L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

79
A recent Historic Macon Foundation restoration Raising funds through properties work September 28, 2012 Wednesday, October 10, 12

description

Thoughts on starting up a new revolving fund.

Transcript of L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Page 1: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

A recent Historic Macon Foundation restoration

Raising funds through properties workSeptember 28, 2012

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 2: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Today’s talk

1. History of Historic Macon’s revolving funds1.1. Saving mansions1.2. Vernacular houses1.3. Neighborhood revitalization1.3.1. Huguenin Heights1.3.2. Beall’s Hill1.3.2.1. Partnerships1.3.2.2. Results1.4. Spot Properties2. Case studies3. Risks4. Ideas5. Summary

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 3: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Motivation

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 4: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Motivation

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 5: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

First property

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 6: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

First property

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 7: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Vernacular buildings

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 8: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Vernacular buildings

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 9: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Small area

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 10: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Small area

Relative size of Huguenin Heights compared to Pleasant Hill

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 11: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Vernacular buildings

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 12: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Vernacular buildings

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 13: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Economic Development

Homes sold Home Ownership Crime

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 14: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Economic Development

Homes sold Home Ownership Crime

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 15: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Economic Development

Homes sold Home Ownership Crime

10%

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 16: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Economic Development

Homes sold Home Ownership Crime

66%

100%

10%

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 17: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Economic Development

Homes sold Home Ownership Crime

66%

100%

10%

100%

15%

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 18: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Economic Development

Homes sold Home Ownership Crime

66%

100%

10%

100%

15%

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 19: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Obsolete housing demolished

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 20: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Revitalization Partners

!

Each partner pays $75,000 in dues/ year

into a revolving fund

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 21: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Days on Market

0

38

75

113

150

Historic Macon National Average

Days on Market

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 22: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Economic Development

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 23: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Economic Development

Property Tax

$40,000/ year

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 24: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Economic Development

Property Tax Sales Tax

$40,000/ year $60,000

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 25: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Economic Development

Property Tax Sales Tax Jobs

56 Jobs$40,000/ year $60,000

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 26: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Recent Beall’s Hill Projects

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 27: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Recent Beall’s Hill Projects

!!P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 28: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Current management

•Executive Director identifies projects, drafts pro formas•ED negotiates and signs contracts for acquisition•Full-time interior designer drafts rehab proposal•Before acquired, Preservation Committee and Board approve acquisition, rehab and sale•ED either hires a General Contractor or Construction Manager not-at-risk (usually the latter for rehab)•Next report to the Board is net performance after sale

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 29: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

306 Orange St.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 30: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

306 Orange St.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 31: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

306 Orange St.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 32: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

306 Orange St.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 33: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

306 Orange St.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 34: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

306 Orange St.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 35: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

923 Washington Ave.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 36: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

923 Washington Ave.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 37: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

923 Washington Ave.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 38: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

923 Washington Ave.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 39: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

923 Washington Ave.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 40: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

923 Washington Ave.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 41: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

923 Washington Ave.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 42: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

923 Washington Ave.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 43: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

923 Washington Ave.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 44: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

923 Washington Ave.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 45: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

1212 Ross St.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 46: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

1212 Ross St.

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 47: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Spot Properties

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 48: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Spot Properties

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 49: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Revolving Funds

Preservation Fund Knight Fund Hills and Heights FundPeyton Anderson Fund Facade Funds

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 50: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Revolving Funds

$800,000

Preservation Fund Knight Fund Hills and Heights FundPeyton Anderson Fund Facade Funds

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 51: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Revolving Funds

$300,000

$800,000

Preservation Fund Knight Fund Hills and Heights FundPeyton Anderson Fund Facade Funds

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 52: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Revolving Funds

$600,000$300,000

$800,000

Preservation Fund Knight Fund Hills and Heights FundPeyton Anderson Fund Facade Funds

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 53: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Revolving Funds

$550,000

$600,000$300,000

$800,000

Preservation Fund Knight Fund Hills and Heights FundPeyton Anderson Fund Facade Funds

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 54: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Revolving Funds

$200,000

$550,000

$600,000$300,000

$800,000

Preservation Fund Knight Fund Hills and Heights FundPeyton Anderson Fund Facade Funds

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 55: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Revolving Funds

$200,000

$550,000

$600,000$300,000

$800,000

Preservation Fund Knight Fund Hills and Heights FundPeyton Anderson Fund Facade Funds

•$2.4 million total

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 56: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Risks

Management Real Estate challenges

•Staff specializing in Real estate is expensive•Even if you outsource construction, you need more staff• Board and staff relationships can strain•Have to be a market expert to acquire and sell property• Very hard to produce enough operating income to cover additional staff, much less help with existing operations

• Preservation and profit compete• Resource intensive• Without doing an entire neighborhood, you don’t control comps, infrastructure• Risks multiply with environmental concerns, market fluctuations• Some properties are worth less than $0• Every neighborhood has a different target buyer, and you don’t have the marketing money to reach them

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 57: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Ideas

•$1 million in endowment yields 5%• Same funds used in revolving fund•Turn twice a year (6 month projects)• Take a 6% developer’s fee/ project• Net a 12% return instead of 5%

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 58: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Ideas

•$1 million in endowment yields 5%• Same funds used in revolving fund•Turn twice a year (6 month projects)• Take a 6% developer’s fee/ project• Net a 12% return instead of 5%

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 59: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Ideas

•$1 million in endowment yields 5%• Same funds used in revolving fund•Turn twice a year (6 month projects)• Take a 6% developer’s fee/ project• Net a 12% return instead of 5%

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 60: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Ideas

•$1 million in endowment yields 5%• Same funds used in revolving fund•Turn twice a year (6 month projects)• Take a 6% developer’s fee/ project• Net a 12% return instead of 5%

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 61: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Ideas

•In kind donations have never been a source of savings•Prefer to pay for work and products and have vendors make donations-- cleaner for taxes and benefits operating•Allow us to develop new expertise•Having rehab experience makes it easier to deal with the private market•Sometimes you can use real estate know-how to get a private developer to save a property instead of you!•Also builds relationships with new donors

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 62: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Before & Afters

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 63: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Before & Afters

P.O. Box 13358 Macon, GA 31208 Ph: 478.742.5084 Fax:478.742.2008 www.historicmacon.org

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 64: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Josh Rogers, Executive [email protected]

phone 478-742-5084 • fax 478-742-2008email [email protected] • site www.historicmacon.org

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 65: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

CASE STUDY

Purchase a home with tax credits in place

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 66: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Homes

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 67: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Homes

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 68: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Restored homes from Historic Macon Foundation

include tax credits

Homes

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 69: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Restored homes from Historic Macon Foundation

include tax credits

Homes

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 70: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Restored homes from Historic Macon Foundation

include tax credits

This home at 980 Maple St. included frozen property taxes at $200 per year and $30,000 in state income tax

credits.

Homes

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 71: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Restored homes from Historic Macon Foundation

include tax credits

This home at 980 Maple St. included frozen property taxes at $200 per year and $30,000 in state income tax

credits.

Homes

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 72: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Restored homes from Historic Macon Foundation

include tax credits

This home at 980 Maple St. included frozen property taxes at $200 per year and $30,000 in state income tax

credits.

The net monthly cost to own this $130,000 home is

$500 per month

Homes

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 73: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

HomesHistoric home

Any other home

House Price $135,000 $135,000

Down Payment $4,725 $4,725

You Get a Raise! $2,700/year $0

Reduced Property Tax $205 $2,260

Total Savings $44,480 $0

Total Monthly Cost $500 $1,160

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 74: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

HomesHistoric home

Any other home

House Price $135,000 $135,000

Down Payment $4,725 $4,725

You Get a Raise! $2,700/year $0

Reduced Property Tax $205 $2,260

Total Savings $44,480 $0

Total Monthly Cost $500 $1,160

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 75: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Down Payment Assistance

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 76: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Down Payment Assistance

The City of Macon offers down payment assistance up to $25,000 for people of low

to moderate incomes

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 77: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Down Payment Assistance

The City of Macon offers down payment assistance up to $25,000 for people of low

to moderate incomes

Mercer University offers $20,000 to all employees for

down payments

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 78: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Down Payment Assistance

The City of Macon offers down payment assistance up to $25,000 for people of low

to moderate incomes

Mercer University offers $20,000 to all employees for

down payments

Georgia Dream can offer $5,000 to $7,500 to help with

down payment and closing costs

Wednesday, October 10, 12

Page 79: L'Enfant Trust Revolving Fund

Sales Sheets

Wednesday, October 10, 12