GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P...

31
GÒǕɐĵțȰɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮ ǚ¬ɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮğS1LJú,ȽKǍħ ȸēȩɍȰƢǧ 2ŵČ

Transcript of GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P...

Page 1: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

GÒǕɐĵțȰɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮ!��ǚ¬ɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮğS1LJú,ȽKǍħ!

ȸēȩɍȰƢǧ�

!!

2�ŵČ�

Page 2: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

�)�&$ ',#��--0�1.!£ýǔã(2005)ȕ~�ȻȞȥɌƄ�ȺIJ�Ɉ~�Ƚ.4ɐŬÔʏşıʏi�ȩȮɌȰɅȽĈȔȺğSȖ�ȴȣɌȧȸʑǗĿʒȱȥȷȺȣȒȯȽ¼ȽŬÔʏşıʏNjsʑɿɲɢʂʎɮʒȻɆǓÉȪȰǒ¬ȵȣɋȠÁƑȱȸțȜÇƧȽǮɃɋȒ~�'Ĕʏ�ą�ʏ~ċŹśȠ�(ȸȺȳȶ~�ȽǯOȵȣɋȻ`ɋŦɆȜȸȬɌSȡȠŽñȻȚɌȓ!!2.!z}�DŽŅ(2007)!ȕ~�ȻȞȥɌƄ�ȺIJ�Ɉ~�Ƚ.4ɐŬÔʏi�ȩȮɌȰɅȽȒ'Ĕʏ�ą�ʏ~ċŹśȻɉɌ�(ŀȺ`ɋŦɄȖ!!→ǗĿȟɊŬÔşıʏğĵɁȸǔħȠŐȳȰȧȸɐ¶ƣȪȒĔǘȽƀĿÄɁȽöºȓ!!�

Page 3: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

¨q�ª���,�n�+�t j^�

�|�¥$¨u§ YZ�ª�!�O�¬���/�+���B47<FL7�~`��������o��ef M��b��N���+�3>17 ��¢W'N� Mu�j£��+������|�N�'¬.�� (��#��p��+ ���

Page 4: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

�[R���R�cr !&�-/�Q��S��e�����«V��Y�­«V����m�� M��"�.��(�����].l%+O�+���AHK:IL�wv�g� k���].�����"�XT a*�#����p��� P�#��%),+���������]®9>;¯.�$�YZ��ª�. �i'����� ����zy�U'�P�#.� +����

"��� zy \��

Page 5: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

1ʔƇzATCMȻɉɌɨɕʎɥʎɨʐɿɲɢʂʎɮȽ�ŶȑȕǒÀɈɃȲȽ�ÀǑɐɉɋıÆȻǁțǯOŀȺ�ÎȻȪȶțȣȰɅȽȒ�ĈȺ�(ȽdžßȻɉɌœĆŀɔɱɡɒɬɓɹȓĒȹȽ�gȾ?ĔdžßʑɶʐɮɰʐɡɫɺʒȽ¸ɐ`ɋȒĈȔȺJ�ɐũgȪȺȠɊ�ąɐƉȜȓȖ!!2ʔNY¬ȽBIDȽ�ŶȑȕBIDsȾNY¬ȽǔƑȺ?ĔdžßʑɶʐɮɰʐɡɫɺʒȷȚɋȒǁǟʋɻʊȽğÄUɐDŽȫȶ¬>(ȽŧġǗĿȽȡȳȟȥɐNɋFȬɆȽȷȚɌȓȖ!BIDY"Ƚ�ŶȕBIDȾȒ�ąIJ�Ƚi�ɈɖʉɒȽQOLɐǮɅɉȜȸŸȝɌƳĴÎõŹɈpąɬɰʎɮȻɉȳȶćÊȩɍɌȒ?ŀȺv(ȷȚɋȒȯȽƬģȾ>ȶƫÒǕȻɉȳȶƲɏɍɌȓȖ!!→Ʀ�zȻȞȥɌɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮʑǩ$ʒȾȒ?ĔdžßȽ�ØȥȻɉȳȶŧġÖƂɐƉȜȧȸȒ~�Ƚ�ƌLȠŌ2ȩɍȶțɌȧȸȠìƚȩɍɌȓ!•  ŦųUɈƬģƣǍȻǙȬɌL´!•  ?@ŕǘȽŬÔşıʏğĵȻǙȬɌċǜŐƩ!

���)�&$ ',#��("*��������!�,&$ ',#�BID�� ����--$

Page 6: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

~�Cij�ąȻɄɌ?ĔdžßȽ¸�

ţŢĔǘ�ą�

ţŢ?@�ą�

?@ɠʐɷɣ�ʑPFI,!ĔsUȒÕ�şıŹśʒ�

?@ƳĴğĵ�ʑ?õ~ğĵĔǘ�ąȒ?@éƛƱƮśʒ�

ƓLʏƠ¢�ʑ!ąƠƁȒɃȲȞȧȪȒ�ąCijȒÐƊǗĿȒƕ;ǡ�śʒ�

� Ĕ

?@ɠʐɷɣ�� ?@ƳĴğĵ�� ƓLʏƠ¢��

�ąŕǘȽÎõŹ� �� �� Ĕ�

�ąNjsŹ� �� Ĕ� Ĕ�

FAʒĀ÷Ŏ�ȕ~�CijȻǕƈɐğȟȬȖ�ƅFĩōɉɋÑŢʏůǡ�

?Ĕdžß�ąȽ�ȣȾȒȕħȖȑandȑƉâ×Z�ąŹǘȽdžß!ȑȑȑȑȑȑȑȑȑȑȑȑȑȑȑȑȑ↓ȑ↓ȑ↓!ɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮȠŃÕȬȽȾȒȕǣȖ!andȑ�äǙ0ŹȽdžß!�

Page 7: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

�)�+%*������.�������/$$

!ȑȑȑȑȑȑȑȑNjS��

ħ�

ǣ�

]P� Y7� ƀŖ�

�ƙ��

ō"Ƶą��

~ċŹ�¢��

'Ĕ]P��

ɨɔɺ� ō"Ƴ÷ȽğĵȸdžßȽ¸� ,�

�ƙ�� Õ�şıŹȒ�ƙɐaȥȶ?@éƛşıʏğĵɐƉȜȓğSȽȺȟȷȒ�ǑȒǣŀȺ±ȠɋɐõȬɌȓ�

ǖę?|ʑɸʅʐɢʆʎǖęʒȒďǠ¬ŖxòǪǰś!

~ċŹ�¢�� BIDȒCǗĿ�ɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮŦųȺȹȠȒY�Ȼɉȳȶ?@ŕǘȽĔǘşıʏğĵ�

�ǚɜʈʎɸʌʎɮȒĘĻ~�DŽƸȒ� õ~WȽ¨ŗŭnjʏƉ°~�DŽƸʏ�njDŽɋś�

ō"Ƶą�� ĮŖ!ąȸȪȶƋȽê�ƳģɐğĵȒ?ĔdžßȻɉɌéƛå6Ɉ?õ~Ƚğĵ�

¦ÏņťĝĸɘɚʐʊȒV�©¬��ōȒüͬɃȲȵɛʉɖɔɬɓɹś�

'Ĕ]P�� ijğŹ�¢ȷƉâȸYƨʏÜƖËțȾ]PȻɉɌɃȲȵȣɋğSȽ�ƹ�

ĶƪWȼȧȫɇɊȪ?|ǰś��

NjS�� ō"�ǭȻɉɌ?@ŕǘȽğĵȒɩɔɒʌʐɜȻɉɌɒɔɭɒNFȒ�ùżÊȑś�

ʀɤɻʉʎɜȒʉɳɻʐɡʆʎɣɛʐʊȑśǰ�

~�Ƚ@hƳ÷ȻǙȬɌÇÂĚ�Ȼ]PȪȒȯɍɐ�ǞȻNjsȬɌ�ŦɄ�

Page 8: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

]ŸƳæ!ªȑ�ǚ¬ɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮğS1LJú,ȻǙȬɌçźƚ�!dȑVĠnj5Ŋ�ĸȽɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮú,ĄƘƳæ�

VĠnjʏ5Ŋ�ĸ!ɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮú,ÊŖʑ2014.9.16)�

�ǚ¬!ɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮğS1LJú,ÊŖ(2014.2.26)�

��������!

���������!

!!!!!! �

���BID���

Page 9: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

?ȸŏȽǘȽǦ�ɁȽĞŃʑƀě(ʒ�

#ɀȺțƬâ!!ɔʎɸʈȽŷøUȸŬÔʏCůȻiȥȰƫÒȽÃ�!!çȰȺɔʎɸʈȽå6ÏĜȽĊŤ!

ɔʎɥʎɬɓɹȻɉɌĔǘ�¢ȻɉɌɔʎɸʈå6ɈşıȽèĜȠƢǧ�

�ǚ¬ɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮğS1LJú,ʑ2014.2ÊŖʒ�

�ǚ¬*ÊƳæ�

Page 10: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

?ȸŏȽǘȽǦ�ɁȽĞŃʑĔǘʒ�

ɜʌʐɵʊȺǒ¬ʏ~�ǘŘ�ȽȺȟȷȒǯOȸ3ÄȚɌ~�ȵȣɋɐƉȜȧȸɁȽƑƤȠǮɃȳȶțɌȓ�

ƉâȸĔǘ�ąŹʑ~ċŹʒȠ@Ȼ`ɋŦɑȷțȣȧȸɁȽɱʐɤʑīȻȒ�(ŀȺŕǘJĵȻǙȬɌƓLŰnʒ�

?njȸŏõ~Ƞ�(UʑJĵȻȾ\ĵƜbȠÁƑȱȳȰʒ�

±�ǑGȾȒTMOȠÕ�şıŹȸȪȶ¬Ȼ�ɏȳȶĔǘşı�

Page 11: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

?ȸŏȽǘȽǦ�ɁȽĞŃʑz}�DŽŅʒ�z}�DŽŅō"Ƴ÷å6�ƨ"ǒ¬ɿɲɢʂʎɮ£�o"ȷȾȒǒ¬éƛʏɔʎɸʈȽå6�(ɈèĜȠ�ĈUȬɌ�ȒȯȽŬÔşıȻȴțȶƨƥɐƉȳȶțɌȓ�

ĔǘȠå6ʏşıȬɌ!?@ŀȺéƛ�

~è?@v(Ƞå6ʏşıȬɌ?@éƛ�

~è?@v(Ƞå6ʏşıȬɌ?ĪşıĜȠȺț?@éƛ�

ĔǘȠ!å6ʏşıȬɌ!?@ŀȺéƛ�

~è?@v(Ƞå6ʏşıȬɌ?ĪşıĜȠȺț?@éƛ�

~è?@v(Ƞå6ʏşıȬɌ?@éƛ�

�Pʏ�ĈUʏƏgUȠƒǀɃɍɌéƛȒɔʎɸʈ�

z}�DŽŅȕřʘuȑçȰȺï�Ƚǒ¬ɿɲɢʂʎɮ£�o"ȖǓ­ƳæɉɋÑŢȪȒŚŹȠCİȪȰɆȽ�

~�ƋȒDŽƸȒǬƻ�ȒǬƾ�Ȓ?Ǘŕ~ȑś�

njƸȒǒ¬?|Ȓ�Ėnjś�

Page 12: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

�ǚ¬!BIDú,Ɂ!ȑ①ɜʈʎɸʌʎɮȻȞȥɌɨɕʎɿɲɢʂʎɮȽ`ŦɄ�

ú,MȟɊ�ɃȳȶțȰɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮȽ`ŦɄȓȯȽȰɅȽƬģƣǍɈƓLȠɴʐɯʊȓ�

�ǚ¬BIDĄƘ�o"ƳæɉɋÑŢ�

Page 13: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

ȗÜƖʕȘ!ǙƐ�ǒ¬{Ƚɹʈʎɯɐ¸ÊȬɌ�ȷ�ǒ¬{ÌļŀȻǔƑȺǒÀɖʉɒȻȞțȶȒȕʡʓʞʠʟȖȻɉɌ�ĔdžßȽ!ą]P�ɃȲȵȣɋɐÚLJȬɌȓ�○!ąʛǰɃȲȵȣɋȽ�(ȸȪȶȒ!ąȽY7ȸ'ĔśȸȽdžßȻɉɋğSɐ¥Ǘ�○ƉâʛǰƓLŰnʏ�Ǒċǜ�ƩśȻɉɋĔȠğSȪɈȬțIJ�å6śɐƉȜ�○ŧġĺʛKFBID!ȽŖ�ȦʏğSàÞȒƉâȸȽŲȢ¹ȒzɁȽ7ȡȟȥśɐƉȜȓ�șɞɒɖʉɒʛǰăĶȒ¾�ŜȒ��§Ȓ�ǚ�lƿȒ��lƿȒtúDŽȺȹ]!!ȗÜƖʖȘȕʡʓʞʠʟȖȽɃȲȵȣɋȾǙƐȽzǞŘ�OȽi�Ȼ�ȬɌğSȷȚɌȧȸɐƺɃȝȒȧȽğSȽð^ʏ�ňȸŪūÄɐÒ2ȬɌȰɅȻȒȩɊȺɌàÞÛŴśȽL´¶UɐĄƘȬɌȓ!①!?@ŕǘşıʏNjsȻ0ɌƓLŰnǰʑĐnjśȽ�ÓŀĔǘşıL´Ⱥȹʒ�②!ğSƬģ��UȽȰɅȽÛŴǰʑɃȲȵȣɋv(ɁȽ��ƉĨȻ0ɌĢőÛ�ŴȒ¡ûŀȺƢǧȸȪȶȒʞʠʟőLȽ¢=ɐĄƘʒ!!FAʒȕʉʐɢʆʎʏɞɒȽɃȲȵȣɋÚLJȻiȥȶʤ!ą]PȽȰɅȽ�ŦɄȋʡʓʞʠʟȌȽÜĂʤȖȒ?ŁōvĜ�ǰǙƐŧġdžg"ȑǒ¬NDžʏƕ;�o"ȑǙƐǒ¬{ȻȞȥɌǒ¬éŝŋŔ"Ȓ2012¯4ôɉɋÑŢ�

�ǚ¬ȑBIDú,Ɂȑȑȑ②ǙŧdžȽÜĂ�

Page 14: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

�ǚ¬ȑBIDú,Ɂȑȑȑ②¬¹ÎȻɉɌƢǧȽåı�

�ǚ¬ȻɉɌBIDú,ơì(2014.3)!ƳæɉɋÑŢ�

Page 15: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

�ǚ¬ȑBIDú,Ɂȑ③¬¹ÎȻɉɌŸȝèȽåı�

yq���T?�

��&�A�KuZ`�Ia���

5=-0+�dF�

�,:=2(04��>CP �

�Npt�!���

^h��$�/*=7�#%�

���������� ��

,:=2(04���

>Cyq�

�,:=2(04dF<yq�

���� ������224�����

�[HroJczlw�V��)9(63.8;1mO��n����Ue{kl�V��Ia�

'G]�%��'X %L\'�[gD���M~�%��'jX�

�ǚ¬BIDĄƘ�o"ƳæɉɋÑŢ�

Page 16: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

i}�&�/*=7��

?B|s�%UQ|s"�[HrdF|s� ����)9(63.8;1Z�)9('X �

?��KEW�RX����Ia��_SZ���%Y��mOf~'X %�������

ʢ

����ʣ

�ʢ

��ʣ

~WƗĹȒǒ¬�

Cijå6ƗĹȽ�

Ă*Ê�

ǒ¬J/�LJ�

Y�ȽŮŨ�

~WNjsƗĹȽ�

*Êʑ¯´Ȩȸʒ�

ɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮ�

ğSȽ�é�

�ą�kò

Ƚ*Êś�

¬ǖȽƟ�� ¬ǖȽƟ�� ¬ǖȽƟ��

GÒǕú,ȽL��

ʑ~WȨȸʒ�

GÒǕ¿_Ȓ���

łʼnȒîĎ�

m�ś�

ǒ¬ƗĹ�ƨ"� �ǚ¬"�

ʑǒ¬CijĜǵǶúȒ�ȑǒ¬ƗĹĜDzdzúȽʘʒ� ʑǒ¬CijĜǷdzúȽʗʒ� ʑ¬ú,ʖúʒ� ʑ¬ú,ȷƓ�ʒ�

ǒ¬Cijå6�

ÚLJĜ�ȽƛŖ�

¬ǖȽÕ��

ʑǒ¬CijĜǷǴúʒ�

�l@�~v�� �|s�xXʑɖʉɒȒ�ąB�Ȓ_àƗĹȺȹʒ�� �mO�Yf��

�ÿ�o"�

ʢ

� ���ʣ

�b�$��

ʑ~èƀěĜdzdzǵȒdzdzǸúʒ�

�ǚ¬ȑBIDú,Ɂȑ③ĄƘȩɍȰBIDú,ȽćDž�

Page 17: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

�ǚ¬ȑBIDú,Ɂȑ③ǒ¬J/�LJY�ȸȾ�

ǒ¬ŕǘȷȒ÷ûȽÎõʏşıŹɐƶȝȶȒ�ÓȪȰğĵɐƉȜȰɅȽY�!!ȯȽY�B�ȻȾȒéƛȽɻʐɡɫɛȺŬÔşıȱȥȷȺȣȒɔɻʎɮ�éȺȹȽğĵǑGɆjɃɍɌȓ�

÷ǤƳæȾȒǒ¬J/�LJY�ơìƳæɉɋÑŢ�

Page 18: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

�ǚ¬ȑBIDú,Ɂȑ!④¬ȠÆ�ȬɌBIDú,ȻɉɌ�UȒēȩɍȰƢǧ�

ƢǧȏʜGÒǕȽǎĵŠwȻǙȬɌŸȝèȽŌŖȎȹȧɃȷǎĵȷȡɌȟȠìŌȷȺȣȒ�uȾȒȟȺɋǜ�ŀȺNjĵȟɊ�ɅɌȧȸȻȺȳȰȓ�

FAʒ�ǚ¬BIDĄƘ"ƳæɉɋÑŢ�

Page 19: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

�ǚ¬ƳæɉɋÑŢȪȒDŇư��

Page 20: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

�ǚ¬ȑBIDú,Ɂȑȑ④BIDú,ȑēȩɍȰƢǧ�

ƢǧȐʜȑɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮv(Ƚ~%ŌŖ!!İĭȷȾȒ�ƃōvĜ�ȸȺɌbžÄȠǮțȑȎȑɃȲȵȣɋğSȽƬģȸȪȶǐ9ȩɍ!Ɍ?@ŕǘȷȽ_Ł�ąȻƢőȩɍɌİĭɐ�ȝɌȧȸɁȽɱʐɤ�

�ǚ¬BIDĄƘ�o"]ŸƳæɉɋÑŢ�

Page 21: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

šƇȽBIDȽŸȝè�BIDȾ)ɐȬɌʝ!1ʔ�Ʌ�ɅɊɍȰɖʉɒȻȞțȶȒ�ĈȺȕǂPŀ(supplemental)Ȗɠʐɷɣ^ɀå6�ąɐƉȜȓA�ŀȺ�ąȾȒ��ȽDŽɋȓ!①ŵUʏŬÔşı!②ě�ŬÔ!③ɿʐɝɬɓʎɜ!④Ƌ�Ʉå6�ą!⑤ñƕi�Ȓşı�ą!⑦pąŀɠʐɷɣ!ȺȞȒBIDȻɉɌɠʐɷɣȾȒ¬â³ȠÜ-ȬɌɠʐɷɣȽŻ�ɏɋɐȬɌɆȽȷȾȺțȓ!!2ʔBIDȾȒ¬â³ȸ~�ɞʀʅɱɬɓȽǘȽʉɖɧʎȸȪȶčžȬɌȓ!

®±țğS�

①BIDL´ȻɉɋȒ��Ƚ�ƌLɐŌ2ȬɌȧȸȷȒ?ȸŏɐȴȺȤĤâ³ŀȺ~%ȠŌŖȩɍȶțɌȓ!!②ȕǂPŀȖɠʐɷɣȻȾȒ?ĪşıȽɄȺɊȭȒɿʐɝɬɓʎɜɈɔɻʎɮȒñƕi�ȺȹȽɦɸɮ�ąȠ�ȣjɃɍɌȓ�

NY¬ȽBIDơìƳæɐńƝʏƼƽ�

Page 22: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

Times!Square!Alliance�

! ƛŖ¯ȑ1992¯!! Šwȑ40F53�ŃȽ6ĽƋȟɊ8ĽƋȻȟȥȶ!! ̄ ǘ�ŞȑUS!$!15,955,914!! Njsv(ȑTimes!Square!Alliance!!501C(3)ƟƞȽǢsJv(!

! �ȺğSB�ȑ!!ě�ŬÔȒŵUȒĐƉŕǘśȽárʏŬÔşıȒ!ɷɢɨʐɥʎɨʐȒɨɔʁɤɣɛɖɒ[ĪǪȽNj!sȒfŒɔɻʎɮʑNew!Year‘s!EveȒ!Broadway!on!!BroadwayʒȒ~�ƢǧȽ�ƨȸâŝÜĂ�

Page 23: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

ǾȂȄȁȈǰǽȆȉȀȇȁǰǹǻǺDZǰǼȁȊǰǿȅȇȃȍ

ĺó�ȽȞɆȶȺȪŕǘȽĥF�

�ª=6:L8K:L'BEL60C¦d�

e_XT ¤�.����?JDL5GK'2@K;�

�h©x {¥s�

YZ�ª U} ¡���

Page 24: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

ƬģȟɊƒɌɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮ�

ƫÒǕ,!11,024,000!ƎQ

Ǖ,!5,905!

��Ǖ,!3,000,763!

İĪ��,!361,163!

ɷɢɨʐɥʎɨʐʈɔɥʎɣ_=,!428,020!

ȯȽ��ą_=,!1,119,807!

J�,!16,256!

ɨɔʁɤɣɛɖɒBIDȽ_=ćDžʑ2011¯´ƬTʋɾʐɮɉɋʒ�

ƓĊȽ«�

Page 25: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

ƬģȟɊƒɌɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮ�

ɨɔʁɤɣɛɖɒBIDȽàFBƝʑ2011¯´ƬTʋɾʐɮɉɋʒ�

ɿʐɝɬɓʎɜ,!3,505,568!

ɷɢɨʐɥʎɨʐ,!

1,194,461!

ě�ŬÔ,!3,594,612!

ŵU,!3,601,663!

âŝYƨʏÜĂ,!725,026!

?@ŕǘå6ʏŬÔşı,!

20,188!

�ąǗĿ,!86,684!

ɿɲɢʂʎɮ,!1,681,247!

ƳǕƣǍƯĵ,!33,270! ɦɸɮ�ąɁȽ

ǓG�

Page 26: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

BIDőʏƫÒǕȽŸȝè�AdFvaloremʑ.4džS�ʒȸnon!adFvaloremʑǢ.4džSʒȽƯĵƫÒȽȚɋè!!ȑMŹȽA�Ⱦy�ƳĴőȱȠȒī�~Wȷī�ɠʐɷɣɐÜ-ȬɌɉȜȺ�gȻȾȒȯȽƯĵȻȟȟɌƫÒɐƳĴÎõŹʏ~ċŹȻėɅɌȧȸȠȚɌʑ�ĖnjȒƋ�Ʉå6Ȓɟʀ_ǡʏEıśʒȓBIDƫÒǕɆȯȽ�ŒȸȩɍȒī�Ƚ�ąɐÁƑȸȬɌ~WȽ~ċŹȠȒȯȽ�ąȻȟȟɌƯĵɐGÒȬɌȸțȜŸȝèȷȚɌȓ!

AdFvaloremȷȚɍȿȒy�ƳĴőȽ���Ƣő!Non!adFvaloremȷȚɍȿȒGÒǕʑ~èƀěĜř224úʒ!

ȕy�ƳĴőȻȞȥɌ���ȺƢőȻȴțȶȖ(ƀěőT¤ǖDŽǍʏƉ�ín51!¯�ʙô26!ëƀěyř48!e)ȽDŽǍ!ȑ①y�ƳĴőȾĪőȷȚɌȸțȜ�÷ŀÄāȟɊȪȶȒy�ƳĴȽÎõŹȒŒǩȒƢőĉĤśȽțȟɑɐqɏȭȒȯȽőįȾȬɂȶȽy�ƳĴɐDŽȫȶ�»ȷȺȥɍȿȺɊȺțȸŸȝɊɍɌȓ!ȑ②ī�Ƚy�ƳĴȻ Ȫȶ�Ƚy�ƳĴȸľȺɌőƫÒɐȩȮɌȧȸȾřʚúřʖǥȟɊbžȷȚɌȠȒĪőȸȪȶȽ�÷ŀÄāɐMÜȸȪȶĜL´ȠŦɄŖȶɊɍȶȞɋȒ���ƢőȾȯȽµMɐLjſȬɌɆȽȸȪȶƜȩɍȺțɆȽȸȪȶțɌȓ!ȑ③3�ʏĜ�ȸțȳȰy�ƳĴȽÎõŹȽWGȒƢőĉĤǨȽ�£Ȓy�ƳĴȽŒǩIɃȰȾĵǃIȻɉɋőƫÒȽ«ɐƛȥɌÛŴȾĜȽ��ȬɌȸȧɎȷȾȺȣƉȜɂȡȷȺțȓ�

ë÷ȻŴȡÝȝɌȸʏʏ�

Page 27: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

aŁŹƫÒȻɉɌ~�ɃȲȵȣɋȽŸȝè�

3,8J�

�����

S+�2R

M O' :/

>L�2R

MVO' ?"

=�UR

M6O' Z

bQA^;

�2R

Municipality Special District

?"X��U

R%W ?"X��UR

\%W

����

db= P$FE�(-

4F�#1�?

��97Da

=�B`

G��<&

*Y@c�

5�C�G

B`

H[���

<&*Y�

db%W=

�KB`�

dbe )IZ� ?"=]N0

!.e ��� ��� ����

9_Z

図-5 特別区の費用徴収方式

C T Porter Douglas R., “Special Districts: A Useful Technique for Financing Infrastructure, second edition,” p.26.

•  必要なサービスや事業があれば、そのための特別地区を設定する。

•  なかには、BIDのようにガバナンスの仕組みを伴うものもある。

çȰȺ�ąʏɠʐɷɣȻȾȒƬģȽƍ�ȥɐȴȥɌȧȸȠǔƔȓ�

Page 28: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

!~ǰ�ǰŧǰsǰɺǰʈǰɫǰɮǰɸǰɗǰʐǰʁ!!(BID)!

~WşıʑŬÔşıȒŵUȒǛĬʏǛĦśʒ!

!ąCSRdžß�ąȒɞʀʅɱɬɓğS!

�ĔdžßȽō"�ǭ!!

?@ŕǘȽğĵʑɔɻʎɮȒĪƭśʒ!

ɿʐɝɬɓʎɜʏɺʌʃʐɡʆʎ�

ō"�ąʑɽʐʁʋɣȒƆŹàÞʒ!

�ą_=ɐƒǀɑȱɔɻʎɮ!

ɖʉɒȻ�ȬɌ�v(Ƚ�ą!

~WȽƳĴɵʉʅʐɒɫɺ!

��ȒƱæśȻɉɌƫÒŹɁȽǐ9�

ȯȽ�Ƭģ!ʑ�ƙʏƎQǕȒ��Ǖśʒ!

ʋɵʋɫɢ!Rþ�

GÒǕ�

àÞ�àÞ� àÞ� àÞ�

~�ȽɺʈɫɮɸɗʐʁȸȪȶȽǹǻǺŦų�

~%ʏċǜ!Ƚ��

Page 29: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

?Ĕdžßɐ!ɔʎɥʎɬɓɹȸȪȰ!Ĕǘ�¢ɃȲȵȣɋ�

①?@éƛʏŕǘȽşı�ƙȎNjsċȽ×Ɂ!! NYC!Plaza!ProgramȽ3rd!ɣɬɫɺȷȚɌɞʎɥɫɡʆʎȽ�ȺÒțÏȾȒBIDʑTimes!Square)!!

! ƀƼƻ1LJɈĐnjȷȽɒɛɬɓɷɬɓȽɿɲʐɢʂʎɮɐƉȳȶțɌɝʐɣ(Miami!CityȷȾȒǬƻ�<ǝķƤæɈǬƻ�ɠʐɪʄʐɢɐƬģȸȪȰ�ąȽ�éɆBIDȻ�ƙȓ!London!BanksideȷɆhĈȽ�ƙ�ąɐ�éȓʒ!

!②?@�ąȎ?Ĕdžß�ąɁ!! BIDȽƗĹOȒɞʐɭɓɲʐɮOȽi�ȻɉɋȒƋ�Ʉå6�ąȺȹȾ?ĔdžßȷƉɏɍɌȓ!

ȑEx:!NYC!Grand!CentralɈTimes!SquareʑÜĂʒȒLondon!ȑȑBankside!BID!ʑŭȽ�ǕȽƛŴʏNjsʒ!!�

Page 30: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

New!York!CityȽ±�ɺʌɜʈʁ�

ɱʅʐʇʐɛ¬�DŽ¤ȾȒ~űv(ɈfŒȽɜʊʐɺȒBIDȺȹȒ¬BȷğSȬɌǢsJv(ȸdžßȪȒ&JĵĭÈȻȚɌnjƸŕǘɐğĕȚɌɦʐɡʄʊȺ?@ŕǘȻ�ȝɌȧȸɐDŽȫȒɲɔɵʐɸɫɯȷğĵȩɍɌ±�ɐȴȣȳȶțȡɃȬȓȧɍȾȒ>ȶȽɱʅʐʇʐəʐȠ½Đ10G�BȷƴȽǮțɘʐɺʎɣɼʐɣȻƉȥɌɉȜȻȬɌȸțȜ¬Ƚ`ŦɄȽ�ȴȸȪȶǔƔȪȶțɌɆȽȷȬȓ�

�Ⱥ�ŦɄ!ǢsJv(ȟɊȽķƤʑĚɃȳȰķƤöǘȠ¯ȻäuȚɌʒȻ�ȵȡ�é!!8:Ƒ !①ɘʐɺʎɣɼʐɣȠ�ƷȪȶțɌȧȸ!②ɞʀʅɱɬɓ�¢ȷȚɌȧȸʑêȻɞʀʅɱɬɓƗĹɐŝ�ȪȶțȰɋȒ�ÎȽǏ�ȠȺȩɍȶțȰɋȪȶȒ~�ȽɠɾʐɮȠƒǀɃɍɌȧȸʒ!③�ÎȽǎHÄʑlƿȽp²ȸȽǙ0ȒǫɁȽǁÙÄȒđcŀƳģȸȽǙ0ȺȹȒ±�ɐĄƘȬɂȡƑ ȠȚɌȧȸʒ!④ŦųȽNjsžOʑķƤŦųȠȒ�ÎȽŬÔşıȒɒɛɬɓɷɬɓȽ!ĹʏNjsśȽžOɐXGȻɆȲȒȯȽÇÂȠȚɌȧȸʒ!

Page 31: GÒ Õ P 5 0 V R r b n - meti.go.jp · L S @ T q a R l S y 9 = g >? Æß v n p a k z =¸ P ` K :J P ig * : J P ! 2 NY¬ =BID = v BIDs >NY¬ = Ô :? Æß v n p a k z 7

! ǒ¬ŕǘɈéƛȽ+țèɈ+țÏȾȒ�ȝɌȧȸȠȷȡɌ!→?@éƛȽŃŀ�+ĵɈéƛƛŴ�ĤśȽ·OŀNjĵȒ?@ŕǘ!ȑJĵȽƓLŰnɈʍʎɣɮɫɺU!!! ?@ŕǘȽğĵȟɊ_ŁɐȚȦȶȒȯɍɐ~�Ȼǐ9ȬɌȧȸȾȕ?@ŀȖɬʐɿȷȚɌ!

→ɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮŦųȽ\ĵæ<ǝȒ?ŁĜ�Ɵ�ȒȩɊȻȾȒȑ!ȑɒʂʉəȽɉȜȻȒ?@ŕǘȽNjĵċƛ�Ƀȷȓ!

! ~�Ƚȕ@hȖȽœɄǔȼȠǒ¬>(Ƚ?ŁȻȴȺȠɌ!→ɖʉɒɿɲɢʂʎɮŦųȽƟ�ʑƓLŰnȸɥɫɮʒȒɖʉɒɿ!ȑɲɢʂʎɮŦųʏƬâȻǙȬɌL´NƛȒ?ĔdžßȻɉɌŕǘş!ȑıɈğĵ!!! ȕɃȲɐÅȣȪȺțȖȟɊȕɃȲɐœĆŀȻɉȣȬɌȖƉĨȻƬâŀɔʎɥʎɬɓɹɐ!

→BIDȒTIF(y�ƳĴőȽ~�ǐ9Ƚ�ŦɄʒȻȺɊȳȶȓŕȡ~!ȑȻȪȰɊőL8ljȷȾȺȣȒȯɍɐǛĦŕ~ɈNJɀ�ȻȪȶ�Ǟ!ȑȻğĵȪȶțɌ�Ȼ8ljȒȒśȓ!