Limina slideshow james smith
-
Upload
james-smith -
Category
Documents
-
view
218 -
download
2
Transcript of Limina slideshow james smith
Making Space for Thought
The blurred line between representation and reality in maps and
diagrams of the 11th to 13th centuries
Some initial questions:
• How can we come to a more nuanced understand medieval maps and diagrams?
• What specificities of medieval thought need to be understood on their own terms before this questions can be addressed?
Discussion Outline
• What is meant by a representation?
• Discussion of source materials and their salient traits
• Proposal of some medieval ideas that ‘blur the lines’ between representation and reality within these images
Medieval Approaches
Image as Distillation?• The ‘mustard seed’ principle – the
representation as a ‘seed’ of a ‘real’ idea• The text as a ‘memory’ of higher principles
Image as Contraction?• The Divine Emanation• The Chain of Being• Quidditas Contracta (contracted quiddity)
Medieval Approaches (cont.)
Image as Sign or Symbol?• The ‘Book of Nature’ or ‘Mirror of the
WorldImage as Independent Creation?• That which is created but does not create
as a ‘type’ of nature, and thus distinct• The creation of a creation is still an act of
the original Creator
Conclusions
• All images must be a type of representation or copy of an original to some extent
• This does not prevent us perceiving a middle position between this representation and the thing it represents
• Medieval thought furnishes us with ideas that appear to support an interpretation of the map or diagram as both copy and original