Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

download Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

of 24

Transcript of Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    1/56

    Meet Jonathan Greenblaand his new VP,Shari Gerstenof Tenafly

    201685NORTH JERSEY

    LOCAL FIRST RESPONDERS RESPOND TO ISRAEL  page 6 

    MEETING MUSLIMS IN FRANKLIN LAKES  page 8

    TEANECK’S MUTANT NINJA TURKEY  page 12 

    PEW REPORT FOCUSES ON ISRAEL’S DIVISIONS  page 30

    MARCH 11, 2016VOL. LXXXV  NO. 27 $1.00

    TheADL’snew

    face

      J  e   w i  s  h   S  t  a  n  d  a  r  d

      1  0  8  6   T  e  a  n  e  c  k   R  o  a  d

       T  e  a  n  e  c  k ,   N  J  0  7  6  6  6

       C   H   A   N   G   E   S   E   R   V I   C   E   R   E   Q   U   E   S   T   E   D

    THEJEWISHSTANDARD.COM

    page 26

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    2/562 JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2016

    englewoodhealth.org

    The first time his heart stoppedwas from love at first sight.

    Robert always considered himself a lucky guy. He married the girl of his dreams, raised a family and enjoyed

    great health. Then, without warning, he suffered a heart attack. In the first critical moments, on the way to

    Englewood Hospital, our paramedics gave lifesaving care. Then, with speed and expertise, our cardiac

    team cleared the blockage and got his heart pumping again. Today, fully recovered, Robert is eagerly

    anticipating his next “heart-stopping” moment – the arrival of his fifth grandchild. Our top 10% national

    rating for cardiac care is one more reason to make Englewood Hospital and Medical Center

     your hospital for life.

    Robert and June Hans, Bergen County, N

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    3/56

    Page 3

    JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2

    NOSHES ...............................................................4

    OPINION ...........................................................20

    COVER STORY ................................................26

    D’VAR TORAH ................................................42

    CROSSWORD PUZZLE ................................43

    CALENDAR ......................................................44

    GALLERY ..........................................................47

    OBITUARIES ....................................................48

    CLASSIFIEDS ..................................................50

    REAL ESTATE ..................................................52

    CONTENTS

    PUBLISHER’S STATEMENT: (USPS 275-700 ISN 002

    published weekly on Fridays with an additional edit

    October, by the New Jersey Jewish Media Group, 108

    Road, Teaneck, NJ 07666. Periodicals postage paid at Ha

    NJ and additional offices. POSTMASTER: Send addres

    to New Jersey Jewish Media Group, 1086 Teaneck Road

    NJ 07666. Subscription price is $30.00 per year. Out-of-

    scriptions are $45.00, Foreign countries subscriptions ar

    The appearance of an advertisement in The Jewish Stan

    not constitute a kashrut endorsement. The publishing

    political advertisement does not constitute an endorsem

    candidate political party or political position by the new

    any employees.

    The Jewish Standard assumes no responsibility to return

    ed editorial or graphic materials. All rights in letters and u

    editorial, and graphic material will be treated as unco

    assigned for publication and copyright purposes and

    JEWISH STANDARD’s unrestricted right to edit and to

    editorially. Nothing may be reprinted in whole or in pa

    written permission from the publisher. © 2016

    Candlelighting: Friday, March 11, 5:41 p.m.

    Shabbat ends: Saturday, March 12, 6:41 p.m.

    For convenient home delivery,

    call 201-837-8818 or bit.ly/jsubscribe

    Israelirhinoescapes

    — again● Back in January2015, we told youabout three rhinoc-eroses who walkedout of the RamatGan zoo whenthe zookeeper fellasleep.

    Some zoos neverlearn.

    On Sundayafternoon, a rhinonamed Tibor calmlywalked out thedoors of the zoo,with a zookeeper running behind him. The escape was short-lived; the rhinoback in the zoo. The fate of the zookeeper remains unknown.

    We can’t help but wonder: Was the zookeeper born in a barn?LARRY YUD

    The new face of Israel activism● Rumor has it thatmost of our jobs are atrisk of being automated.But we thought thatone bit of human capitalwas secure — policingcampus discourse. Now,according to an accountof a Middle Easternstudies event at BrownUniversity, even that roleseems destined for aJohn Henry moment.

    Short story: asreported by Brown’schapter of Open Hillel,while students andscholars are havinga discussion aboutPalestinian citizens ofIsrael, a robot — or,more accurately, an iPadfeaturing the face ofStand With Us Northeast

    Director Shahar Azaniattached to a suit attached to a “doublerobotics telepresence robot” (that’sright, a robotics robot) — proceedsto chat with students about why theyattended the event. (Brookstone sells

    the extremely high-end wheelie robotwithout coat and tie,but we totally get whythey make the wholeshtick more profesh.)

    The idea wasthe brainchild of“futurologist” Dr.Roey Tzetzana, whohas no professionalaffiliation with StandWith Us, and whomeant the tool tobe an experimentin “engagementover distance” andan opportunity forstudents to “hear othervoices.” But a numberof students reportedfeeling uncomfortable.We’re thinkingthere might be a

    better (if less clever)way to start difficult conversationsthan dressing a robot in a suit andmansplaining over Skype. Not thatthat’s gone so well in the past

    LEAH FALK / THEJEWNIVERSE.COM

    Mr. Tambourine Man’s hey● For decades, Dylanologists — thisauthor included — have pored overscraps of lyrics to answer the intrigu-ing, if pointless, question: How Jewishis the man born as Robert Zimmer-man?

    Now there’s one more scrap ofevidence — this one on paper.

    The clue comes in a page from

    a notebook that is now in thepossession of the George KaiserFamily Foundation, which boughtBob Dylan’s 6,000 item trove ofnotebooks, typed lyrics, recordingcontracts, address books, andsoundboard recordings for a reported

    $15 to $20 million. As shown in thispicture featured on the New YorkTimes’ website, Mr. Dylan took pen tohand to doodle a series of what may— or may not — be the Hebrew letterhey.

    The foundation, which boughtthe archives of Mr. Dylan’s heroand inspiration, Woody Guthrie, in

    2011, is the beneficiary of GeorgeKaiser, one of Tulsa, Oklahoma’s twoJewish billionaires. (The other is LynnSchusterman.) Following the exampleof Bill Gates, Mr. Kaiser has pledged todonate most of his wealth to charitybefore he dies. A year younger than

    Mr. Dylan, who turns 75 in May, Mr.Kaiser was born in Tulsa to refugeesfrom Nazi Germany. Forbes estimateshis worth at $7.4 billion, made mostlyin the oil and energy business; hehas donated more than $4 billionto his foundation, which focuses oneliminating poverty and inequalityand supporting the city of Tulsa.

    How much the citizens of Tulsa willbenefit from the city’s new status asa mecca for Dylanologists remainsto be seen. But certainly the fieldis due for a renaissance, with therevelations in the initial press barrageopening up more questions. It is,

    after all, impossible to gauge thesignificance of Mr. Dylan’s possiblyHebrew doodles without knowingwhat year the notebook is from. Anthose of us who have found meaninin an apparent reference to a shivahhouse in the lyrics to the song Dign— “Drinkin’ man listens to the voicehe hears / In a crowded room full of

    covered-up mirrors” — now have toask: What other Jewish secrets areconcealed in the 40 pages of draftlyrics to the song reported to be inthe archive?

    LARRY YUDEL

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    4/56

    Noshes

    4 JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2016

    Want to read more noshes? Visit facebook.com/jewishstandard

    nickname of “Revenant”

    cinematographer

    EMMANUEL LUBEZKI,

    51, who won his third

    consecutive Oscar the

    same night.

    While he certainly

    doesn’t look goatlike

    now, Lubezki told the

    New York Times in 2014

    how he got his nick-

    name: “When I was 5 a

    [Mexican] schoolmate

    gave it [to me]. I guess

    it was my face looked

    like a goat, almost every

    boy in the school had

    the animal nickname.”

    Lubezki, by the way,

    filmed “Knight of Cups.”

    So I can almost guaran-

    tee you “Knight” will be

    visually exciting even if

    the film is “too arty” for

    most tastes.

    Recently, I wrote

    about Donald

    Trump’s familial

    Jewish connections, so I

    figure it’s time to write

    about Hillary’s. Of

    course, just about

    everyone knows that her

    daughter, Chelsea, has

    been married since 2010

    to MARK MEZVINSKY,

    38, an investment

    banker who is the son of

    two former House

    members. They have

    one child and another is

    on the way. Speculation

    is that their children will

    be raised in both their

    parents’ faiths. Less well

    known, although I have

    noted this before, is that

    Hillary Clinton had a

    Jewish “half aunt,” the

    late ADELINE ROSEN-

    BERG FRIEDMAN.

    Hillary was fairly close to

    Adeline. This aunt was

    the daughter of Hillary’s

    paternal grandmot

    Dorothy, and her se

    husband, MAX ROS

    BERG, who was Je

    (Adeline was the ha

    brother of Hillary’s

    father). While Doro

    never converted to

    Judaism, Adeline d

    and lived her life as

    Jew.

    Early in Febr

    “Empire” staJUSSIE SMO

    LETT, 32, visited Fli

    Michigan, and donat

    $10K for relief effort

    Oscars night, Febru

    28, he joined other

    African-American st

    on the stage in Flint

    raise awareness of t

    water crisis and to r

    money for Flint resid

    Smollett sang a son

    son of a Jewish fath

    and an African Ame

    mother, Smollet (his

    words)—identifies a

    African American an

    Jewish man.” By the

    his sister JURNEE

    SMOLLETT-BELL, 2

    co-stars in “Undergr

    in Louisiana,” a new

    10-episode series on

    cable station WGN.

    about the Undergro

    Railway, the networ

    spirited slaves to fre

    dom. Christopher M

    (“Law and Order: SV

    co-stars. It began on

    March 9, but you ca

    catch up via encore

    online. New episode

    Wednesdays at 10 p

    Natalie Portman

    CHAPTER BY CHAPTER :

    ‘Knight of Cups’features Portman

    Max Greenfield Natasha Lyonne

    Mili Avital Mark Mezvinsky Jussie Smollett

    “Knight of Cups”

    is opening Friday,

    March 11. This

    Terence Malick film,

    which is labeled as

    experimental by the

    director, stars Christian

    Bale as Rick, a success-

    ful but unhappy screen-

    writer who finds his only

    solace in women.

    NATALIE PORTMAN, 34,

    stars in one of eight“chapters” in the film. All

    of the chapters center

    on one person in Rick’s

    life; Portman plays a

    woman Rick once

    wronged

    “Hello, My Name is Do-

    ris” is opening the same

    day. It stars Sally Field

    as Doris, a woman who

    is smitten with John, her

    company’s new, much-

    younger art director.

    MAX GREENFIELD, 35,

    who is best known as

    Schmidt on TV’s “The

    New Girl,” plays John.

    Doris mines the Internet

    for info on John and

    finds out who his hip

    friends are and where

    they hang out. She

    seeks out these friends

    and they like her. Over

    time she adopts these

    friends’ bohemian ways,

    and her personal style

    loosens up. But her fam-

    ily and old friends think

    that Doris is making a

    fool of herself pursing

    her crush on John. Co-

    stars include NATASHA

    LYONNE, 36.

    The director is MI-

    CHAEL SHOWALTER,

    45 who is best known as

    a co-star and co-writer

    of “Wet Hot American

    Summer” and its recent

    Netflix prequel. One

    of his more obscure

    credits is the 2005 film

    “The Baxter,” which he

    directed and starred

    in. This very quirky and

    uneven romantic com-

    edy didn’t make muchmoney, but it’s worth

    renting. It’s a send-up of

    all the romantic comedy

    clichés about the “right

    guy” sweeping the girl

    off her feet at the last

    minute. Showalter plays

    a nebbishy nice guy who

    is repeatedly dumped

    for the “right guy.” So I

    wasn’t surprised that he

    is helming another film

    about possibly unrequit-

    ed love like “Doris.”

    You might have

    heard Charles

    Randolph, a

    co-Oscar winner for his

    “Big Short” screenplay,

    say “I love you, Mili” in

    Hebrew from the Oscar

    stage. He was speaking

    to his wife, Israeli actress

    MILI AVITAL, 43. As

    noted in my story about

    the Oscars, their son is

    being raised Jewish. You

    also might have heard

    best actor winner

    Leonardo DiCaprio and

    “Revenant” director

    Alejandro Iñárritu thank

    “Chivo” in their speech-

    es. “Chivo” means goat

    in Spanish, and it’s the

    California-based Nate Bloom can be reached at

     [email protected]

    “ings got a little awkward when the gutelling me about how Jews controlthe media asked if I was Jewish.”

    — Huffington Post reporter and Teaneck native Daniel Ma

    discussing the reporting for his article “How Trum

    Inspiring A New Generation Of White Nationa

    benzelbusch.com

    The All-New 2016 GLC SUV

      _ _ .

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    5/56JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2

    Time 

    is on our side.

     Artfully crafted and meticulously aged for optimal enjoyment.

    Enjoy Tomintoul responsibly

    Imported by Medek Spirits, New York, NY

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    6/56

    Local

    6JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2016

    ‘A cop is a cop is a cop’First responders go to Israel with Jewish Federation of Northern New Jersey

    ABIGAIL KLEIN LEICHMAN

    Was Paramus Detective Sgt.

     John Devine scared about

    traveling to Israel for the

    irst time?

    “Yes. I was scared because I was so

    excited,” the strapping police detective

    replied with a grin. “I’m ecstatic to be here,”

    he added. He was at dinner in Jerusalem

     with the rest of his co-travelers — a delega-

    tion of irst responders invited by the Jew-

    ish Federation of Northern New Jersey to get

    an up-close look at the Jewish state and its

    police and emergency services.Sgt. Devine and Paramus Police Chief

    Kenneth Ehrenberg said they were inter-

    ested in learning how Israeli law enforc-

    ers deal with constant security threats and

     what systems they use day to day to protect

    their infrastructure, schools, and malls.

    They noted that Paramus is not only a

    city of many shopping malls but also of

    many Jewish residents and institutions,

    including four synagogues, the federation

    ofices, and most of the Jewish day schools

    in Bergen County. Chief Ehrenberg was

    head of the city’s detective division in

    2012, when arsonists targeted two Para-

    mus synagogues.

    “Certain things we saw here are applica- ble for us and certain things aren’t,” Chief

    Ehrenberg said.

    For example, all Israeli shopping malls

    have guards and metal detectors at every

    entry point. “I hope we never have to raise

    our mall security to that level,” he said,

     given that a typica l Saturday can bring

    40,000 people to the Garden State Plaza

    alone. At the same time, he acknowledged,

    in November 2013 “someone came with a

    fully loaded assault weapon to the Garden

    State Plaza, and even though by God’s

     grace nobody was killed, it was an awak-

    ening for us.”

    Watching their counterparts in action

    at the Nahariya police station, the North-

    ern District regional police command, and

    SWAT and anti-terrorism units, the mem- bers of the delegation observed more simi-

    larities than differences.

    “It was pleasant to see that a cop is a cop

    is a cop, whether in Israel or in the United

    States,” Chief Ehrenberg said. “We all use

    the same equipment and procedures.”

    Captain Jacqueline Luthcke of the Ridge-

     wood Police Department said she wanted

    to ind out how Israelis secure large public

     gatherings, with an eye toward enhancing

    security at such Ridgewood events as the

    Fourth of July parade and the Memorial

    Day Run.

    “I’m hoping to learn how to make it

    safer for our residents,” she said. “But

    the funny thing I’ve learned so far is how

    similar the Israelis are to us, and I was not

    expecting that. Even their proceduresare very similar to ours, although some

    of their technologies are better, like their

    computer systems.”

    Bergenield Police Chief Cathy Mad-

    alone said she was “very surprised at how

    similar we are to the police here as far as

    dispatching, answering calls, even the

    SWAT team procedures. We have the same

    things they have, but the main diffe

    is that the Israel Police is one big d

    ment and we are 70 small departme

    Bergen County.”

    Chief Madalone said she was hap

     be invited on the trip. “I have a very

     Jewish population in my town. We

    square miles and we have three Ort

    synagogues, so I am very, very conn

     with my Jewish community, and I thit would be a phenomenal opportun

    me to learn more about Israel. My

    had some hesitations about my going

    didn’t at all. I’m loving every second

    Miriam Allenson, the federation’s

    tor of communications, accompani

     group. She said that the federation’

    nership2Gether missions for emer

    Jersey legislative delegation visits a variety of sites

    A weeklong New Jersey legislators’

    study mission to Israel overlapped with

    the Jewish Federation of Northern

    New Jersey’s first-responders mission

    in late February to early March.Organized by the New Jersey State

    Association of Jewish Federations

    and co-chaired by Assemblywomen

    Pamela Lampitt and Holly Schepisi, the

    mission included a bipartisan, multi-

    ethnic group of 15 legislators, who paid

    their own way.

    “This is not a lying-on-the-beach

    trip,” said Mark Levenson, head of the

    New Jersey State Association of Jew-

    ish Federations, an umbrella body en-

    compassing 10 Jewish federations.

    “Our overall goal is to educate the

    legislators about Israel and to give

    historical perspective for what goes

    on here. Four of our participants are

    sponsors of anti-BDS legislation that

    we expect to be passed in mid- to late

    March.”

    Among other items on its full itiner-

    ary, the delegation toured several IDFbases, Israel’s national defense college,

    Tel Aviv University, the Golan Heights,

    Kibbutz Erez, and Sderot near the

    Gaza Strip.

    They met with U.S. Ambassador Dan

    Shapiro; Speaker of the Knesset Yuli

    Edelstein; Minister of National Infra-

    structures, Energy, and Water Yuval

    Steinitz; Foreign Ministry representa-

    tives; participants in Roots, a dialogue

    group between Israelis and Palestinian

    Arabs, and Civil Aviation Authority of

    Israel Director Giora Romm, who was

    a prisoner of war in Egypt in 1969 and

    was deputy Israel Air Force command-

    er during the 1991 Gulf War.

    “As a county legislator and as a

    board member of Jewish Federation

    of North Jersey, this journey has been

    majorly impactful,” said Tracy Silna Zur,

    vice chairwoman of the Bergen CountyBoard of Chosen Freeholders.

    “Our bipartisan group traveled from

    north to south to see and understand

    what Israel is all about and to under-

    stand the importance of the relation-

    ship between Israel and the United

    States and specifically with the state

    of New Jersey,” she said. “We met with

    everyone from kibbutz members to

    a Palestinian working toward nonvio-

    lence to the speaker of the Knesset.”

    Ms. Zur said it is important for New

    Jersey residents “to know that this

    group, as a whole and as individuals, is

    dedicated to understanding the chal-

    lenges in Israel and the importance of

    anti-BDS legislation, as well as lear

    best practices from one another.”

    She said the group is coming ho

    with ideas for strengthening partne

    ships between Israel and New Jers

    trade and economic development,

    possibly incorporating Israeli techn

    gies into the state universities.“It’s also a religious journey,” Mr. L

    enson said. “All but two of the legis

    tors on this mission are Christian, a

    they were able to see their roots in

    Jerusalem and in Tiberias.”

    During one emotional moment o

    the trip, Mr. Levenson gave a $125,0

    check to the Regional Council of G

    Etzion from the Jewish Federation

    Greater Clifton-Passaic toward buil

    ing a promenade commemorating

    three teenage boys kidnapped ther

    and killed by terrorists in 2014. The

    donation was given in memory of M

    and Eta Levenson’s son, Eric Elieze

    who recently died. He was 28 years

    From left, Lafe Bush, Cathy Madalone, John Devine, Dr. Ja

    Pruden, Jacqueline Luthcke, Todd Pearl, Timothy Torell, a

    Kenneth Ehrenberg stand in a gallery at the Knesset.

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    7/56JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2

    Great Rate and a Bonus on Each 1-Year Anniversary

    Established 1863 · Member FDIC

    www.applebank.com

    PLUS$25,000 minimum to earn stated rate

    0.75% APY*  Savings AccountBONUS BONUS**

    On each 1-year anniversary of account opening

    0.25% Visit us today!

    75 Route 59, Monsey Town Square (Evergreen Kosher Market Center)

    Anita Levine, VP, Branch Manager • 845-425-0189 O P E N  S U

     N DA Y

     F R O M

     9A M  -  1 P

     M

    *For the Apple Bank BONUS Savings account, interest earned on daily balances of $2,500 or m ore at these tiers: $2,500-$24,99 9: .10% Annual Percentage Yield (APY), $25,000 and up: .75% APY. There is no interest paid on balancesof $0-$2,499. APYs disclosed effective as of January 5, 2016. APYs may be changed at any time at the Bank’s discretion. There is a minimum of $2,500 required to open the Apple Bank BONUS Savings account. $2,500 mini-mum daily balance is required to avoid $10 monthly maintenance fee. Fees may reduce earnings. Funds used to open this account cannot be from an existing Apple Bank account. Maximum deposit amount is $1,000,00 0 perhousehold. **Special bonus feature: A .25% simple interest rate bonus will be paid on each anni versary date of account opening on the lowest balance for that year (anniversary date to anniversar y date). No bonus is paid if theaccount balance is less than $2,500 on the anniversary date. Ad ditional deposits during a given anniversary period do not affect the bonus interest payment. Deposits made to the account on any anniversary date will be used tocalculate the lowest account balance for the next anniversary period. The bonus interest is calculated on the lowest balan ce on deposit from one anniversary date to the next anniversary date. Simple interest rate bonus is subjectto change at any time after first anniversary date of account opening. Hypothetical example of how bonus works: Assume an account is opened on January 12, 2016 for $50,000. A $10,000 withdrawal is made on July 12, 2016.No other withdrawals are made prior to the January 12, 2017 anniversary date. The low balance is now $40,000, so $100 in bonus interest will be paid on January 12, 2017.

     

    medical, ire, and security personnel are

     geared toward “influencers, the kinds of

    people who can change minds and hearts.

    “These people go back to their com-

    munities as ambassadors for Israel, whocan speak to misconceptions about Israel

     because they understand on a gut level

    and an intellectual level what Israel is to

    America,” she said.

    The itinerary is designed “to show the

    real Israel behind the headlines, and the

    only way to do that is by being here,” she

    added. “When those people go back and

    talk about it, it’s like throwing a stone in

    a pool and watching the rings that ripple

    out from the stone. This type of mission is

    an ANumber-One priority for federation.”

    Lafe Bush, director of emergency ser-

     vices for the Valley Health System in Ridge-

     wood, said he enjoyed the group’s tour of

    Galilee Medical Center in Nahariya, the

    federation’s partner city in the WesternGalilee. This hospital has treated many

     victims of the Syrian civil war, and has full

    underground facilities in case of attack

    from Lebanon.

    “The Centers for Medicaid and Medi-

    care Services in America and the Joint

    Commission, an accrediting body for hos-

    pitals, are starting to look at emergency

    management and demands on hospitals’

    physical infrastructure and the improve-

    ments they can make,” Mr. Bush said.

    “One of the ideas they have talked about

    is bombprooing the emergency rooms

    and building underground ERs. I don’t

    know if it will get to that point because

     building an underground ER would be a

    multimillion-dollar task in existing hospi-

    tals, although it could potentially be built

    in a new hospital. So it was very in

    ing for me to see that Nahariya has a

    done that. When their regular emer

    room was bombed they were able to

    underground.”A trauma surgeon at Galilee M

    Center described mass casualty pla

    procedures and the checklist the

    tal uses to assure that incoming pa

     with different types of injuries will b

    cessed appropriately.

    “I’ve worked on preparedness f

    healthcare system, so this was an o

    tunity for me to see how people wh

    had frequent exposure to unusual c

    stances responded and how they

    adjustments in their response, and

    if there is anything we can take hom

    their experience,” said Dr. James Pr

    an emergency care physician at St. Jo

    Regional Medical Center in Paterson

    “The difference is the real and pthreat that exists in Israel, and so

    commitment to preparedness is

    ably at a higher level than at hospi

    the United States,” he said. “What’

    lar is the general stratey of rapid

    At the police academy in Beit Shemesh, an instructor shows Chief Kenneth Eh-

    renberg a knife. Dr. James Pruden, who is partially hidden, and Captain Jacque-

    line Luthcke look on.

    SEE FIRST RESPONDERS PA

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    8/56

    Local

    8JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2016

    Fill Our Food Pantry!

    The JFS Food Pantry provides nutritional

    assistance to families with food insecurity.

    Please help us help those in need.

    1485 Teaneck Road, Teaneck, NJ - 201-837-9090 - www.jfsbergen.org

    ‘People were so open,’ Barnert rabbi saysGathering in friendship over food breaks down barriers

    LOIS GOLDRICH

    What keeps her awake at

    night is fear, Rabbi Elyse

    Frishman wrote in a

    recent article. Fear of

     wasting time and of spending “more time

    thinking about why I can’t do something

    than getting out and doing it.”

    To address at least one communal fear

    — the fear of Muslims — Frishman, the reli-

     gious leader of Barnert Temple in Franklin

    Lakes, joined with other members of the

    Oakland/Franklin Lakes Interfaith Clery,

    as well as with religious leaders from the

     wider Muslim community, to bring their

    diverse congregants together for an eve-

    ning of “safe conversation.”

    Since there are no mosques in the grou p’s cat chm ent area, the cou nci l

    invited representatives from the Islamic

    Center in Midland Park, from the Muslim

    Society of Ridgewood, and from the Peace

    Island Institute, a Turkish Muslim group

    involved in outreach and education.

    In publicizing the meeting, the council

    issued a statement noting that it “came to

    the realization that conversation between

    different faith groups, in a person-to-per-

    son setting, was crucial to create under-

    standing of, and relationships with, each

    other.”

    Taking this to heart, Rabbi Frishman

     wrote to her congregants, telling them

    that after the shul’s High Holy Days driveto raise awareness of the Syrian refugee

    crisis — every member of the congregation

     was asked to call President Barack Obama,

    urging him to accept more refugees — she

     began meeting with her interfa ith col-

    leagues to discuss the issue.

    “We realized that many people are

    afraid of the refugees because they are

    afraid or suspicious of Muslims; much of

    this stems from not knowing any Mus-

    lims,” Rabbi Frishman said. To rectify that,

    she told her members, “we have organized

    the irst social gathering of Muslim, Jews,

    and Christians in western Bergen, hosted

     by us at Barnert.”

    The gathering, held on March 6, was

    hugely successful, Rabbi Frishman said.

     Jews, Christians, and Muslims talked to

    each other for hours, despite the fast-

    approaching inal episode of “Downton

    Abbey.” Some participants were so ener-

     gized by the table talk — they chatted dur-

    ing a potluck supper — that they resolved

    to go out to eat together at a later date to

    inish their conversation.

    The evening, called “Make Love Not

    War — Christians, Jews and Muslims from

    Our Neighborhoods,” began with a brief

    cross-denominational service, including

    elements of Jewish, Christian, and Mus-

    lim prayers. The dinner that followed,

    to which all attendees contributed, was

     vegetarian.

    “That way, we didn’t have to worry

    about dietary restrictions,” Rabbi Frish-

    man said. “Everyone brought food, and it

     was so much fun that people asked for a

    cookbook of all the recipes.”

    In planning the evening, she added, “We

    decided not only to bring people together

    in the sanctuary but to have a potluck sup-

    per where we could break down xenopho-

     bic barriers.” Members of the interfaith

    council brought members from their own

    congregations, and tables were arranged

    so that they included people from all reli-

     gious groups. It also was geared to all age

     groups, with separate rooms for tee

    elementary school students.

    “There were facilitators at the t

    asking social questions like where a

    from, and what books do you like to

    Rabbi Frishman said. “It was safe c

    sation, nothing controversial. And

    the irst of what will become many o

    tunities for people to get together.”

    In all, the gathering drew som

    adults and 40 teens. “There was

    thing for everyone,” Rabbi Frishman

    And when it was over, “there wa

    nomenal feedback,” she added. “It

    simple it was brilliant — opening th

    Before dinner, from left, Barnert’s Rabbi Elyse Frishman, Imam Moutaz and Ammar Charaf, both of the Elzahra Islamic

    Center in Midland Park; Rabbi Daniel Freelander, president of the World Union for Progressive Judaism; Rev. Kathryn

    King of St. Albans Episcopal Church and Rev. Lou Kilgore of High Mountain Presbyterian Church, both in Franklin Lake

    the Peace Institute’s Ercon Tozan; Mahomoud Hamza of the Elzahra Islamic Center; Rev. Alison V. Philip of the United M

    odist Church in Franklin Lakes; Meryem Teke of the Peace Institute, and Rev. Nathan Busker of Ponds Reformed ChurcOakland stood together.

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    9/56

    Local

    JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2

    For a totally new look using your furniture or starting anew.

    Staging also available

    973-535-9192

    Sandi M. Malkin, L L C Interior Designer 

    (former interior designer of modelrooms for NY’s #1 Dept. Store)

    More than

    332,000 likes.

    Like us on

    Facebook.

    facebook.com/ 

     jewishstandard

    to look into each other’s eyes. I was surprised by how

    easy it was.

    “People were so open. Especially with what’s going

    on in our nation right now — we’re overwhelmed by

    absurdity, anger, polarization, and we don’t buy into

    that. People want to get to know each other, to break

    down barriers. They don’t want to be afraid or igno-

    rant of the other. They just need the opportunity.”Rabbi Frishman said the clery council will meet

    soon to brainstorm its program for the coming year,

    looking to facilitate “small and large gatherings for fur-

    ther dialogue and conversation. We need to build faith

    and trust one another.” Eventually, the communities

    may move on to discuss more controversial issues. In

    the meantime, “There are a lot of different opportuni-

    ties, like book groups, and teens working in the gar-

    den. It depends on what people are interested in. The

    door is wide open.”

    Other religious leaders were thrilled as well.

    Rev. Alison V. Philip, pastor of the Franklin Lakes

    United Methodist Church, said, “Sometimes, with-

    out realizing it, cynicism builds up within me. Last

    night at the interfaith friendship gathering, instead

    I felt illed up with hope that change can really hap-

    pen in our world and that it happens through humanrelationship.

    “One thing that sticks with me is a conversation I

    had with an imam who identiied the struggles refu-

     gees face in this country,” she continued. “Prejudice

    is a huge problem from elementary-aged children

    and up, and it only perpetuates animosity between

     groups. Distrust of the stranger in turn produces dis-

    trust within the stranger.

    “My hope going forward is to ind ways as faith

    leaders to address prejudice, perhaps by continuing

    to offer opportunities for people to connect human

     being to human being, and to become truly neighbors

    rather than strangers.”

    Asked if anything surprised her at the gathering, the

    Rev. Philip said, “It shouldn’t surprise me but it still

    does — each time when I meet someone who seems

    different from me and as we talk I realize how simi-

    lar we are. It doesn’t erase differences, of course, but

    it grounds me in the truth that people have sharedhopes and values and dreams.”

    Rev. Nathan Busker of Ponds Reformed Church in

    Oakland was moved as well, noting that “With all the

    rhetoric about building walls and fearing the stranger,

    the power of love during the interfaith event was pal-

    pable. Last night, the space between us disappeared

    as bridges of friendship were built.”

    Ercan Tozan, executive director of the Peace Island

    Institute, said, “We are polluting the world with our anger,

     jealousy, envy, animosity, hatred, prejudices, ego, and

    many other contemptuous feelings with the excuse of a

     better life, nationalism, or religion.” For harmony to flour-

    ish, it is “vital that we get to know each other. Knowing is

    the irst step in the road leading to love and peace.”

    It doesn’t erasedifferences, ofcourse, but it

     grounds me in thetruth that people

    have shared hopesand values and

    dreams.

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    10/56

    Local

    10JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2016

    ‘The best kind of career’Teaneck millennial video-makingmusician talks about his choices

    LIZ POSNER

    “Do you want to be in a music video?” Teaneck

    musician and entrepreneur Jeremy Katz

    asked me as soon as I stepped into his home

    studio. I’ve never had an interviewee begin

     with a question for me, let alone an invitation to live out my

    teenage fantasy of becoming a pop star. Eagerly, I agreed.

     Jeremy directed me to his drum set in front of a large green

    screen, which he has set up permanently in front of a digital

    camera and a MacBook. He hit “play” on his speakers and

    “record” on the camera, and I drummed awkwardly along to

    David Bowie’s “Under Pressure.” A quick few minutes later,

     Jeremy had uploaded the v ideo, chosen a backdrop, and

    added spliced footage of himself on guitar and vocals. The

     green screen disappeared, replaced by a full football ield.We watched the inal product: me, on drums; Jeremy at the

    mic and another Jeremy strumming the guitar in front of a

    screaming stadium of thousands. I have to say, Jeremy, his

    clone, and I make quite the trio.

    Wearing many hats comes naturally to Jeremy, 24, a Frisch

    School and Yeshiva University graduate. His professional web-

    site, JeremyKatzMusic.com, showcases his various passions,

     which range from instrumentals and vocals to writing original

    music, video production, and gear reviews.

    Music is in his blood. As a teenager he played in a blues

     band with his family. “My father, older brother, and younger

     brother used to rehearse together,” he said. “Our basement

     was always like a mini-studio.” He plays 14 different instru-

    ments, including drums, banjo, mandolin, and guitar. “My

    father used to record us playing together on a daily basis.

    We’d dance all day and he’d ilm us. It’s fun to go back

    and watch the videos now.”

    Some young musicians give up their dream of

    making it big once they graduate and realize

    open-mic nights won’t cover their rent or col-

    lege loans. Not Jeremy. In the pragmatic tradi-

    tion of the Jewish people, he found a way

    to turn his passion for music into a career.

    “I wanted to ind a way to showcase the

    fact that I play 14 instruments,” he said.

    On his YouTube channel, which

    has more than 900 subscrib-

    ers, Jeremy produces and stars

    in music video covers of pop

    songs old and new, includingsingles by some of his all-time

    favorite artists: Queen, Elvis,

    Maroon 5, and Bruno Mars.

    Some have gone viral — his cover

    of The Weeknd’s “Can’t Feel My

    Face,” for example, has more than

    9,500 views.

    “Not everyone is nice on YouTube,

     but I try to listen to what everyone

    has to say,” he said. “I also respond

    to all of the comments viewers leave.

    I’ll sit down once a week and answer

    everyone’s questions. It makes any-

    one who comments feel important.”

    Jeremy Katz, above, plays the drums in his Teaneck home studio. Right, Katz on guitar,

    one of the many instruments he’s mastered.

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    11/56

    Maybe Jeremy’s most valuable asset is the healthy

    sense of humor he brings to his videos. He frequently

    dons costumes to heighten his music videos into trib-

    ute-parody hybrids. “The costumes are the best part,”

    he said. “It’s one thing hearing me, and it’s another

    thing seeing me play.”

    Performance certainly is on his mind throughout the

    creative process. “I try to make it as entertaining as pos-sible. I thought, I’m doing a Queen song, why not dress

    up like Freddie Mercury? I’ll just put the mustache on,

     get the wigs, and go for it. I want you to watch my music

    and be like ‘damn, that was a really good song and at

    the same time, that was funny as hell.’”

     Jeremy launched his entrepreneurial enterprise in

    2015. So far, he has worked with major companies

    like Shell Oil to create music videos for corporate

    team-building. He combined his love of music, enter-

    tainment, and video editing to jumpstart his music

     video production career. “It was an awesome experi-

    ence. I had a such a great time working with Shell, I

    thought, why not keep doing this?”

    For his most recent project, he created a video for

    Campus Pursuit, which organizes scavenger hunts

    for college students to connect them with brands.

    “They’re using the music video more for advertisingand marketing,” he said. “I leave the creative decisions

    up to them — I give them certain production clues.”

    The rest is up to the company.

     Jeremy does not see a strict divide between his cur-

    rent projects. “It’s goes two ways,” he says of his You-

    Tube channel and his corporate work. “The people

    in the companies will share it all around, so the more

    people I work with, the more my channel grows.”

    Like most ambitious millennials, Jeremy uses social

    media to build his personal brand. “I use Twitter, Ins-

    tagram, Snapchat. I’m not the best at Twitter but I’ll

    tweet something special for famous dates, like the day

     John Lennon was killed, or on Elvis’ birthday I’ll post a

    picture of myself dressed as Elvis.” Social media helps

    him interact with younger fans, though he says some

    older admirers often leave comments on his videos.

    “I’d say I’m best at piano and guitar. I hated piano

     when I irst started it. I wanted to play guitar because

    my dad always played rock, but then I realized I loved

    listening to Billy Joel and Elton John, and that’s allpiano. So I started teaching myself piano again when

    I was ive or six. Then I realized I liked the saxophone

    part in another song, and so I picked up the sax.”

    Some instruments are more challenging than others.

    “By far, the hardest instrument is the violin. I still play

    it, but saxophone only took me a couple of months to

    learn. But the violin, it’s like no matter how hard I try,

    I can’t get down.”

    So why don’t you just give it up? I asked him.

    “Because I’m dying to play ‘The Devil Went Down

    To Georgia,’” he said jokingly, but I could hear the

    seriousness in his voice. “You can’t half-go at music.

    With these videos, I had to dive in head-irst. It takes

    me about four days to make a music video now. The

    By far, the hardest instrument is the

    violin. I still play it,but saxophone onlytook me a couple of

    months to learn.

    Loc

    JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2

    The finest selection

    of Italian designer 

    men’s & boy’s suits,sport jackets, pants,

    shirts, shoes and 

    accessories, at 

    discounted prices.

    OUR NEW SPRING

    MERCHANDISE

    HAS ARRIVED!

    FLATBUSH:

    1505 Coney Island Ave.718.676.7706

    BORO PARK:

    5020 13th Avenue718.972.4665

    LAKEWOOD:

    1700 Madison Ave.732.987.9480

    LONG ISLAND:

    467 Central Avenue516.295.5006

    TEANECK:

    215 W. Englewood Ave. | 201.530.7300

    irst time, it took me three weeks. It’s trial and error, but I

    decided ‘I’m doing this,’ and so I did it.”

    Like anything, hard work is just that: hard work. The

     video production aspect of his business is the most dificult

    for Jeremy. “It’s frustrating at times. Like with the violin,

    sometimes I want to break the instrument. But I give it a

    day and try again.”

    He plans to build his personal brand by continuing to cre-ate music videos, both the corporate ones and the ones he

    makes for fun. “I want to have a big, successful YouTube

    channel. At the same time, I want to build my corporate

     work. They go hand in hand.” His videos already have been

    syndicated to TV networks worldwide, and he has a large

    fan base in Germany.

    Growing up in a Jewish home had a major impact o

    “My Jewish background has influenced me tremend

    he said. “Jewish homes always have a lot of music.

    about it — when you’re learning about your religio

    child, they teach you through songs.”

    As a fellow 24-year-old pursuing my own creative

    I told Jeremy how much I admire his commitment to what he loves. What’s his advice for other young as

    musicians, I asked. “When you ind a career that you’

    sionate about, you’re going to give it 110 percent,” he s

     wake up and I want to inish a song or a video I’m w

    on. That’s the best kind of career you can have.”

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    12/56

    Local

    12JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2016

    Scouts build bridgesLocal high school senior earns highest rank of Eagle

    ABIGAIL KLEIN LEICHMAN

    During one of his walks around the TenaflyNature Center, 18-year-old Avi Samuel of

    Teaneck noticed a patch of dirt near the pond

    that was unprotected by footboards and prone

    to muddiness.

    Instead of complaining about the problem, he remedied

    it as his Eagle Scout service project.

    Mr. Samuel planned and built a walkway extension with

    the help of eight scouts and other volunteers under the

    supervision of Amanda Shuster, the nature center’s scout

    coordinator and environmental educator.

    “I took woodworking classes at summer camp one time,

     but this was my irst big project,” Mr. Samuel said.

    “The actual building took about four hours, but get-

    ting all the permissions and signatures took a long time,

    and we had to plan and design it over many hours,” he

    explained. “The nature center told us what they wanted,

    and my dad helped with the design and materials.”They used composite decking material and pressure-

    treated lumber.

    “Avi’s footboard project was helpful in extend

    stretch of elevated walkway next to our pond, whic

    flood seasonally and with heavy rainfall,” Ms. Shuste“By adding the footboards — which matched the ex

    footboards seamlessly — he has helped to prevent e

    that can occur when people widen the path by walk

    avoid muddy areas.”

    On February 28, Avi, who is Troop 226’s senior

    leader was feted at an Eagle Scout Court of Honor

     Jewish Center of Teaneck, where the Jewish Boy

    troop meets.

    Eagle Scout is the highest rank in the Boy Scou

    requires earning at least 21 merit badges and comp

    a service project. Nationally, only about 5 percent o

    Scouts achieve this level.

    “Relatively few scouts ever attain the rank of Ea

    as the scoutmaster of the troop, I am proud when a

    does achieve this honor,” said Daniel Chazin, a r

    Teaneck attorney who has led Troop 226 since 1977

    “I have never kept an accurate count, but I canof about a dozen Eagle Scouts that we’ve had in the

    since I became scoutmaster,” he added. “I know

    Eagle Scout Avi Samuel; his older brother, Adam Sam-

    uel; Zachary Fishman; Avi’s cousin Zachary Samuel,

    and Yoni Stern worked on the Tenafly Nature Center

    footboard project.  DAVID SAMUEL

    Wild birdmakes forfoul guestSaturday, the turkeycame for breakfast

    LARRY YUDELSON

    It is the stuff of suburban nightmares.

    Courtney Lopchinsky was drinking her coff

    sharing a breakfast of cookies and ice cream

    two of her children on a recent Shabbat mo

    Her husband and youngest child already had left fo

    She looked out the kitchen window and saw fou

    turkeys fly up to her neighbor’s roof and perch ther

    She didn’t know that one of those birds had her nu

    The number turned out to be 6,000.

    That’s how many dollars of damage ensued when

    the birds flew off the roof and straight

    charging right through her kitchen winNo one ever said turkeys were smart

    With the loud crash of a plate glas

    dow, shards of glass and feathers ille

    air of the Teaneck kitchen and a t

    Clockwise, from top right: A wild tu

    splattered blood on the window sill

    a Teaneck home and left debris on t

    kitchen floor when it crashed throug

    window, now boarded up, and disru

    breakfast for the Lopchinsky family.

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    13/56

    Local

    JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 20

    Tables & Chairs - all sizes, all sty

     

    Decorators & Designers Welcom

     

    908.583.6109

    2500 Brunswick Avenue

    Bldg H, Linden, NJ 07036www.uniqueelegantseating.com

    uniqueelegantseating

    seasonal promotion

    Traditional. Modern.Contemporary.

    scouting has meant a great deal to Avi, and I’m pleased

    to see how his work in earning the Eagle badge has

    helped him grow and mature.”

    Avi is a senior at Torah Academy of Bergen County

    in Teaneck and has been an active member of Troop

    226 since he was a sixth-grader at Yavneh Academy in

    Paramus.

    “I enjoy scouting,” Avi said. “It’s a unique opportu-nity to learn many life skills such as camping, survival,

    and leadership. It’s fun at the same time.” He especially

    enjoys hiking and rock-climbing trips with the troop,

     which now has 12 active members.

    Troop 226 is Bergen County’s only Jewish-sponsored

    Boy Scout troop and one of only a handful in the state

    that is Sabbath observant, although 11- to 18-year-old

     boys from all religious backgrounds are welcome to join.

    Mr. Chazin said that Troop 226 was established in

    1970. “It was originally chartered to the Moriah School of

    Englewood and moved to the Jewish Center of Teaneck

    around 1975,” he said.

    The irst Jewish Boy Scout troop in the country was

    formed at the 92nd Street Y in Manhattan in 1913. Today

    there are about 60 Jewish Cub Scout packs and 70 Jew-

    ish Boy Scout troops nationally. Of those, about 40

    percent are Sabbath observant. (There also are JewishDaisy, Brownie, and Girl Scout troops across the coun-

    try, including Junior Girl Scout Troop 5826 in Teaneck.

    As of press time, Girl Scouts of the USA did not respond

    to inquiries for details.)

    Sabbath-observant troops do not have regular meet-

    ings or activities on Saturdays, but they do offer weekend

    camping experiences that give scouts an opportunity to

    learn skills that straddle Jewish and scouting traditions.

    They include building an eruv — the boundary that legally

    transforms a campsite into a private area in which you arepermitted to carry on Shabbat — and cooking cholent, the

    traditional Shabbat stew that stays on a continuous flame

    from Friday before sundown until Saturday lunch.

    David and Jodi Samuel, who are members of Congre-

     gation Rinat Yisrael in Teaneck, believe scouting has

     been beneicial for their son.

    “Boy Scouts gave him the opportunity of learning how

    to work his way up in organizations like you would in a

    company,” Mr. Samuel said. “As he got older, he learned

    leadership skills and the necessity of sticking to a pro-

     gram, starting at the bottom and working his way up.

    We’re quite proud of him.”

    Avi acknowledged that extracurricular activities, like

    scouting, can be dificult to squeeze into the weekly

    schedule for students in Jewish day schools, which have

    a longer day and a double curriculum of secular and

     Jewish studies.“It was kind of hard, but I got my homework done fast

    so I could go to meetings on Mondays,” he said.

    landed on the table.

    Ms. Lopchinsky grabbed her

    two children and “literally ran

    for our lives,” she recalled this

    past week.

    They ran next door andcalled 911 from the neighbor’s

    house.

    Teaneck police were initially

    skeptical, she said. But the

    skepticism fell away when they

    saw Ms. Lopchinsky and her

    daughter pulling glass shards

    from their hair.

    Ms. Lopchinsky returned to

    her kitchen with the police. The

    turkey had been cut by his jag-

     ged entrance and was bleeding.

    He was muddy. He spread his

     wings and puffed up his feath-

    ers and glass and dirt flew onto

    the floor.

    “It was disgusting,” Ms. Lopchinsky said.The police chased the turkey around the kitchen

    and around the house. He jumped up to the sink. He

    knocked the slow cooker with cholent off the coun-

    ter. He pecked at another window, hoping to escape.

    “Finally, they caught him,” she said.

    But if Ms. Lopchinsky was hoping for the turkey to be

    taught a lesson, she was disappointed.

    “They just let him go,” she said.

    Apparently, breaking and entering isn’t prosecuted in

    Teaneck, if the perpetrator is a bird.

    Sadly, it turned out that Ms. Lopchinksy’s homeown-

    er’s insurance also didn’t mete out just rewards when

    the perpetrator is a bird.

    Her policy’s coverage speciically exempts damage by

     birds, as well as by snakes and other reptiles, according

    to its ine print.Secondary damage from the broken glass, however,

     was covered. Not, though, the feathers, the blood, the

    mud, and the glass shards the turkey left all over the

    house.

    It took two industrial cleaning companies to clean up

    the mess.

    A week later she found glass fragments in her child’s

    Lego box.

    The turkeys continue to roam in her corner of

    Teaneck.

    Soon, a new window will replace the wooden board

    that has covered the damage.

    “We asked the window guys, is it a turkey-proof win-

    dow? He said he couldn’t guarantee anything.”

    Wild turkeys make their way across a suburban Teaneck street.

    Like us on Facebook.

    facebook.com/jewishstandard

    More than 332,000 likes.

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    14/56

    Local

    14JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2016

    L’chaim! To life — and good tasteRoyal’s Kosher Food and Wine Experience returns to Chelsea Piers

    JOSH LIPOWSKY

    Kosher Champagne from Cham-

    pagne, France? Cabernet sau-

     vignon sorbet? Perhaps a little

    pastrami babka?

    A sold-out crowd of approximately 1,600

    packed into New York’s Chelsea Piers on

    February 29 for Royal Wine’s tenth annual

    Kosher Food and Wine Experience to try

    these and other delicacies.

    Bayonne-based Royal Wine returned

    the show to Chelsea Piers, overlooking the

    Hudson River. To take advantage of the

    setting, the show offered a docked yacht

     with a new VIP section featuring sushi,

    special selections from Teaneck’s Etc

    Steakhouse (such as carved roast turkey

    and pastrami), and older vintage wines.Three hundred VIP tickets sold out within

    48 hours, according to Mordy Herzog,

    executive vice president of Royal Wine.

    Mr. Herzog credits the show’s popularity

    to kosher wine consumers expanding their

    tastes and trying new flavors.

    “Five years ago everybody just wanted

    cabs on the red and chards on the white,”

    Mr. Herzog said. Now, “the consumer is

    opening up and people are more inter-

    ested to try new varietals.”

    There was no shortage of variety. With

    more than 200 wines and 30 restaurants

    and caterers at the show, it is impossible

    to do justice to every delectable dish and

     wine. So below we present you with justa few of our choice selections from this

    year’s show.

    Fireside, MonseyFireside has been open for just nine

    months and made its irst appearance this

    year at KFWE. Executive chef Alex Remer,

     who lives in Teaneck, brought a Chicago-

    style deep-dish fleishig pizza topped with

    house-made beef bacon, ground beef,

    shredded salami, a wild mushroom med-

    ley, and a maple aoli. Tumbleweed onions,

    crisp red onions served with a special

    house sauce, were on the side. Both dishes

    are on Fireside’s regular menu. The tum-

     bleweed onions have been on the menu

    since the beginning, while Mr. Remerintroduced the pizza about six months

    ago. Both have been big hits, he said.

    This is not Mr. Reme’s irst visit to

    KFWE; he had been there when he worked

    at Teaneck’s Etc. Steakhouse. People tend

    to think of Monsey as “upstate,” he said. “I

    knew KFWE was a great place to introduce

    ourselves to the greater kosher-eating

    community.”

    Pomegranate, BrooklynEvery year this kosher market brings new

    flavors and experimental dishes to KFWE.

    This year was no different. Pomegranate

    offered one of the largest booths at the

    show, and standing out among its offer-

    ings were its pastrami-illed babka and

    corned beef-illed babka. And they tasted

    exactly as you would expect — like a delisandwich on babka. How could you go

     wrong?

    Teaneck DoghouseCo-owner Jonathan Gellis likes to try new

     wines and foods to keep the restaurant

    uptempo, its manager, Josh Pinsker, said.

    Mr. Pinsker managed the Doghouse’s

    table while Mr. Gellis explored the show.

    The Doghouse offered a few staples

    from its menu: pulled brisket sliders,

     barbecued salami tossed in a barbecue

    sauce, and sausage eggrolls in a sweet

    chili sauce. “Now we’re just trying to

    show everybody what’s so great about

    Teaneck,” Mr. Pinsker said.

    The KFWE App

    Every year KFWE attendees have receiveda spiral-bound notebook listing all the

     wines and foods available for tasting. A

     week later, many struggle to re ad their

    handwriting or ind the pages on which

    they scribbled their new favorite bottles.

    This year, KFWE did away with the book

    and created a unique phone app for the

    event. The app offers users the ability to

    take notes and pictures of each wine and

    dish they try, without the hassle of deci-

    phering hurried handwriting.

    “We just decided it was time to move

    into a higher tech version of the book,” Mr.

    Herzog said.

    Herzog Wine Cellars

    Herzog brought an interesting com

    tion, which head winemaker Joe Hur

    referred to as the “Battle of the BaTwo cabernet sauvignon wines usi

    same grape but one aged for nine m

    in American oak and the other ag

    nine months in French oak. Wine

    in American oaks tend toward str

    flavors, while wines aged in French

    tend to have more subtle flavors. “

    an exciting concept,” Mr. Hurliman

    (This reporter preferred the French

    AppleationAppleation showcased three

    ciders: dry, sweet, and cinnamon fla

    It’s like apple pie in liquid form.

    Joe Hurliman shows the

    latest vintages from Herz

    Appleation showcased

    three varieties of hard cider

    Teaneck Doghouse displayed

    specialties from pulled brisket

    sliders to barbecued salami.

    Mordy Herzog,

    executive vice

    president of

    Royal Wine.

    Babka from

    Pomegranate

    is stuffed with

    corned beef or

    pastrami.

    Executive chef Alex Remer from

    Fireside presents his fleishig pizza.

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    15/56JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 20

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    16/56

    Local

    16JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2016

    Party planned for LGBTQ teens

    The LGBTQ Connection holds the Un-

    Masquerade Ball, sponsored by Jew-

    ish Family Service of Bergen and North

    Hudson and Sha’ar Communities, with

    funding from the Jewish Federation of

    Northern New Jersey.

    The party, a celebration of individual-

    ity, acceptance, and self-expression in a

     Jewish context, for eighth- to 12th-grad-ers, is on Wednesday, March 23, from 8

    to 10 p.m., at the Kaplen JCC on the Pali-

    sades in Tenafly, where there will be a

    Megillah reading at 6:45.

    According to Sha’ar’s Rabbi Adina

    Lewittes, “Four in 10 of these teenagers

    say that the community in which they

    live is not accepting of LGBTQ people.

    Given our strong and cohesive Jewish

    community, the alienation experienced

     by these adolescents is likely even more

    intense, often leading to deep feelings of

    isolation. We wanted to provide an inclu-

    sive event, focused on our shared faith,

     while having a great time.” The ball will

    include a DJ, food, and opportunities to

    meet new friends. JFS’ LGBTQ Connec tion serve s les-

     bian, gay, bisexual, transgendered, and

    questioning Jewish adolescents and their

    parents. Entry fees will be donated to

    Keshet and GLSEN. For information, call

     JFS at (201) 8379090 or email Lauren.

     [email protected].

     Joy Kurland to be honored in MayThe Jewish Historical Soci-

    ety of North Jersey will

    honor Joy Kurland for her

    contribution to the Jewish

    community at its annualtribute dinner, Tuesday,

    May 17, at 6:30 p.m. The

    informal celebration,

     which will be at Temple

    Beth Rishon in Wyckoff,

    offers a chance to share

    memories.

     Joy Kurland’s work in northern New

     Jersey included fostering intergroup

    relations, building coalitions, advocat-

    ing for Israel, strengthening govern-

    ment relations, and promoting initia-

    tives that contributed to enhancing

     Jewish community relations.

    Throughout her career, she received

    many honors, awards, a

    recognitions for her cont

     butions to the communi

    from organizations includi

    the Anti-Defamation LeaguBergen County NAACP, t

     Jewish Federation of Nor

    ern New Jersey, Drew Univ

    sity Hillel, and Bergen Cou

    ty’s Brotherhood/Sisterho

    Interfaith Coalition.

    Ms. Kurland is a member and p

    chair of the Bergen County Hum

    Relations Commission. She is t

    immediate past president of the JC

    Directors Association of the Jewi

    Council for Public Affairs. Ms. Kurla

    also is on the board of the Jewish H

    torical Society of Northern New Jerse

    For information, call (201) 300659

    Women’s League spring program“Step Up For Israel,” the spring program

    from the Garden State Region of Wom-

    en’s League for Conservative Judaism, is

    on Sunday, April 10, at 9:30 a.m., at Tem-ple Beth O’r/Beth Torah in Clark. The

    program will include presentations and

    an interactive discussion led by experts

    on Israel, focusing on the myths and the

    facts in the media and the college cam-

    pus. Participants will gain the practical

    tools to advocate for Israel and develop

    synagogue-wide connections with Israel.

    Speakers include Miri Kornield, the

    executive director of high school affairs

    at Stand With Us; Shimon Mercer-Wood,

    consul for media affairs at Israel’s Con-

    sulate General, and Janet Tobin, thepresident of Mercaz USA and a past pres-

    ident of Women’s League for Conserva-

    tive Judaism.

    An Israeli-style breakfast will be

    served. High school and college students

    are welcome. Reservations are due April

    4. For information, call (732) 2544966 or

    email [email protected].

    Project Sarah breakfastThe 10th annual Project Sarah

     breakf ast, the organization’s

     biggest fundraiser, i s Sunday,

    April 3, at 9:30 a.m., at Congre-

     gation Keter Torah in Teaneck.

    Robin Niman of the Five

    Towns, who used to work at

    Project Sarah, will receive the

    Magen Yeladim Hero award;

    Rabbi Haim Jachter will be

     given the Rabbinic al Support

    award; and Marcia Levy will accept the Vol-

    unteer Recognition Award on behalf of theNational Council of Jewish Women.

     Judy Brown, the author of “Hush” and

    “This Is Not A Love Story” will be the key-

    note speaker.

    Project Sarah (Stop Abusive Relation-

    ships At Home) is a program that works

    to overcome cultural, lega

    religious barriers confro

     victims of domestic violen

    sexual abuse. No one is t

    away because of race, gend

    inancial dificulties. The

    is funded by the N.J. Depar

    of Law and Public Safety, t

    Department of Justice’s Of

    Violence Against Wome

    N.J. Department of Childre

    Families, Jewish Family Service &

    dren’s Center of Clifton-Passaic, an vate donations and foundations.

    The breakfast is free and babysitti

     be provided. Reservations are req

    make them at www.ProjectSARAH.o

    information, call (973) 7777638, ext

    Attending medical school in IsraelDr. Gabriel Farkas, a graduate of Ben-

    Gurion University’s Medical School for

    International Health and Yeshiva Univer-

    sity, spoke to students at Stern College forWomen about going to medical school in

    Israel and transitioning to practice in the

    United States. Dr. Farkas is an anesthesi-

    oloy resident at New York Medical Col-

    lege in Westchester. Beth Chesir, MSIH’s

    admissions coordinator, and Kelly Cole-

    man, a recruitment coordinator, were

    also there. Yeshiva will host another infor-

    mation session on March 20.

    MSIH, one of Ben-Gurion University’s

    two medical schools, is on the universi-

    ty’s Beer Sheva campus. It is an English

    language North-American style medical

    school that incorporates global health

    coursework into all four years of study.

    For information on information ses-

    sion or about attending medical school

    in Israel, email [email protected] or

    [email protected] or call the MSIH

    ofice at (212) 9951231.

    Lander College welcomes gradsfor annual alumni Shabbaton

    More than 100 former students

    returned to their alma mater

    for the sixth annual Lander Col-

    lege for Men Alumni Shabba-

    ton. Alumni came from acrossthe tristate area, Baltimore,

    Dallas, Los Angeles, and Israel.

    Including faculty, spouses, and

    children, 300 people were at

    the reunion.

    Speakers included the col-

    lege’s dean, Dr. Moshe Sokol,

    and its rosh yeshiva, Rabbi

    Yehuda Shmulewitz. The

     weekend included communal

    meals, davening, and a variety of shiurim

    and divrei Torah. After Shabbat, juggling

    comedian Michael Karas performed for

    the adults, while Uncle Moishy’s character

    Nachum the Clown entertaine

    children.

    The Lander College for Men is an u

     graduate division of Touro College.

    Judy Brown

    Joy Kurland

    NORPAC hostsHouse leaderin TeaneckOn Sunday, March 13 at 7 p.m., Drs. Mort

    and Esther Fridman will host a NORPAC

    meeting in Teaneck for House of Repre-sentatives Majority Leader, Congressman

    Kevin McCarthy (RCalif.). For informa-

    tion email [email protected] or call (201)

    7885133.

    Congressman Kevin McCarthy, left,

    with Esther and Mort Fridman.

    COURTESY NORPAC

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    17/56JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 20

    KAPLEN JCC on the Palisades TAUB CAMPUS | 411 E CLINTON AVE, TENAFLY, NJ 07670 | 201.569.7900 |  jccotp.org

    UPCOMING AT KAPLEN JCC on the Palisades

    TO REGISTER OR FOR MORE INFO, VISIT

     jccotp.org OR CALL 201.569.7900.

    ADULTS   FILM   MUSIC

    JCC U Film School SeriesJoin us as we explore film noir —Hollywood crime

    dramas from the years immediately following

    World War II. Connect with fellow movie lovers and top

    film studies expert, PHILIP HARWOOD, as he leads a

    discussion on three film noir features:

    Mar 23, Crossfire (1947); Apr 6, Kiss of Death (1947); &

    Apr 20, The Naked City (1948).

    Call Esther at 201.408.14563 Wednesdays, 10 am, $40/$50 ($16/$20 one day)

    A Sunday of Strong WomenAUTHORS, LUNCH, INSPIRATION

    Join us for a day of inspiration (lunch included)

    as four women authors teach us how to empower

    ourselves. Their work will entertain, entice, inspire,

    inform and empower you in ways you never

    thought possible. Great occasion for a girl’s day

    out!

    Authors include LISA GREEN On Your Case;

    CHEF ROSSI The Raging Skillet ;

    ELYSSA FRIEDLAND Love and Miss Communication;

    and GERALYN LUCAS Then Came Life.

    Visit jccotp.org/ssw for details

    Sun, Mar 13, 10 am-2 pm, $36/$44

    Cello Master Class withPaul Watkins

    Gain insight into the music and the artistic processin this intimate, public coaching featuring Paul

    Watkins, cellist of the Emerson String Quartet. Part

    of the Sylvia and Jacob Handler Master Class series.

    Thu, Mar 31, 4 pm, Free

    Top Films You May HaveMissed: Her An Oscar winning 2013 romantic science-fiction

    comedy-drama. Joaquin Phoenix plays a professional

    writer in the midst of a divorce from Amy Adams.

    He buys and bonds with an intelligent computer

    Operating System, Samantha, played by Scarlett

    Johansson. Film followed by optional discussion.

    Coffee and snacks included.

    Mon, Mar 14, 7:30 pm, $7/$10

    Upcoming: Apr 4, A Stranger Among Us;

    Apr 18, Blue Jasmine; May 16, Serpico

    Rubach Family Purim CarnivalBring your children in their favorite Purim costumes to

    enjoy bounce houses, slides, games, prizes, life-size cartoon

    characters, cotton candy, a costume parade and more.

    Sun, Mar 20, 1-4 pm

    Suggested entrance donation: $1 per person or

    non-perishable food item to be donated to the

    Center for Food Action.

    All ride & game tickets sold on $25 cards for 30 tickets

    Carnival opens at 12 pm for families with children

    with special needs

    The Incredible, Edible EGG!WITH CHEF MICHAEL WOLF

    You’ll be amazed at the versatility of this surprisingly

    simple food and how it can transform your meals.Learn the quintessential techniques for making

    frittatas, omelets, soufflés and meringues.

    Call Michele at 201.408.1496

    Mon, Mar 28, 7-9:30 pm, $60/$75

    FamilyPurimCarnival 

    Step right up to theRUBACH

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    18/56

    Sinai

    18JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2016

    Nearly 850 people attended the Sinai Schools

    annual beneit dinner at the Marriott Glenpointe

    Hotel in Teaneck on February 28 to support

    Sinai and its unique model of inclusive special

    education.Rena and Jerry Barta of Teaneck, Eve and Heshy

    Feldman of Englewood, Karen and Rabbi Steven

    Finkelstein of Bergenield, Rosalyn and Stephen

    Flatow of West Orange, and Annette and Jerry

    Kranson of Fair Lawn were honored. The Commu-

    nity Partnership award was presented to Alfred

    Sanzari Enterprises, celebrating 30 years of Sinai

    dinners at Sanzari’s Glenpointe Hotel.

    The program included the dedication of

    Sinai’s Bayrish Schreiber Music Therapy Pro-

     gram, by AJ and Leah Schreiber, and short ilms

    about the issues facing parents of children with

    special needs. A highlight was the premiere

    of this year’s feature documentary, “Saving

    Freddy,” which addressed the topic of depres-

    sion and suicidal ideation in teens on the autis-

    tic spectrum. Presentation speeches and ilms

    at the dinner are online at www.sinaischools.

    org/2016-dinner-videos.Sinai partners with inclusive Jewish day and

    high schools in New Jersey to provide secular and

     Jewish special education to children with a wide

    range of disabilities. Sinai creates a completely

    individualized program for each child based on

    his or her social, emotional, and academic needs,

    translating into a 1:2 professional staff-to-student

    ratio and several different in-house therapies, with

    specialists on staff at each school.

    If they do not get signiicant inancial aid, Sinai’s

    tuition — which reflects its own costs — is beyond

    the reach of most families.

    For information or to make a donation, call (201)

    8331134, ext. 105, or go to www.sinaischools.org.

     1 Rabbi Wallace Greene with honorees Rosalyn and Stephen Flatow. 2 Esti Herman, Sinai’s chief development officer,

    with honorees David Sanzari, the president and CEO of Sanzari Enterprises, and Jerry Barta, its vice president.

     3 Sam Fishman, Sinai’s managing director, with honorees Jerry and Annette Kranson.  4 Leah and AJ Schreiber, sponsors

    of Sinai’s Bayrish Schreiber Music Therapy Program.  5 Rabbi Steven and Karen Finkelstein 6 Rena and Jerry Barta

    7 Eve and Heshy Feldman 8 Honoree Karen Finkelstein with Sinai’s dean, Rabbi Dr. Yisrael Rothwachs.

    Sinai Schools holds 30th annual benefit dinner1

    2 3

    4 5 6

    7

    8

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    19/56JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 20

    B artenure’lE*

    Freilichen Purim! *Bartenura Moscato is now available in adorable375 ml bottles, perfect for your Mishloach Manos!

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    20/56

    Editorial

    1086 Teaneck RoadTeaneck, NJ 07666(201) 837-8818Fax 201-833-4959

    PublisherJames L. Janoff

    Associate Publisher EmeritaMarcia Garfinkle

    EditorJoanne Palmer

    Associate EditorLarry Yudelson

    Guide/Gallery EditorBeth Janoff Chananie

    About Our Children EditorHeidi Mae Bratt

    CorrespondentsWarren BorosonLois GoldrichAbigail K. LeichmanMiriam RinnDr. Miryam Z. Wahrman

    Advertising DirectorNatalie D. Jay

    Classified DirectorJanice Rosen

    Advertising CoordinatorJane Carr

    Account ExecutivesPeggy EliasGeorge KrollKaren NathansonBrenda Sutcliffe

    International Media PlacementP.O. Box 7195 Jerusalem 91077Tel: 02-6252933, 02-6247919Fax: 02-6249240Israeli Representative

    Production ManagerJerry Szubin

    Graphic ArtistsDeborah HermanBob O'Brien

    ReceptionistRuth Hirsch

    JewishStandard

     jstandard.com

    FounderMorris J. Janoff (1911–19

    Editor EmeritusMeyer Pesin (1901–1989

    City EditorMort Cornin (1915–1984)

    Editorial ConsultantMax Milians (1908-2005

    SecretaryCeil Wolf (1914-2008)

    Editor EmeritaRebecca Kaplan Boroso

    Stop it now, Donald Trump!

    W

    e don’t endorse can-

    didates for politicalofice at the Jewish

    Standard. It would

     be neither wise nor appropriate for

    us to do so. In fact, although each

    one of us has strong feelings both

    in favor of and against some candi-

    dates, we keep those personal feel-

    ings as far as possible from the com-

    munal editorial voice of the paper.

    Okay, sometimes that editorial voice

    is a touch snarky, often it is a little bit

    irst-person, but it’s never ragingly

    partisan about politics.

    But not only has Donald Trump

     broken all the rules, he is making it

    impossible for us not to break one

    as well.We are not going to argue about

    Donald Trump’s policy proposals

    here. We will not argue about his

    extraordinary vulgarity. We are very

    happy for him that he is so thrilled

     with the size of his various body

    parts that he wants to share that joy

     with us. We will avert our eyes and

    move on.

    We will not even argue about the

    flatness of his jokes.

    We cannot ignore the ugliness of

    his attacks on large groups of peo-

    ple — on, say, women’s looks and

    on their tendencies to bleed from

    their whatevers, thus impedingtheir thought processes. We cannot

    ignore his attacks on war prisoners,

     whose courage and ability this battle-

    untested man derides. We cannot

    ignore his attacks on immigrants —

     we here are all the children, grand-

    children, and great grandchildren of

    immigrants who found safe haven in

    this miraculous country.

    We cannot and should not — in

    fact we must not — ignore his hesita-

    tion in refusing the endorsement of

    David Duke and the Ku Klux Klan. Mr.

    Trump said that he knew nothing

    about them, and then, bizarrely, he

    said, “I don’t like to disavow groups

    if I don’t know who they are. I mean,you could have the Federation of

     Jewish Philanthropies in ‘groups.’”

    To which the only possible responseis “What????”

    But now Mr. Trump, at whose

    rallies violence often threatens —

    his crowds are volatile, their emo-

    tions are roiled, and their tempers

    are enflamed — has begun to ask

    his audiences to give a stiff-armed

    salute. The gesture is a pledge to Mr.

    Trump. He is quoted as saying, at

    a North Carolina rally: “Raise your

    right hand. ‘I do solemnly swear that

    I — no matter how I feel, no matter

     what the conditions, if there’s hurri-

    canes or whatever — will vote, on or

     before the 12th, for Donald J. Trump

    for president.’”

    On its face, that is odd. But whenyou look at — when you see videos or

    still shots of this salute — it is chilling.

    It is a Nazi salute.

    Abraham Foxman of Bergen

    County, who survived the Holocaust

    as a small child and retired last sum-

    mer as the longtime head of the Anti-

    Defamation League (see story, page

    26), inds the gesture chilling.

    Mr. Trump “is a great marketing

    person,” Mr. Foxman said. “He put

    his name out there for years, on

     buildings, parks, other enterprises,

    and he is now collecting on what he

    had invested. He is asking for alle-

     giance to his own name.”Did Mr. Trump know the history

    of the gesture he was asking his fol-

    lowers to make?

    “There are two possibilities,” Mr.

    Foxman said. “At best, it is innocent

    and ignorant. If that’s the case, it’s

    pretty sad, that a man who claims

    to be so worldly, so smart, so know-

    ing, doesn’t know what that salute

    means. At worst, he knows exactly

     what it means. That is just such a

     bizarre idea.

    “No matter what he is in the rest of

    his life, he is campaigning as popu-

    list, and populism can morph into

    something worse — into fascism or

    neo-fascism,” he continued.“Mr. Trump has broken so many

    of our taboos,” Mr. Foxman said.

    “There is a social contract, a civilcontract, against insulting people.

    You can say that it’s just political cor-

    rectness, but political correctness is

    a social contract. You may feel a cer-

    tain way, but you don’t say it publi-

    cally. He does.

    “He has broken all the taboos of

     what is acceptable, and he has got-

    ten rewarded for it.

    “The way people are being treated

    at his rallies is frighteningly reminis-

    cent of totalitarian environments,

     where they don’t tolerate other

    points of view.”

    Mr. Foxman sighed. “It makes

    Holocaust survivors quiver even

    earlier than most other people when they see it,” he said. “And

     what’s even more scary than Donald

    Trump are the people who follow

    him. There is so much anger and

    frustration and anxiety and fear in

    the country now, and he is playing

    on all of it.”

    We’re with Mr. Foxman. All parti-

    san issues aside, we know that his-

    tory teaches that breaches of basic

    civility, of the normal rules of con-

    duct, a descent into crudeness, bul-

    lying, and brutishness, is deeply

     bad for society. We all should work

    to stop it now, before it goes any

    further.We are sure that Mr. Trump, as

    loutish as he is, does not think of

    himself as Hitler. He is not asking

    for a Nazi salute because he fancies

    himself a Nazi, or a fascist. In fact,

    he has disavowed any knowledge of

     what the salute might mean, claim-

    ing to be, in Mr. Foxman’s words,

    “innocent and ignorant.”

    “I don’t know about the Hitler

    comparison. I hadn’t heard that,

     but it’s a terrible comparison. I’m

    not happy about that certainly,”

    he said on ABC’s “Good Morning

    America.

    But the emotions he is roiling

    are unhealthy, and he should stop.We should not encourage him. —JP

    KEEPING THE FAITH

    Letter of the law

    A letter to the editor in last week’s issue of the Jewisdard (“Scalia on changing the law”) raises some in

    ing points. I thank its author, Rabbi Gary Karlin, f

    letter because it provides an opportunity to exp

    the discussion begun two weeks ago.

    In my last column, “Scalia would have stewed over a Sh

    staple,” I equated the U.S. Constitution to the “constitution

     Jewish people,” meaning the Torah, and suggested that had

     been a rabbi, and had his view prevailed, “Judaism probably

    have disappeared by now, dead under the heavy weight of i

     words.”

    That is because the late Supreme Court justice believed the

     good Constitution is a dead Constitution,” meaning it is not o

    subjective reinterpretation, whereas Judaism’s ability to sur

    directly related to the Torah being open to just such subjec

    interpretation. Torah law has been able to evolve because it w

    stuck in time and place, and b

    individual rabbis and groups  bis recognized that and acted u

    Karlin, it seems, actually a

     with me on this point. “In th

    chic system,” he wrote, “rabb

    and continue to formulate, wr

    seminate, challenge, and chan

    ish law.”

    In his letter, Karlin argued th

    Torah and the U.S. Constitutio

    little in common. (So did sever

    ple who responded to the Ti

    Israel blog posting, although n

    the kind of reasoned argumen

    lin proffered.)

    The “Jewish legal tradition that got us to [this] point is very

    ent from the American jurisprudence,” he wrote. “Where docomparison between American and Jewish law break down?

    ish law, unlike in American law, there is no separation of pow

    To be fair, what Karlin wrote is correct in fact; Judaism op

    the way he outlined.

    “Rabbis are both judges (dayanim) and halachic authoritie

    kim) who issue rulings,” he wrote. “A rabbi is the inal voice o

    authority in his or her community … and may join others

    ment their authority….

    “For millennia, there has been no formal, authoritative

    congress legislating laws. No Jewish chief executive. No su

     Jewish court. Just individual rabbis, working to keep Jewish

    evant and real….”

    That is the system we have, but it is not the system we were

    If not for the system we were given, the system we have pro

    never would have come to be.

    Shammai Engelmayer is the rabbi of Congregation Beth Isrthe Palisades in Cliffside Park.

    20JEWISH STANDARD MARCH 11, 2016

     RabbiShammai

     Engelmayer 

  • 8/19/2019 Jewish Standard, March 11, 2016

    21/56

    Opinion

    That is a head-spinning statement, to be sure, but

    perhaps it will make sense as we address some of the

    rabbi’s speciic points.

    It is true; there is no separation of powers in the

    current Jewish legal system. That, however, is the

    consequence of history. Originally, Israel was to be

    ruled by three “branches”: king, priest, and prophet.

    Each had his role to play. That is why a prophet,Nathan, could stand before the mighty King David

    and proclaim him guilty of horrendous crimes. In

    any eastern court then and for many centuries after,

    the man who so accused the king would quickly have

    his head separated from his shoulders. In Israel, it

     was the king who had to bow to the prophet’s judg -

    ment. (See 2 Samuel 12.)

    Eventually, Israel was exiled, prophecy ceased, the

    Temple was destroyed (twice), and there no longer

     were kings, priests, or prophets to govern. There was

    a power vacuum, and the rabbis illed it.

    How did they get the authority to do so? Aside

    from creating a direct line from Moses to themselves

    (see Pirkei Avot, Chapter 1), they took several verses

    from the Torah and reinterpreted them in their own

    favor. (See Deuteronomy 17:914.) They could do

    so because the Torah is subject to reinterpretation when the need arises.

    Karlin did allow that “[p]erhaps one can claim that

     Jewish communities, and in a broader sense, k’lal Yis-

    rael, the Jewish people as a whole, balance rabbinic

    authority,” but in practical terms, that is not the case.

    But it is supposed to be.

    To begin with, according to black letter Jewish

    law, rabbis, by acting in concert, can even stand the

    Torah on its head, if by doing so they would bring

    people closer to the Torah and to God.

    Maimonides, the Rambam, states this concept

    clearly. In his Mishneh Torah volume Rebels [Mam-

    rim] (2:4), he says of the rabbis: “If they should

    conclude that it is necessary to suspend a positive

    [Torah] commandment or nullify a negative one in

    order to restore the people to the faith or to savemany Jews from otherwise becoming lax in matters

    [of observance], they may act as the needs of the

    time require.”

    By this, the Rambam means that if a clear major-

    ity of the People Israel have abandoned observance

    of a particular God-given commandment, the rabbis

    have the power (perhaps even the duty) to suspend

    that commandment temporarily, rather than see the

    entire halachic system plummet down a slippery

    slope. (Does putting a string around Route 4 really

    create a “private domain” allowing people to carry

    on Shabbat? The eruv’s purpose is to provide a way

    for people to do what they would do in any case —

    carry on Shabbat — without thinking they are violat-

    ing Shabbat by doing so. Otherwise, they might start

    to ignore other Shabbat rules.)

    Fi