Goethe University Frankfurt and FIAShees/publ/alice17.pdf · Goethe University Frankfurt and FIAS...

61
Dileptons with a coarse-grained transport approach Hendrik van Hees Goethe University Frankfurt and FIAS July 19, 2017 in collaboration with S. Endres, J. Weil, M. Bleicher Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 1 / 40

Transcript of Goethe University Frankfurt and FIAShees/publ/alice17.pdf · Goethe University Frankfurt and FIAS...

  • Dileptons with a coarse-grained transport approach

    Hendrik van Hees

    Goethe University Frankfurt and FIAS

    July 19, 2017

    in collaboration with S. Endres, J. Weil, M. Bleicher

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 1 / 40

  • Outline

    1 Electromagnetic probesChiral symmetry and QCD phase diagramElectromagnetic radiation from hot/dense QCD matterHadronic many-body theory

    2 Bulk-medium evolution with transport and coarse grainingcoarse-graining in transport models

    3 Dileptons in heavy-ion collisionsDielectrons (SIS/HADES)Dimuons (SPS/NA60)Dielectrons at RHIC and LHCDielectrons at FAIR/RHIC-BES

    4 Signatures of the QCD-phase structure?

    5 Conclusions and Outlook

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 2 / 40

  • Electromagnetic probestheory perspective

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 3 / 40

  • Hadron phenomenology and chiral symmetry

    in vacuum: Spontaneous breaking of chiral symmetry

    ⇒mass splitting of chiral partners

    qq-excitations of the QCD vacuum

    π

    ρ ω

    φ

    (140)

    (770) (782)

    (1260)

    (1020)

    (1285)

    (400-

    1200)

    a f

    f

    f

    1 1

    1

    0

    Energy (MeV)

    P-S, V-A splitting

    in the physical vacuum

    (1420)

    0 1 2 3

    s [GeV2]

    0

    0.02

    0.04

    0.06

    0.08

    −Im

    ΠV

    ,A/(

    πs)

    [dim

    .−le

    ss]

    V [τ −> 2nπ ντ]

    A [τ −> (2n+1)π ντ]ρ(770) + cont. a

    1(1260) + cont.

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 4 / 40

  • The QCD-phase diagram

    hot and dense matter: quarks and gluons close together

    highly energetic collisions⇒ “deconfinement”quarks and gluons relevant dof⇒ quark-gluon plasmastill strongly interacting⇒ fast thermalization!

    0.0µ

    N

    0.05

    0.10

    0.15

    0.20

    0.25

    T [

    Ge

    V] SPS

    AGS

    SIS

    RHIC

    nuclei

    hadron gas

    〈q̄q〉 6= 0 〈qq〉 6= 0

    quark-gluon plasma

    〈q̄q〉= 〈qq〉= 0

    crit. point 1 storder

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 5 / 40

  • The QCD-phase diagram

    at high temperature/density: restoration of chiral symmetrylattice QCD: T χc ' T deconfc

    MassS

    pec

    tral

    F

    un

    ctio

    nS

    pec

    tral

    F

    un

    ctio

    n

    "a1"

    "ρ"pert. QCD

    Melting Resonances?

    "a1"

    "ρ"

    pert. QCD

    Dropping Masses?

    mechanism of chiral restoration?two main theoretical ideas

    “dropping masses”: mhad∝

    ψψ�

    “melting resonances”: broadening of spectra through medium effectsMore theoretical question: realization of chiral symmetry in nature?

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 6 / 40

  • Electromagnetic probes in heavy-ion collisions

    γ,`±: no strong interactions

    reflect whole “history” of collision:from pre-equilibrium phasefrom thermalized mediumQGP and hot hadron gasfrom VM decays after thermalfreezeout

    ρ/ω γ∗ e−π, . . .

    e+

    γ

    0 1 2 3 4 5

    mass [GeV/c2]

    dN

    ee /

    dyd

    m

    πo,η Dalitz-decays

    ρ,ω

    Φ

    J/Ψ

    Ψl

    Drell-Yan

    DD

    Low- Intermediate- High-Mass Region> 10 fm > 1 fm < 0.1 fm

    Fig. by A. Drees

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 7 / 40

  • Electromagnetic probes from thermal source

    photon and dilepton thermal emission rates given by sameelectromagnetic-current-correlation function (Jµ =

    f Q f ψ f γµψ f )

    McLerran-Toimela formula [MT85, GK91]

    q0dNγ

    d4 x d3 ~q=−

    αem2π2

    g µν Im Π(ret)µν (q , u )�

    q0=|~q |fB (q ·u )

    dNe +e −

    d4 x d4q=−g µν

    α2

    3q 2π3Im Π(ret)µν (q , u )

    q 2=M 2e+e−fB (q ·u )

    Lorentz covariant (dependent on four-velocity of fluid cell, u)

    q ·u = Ecm: Doppler blue shift of qT spectra!

    to lowest order in α: 4παΠµν 'Σ(γ)µν

    vector-meson dominance model:

    Σγµν =

    `+`−-inv.-mass spectra⇒ in-med. spectral functions of vector mesons (ρ,ω,φ)!

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 8 / 40

  • Radiation from thermal QGP: q q̄ annihilation

    General: McLerran-Toimela formula

    dN (MT)l +l −d4 x d4q

    =−α2

    3π3L (M 2)

    M 2gµνIm

    i

    Πµνem,i (M , ~q ) fB (q ·u )

    i enumerates partonic/hadronic sources of em. currents

    in-medium em. current-current correlation function

    Πµνem,i = i

    d4 x exp(iq x )Θ(x 0)

    j µem,i (x ), jνem,i (0)

    ��

    in QGP phase: q q̄ annihilation

    hard-thermal-loop improved em. current-current correlator

    q

    γ∗ γ∗−iΠem,QGP =

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 9 / 40

  • Hadronic many-body theoryhadronic many-body theory (HMBT) for vector mesons[Ko et al, Chanfray et al, Herrmann et al, Rapp et al, . . .]

    ππ interactions and baryonic excitations

    effective hadronic models, implementing symmetries

    parameters fixed from phenomenology(photon absorption at nucleons and nuclei, πN →ρN )evaluated at finite temperature and density

    self-energies⇒mass shift and broadening in the medium

    ρ ρ

    π

    π B , a , K ,...*1 1

    π,...N, K,

    ρ ρ

    Baryons important, even at low net baryon density nB−nB̄reason: nB+nB̄ relevant (CP inv. of strong interactions)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 10 / 40

  • Meson contributions

    0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2

    M [GeV]

    −30

    −20

    −10

    0

    10

    20

    30

    Re

    Σρ/m

    ρ [

    Me

    V]

    −70

    −60

    −50

    −40

    −30

    −20

    −10

    0

    Im Σ

    ρ/m

    ρ [

    Me

    V]

    a1

    π’h

    1K1

    ω

    f1

    sum

    T=150MeV

    q=0.3GeV

    ω

    suma

    1

    K1

    [RG99]

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 11 / 40

  • In-medium spectral functions and baryon effects

    [RW99]

    baryon effects importantlarge contribution to broadening of the peakresponsible for most of the strength at small M

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 12 / 40

  • Dilepton rates: Hadron gas↔QGP

    in-medium hadron gas matches with QGP

    similar results also for γ rates

    “quark-hadron duality”?

    [Rap13]

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 13 / 40

  • Bulk-medium evolution

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 14 / 40

  • Bulk evolution with transport and coarse graining

    established transport models for bulk evolutione.g., UrQMD, GiBUU, BAMPS, (p)HSD,...solve Boltzmann equation for hadrons and/or partons

    dilemma: need medium-modified dilepton/photon emission rates

    usually available only in equilibrium QFT calculations

    ways out:use (ideal) hydrodynamics⇒ local thermal equilibrium⇒ use equilibrium ratesuse transport-hydro hybrid model: treat early stage with transport, then coarsegrain⇒ switch to hydro⇒ switch back to transport (Cooper-Frye “particlization”)

    here: UrQMD transport for entire bulk evolution⇒ use coarse graining in space-time cells⇒ extract T , µB , µπ, . . .⇒ use equilibrium rates locally

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 15 / 40

  • Coarse-grained UrQMD (CGUrQMD)

    problem with medium modifications of spectral functions/interactions

    only available in equilibrium many-body QFT models

    use “in-medium cross sections” naively: double counting?!?

    way out: map transport to local-equilibrium fluid

    use ensemble of UrQMD runs with an equation of state

    space-time grid with∆t = 0.2 fm/c ,∆x = 0.8 fm

    fit temperature, chemical potentials, flow-velocity fieldfrom anisotropic energy-momentum tensor [FMRS13]

    T µν = (ε+P⊥)uµuν−P⊥g µν− (P‖−P⊥)V µV ν

    thermal rates from partonic/hadronic QFT become applicable

    here: extrapolated lattice QGP and Rapp-Wambach HMBT

    caveat: consistency between EoS, matter content of QFT model/UrQMD!

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 16 / 40

  • Coarse-grained UrQMD (CGUrQMD)

    Tc = 170 MeV; T > Tc ⇒ lattice EoS; T < Tc ⇒HRG EoS

    0ε/εEnergy density

    0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100

    Tem

    pera

    ture

    [M

    eV

    ]

    100

    120

    140

    160

    180

    200

    220

    240

    260

    280

    300

    =170 MeV)c

    Lattice EoS (T

    =0)B

    µHadron Gas EoS (for

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 17 / 40

  • Coarse-grained UrQMD (CGUrQMD)

    pressure anisotropy (In-In collisions (NA60) at SIS)

    Time t [fm]0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14

    -310

    -210

    -110

    1

    10

    210In+In @ 158 AGeV

    >=120η/dch

  • Coarse-grained UrQMD (CGUrQMD)

    energy/baryon density⇒ T ,µB (for In+In @ SPS; NA60)central “fluid” cell!

    Time t [fm]0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14

    0ρ/

    an

    d

    0ε/

    ε

    -210

    -110

    1

    10

    210In+In @ 158 AGeV

    >=120η/dch

    =120η/dch

  • Coarse-grained UrQMD (CGUrQMD)

    energy (ε) and baryon (ρ) density profiles (for In+In@SPS; NA60)

    x-axis [fm]-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8

    ]0

    ρ/ρ

    an

    d

    0ε/

    εE

    nerg

    y a

    nd

    bary

    on

    den

    sit

    y [

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120Transverse density profilesIn+In @ 158 AGeV

    t = 1fm:

    t = 3fm:

    t = 5fm:

    0ε/ε

    0ρ/ρ

    x 50

    ε/ε x 5

    0ρ/ρ

    x 80

    ε/ε x 8

    0ρ/ρ

    (a)

    z-axis [fm]-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8

    ]0

    ρ/ρ

    an

    d

    0ε/

    εE

    ne

    rgy

    an

    d b

    ary

    on

    de

    ns

    ity

    [0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120Longitudinal density profilesIn+In @ 158 AGeV

    t = 1fm:

    t = 3fm:

    t = 5fm:

    0ε/ε

    0ρ/ρ

    x 50

    ε/ε x 5

    0ρ/ρ

    x 80

    ε/ε x 8

    0ρ/ρ

    (b)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 20 / 40

  • Dielectrons (SIS/HADES)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 21 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Ar+KCl (1.76 AGeV) (SIS/HADES)

    coarse-graining method works at low energies!UrQMD-medium evolution + RW-QFT rates

    ]2M [GeV/c0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

    -1]

    2 d

    N/d

    M

    [Ge

    V/c

    ×)

    1/N

    (

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    -510

    -410

    -310

    -210UrQMD

    πη

    foωfo

    ρφρMedium

    ωMedium πMulti

    Coarse-Graining

    < 1.1 GeV/ce

    HADES acceptance, 0.1 < pAr + KCl @ 1.76 AGeV

    (a)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 22 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Ar+KCl (1.76 AGeV) (SIS/HADES)

    dielectron spectra from Ar+KCl(1.76 AGeV)→ e+e− (SIS/HADES)mt spectraMee < 0.13 GeV

    ]2 [GeV/ctm0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

    2/5

    ]2

    [G

    eV

    /ct

    dN

    /dm

    ×)

    3/2

    t)m

    1/(

    N(

    -610

    -510

    -410

    -310

    -210

    -110

    1

    10UrQMD

    πη

    foωfo

    ρφρMedium

    ωMedium πMulti

    Coarse-Graining

    2 < 0.13 GeV/ceeM

    (a) Ar + KCl @ 1.76 AGeV

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 23 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Ar+KCl (1.76 AGeV) (SIS/HADES)

    dielectron spectra from Ar+KCl(1.76 AGeV)→ e+e− (SIS/HADES)mt spectra0.13 GeVMee < 0.3 GeV

    ]2 [GeV/ct

    m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

    2/5

    ]2

    [G

    eV

    /ct

    dN

    /dm

    ×)

    3/2

    t)m

    1/(

    N(

    -810

    -710

    -610

    -510

    -410

    -310

    -210

    2 < 0.30 GeV/cee0.13 < M(b)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 23 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Ar+KCl (1.76 AGeV) (SIS/HADES)

    dielectron spectra from Ar+KCl(1.76 AGeV)→ e+e− (SIS/HADES)mt spectra0.3 GeVMee < 0.45 GeV

    ]2 [GeV/ct

    m0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2

    2/5

    ]2

    [G

    eV

    /ct

    dN

    /dm

    ×)

    3/2

    t)m

    1/(

    N(

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    -510

    -410

    -310

    2

    < 0.45 GeV/cee0.30 < M(c)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 23 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Ar+KCl (1.76 AGeV) (SIS/HADES)

    dielectron spectra from Ar+KCl(1.76 AGeV)→ e+e− (SIS/HADES)mt spectra0.45 GeVMee < 0.65 GeV

    ]2 [GeV/ct

    m0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    2/5

    ]2

    [G

    eV

    /ct

    dN

    /dm

    ×)

    3/2

    t)m

    1/(

    N(

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    -510

    -410

    2 < 0.65 GeV/cee0.45 < M(d)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 23 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Ar+KCl (1.76 AGeV) (SIS/HADES)

    dielectron spectra from Ar+KCl(1.76 AGeV)→ e+e− (SIS/HADES)mt spectraMee > 0.65 GeV

    ]2 [GeV/ct

    m0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6

    2/5

    ]2

    [G

    eV

    /ct

    dN

    /dm

    ×)

    3/2

    t)m

    1/(

    N(

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    -510

    -410

    2 > 0.65 GeV/cee M(e)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 23 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Ar+KCl (1.76 AGeV) (SIS/HADES)

    dielectron spectra from Ar+KCl(1.76 AGeV)→ e+e− (SIS/HADES)mt spectra

    rapidity spectrum (Mee < 0.13 GeV)

    Radpidity y-0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2

    dN

    /dy

    ×)

    1/N

    (

    -710

    -610

    -510

    -410

    -310

    -210

    -110

    12 < 0.13 GeV/ceeM(f)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 23 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Au+Au (1.23 AGeV) (SIS/HADES)

    ]2M [GeV/c0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

    -1]

    2 d

    N/d

    M

    [Ge

    V/c

    ×))

    0

    π(1

    /N(

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    -510

    -410

    -310

    -210

    < 1.1 GeV/ce

    HADES acceptance, 0.1 < pAu + Au @ 1.23 AGeV (b)

    caveat: pp/np acceptance filter with single-e cut, pt < 100 MeV

    correct filter urgently needed!

    excellent agreement with preliminary HADES data

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 24 / 40

  • Dimuons (SPS/NA60)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 25 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)

    M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    -510

    ρIn-medium ρNon-thermal

    QGP (Lattice)πMulti

    Sum

    ρThermal (no baryons)

    qPerturb. q

    For comparison:

    In+In @ 158 AGeV

    HG-EoS + Lattice EoS

    > 0 GeVT

    >=120, pη/dch

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)higher IMR: provides averaged true temperature〈T 〉1.5 GeV®M®2.4 GeV = 205-230 MeVclearly above Tc ' 150-160 MeV(no blueshifts in the invariant-mass spectra!)

    M [GeV]0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2 2.2 2.4 2.6 2.8

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    (b)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)pT < 0.2 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    ρIn-medium ρNon-thermal

    QGP (Lattice)πMulti

    Sum

    In+In @ 158 AGeV>=120η/dch

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)0.2 GeV < pT < 0.4 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    < 0.4 GeVT

    0.2 < p(b)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)0.4 GeV < pT < 0.6 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    < 0.6 GeVT

    0.4 < p(c)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)0.6 GeV < pT < 0.8 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    < 0.8 GeVT

    0.6 < p(d)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)0.8 GeV < pT < 1.0 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    < 1.0 GeVT

    0.8 < p(e)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)1.0 GeV < pT < 1.2 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    < 1.2 GeVT

    1.0 < p(f)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)1.2 GeV < pT < 1.4 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    < 1.4 GeVT

    1.2 < p(a)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)1.4 GeV < pT < 1.6 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    < 1.6 GeVT

    1.4 < p(b)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)1.6 GeV < pT < 1.8 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    < 1.8 GeVT

    1.6 < p(c)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)1.8 GeV < pT < 2.0 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    < 2.0 GeVT

    1.8 < p(d)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)2.0 GeV < pT < 2.2 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    < 2.2 GeVT

    2.0 < p(e)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)2.2 GeV < pT < 2.4 GeV

    Invariant Mass M [GeV]0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    ]-1

    ) [2

    0 M

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    /dM

    d2

    µµ

    (dN

    -1010

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    < 2.4 GeVT

    2.2 < p(f)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 26 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)

    -M [GeV]t

    m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2

    ]-2

    ) [G

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    d t/d

    m2

    µµ

    )(d

    Nt

    (1/m

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    -510

    -410ρIn-medium

    ρNon-thermal

    QGP (Lattice)

    πMulti

    Sum

    0.2 < M < 0.4 GeVIn+In @ 158 AGeVHG-EoS + Lattice EoS

    >=120η/dch

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)

    -M [GeV]t

    m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2

    ]-2

    ) [G

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    d t/d

    m2

    µµ

    )(d

    Nt

    (1/m

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    -510

    -410 0.4 < M < 0.6 GeV(b)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 27 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)

    -M [GeV]t

    m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2

    ]-2

    ) [G

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    d t/d

    m2

    µµ

    )(d

    Nt

    (1/m

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    -510

    -410 0.6 < M < 0.9 GeV(c)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 27 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: In+In (158 AGeV) (SPS/NA60)

    dimuon spectra from In+ In(158 AGeV)→µ+µ− (NA60) [EHWB15]min-bias data (dNch/dy = 120)

    -M [GeV]t

    m0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2

    ]-2

    ) [G

    eV

    η/d

    ch

    )/(d

    d t/d

    m2

    µµ

    )(d

    Nt

    (1/m

    -910

    -810

    -710

    -610

    -510

    -410 1.0 < M < 1.4 GeV(d)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 27 / 40

  • Dielectrons at RHIC and LHC

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 28 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Au+Au (p

    s N N = 200 GeV) (RHIC/STAR)

    ]2 [GeV/ceeM0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    )]2 [

    1/(G

    eV/c

    eed

    N/d

    M

    -310

    -210

    -110

    1

    10UrQMD

    0πη

    (fo)ω (fo)ρ

    φ

    Coarse-grainedρRapp in-med ωRapp in-med

    Multi-pionQGP (Lattice)

    = 200 AGeV (0-10% centr.)sAu+Au @ > 0.2 GeV/ce

    Tp

    | < 1ee

    | < 1, |yeη|

    STAR data

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 29 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Au+Au (p

    sN N = 200 GeV) (RHIC/PHENIX)

    ]2 [GeV/ceeM0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 1.4

    )]2 in

    PH

    EN

    IX a

    cc. [

    1/(G

    eV/c

    eed

    N/d

    M -510

    -410

    -310

    -210

    -110

    UrQMD

    0πη

    (fo)ω (fo)ρ

    φ

    Coarse-grainedρRapp in-med ωRapp in-med

    Multi-pionQGP (Lattice)

    = 200 AGeV (0-10% centr.)sAu+Au @ > 0.2 GeV/ce

    Tp

    > 0.1 radeeΘ| < 1, e|y

    PHENIX HBD data

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 30 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Pb+Pb (p

    sN N = 2.76+5.5 V ) (ALICE)

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 31 / 40

  • Dielectrons atRHIC-BES/FAIR/NICA

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 32 / 40

  • CGUrQMD: Au+Au (Elab = 2-35 AGeV)

    NB: also photon spectra [EHB16]

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 33 / 40

  • Signatures of theQCD-phase structure?

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 34 / 40

  • QCD phase structure from em. probes?

    hadronic observables like pT spectra:“snapshot” of the stage after kinetic freezeout

    particle abundancies: chemical freezeout

    em. probes: emitted during the whole medium evolutionlife time of the medium⇒ “four-volume of the fireball”use CGUrQMD to study system-size dependence

    study AA collisions for different A [EHWB15]

    “excitation functions”:systematics of `+`− (and γ) emission vs. beam energy [EHB16, RH16]similar study in [GHR+16]

    caveat: phase transition not really implemented!!!

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 35 / 40

  • Dilepton systematics in the beam-energy scan

    thermal-fireball model [RH16]

    beam-energy scan at RHIC and lower energies at future FAIR and NICAaccelerators

    dilepton yield as fireball-lifetime clock

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    10 1000

    5

    10

    15

    20

    Nℓ+

    ℓ−/

    Nch·1

    06

    τ fb(

    fm/

    c)

    √sNN (GeV)

    0.3GeV < M < 0.7GeVhadronicQGPsumsum (acc)×3.75τfb

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 36 / 40

  • Conclusions and Outlook

    General ideasem. probes⇔ in-medium em. current-correlation functiondual rates around Tc (compatible with χ symmetry restoration)medium modifications of ρ,ω,φimportance of baryon-resonance interactions

    Application to dileptons in HICscoarse-grained transport (here: CGUrQMD)allows use of thermal-QFT spectral VM functionsapplicable also at low collision energiesallows use of thermal-QFT models for dilepton ratessuccessful description from SIS to RHIC energiesconsistent description of M and mT spectra!effective slope of M spectra (1.5 GeV

  • Bibliography I

    [EHB16] S. Endres, H. van Hees, M. Bleicher, Photon and dilepton productionat the Facility for Proton and Anti-Proton Research and beam-energyscan at the Relativistic Heavy-Ion Collider using coarse-grainedmicroscopic transport simulations, Phys. Rev. C 93 (2016) 054901.http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.93.054901

    [EHWB15] S. Endres, H. van Hees, J. Weil, M. Bleicher, Dilepton production andreaction dynamics in heavy-ion collisions at SIS energies fromcoarse-grained transport simulations, Phys. Rev. C 92 (2015) 014911.http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.92.014911

    [FMRS13] W. Florkowski, M. Martinez, R. Ryblewski, M. Strickland, Anisotropichydrodynamics, Nucl. Phys. A 904-905 (2013) 803c.http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2013.02.138

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 38 / 40

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.93.054901http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.92.014911http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2013.02.138

  • Bibliography II

    [GHR+16] T. Galatyuk, P. M. Hohler, R. Rapp, F. Seck, J. Stroth, Thermal Dileptonsfrom Coarse-Grained Transport as Fireball Probes at SIS Energies, Eur.Phys. J. A 52 (2016) 131.http://dx.doi.org/10.1140/epja/i2016-16131-1

    [GK91] C. Gale, J. I. Kapusta, Vector dominance model at finite temperature,Nucl. Phys. B 357 (1991) 65.http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0550-3213(91)90459-B

    [MT85] L. D. McLerran, T. Toimela, Photon and Dilepton Emission from theQuark-Gluon Plasma: Some General Considerations, Phys. Rev. D 31(1985) 545.http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.31.545

    [Rap13] R. Rapp, Dilepton Spectroscopy of QCD Matter at Collider Energies,Adv. High Energy Phys. 2013 (2013) 148253.http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2013/148253

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 39 / 40

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1140/epja/i2016-16131-1http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0550-3213(91)90459-Bhttp://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.31.545http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2013/148253

  • Bibliography III

    [RG99] R. Rapp, C. Gale, ρ properties in a hot meson gas, Phys. Rev. C 60(1999) 024903.http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.60.024903

    [RH16] R. Rapp, H. van Hees, Thermal Dileptons as Fireball Thermometerand Chronometer, Phys. Lett. B 753 (2016) 586.http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2015.12.065

    [RW99] R. Rapp, J. Wambach, Low mass dileptons at the CERN-SPS: Evidencefor chiral restoration?, Eur. Phys. J. A 6 (1999) 415.http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s100500050364

    Hendrik van Hees (GU Frankfurt/FIAS) Dileptons in coars-grained transport July 19, 2017 40 / 40

    http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevC.60.024903http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.physletb.2015.12.065http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s100500050364

    Electromagnetic probesChiral symmetry and QCD phase diagramElectromagnetic radiation from hot/dense QCD matterHadronic many-body theory

    Bulk-medium evolution with transport and coarse grainingcoarse-graining in transport models

    Dileptons in heavy-ion collisionsDielectrons (SIS/HADES)Dimuons (SPS/NA60)Dielectrons at RHIC and LHCDielectrons at FAIR/RHIC-BES

    Signatures of the QCD-phase structure?Conclusions and Outlook