by specialty or experience to make a professional diagnosis and prognosis regarding the patient's disease.

California: “Consulting physician” means a physician who is independent from the attending physician and who is qualified by specialty or experience to make a professional diagnosis and prognosis regarding an individual’s terminal disease.

BRD 4 - 39

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 39


Attestation Form (CA only)

Agenda Item 4

Attestation Form (CA only)

Within 48 hours prior to the individual self-administering the aid-in-dying drug, the individual shall complete the final attestation form. ….. the completed form shall be delivered by the individual’s health care provider, family member, or other representative to the attending physician to be included in the patient’s medical record.

BRD 4 - 40

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 40


Barriers for Citizens(Social Justice)

Agenda Item 4

Barriers for Citizens (Social Justice)

LACK OF EDUCATION (of both citizens and licensees)

OR: process cannot often, in reality, be completed in 15 days; median time for DWD is 48 days

OR: some communities (Roseburg) have no licensees who participate

Medical providers opposed to the law have provided patients with misinformation or delayed the patient from starting the process until it is too late

BRD 4 - 41

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 41

California End of Life Option Act - Effective June 9, 2016

AIIX215 (Eggmon, Chaptor 1) eslablishes lhe End of Life Option Act (Act) In Callfomla, which becomes elled!ve on June 9, 2016 and wll remain In offect unll January 1, 2026. This Ad gr1es a men ta ly competenl, adult California n,sldent who has a 1ermln81 dlsaooe the legal right to 811c tor and recelYe a p,esa1ptlon Imm his or her ph)'Slclan to hasten death, as 1""11 •• required aileria Is mel

► AB-1 S End of Ufe

The 11W requires physicians to meet specific criteria ~ lhey are going to perticlpale In lhls N1. and prescribe ald-ln-<fyfng drugs to patients • The ~ raecuroes give an overview of the reqtirements of the law for beth physicians and patients:

► The Medical Board of Cal1fpmja's (Board) analysis of lb/S b!U

► 0\/!ltylew Pl the Glldorola E/ld o( Ufa Option AGI • Winter 2016 N~

► Cahfomla Medal AssodaliDQ On ean Oocument

The law requires spa<:lflad fom,s 10 l>e oompletad bafon, Iha aid-ln-<!y,ng drugs can be presonbad and additional loons a1ter lhe drugs - _, presaibad. These fom,s must be submrtl8d 10 the Callfomla Department of Public Heallh (CDPH) and also Included In the

lndlvldl.81'8 med,cal record.

e • 0

• •

comp ssion & choices

Medical Board of CaliforniaMedical Board of California

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 42

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 42

n &choices

What might be the MBC potential concerns

Agenda Item 4

What might be the MBC potential concerns

The intent of the law, and how to deal with Licensee’s who violate it “Pure paper” complaints – what to do? e.g. “Attestation Form”

Dealing with complaints Legitimate and non-legitimate

Responding to opponents

BRD 4 - 43

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 43

0 ch s

Endoflifeoption.org

Agenda Item 4

Endoflifeoption.org

Website includes: A policy library for navigating health

systems across the state (FIND CARE)

Videos and fact sheets for physicians, pharmacists, and patients Information in both English and Spanish

BRD 4 - 44

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 44

https://Endoflifeoption.org

, .. ... ,.,::, - -·· .. .I

. ; . ~ ... ~..:1,a.tk',~

e compassion \ &choices CA

ABOUT FOR MEDICAL PROVIDERS FIND CARE

Q

The End of Life Option Act DONATE

NEWS VOLUNTEER

www.endoflifeoption.orgwww.endoflifeoption.org

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 45

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 45

www.endoflifeoption.org

comp ssion & choices

Agenda Item 4

Chapter 1Chapter 1

BRD 4 - 46

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 46

Chapter 2Chapter 2 ondofldooptlon,o,g C

compass, on & choices

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 47

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 47


Chapter 3Chapter 3

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 48

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 48

~..11..iQf;/l'I

~......__...._._._......""'..................,....., ~ ...... 1 0.., it

.....

-

Agenda Item 4


BRD 4 - 49

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 49

OF PALLIATIVE MEOtCINE Volume 18, Number X. 2015 DOI: 10.1089/jpmi.2015.0092

Clinical Criteria for Physician Aid in Dying

David Orentlicher, MO, JO: Thaddeus Mason Pope, JO, Ph0,2 and Ben A. Rich, JO, Ph03;

Physician Aid-in-Dying Clinical Criteria Committee


Agenda Item 4

1) How to respond to a patient’s request formedical aid in dying

2) How to assess patient decision makingcapacity

3) How to address other significant issues

BRD 4 - 50

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 50


Conclusions (OR)

Agenda Item 4

Conclusions (OR)

Medical aid in dying is not commonly used There are barriers and the law is not

necessarily easy to navigate The OMB has not uncovered licensees who

have violated the intent of the law The unexpected consequences are good: Improved end of life care, no “slippery slope,” no

abuse of disabled, poor, etc.

BRD 4 - 51

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 51


Agenda Item 4

One does not ask of one who suffers: What is yourcountry and what is your religion?

One merely says: You suffer, this is enough for me:you belong to me and I shall help you.

LOUIS PASTEUR MD 1886

BRD 4 - 52

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 52

0 ch s

Resources:Compassion and Choices

Agenda Item 4

Resources: Compassion and Choices

www.endoflifeoption.org YouTube:

The Clinical Practice of Medical Aid in Dying(all six chapters)

Doc2Doc 1-800-247-7241 California Hotline 1-800-893-4548

BRD 4 - 53

Agenda Item 4

BRD 4 - 53

www.endoflifeoption.org

Medical Board of California · 7/28/2016 · Overview of . Medical Aid in Dying Review ORS 127.8...

Documents

Transcript of Medical Board of California · 7/28/2016 · Overview of . Medical Aid in Dying Review ORS 127.8...