I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I '...

13
j ; .. ' " i ' 1, 1 ' j :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l J I! I . . \ . f ' .·, I ; . ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1J<'lt'>a"<JOOU m>3oll::J'llc::>01J 0>63om>t'>aIJ o61Jooo:xio aob: mooc::>olJo, ><::>. 0 t'>o5MQW"'3o1J.N3 ,· .. oQ 0 'b>36,m 2020 V<:!'OIJ 16 o.>63t'>olJ o>61\o6Qo> IJIJoJ IJ>d>t'>m3Q<:!'<'llJ QM<'l36't'.J<:!'0 >t'>do301J IJ>>3Qc::>>OO<'l lJ>llo3;t'>m;6 Q?>J>3oot'>om. 12 '1J't'.JMO<:!'>I!?· IJ,daa N 33031001soo2657632 IJ>d8a N35/1559-19 m,a,t'> a,olJ't'.)t'>>da 0.. ' mboc::>olJolJ IJ»3ac::>>oo IJ > >t'>m Mil >w80601Jot'>>oo't'.I<:!' IJ>d8Qm> 3><::>>QOU 8MIJ>8> ffi<:!'OIJ 0»6>0Q8VQ m5oc::>o1JolJ IJ>>Jac::>>oo<'l IJ;IJ,a,t'>mc::><'l .1 d,m5oc::>o1Jo, 0 t'>.t'>M5>dodo1J 0 >8'b. N7> 0159; one::>: 51.85.21/22/23; '1J>d1Jo: 51.87.11; 3a5·?,:JQM(!?O: www.tbappeal.court.ge; Q<:!'· '1J<'lUo>: tbappeal@court.ge - . 1 ' ? '· I ! ' i I,

Transcript of I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I '...

Page 1: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

j; .. ' " i ' 1,

1 '

j :\ JI 1 ,1

L l j l JI! I • • .

. \ . f ' .·, I ; . ' 1 ,I

1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613

03.02.2020 vac::>o

1

;,oJ 00'1J<'lt'>a"<JOOU m>3oll::J'llc::>�01J 0>63om>t'>a�IJ o61Jooo:xio

aob: mooc::>olJo, ><::>. 0t'>o5MQW"'3o1J.N3

,· ..

oQ0'b>36�,m 2020 V<:!'OIJ 16 o.>63t'>olJ o>61\o6Qo> IJIJoJ IJ>d>t'>m3Q<:!'<'llJ QM<'l36't'.J<:!'0 >t'>do301J IJ>>3Qc::>>OO<'l lJ>llo3;t'>m;6 Q?>J>3oot'>�om. 12 '1J't'.JMO<:!'>I!?·

IJ,daa N 33031001soo2657632 IJ>d8a N35/1559-19

m,a,t'> a,olJ't'.)t'>>da 0.. ' mboc::>olJolJ IJ»3ac::>>oo IJ > >t'>m Mil >w80601Jot'>>oo't'.I<:!' IJ>d8Qm> 3><::>>QOU 8MIJ>8> ffi<:!'OIJ 0»6>0Q8VQ

m5oc::>o1JolJ IJ>>Jac::>>oo<'l IJ;IJ,a,t'>mc::><'l .1 d,m5oc::>o1Jo, 0t'>.t'>M5>dodo1J 0>8'b. N•7> 0159; one::>: 51.85.21/22/23; '1J>d1Jo: 51.87.11;

3a5·?,:JQM(!?O: www.tbappeal.court.ge; Q<:!'· '1J<'lUo>: [email protected]

- •. 1

' ? '·

I ! '

i I,

Page 2: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

N°330310018002657632 b,naa No3-o-ISS9-19

2).)6Ro6or>.) b>d><'i0>3D<::'"'" boba<::>om

16 0>63,<'io, 2020 vn<::>o

rooo<::>obob u»aa<::>•oo"' u,u,a.<'im<::>"'" ,wao6obo<'i•oo::i<::> bod8aro, 3><::>>o>

;

8MU>8>MO><::'D' b>QO;>M\!?>'t,0830<::'0 . .

.>3a<::>>6QO (8M3>U::Jba) - bbo3 U>d>MO>Jac::'MU a"'M36::J<::'O >Mjo30 \)o<'i8M8>\!?W6n<::>o - 1>0MM1>0 UM\'JMM8oaa. dnma3>6 jM<'ioaa

8M\)06»1:?awnw ab,<'ia (8Mbo<'iRn<::>nl 1>>6300,o<'inoob o6booo�o \)o<'i8M8>11?W6n<::>o - 6o6M 8a<'iall>il30<::>0-\'300DM

iHlliill II IIII II 1111 � 0001126470067183

d· 0>00<::'000

. ,

1>>boR03<'iall::J<::>O 1>>11?>V�3noo<::'all, O>OCJ<1:'.'0UOU b•d><::>>dM b;b,8;<',o,<::'"'" ,wao6obo<'i>oo::i<::> b,jaaro, J"'<::'81,000 2019 v<::>ob 04 ;JMO<::>OU 1,>W>li�3DOO<::'Dll>

Page 3: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

;J<'>o<;::>ob o>Q?>\iH30t'JO(;'.'.'OOOOJ, >(>)oJ 06'1J!"lM8>(lOOb m>3ob::J'IJ<;'.'.'OOOb 1>>63om><'>ooob o6bt')ot'J::it'Job b><'>Ro<;::>o (!/>J8>H<'l'IJO<;'.'.'(!/>- (!?>03><;::>> 8<'lJ>b::ibob - bboJ b>d><'>m30<;::>01b 0<'>(')36::J<;::> ><'>do3b, >(>)oJ 06'1J!"lM8>(lOOU m>3ob::J'IJ<;'.'.'OOOU 1>>63om><'>ooob o6bt')ot'J::it'Job 2018 \')<;::>ob 29 036obob FOI06/18-001 1>>6(lb>(!?QOOOJ (<'>ooobt')<'>>(lOOU OJ>MO(:!O: 04.07.2018\j .• <'>ooobt')M>(lOOU N85834) 8<'l0Jb<'l360<;::>o 06'1JC'lM8>(lOOU o>Goa,.

1.2.1. 2018 \i<;::>Ob 29 036obb >(>)oJ o6'1JC'lM8>(lOOb m>3ob::i'IJ<;'.'.'OOOU 1>>63om><'>ooob o6bt')ot'J::it'J8> N•FOI06/18-001 1>>6(lb>(!?QOOOJ (<'>01,obt')M>(lOOb OJ>MOl:!O: 04.07.2018 \io<;::>o, <'>ooobt')<'>>ooob N85834) 808,<'>m> bboJ b>d><'>m30<;::><'lb QMC'l36::J<;::>O ><'>do3ob b>,c>M<'l 06'1JC'lM8>(lOOlJ 1>>008>'bo Joll::iboll8o000<;::> Jo<'>b (!/> 8C'lo0Jb<'l3> aoawooo 06'1JC'lM8>(lOOlJ o>Go8>: I. 2013 \j<;::>oll 1 0063<'>ow>6 Q?l:!08Q?O (\i<;::>ooolJ 8obow3om (l><;::>-(l><;::> JO), 833<;::>03><'>ooolJ MOC'l(!/Q6C'lo>, MC'l8<;::>ooll>(l omd3>m ::i><'>o bo83omb3Q(;'.'.'<'l Q?><'>oo'boo w>o3oo>'bo oo6t'J<'>><;'.'.':J<'> (!/0 <'>oooC'l6::J<;::> ><'>do30000 (><'>do3olJ aomomoooOJ (!/> 8J3<;::>03><'>olJ 8<'ld><;::>>do!"loolJ 8omomooom); 2. 2013 \i<;::>oll 1 0063<'>0(!?>6 Q?l:!08Q?O (\i<;::>ooolJ

· 8obow3om (l><;'.'.':(l><;'.'.'JO) mo8>t')o3olJ/lJ»<'>do3C'l 'IJC'l6(.\?QoOlJ R>8C'lfom3><;::>o, M<'l8<;::>oo'boo S(:!6006::J<;::>8> 8J3(;'.'.'Q3>MQ080 o»JOOJQlJ 0>6>(lb>(!?O ><'>00300 8::JOSC'lo>'bQ; 3. OJOOJC'lQ'CJ(;'.'.' JC'l6J<'>Ot'J::J(;'.'.' 008mb303>'bo 8.33<;::>03><'>olJm3olJ ::i><'>olJ md8olJ O::JMO(!?O::J(;'.'.'O ll>'IJ::ia30<;::>o.

1.2.2. lJboJ ll>d><'>m3Q<;::>C'llJ 0<'>'"36::J<;::> ><'>do3ll, >(>)oJ o6'1J!"lM8>(lOOlJ m>3oll::J'IJ(;'.'.'OOOb 1>>63om><'>ooolJ o6llt')ot'J::it'Job 2018 \i<;'.'.'Oll 29 036olJolJ N°FOI06/18-00i 1>>6ob>(!?QOOOJ a'""'b'"3o<;::>o o6'1J<'l<'>a,Go, ><'> 1>>::ioo,.

. . 1.3. Q?>ll336300 ll,8,<'>m<;::>30<'>03 00<'>38<'l3031>m,o Q?>J>300<'>:J1>om

1.3.1. ll>d><;::>>o'" lloll>8><'>m<;::>'"8 80::imom>, <'>'"8 ll>d><'>m30<;::>'"ll JC'l6lJt')ot'J::iGoolJ ao-18 8::Jb<;::>oll 80-2 Q?> ao-3 J::i6dt'JooolJ m>fob8>Q?, H30<;::>>ll od3lJ ::J'll<;::>Oo> J>6!"l6om Q?><:!?1>060<;::>o \iollom 0>oG6'"lJ !Jax><'>'" Q?>\iolloo::i<;::>oo>oo a,lJ'b3 ><'>lloo::J<;::> 06 lib 3, 06'1J01<'>8>oo>b 06 C'l'IJO(lOO(;'.'.'::JM (!/C'lJ::J8o6t'Jll, o><'>Q?> oa 008mb303ob>, MC'l(!/Qll>(l 01>0 0000>3ll JC'l8QM(l0::J(;'.'.' ,6 OMC'l'IJQbO::J(;'.'.' ll>o(!?::J8(;'.'.'C'lQO>lJ ;6 (!?QB<'lJM>t'JO::J(;'.'.' lJo'bC'loO(!/C'lQO>clo >::J(lO(;'.'.'QOQ(;'.'.'O b>bo<;::>8\jo'IJ<'l ,6 ll>'b!"lo>(!/C'lQO<'>c>30 . ::Jb>'IJf>mbC'loo�lJ >6 ll>8><'>m><;::>\i><'>8<'looolJ 06t')3<'>oll3oolJ Q?>b>(l>3>Q? 306!"l6om >6 J>6C'l6om Q?><:!?1>060<;::>o ljo!Joor >(:!O><'>oo::J(!'.'O> bob o<;::>8\jo'IJC'l lJ>O\.\?'C)8(!'.'C'lQO>(!/. C'l'IJO(lOO(;'.'.'::JM Rofo\io<'>oooo ><'>lloo::i<;::>o 06'1J!"lM8>(lO>. MC'l8 Q(!'.'O(l Q?>J>300<'>00::i<;::>o> ,w,ao,6olJ x ;68<'>mo<;::>C'loollm>6, 'IJOfo6lloom>6 >6 bb3> Jo<'>>(!? llo3omboom,6, ,<'>,3ollm3olJ ::J6(!?> OH'"" bo<;::>8ollo\j3(!?!"l80 m3om ,a >(!?>8o,6olJ m>6b8!"loolJ 1>><'>000, o>M(!/0 J>6!"l600J 1>>m3"""ollljo600::i<;::>o 038mb333oooll,, MC'l(!?Qll>(l oil >::J(lO(;'.'.'QOQ(;'.'.'O> bob3<;::>8\jo'IJC'l >6 lJo'b<'lo>(!/<'lQOM03_'.) ::ib>'iJMOJbC'l3oolJ ::i'b<'>::i633<;::>ll>H'"'ll'<:!?· ll>x><'><'l 06t'Jo<'>obo1>oll. =: 1>��6 W30�> ::J'll<;::>Ooooob Q?>ll>(l>3>(!?- � -- ->: ,, '\ � �7 .---.._ \.

·.d I , -,-\ ll>d><'>OJ30(;'.'.'<'lll JC'l6lJt')ot')::J(lOOOJ <'>01><;::>>836t')o<'>oo�f \; "::�(')� '.�?6'1J<'lM8>(lOOb

(�:., - -�� 2 ' . -

Page 4: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

bo<::>Bob>\]3Q?M8Moob 'boBM><:!6006::1<::>o 'bMo>wo J<'m5Go3o JM5J<'>o('.>o'bo<'>oo::i<::>o> b>d><'>m30<::>Mb 'bMo>wo >w8o6ob{'.><'>>GO::J<:'.'0 JMWOdbob Bo-3 m>3om (.,06\')MMB>GoOb m>3ob::J\'J<:'.'OO>"). ><:!6006::1<::>o m>3ob 28-o a::ib<::>o oBoM<'>oob JM6b('.>06::1Go::1<'> 6M<'>B,b, MMB b>x ><'>M 06\')MMB>GO> <:!O», o><'>w> J>6M6om 1,>m3><::>ob\]0600::i<::>o 00Bmb303ooob; w> w>wo060<::>o \]obom bobo<::>B\]o\')M, JMBo<'>GO::J<:'.'0 ,6 OM<'l\'JObO::J<:'.'0 b>nw::1B<::>MOOObm3ob ,6 Jo<'>bMfo<::>::i<'>o BMfoG0Booobm3ob Bo3::im3600::i<::>o 06\')MMfoGOOb>. ,a,30 b>3>6M6Bwoo<::>M >d('.>ob 37-o B::ib<::>ob 30<'>30<::>o fo\]o<::>ob o,;fobB>w, S30<::>>b >d3b ::J\'l<:'.'OO> BMombM3Mb b>x><'>M 06\')M<'>B>GO> Bobo \'JO'bo3::i<'>o \'JM<'>Bob, w> aofob3ob BQ?1,MB><'>0Moob ao::ibow>3,w W" >o<'>RoMb b>x><'>M 06\'JM<'>B>GOOb Bo<:!ooob \')MMB>, O>::J OoO bb3,w,bb3> boboco ><'>booMob, >1,<'>om30 1,>0G6Mb 05\'JMMfoGo>b wow>6oo. O>::J ><'>booMob wow5ob w>'bo>6ooob b>\')<'>mbo, b>x><'>M <s>>\]oboo::i<::>oo> 3"<:'.'Q?OO:'.J<:'.'O> ::i'b<'>::1630<::>sMb 'bow>Bbo<s>30<:'.'MOOb d300 Bobo 1,,06Moob oob>d<::>oo<::>MOj ,6 \]><'>::iwao6Mb b,m,foQ?M \]oboo, w>BM\]Boo::J<:'.'0 >b<::>o. >8>30 JMWOdbob 38-o B::ib<::>o >wo06b, <'>MB b>x><'>M w>\loboo::i<::>oo> 3><:'.'WOO::J<:'.'O" ::i'b<'>::1630<::>sMb b>x><'>M 06\')MMO>Goob >b<::>ooob bo<::>Bob>\]3Q?MBM0>. <s>>::J0300Q<::>O> <s>>\]obwob <'>>oBo bcbob U>\')>b::i<'>o b>x><'><'> 06\')<'lMO>GOOb 0>00Bob>m3ob, o><'>w> >b<::>ob 1,><s>><:!ooob>m3ob "::JGO<:'.'QOQ<:'.'0 o,;6bob >fo'b<:!>::i<'>ooob,.

b;b;fo<'>m<::>MB >bo30 80':'.)(J)OO)j bbo6oi'>::J<::>o b>3>6M6Bwoo<:'.'<'l >d('.>ob Bo-40 8::Jb<::>'bo, MMB<::>ob 30<'>30<::>o fo\]o<::>O >w1,06b, MMB b>x><'>M <s>>\]oboo::i<::>oo> 3"<:'.'WOO:'.J<:'.'O> o>bGob b>x><'>M 05\'JMMB>GO>, acco oe,<'iob, o<::>od6<'>M6::J<:'.'O \'JM<'>Bom 8MmbM360<::>o b>x><'><'> 06\'JM<'>B>Go>, w>::JsM35oo<::>03 ,6 ""'" ::iwo>6ob 10 w�b,, m::i b>x><'>M 06\'JM<'>B,Goob 8MmbM3fo'bo Job::ibob o>Goa, BM00>bM3b: o) bb3> w>b>b<::>oo::i<::> J::16d('.>clo ><'>boo::i<::>o Bobo b6<'>::id6::i<'>::i<::>o d3o<s>>fosM\'JOQ?>6 ,6 bb3, b>x><'>M <s>>\]oboo::i<::>ooow>6 06\'JM<'>B>GOOb BMdooo>b> w> w>B::10>3oo>b; o) 8600360<::>M3>60 8MG::J<:'.'MOOb o<'>m8>6omm,6 w>::13>300<'>000<::>o G"<:'.'JO::J<:'.'0 Q?MJ::J8066ooob BMdooo>b> w> w>B::10>3oo>b; 1,) bbgo w>b>b<::>oo::i<::> J::16d('.>ao ><'>boo::i<::> Bob b6<'>::id6::i<'>::i<::> d3o<s>>fosM\'Jm>6 ,6 bb,;i> b>;,s;;,<'>M <s>>\]oboo::i<::>oo>bm>6 JM6b::J<::>6>Go>b. ao-2 fo\]o<::>ob o,;foba,w. m;j b>x><'>M .. ob'/iei<'>B>G<iob

. c- o>G0Bob,m3ob b>Jo<'>M> -10 Q?<:!0>6o 3>w>, b>x><'>M <s>>\]oboo::i<::>oo> 3"<:'.'WOO::J<:'.'O> 8MmbM36obm>fo30 >G6MOMb caob oob>boo 1,>68Gb>wooo<::>b. Bo-3 fo\]o<::>ob oob>o>Bob>w JO, b>x><'>M 06\'JM<'>B,oo_ob 3<'>M>d6o::i<:P><s> 1,>8Md30s600> ""' >m>3ob::1\'l<::'OOb b>x><'>M <s>>\]oboo::ic::>oo>b 08>30 ,6 bb3> b>x><'>M 06\'JM<'>B,ooob 8MmbM36ob 00Bmb303>00 Bobo <s>><s>oo6oc::>o \]obom o>GoBob 3><::>Q?OO::J<::'Ooob1,>6.

b,b,a,<'>m<::>MB 1,068><'>6>, MM8 b>x><'>M 06\'JM<'>B,ooob <:'.'Oo"<::'::J<'> WO\'J060GO>b od<::>03> b>d><'>m30<::>Mb 'bM1,>Q?O >wB06ob('.><'>>GO::J<:'.'O JMWOdbob ao-2 B::ib<::>ob Jo<'>3oc::>o fo\]o<::>ob .,B'' d30J::16d60, MMB<::>ob oob>o>Bob,w, b>x><'>M 06\')MMB>GO> ><'>ob <'l\'JOGO><::>::i<'>o Q?MJ::JBo66o (dom OM<'iob, fob;'bo, a,3060, 1,01,a,, bdoB>, \')M{'.)Mb::J<'>>mo, O<::'Od6<'>M6::J<::>O --- 06\')MMB>GO>, 30Q?QM- <!;>> "::JQ?OM8>fo\]o<'>ooo), >6::i b>x><'>M sl)>\]ob6o::i<i:>oo>oo W"G::J<:'.'0,

/ ' >1,<'>om30 b>x><'>M Q?>\]oboo::ic::>ooob ,6 8Mb>Bb>b::JMOb Bqo<'> b,ab,b::1<'>00<'>03 '/,.,/ / -. I b>d8o,6Mo>bm,6 <s>>J>300<'>0000, ao<:!oo=o, w>B::10>300=�· ood86o<::>o >6 o"o 'b,360<::>0

06\'JM<'>B>co>, ,bo30 b>x><'>M <s>>\]oboo=ooob Boo<'> J4i&d6o:S<::>>w 1,>BMd3os600::i<::>o _,_

3

Page 5: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

06\')C'leJaa(lO>. ,awofow, MC'loC'lM(l >1:?6006:,<::>o a:,b<::>ob 'ilofoo<'ibo (lb>\!?8C'l\'JU, ,wao6obo<'i>(lO::J(!'.'O J>6C'l6aw30(!'.'C'lOO b>x><'iC'l 06\')C'lMaa(lOOU 1>>C33aob 3>(!'.'\!?30::J(!'.'3000 b:,003d6>\!? b>x><'iC'l w>\J3b30:,(!'.'3o>b aooR633b 8b<'l(!'.'<'l\!? bsx><'iC'l w>\J3b30:,(!'.'30>00 \!?>(l::J(!'.', >1><'i3m33, b>x><'i<'l w>\J3b30:,(!'.'30,ao ,6 aC'lb,ab,b:,<'iob ao3<'i b,ab,b:,<'i3o<'io3 badaoo5C'l00Uffi05 \!?>J>3ooe,3oom ao\:?30::J(!'.'O, \!?,a::J0>331>::J(!'.'O, 03da60(!'.'0 06 o>o 'bo360(!'.'0 06\')<'lMa,(loOb - C'l\')0(300(!'.'::JMO \!?<'lJ::Ja36oob aoa,<'im.

1.3.2. 1>>5bobo<::>30<::' 03amb333,oo aC'lbo<'iR3(!'.'3 ombM3b aC'l3>b:,b3 - bbo3 b>d><'im33(!'.'C'lU 3<'i<'l36:,<::>o ><'ido3obm3ob, 2018 \J<::>ob 29 036obob N°F0106/18-001 0>5(lb>w3oom (<'i31>obo<'i>C300U m>MOl:?O: 04.07.2018 153<::'0, <'i31>obo<'i>C300U N85834) aMmbC'l360(!'.'0 06\')<'lMa,(lOOU 1>>(l3aob w>3><::>31>ob.

l>obaaa<'im(!'.'<'la ao:,mom> ,,3<'iC'l36=0 bo><'ido3<'> \'3C'l6\!?0UO \!?> 3<'i<'l36::J(!'.'O ><'ido3ob 03bob30" l>,J,<'im33(!'.'C'lb 306Cl6'b3, <'i<'la3<::>0G 006b>'b1:?3<'i,3b 3<'iC'l36:,<::>o l>»<'ido3C'l \'3C'l6wob, \!?> b>d><'im33(!'.'C'lU 3<'iC'l36::J(!'.'O o<'ido3ol> b,a,<'im(!'.'3o<'io3 bo>o:,bl>, 3'""'36::J(!'.'O l>»<'ido3C'l \'3C'l6\!?ob,m3ob \!?C'lJ::Ja3603ool> ao3:,m363oob 3<'io6(lo33ob, ascco \!?>(330b, \!?> o>aC'l8363oob l>o3omb3ob. >1:?6006:,<::>o J>6C'l6ol> a3-3 a:,b(!'.'OU 3o<'i33(!'.'0 3:,6doob msfobfow, 3<'i<'>36:,<::>o b»<'ido3C'l \'J<'l6\!?0 s<'iob b>d><'im33(!'.'<'lU 63<'iooC'l<'ioo'b3 s<'ib30:,<::>o of \!?<'>J::Ja3603oob (1>>6::J<'iR33<::>>\!? Bocoo aoo><'i30(!'.'0U bob3Moob>) 3<'im<'lO(!'.'OC'lOO, eJC'l8(!'.'3ob>(l >d3m OUQC'lMO::J(!'.'O, '"3<::'01>0::JMO, a3(3603<'i::J(!'.'O, 3C'l(!'.'OQOJ::JMO, 3J<'>6C'l80J::JMO, J::J<::'6::J'"::J<::'0, bob3�\Jo\'JC'l 06/w> bo'b<'lo0\!?C'l30M030 l:?OMOO::J(!'.'300. 3<'i<'>36::J(!'.' U»Md03C'l \')C'l6\!?U >oM3ffi33 8033:,m3630> bb3> bob3(!'.'a\)o\'JC'l3000 \!?>(l::J(!'.'O \!?C'lJ::Ja360300, MC'la(!'.'300(3 b>d><'im33(!'.'<'ll> b,3<'im>o<'>MOUC'l b3(!'.'03J'"::J<::'30300U mofoba,w :,5w, w>:,o<'i:,5wol> >5 o>wa<'loCJO" "'D°'"°'33<::'C'lb. - - - - -- -

,a,33 b>3>6C'l6aw30(!'.'C'l >doob a3-6 a:,b<::>ob Jo<'i33(!'.'o 3:,6doob mofoba,w, b>d><'im33(!'.'<'>00 b»<'ido3C'l boda3b a,<'im,3b \!?> badaol>\)o<'ia<'l3oob UM::J(!'.'8C'l\'J>U> \!?> 3<'i<'l36::J(!'.'O b»<'ido3<'l \'JC'l6\!?ob 1>>63om,<'i3oob :,'b<'i:,633(!'.'8C'l\'JU bodo<'im33(!'.'C'lU o:,booCJOOU b,ao6ol>o<'iC'lb (038\!?o<'laoo - b,ao5obo<'iC'l) aa,<'im33(!'.'C'loOb U\'J3M<'>00 03aa3>(!'.'0 "'X''"('l b,a,<'im(!'.'OU O::JCJO\!?O::J(!'.'O ,>OMO - _b>d><'im33(!'.'C'lb 3M<'l36':'.J(!'.'O ><'ido30 (cl3a\!?o<'l800 - 3MC'l36::J(!'.'O ><'ido30). a3-2 3:,6doob 03baooaol>>\!?, 3<'i<'l36':'.J(!'.'O ><'ido30 :,'b<'i:,633(!'.'8<'>\'JU 3<'i<'>36::J(!'.'O - · b»<odo3C'l \'JC'l6\!?ob 033b31>,b, \!?<'lJ::Ja3603oob m6o<'i>(!'.'O'b31>:,<::> >1:?MOC3b3,b (Ber» OC'leJOU, 3<::'3d6<'i<'>5::J(!'.'O \'3C'leJ8om), '!:?VO'"'"· 3'"C'l36::J(!'.'O b»<'ido3C'l \'JC'l5\!?ol> \!?<'lJ::Ja3603oob 3<::'3d6M<'>5::J(!'.'O o,'bob \'3C'l<'iao<'i30,b \!?> Bob a:,wao3 1>>fob<::>3il>l>, wo'bo,630:,<::>o \!?<'lJ::Ja3603oob JC'l6b3<'i3>C30>-<'i3b6>3<'i>(lO>b \!?" 1>>6l>o3:,m<'i30:,<::>o l:?0M30':'.J(!'.'300U ad<'>63 \!?<'>J::Ja3663ilobom3ob b>w>'b!:!333C'l \'3"'5\!?ob a3dafob, 3<'i<'l36:,<::>o b»<'ido3C'l \'JC'l5\!?ob \!?C'lJ::J836031>m,6 m,3ob:,\'l>(!'.' w,0331>,l> bod><'im33(!'.'C'lU J05C'l58w30(!'.'C'lOOOJ \!?'\!?1>350(!'.' \'J>Mo(!'.'3000; 3<'i<'l36::J(!'.'O ><'ido30 3<'i<'>36:,,::,o b>o<'ido3<'l \'3<'>5\!?0ll \!?<'lJ::Ja3603oob 0,a"'83631>om ,a'b,w31>b il::JJ<::>363ill>, o<'i<'>o:,<'i3ol>, bb3,w>b��bob 0,a<'l(l3a31>b (Ssco OC'lMOU, 3<::'3d6<'i<'l5::J(!'.'O 8o0o<'i30(!'.'0U bcboco). b>d>MO):JQ(!'.'C'lU 3>6M6aw30(!'.'C'lOOOJ

J�,- / W'\!?o35o<::>o \53bom Sccco 03aw0C'l8o <'i3><::>o'b>(loob ::J\'l<::'3ijom.'_ 83-3 3:,5doob mofobaaw I ! '<... ,

JO, 3<'i<'>36:,<::> ><'ido3b >d3l> 3MC'l36':'.J<::'o l>»<'ido3Cl \'J<'l5\!?ob \2':!J::Ja3603oob (Bcco aC'l<'iob, -�

lf - v "v �� 4

Page 6: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

3<'><'>3&cJ<::> bo,<'>jo3<'> 'IJ<'>6Q?OO ,<'>b30:J<::>0 J=o'J<'>=o 838330!;!?<'>3<'>oob doo<::>�ob) O(!?MOGb3ob, Q?OG3obo Q?O 03fob3ob boba<::>8\Jo'IJ<'> J<'>60<'><'><::>obo Q?O 'b3wo8b3Q?3D<::>e,oob 'J'll(!'.'DOO, oo&cJ<'>R33(!'.'>Q? 800,0 03fob3ob "Wo<><::'OUO.

bob"8o<'>m<::><'>8 ob333 80:Jmomo •• 3<'>e,3&cJ<::>o bo,<'>jo3e, '1Je,6wobo wo 3<'>e,36:)(!'.'0 o<'>do3ob 03bob30" boj,<'>m33(!'.'(')U 3,6e,6ob 22-o 8:)b(!'.'OU 30<'>33<::> 3::i6dO'bo, M<'l8(!'.'0U mofob8,w 3<'><'>36:J(!'.'O b»<'>do3<'l '13(')6Q/ob Q?<'>J:)8360oomo6 woo3300 mo3ob:J'130(!'.'00, oo<'>wo 08 8:)b(!'.'OU 83-4 3:J6dOomo Q?O "8 306e,6ob 23-o 8:Jb(!'.'OU 30<'>33(!'.'o 3::i6dOom 1,om30(!'.'0b\jo630::i<::>o 038mb3333oobo. w>o603<'>3b30= 3o<'>b 03:)d(!'.'OO b>n6'13<'lM80GO(')­ bodo3oe, bobOa8ob 83033<'>000, 8e,d306<'lb wo 1,0QGOOU 3<'><'>36:)(!'.'0 b»<'>do3e, '13(')6Q?OU we,3:J5360b 06 8ob 3o<'>b, 0»33=b Q?eJJ:)8360ow"6 "8e,fo\j3<'>0 wo obo<'>o30<::>eJb 3<'>e,36:)(!'.'0 o<'>jo3ob b>n6'1Je,M8"GO(') 8e,8bob::i<'>ooom. boba<::>8\J0'1J<'l UOJ:Jm<'>noob !;!?(')J:)8360m"6 woo33oob \j3bb 0308::ioo�b 3<'>e,36=0 ,<'>jo30 Q?O o<'>d"63oom 080JO()DOU 8o6obO<'>o, be,(!'.'Cl '1JO'bo3:)<'>o "6 o'J<'>own::i<::>o Jo<'>ob J:)0)360<::> Q?e,J:)8360m"6 woc33oob \j3bb - 03booo8obo 3o<'>o. Q?<'>J:J8360mo6 woo330::i<::> woo603<'>3b30':)<::> 3of'>b :J6wo 803rob Q?eJJ:J8o60ob o"GOOOOU 03b>d(!'.'�(!'.'eJOO. "8033 6e,<',8ob 83-4 3::i6dOo om30<::>ob\jo63ob 08 !;!?(')J:)83603oob R,8e,6,m30<::>b, <',e,83(!'.'mOfoG oo'b�Q?'J(!'.'00 woo3300. 23-3 8:Jb<::>ob 30<'>33<::>o 3:J6dOoli 03b>o.>!lol!,w ,;,ii� 3o<'>b · ':)'13(!'.'300 od3b, 3<'>e,36:J<::> o<'>jo3b 8<'lbmbe,3<'lb, ;,<'> wo::io3ob mo3obo J:Jm36o(!'.'O Q?<'>J:J8360ob 1,"8<'>8D6000 "6 box_OM(')Q? R336300 mo3ob 803<'> 1,06bO'b(:?3M:)(!'.'O 3owom, f'>e,83(!'.'0G o<'> ::i5wo 01:?38003oe,w3b 75 \Jo<::>b 8obo 03j85ow£.

boj83'b3 Q?OQ?o360(!'.'00, M<'>8 2018 \J<::>ob 29 036obb o(o)o3 06'13(')M80Goob mo3ob:)'13(!'.'3oob 0"63om,<'>3oob o5bOoO::i08o N'FOI06/18-001 0"6Gb>wooom 808,<'>mo bbo3 boj,<'>m33<::>(')b DM(')36:J(!'.'O of'>jo3ob box_OM(') 06'13(')M80GOOU 1,oro8o'b3 3ob::ibob8o303(!'.' 3of'>b Q?O 8e,oo,b(')30 038Q?30o 05'1)(')<'>80Goob 0>()D80: I. 2013 IJ<::'ob 1 oo5:Jf'>owo5 Q/1:?38Q?3 (IJ<::>3oob 8ob3Q?3om o><::>- oo<::>J3), 8J3<::>D3,<'>3oob <'>>MQ?36e,oo, <'le,8<::>ooboo 3mj3>m ::io<'>o bo83omb33(!'.'(') wof'>oo'boo woo33oo'b3 oo50<'>o<::>"::J<'> wo <'>31,oe,6:J<::> of'>jo33000 (of'>jo3ob 8omom3oom wo 8J3<::'D3o<'>ob 8(')d><::>od3e,oob 8omom3000J); 2. 2013 IJ<::>ob 1 0063<'>owo6 Wl:?:J8Q?D (\J<::>3oob 8ob3w3om GO<::>- G0<::'J3) m3800o3ob/bo,<'>jo3e, 'lle,6w3oob Ro8e,6,m30<::>o, <'le,8<::>3o'boG "l:?5o05:J<::>80 833(!'.'33,<'>3080 1,»33m3b 1,"6>ob,wo of'>do300 8:)0>(')00'b3; 3. 0)00)(')3:J<::' J(')5Jf'>DO'J<::' 038mb333o'b3 833<::>33><'>nbm3ob :J""'ob mj8ob o::if'>owo=o b"'1J:Jd3D<::'O.

wowo360(!'.'00 ob333. M(')8 bbo3 boj,<'>m33(!'.'(')U 3<'><'>36=0 o<'>jo3b, o(o)o3 06'13(')M8"GOOU mo3ob::i'IJ<::>3oob 0063omo<'>3oob o6bOOO'::)Oob 2018 \J<::>nb 29 036obob N•FOI06/18-001 1,06Gbowaoom 8(')mb<'l30(!'.'0 06'13(')M8"GOO o<'> 1,0'::JGOO.

bobo8of'>m<::>(')8 ob333 80':)0JOOJO boj83'b3 \jo<'>8(')Q?o360<::> bbo3 bojof'>m33(!'.'(')U 3f'>e,36:)(!'.'0 o<'>jo3ob 2019 \J<::>ob 5 8o<'>Oob N02-3n4732 \j3<'>0<::>'b3, e>(')8(!'.'00J"G of'>.33330, f\e,8 f'>o0 038mb303000 a<'>(')3� ""'doaou 833<::>03o<'>mo wo<'>o>'bo�>o60o<'>ouoo::i<::>o aof'>ob woc3300 O'b(!?'::JQ?DOO w<'>e,3oom, bo<'>33'bob 1,08(')b\jMf'>3008w3 (>(!?6006::i<::>b 3f'>e,36:)(!'.'0 o<'>do30 o<'> 800B633b, <'>(')1,(')MQ 833<::>33,<'>mo Q?><'>o>'bo7�(1>0033oo'b3 ::io<'>ow). o8obm"6, 0(:?6006::i<::> 038mb3333000, OJ':)30 1,068GbOQ?DOD(!'.'O 3f'>e,36'9<:'.'0 o<'>jo3ob1,06 8(')00)b(')3u

1�\.;:,: 5

Page 7: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

Jsb':'.Jbb \JJMO(!'.'MOO(J)O 'l3M<'>8om, Bob 8bM(!'.'MCJ? a,006 01,'b,3600> \JJMO(!'.'MOOO>O JSb'C)bO, S(:?6006':'.)(!'.'0 008mb3J3JOO JO oawofow 800<'>0>, MM8 obo6o b<'>'CJ<::>'CJ? 30<'> ,b,b,3J6 JMM36'C)(!'.'O ><'>do3ob Boo<'> w>o6oJ<'>JbJO'CJ(!'.'O 3o<'>ooobom3ob �M3J<!'.'CJ?(:?O'C)MSCJ? 1,>\jJ'CJ<!'.' JM6b'CJ<::>O'GOOb/ JM8':'.)60J0GOOb 3<'>MGJbb.

b,b,8,<'im(!'.'M8 S(:?60ofo, M('la bS)(SM<'l 06'l3M<'>8sooob 1,,roaob b'CJOOJdob \js<'>8MSCJ?1,J6b �3J<!'.'' ob bsx><'>M CJ?>\jJbJO'CJ(!'.'JOS, MMBJ<::>b>o o"R6o, b,m,fo<J?M b>)(SMM 06'l3M<'>8soo> ,6 bJ(!'.'O 80':'.)\:;3CJ?JOS a,b'bJ. BMoJB'CJ(!'.' 008mb3J3>00, b,b,8,<'>=<::>M8 �'CJMSCJ?(:?JOS 1,,,a,b30(!'.'S, MM1,MMG 1,068ob'CJ?JO(!'.'Ob Boo<'> 8MmbM360(!'.'0 06'l3M<'>8sooob oofos<'>b'bJ, SbJ3J 8MJSb'C)bJ 8bs<'Job 'bJ8MS(:?6o'iJ6'C)(!'.' JM'booo>'bJ, O)'C) MSQM8 SM 1,>bo> 06'13MM8>00>. 1,068ob>CJ?JO(!'.'Ob Boo<'> 8M0>bM360(!'.'0 06'13M<'>8soo>, mo3obo 'ilofos<'iboo,, '"' 000003b bsbo<::>8\jo'l3M bMCJ?':'.)8(!'.'MJOOb, JMBJM()O'C)(!'.'O CJ?' 3o<'iob 3J<'>bMfo(!'.''C)MO 8Mfoe30Booob oobsboo <'i,oao bcbob 8M6"<3J8oob, 3ofoow,6 1,068ob'CJ?JOJ(!'.'O ombM3b 833(!'.'J3''""'' MSMCJ?J6MoSb, mo8>003oblll,,<'>do3M 'l3M6CJ?JOOb R;,iJMfom3>(!'.'U CJ?' ':'.)><'>ob md8ob O'CJMOCJ?O'CJ(!'.' bS'13'C)d3J(!'.'b. m,3ob 8b<'>o3, 8M3Sb':'.JbJ 8b,<'>ob "'3J(!'.'OMJOS 08,'bJ, MM8 a,bm,6 CJ?'G'CJ<!'.'O 06'13M<'>8soos, 8Mbs<'>RJ(!'.'Ob 8oif, 8MmbM360<::> 008mb3J3Jo0106 CJ?>J>3ao<'>ooom oawofow 800<'>0>, MM8 UM':'.)(!'.''<!> 30<'> ,ti,b,3b JMM36':'.J(!'.'O ><'>do3ob Boo<'> wso60J<'>JbJO'C)(!'.'O 3o<'>ooob,m3ob �M3J<!'.'CJ?(:?O'CJMSCJ? o'VJ'CI<!'.' JM6b'CJ<::>O'()OOb I JMB':'.)603,ooob 3MM()Jbb, '"' 1,;,(JM<'>oobs3b ,wao5obo<'>>oo'CJ(!'.'O MM1,06Mb 3'<!'.'CJ?JO'CJ(!'.'JOSb 1,sboob ob 06'1JMM8S()OS, '"'G a,b 1,s.>f\60, 306M600, CJ?'CJ?oJ60(!'.'0 \'ioboo, ,6 bJ(!'.'O 8o'CJl'i3CJ?JOS �� - - . ,.

•, - J.3.3. b>dSM013J(!'.'Mb >CJ?8060bQMS()O'CJ(!'.'O bC>JMM()JbM JMCJ?Jdbob 33, 8':'.)b(!'.'Ob O>Sfob8SCJ?, O)'C) ,wao6obo<'>>oo'CJ(!'.'O M<'i1,slmb Boo<'> <'i,oao 8Md8JCJ?JOOb 1,06bMM(lOJ(!'.'JOS 06 ':'.)OMO <'i,oao 8Md8JCJ?JOOU 1,06bMM()OJ(!'.'JOS'bJ 'C)JS6M6MS CJ?' ob 3o<'>w'3o<'> CJ?' 'CJO'C)S(!'.'M 'bos6b '�J6Job 8Mbs<'>RJ(!'.'Ob JS6M60JM 'Cl'll<!'.'JO'b ,6 o6oo<'>obb, bsb;,80<'>01(!'.'M 'Cl'll<!'.'JOS8Mbo<::>o> bbJ6JO'CJ(!'.'O J"'CJ?Jdbob 24-J B'C}b(!'.'OO S(:?6oOfi'C}(!'.' bs<'>Ro<::>m>6 CJ?SJ>300<'>00001 1,08('100>6Mb o'CJ?'V�3JQO(!'.'JOS, "'"'8(!'.'00)0() ,CJ?806obo<'>>oo'CJ(!'.' "''"o'6"'b '3'<!'.'JOb, 1,sfob('}M()OJ(!'.'"'b J"'6J<'>Jo'CJ<!'.'0 8('1d8JCJ?JOS ,6 m,30 OJOJ'3"'b sa a('ld8JCJ?JOOb 1,06b('1M()OJ(!'.'JOOba1,,6.

bsdBJ'bJ CJ?'CJ?oJ60(!'.'0 'll'Oo"'o<'>o30 1,,<'>J8('1JOJOOU OJ'IJ>booob, CJ?' 'bJ8"''(:?6006':'.J(!'.'O abXJ(!'.'MOOb 1,>m3><::>0b\5060000,, bsb,8,<'>o,=a aooR6o,, MM8 a('lJSb':'.JbOb aoo<'> a('lb,<'>RJ(!'.'Obm3ob bsxs<'>M 06'13('1M8sooob 80\jMCJ?JOS'bJ ':'.)><'>ob mda, b,a,<'>m<::>00<'>03 b>'13'C)d3J(!'.'U a"'J(!'.'JO'C)(!'.'00, <'>ob 1,>BMQ b,b,<'>RJ(!'.'"' a('10,b('13fo 'C)6CJ?S CJ?SJ8S�('1'130(!'.'CJ?Jb CJ?' 8('13Sb':'.JbJb 'CJ6CJ?' CJ?'J3'<!'.'"'b dBJCJ?JOOb 1,06b('1MGOJ(!'.'JOS, JJMdMCJ?, ,(,)o3 06'13('1M8>ooob 0103ob'C)'IJ(!'.'JOOb 1,063om,<'>ooob o6booo'Cloob 2018 \'i(!'.'Ob 29 ogfiobob N°FOI06/18-001 1,>6ob>CJ?JOOO) 8Mmb('130(!'.'0 bS)(SM('l 06'l3M<'>8sooob 1,>ooa,.

Page 8: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

N'F0!06/18-00I 1,>6ob>w3oom 8!'lmb<'l300(!'.'0 06\'j!'lM8>oo> 3<'i!'l36':_'.J(!'.' ><'>do3clo ><'> ><'>olJ ood85o(!'.'O, (!?>8':_'.10>300':_'.J(!'.'O Q?> (l?S(l':_'.J(!'.'0.

OM<'l35':_'.l(!'.'0 ><'>do3olJ 8J3(!'.'33o<'>mo (l?>MO>'boo (l?>05QOMOlJOO':_'.l(!'.'0 JoMolJ Q?>'il300> o'bl:?':_'.IQ?OO> (l?M<'looom, b><'>3o'bolJ 1,>8!'l\Jv!'l<'>oo>8wo, M!'l80(!'.'0(3 bwoo> 'bo3o<'io J<'l8':_'.160JS(lOOm, oolJ>oo8olJ>w, >(>)o3 o5\'j!'lM8>ooolJ m>3olJ':_'.l\'l<::'OOOlJ 1,>63om><'>ooolJ o6lJoo<'J':_'.JoolJ 800<'> 8<'lmb<'l360(!'.'0 3<'>003<'>0':_'.18ooom 1,>6(lb>wooooolJ >1:?MO(lb3> w> Q?O\'J3<'>o5oo<'>oo> ><'> b!'lM(l00<::'<l?30>, 305oow>5 3<'i<'l36':_'.J(!'.'O ><'>do30 ><'> 800R603lJ, M!'l8 olJ3m (l?M<'llJ ':_'.J>MlJ 0':_'.10500> w>o6oo<'>olJ30= 3o<'ib w><'>o>'b'ilo w>'il33o>'b3. 1,>8!'lfoJ(!'.'OlJ 008m3033o'bo, ffi':_'.J 1,>68ob>woo3(!'.'o 'bo,Jo<'io J<'l8':_'.160J>()OOlJolJ 3<'>!'l36':_'.J(!'.'O ><'>do3olJ1,>6 8e,ombe,3lJ 3>lJ':_'.JblJ VOMO(!'.'!'lOOffiO \'J!'lM8om, 8,lJ 8b<'l(!'.'<'l(l? 80006 1,>01,'b,3630> VOMO(!'.'<'lOOmO 3>lJ':_'.JbO. >1:?6006':_'.J(!'.'O V3MO(!'.'!'l00ffi0 3>lJ':_'.Jbooob MS!'l(l?05!'loo o8wofow 800<'>0>, M<'l8 obo5o lJ<'>':_'.l<::>>W 33<'> ,tJ,b,306 3<'i!'l36':_'.J(!'.'O ><'>do3olJ 803<'> w>o600<'>3lJoo':.'.1<::'0 3o<'>ooob,m3ob �<'l33<::'Q?\:?0':_'.IM>Q? o'V3':.'.l<::'0 Je>5lJ':_'.1<::>(')>()00lJ/J<'l8':_'.150J>()OOb 3M<'l(l3bb.

lJ>lJ>8>Mm(!'.'<'lU 800<'> JO o><l?'V83300(!'.'JO> 08 86o'il360<::>e>3>60 1,><'>08e>ooolJ 'il3\'j>lJ3oolJ 1,><'>303 odfo 801:?01>':.'.l<::>o-

lJ»Jo(!'.'>()O<'l 3><::>>6>8 0;5obO(!'.'> lJ>d8olJ 8>\J>(!'.'000, 8e,olJ8o5> 8b><'>om> >blJfo- 0;58oMQ00300, 'ilo>8!'lu8> o>w>V830QO(!'.'OOOU 306e>600<'>00>-w>b>o':_'.Jmoo':.'.l<::'<'lO> w> 8ooR533tJ, <'>e,8 tJ»33<::>>oo!'l lJ>f\03><'>0 ,.., ':.'.15w> w>J8>�<'l\'Jo<::>wob, ao8wo1> 1,><'>38!'loo>m> ().'.>8(").:

b»3o<::>>()O<'l 3><::>>o>b ao,R5o,, M<'l8 b»33(!'.'>()0<'l b,Ro3o<'i'ilo aomomoo':_'.J(!'.'0 1,><'>08(')30300 ><'> :Jd85o>5 b>8!'ld><::>>d!'l b>J<'><'l()OU<'l J<'l<l?odbob 393-o w> 394-3 8':_'.ib<::>ooocn 1,>m3><::>obuo630':_'.l(!'.' 'il38;Q?oJ6(!'.'!'lOob Q?> 'il3boos8olJ>Q?, o>Q?>V83JOO(!'.'JOob o>':_'.ld83oob 3<'>e>oOb':_'.1>(!'.'':_'.l<'>·b>8><'>m<::>30<'>03 b>\'l':_'.1d3(!'.'3ob.

lJ>d><'>m30(!'.'<'lU >w8o5ob(')M>()O':_'.J(!'.'0 b>3M!'l(l3ll!'l J!'l<l?Odbob Jo<'>33(!'.'0 8':_'.Jb(!'.'OU 83-2 foUO(!'.'OlJ oolJ>o>8olJ>Q?, ffi':_'.i >8 Je>Q?3dlJom lJb3> M>8 >M >MOU (l?>(l:?1,050(!'.'0, ,wao5ob(')M>()O':_'.J(!'.' tJ,ao<'>m><::>v><'>8!'l30>00 1,>8!'l080600> b>d><'>m30(!'.'!'lU bs8!'ld><::>>d<'l lJ;J<'><'l()OU<'l J<'l<l?Odbob Q?OO':_'.l(!'.'00>5o. b>d><'>m33(!'.'<'llJ lJ>8<'ld><::>>d!'l b>3M!'l(l3ll<'l J!'l<l?3dbob 377-o 8':_'.Jb(!'.'OU 30<'>30<::>o fouo<::'ob m>foba,w, lJ>>Jo<::>>()O<'l b,tJ,a,<'>m<::'<'l >8<'lvaoob o><l?>V�3360<::'3o>b b»30<::'>()0<'l bsR03<'>ob·\'l><'>o<::'OO'ilo \'l>do!'lo<'io30 (l?> b,ac<'>m<::'30<'>030 m3>c::>b>'b<'>obom. 08>33 8':_'.Jb(!'.'OlJ ao!'l<'>o fouoc::>ob 'ilob>o>8ob>w, b,8,<'>m<::'00<'>030 m3>c::>b>'b<'>olJom oo8<'lu8ooob>b b>b>fo<'>m<::'<'l b3<::'8d1:?3>63<::>�b--393-o w> 394-o 8':_'.lb<::'ooob 8!'lmb<'l36ooom. b>8<'ld><::'>d<'l b;3<'><'l()Ob<'l J<'l<l?Od� 390}J �b<::'ob ao-3 foU0(!'.'00 ,,1," d300':_'.15d(')olJ m>fob8>(l?, ffi':_'.J lJ>>Jo<::'>()O<'l U>U>8o'401�-3mo6b800>\JoM30(!'.'0 o5lJ(')>5ooob b,b,So<'>m<::><'lb 03\'J>boooob w> w>b336oob f-i>d8ob \'l>"<'J<'l5<'>03 ;5/w> /,'1- � .I b>B><'>m<::'30<'>03 b>3omboom>6 (l?>J>3oo<'>ooom, a,006 Q?>\ b>o':_'.lmo,o>, ��3Jlb Ssm'bo

' -: .;;/ 7

-------

Page 9: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

aomom::15om.

l»>Jo(!'.'>(30<'> b>b>8><'>m(!'.'<'> bM:J(!'.'>(!? om>6b8oo> Jo<'>30(!'.'o o6b(')>6(lOOb b>b>8>MOl(!'.'<'lb OJ\'J>bJoJob (!?> (!?>b336oob b>j8ob \'J>d(')<'>o<'>o3 0><'>J8<'>oooomo6 (!?>J>3clo<'>ooom. b»JJ(!'.'>(lO<'> J>(!'.'>(')ob 8Mb>'b<'>ooom, b>d><!'.'>d<'> b>b>8><'>m(!'.'<'>8 b(i<'><'>><!? (!?»(!?1,ofo bsj8ob \'J>d(')<'>OMo30 1,><'>J8<'>JOJOO, <'>>b>(l o'bo><'>oob b»JJ(!'.'>(30<'> J>(!'.'>(')>(l.

b»JJ(!'.'>(lOCl b,b,8,<'>m(!'.'Cl >bJ3J bM:J(!'.'>(!? o'bo><'>oob Jo<'>3J(!'.'O o5b(')>6(lOOb b>b>8><'>m(!'.'<'lb OJ\'J>boooob <!?> w>b336oob bsj8ob b"8><'>m<!'.'00<'>03 b>3omboom>6 (!?>J>3clo<'>ooom. b»Jo<!'.'>(lO<'l J>(!'.'>(')ob 8C1b>'b<'>ooom, b>d><!'.'>d('"l b>b>8>Mm(!'.'<'>8 b(ielMO b>8><'>m<!'.'00<'>030 OJ\'J>boo> 8ob(l> b>j8ooo (i><'>8C1(!?1>J60(!'.' 8(')30(300:J(!'.'OOJob.

3.2.1. b»JJ(!'.'>(30<'> J>(!'.'>(')> 80:JOlOOlJOb, Mel8 b>d><'>m3J(!'.'Clb J<'l5b(')O('):J(lOOb ao-18 8:Jb(!'.'Ob 8J-2 (!?> 8J-3 J:'.)6j(')JOOb m>fob8>(!?, 83J(!'.'>b >j3b :J\'3(!'.'00> J>6C1600, (!?>(!?1,050(!'.'0 (iobom 1,>J(l5Clb b>x><'>Cl (!?>(iobo1>:J(!'.'JO>OO a,b'bo ><'>bJO:J(!'.' ,5 bb3> 061'3C1M8>(30>b ,5 <'l\')0(30>(!'.':JM (!?<'lJ:'.JBJ5(')b, 1,><'>w> 08 008mb303ob>, Mel(!?Jb>(l 01,0 OOO(l>3b J<'>8JM(lO:'.)(!'.' >5 JM<'l\')Jbo= b>O(!?:J8(!'.'<'1JO>b >6 (!?J8C1JM>(')O:J(!'.' b>'b<'>1,>(!?ClJO>Oo

.>:J(lO(!'.'JOJ(!'.'O bobo<!'.'8oo\'JC1 >6 b;'bc,�>(!?C1Jo<'>o30 :Jb>l'3<'>mbC1ooob - ,6 b.>8><'>m>(!'.'(i><'>8(.')JOOb o6oo<'>obooob (!?>b>(3>3>(!? J>6C16om >6 3>6C16om (!?>(!?1,060(!'.'0 (iobom

. >�0><'>00'5(!'.',;;·1.»t>Qi58�0?3e, -•(i's,-,w:'.JB<!'.'"'J1>>(!?. <'l\'JO(lO><!'.':'.)M �>fo(io<'>Boclo ><'>bJO:'.)(!'.'O 05\')<'lM8>(lO>, <'>M8J(!'.'O(l (!?>J>3clo<'>oo:J(!'.'O> >(!?>8o,6ob x>58<'>mo<!'.'<'lO>bm,6, \')Ofo6boom,6 ,5 bb3> Jo<'>>(!? b>3omboom;6, ><'>>3obm3ob :J5(!?> 08<'>b bJ(!'.'8ob>(i3(!?<'180 m3om ,a >(!?>8o>5ob m>6b8<'loob 1,>MJOJ, 1,>M(!?> J>6C1600, 1)>0>3>(!'.'ob(io600:J(!'.'O OJ8mb3J3Joob;, M<'l(!?Jb>(l ob >:J(lO(!'.'JOJ(!'.'O> b>bJ(!'.'8(io\')<'> >6 b>'b<'>1,>(!?<'lJOMo30 :Jb>\')MOlb<'lJOOb :J'bM:J63J(!'.'b>8<'l\'J>(!?, box><'><'> o6oo<'>obooob, x>58<'>mo<!'.'<'lOOb >6 bbgcc» :J\'3<!'.'JOOOOb (!?>b>(3>3>(!?.

b>d><'>m3J(!'.'<'>b JC16b(')O('):J(3000) MJ1,(!'.'>8o5oo<'>o1>:J(!'.'O box >Mel 06\')<'lM8>(lOOb bJ(!'.'80b>(i3(!?C18ClOOU 'bJ8r»(!?50'IJ5:J(!'.'O 'bCl1)0(!?0 Jt'Jo5(30JO J<'>5JMJ(')O'bOMJO:J(!'.'O> b>d><'>m3J(!'.'Clb 'b<'>i,>(!?O >w8o6ob(')M>(lO:J(!'.'O Jel<!?Jdbob ao-3 m>3om (,,06\'3C1M8>(300U m,3ob:J\'3<!'.'J1>>"). >(!?5o'll6:J(!'.'O m>3ob 28-o 8:Jb(!'.'O o8J<'><'>oob J<'l5b(')o('):J(lO:JM 6C1<'>8>b, Mel8 U>X>Mel o6\')<'lM8>(lO> (!?O», 1,>M(!?> J>6C16om 1,>m3>(!'.'ob(io600:J(!'.'O 008mb303ooob> (!?> w>w1,060(!'.'0 (iobom b>bJ(!'.'a(iOl')Cl, JC18JM(l0:J(!'.'O >6 JM<'l\')000:J(!'.'O b>O(!?:J8(!'.'<'lJOObm3ob ,5 JJMU<'lfo(!'.':JMO 8<'lfo(3J8ooobm3ob 803:Jm36JO:J(!'.'O 061'3C1M8>(300U>. bbo5o1>:J(!'.'O b>3>6<'l68(!?00(!'.'Cl >doob ao-40 8:Jb(!'.'OU Jo<'>3J(!'.'O fo(iO(!'.'O

' >wi,o5t, "'"'a t,x,"'"' w>ootoo:J<!'.'oo> 3"<!'.'<!?JO:J<!'.'O> 0,t00b t>x><'>Cl 06\'JC1�8>(lo>, Bee» OelMOb, O<!'.'Od6<'><'l5:J(!'.'O \')<'lM8om 8C1mbC1360(!'.'0 b>x><'><'l 06\')<'lM8>(30>, (!?>:J8<'>35Jo(!'.'03 ,5 ><'>> :J1)30>5ob IO (!?(!?Ob>, Ol:J b>x><'>Cl 06\')<'lM8>(lOOU 8Clmb�-�-�>'bo J>b:Jb) ob' 1,>(3J8>

\: . . 8

Page 10: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

8MoOJbM3oc c) t,b3, w>o>b<::>OO::J<::' 3::J6dl'Joo '"'"80::J(!'.'O Bobo "o"'::idl'J::JM::J(!'.'O d3ow>fo�M'IJ0<;(>06 ,6 t,b3, "'X''"('} w>voooo::i<::>ooow,6 06'1JMM8S(l000 8Mdooo,t,, W' w>8::10>301>,t,; o) 8600360<::>M3>60 8Cl(l::J(!'.'MOOO OMOJ8>6omm,6 W'::JJ>3ooe,ooo<::>o G'<::'JO::J<::'0 <;(>MJ::J8o6l'Joooo 8Mdoo1>,t,, W' w>8::10>301>,t,; 1,) ob3, w>o>b<:::>o1>::i<:::> J::i6dl'Joo ,.,t,81>::J<:::> Bob ol'JM::Jdl'l::J"'::I<::' d30W'fo�M'IJm"6 ,6 ob3> o>x>MM w>\Joooo::J<:::>01>>omo6 JM60::J<::'O'G000. 80-2 fo\)0(!'.'00 mofoba,w, "'::I "'X '"'('} 06'1JMMfo(lOOO 1,>00800,m3ot, t,,Joe,roo 10 <;(>l:?0>6o 3>w>, "'X'"""' <;(>>\)0000::J<::'oo> 3><::'WOO::J(!'.'O> 8rombro36oomofo30 ,06rooMo cdob a8o,boo 0,68ob>wo<'>o<:::>"- 80-3 fo\Jo<:::>ot, 000,0,800,w 30, ""X''"('} 06'1JMMfo(lOOO JMM>dl'JO::J<::''W o"8Md:Jo�6oo> ""' ,m,300::i'IJ<:::>OOO "'X''""' w>voooo::i<:::>oo,t, 08030 ,6 bb3, "'X '"'"' 06'1JMM8>ooot, arombro36ot, ooamb303>00 Bobo w>ww6o(!'.'O voooa, 0>00800 3><:::>woo::1<:::>0000006.

"'X''""' 06'1JMM8S(lOOb <::'Oo'<::'::J'" WO'IJ06ooo>o od<:::>83' "'d'"'"'38<::'Mb 'bMo>wo >w8o6obl')MO(l0::J(!'.'O JMWOdl>oh ilo-2 il::Jh<:::>oh ,lne,30<:::>o fo\)o<:::>Ob ,,8'' d30J::16dl'Jn, MM8<::>ob oob,o,aob>w, box'"""' 06'1JMM8>oo> >Mob M'IJO(lOO<::'::JMO <;(>MJ::J8o6l'Jo (8,ro OMMOb, fob,'bo, 8>Jol'Jo, wo8>, bdo8>, 'IJ"'6Mb::JM>mo, 8<::'0do"'"'6::J(!'.'O o6'1JMM8S(lOO, 3oworo- W' '::JWOMR>fo\Jo"'ooo), 06::1 box'"""' w>\Joboo::i<:::>oo,oo W'G::J(!'.'O, '<'>"'8"'38 box'"""' w>\Jobo<'>::i<:::>ooob ,6 8Mbo8b,b::JMOU 800"' bo8b,b::JMOOM03 b>d8o,6roo,bro,6 w,3,3ooe,ooom 801:?80::J(!'.'O, wsa::10>300::i<:::>o, ood86o(!'.'O ,6 .,,,.,,'b,360(!'.'0 06'1JMM8>oo,, '"838 "'X''""' w>\Joboo::i<:::>ooob 800"' 3MM>dl'JO::J<::''W 0>8rod30�60<'>::1<:::>o o6'1JMM8>oo>. ,8wofow, MM<',MM(l '1:?6006::1<:::>o 8::Jb(!'.'OO 006,>e,bo ob>Wtl"''IJb, >w8o6obl')MO(l0::J(!'.'O 306ro68woo<:::>Mo> box'"""' 06'1JMM8S(l000 o>oo8ob 3'<::'WOO::J(!'.'8900 _b::iooodl'l>w box'"""' w>\Joboo::i<:::>oo>b 800P,603b 8bM<::>MW "'X''""' w>\Joboo=oo>oo W'G::J<::', - '<'>"'8"'38, box'"""' w>\Joboo::i<:::>oo>oo ,5 arob,ab,b::JMOb 8ro"' bo8b,b�M00603. b>d8p,6roo,ba,,&. -w,3>3ooo',ooom 801:?00':'.J<::'.'O,

• W'88cE3ri1>'cJ<:::>..;, ood86o(!'.'O ,6 o'o 'b,360<:::>0 06'1JMM8:ooob. - 'M'iJO(lOO(!'.'::JMO W"'J::J006l'Job 800,o',a,_

»8"'"'36::J(!'.'O b»Md03('} 'IJC'l6<:(>000 W' 8"'"'36::J(!'.'O '"'do3ob oob>boo" bod'"'"'38<::'"'" J>6ro6o 0o6b>'bl:?3"''3" 8"'"'36::J<:::>O b»o',do3M 'IJM6<;(>ob, W' bod''""'38<::'"'" 8"'"'36::J<::>O >Mdo3ob u,a,.,m<:::>0<'>"'03 ·bl'J>l'J::Jbb, · 8"'"'36� · """'dos� __ 'IJ"!5wob>m3ob W"'J::J8o6l'Jooob 803::1m36ooob Je,o6ooJooli, Bocoo <;(>>(l30b> W' .,,,aro�o6ooob bo3omboob. '1:?6006::1<:::>o 3,6ro6ob 80-3 O::Jb<:::>ob Joe,30<:::>o 3::J6dl'Job ro,fob8,w, 8"'"'36::J(!'.'O b»Md03('} 'IJ<'l6<:(>0 >Mob b>d'"'"'38<::'"'b l'JOMOl'JMMO>'bo '""boo::i<:::>o od W"'J::J006l'Jooob (<',>6::JMR03<::''W Bacoo 8ol')oMOO(!'.'Ob bsboMoob,) OM(J)MO(!'.'OMOO, MC'lO(!'.'OOb>o >d3m obl')MMO::J(!'.'O, "'8<::'0oO::JMO, 800600M::J(!'.'O, JM(!'.'Ol'JO J::JMO, OJM6M80J::JMO, J::J<::'l'J::JM::J(!'.'O, bsbo<:::>8\jo'IJM ,6/ W' bo'bro0,wroooo',030 \:?OMOO::J<::'O<'>>. 8"'"'36::J<::' b»o',do3M 'IJM6<J;ib '<'>"'8"'38 0003::im3600> bb3, bobo<:::>8\Jo'IJMOOOO W'G::J<::'0 ();!MJ::J8o6l'Jooo, MM8<:::>o<'>oo b,d'"'"'38<::'"'b bso"""''""'"'obM bo<:::>clOJM::J<::'8<'>80ob mofob8ow ::J6W> W>::J<'>M::J6wob ,6 0><J;i8"'8G8b b>d'"""'38<::'"'b-

,8,33 b,3,6ro68woo<:::>M >dl'Job 83-6 8::Jb<:::>ob Joe,33(!'.'o J::i6d���d>M0">38<::'M00 b»Mdo3M bod8ob 8oo',mo3b W' bod8ob\joo',8ro3oob bM::J(!'.'�<'l\'J>b> W' Oi:c"'36::J(!'.'O b»Mdo3M

I I · 'IJM6();!ob 0063om,o',30,b ::J'bM::J633(!'.'�M'IJb b>d>Mm33<!3"\ti o::ibl'Joooob , b,8o6ob(')e,Mb ,

9

Page 11: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

caaawo(')aoo - b,ao5ob('J<'>e,) aa,<'>m30(!'.'(')00b b\'JQM(')OO 008>3>(!'.'0 b>x><'>(') b,a,<'>m(!'.'ob O:'.'.JMO<.J?O:'.'.J(!'.'O Jo<'>o - b,j,<'>m30(!'.'(')b o<'>e,36=0 ><'>do30 caaawo(')aoo - o<'>e,36:'.'.)(!'.'0 ><'>jo30). ao-2 3:'.'.)6j('Job oob>b,aob><.J.>, o<'>e,36:'.'.)(!'.'0 o<'>jo:30 :'.'.)'b<'>:'.'.)63Q(!'.'HC'1\'Jb QMC'135:'.'.J(!'.'O b>o<'ijo3e, \'le,6<.J.>Ob 003boo>b, <.J?C,J�o5oooob 3060<'>>(!'.'0'bQO:'.'.)(!'.' >(!?MO(lb3>b (Socn ae,<',ob, O<!'.'Odo<'>e,5:'.'.J<!'.'o \'le,<'>8om), >1:?\lo<'>ob, o<'>e,36:'.'.J<!'.'o b»<'>jo3e, \'JC'15<.J.>ob <.J?C,J:'.'.1806oooob O<!'.'Odo<'>e,6:'.'.)(!'.'0 &,'bob \'J!'lM8o<'>ooob <.J?> Bob a:'.'.lwao3 o>fob(!'.'QO>b, <.J.>>'boo5oo:'.'.J<!'.'O <l?(')J:'.'.lao5oooob 3e,6bo<'>3>30>-<'>obo>3<'>0(3o>b <.J?> &>5b>J:'.'.)OlMQO:'.'.J(!'.'O (!?OMQO:'.'.)(!'.'QOOb 8j!'l5Q <.J?MJ:'.'.J806oooob>m3ob b><.J.>O'b(!?3Q3C'l \'j!'l6<.J?Ob aod8fob, QMC'135:'.'.J(!'.'O b»<'>jo3C'l \'jC'16<.J?Ob <.J?!'lJ:'.'.J8o5ooom,5 m>3ob:'.'.)\'l'(!'.' w>a3oo>b b>d><'>m3Q(!'.'C'1b 3>6C'l68<.J.>QO(!'.'!'lOOOl <.J?><.J.>0060<!'.' \'J><'>o<!'.'QOOO; o<'>e,36:'.'.)(!'.'0 ><'>do:io o<'>e,35:'.'.J(!'.'O b>o<'>jo3C'l \'j!'l6<.J?Ob <.J?C'1J:'.'.Jao5oooob 0>8e,Ho5ooom >8'b><.J.>o&b O:'.'.IJ<!'.'OOQ<'>b, o<'>Mcl:'.'.J<'>oob, bb3><.J.>>bb3> bcbob 0>8C'1(loaoob (Sor» OC'lMOb, 3<!'.'3do<'>e,6:'.'.)(!'.'0 8>0><'>00<!'.'ob bcbor»), bojo<'>m30(!'.'C'lb J>5C'l58<.J?Q0(!'.'(')000) <.J?>Q?oQ50(!'.'0 \lobom Bccoo 008<.J?&!'lao <'>3>(!'.'o'b>3oob :'.'.J\'l(!'.'0000'). ao-3 3:'.'.)6j(')ob m>foba,w JO, QMM36:'.'.)(!'.' o<'>jo3b >d3b QMC'l3fi:'.'.J<!'.'0 b>o<'>jo3C'l \'j!'l6<.J?Ob <.J?C'lJ:'.'.)8Q6(')3oob {doc» O!'lMOb, o<'>M36:'.'.J<!'.'. b»<'>do:i('} \'JC'l5<.J.>oo ><'>bo<'>:'.'.1<!'.'o J:'.'.l<!'.'6:'.'.1<'>:'.'.J<!'.'0 a3a33ow<'>oe,oob aoo<!'.'ooob) >(!?M0(3b3ob, <.J.>>33obo <.!?' aofob3ob b>bQ<!'.'8\JO\'JC'l 3e,6('JM!'l(!'.'Ob> <.J?> 'bowsabow33(!'.'C'lOOb :'.'.J\'l<!'.'Q<'>>, 006:'.'.J<'>RQ3(!'.'><.J? accco oofob3ob >Q?oo<!'.'obo .

.... - ,,Q<'Je,36:'.'.)<:'.'0 b>o<'>jo3C'l \'JC'l5<.J?Ob> <.J?O QM<'l36:'.'.)(!'.'0 ><'>jo3ob OQb>b30" bsjo<'Jm3Q(!'.'C'lb JS5C'l50b 22-o a:'.'.)b(!'.'ob 30<'>33(!'.'0 3:'.'.J5doob m>foba,w 3<'>M36:'.'.)(!'.'0 b»<'>do3e, \'j!'l6<.J.>ob <.J?C'lJt)8Qfi(')Q00')05 <.J.>>0330> m>3ob:'.'.)\'jO(!'.'OS, l\>M<.J?> >8 8"3b�ob. 8Q•4 il:'.'.)fij(')OOJ> (l?> 08 JS5C'l5ob 23-3 8:'.'.)b(!'.'ob OOM3Q(!'.'O 3:'.'.)5j(')om o>m30(!'.'0b\jo630:'.'.)(!'.'0 a38mb3Q3QOOb>. w>o5oo<'>oboo:'.'.J(!'.' Jo<'>b OQ:'.'.Jd(!'.'OO b,06\'j!'lM80(lOC'l-bodo30('} bobooaob aoa33e,oom 8Md306e,b (l?O o>Q(l5C'lb 30,e,36:'.'.)(!'.'0 b>o<'>jo3e, \'JC'lfi<.J.>ob <.J?C'lJ:'.'.)836('Jb >5 8ob Jo<',b, o»JQmC'lb <.J?!'lJ:'.'.J8o5oow>6 >8C'lfo\Jo<'>o <.!.>> ob><'>wo<!'.'C'lb QMC'l36:'.'.J(!'.'O ><'>jo3ob boo6\'j!'lM8>(lOC'l 8C'l8b>b:'.'.JMQOOOl. b>bo<!'.'8\Jo\'JC'l b>J:'.'.)m<'>ooob <.J?!'lJ:'.'.)836(')m>6 woa33oob \lobb a308:'.'.J0>33ob QMC'l36:'.'.)(!'.'0 ><'>jo30 <.J?> o<'>d>63000l ,a03oroob ao6ob(')<'>o, b!'l(!'.'C'l \'JO'bOJ:'.'.JMO >6 O:'.'.JMO<.J?O:'.'.J(!'.'O Jo<'iob J:'.'.1"'360(!'.' (l?C'lJ:'.'.)836(')mo6 w>a33oob IJ3bb - 03bo&,aobo Jo<'io. <.J?!'lJ:'.'.)836(')m>6 woa30<'>:'.'.J(!'.' <.J?>06(')3<'>oboo= 3o<'>b :'.'.)6<.J?> ao33ob <.J?!'lJ:'.'.)836(')ob 1,>(l6C'loob a3b>d(!'.'QO(!'.'Mo>. >8>30 6C'l<'>8ob 80-4 3:'.'.)6j(')o om30(!'.'ob1Jo6oob of <.J?C'lJ:'.'.)836(')3oob Rs8C'lfom3>(!'.'b, MC'l8Q(!'.'ITTOfo(l OQ'b(!?:'.'.J<l?:'.'.)(!'.'O> woa330>. 23-o 8:'.'.)b(!'.'ob 30<'>33(!'.'0 3:'.'.J6doob aob>o>8ob>Q? JO, Jo<'>b :'.'.l\'l<!'.'OO> >dab, QMC'l36:'.'.I<!'.' ><'>jo3b 8C'lb0lb!'l3C'lb, '"' <.J?>:'.'.)a3>b m>3obo J:'.'.)m360(!'.'0 <.J?!'lJ:'.'.J8o6oob 0>8C'l�o6000 o6 b>x><'>MQ? R30600> o-cgob aoo<'> 0>6b>'b(!?3M:'.'.)(!'.'O 3>wom, M!'l8Q(!'.'O(l ><'> :'.'.)6<.J?> 'l!?aaoooo!'l<.J.>QO 75 \10<!'.'b Bobo aoj85ow>5.

3>(!'.'>(')> o'bo><'>3ob b>j>(!'.'Oj!'l b;b;8o<'>m(!'.'!'lb 8omomooob, M!'l8 2018 \)(!'.'Ob 29 036obb >(>)oJ 06\'j!'lM803oob mo3ob:'.'.)\'l(!'.'QOOb 0>63omo<'>3oob 06b(')oo:'.'.Jo8> N•FOI06/18-001 0>63b>(l?QOOO') aoa,<'>m> bboJ b>j><'>m33(!'.'C'lb 3<'>M36:'.'.)(!'.'0 ><'>jo3ob b>x><'>C'l 06\'j!'lM8>3oob 1,>338>'b3 3>b:'.'.Jbob8o003(!'.' Jo<'>b <.J?> 8MombM3> aoawo1,o 06\'JM<'>803oob 00338>: 1. 2013 \)(!'.'ob I 0>63<'>ow>6 'l?l!?Oawo (\l(!'.'QOOb aob3w3om GO<!'.'- (30(!'.'JQ), 833(!'.'33><'>3oob MO!'l<.J?Q6C'lo>, - � MC'l8(!'.'3obo3 3mj3>m :'.'.)OMO b,a3omb33(!'.'C'l w><'>o>'bao w>a3oo>'bo-Go60<'>>(!'.':'.'.JM <.!?' '""'"""" ,,m,oo ,�..,,. �- � ·;�? ,oo""''"':'.

' . '<,

Page 12: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

800,omooom); 2. 2013 \)(!'.'ob 1 o,631"rn;g,6 (!?(:?08(!?0 (\J(!'.'OOOb 8obow300, G'<!'.'- G'<!'.'Jo) mo8>603ob/l>»M303('} 'IJC'l6(!?000b Ro8C'l6:,a,3,(!'.'o, MC'l8(!'.'oo9'ioG 0(:?6006:,(!'.'a, 833(!'.'0301"0080 oO>Jomob o'foGbO(!?O 01"30300 8::fllO<'loo'bo; 3. 0)00)('}0'::)<!'.' JC'l5JM06'CJ<!'.' 008mb30309'io 833(!'.'0301"obm3ob :,o1"ob m38ob o:,1"owo:,(!'.'o bo'l3:,d30(!'.'o. bbo3 bo301"m30<!'.'"'" 0"'"'36::J(!'.'O 01"303b, >(>)o3 o6'1l"'"'a'Goob m,3ob:,'13<!'.'0oob 0063omo1"ooob o5b6o6:,6ob 2018 \j(!'.'OU 29 ogtiobob N•FOI06/18-001 o05Gbowooom 8C'lmbC'l3oc::>o o5'll"'"'ao0oo '"' 00:,Go,.

3oc::>06> '"' n'boo1"oob '3o(!'.'>56ob o>58>M6ooob, MC'l8 3ofoowo6 0"'"'36::J(!'.'O 01"303ob 8J3<:'.'03'"'m' (!?0Moo9'ioo (!?0066o"'obo�n 3o1"ob (!?>0300> 09'(:?::J(!?OOO '1?"'"'0000), bo1"309'iob 0>8C'lb\jC'l1"00>8\J?O, MC'l80(!'.'0G b(!?ooo 9'io3o1"n JC'l8:,603,Goom, oobooo8obow, 0(0)03 06\')C'lM800oob mo3ob:,'13<:'.'000b 0063om>Mooob o5b6o6:,6ob 8001" 8C'lmbC'l36oc::>o 31"0601"0:,aooom o>5Gb0(!?00000b O(:?MOGb30 'I?' (!?O'IJOM06GOM000 '"' bC'lMGOO(!'.'\J?OOO, 306'0(!?05 0"'"'36::J(!'.'O 01"3030 "" 800R603b, MC'l8 obom (!?MC'lb :,o1"b 0:,0600> (!?00560MObOO::J(!'.' 3o1"b (!?OMoo9'ioo (!?>030009'0. 0'8C'lfoJc::>Ob ao8m303009'io, m:, o>58Gb0(!?000(!'.'0 9'io3n1"o JC'l8:,603>GOObob 0"'"'35::J(!'.'O 01"303obo>6 8C'lombC'l3b 3ob:,bb \JOMO(!'.'C'lOOO)O 'IJC'lM8nm. Bob 8bC'l(!'.'C'l(!? 80006 1,>01,9'036000 \JOMO(!'.'C'lOOOlO 3ob:,bo. 0(:?5o'll5:,(!'.'o \JOMO<:'.'C'lOOOlO 3ob:,booob "''"''l?05C'lo0 08(!?Jfo(!? 8GO"'O'· MC'l8 nbo6o bM::J(!'.'O(!? 30M ObOb>306 0MC'l36::J(!'.'O OM303ob 800(', (!?00560MObOO'CJ(!'.'O J0Moooboo,3ob �"'301!'.'\l?\'.?O'::JM'\J? o'VO'CJ(!'.'O JC'l5b::J<!'.'6'GOOb/JC'l8::J60JOGOOb 3MC'lGobb 'I?' omo5b8ooo bo3>c::>>3C'l bobo8oMOl(!'.'C'lb, MC'l8 _b>;>c>MC'l 06\')C'lM80GOOb o'Goaob b:,00036b \j>M8C'lO(!?oQ5b �30<1:'.'' ob b>;>c>MC'l (!?>\joboo::J<!'.'oo>, MC'l8oc::>b>_G 0»R6oo bom>fo(!?"' bo'l(;M"' 06\')C'lM8>00> 06 bo<!'.'o 80:,v3wooo .. a_,b'bo. o.>68Gb"Q?OO(!'.'Ob 8001" 8C'lmbC'l360(!'.'0 06\')C'lM80G00, mo3obo 'llofoo1"bom, 01" aooG03b bobo<!'.'8\Jo\'l"' boo=8(!'.'<'l0oob, J<'l80MGO::J(!'.'O Q?> 3o1"ob 3o1"b<'lfo<:'.'::JMO 8<'lfoGJ8ooob aoboboo 1"0080 bcbob 8<'lfoGo8oob, 3ofoowo6 o>58Gb>woooc::>o ocobcogb 833(!'.'03>1"mo MO<'lQ?06<'loOb, mo8>603ob/l>»M303<'l 'IJ<'l5(!?000b Ro8<'lfom3>(!'.'b Q?O :,o1"ob m38ob O::JMOQ?O'C)(!'.' bO\')::Jd3o<:'.'b. mo3ob 8b1"03, 8<'l3ob:,bo 8bo1"ob o3oc::>o1"oo> o8o'bo, M<'l8 a,bmo5 'l?'G�O 06\')<'lM8>G00, 8<'lbo1"Ro<!'.'ob 8001" 8<'lmb<'l360(!'.' 'llo8mb303oomo6 (!?>303'1Jo1"ooom oawofow 8Go1"oo: -M<'l8 bM'CJ(!'.'OQ?. 30"' obobo3b 0"'"'35::J(!'.'O 01"jo3ob 8001" Q?0056o"'oboo:,(!'.'o 301"ooob,m3ob �"'301!'.'Q?\'.?O::JMO(!? o'UO'CJ<!'.' J<'l5b:,(!'.'60GOOb/ J<'l8:,6030Gnob 3M<'lGQbb, '"' 0'8<'lMOGbo3b 0(!?806ob6M>GO::J(!'.'O C'lMo05C'lb 3'<:'.'Q?OO'CJ(!'.'OO>b 0>bGob ob o5'1JMM8'Go>, ""'G 8ob 0»R6oo 306M6om 'l?'Q?o05o(!'.'n \Jobom 06 bo<!'.'o ao:,\J3\l?oo> a,b9'io.

�<'l30(!'.'030 9'io8<'l0(:?6o'IJ6:,(!'.'0Q?05 o'8<'l8(!?0fo1"o, 30(!'.'>6ob 8C'lbo9'1"ooom, bo30(!'.'0J<'l bob,8oMm(!'.'<'l8 b\j<'lMO(!? o>(!?0\)�306>, M<'l8 bo1"Ro<!'.'o b0'13::Jd3c::>0>600 'I?' :,6(!?0 Q?OJ80�<'l\')O(!'.'Q?Ob, 8<'l3ob:,bob :,6(!?0 W'03�<'lb d8owooniJ<506bC'lMGOJ(!'.'OOO, JOMd<'lQ?, 0(0)03 06'13<'l1"800oob mo3ob:,'13(!'.'00ob 0063omo1"3oob o5b6o6_QOo�l8 \Jc::>ob 29 ogfiobob N•FOI06/18-001 o'6Gb>wooom 8<'lmb<'l30<:'.'0 bO;>(>MC'l 06'13<'lM80GO�b-o �fa,

4. a0a,x,aooo<!'.'o b,b,a,""m<!'.'"' w,b33fo ;

) 11

Page 13: I, j; Inquiry... · 2020-02-12 · j; .. " ' i ' 1, 1 j ' :\ JI 1 ,1 L l j l JI! • I .·, f ' I ' 1 ,I 1111111111111111111 II 0001126520213613 03.02.2020 vac::>o 1 ;,oJ 00'1Ja"

'bJ8Cl><:?6ocl6':'.)(!'.'0 o>0J8MJ&J&ob >fo<::>o'bob 0"'1J':'.Jd3J<::>'bJ b>"'3J<::>>(lOM 3><::>>6>b ao,R5o>, C)(')a b>"'3J<::>>(lOM b,Ro300oo aomomJ&':'.)(!'.'O o>0J8MJ&J&O '"' �d86o,6 b,j,0m3J(!'.'MO o>8Md><::>>dM b;J<',M(lJOM J"'<!?Jdbob 393-J w> 394-J 8':'.Jb(!'.'J&Om o>m3>(!'.'00\jo6J&':'.J<::> OJ8>Q?&J5(!'.'M&>b. Jo03J(!'.'O o6b6>6(lOOO b,o,a,0m<::>M8 b\jM0>w o'W'V8306> O>Q?>3M bcjocooo. <',ob 0>8M(l, ,<', o0bJ&M&b b>"'3J<::>>(lo"' b,Ro30ob Q?>J8>8"'\'JO(!'.'J&ob> (!?> o>b>Ro30J&':'.J<::>O a>w>V83J60<::>J&ob o>':'.Jd8J&ob 30M(lJO':'.J><::>':'.J0-b,a,0m<::>J&0030 0>'13':'.)d3(!'.'J&O.

b>d>0m3J<::>"'" 0>8Md><::>>dM bo30M(lJOM J"'<!?Jdbob 55-J 8':'.Jb<::>ob O>\'J':'.Jd3J<::>'bJ, >3J<::>>66ob 80J(,) O>bJ<::>8\jo\'JM 3>1JOO boboco o><J?Sb(!?O(!'.'O 150 (>OMC)8M(l<J?o>O,O) <::>>(,)o, ':'.)5(!?> R>om30(!'.'MO b>bJ(!'.'a\)0'13(') &O':'.JXJ600 b;b;<',33&(!'.'MQ? o><J?>bwo<::>>w.

ObJ<::>8d<:?3>6J<::>> <',; bojo0m3J(!'.""O ,wao5ob60>(lO':'.)(!'.'O b"'30M(lJOM J"'<!?Jdbob Jo03J<::>O a'.'.;)b<::>ob 8J-2 fo\jo<::>om, bsj;<',mJJ<:'.'"'" b,a"'ao<::>>d"' bs30M(lJ""' J"'<!?Jdbob 257-J, 372-J. 390-J, 397-J a':'.Jb<::>J&om

b»JJ(!'.'>()OM b,b,a,0m(!'.'MU ,wao6ob60>(lO::J(!'.' boj8Jm> 3>(!'.'>6>8 <!? > > <!? 0 0 6 c:

2. :'.)(33<!'.'J<!'.''W w;<',RJb m.00(!'.'0000 bod><::>>dM O>�e8>0m(!'.'M_b awao5ob60>(lO:'.)(!'.' b;j8Jm> .JM\!'.'Jl',000 2019 \)(!'.'00 04 "'3<',o(!'.'OO o><J?>V83J60(!'.'J&>;

3. o>6Ro6J&> OJOd<::>J&o o>O>Ro30Q?JO, ab,0Jo»m3ob w>bo&::imJ&::J(!'.'O o>6Ro5J000 o><J?>()J80Q?o6 21 ( "'G<!?>J0mo) <J?\!?00 3>wsoo, OoJSOo(lOM bsP,03<',om, b>d>0m3J<::'"'" ::J'bJfoJOO b,o,a,0m(!'.'MO ,wao6ob60>(lO:'.)(!'.' b>d8Jm> 3>(!'.'>6>cio (8Q?Jl'>>0J aob,a,0m'bJ: d· m&o(!'.'obo, d8J&o 'b::i&><::>>030(!'.'J&ob d::JR> N•6) m&o<::>obob b>"'3J<::>>()OM b,b,a,0m<::>"'" ><J?0060060>(30:'.J<::' O>J8Jm> 0o(!'.'>6oO 8J03JM3oo, (8<J?J00C)J 800;8;<',o,'bJ: J· 0)\',0<::'000, 30o0M<::> 0M&ojodob 0;8'bo<',o N•7 s ).

� -e

._:;

/1 .>

12