Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science Prof. Randolph ..."Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic...
Transcript of Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science Prof. Randolph ..."Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic...
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 1
1
Randolph M. Nesse, M.D.
The University of Michigan
"Evolution: Medicine's MissingBasic Science"
2
3
Medicine Uses Some Evolution
• Antibiotic resistance
• Evolutionary genetics
• Human phylogeny
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 2
4
But Much Is Missing
• Co-evolution and arms races
• Subtle evolutionary genetics
• Evolution and behavior
• Evolutionary epidemiology
• Asking why natural selection has left the body so vulnerable
5
Some General Principles?
• Imperfections cannot be eliminated because natural selection is too weak and random
• Selection shapes traits to benefit the species
• Pathogens evolve to co-exist with hosts
• Natural selection shapes health and longevity
• Genetic disease results from mutations that natural selection can’t eliminate
• Aging results because body parts wear out
• Natural selection cannot influence anything after reproduction ends
They are all false
6
General Principles Corrected
• Imperfections are present for 6 reasons
• Natural selection shapes traits for genes
• Pathogens evolve to maximize replication
• Natural selection shapes the body to maximize reproductive success
• Common genetic disease results mainly from quirks interacting with novel environments
• Aging results because of pleiotropy
• Natural selection continues after reproduction
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 3
7
Percent of schools that include topic in medical curriculum
(n = 55) Nesse & Schiffman, 2000
0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%100%
Antibiot ic resistance
Vir ulence evolution
Population genetics
Sel. for disease genes
Mutation sel. bal.
Levels of selection
Host-patho. arms races
Mism
atch of body-envir.
Design trade-offs
Comparative anatomy
Defense r egulation
Life history tr aits
Path dependen ce
Human p hylogeny
Kin selection
Proximate ultimate dis...
8
Evolutionary Biology Facultyin Medical Schools
9876543210
30
20
10
0
Std. Dev = 1.76
Mean = 1
N = 33.00
9
Gertrude Stein on Her Deathbed
“ The answer, the answer, what is the answer?The answer, the answer, what is the answer?...
No, no that’s not it
What is the question?”
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 4
10
Why Has Natural Selection Left the Body So Vulnerable?
Parts of the body are exquisite Others are botched
WHY?
11
The Old Answer: Natural Selection Is Just Too
Weak to Make the BodilyMachine Better
Flaws are inevitable because natural
selection is a random process
of limited power
12
The New Answer
There are six reasons why natural selection leaves
the body vulnerable to disease
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 5
13
14
15
Disease and Evolution
Disease is not shaped by selection
But vulnerabi li ty to disease is
Natural selection can help explain
maladaptation as well as adaptation
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 6
16
An Example: the Eye
• An organ of extreme perfection?
• Or, the exemplar of selection’s limits?
17
1. Upper eyelid
2. Lower eyelid
3. Lateral angle
4. Medial angle
5. Lacrimal caruncle
6. Limbus
7. Iris
8. Pupil
9. Lacrimal papilla
10. Sclera
11. Plica semilunaris
First Half of Medical School:An Organ of Perfection
18
In the Clinic: a Botched Design
•Glaucoma•Cataracts•Myopia•Presbyopia•Iritis•Corneal clouding•Retinal detachment
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 7
19
You Could Design a Better Bodyin One Afternoon!
• Eliminate the appendix
• Take out the wisdom teeth
• Turn the eye inside out
• Make bones stronger
• Improve immune responses
• Make blood clot a bit more slowly
• Install a zipper so babies can exit more easi ly!
20
Natural Selection
When heritable variations
in a trait influence
reproductive success, the trait wi ll inevitably
change over the generations
21
Two Kinds of Explanation
“No biological problem is solved unti l both the proximate and the evolutionary causation has been elucidated; Furthermore, the study of evolutionary causes is as legitimate a partof biology as is the study of the usuallyphysico-chemical proximate causes”
E. Mayr, 1982 The Growth of Biological Thought
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 8
22
Two Complementary Explanations
• Proximate explanations are about howa trait works
• Evolutionary explanations are about howa trait increases fitness
23
Tinbergen’s 4 QuestionsOrigins of Darwinian Medicine
1. Immediate causes
2. Developmental causes
3. Function4. Evolutionary origins
Tinbergen, 1963
24
Tinbergen’s 4 Questions Organized
New Question
Proximate Evolutionary
Transition over time Ontogeny Phylogeny
Cross section Mechanism Selective advantage
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 9
25
Four questions about
honeycreeper beaks
1. Mechanism
2. Ontogeny
3. Phylogeny
4. Selection
26
Darwin: On the Various Contrivances by Which Britishand Foreign Orchids Are Fertilised by Insects;
London John Murray, 1862
Angraecum sesquipedaleThe Star Orchid of Madagascar
Xanthopan morganii praedicta
Why would an orchidhave a spur 30 cm long?
27
Darwinian Medicine
• Noting radical or alternative about it
• Not opposed to allopathic medicine
• Not a method of practice
• Just applying a basic medical science whose power is just being recognized
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 10
28
How Is Evolution Usefulfor Medicine?
• Established contributions• antibiotic resistance
• genetics
• physiology
• Asking new research questions
• A deeper feeling for the organism• the analogy of body as machine is wrong
• the body is a bundle of evolved tradeoffs
29
Direct Applications in the Clinic?
• Medicine is suspicious of theory
• Direct applications mostly unwise
• But evolution inspires new research with major clinical implications
• And understanding that the body as a bundle of tradeoffs shaped by selection, fundamentally changes doctors understanding of why disease exists
30
Evolution and Medicine - Branches
• Genetics and pathogen evolution• Stearns, Ebert et al.
• Anthropology• Trevathan et al.
• Genetic indicators of selection• Wallace et al.
• Why selection leaves us vulnerable• Nesse, Williams et al.
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 11
31
32
Evolutionary Q. About Disease
• Why has natural selection left us vulnerable to disease?
• Not just why some people get sick
• Why has natural selection left us all with bodies that are vulnerable to disease
• Six possible reasons
33
Six Reasons Why Diseases Exist
Selection is slow1.Mismatch: body in a novel environment
2.Competition with fast evolving organisms
Selection is constrained3.Every trait is a trade-off
4.Constraints on natural selection
We misunderstand5.Organisms shaped for R/S, not health
6.Defenses and suffering
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 12
34
1. Mismatch
• Our bodies were never designed to cope with this novel environment
• Selection is slow
• The mismatch explains most chronic disease
• Our fulfi lled desires are ki lling us
35
Atheroma
36
Cholesterol Levels
• Modern American 200
• 20 pre-industrial 131
• 5 hunter-gatherer 123
• Rural Chinese 127
Eaton, et al.,
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 13
37
Breast Cancer• Much more common now
• Hormone exposure• 400+ cycles now, about 110 then
• Night light exposure
• blind Norwegians
• melatonin actions
• nurses study
• new rat studies
38
Genetic “Quirks”
• Harmless in a natural environment
• Cause disease in novel environment• atherosclerosis
• myopia
• drug abuse
39
Myopia
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 14
40
Mean Negative Affect Scores vs. BDNF Genotype(Sen, Nesse, Weder, Burmeister’s 2004)
25516120N =
BDNF Genotype
Val/ValVal/MetMet/Met
Mean Neuroticism +/- 1 SEM
95
85
75
65
N = 20 N = 161 N = 255
p = 0.0057Negative affect score
41
Hygiene Hypothesis
• Lack of exposure to pathogens deprives immune system of inhibitory components
• Rapidly increasing immune diseases (Rook)• type I diabetes
• Crohn’s disease
• asthma
• Acute lymphoblastic leukemia (Greaves)
42
Signals of Recent Selection
• Prevalent mutations with high linkage disequi librium
• ADH — Ken Kidd
• Lactase — in herders
• DRD4-7Rpt — Moyzis
• G6PD/ CD4OL — Lander-Malaria
• Apo E? — Sapolsky and Finch
• BDNF?? — Sen/Nesse Depression
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 15
43
BP, Genes, Latitude and EnvironmentYoung et al., PLOS 2006
44
2.Competition with Other Organisms
• Pathogens evolve faster
• Also predators and conspecifics
45
Streptococcal Infection
• Why not better defenses?
• Streptococci antigens mimic our proteins
• Rheumatic fever, scarlet fever, OCD
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 16
46
Antibiotic Resistance Profiling of 480 Soil-Derived Bacterial Isolates
V. M. D'Costa et al.,Science 311:374 -377 (2006)
47
Virulence
• Selection not for benignness
• Virulence maximizes spread
• Vectors increase virulence• mosquitoes — malaria• impure water — cholera• human hands!!
Anderson, May Ewald, Ebert, Levin, et al.
48
3. Every Trait Is a Trade-Off
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 17
49
Malaria in Melanesia
50Copyright©1997 by the National Academy of Sciences
Alpha + Thalassemia Protects Against Malaria
Allen, S. J. et al., (1997) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 94:14736-14741
51
Uric Acid Concentration/SMR vs. MLSP
-0.05
0
0.05
0.1
0.15
0.2
0.25
0.3
0 20 40 60 80 100
Years
Uric Acid/SMR
(mg/100ml)/(cal/g/day)
Gout
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 18
52
Why Bilirubin?Sedlak and Snyder, Pediatrics, 2004
53
4. Constraints
• Path dependence
• Mutation
• Weakness of selection
• Happenstance
54
Terrestrial Whales
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 19
55
Path Dependence
Vitreous chamber
Conjunctiva
Cornea
Anterior chamber
Iris
Blind spot
Optical nerve
Fovea
Neuralretina
Retinal pigment epithelium
ChoroidScleraEpidermis
of eyelid
Copyright 1997 The Anatomy Project
56
5. Health Is Not Selection’s Goal
• Selection maximizes reproductive success not health, longevity and happiness
• Reproduction trumps all
• senescence
• the feeble sex
57
Senescence and Pleiotropy
• Some genes that cause aging have no selective cost in the wi ld
• Others offer advantages early in life when selection is stronger
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 20
58
I = (IRYh - IRYa) / IRYh
59
Force of Selection Against Senescence• Dall sheep .86• Waterbuck .64 • Impala male .69• Buffalo male .79• Caribou .05• Himalayan Thar .18• Zebra male .41• Black rhinoceros .24• Hippopotamus .75• African elephant .40• Herring gull .04• Lapwing .06• Great tit male .26 • American Mallard -.03• Blue jay .02• Lake trout .22• Sessile rotifer .60• Barnacles .57• Human, USA, 1970 .85
60
If Mortality Stayed at EarlyAdulthood Rates Throughout Life
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 21
61
The Vulnerable Sex
• Consider the mortality ratio
• percent of males who die in a year--------divided by--------
percent of females who die in a year
• M.R. > 1.0 means that proportionately more males than females are dying
62
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 to 4
5 to 9
10 to 14
15 to 19
20 to 24
25 to 29
30 to 34
35 to 39
40 to 44
45 to 49
50 to 54
55 to 59
60 to 64
65 to 69
70 to 74
75+
Age G roup
M:F Mortality Ratio
Australi a
Belgu im
Canada
Colomb ia
El Salvado r
Fi nland
France
Greece
Irelan d
It aly
Japan
Norway
Po land
Si ngapore
Russia
Sp ain
Sweden
Sw itzerland
Ukrain e
USA
63
Developmental Pleiotropy a Prediction
• Only .0001% of sperm ferti lize an egg
• Only 20% of ferti lized eggs go to term
• A mutation that gave a tiny incremental advantage at these stages would spreadeven if i t caused disease• sperm motility, fertilization advantage
• implantation advantage ( HLA-diabetes)
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 22
64
6. Defenses and Suffering
Nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, fever, coughfatigue, anxiety are painful but useful responses
65
Pain or suffering of any kind, if long continued, causes depression and lessens the power of action; yet it is well adapted to make a creature guard itself
against any great or sudden evi lCharles Darwin, 1887, pp. 51-52
66
Defenses vs. Defects
• Defects• seizures
• cancer
• paralysis
• jaundice
• injury
• Defenses• fever
• cough
• pain
• fatigue
• anxiety
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 23
67
Defense Regulation
• Pain, fever, cough, nausea, anxiety, etc.often seems excessive
• We can usually block them safely
• Did selection make a mistake?
68
“The Smoke Detector Principle”Optimal Defense Regulation
• Monitor cues associated with danger
• If the cost of the defense is less than the expected reduction in harm from the danger then it is worth expressing the defense
• Express defense if:
C(D) < C(HsD) - C(HwD)
69
What If the Cue Is Unreliable?
• Signal detection analysis needed:• cost of the defense (C(D) = cost of false alarm)
• cost of harm if no defense
• cost of harm if defense (correct response)
• probability that harm is present (S/N ratio)
• Express defense whenever
C(D) < pH ((C(HNoD) - C(HwD))
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 24
70
Signal comes from real danger
Signal comesfrom noise
71
Optimal Response Threshold
p(x|s) p(n) v(rej.) + v(f.a.)p(x|n) p(s) v(hit) + v(miss)
72
Should You Flee from a Noise? It Could Be a Monkey… or a Lion!!
• Cost of fleeing = 200 calories
• Cost of not fleeing if tiger = 200,000 kcal
• Optimal: flee whenever p tiger > 1/1000
• 999/1000 panic attacks wi ll be unnecessarybut perfectly normal
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 25
73
74
“Few failures are as unforgiving as failure to avoid a predator; Being killed greatly decreases future fitness”
Lima and Dill, 1989, p. 619
75
Panic Disorder
• A fight-flight response false alarm
• the smoke detector principle
A dysregulated defense
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 26
76
The Smoke Detector Principle
• Optimal regulation system expresses many normal false alarms
• This is why we can block defenses safely
• (except for that one time out of a thousand!)
• Also: pain, fever, vomiting, fatigue, etc.
77
78
A Conclusion About Defenses:Most Human Suffering Is Normal but Unnecessary
Except for one time in a thousand,
when the defense is essential!
This explains how generalmedicine is possible!
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 27
79
Six Reasons for Vulnerability
1. Mismatch: body in a novel environment
2. Competition with fast evolving organisms
3. Every trait is a trade-off
4. Constraints on natural selection
5. Organisms shaped for R/S, not health
6. Defenses and suffering
80
Main Conclusions
• Evolution is as essentialto medicine as physicsis for engineering
• The body is not a machine but a soma shapedby selection
81
Some of Many Implications
• No normal genome
• Need explanations for universals• not just for individual differences
• Expect poor design everywhere
• But recognize that what you think is poor design may well be exquisite
• Studying evolution is great fun!
"Evolution: Medicine's Missing Basic Science"
Prof. Randolph M. Nesse
The screen versions of these slides have full details of copyright and acknowledgements 28
82
Overall Conclusion
Nesse, Omenn, StearnsScience, 2006
83
The State of Darwinian Medicine• Many conferences and new books
• Lectures now avai lable
• But no training programs yet
• Little research funding in the USA
• And medical curricula don’t includemedicine’s most basic science
• A field ready to flower — and about time!
84
http://EvolutionAndMedicine.org