Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

18
Biomass Energy Centre Opportunities for land managers to enter the bioenergy supply chain West Midlands Bioenergy Conference December 2008

description

2008 West Midlands Bioenergy Conference Harper Adams University College

Transcript of Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Page 1: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Biomass Energy Centre

Opportunities for land managers to enter

the bioenergy supply chain

West Midlands Bioenergy Conference

December 2008

Page 2: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Aim of the presentation

• Give an overview of biomass fuel types

• Describe the basics of the biomass

market

• Brief description of perennial energy

Crops

• Brief description of anaerobic digestion

• Give details of where to get further

information

Page 3: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Biomass as a fuel

• Logs and wood chips

from woodlands

• Miscanthus and SRC

• Sawdust and off cuts

from wood processing

• Dry agricultural

residues - straw

• Food wastes, slurries

• Oil seed crops and

cereals for liquid biofuel

production

Page 4: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

How is biomass being used?

• Most common application is heat production

using woodchips, logs or pellets

• Typical scale is between 100 - 1000kW

(around 2000 installations at present)

• Generally a single boiler in a single building

• Growing interest and application of ‘district

heating’ systems

• Industrial scale co-firing and ‘biomass only’

power generation (~6 biomass only power

stations in operation, ~12 planned)

Page 5: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Forestry Commission’s Strategy

• 2 million tonnes of

woodfuel from

privately owned,

undermanged

woodland

• Equivalent to

250,000 homes

worth of energy

Page 6: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

How can I supply this market?

• Use thinnings, poor quality trees

• Allow to dry ‘in the round’

• Chip using a woodfuel grade chipper

• Keep chips dry - make sure they match

boiler specification and follow industry

standards

Page 7: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Drying round wood prior to chipping

Page 8: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Producing good quality chips• Use a woodfuel grade

chipper - inconsistent

chip size can block

augers

• Moisture content is

critical

• CEN standards

developed for use

across Europe

• Chippers are

expensive - consider

hiring in unless you

have large quantities

to process

Page 9: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Is woodchip competitive with

other fuels?

• Market price varies considerably £50 - £90 per

tonne delivered typical

• Price of oil ~4.0p per kWh (@ 40p per litre)

• Gas price currently around ~ 4.0p per kWh

• 1 tonne of 30% MC woodchips contains 3500

kWh of energy

• Paying anything less than £120 per tonne of

chips is competitive with oil and gas at today’s

prices

Page 10: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Wood chip production costs

Variations in the cost of producing woodchips

0

20

40

60

80

100

system

1

system

2

system

3

system

4

system

5

system

6

system

7

system

8

system

9

system

10

system

11

system

12

co

st

per

ton

ne

Page 11: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Adding value - selling heat

• ‘Energy Supply Company’

(ESCo)

• Attractive to end users -

they do not have to worry

about sourcing fuel

• User billed according to

kWh of heat used - recorded

by a ‘heat meter’

• Watch out for ‘heat

incentive’ - being developed

now.

Page 12: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Capital cost

• Biomass systems often much more expensive than

fossil fuel counterparts

• DECC ‘bioenergy capital grant’

• Aimed at ‘industrial and community sectors that are

considering investing in biomass-fuelled heat

and/or combined heat and power projects,

including anaerobic digestion’

• Covers ‘up to 40% of the difference in the cost of

installing biomass…..compared to fossil fuel

alternative’. Max single award £500k

• www.bioenergycapitalgrants.org.uk

Page 13: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Energy Crops

• Generally refers to willow short rotation

coppice and Miscanthus

• Energy Crop Scheme grant available via

Natural England - 40% of establishment cost

• Generally associated with larger scale power

plants (E.ON at Lockerbie, SembCorp in the

North East, Eccleshall West Mids) or co-firing

• Some examples of small scale heat in the

region (Lionel Hill)

• Economics investigated by NNFCC

Page 14: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Short Rotation Coppice

• Plant spring year 1

• Cutback winter year

1-2

• Harvest every 3

years

• Yields 8 odt per ha

per year

• Needs specialised

harvester and

planter

Page 15: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Miscanthus• Plant spring year 1

• 1st harvest winter year

2 -3

• Annual harvest there

after (usually baled)

• Yields ~ 10 odt ha yr

from year 3

• Similar to a

conventional

agricultural crop

• Eccleshall in W.

Midlands

Page 16: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Anaerobic digestion

• Uses animal slurries, food waste, sewage

sludge, maize or grass silage to generate

‘Biogas’ (methane and carbon dioxide)

• Gas powers combustion engine, end

products are power and heat

• Could earn tradeable ‘renewable energy

certificates’

• Digestate could be used as a soil

conditioner - properties dependant on

feedstock

Page 17: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

In conclusion

• Biomass is an established fuel and is here

to stay

• Can be economically viable

• Matching fuel quality to the end market is

paramount

• Can use existing resources or dedicated

crops

Page 18: Ian Tubby Bioenergy Supply Chain

Sources of information• Biomass Energy Centre

www.biomassenergycentre.org.uk

• Forestry Commission

www.forestry.gov.uk/england-woodfuel

• Heartwoods

www.heartwoods.co.uk

• Marches wood energy network

www.mwen.org.uk

• Bioenergy West Midlands

www.bioenergywm.co.uk

• West midlands woodland & forestry forum

www.growingourfuture.org

• National Non Food Crop Centre

www.nnfcc.co.uk