EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on...

57
EURO CRISIS TIMELINE JOSEP BORRELL FONTELLES

Transcript of EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on...

Page 1: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

EURO CRISIS TIMELINE

JOSEP BORRELL FONTELLES

Page 2: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

This timeline summarizes the events from thebeginning of the Greek crisis in October 2009to May 2013

Through them the Greek crisis wasbecoming the euro crisis.

Page 3: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

PASOK leader Georges Papandreou defeats outgoing Prime MinisterKostas Karamanlis in the Greek Parliamentary elections.October 4th

The new Greek government announces that the public deficit in 2009would top 10% of GDP, a figure much larger than the deficit figuresnotified to Brussels. Two weeks later, it is officially estimated at 12.7%of GDP.

2009

Debt crises in Dubai. The Emirate affected by the burst of a buildingbubble is unable to reimburse its Debt. Suddenly it appears that thesovereign debt is not a risk free asset. Fears that the same think canhappen to Greece.

November

The three main rating agencies – Fitch, Moody’s, and Standard andPoor’s – downgrade Greece’s sovereign credit rating.

December8th‐22nd

October 16th

Page 4: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2010The Greek government unveils its deficit reduction plans, with a deficittarget set at 2.8% of GDP in 2012.January 14th

March 25th European leaders announce that they are willing to prepare a financialassistance package to Greece, in cooperation with the IMF.

However, they also announced that this assistance should beconsidered “ultima ratio”, and would be provided at explicitly punitiveinterest rates to encourage a quick return to market financing.

They simultaneously task European Council`s president Hermann VanRompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening ofeconomic governance.

Page 5: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2010Slow and confuse reaction of the euro members governments.Germany swings from promising conditioned help to threaten with theeuro exit for those that do not fulfil the SGP . The Greek premium riskclimbs above 1.200 b.p.

March‐April

Greece’s 10‐year borrowing costs reach 8.7%, an increase of 270 basispoints compared to the previous month. On the 23rd of April, PrimeMinister Georges Papandreou requests activation of the financialassistance package.

April 21st

May 2ndEuro area member states and the IMF announce a three‐yearprogramme for Greece, totaling €110bn, initially comprising €80bn inbilateral loans and €30bn from the IMF. The following day, the ECBannounces that the Governing Council has decided to suspendminimum credit rating thresholds for Greek government debt used ascollateral in Eurosystem refinancing operations.

Page 6: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

The euro area leaders announce that all the institutions of the euroarea, including the ECB, commit to an overhaul of the Europeanmacroeconomic surveillance framework and that they have agreed to“use the full range of means available to ensure the stability of theeuro area”.

Following this meeting, Finance Ministers announce the creation of theEuropean Financial Stability Facility (EFSF), with a total volume of upto 500 billion Euros.

At the same time1, the ECB announces exceptional measures includingsecondary markets sovereign debt purchases (within the framework ofthe Securities Market Programme, or SMP). Initial purchases mainlyfocus on Greek government bonds.

May 7th‐9th

2010

______________________________1 €60bn will actually be assigned to the EFSM, a community mechanism guaranteed by the EUbudget.

Page 7: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

May 10th The ECB starts buying Public debt in the secondary financial markets.

May 10th In a tense meeting the Economics Affairs Council requires Spain toimplement urgently a severe adjustment plan.

2010

May 12thPremier Zapatero announces in the Parliament a radical change in itseconomic and social policy with an immediate austerity plan of 1,5 %of the GNP. This measure will have severe consequences for theSpanish socialist party.

May 12th The EU Commission presents his proposals for an “European economicgovernance” and the reform of the SGP.

May 21st First meeting of the Special Task Force chaired by H Van Rompuy toreinforce the budgetary discipline and economic governance.

Page 8: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

The European Commission presents the “six‐pack”, a package of sixlegislative proposals (five regulations and one directive) aiming atreforming economic governance and strengthening the framework forpreventing excessive imbalances and excessive deficits.

The package is endorsed by the Van Rompuy report on thestrengthening of economic governance.

September29th

September30th

The Irish government announces that the cost of rescuing Anglo‐IrishBank is much higher than expected – at least €30bn – and that otherbanks will also face additional capital needs.

2010

July 23rdThe results of the first pan‐European stress tests of the banking systemare published. Only seven banks fail the stress tests, with an aggregatecapital shortfall of €3.5bn. Market analysts express skepticism at theresults .

Page 9: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

October 18thFrench President Nicolas Sarkozy and German Chancellor AngelaMerkel meet in Deauville, France, and agree on a Treaty change tocreate a permanent crisis resolution mechanism (the future ESM)which will also provide for the possibility of sovereign debtrestructuring.

2010

October 26thThe Irish government announces that reaching its deficit targets for2014 would require 15 billion measures of additional measures overfour years, almost 10% of Irish GDP. In the following month, yields on10‐year government bonds increase by more than 250 basis points,reaching levels in excess of 9%.

Fitch, the rating agency, downgrades Ireland’s sovereign credit rating.Moody’s and Standard and Poor’s both follow suit before the end ofDecember.

October 6th

Page 10: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

European leaders and the IMF agree to grant an €85bn assistancepackage to Ireland, following the request made by Irish authorities onthe 22nd of November.

November28th

2010

European leaders reach an agreement on the need to set up apermanent crisis mechanism to safeguard the financial stability of theeuro area as a whole (the European Stability Mechanism, or ESM).

October28tth‐29tth

Page 11: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

March 11th

2011

Euro area leaders agree to lower the interest rates on Greek loans to5% and to increase the maturity of programme loans to 7.5 years, inexchange for the swift completion of a €50bn privatisation plan.

Leaders also agree to make the EFSF’s €440bn lending capacity fullyeffective, and to allow the EFSF and the ESM to intervene in theprimary markets for sovereign debt, as an exception and only in thecontext of a financial assistance programme.

March 15th‐29th

The three main rating agencies, Fitch, Moody's and Standard andPoor's, downgrade Portugal's sovereign credit rating (Standard andPoor’s downgrades Portugal twice in one week, following news aboutthe design details of the forthcoming European Stability Mechanism).

Axel Weber, President of the Bundesbank, hands in his resignation,expressing disagreement with the actions of the European CentralBank. He had until then been seen as one of the most likely successorsto Jean‐Claude Trichet.

February 11th

Page 12: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

May 17th

2011

Having received a request from Portugal on 7 April, the EuropeanCouncil agrees on a financial assistance package totalling €78bn overthree years (of which €26bn to be provided by the IMF).

May 25thReuters reports that the IMF has threatened to not allow disbursementof the next tranche of aid for Greece in June if the euro area memberstates do not reach an agreement on how to cover the country'sfinancing needs for 2012.

March 23rdCouncil approval of the “euro pact” proposed by France and Germanyand finally called Euro Plus Pact.

Page 13: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

June 5th

July 6th

2011Moody’s downgrades Portugal’s sovereign rating to junk status, citingpotential consequences of on‐going discussions related to privatesector involvement in the case of Greece.

Giorgio Napolitano, the Italian president, greenlights thegovernement’s austerity package. Italian spreads begin to widen in thefollowing days, amidst confusion and controversy as to the package’scontent and its perceived lack of ambition.

July 11th The first ESM Treaty is signed by euro area member states.

July 15th The results of the second round of pan‐European stress tests are madepublic. Accompanying publications are more complete and detailedthan in 2010.

Page 14: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

July 21st

2011Euro area Heads of State or Government and EU institutions decide ona new package of measures to end the crisis and prevent contagion,including:

‐ a new programme for Greece, initially amounting to an estimated€109bn (the figure was subsequently brought to €130bn in October);

‐ support from the private sector to strengthen Greek public financesustainability, on a voluntary basis, with a net contribution estimatedat €37bn (corresponding to a 21% haircut);

‐ a secondary market debt buyback programme for Greece;

‐ a lowering of the interest rate on assistance loans (to about 3,5%,equivalent to the lending rates on Balance of Payments facility loans tonon‐euro area countries)

‐ and a lengthening of maturities (from 15 to 30 years).

Page 15: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

July 21st

2011The agreement also includes measures to enhance the flexibility ofstabilization tools by allowing the EFSF/ESM to act on the basis of aprecautionary programme, to intervene in secondary markets, and tofinance the recapitalization of financial institutions through loans togovernments, including in non‐programme countries.

July 25th‐27thMoody’s and Standard and Poor’s downgrade Greece’s credit rating,following the 21st of July Summit decisions related to private sectorinvolvement. Fitch had already downgraded Greece’s credit rating forthe same reasons.

August 4th The ECB reactivates secondary market purchases and startspurchasing Italian and Spanish bonds in an attempt to ease markettensions.

Page 16: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2011

August 5th The President of the European Central Bank, Jean‐Claude Trichet, andhis successor, Mario Draghi, send a confidential letter to Italian PrimeMinister Silvio Berlusconi, urging him to adopt the measures necessaryto bring public finances back on track. In the following days, however,the government coalition decides to backtrack on several of itsbudgetary commitments.

August 5th

August 10th

Standard and Poor’s downgrades the United States’ sovereign creditrating, stripping the country of its triple‐A status.

French bank stocks slide on rumours that France might lose its triple‐Acredit rating and on worries about the financial health of Frenchbanks. During the month of August, banks throughout the euro areaexperience a significant and widespread deterioration of theirfinancing conditions.

Page 17: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2011

August 17thAngela Merkel and Nicolas Sarkozy call for strengthening economicgovernance in the euro area (including through the creation of a“European Economic Council”) and closer coordination of economicpolicies.

The two leaders reject Eurobonds as a short‐term solution to the crisis,saying that they may come only at the end of the process of Europeanintegration.

August 31st The IMF claims that losses due to exposures to sovereign bonds couldpotentially reach €200bn for European banks.

Page 18: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

September

2011Under the initiative of Premier Zapatero the PSOE and the PP agreedon a quick reform of the Spanish Constitution.

It was implemented on a week, to introduce the “golden rule” thatalmost forbids the public structural deficits as required by Merkel andTrichet.

The debt payment will have full priority over any other kind ofexpenditure. This measure produces strong debates in the Spanish left.

September6th

The Swiss Central Bank announces its decision to cap the Swiss franc’seuro exchange rate, in an attempt to halts it appreciation.

According to the central bank, “the massive overvaluation of the Swissfranc poses an acute threat to the Swiss economy and carries the riskof a deflationary development”. The SNB therefore will enforce the cap“with the utmost determination and is prepared to buy foreigncurrency in unlimited quantities”.

Page 19: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2011September7th

The German Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe rules that the rescuepackages agreed so far do not go against the German constitution.

However, the Court also states that the government must seek priorapproval of the Bundestag for all future EFSF programs. Otherelements of the Court’s ruling are interpreted as precluding thecreation of Eurobonds.

September9th

Jürgen Stark, the German member of the ECB’s Executive Board,resigns amid disagreement with the ECB’s sovereign bond purchases.

September16th

At a meeting of euro area Finance Ministers in Wroclaw, in Poland,Timothy Geithner, the United States Secretary of the Treasury, callsupon European leaders to find a quick solution the crisis and toincrease the EFSF’s firepower with the help of the ECB.

Page 20: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2011September19th

Standard and Poor’s downgrades Italy’s sovereign rating, citingworsening growth prospects and the fragile political environment. Thegovernment austerity package had been approved by Parliament onlyone month earlier.

September22nd

Six G20 countries write a letter to G20 chairman Nicolas Sarkozy, inwhich they call upon European governments to provide a quickresponse to the crisis and accelerate implementation of the measuresdecided on the 21st of July. .

September20th

The European Council, the European Commission and the EuropeanParliament finalize an agreement on the “six‐pack” legislation.

Page 21: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2011October 3rd‐4th

The Ecofin Council reaffirms that member states should adoptdifferentiated speed in fiscal consolidation.

Member states benefiting from financial assistance programs andmember states facing market pressure are urged to stick to headlinetargets and adopt further measures if needed.

Member states with high deficits are asked to stick to headline deficits,even in the event of limited downside revisions to the macroeconomicscenarios.

Member states with no excessive deficit can let automatic stabilizerswork around the path of structural fiscal adjustment.

October 4th‐18th

Spain and Italy are hit by a wave of rating downgrades by the threemain rating agencies. Stated motives include weak growth prospects,the intensification of the euro‐area crisis, and political uncertainty inthe case of Italy.

Page 22: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2011October 27th After a night of tense negotiations, European leaders agree on another

comprehensive package of additional measures, focused on Greeceand European firewalls.

On Greece, leaders agree on a 50% discount on Greek debt held byprivate investors (with the aim of bringing Greece’s debt to GDP ratiodown to 120% by 2020).

Leaders also agree to “optimize” the resources of the EFSF byintroducing two leverage options, allowing the EFSF’s firepower to bemultiplied.

They also agree on measures to strengthen the governance of theeuro‐area and on a strengthening of budgetary discipline (adoption ofbalanced budget rules at a national level and stronger mechanisms forbudgetary surveillance).

October 31stJean‐Claude Trichet’s term as President the European Central Bankends. He is replaced by Mario Draghi, former governor of the Bancad’Italia.

Page 23: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2011

November11th

October 31stGreek Prime Minister George Papandreou announces a referendum onthe deal reached on the 26th of October. The referendum is called offon November 3rd, following strong political opposition in Greece andpressure from foreign governments.

November4th:

The Cannes G20 is overshadowed by developments in the euro area,especially in Greece and Italy.

Angela Merkel and Nicolas Sarkozy tell George Papandreou that areferendum can only be on staying within the euro or leaving. Italyconsents to an ad hoc monitoring of its budgetary and reformcommitments by the EU and the IMF on the sidelines of the G20Summit.

Lucas Papademos, a former Vice President of the European CentralBank, is chosen to lead an interim coalition government in Greece,following George Papandreou’s resignation.

Page 24: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2011November13th

Following Silvio Berlusconi’s resignation Mario Monti, former EUCommissioner, is nominated by Italian President Giorgio Napolitanoto head a caretaker technocratic government.

November20th

In Spain, the right‐wing People’s Party (PP), led by Mariano Rajoy,defeats the outgoing socialist party PSOE in the general elections,scoring an absolute majority in Parliament.

November23rd

The European Commission proposes two new regulations tostrengthen budgetary surveillance and monitoring (the so‐called"two‐pack"), on top of the package of six legislative proposalsalready adopted.

The same day, the European Commission opens consultations onthe feasibility of introducing "Stability Bonds", common issuancesof sovereign bonds among the member states of the euro area.

Page 25: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

November25th

2011After several weeks of tensions on markets, Spanish and Italian yieldsreach unprecedented levels.

The Italian yield curve inverts, with 2‐year bonds yielding 7,65%compared to 7,3% for 10‐year bonds. For the first time since thebeginning of the crisis, the spreads of triple‐A rated sovereigns alsowiden significantly.

November30th

The ECB, the Fed, the Bank of Japan, the Bank of England and theSwiss National Bank announce agreement to enhance their ability toprovide liquidity.

The agreement involves the extension of these arrangements toFebruary 2013, and the possibility for each of the central bank toprovide liquidity support in any of their currencies.

Page 26: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

December4th

2011

Mario Monti unveils a comprehensive package of measures to bringItaly’s finances back on track and to enhance growth.

The package includes €30bn in new austerity measures and €10bn ingrowth‐enhancing measures, as well as a plan to liberalize the Italianeconomy.

December 1stMario Draghi, speaking before the European Parliament, calls for a“new fiscal compact”, which would enshrine “the essence of fiscalrules”, in much the same way that an independent central bank withan objective of maintaining price stability describes the essence ofmonetary policy.

Mario Draghi states euro area countries should keep all options open,including far‐reaching Treaty changes, to move towards a genuineeconomic union.

Page 27: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

December8th– 9th

2011

25 European leaders (representing all countries but the UK and theCzech Republic) agree on a new treaty‐based “fiscal compact”,containing the adoption of fiscal rules at national level, ex antereporting of national debt issuance plans, and nearly‐automaticsanctions for member states in breach of budgetary discipline.

Leaders also decide to strengthen and adjust the stabilization tools (bydeploying the EFSF’s leverage options, accelerating the entry into forceof the ESM – by July 2012 ‐, reassessing the overall ceiling of theEFSF/ESM in March 2012, increasing the IMF’s resources by up to€200bn, and reaffirming the “unique and exceptional” nature of thedecisions concerning private sector involvement in Greece).

Page 28: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

December21st

2011

The first 36‐month LTRO takes place, with a take‐up of 489.2 billioneuros by 523 banks.

December13th

The six‐pack enters into force.

December 8th The ECB reduces its policy rate by 25 basis points and announces apackage of measures to support the banking system.

These measures include increasing collateral availability for banks byenlarging the pool of eligible assets, and the decision to conduct twolonger‐term refinancing operations (LTRO) with a maturity of 36months to provide liquidity to banks (the maximum maturity forrefinancing operations, was until then of 12 months).

Page 29: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2011

December30th

Two weeks after taking office, Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoyannounces that the Spanish deficit for 2011 will exceed 8% of GDP,against a government official target of 6% of GDP.

The government decides to temporarily extend the 2011 budget, andadopts more than €15bn worth of new austerity measures.

December24th

Cyprus signs a 2.5 billion euro loan agreement with Russia to cover itsfinancing needs for 2012.

Page 30: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

February 2nd

2012

The new ESM Treaty is signed by euro area member states,incorporating all the decisions taken since July 2011.

Its entry into force is scheduled to take place when a sufficient numberof member states have completed the relevant ratification, approvalor acceptance processes.

January 13thStandard and Poor’s carries out a sweeping downgrade of 9 euro areasovereigns (Austria, Cyprus, France, Italy, Malta, Portugal, Slovakia,Slovenia and Spain), two of which – Austria and France – are strippedof their triple‐A status.

As justification for its decision, Standard and Poor’s cites the inabilityof European leaders to provide an adequate response to the euro areacrisis and the failure to recognize that not all of the euro area’stroubles stem from fiscal profligacy in certain countries. Finland,Germany and the Netherlands keep their triple‐A rating.

Page 31: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2012

February 3rdThe Spanish government adopts a new set of measures to reform andstrengthen the banking sector.

These measures include a cleaning‐up balance sheets (by increasingprovisions and capital by €50bn to cover problematic real‐estateexposures) and incentives to continue banking sector restructuringthrough mergers and acquisitions.

February12th

Amid fierce clashes between police and demonstrators, the GreekParliament approves a new round of austerity measures to complete apackage demanded by official creditors as a precondition for a newEU/IMF programme.

Page 32: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2012

February 28thThe second 36‐month LTRO takes place, with a take‐up of 529.5 billioneuros by 800 banks. The second operation brings to a total of 1018billion euros the amounts allotted by the ECB in the two 36‐monthLTROs.

February 21st European leaders agree on the terms for a second rescue programmefor Greece, with a marginally higher contribution from the privatesector (a 53.5% haircut instead of the 50% agreed in October 2011).

Formal approval of the second programme is postponed until thecompletion of the PSI operation. Greece formally launches theexchange offer a few days after.

Page 33: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

March 2nd

March 2nd

2012EU member states – with the exception of the United Kingdom and theCzech Republic – sign the Treaty on Stability, Convergence andGovernance in the Economic and Monetary Union (the “fiscalcompact”), which had been finalized by Members of the EuropeanCouncil in January.

Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy unilaterally announces that hisgovernment is aiming for a deficit of 5.8% of GDP in 2012 – a farhigher figure than Spain’s initial target of 4.4%. On the 12th of March,the Eurogroup gets Spain to agree to an additional frontloaded effortof 0.5% of GDP in 2012. Spain’s deficit target of 3% of GDP in 2013remains unchanged.

March 5thItalian 10‐year sovereign bond yields drop below Spain’s for the firsttime since summer 2011.

Page 34: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

March 9th

March 9th

2012The Greek Finance Ministry announces an 85,8% participation rate inthe PSI operation, which the Eurogroup deems satisfactory. The secondGreek rescue package is formally approved by the Eurogroup in thefollowing days.

The Eurogroup decides to go ahead with the second Greek assistanceprogramme, following a positive report from the Troika on theimplementation of the agreed prior actions and high private sectorparticipation in the debt exchange offer.

March 30thThree months into 2012 the Spanish government finally presents abudget for 2012, with €27.3bn of new austerity measures. Theadjustment plans of Spain’s Autonomous Communities, however, arestill pending.

Page 35: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

March 30th

April 20th‐21st

2012The Eurogroup increases the overall ceiling for EFSF/ESM lending to€700bn, up from €500bn previously (because of the EFSF’s outstandingcommitments, amounting to €200bn, the EFSF/ESM lending ceiling of€500bn would have entailed a 300bn maximum new lending ceiling).

The IMF receives $430bn in pledges from IMF member to increase itsresources during the spring meetings in Washington, almost doublingthe Fund’s lending capacity.

April 23rdDutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte resigns, as talks break down withinthe government coalition on additional austerity measures. Downwardrevisions to the Netherlands’ growth prospects had made it necessaryto adopt extra measures to respect the country’s deficit targets, andcorrect the excessive deficit by 2013.14

Page 36: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

April 30th

May 6th

2012Standard and Poor’s lowers the credit rating of 16 Spanish banks,including large international banks Santander and BBVA. The ratingagency had downgraded Spain’s sovereign credit rating the weekbefore, citing risks for the banking sector.

The second round of the French Presidential elections and the Greeklegislative elections take place the same day. In France, left‐wingcandidate Francois Hollande defeats outgoing President NicolasSarkozy. In Greece, New Democracy led by Antonis Samaras comes outon top with almost 19% of votes, but does not have enough seats for amajority in Parliament.

In the following days, three main political parties fail to form acoalition.

Page 37: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

May 12th

2012

In a last‐ditch attempt to reassure markets, the Spanish governmentadopts a new comprehensive package of measures to strengthen thebanking sector.

The measures include €28bn in new provisions to cover real‐estateexposures, compulsory transfers of problematic real‐estate assets toAsset Management Companies (AMC’s), easier access to the fund forbank restructuring (the FROB), and independent audits.

May 7thIn Spain, Bankia CEO and former IMF Managing Director Rodrigo Ratoresigns, after an auditing firm refuses to sign off on the bank’saccounts. The Spanish government decides to nationalize Bankia, aconglomerate created out of several regional savings banks andSpain’s fourth largest bank.

Page 38: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2012

May 23rd Newly elected French president Francois Hollande makes his firstsignificant foray into European discussions during the informal dinnerof the European Council, dedicated to preparing the June summit.

The subjects of Eurobonds, growth and banking union are put on thetable.

May 25thBankia’s capital shortfall is estimated at €19bn, bringing the total costof its rescue to €23.5bn (almost 2,5% of Spanish GDP).

Page 39: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

May 30th

June 7th– 13th

2012The European Commission adopts a package of recommendations forbudgetary measures and economic reforms within the framework ofthe European Semester, and recommends that the euro area makesteps towards a “full economic and monetary union” including abanking union, integrated supervision and a common depositinsurance scheme.

The European Commission also publishes the conclusions of its in‐depth reviews within the framework of the MacroeconomicImbalances Procedure (a new surveillance procedure resulting fromthe sixpack). It concludes that although many member states haveimbalances, none of them are excessive.

Moody’s and Standard and Poor’s downgrade Spain’s credit rating toone and two notches above “speculative” grade respectively, citingrisks to the banking sector, poor economic prospects and worseningmarket access. Standard and Poor’s had already downgraded Spain inApril for similar reasons.

Page 40: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2012June 8th The IMF estimates that the aggregate capital shortfall of the Spanish

banking sector, in a stressed scenario, would reach 37 billion euros.According to the IMF’s findings, the core of the Spanish banking sectoris resilient, with vulnerabilities mostly concentrated on a small numberof former savings banks.

June 9th Spain becomes the first country to request financial assistance torecapitalize its banking sector, within the framework of a €100bnprogramme focused on the banking sector only.

Market react negatively when it becomes apparent that the assistancewill be channeled through the Spanish government, thereby increasingpublic debt, and that assistance provided under the ESM may haveseniority status.

June 17th New elections take place in Greece. New Democracy gets almost 30%of votes and succeeds in forming a coalition government.

Page 41: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2012

June 19thAt the G20 Summit in Los Cabos in Mexico, Europeans pledge toconsider “concrete steps towards a more integrated financialarchitecture, encompassing banking supervision, resolution andrecapitalization, and deposit insurance”.

June 25th Cyprus formally requests financial assistance from the EU and the IMF.

June 28th‐29th

In order to break the banking/sovereign feedback loop, euro areacountries endorse the concept of banking union and open the door topossible direct bank recapitalizations by the ESM once an effectivesingle supervisory mechanism for banks in the euro area is established.

Page 42: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

July 5th

2012

Ireland’s ten‐year sovereign bond yields drop below Spain’s.

July 11thThe Ecofin Council decides to grant Spain an extra year to correct itsexcessive deficit, pushing back the deadline for returning below the 3%to 2014. Deficit targets for 2012 and 2013 are adjusted accordingly.

July 11thSpanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy underpins the deficit targets for2013 and 2014 with a new €65bn austerity package.

June 28th‐29th

Leaders also agree to abandon the ESM’s preferred creditor status forthe financial support granted to Spain. The European Council adopts a“growth compact” and tasks the President of the European Council,the President of the Commission, the President of the Eurogroup andthe President of the ECB (the “Four Presidents”) with developing aspecific, time‐bound roadmap for the achievement of a genuineEconomic and Monetary Union 16.

Page 43: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

July 12th

July 26th

2012The Troïka confirms that Ireland’s implementation of its economicadjustment programme is on track. A similar statement had beenreleased on Portugal one month earlier.

ECB President Mario Draghi says that the ECB, within its mandate, willdo “whatever it takes to preserve the euro”. “Believe me, it will beenough”, he adds, triggering a market rally.

August 2ndECB President Mario Draghi announces that the ECB may considerinterventions on secondary debt markets focusing on the short‐termend of the yield curve, “of a size adequate to meet its objectives”, inorder to restore the functioning of monetary policy. To unlock theseinterventions, governments must have entered into an agreement withthe EFSF/ESM.

Page 44: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

September6th

September12th

2012

The ECB provides details on its new bond purchasing programme,dubbed “Outright Monetary Transactions (OMTs)”, mostly confirmingthe information provided in August.

The German Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe allows ratification of theESM and TSCG Treaties, clearing the way for the entry into force of theEurozone’s permanent rescue mechanism. The Treaty formally entersinto force on September 27th.

August 21st–25th

Antonis Samaras, the newly elected Greek Prime Ministers, toursEuropean capitals to convince European leaders that the new Greekgovernment is fully committed to implementing the adjustmentprogramme.

Page 45: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

2012

September12th

The European Commission unveils its proposal for a single supervisorymechanism for banks, following the June 28/29th Council decision tomove ahead with banking union.

September25th

The Finance Ministers of Germany, the Netherlands and Finlandpublish a joint statement widely interpreted as ruling out retroactivedirect recapitalizations for Spain, seen as one of the most likelybeneficiaries of the July 28/29th agreement (despite the factretroactivity was not explicitly mentioned). 10‐year yields on Spanishbonds leap by 30 bps the following day.

Page 46: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

September27th‐28th

October 9th

Spain, widely seen by markets as the most likely to benefit from theECB’s new instrument, unveils new cuts as part of the 2013 budget aswell as a wide‐ranging agenda of structural reforms, in line withCouncil recommendations.

Markets interpret these announcements as signaling that ECBintervention might be near, although regional elections in October areseen as an obstacle to a programme request by Spain.

After Spain in July, another country – Portugal – is given an extra yearto correct its excessive deficit, owing to downward revisions to thecountry’s growth prospects.

2012

Page 47: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

October 9th German Chancellor Angela Merkel visits Athens for the first time sincethe beginning of the European debt crisis in 2009, and declares thatGermany “hopes, and wishes” that Greece remain a partner in theEurozone.

Germany’s position had appeared to soften in September, after asummer where adjustments to the programme seemed to be entirelyoff the table.

October 10thA two‐page box in the IMF’s latest World Economic Outlook reportcaptures attention as the IMF admits that fiscal multipliers, thatmeasure the effects of fiscal consolidation on growth, have beengrossly under‐estimated since the beginning of the crisis.

2012

Page 48: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

October15th– 26th

October18th– 19th

The first review mission of the financial assistance programme forSpain finds that programme implementation is fully on track; bankingrecapitalizations are still pending, however.

During the European Council, EU leaders discuss the completion of theEconomic and Monetary Union on the basis of an interim reportpresented by Van Rompuy and agree to have the legal framework forthe single supervisory mechanism in place by the 1st of January 2013.

November7th

The European Commission presents its autumn forecasts, depicting agradual return to GDP growth in 2013 for the EU economy andshowing a large improvement in the budgetary situation of manyMember States. Spain, however, is forecast to largely overshoot itstargets.

2012

Page 49: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

December 12th

December 13th

B Bernanke announces that will not increase rates until unemploymentfalls below 6,5 %.

M Draghi never could have said such an statement that links explicitlymonetary policy and employment.

The Eurogrup agrees to unlock 49.100 millions euros to Greece in orderto avoid the bankruptcy of the country.

16.000 millions will be for bank recapitalization and 11.300 to re‐buyGreek debt in order to reduce its amount to 170 % of the GNP.

December 13th‐14th

European Council agrees on the first step toward the Banking Unionand the creation of a SSM (single supervisory mechanism).

The ECB will act as a single supervisor authority for the biggest banks(200 over 6.000 european banks).

2012

Page 50: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

January 3rd

January 10th

The FMI recognises that has underestimated the impact of theausterity policies. The fiscal multiplier was much bigger that they havecalculated. Close to 1,5 instead to 0,5.

Juncker alerts about the tragedy of the high levels of unemploymentand criticises the attitude of the northern countries.

January 11th The risk premium of the Spanish debt falls to 330 bp., half themaximum reached on July 24.

2013

January 12th Premier Cameron threatens to abandon the EU.

Page 51: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

January 22nd

January 23rd

Eleven countries of the Eurogroup decided to create a financialtransaction tax to be applied from January 2014 to collect 35.000millions euros.

Speech of Cameron about the new relations between UK and EU.Proposes a referendum in 2017.

January 24th Nicos Anastasiadis wins the elections in Cyprus.

2013

January 15thThe German economy affected by the slowdown .Only 0,7 % growth in2012,the lowest data since 2009.

February 4th Corruption scandals in Spain. The risk premium climbs to 382 bp.

Page 52: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

February 7th M Draghi alerts of the effect of the exchange rate of the euro oneconomic growth. Ireland reaches an agreement with the ECB torestructure its Debt.

February 7th‐8th

European Council agrees on the Multiannual Financial Framework2014 2020 limited to less than 1 % of the European GNP.

2013

February 16th Rajoy asks Merkel for economic stimulus to boost growth. Spanishpublic debt reaches 84 % of the GNP.

February 20th The European Parliament, the Council and the Commission agrees onthe Two Pack after a delay of 9 months of long discussions New powerfor the Commission to reinforce fiscal discipline.

Page 53: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

March 7th

March 12th

The ECB maintains the interest rate at 0,75 %.

Ireland back to the capital market paying less than Spain.

March  14th‐15th

European Council starts a discreet turn toward growth and not onlyausterity.

2013

March  16thCrisis in Cyprus. The bail out do not respect the guarantee on the first100.000 euros deposits in the current accounts.

Page 54: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

April 5th

April 6th

The Portuguese Constitutional Court annuls several points of theausterity measures.

Japan launches the Abenomics and duplicate the central bank balancesheets to stimulate the economy and fight against deflation.

April 10th The Commission points out the excessive macroeconomicdisequilibrium in Spain.

2013March  17th

Confusion in Brusells. EU Rectification. The first 100.000 euros will notbe penalized.

March  19thThe Parliament of Cyprus votes against the bail out and ask Russia forfinancial support.

Page 55: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

May 2nd

May 5th

The ECB reduces the interest rate to 0,5 %. But do not take any othermeasures in order to reactivate the credit to the firms.

Confrontation between Berlin and Paris about austerity and growth.

May 8thThe commission gives 2 more years to Spain and France to reduce thedeficit to 3 % of GNP and closes the procedure for excessive deficit toItaly and Belgium.

2013

May 20th New unemployment records and slow growth in Europe, especially inSpain and France.

Page 56: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

May 22nd

May 28th

European Council devoted to the fight against fiscal heavens andenergy policy.

Joint press conference of Merkel and Hollande announcing their willingto act together against young unemployment in Europe.

Meeting of the labour and economic ministers of Germany and Franceto prepare a “new deal for Europe”.

May 30thMeeting of Merkel and Hollande in Paris Announcement of measuresto boost jobs creations for young people and new proposals for aneconomic government of Europe. The German/ French engine seemsto restart again.

Merkel and Hollande will chair a big conference in Berlin the 3th ofJuly about competitivity, growth and jobs creations.

2013

Page 57: EURO CRISIS TIMELINE - UCM · EURO CRISIS TIMELINE ... Rompuy with the preparation of a report on the strengthening of economic governance. 2010 ... Greece’s 10 ‐year borrowing

Thanks for your attention