EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS...

16
NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION 1 EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 VOL. 3 NO.1 FEBRUARY/MARCH 2013

Transcript of EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS...

Page 1: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION 1

EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011

VOL. 3 NO.1 FEBRUARY/MARCH 2013

Page 2: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

MISSION

To safeguard and promote competition in the Namibian economy

VISION

Fair market competition

BRAND PROMISE

Fair competition, prosperous economy

VALUES

NATIONAL ECONOMIC INTERESTS COME FIRST

Our priority and commitment is to put national economic interests towards

attainment of Vision 2030 ahead of any other considerations

IMPARTIALITY

We shall be fair and equitable living our purpose and uphold principles of impartiality

and confidentiality regardless of the circumstances

CONSISTENCY

We are consistent in our approach in every instance, regardless of the

circumstances and pressures that may be brought to bear

ACCOUNTABILITY FOR OUR ROLE

We accept our responsibilities and are accountable for all our decisions and actions

We uphold and respect decisions taken by the Commission, whether an individual

was party to an decision or not

Page 3: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION 3

CONTENT

Editorial Note ..................................................................................................................................................4

The Need for Creating Capacity on Consumer Protection at the Commission .................................5

Consumer Protection and Competitiveness: an Overview ....................................................................7

NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .......................................................8

African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills ............................................................10

Minister of Trade and Industry Visits the Commission ...........................................................................12

Namibian Competition Commission and Anti-Corruption Commission Signs MoU .........................13

Visit By Technical Expert from Bundeskartellamt ....................................................................................14

Page 4: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

4 NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION

EDITORIAL NOTE

Dear Readers,

!"#$%#&$"'#$(()*%)#+,)-%./)#"'-"#&)#+/)%)*"#"0#10.#"')#20(($%%$0*3%#

4/%"#*)&%,)"")/#50/#"')#1)-/6#7)#&0.,8#,$9)#"0#"'-*9#-,,#%"-9)'0,8)/%#

50/#"-9$*:#$*")/)%"#$*#"')#5.*;"$0*#-*8#/0,)#05#"')#20(($%%$0*#-*8#

"-9$*:#"')#"$()#"0#;0*:/):-")#&$"'#.%#50/#&0/9%'0+%<#:-"')/$*:%#0/#

())"$*:%#&')*)=)/#;-,,)8#.+0*6#7)#-,%0#&-*"#"0#"'-*9#"')#()8$-#

50/# +/0=$8$*:# ;0=)/-:)#05# "')# )=)*"%#'0%")8#>1# "')#20(($%%$0*<#

-"#"$()%#0*#%'0/"#*0"$;)6#?*8#0*#"'-"#*0")<#&)#&$%'#10.#-,,#-#:/)-"#

year ahead!

!"#$%#&'$()*'*+,$&'-#'&$+,$-$.*/'"#($+0$1*23'43(-#'()$-,)$&(#*+"&$.-''(#&5$

2*6*,2$ 7+"5$ +"#$ #(-)(#5$ -$ 21*.8&($+0$ '3($8(+81($ 9(3*,)$ '3*&$ *,&'*'"'*+,5$

:3+&($&+1($-*.$*&$'+$(,&"#($'3-'$(6(#7$;-.*9*-,$3-&$-$0-*#$<3-,<($*,$'3($

(<+,+.*<$-#(,-=$>3"&5$'+:-#)&$'3($(,)$+0$'3*&$8"91*<-'*+,5$:($*,<1")($-$

83+'+4&8#(-)$+0$'3($?+..*&&*+,$&'-00$)"#*,2$'3($&'-00$#('#(-'$3(1)$*,$'3($

'+:,$+0$!@-3-,)A-$1-&'$7(-#=

B*,<($'3($?+..*&&*+,$<-##*(&$-'$*'&$3(-#'$'3($:(10-#($+0$<+,&".(#&5$:($

'3+"23'$*'$9(&'$'+$8#+6*)($7+"$:*'3$-,$-#'*<1($(,1*23'(,*,2$:3(#($:($-#($-&$

-$<+",'#7$*,$'(#.&$+0$<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,=$>3($?3*(0$C/(<"'*6($!0%<(#5$

D*3($E-+.-9$FF5$&3()&$.+#($*,&*23'$*,$'3*&$*&&"(=

>3($?+..*&&*+,$:-&$2#-<()$97$+6(#$0+#'7$#(8#(&(,'-'*6(&$0#+.$$G0#*<-,$

<+.8('*'*+,$ -"'3+#*'*(&$ )"#*,2$ '3($ G0#*<-,$ ?+.8('*'*+,$ H+#".$ IG?HJ$

<-8-<*'7$ 9"*1)*,2$ :+#@&3+85$ :3*<3$ :-&$ A+*,'17$ 3(1)$ 97$ '3($ G?H$ -,)$

;-??=$>3($%#&'$+0$*'&$@*,)$'+$9($3(1)$97$G?H5$'3($:+#@&3+8$0+<"&()$+,$

#(&(-#<3$&@*11&$*,$#(1-'*+,$'+$(00(<'*6(17$8#+6*)*,2$+"'<+.(&$-9+"'$*&&"(&$

<+,<(#,*,2$-,'*4<+.8('*'*6($8#-<'*<(&=$K($8#+6*)($7+"$-$9#*(0$&"..-#7$

+0$'3-'$:+#@&3+8=

G&$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,$ -1&+$ )(-1&$ :*'3$ .(#2(#&$ -,)$ -<L"*&*'*+,&5$ *'$ 3(1)$

*'&$%#&'$&'-@(3+1)(#&$<+,0(#(,<($ 0+#$ '3($7(-#$MNOP5$ *,$-<<+#)-,<($:*'3$

B(<'*+,$QR$+0$'3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$M$+0$MNNP5$:3*<3$:-&$-*.()$-'$2(''*,2$

&'-@(3+1)(#&$6*(:&$-,)$<+,<(#,&$-9+"'$ '3($8#+8+&()$.(#2(#$9(':((,$

C4DCS$ -,)$ FB!B=$G$ )('(#.*,-'*+,$ 3-&$ 9((,$ .-)($ +,$ '3($ 8#+8+&()$

.(#2(#$-,)$:($8#+6*)($7+"$:*'3$'3($+"'<+.($'3(#(+0=$

>3($,(:174-88+*,'()$D*,*&'(#$+0$>#-)($-,)$ F,)"&'#75$T+,+"#-91($?-11($

B<31('':(*,$ 6*&*'()$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,$ '+$ 0-.*1*-#*&($ 3*.&(10$ :*'3$ '3($

+8(#-'*+,&$-,)$&'-00$+0$'3*&$(,'*'7=$G'$'3($+<<-&*+,5$:($9*)$0-#(:(11$'+$'3($

+"'2+*,2$?3-*#8(#&+,$+0$'3($;-??$U+-#)$+0$?+..*&&*+,(#&5$D#$V"<*"&$

D"#+#"-5$:3+&($'(,"#($(,)()$PO$W-,"-#7$MNOP=$K($:*&3$3*.$-11$'3($9(&'$

*,$3*&$,(:$(,)(-6+"#&=$

H#+.$'*.($'+$'*.(5$'3($?+..*&&*+,$(,2-2(&$'(<3,*<-1$(/8(#'&$'+$-&&*&'$

*,$*'&$<-8-<*'7$9"*1)*,2$(00+#'&5$'3"&$:($3-6($+,$9+-#)$C)*'3$D-#*-$D"(11(#$

0#+.$'3($U",)(&@-#'(11-.'5$E(#.-,7=$

F,$+#)(#$'+$3(18$&'#(,2'3(,$'3($#(2"1-'+#7$0",<'*+,$+0$'3($$E+6(#,.(,'5$

'3($?+..*&&*+,5$*,$'(#.&$+0$B(<'*+,$RX$+0$'3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$M$+0$MNNP5$

*&$+91*2-'()$'+$(,'(#$*,'+$.(.+#-,)-$+0$",)(#&'-,)*,2$:*'3$<+4#(2"1-'+#&$

-,)$ -&$ &"<35$ &*2,()$ -,$D+Y$:*'3$ '3($G,'*4?+##"8'*+,$ ?+..*&&*+,$ '+$

A+*,'17$%23'$<+##"8'*+,5$9*)4#*22*,2$-,)$'(,)(#$<+11"&*+,5$-.+,2&'$+'3(#&=

K($'#"&'$'3-'$7+"$:*11$(,A+7$8(#"&*,2$'3#+"23$+"#$8-2(&$-&$."<3$-&$:($

3-)$81(-&"#($*,$<+.8*1*,2$'3*&$()*'*+,=

Dina Gowases

Editor

ZB*,<($'3($?+..*&&*+,$<-##*(&$-'$*'&$

3(-#'$'3($:(10-#($+0$<+,&".(#&5$:($'3+"23'$*'$

9(&'$'+$8#+6*)($7+"$:*'3$-,$-#'*<1($(,1*23'(,*,2$

:3(#($:($-#($-&$-$<+",'#7$*,$'(#.&$+0$

<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,=[

Page 5: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION 5

THE NEED FOR CREATING CAPACITY ON

CONSUMER PROTECTION AT THE COMMISSION

?"# $"%# 20(($%%$0*)/%3# ())"$*:# '),8# 0*# @A# B.,1# C@AA<# "')# D0-/8#

05# 20(($%%$0*)/%# ;0*%$8)/)8# -# :/0.*8# >/)-9$*:# +-+)/# 0*# "')#

*))8# 50/# -%;)/"-$*$*:# "')# ,$*9# >)"&))*#20*%.()/# E/0");"$0*# -*8#

20(+)"$"$0*#E0,$;16#

>3($ ?+..*&&*+,$ '3+"23'$ *'$ -88#+8#*-'($ '+$ *,'(##+2-'($ '3($ 1*,@$ -&$ *'$ *&$

6*'-1$ '+$ '3($.-,)-'($ +0$ '3($;-.*9*-,$?+.8('*'*+,$?+..*&&*+,5$ :3*<3$

:-&$(&'-91*&3()$ *,$ '(#.&$+0$ '3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$M$+0$MNNP$ *,$+#)(#$ '+$

&-0(2"-#)$<+.8('*'*+,$*,$'3($<+",'#7=$;-.*9*-$<"##(,'17$)+(&$,+'$3-6($-$

1(2-1$&'-'"'($2(-#()$'+:-#)&$?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,=$

>3($?+..*&&*+,$'3+"23'$*'$(&&(,'*-1$'+$<+,)"<'$#(&(-#<3$+,$'3*&$.-''(#5$

-&$ B(<'*+,$ M$ +0$ '3($G<'$ )+(&$ &8(<*%<-117$ -''(&'$ '3-'$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,$

3-&$+6(#&*23'$+,$?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,5$,-.(17$'3-'$*'$&(#6(&$'+$8#+6*)($

<+,&".(#&$:*'3$<+.8('*'*6($8#*<(&$-,)$8#+)"<'$<3+*<(&=

>3($ ?+..*&&*+,$ %,-1*&()$ *'&$ #(&(-#<3$ 8-8(#$ +,$ (/81+#*,2$ '3($ 1*,@$

9(':((,$ <+.8('*'*+,$ -,)$?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$ -,)$ &3-#()$ *'$ :*'3$ '3($

9#+-)(#$&'-@(3+1)(#&$<+,<(#,()$:*'3$?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$*,$;+6(.9(#$

MNOO=

>3(#($:(#($&"9&'-,'*-1$<+..(,'&$#(<(*6()$0#+.$'3($&'-@(3+1)(#&$)"#*,2$

D-#<3$MNOM$+,$'3($#(&(-#<3$)+,(5$:3*<3$0"#'3(#$-<<(,'"-'()$'3($,(()$

0+#$3-6*,2$<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,$8+1*<7$-,)$1-:$*,$;-.*9*-=

S"#*,2$W"17$MNOM5$ '3($U-,@$+0$;-.*9*-$%,-1*&()$ *'&$ #(&(-#<3$8-8(#$+,$

?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$-,)$8#+8+&()$&*.*1-#$8+&*'*+,$-&$'3($?+..*&&*+,$

*,$ '3-'$ 2*6(,$ '3($ &.-11$ &*]($ +0$ '3($;-.*9*-,$ (<+,+.75$ '3-'$?+,&".(#$

\#+'(<'*+,$9($-<<+#)()$ '+$ '3($;-.*9*-,$?+.8('*'*+,$?+..*&&*+,$-,)$

'3-'$ '3($ #(2"1-'+#7$.-''(#&$+,$?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$&8(<*%<$ '+$&(<'+#&$

9($-<<+#)()$'+$&(<'+#-1$ #(2"1-'+#&=$>3($8#+8+&-1$:-&$:*)(17$(,)+#&()$

97$ '3($.(.9(#&$+0$ '3($H*,-,<*-1$?+",<*15$ +0$:3*<3$ '3($?+..*&&*+,$ *&$

-1&+$-$.(.9(#=

B*,<($ *'&$ *,<(8'*+,$ *,$ MNON5$ '3($?+..*&&*+,$ *&$ -1&+$ -$.(.9(#$ +0$ '3($

?+,&".(#$H*,-,<*-1$V*'(#-<7$?-.8-*2,$1()$97$'3($D*,*&'#7$+0$H*,-,<(5$U-,@$

+0$;-.*9*-$-,)$;GDHFBG=$

>3($ ;-.*9*-,$ ?+.8('*'*+,$ ?+..*&&*+,$ 3+&'()$ '3($ ?+.8('*'*+,$ -,)$

?+,&".(#$ K((@$ 0#+.$ MQ4M^$ B(8'(.9(#$ MNOM$ -&$ 8-#'$ +0$ *'&$ -)6+<-<7$

)#*6($+,$<+.8('*'*+,$ 1-:$-,)$8+1*<75$-&$:(11$-&$?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,=$>3($

?+..*&&*+,$ )(1*6(#()$ -$ 8#(&(,'-'*+,$ 9-&()$ +,$ '3($ (/81+#-'+#7$ #(&(-#<3$

8-8(#$ '*'1()_$The Link between Competition and Consumer Protection in

Namibia.

The presentation below provided an overview of Consumer Protection

from a competition law/policy perspective, highlighting the link between the

two as it enhances consumer welfare.

Continued on next page.

?TFCH$C`C?Y>FaC$!HHF?Cb

Page 6: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

R NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION

THE NEED FOR CREATING CAPACITY ON

CONSUMER PROTECTION AT THE COMMISSION

F'$ 0"#'3(#$ )(1*9(#-'()$ +,$ '3($ *.8+#'-,<($ +0$ <+.8('*'*+,$ -,)$ <+,&".(#$

8#+'(<'*+,$'+:-#)&$-''-*,*,2$,-'*+,-1$)(6(1+8.(,'5$3*231*23'()$'3($<"##(,'$

&'-'"&$ +0$ ?+,&".(#$ \#+'(<'*+,$ *,$ ;-.*9*-5$ '3($ *,&'*'"'*+,&$ *,6+16()$ *,$

*&&"(&$+0$<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,5$-,)$2-6($-$:-7$0+#:-#)=

>3($ :+#@&3+8$ <+,<1")()$ '3-'$ '3(#($ :-&$ -,$ (&'-91*&3()$ ,(()$ 0+#$

?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$*,$'3($<+",'#7$-,)$*,)*<-'()$'3-'$'3(#($:-&$-$,(()$

0+#$<++#)*,-'*+,$+0$(/*&'*,2$(00+#'&$'+:-#)&$'3($)(6(1+8.(,'$+0$?+,&".(#$

\#+'(<'*+,$V-:$-,)$\+1*<7=$>3($,(()$0+#$<(.(,'*,2$-$<+3(#(,'$-88#+-<3$

'+$?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$*,$'(#.&$+0$<+6(#-2($+0$'3($?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$

1(2*&1-'*+,$ *,$ '3($ ?+.8('*'*+,$ G<'$ -,)$ A"#*&)*<'*+,-1$ .-''(#&$ :(#($

3*231*23'()$-,)$-0%#.()=

>3($:+#@&3+8$ 0"#'3(#$<+,<1")()$ '3-'$ '3(#($ *&$-$,(()$ 0+#$&'#(,2'3(,*,2$

*,&'*'"'*+,&$&"<3$-&$;-??$'+$9(''(#$<-##7$+"'$*'&$.-,)-'($*,$+#)(#$'+$9(''(#$

(,0+#<($<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,=$

>3($8#+8+&()$-88#+-<3$'+$<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,$-,)$'3($&'#+,2$#(1(6-,<($

'3(#(+0$'+$<+.8('*'*+,$8+1*<7$-,)$1-:$:-&$+6(#:3(1.*,217$&"88+#'()$97$

D#=$?3*1"07-$B-.8-5$C/(<"'*6($S*#(<'+#$+0$'3($c-.9*-,$?+.8('*'*+,$-,)$

?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$?+..*&&*+,=$D#$B-.8-$)(1*6(#()$-$8#(&(,'-'*+,$

+,$'3($c-.9*-,$(/8(#*(,<($:*'3$<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,=$F,$3*&$8#(&(,'-'*+,5$

3($2-6($-$3*&'+#*<-1$9-<@2#+",)$+,$'3($c-.9*-,$(<+,+.75$:*'3$#(0(#(,<($

'+$'3($(,-<'.(,'$+0$'3($?+.8('*'*+,$-,)$H-*#$>#-)*,2$G<'$+0$OddQ5$:3*<3$

3-)$1*.*'()$8#+6*&*+,&$+,$<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,=$G0'(#$OP$7(-#&$+0$(,0+#<*,2$

'3($?+.8('*'*+,$-,)$H-*#$>#-)*,2$G<'$+0$OddQ5$'3($<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,$

-&8(<'&$:(#($ *,<+#8+#-'()$ '+$ '3($(/*&'*,2$ 1-:$ '+$ 0+#.$ '3($?+.8('*'*+,$

-,)$ ?+,&".(#$ \#+'(<'*+,$G<'$ +0$ MNON5$ :3*<3$ 1()$ '+$ '3($ #(,-.*,2$ +0$

'3($ c-.9*-,$ ?+.8('*'*+,$ ?+..*&&*+,$ '+$ c-.9*-,$ ?+.8('*'*+,$ -,)$

?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$?+..*&&*+,$ -,)$ 9(<-.($ '3($ 8#*.-#7$ <+,&".(#$

8#+'(<'*+,$-)6+<-'($-,)$(,0+#<(.(,'$-2(,<7=$

>3($8#(&(,'-'*+,$+"'1*,()$'3($-).*,*&'#-'*+,$+0$'3($c-.9*-,$?+.8('*'*+,$

-,)$?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$G<'$+0$MNON$",)(#$ '3($c-.9*-,$?+.8('*'*+,$

-,)$ ?+,&".(#$ \#+'(<'*+,$ ?+..*&&*+,=$ >3($ 8#(&(,'(#$ 0"#'3(#$ ,+'()$

'3-'5$2*6(,$ '3($)(6(1+8.(,'&$-#+",)$ '3($ #(2*+,5$;-.*9*-$-&$-$<+",'#7$

*&$.+6*,2$-'$ -$ #-'3(#$ &1+:$8-<($ *,$ )(6(1+8*,2$ '3($ 1(2*&1-'*+,$ -,)$ '3-'$

*'$ *&$ <#"<*-1$ '+$ 3-6($ -$ <(,'#-1$ 9+)7$ :3(#($ <+,&".(#&$ <-,$ 1+)2($ '3(*#$

<+.81-*,'&=$T($ &"88+#'()$ '3($ <+,<1"&*+,$+0$ &'#+,2$ #(1(6-,<($9(':((,$

<+.8('*'*+,$ (,0+#<(.(,'$ -,)$ <+,&".(#$ 8#+'(<'*+,$ -,)$ &"88+#'()$

'3($ #(<+..(,)-'*+,$ +0$ '3($ (/'(,&*+,$ +0$ '3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$ '+$ <+6(#$

?+,&".(#$ \#+'(<'*+,$ -&8(<'&$ -,)$ '3-'$ *'$ 9($ )(&*2,()$ '+$ 9(&'$ &"*'$

;-.*9*-e&$&*'"-'*+,=

>3($<+,<1"&*+,$#(-<3()$0#+.$'3($:+#@&3+8$*&$'3-'$<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,$

*&$ -,$ (6+16*,25$ )7,-.*<$ -,)$ <+.81(/$ -#(-5$ A")2*,2$ 0#+.$ '3($ PN$ 81"&$

8-2($)(6+'*+,$+,$<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,$*,$c-.9*-$-,)$'3($fNN$+))$8-2($

?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$G<'$*,$B+"'3$G0#*<-=

>3(#($ *&$ -1&+$ -$ 2(,(#-1$ #(<+2,*'*+,$ 97$ '3($ 0+#.(#$ D*,*&'(#$ +0$

>#-)($ -,)$ F,)"&'#75$ S#$ T-2($ E(*,2+95$ *,$ '3($ #(<(,'$ ?+,&".(#$

;(:&$ 8"91*<-'*+,$ +0$ B(8'(.9(#$ MNOM$ '3-'$ '3($ <+",'#7$ -'$ 8#(&(,'$

3-&$ ,+$ *,&'*'"'*+,-1$ 0#-.(:+#@$ 8(#'-*,*,2$ '+$ ?+,&".(#$ \#+'(<'*+,$

*,$ ;-.*9*-$ -,)$ '3-'$ '3($ )-:,$ +0$ (,'#(,<3*,2$ ?+,&".(#$

\#+'(<'*+,$(00+#'&$&3+"1)$9($(/8()*'()$*,$;-.*9*-=

>3($ ?+,&".(#$ \#+'(<'*+,$ -,)$ ?+.8('*'*+,$ \+1*<7$ K+#@&3+8$ +,$ MX$

B(8'(.9(#$MNOM$-))#(&&()$+,$9(3-10$+0$'3($\(#.-,(,'$B(<#('-#7$+0$'3($

D*,*&'#7$+0$>#-)($-,)$ F,)"&'#7$-,)$)(1*6(#()$97$ '3($G<'*,2$\(#.-,(,'$

B(<#('-#75$D#&=$T(#.*,-$T*.-#"-5$&8(<*%<-117$&'-'()$'3-'$;-.*9*-$ 1-2&$

9(3*,)$.-,7$<+",'#*(&$*,$B+"'3(#,$G0#*<-$-,)$9(7+,)$*,$'3-'$*'$)+(&$,+'$

3-6($ -$ 1(2*&1-'*+,$ +,$?+,&".(#$\#+'(<'*+,$:*'3$ '3($ #(&"1'-,'$ (00(<'$ +0$

'3($;-.*9*-,$(<+,+.7$&'*11$9(*,2$<3-#-<'(#*&()$97$",0-*#$'#-)($8#-<'*<(&$

-,)$6(#7$1*''1(5$*0$-,75$#(<+"#&($0+#$<+,&".(#&$:3+$3-6($9((,$:#+,2()=$

>3*&$1(-)&$'+$(/81+*'-'*+,$+0$<+,&".(#&$-&$'3(7$-#($1(0'$:*'3$1*''1($<3+*<(5$

(&8(<*-117$2*6(,$'3($<+&'$+0$1*'*2-'*+,=$>3($-))#(&&$<+,<1")()$+,$'3($,(()$

0+#$<#(-'*+,$+0$-$&.-11$<1-*.&$<+"#'$'+$(00(<'$<+,&".(#$#()#(&&$*,$;-.*9*-=

>3($ <#(-'*+,$ -,)$ <-8-<*'-'*+,$ +0$ -$ ?+,&".(#$ \#+'(<'*+,$ S*6*&*+,$

*&$ <+,&*&'(,'$ :*'3$ '3($ '#(,)$ +0$ '3($ &(<'+#-1$ #(2"1-'+#&$ <#(-'*,2$ &"<3$

(,'*'*(&$:*'3*,$'3(*#$&'#"<'"#(&5$,+'-917$'3($;-.*9*-,$B'-,)-#)&$F,&'*'"'($

I;BFJ$ 3-6*,2$ -$ ?+,&".(#$ \#+'(<'*+,$ -,)$ F,&8(<'*+,&$ S*6*&*+,$ -&$ :(11$

-&$ ;GDHFBG$ 3-6*,2$ -$ ?+,&".(#$ C)"<-'*+,$ S(8-#'.(,'=$ >3*&$ *&$ +,17$

,-'"#-1$ &*,<($ ?+.8('*'*+,$ ?+..*&&*+,e&$ :+#@$ "1'*.-'(17$ #(&"1'&$ *,$

<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,$-,)$:(10-#(5$'3-'$'3($?+..*&&*+,e&$&'#"<'"#($&3+"1)$

-<<+..+)-'($8#+8(#$<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,$.(<3-,*&.&=

Mihe Gaomab II

!"#$%&'($)*+#,$&-%.)$/

<< Continued from previous page.

Page 7: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION X

F0,,0&$*:# -/)# %*$++)"%# 05# 0+$*$0*%# -*8# ;0*;)/*%# )G+/)%%)8#

8./$*:#"')#"&0#&0/9%'0+%6 Kindly note that the comments expressed

in this article are those of individual stakeholders and do not

!"#"$$%&'()*&"+"#,*,-"*./00'$$'/!1$*$,%!#"2

“?+,&".(#&$-#($-1:-7&$-'$'3($1+&*,2$(,)$9(<-"&($'3($'#-)(#$+#$<+.8-,7$*&$-1:-7&$*,$-$9(''(#$9-#2-*,*,2$8+&*'*+,=$?+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,$*&&"(&$<-,$

9($'-@(,$'+$<+"#'5$9"'$'3($1(2-1$8#+<(&&$*&$<".9(#&+.($-,)$(/8(,&*6(=$

>3-'$*&$:37$*,&'*'"'*+,&$&"<3$-&$'3($?+.8('*'*+,$?+..*&&*+,$&3+"1)$'-@($

+6(#$'3-'$0",<'*+,$-,)$-<'$+,$9(3-10$+0$'3($<+,&".(#$-&$:(11=$?+.8('*'*+,$

&3+"1)$9($*,<1"&*6($+0$<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,=$>3(#($*&$-$,(()$'+$#(6*(:$'3($

8+1*<7$*,$'3-'$#(2-#)$4$-$,(()$'+$1++@$-'$1-:$#(0+#.=”

“>3(#($*&$,+$1(2*&1-'*+,$'3-'$'#"17$(.8+:(#&$'3($?+..*&&*+,$'+$-))#(&&$<+,&".(#$<+.81-*,'&=$!'3(#$<+",'#*(&5$&"<3$-&$B+"'3$G0#*<-5$(.9#-<()$

<+,&".(#$ 8#+'(<'*+,$ ",)(#$ '3(*#$ <+.8('*'*+,$ <+..*&&*+,&=$ F&$;-.*9*-$

2(-#*,2$'+:-#)&$2+*,2$'3($&-.($#+"'(g”

“?+.8('*'*+,$ -11+:&$ 0+#$ <3(-8(#$ 8#+)"<'&$ '+$ 9($ *.8+#'()=$ >3(#(0+#(5$0#+.$-$<+.8('*'*6(,(&&$8(#&8(<'*6(5$'3($*,0-,'$*,)"&'#7$*&$,+'$8#+'(<'()=$

S+,e'$<+.8#+.*&($+,$L"-1*'7$0+#$1+:$L"-1*'7$*.8+#'&=”

“;-.*9*-,$8#*<(&$0+#$<+,&".-91($2++)&$-#($(/<(&&*6($-,)$'3*&$.-@(&$<+.8('*'*+,$*.8+&&*91($-,)h+#$)*0%<"1'=$;-.*9*-$<3-#2(&$+,$8-#$:*'3$3*23$

*,<+.($.-#@('&$+#$<+",'#*(&=”

“;-.*9*-,$8#+)"<(#&$&"8817$8#+)"<($+0$3*23$L"-1*'7$0+#$(/8+#'$8"#8+&(&5$9"'$ 3-6($ '+$ <+.8('($ -2-*,&'$ *,'(#,-'*+,-1$ 8#+)"<(#&$ :3+$ -#($ %#.17$

(&'-91*&3()5$(&8(<*-117$:*'3$2+6(#,.(,'$9-<@*,2=”

“C<+,+.7$*&$2#+:*,2$7('$(/8+#'$8+'(,'*-1$*&$,+'$+,$'3-'$1(6(1=$>3($(/8+#'$8+'(,'*-1$*&$,+'$2#+:*,2$9(<-"&($'3($8#*.-#7$&(<'+#$*&$:(-@i$'3($&'#(,2'3$

+0$'3($(<+,+.7$*&$0#+.$'3($&(<+,)-#7$&(<'+#=$;-.*9*-$3-&$-$3*23$1(6(1$+0$

*,6(&'.(,'$9"'$'3($(<+,+.7$*&$&'-'*<$-'$Qj=$?+&'$+0$(/8+#'$*&$3*23i$3+:$

(00(<'*6($-#($'3($*,<(,'*6(&g”

“>3($B'-'(4+:,()$C,'(#8#*&(&$E+6(#,-,<($G<'$3-&$8"'$*,$81-<($8#+8(#$&'#"<'"#(&$'+$2"*)($B!C&=$F0$'3(&($2"*)(1*,(&$-#($"&()$8#+8(#175$:($:*11$

&"<<(()$*,$<#(-'*,2$-$0+#.*)-91($(<+,+.7=”

“H+#(*2,$*,6(&'+#&$1*@($'+$3-6($k(/*9*1*'7$*,$'3($3*#*,2$-,)$%#*,2$8#+<(&&(&=$K($3-6($&'#"<'"#(&$+0$:-#,*,2&$-,)$)*&<*81*,-#7$3(-#*,2&$9(0+#($%#*,2=$

>3-'$*&$:37$:($3-6($-$1+:$#-,@*,2$+,$'3-'$&<+#(=”

CONSUMER PROTECTION AND COMPETITIVENESS:

AN OVERVIEW

The Namibian Competition Commission held a week-long consumer protection

and competitiveness event to sensitise stakeholders on the issues of consumer

welfare and the level of Namibia’s competitiveness. Much has been publicised

in the media about the event, which took place in September 2012. In this edi-

tion we give you a glimpse into comments made during the panel discussions

of two workshops that were held on consumer protection and competitiveness.

It is important that consumers have choices and deserve qualitative goods and

services. During this event, strong emphasis was placed on policy and law re-

form with regard to consumer protection in relation to protectionism and redress

mechanisms.

“>3($#(<(,'$<+.8('*'*6(,(&&$#-,@*,2$+,$;-.*9*-$ *&$ *,0+#.()$97$.-,7$*,)*<-'+#&=$K($ '-1@$-9+"'$ -$ 1-<@$+0$ &@*11&$ *,$ '3($ <+",'#7=$K3(,$ 1-&'$ )*)$

:($<-##7$+"'$-$&@*11&$-&&(&&.(,'$&"#6(7g$S+(&$)(.-,)$-,)$&"8817$2+$

3-,)4*,43-,)g$>3(#($-#($'++$.-,7$L"-1*%()$A+9$&((@(#&$+,$'3($&'#(('&$

9(<-"&($ :3-'$ '3(7$ <-,$ +00(#$ *&$ ,+'$ .('$ 97$ )(.-,)$ 0+#$ '3(*#$ @*,)$ +0$

L"-1*%<-'*+,&=”

“b(4(6-1"-'($ '3($ ()"<-'*+,$ <"##*<"1-$ -,)$ 81-<($ &'#+,2$ 0+<"&$ +,$6+<-'*+,-1$'#-*,*,2$'+$#(-1*2,$:*'3$'3($.-#@('=”

“K3+$<+,)"<'&$'3($#-,@*,2$+,$<+.8('*'*6(,(&&g$F&$(6(#79+)7$*,<1")()$*,$&"#6(7&$+0$#-,@*,2&g$K($,(()$'+$ 1++@$-'$:3-'$ *&$+"#$<+&'&$&'#"<'"#($

-&$-,$(<+,+.7=$K($,(()$'+$1++@$*,'+$:3-'$*'$.(-,&$-,)$'-@(&$'+$(/8+#'$

+"#$8#+)"<'&$-,)$&(#6*<(&=$B*,<($'3($<1+&"#($+0$b-.-'(/5$-,$+88+#'",*'7$

(/*&'&$'+$%11$'3-'$2-8$-,)$.-@($"&($+0$'3($(/8+#'$+88+#'",*'7=$>3($<+&'$+0$

(/8+#'$&3+"1)$9($1++@()$-'$*,$+#)(#$'+$&(*]($'3*&$+88+#'",*'7=”

“V+<-1$9"&*,(&&(&$-#($<+.8('*,2$-2-*,&'$0+#(*2,$)*#(<'$ *,6(&'.(,'$9"'$-#($,+'$8#+'(<'()=$G,'*4<+.8('*'*6(,(&&$97$9*2$<+.8-,*(&$3*,)(#&$ 1+<-1$

&.-11$-,)$.()*".$(,'(#8#*&(&$0#+.$6(,'"#*,2$*,'+$'3($(/8+#'$-#(-=”

“>3(#($ -#($ *,3(#(,'$ &'#"<'"#-1$ )*00(#(,<(&$ '3-'$ <+"1)$ *.8()($ +,$<+.8('*'*6(,(&&=$K($,(()$'+$1++@$-'$+"#$<-8-9*1*'*(&5$8"'$+"#$#(&+"#<(&$

-,)$*,0#-&'#"<'"#(&$*,'+$1+:43-,2*,2$0#"*'&=”

“V+<-1$8#+)"<(#&$&3+"1)$(,&"#($-$3*23$1(6(1$+0$8-<@-2*,2$-,)$.-#@('*,2$+0$'3(*#$8#+)"<'&$*,$+#)(#$'+$<+.8('($*,'(#,-'*+,-117=$T*23$*,(L"-1*'7$*,$'3($

&8#(-)$+0$:(-1'3$#()"<(&$'3($)(.-,)$0+#$1+<-1$8#+)"<'&=”

“C)"<-'*+,$ -,)$ -)6+<-<7$ 8#+2#-..(&$ +,$ <+,&".(#$ 8#+'(<'*+,$ -#($<"##(,'17$+,17$'-#2('*,2$'3($()"<-'()=$>3($2#-&&#++'&$1-7.(,$&3+"1)$-1&+$

9($*,<1")()$:3(,$()"<-'*6($-,)$*,0+#.-'*6($.(&&-2(&$-#($8"91*<*&()=”

Page 8: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

^ NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION

NaCC MAKES DETERMINATION ON E-MED/ISOS

PROPOSED MERGER

HIJ)8#K)%;.)CL#-*8#!*")/*-"$0*-,#MNM#O-($>$-#E/0+0%)8#J)/:)/#

E/0'$>$")8#I#>1#P-"-*80#P-*:.))'$

>3($;-.*9*-,$?+.8('*'*+,$?+..*&&*+,$+,$MO$H(9#"-#7$MNOP$8#+3*9*'()$

'3($8#+8+&()$.(#2(#$9(':((,$;-.*9*-$b(&<"($B(#6*<(&$I\'7J$V')$4$'#-)*,2$

-&$C4D()$b(&<"(MQ$IC4D()J$4$-,)$F,'(#,-'*+,-1$B!B$;-.*9*-$I\'7J$V')$

IFB!BJ$ -,)$ ;(:<+$ 9(<-"&($ '3($ 8#+8+&()$ .(#2(#$ #-*&()$ <+.8('*'*+,$

<+,<(#,&=$>3($)(<*&*+,$:-&$#(-<3()$0+11+:*,2$-$'3+#+"23$*,6(&'*2-'*+,$

+0$ '3($ 8#+8+&()$.(#2(#$ 9-&()$ +,$ '3($ <+,&*)(#-'*+,&$ <+,'(.81-'()$ *,$

B(<'*+,$QXIMJ$+0$'3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$M$+0$MNNP=

!,$ '3($ Md'3$!<'+9(#$ MNOM5$ '3($?+..*&&*+,$ #(<(*6()$ -$ ,+'*%<-'*+,$ *,$

'(#.&$+0$B(<'*+,$QQIOJ$ +0$ '3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'5$G<'$;+=$ M$ +0$ MNNP$ I'3($

G<'J5$ +,$ '3($ 8#+8+&()$ '#-,&-<'*+,$ 9(':((,$C4D()5$ FB!B$ -,)$;(:<+=$

>3($'#-,&-<'*+,$(,'-*1&$C4D()$-,)$FB!B$'#-,&0(##*,2$-11$'3(*#$(.(#2(,<7$

.()*<-1$ &(#6*<(&$ -&&('&$ -,)$ '3(*#$ (.(#2(,<7$ &(#6*<(&$ 9"&*,(&&$ '+$

;(:<+$-&$-$2+*,2$<+,<(#,=

C4D()$*&$-$<+.8-,7$#(2*&'(#()$*,$'(#.&$+0$'3($1-:&$+0$'3($b(8"91*<$+0$

;-.*9*-=$C4D()$*&$<+,'#+11()$97$\#+&8(#*'7$G0#*<-$T+1)*,2&$I\'7J$V')5$-$

)*6(#&*%()$;-.*9*-,$",)(#'-@*,2$:*'3$*,'(#(&'&$*,$3(-1'3<-#(5$*,&"#-,<(5$

Page 9: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION d

8#+8(#'*(&$ -,)$ '+"#*&.=$ \#+&8(#*'7$ T+1)*,2&$ *&$ *,$ '"#,$ <+,'#+11()$ 97$

V*0(<-#($>#"&'=$

FB!B$ *&$-$ <+.8-,7$ #(2*&'(#()$ *,$ '(#.&$+0$ '3($ 1-:&$+0$ '3($b(8"91*<$+0$

;-.*9*-$-,)$*&$-$:3+1174+:,()$&"9&*)*-#7$+0$F,'(#,-'*+,-1$B!B$IB+"'3(#,$

G0#*<-J$ T+1)*,2&$ V*.*'()5$ I-$ &"9&*)*-#7$ +0$ U1"($ ?#+&&$ >#-6(1$ B(#6*<(&$

I;('3(#1-,)&JJ=$ F,'(#,-'*+,-1$ B!B$ IB+"'3(#,$ G0#*<-J$ T+1)*,2&$ V*.*'()$

-1&+$<+,'#+1&$'3#(($IPJ$B+"'3$G0#*<-,$&"9&*)*-#*(&$-,)$+,($IOJ$D-"#*'*-,$

&"9&*)*-#7=

C4D()$8#+6*)(&$(.(#2(,<7$-,)$,+,4(.(#2(,<7$.()*<-1$'#-,&8+#'-'*+,$

97$ -*#$ -.9"1-,<($ -&$ :(11$ -&$ #(1-'()$ .()*<-1$ '#-*,*,2$ &(#6*<(&=$ >3($

0+11+:*,2$-#($ '3($(.(#2(,<7$.()*<-1$&(#6*<(&$8#+6*)()$97$C4D()_$MQ4

3+"#$ .()*<-1$ &"88+#'$ <-11$ <(,'#(5$ #+-)$ -.9"1-,<($ '#-,&8+#'-'*+,5$ -*#$

-.9"1-,<($'#-,&8+#'-'*+,5$9-&*<$-,)$-)6-,<()$1*0($&"88+#'5$*,'(#.()*-'($

1*0($&"88+#'$8-#-.()*<&5$(.(#2(,<7$*,'(#43+&8*'-1$'#-,&0(#&5$(.(#2(,<7$

#(8-'#*-'*+,$&(#6*<(&5$-,)$.()*<-1$'#-*,*,2$&(#6*<(&=

FB!B$ -1&+$ 8#+6*)(&$ (.(#2(,<7$ -,)$ ,+,4(.(#2(,<7$ .()*<-1$

'#-,&8+#'-'*+,$ 97$ #+-)$ +#$ -*#$ -.9"1-,<(5$ -,)$ #(1-'()$ .()*<-1$ '#-*,*,2$

&(#6*<(&$&*.*1-#$'+$'3+&($+00(#()$97$C4D()=

>3($ ?+..*&&*+,5$ )"#*,2$ *'&$ *,6(&'*2-'*+,5$ 0+",)$ '3-'$ '3($ 8#+8+&()$

.(#2(#$8#(&(,'()$3+#*]+,'-1$+6(#1-8&=$>3*&$*&$9(<-"&($C4D()$-,)$FB!B$

-#($'3($':+$9*22(&'$8#+6*)(#&$+0$(.(#2(,<7$.()*<-1$(6-<"-'*+,$&(#6*<(&$

*,$;-.*9*-=$>3($8#+8+&()$.(#2(#$:+"1)$'3(#(0+#($#(&"1'$*,$'3($#(.+6-1$

+0$l'3($9*22(&'m$<+.8('*'+#$*,$'3($#(1(6-,'$.-#@('=$

>3($.()*<-1$(.(#2(,<7$(6-<"-'*+,$.-#@('$ *&$3*2317$<+,<(,'#-'()$:*'3$

3*23$(,'#7$9-##*(#&=$>3($8#+8+&()$.(#2(#$:+"1)$*,<#(-&($'3($<+,<(,'#-'*+,$

1(6(1$ *,$ '3($ .-#@('$ -,)$ :+"1)$ -1&+$ #(&"1'$ *,$ '3($ .(#2()$ ",)(#'-@*,2$

-<L"*#*,2$-,)$&'#(,2'3(,*,2$-$)+.*,-,'$8+&*'*+,$*,$'3($#(1(6-,'$.-#@('=$

>3($?+..*&&*+,$*&$'3(#(0+#($+0$'3($6*(:$'3-'$'3($*,<#(-&()$<+,<(,'#-'*+,$

1(6(1$-,)$'3($-<L"*&*'*+,$+0$-$)+.*,-,'$",)(#'-@*,2$:+"1)$#(&"1'$ *,$ '3($

8#(6(,'*+,$+#$1(&&(,*,2$+0$<+.8('*'*+,$*,$'3($#(1(6-,'$.-#@('=$

>3($?+..*&&*+,e&$*,6(&'*2-'*+,$0"#'3(#$#(6(-1()$'3-'$'3($.-#@('$&'#"<'"#($

<+"1)$ 8+'(,'*-117$ #-*&($ <+.8('*'*+,$ <+,<(#,&=$ C4D()$ -,)$ FB!B$ 3-6($

9+'3$8#(6*+"&17$-,)$<"##(,'17$<+,<1")()$&(#6*<($1(6(1$-2#((.(,'&$IBVGJ$

:*'3$.()*<-1$ -*)$ 0",)&$ #(2-#)*,2$ '3($ 8#+6*&*+,$ +0$ (.(#2(,<7$.()*<-1$

(6-<"-'*+,$&(#6*<(&=$>3($?+..*&&*+,$ *&$+0$ '3($6*(:$ '3-'$ *0$ '3($.(#2(#$

*&$-88#+6()$+,17$+,($",)(#'-@*,2$*,$'3($.-#@('$<+"1)$<+,<1")($BVG$:*'3$

.()*<-1$-*)$0",)&=$>3*&$:+"1)$#(&"1'$ *,$'3($8#(6(,'*+,$-,)$1(&&(,*,2$+0$

<+.8('*'*+,$*,$'3($.-#@('=$

>3($?+..*&&*+,$<+,6(,()$-$&'-@(3+1)(#$<+,0(#(,<($*,$'(#.&$+0$B(<'*+,$

QRIOJ$+0$'3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$+,$M^'3$W-,"-#7$MNOP=$>3($8"#8+&($+0$'3($

<+,0(#(,<($ :-&$ '+$ 8#+6*)($ -$ 81-'0+#.$ '+$ *,'(#(&'()$ 8-#'*(&5$ *,<1")*,2$

.(.9(#&$+0$'3($8"91*<5$'+$.-@($#(8#(&(,'-'*+,&$#(2-#)*,2$'3($8#+8+&()$

.(#2(#=$G$&'-@(3+1)(#$<+,0(#(,<($ *&$<+,6(,()$97$ '3($?+..*&&*+,$ *0$-$

8#+8+&()$.(#2(#$#-*&(&$<+.8('*'*+,$-,)h+#$8"91*<$*,'(#(&'$<+,<(#,&=$

\-#'*<*8-,'&$-'$'3($<+,0(#(,<($#-*&()$<+.8('*'*+,$<+,<(#,&$:3*<3$:(#($

<+,&*&'(,'$ :*'3$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,e&$ *,*'*-1$ -&&(&&.(,'$ +0$ '3($ 8#+8+&()$

.(#2(#=$

!*#%.((-/1<#"')#20(($%%$0*#+/0'$>$")8#"')#+/0+0%)8#()/:)/#>);-.%)Q

O=$ >3($ 8#+8+&()$ .(#2(#$ :+"1)$ #(&"1'$ *,$ '3($ *,<#(-&()$ 1(6(1$ +0$

<+,<(,'#-'*+,$ *,$ '3($ #(1(6-,'$ .-#@('=$ >3($ 8#+8+&()$ .(#2(#$ -1&+$

*,6+16(&$ '3($ #(.+6-1$ +0$ -,$ (00(<'*6($ <+.8('*'+#$ *,$ '3($ #(1(6-,'$

.-#@('5$ 1(-6*,2$ '3($ .(#2()$ ",)(#'-@*,2$ :*'3+"'$ -$ 0+#.*)-91($

<+.8('*'+#$8+&'4.(#2(#i$

M=$ F'$:*11$#(&"1'$*,$'3($",)(#'-@*,2&$*,6+16()$*,$'3*&$'#-,&-<'*+,$'+$-<L"*#($

-,)$&'#(,2'3(,$-$)+.*,-,'$8+&*'*+,$*,$'3($#(1(6-,'$.-#@('i

P=$ >3($ -11(2()$ 9(,(%'&$ '+$ '3($ 8"91*<$ I*,<#(-&()$ ,-'*+,-1$ 0++'$ 8#*,'J$

)+$ ,+'$ +"':(*23$ '3($ )('#*.(,'$ :3*<3$:+"1)$ 1*@(17$ #(&"1'$ 0#+.$ '3($

",)(#'-@*,2$'+$'3($'#-,&-<'*+,$-<L"*#*,2$-$)+.*,-,'$8+&*'*+,$*,$'3($

.-#@('i

Q=$ U-##*(#&$ '+$ (,'#7$ *,$ '3($ #(1(6-,'$ .-#@('$ -#($ 3*23$ -,)$ &.-11$

",)(#'-@*,2&5$ *,$8-#'*<"1-#$&.-11$",)(#'-@*,2&$+:,()$+#$<+,'#+11()$

97$3*&'+#*<-117$)*&-)6-,'-2()$8(#&+,&5$-#($,+'$1*@(17$'+$2-*,$-<<(&&$

'+$+#$9($<+.8('*'*6($*,$'3($#(1(6-,'$.-#@('=$

>3($ 8#+8+&()$ .(#2(#$ *&$ '3(#(0+#($ 1*@(17$ '+$ &"9&'-,'*-117$ 8#(6(,'$ -,)$

1(&&(,$<+.8('*'*+,$*,$'3($.-#@('$0+#$'3($8#+6*&*+,$+0$(.(#2(,<7$.()*<-1$

(6-<"-'*+,$&(#6*<(&$-,)$:-&$'3"&$8#+3*9*'()=

Katando Kangueehi

Economist: Mergers and Acquisitions

Katando Kangueehi

Page 10: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

ON NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION

R')#4/%"#)=)/#;-+-;$"1#>.$,8$*:#&0/9%'0+#0*#/)%)-/;'#%9$,,%#$*#;0(+)"$"$0*#

-*-,1%$%#&-%#'),8#$*#7$*8'0)9<#O-($>$-<#5/0(#SIT#U);)(>)/#C@AC#>1#"')#

?5/$;-*# 20(+)"$"$0*# F0/.(# V?2FW<# $*# ;0,,->0/-"$0*# &$"'# "')# O-($>$-*#

20(+)"$"$0*# 20(($%%$0*# VO-22W# -*8# "')# 20(+)"$"$0*# 20(($%%$0*#

05# M0."'# ?5/$;-# V22M?W6# R')# -$(# 05# "')# &0/9%'0+<# >)%$8)%# $(>.$*:#

8),):-")%# &$"'# 50/(-,# /)%)-/;'# ");'*$X.)%<# &-%# "0# -,%0# 8),$>)/-")# 0*#

$%%.)%#+)/"-$*$*:#"0#+/-;"$;-,#/)%)-/;'#-*8#-*-,1"$;-,#%9$,,%<#&'$;'#50/(#-#

=$"-,#+-/"#$*#;-//1$*:#0."#"')#(-*8-")#05#"')#;0(+)"$"$0*#-."'0/$"$)%6

b(&(-#<3$ &@*11&$ *,$ <+.8('*'*+,$ -#($ -9+"'$ '(<3,*L"(&$ '+$ -*)$ *,$ '3($

",)(#&'-,)*,2$+0$:3-'$",)(#1*(&$+9&(#6()$+"'<+.(&$4$&"<3$-&$-88-#(,'17$

",<+.8('*'*6($8#*<(&$4$'3#+"23$2-'3(#*,2$'3($,(<(&&-#7$*,0+#.-'*+,$-,)$

)-'-5$-,)$-,-17&*,2$*'$97$)#-:*,2$+,$'3(+#*(&$-,)$<+,<(8'&=$

S(6(1+8*,2$ -,)$ *.8#+6*,2$ #(&(-#<3$ <-8-9*1*'*(&$ 3-88(,&$ '3#+"23$

8#-<'*<(=$ $ >3(#(0+#(5$ '3($:+#@&3+8$:-&$ +#*(,'()$ '+:-#)&$ '3($ 8#-<'*<-1$

<3-11(,2(&$+0$",)(#'-@*,2$#(&(-#<3$0+#$<+.8('*'*+,$-,-17&*&5$<+.9*,*,2$

9#(-@-:-7$:+#@*,2$&(&&*+,&$"&*,2$378+'3('*<-1&$:*'3$81(,-#7$&(&&*+,&=$

>3($ #(&(-#<3$ &@*11&$ <-8-<*'7$ 9"*1)*,2$ -1&+$ *,<1")()$ 8#(&(,'-'*+,&$ +0$

*,*'*-1$8-8(#&$ 0#+.$&*/$<+",'#*(&e$&'")*(&$+,$8+"1'#75$<(.(,'$-,)$&"2-#=$

>3($ 8#(&(,'-'*+,&$ :(#($ .-)($ 97$ #(8#(&(,'-'*6(&$ +0$ B+"'3$ G0#*<-5$

;-.*9*-5$U+'&:-,-5$c-.9*-5$n(,7-$-,)$>-,]-,*-=$!,$R$S(<(.9(#5$'3($

8#(&(,'-'*+,&$ :(#($ <+,<1")()$ :*'3$ )(1*9(#-'*+,&$ '3-'$ 7*(1)()$ )('-*1()$

#(&(-#<3$81-,&$0+#$'3($&(<+,)$83-&($+0$'3($&'")7=$>3($#(&"1'&$+0$'3($&'")7$

-#($(/8(<'()$'+$9($8"91*&3()$'+:-#)&$'3($(,)$+0$MNOP=

>3($ :+#@&3+85$ &'((#()$ 97$ S#$ B*.+,$ b+9(#'&5$ ?3*(0$ C<+,+.*&'$ -,)$

D-,-2(#$ +0$ \+1*<7$ -,)$ b(&(-#<3$ S*6*&*+,$ +0$ '3($ ??BG5$ 0+<"&()$ +,$

&8(<*%<$-#(-&$+0$:3-'$#(&(-#<3$(,'-*1&i$'3(+#*(&$+0$3-#.i$#(&(-#<3$&@*11&$

-881*()$ '+$ -)6+<-<7$ -,)$ 8+1*<7$ L"(&'*+,&$ -,)$ .(#2(#&i$ 8#(&(,'-'*+,$

+0$ #(2*+,-1$ '#-)($ )-'-i$ -,)$ '3($ 8#(&(,'-'*+,&$ +,$ 8+"1'#75$ <(.(,'$ -,)$

&"2-#=$S#$D*<3-(1$T".-6*,)"5$S*#(<'+#$+0$b(&(-#<3$-,)$S(6(1+8.(,'$

+0$ '3($ ;-??$ 8#+6*)()$ ."<34,(()()$ &"88+#'$ -&$ '3($ 3+&'$ *,&'*'"'*+,$

#(8#(&(,'-'*6(=

>3($:+#@&3+8e&$#(&+"#<($8(#&+,&$:(#($\#+0(&&+#$C1(-,+#$H+/i$K-1'(#$W$

S(#(,9(#25$\#+0(&&+#$+0$>#-)($b(2"1-'*+,$0#+.$'3($;(:$o+#@$Y,*6(#&*'7$

B<3++1$+0$V-:i$-,)$\#+0(&&+#$H#()(#*<$W(,,75$?3-*#.-,$+0$ '3($!C?S$

?+.8('*'*+,$V-:$-,)$\+1*<7$?+..*''((=$>3(7$&3-#()$'3(*#$(/8(#'*&($*,$

'3($%(1)$+0$#(&(-#<3$-,)$<+.8('*'*+,$1-:$-,)$8+1*<7=$

R')#&0/9%'0+# ;0*;,.8)8#&$"'# -# :-,-# 8$**)/# '0%")8# >1# O-22<# -"#

&'$;'#70/,8#20(+)"$"$0*#U-1#&-%#-,%0#;0(()(0/-")86#F0,,0&$*:#

-/)# /)(-/9%# (-8)# >1# =-/$0.%# %+)-9)/%# -"# "')# :-,-# 8$**)/# 0*#

T#U);)(>)/Q

2'-$/(-*#05#"')#O-22#D0-/8#05#20(($%%$0*)/%<#Y.;$.%#J./0/.-#

“>3($ *.8+#'-,<($ +0$ 3-6*,2$ -$ <+.8('*'*+,$ -"'3+#*'7$ -,)$ *'&$ #+1($ '+$

(<+,+.*<$)(6(1+8.(,'$-,)$<+.8('*'*6(,(&&$<-,,+'$9($+6(#(.83-&*&()=$

!"#$ '-&@$ *&$ '+$ (/-.*,($ -,)$ #(.()7$ -,'*4<+.8('*'*6($ <+,)"<'$ -,)$ '+$

(,&"#($'3-'$.(#2(#&$)+$,+'$&*2,*%<-,'17$)(<#(-&($<+.8('*'*+,=$!"#$#+1($

*&$ '+$ 8#+'(<'$ <+,&".(#&$ 0#+.$ -,'*4<+.8('*'*6($ 8#-<'*<(&$ -,)$ (&8(<*-117$

.-#@('$ <+,)"<'$ '3-'$ <+,&'#-*,$ <+,&".(#$ 9(3-6*+"#$ '3#+"23$.*&1(-)*,2$

-)6(#'*&*,25$ (/<(&&*6($ +#$ 8#()-'+#7$ 8#*<*,25$ +#$ <+,&'#-*,()$ 8#+)"<'$ +#$

&(#6*<($<3+*<(&=

>3($+6(#-#<3*,2$2+-1$+0$-$<+.8('*'*+,$-"'3+#*'7$*&$'+$(,&"#($'3-'$<+,&".(#&$

+0$2++)&$-,)$&(#6*<(&5$ 0#+.$*,)*6*)"-1$&3+88(#&$ '+$9"&*,(&&(&5$9(,(%'$

0#+.$8-7*,2$1(&&5$-,)$#(<(*6*,2$.+#($<3+*<($-,)$L"-1*'7$0+#$'3(*#$.+,(7=$

F'&$"1'*.-'($8"#8+&($*&$'+$-*)$*,$'3($)(6(1+8.(,'$+0$'3($(<+,+.7$'3#+"23$

-$ 0-*#$-,)$ A"&'$<+.8('*'*6($-<'*6*'7=$>3(#(0+#(5$:($-#($ 0+#'",-'($ '+$3-6($

-$ 2+6(#,.(,'$ '3-'$ '3#+"23$ '3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$ M$ +0$ MNNP$ (&'-91*&3()$

'3($?+..*&&*+,$'+$&'((#$*'&$+9A(<'*6($+0$<+,&".(#$:(10-#($-,)$(<+,+.*<$

2#+:'3$0+#$'3($<+",'#7=$K($-#($0"#'3(#$<+,&*)(#-'($'3-'$-&$-$?+.8('*'*+,$

G"'3+#*'7$'3-'$:($:*11$-<<(,'"-'($'3($8#+6*&*+,&$+0$'3($G<'$+,$<+,&".(#$

8#+'(<'*+,$*,$;-.*9*-$*,$MNOP=

>3($;-.*9*-,$?+.8('*'*+,$?+..*&&*+,$3-&$A"#*&)*<'*+,$+6(#$̂ N5NNN$%#.&5$

<+.8-,*(&$-,)$9"&*,(&&(&=$>3($?+..*&&*+,$3-&$-$#+1($+0$<+,&*)(#*,2$

(/(.8'*+,$ -881*<-'*+,&$ +0$ +6(#$ f5NNN$ 8#+0(&&*+,-1$ -&&+<*-'*+,&$ *,$ '3($

<+",'#7=$>3($ #+1($+0$ '3($?+..*&&*+,$ *&$-1&+$ '+$<++#)*,-'($-,)$(,2-2($

(00(<'*6(17$*'&$<+.8('*'*+,$0",<'*+,&$-,)$#(&8+,&*9*1*'*(&$:*'3$-11$&(<'+#-1$

#(2"1-'+#&5$:3*<3$,".9(#&$"8$'+$MN=$

;-.*9*-$*&$'3($M,)$<+",'#7$'+$*.81(.(,'$'3($<+.8('*'*+,$1-:$-0'(#$B+"'3$

G0#*<-$*,$'3($B+"'3(#,$G0#*<-,$?"&'+.&$Y,*+,$-,)$*&$'3($R'3$'+$)+$&+$:*'3*,$

'3($ B+"'3(#,$ G0#*<-,$ S(6(1+8.(,'$ ?+..",*'7$ IBGS?J$ 0+11+:*,2$ '3($

1(-)*,2$(<+,+.*(&$&"<3$-&$bBG5$D-1-:*5$>-,]-,*-5$c-.9*-5$c*.9-9:(=

D(.+#-,)-$+0$Y,)(#&'-,)*,2&$:(#($&*2,()$ *,$ '3($\+#'&5$U-,@*,2$-,)$

F?>$B(<'+#&$-,)$#(<(,'17$:*'3$'3($G,'*4?+##"8'*+,$?+..*&&*+,5$-,)$'3($

?+..*&&*+,$*&$(/81+#*,2$&*.*1-#$-6(,"(&$:*'3$+'3(#&$:3+$-#($(,'#"&'()$

:*'3$#(2"1-'+#7$#(&8+,&*9*1*'*(&$*,$'3($,+,49-,@*,2$%,-,<*-15$'+"#*&.$-,)$

(1(<'#*<*'7$&(<'+#&=

S"#*,2$.7$8(#*+)$-'$'3($?+..*&&*+,5$F$3-6($8#*,<*8-117$9((,$<+,<(#,()$

+,$ '3($ *,&'*'"'*+,-1$ )(6(1+8.(,'$ +0$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,$ -,)$ <"##(,'$

.()*-$ #(8+#'&$ &3+:$ '3-'$ :($ 3-6($ <+.($ +0$ -2($ '+$ 2*6($ (00(<'$ '+$ '3($

*,&8*#*,2$ 6*&*+,$ +0$ &(#6*,2$ +"#$ <1*(,'&$ -,)$ &'-@(3+1)(#&$ )*1*2(,'17$ -,)$

8#+<()"#-117=$F$-.$8#+")$'+$&-7$'3-'$'3($?+..*&&*+,$*&$,+:$-$0"117$k()2()$

0",<'*+,*,2$ *,&'*'"'*+,$ :*'3$ -$ &'#+,2$ <+#8+#-'($ 2+6(#,-,<($ &'#"<'"#($ +0$

%6($ ?+..*&&*+,(#&5$ ?C!hB(<#('-#7$ '+$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,5$ -,)$ PN$ &'-00$

8#+0(&&*+,-1&$-).*,*&'(#*,2$-,)$ *.81(.(,'*,2$ '3($<+.8('*'*+,$ 1-:=$K($

3-6($ 2-'3(#()$ .+.(,'".$ '+$ (,&"#($ +"#$ <+.8('*'*+,$ :+#@$ *&$ -#+",)$

'3($ (<+,+.*<$ *.8-<'5$ #(2"1-#17$ (6-1"-'*,2$:3-'$:($ )+5$ (,3-,<*,2$ '3($

?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$'+$'-<@1($.-#@('$8#+91(.&$3+1*&'*<-1175$8#+.+'*,2$-$&'#+,2$

0+<"&$ +,$ <+.8('*'*+,$ :*'3*,$ E+6(#,.(,'5$ -,)$ :+#@*,2$ -<'*6(17$ :*'3$

9"&*,(&&$'+$0+&'(#$<+.81*-,<($:*'3$'3($1-:=$

!"#$ :+#@$ 8#+)"<(&$ (<+,+.*<$ 9(,(%'&$ -&$ (6*)(,'$ 0#+.$ 3*23$ 8#+%1()$

<-&(&$ *,<1")*,2$ '3($<(.(,'$&(<'+#5$ F?>5$9-,@*,25$-,)$ '3($8+#'&$&(<'+#=$

!"#$.-'"#*'7$-&$-$?+.8('*'*+,$(,0+#<(.(,'$-2(,<7$:-&$-.817$8*'<3()$-'$

'3($K-14D-#'hD-&&4D-#'$B"8#(.($?+"#'$<3-11(,2($'3-'$:($3-6($:+,$'+$

'3($9(&'$(<+,+.*<$,-'*+,-1$*,'(#(&'&$+0$;-.*9*-=

!"#$83*1+&+837$-&$?+..*&&*+,$3-&$9((,$'+$:+#@$:*'3$ '3($2#-*,$+0$ '3($

.-#@('5$ *,'(#6(,*,2$ +,17$ :3(#($ :($ 9(1*(6($ :($ <-,$ -1'(#$ *,<(,'*6(&$ '+$

-<3*(6($ -$ 9(''(#$ .-#@('$ +"'<+.($ 0+#$ +"#$ &'-@(3+1)(#&=$ F$ 9(1*(6($ '3-'$

:3*1($*.8#+6(.(,'&$<-,$-1:-7&$9($.-)(5$.-,7$.-#@('&$*,$'3($;-.*9*-,$

(<+,+.7$ -#($ <3-#-<'(#*&()$ 97$ *,'(,&($ -,)$ <+,<(,'#-'()$ <+.8('*'*+,5$

:*'3$ -<'*6($ -,)$ (,2-2()$ <-#'(1$ 9(3-6*+"#=$ T(,<($ :($ -*.$ '+$ &('$ '3($

AFRICAN COMPETITION AUTHORITIES DELIBERATE

ON RESEARCH SKILLS

Page 11: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION 11

-2(,)-$ 0+#:-#)$+,$ &'#+,2$(,0+#<(.(,'$ '+$ (,&"#($ #(+#*(,'-'*+,$ 0+#$ +"#$

(<+,+.7$*,$MNOP=

>3($;-.*9*-,$?+.8('*'*+,$?+..*&&*+,$3-&$(,&"#()$*'&$#(1(6-,<($-,)$

(/8+&"#($'3#+"23$*'&$<+,'#*9"'*+,$'+$'3($F,'(#,-'*+,-1$?+.8('*'*+,$;(':+#@$

-,)$'3($G0#*<-,$?+.8('*'*+,$H+#".$-,)$8-#'*<*8-'*+,$*,$+'3(#$0+#-=$$F$-.$

8#+")$ '3-'$ '3($ ?+.8('*'*+,$ ?+..*&&*+,$ 3-&$ 81-7()$ -$ &'#+,2$ #+1($ *,$

8#+.+'*,2$.+#($ <+,&*&'(,'$ &'-,)-#)&$ +0$ -88#+-<3$ '+$ +"#$ &'-@(3+1)(#&$

:*'3$#()"<()$",<(#'-*,'7$0+#$*,'(#,-'*+,-1$9"&*,(&&$*,6(&'.(,'5$(,3-,<()$

<++8(#-'*+,$ '+$ )(-1$ :*'3$ 1+<-1$ .-#@('$ *&&"(&5$ -,)$ (,&"#()$ &"88+#'*6($

;-.*9*-,49-&()$ <-8-<*'7$ +,$ <+.8('*'*+,$ .-''(#&$ *,$ '3($ <+",'#7=$ >3($

-).*,*&'#-'*+,$ -,)$ *.81(.(,'-'*+,$ +0$ '3($ ?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$ *&$ )-",'*,2$

-,)$<3-11(,2*,25$9"'$*&$,+'$)*0%<"1'$'+$-<3*(6(=$F'$*&$-$'#*9"'($'+$.7$0(11+:$

?+..*&&*+,(#&$ '3-'$ :($ 3-6($ .-,-2()$ '+$ .-*,'-*,$ +"#$ +"'8"'$ :3*1($

*.81(.(,'*,2$'3($G<'$:*'3$-$1*.*'()$9")2('=$>3($<+.8('*'*+,$(,6*#+,.(,'$

*&$-'$*'&$9(&'$3-6*,2$-$<3-11(,2()$,-##+:$6(&'()$*,'(#(&'&$-,)$*'$*&$6*'-117$

*.8+#'-,'$'3-'$'3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$*&$,+'$<+.8#+.*&()$'+$&"<3$*,'(#(&'&$

-'$'3($(/8(,&($+0$&+<*('7$-'$1-#2(=”

E/05)%%0/#H,)-*0/#F0G

B8(-@*,2$ +,$ '3($ <3-11(,2(&$ 0-<*,2$ 7+",2$ <+.8('*'*+,$ -"'3+#*'*(&5$

\#+0(&&+#$C1(-,+#$H+/$L"+'()$-"'3+#$?3-#1(&$n"8<3-,5$:3+$:#+'(5$Z;+$

!,(e&$K+#1)_$>3($K(&'5$>3($b*&*,2$b(&'$-,)$'3($?+.*,2$E1+9-1$>"#,=[$

-,)$&'-'()$ '3-'$ ZI-J$21+9-1$ '"#,$:*11$9#*,2$ '+$-,$(,)$ '3($(#-$+0$K(&'(#,$

)+.*,-,<(=$ $U"'$:3-'$<+.(&$,(/'$:*11$,+'$9($'3($?3*,(&($<(,'"#75$ '3($

G&*-,$<(,'"#75$+#$-,7+,($(1&(e&$<(,'"#7=$$b-'3(#5$,+$+,(e&$:+#1)$:*11$(/3*9*'$

&'#*@*,2$ )*6(#&*'7i$ -1'(#,-'*6($ <+,<(8'*+,&$ +0$ )+.(&'*<$ -,)$ *,'(#,-'*+,-1$

+#)(#$:*11$<+.8('($-,)$<+(/*&'$+,$'3($21+9-1$&'-2(=[

“>3($'(<'+,*<$81-'(&$3-6($&3*0'()=$;+'$'3-'$K(&'(#,$1-:$3-&$1+&'$*'&$#+1($

-&$-$#(0(#(,'5$9"'$ '3(#($ *&$-$k-''(,*,2$+0$ '3($<+.8('*'*+,$:+#1)=$!6(#$-$

3",)#()$+'3(#$,-'*+,&$3-6($-)+8'()$<+.8('*'*+,$1-:&$+0$'3(*#$+:,=$F'$*&$

,+'$'3($G.(#*<-,$:+#1)i$*'$*&$.+#($C"#+8(e&$:+#1)i$*'$*&$C6(#7+,(e&$K+#1)=

F$#(*'(#-'($'3($&'-'(.(,'$.-)($97$;-??$?C!5$D*3($E-+.-9$FF$*,$-$1+<-1$

)-*17$ '3-'$ <+.8('*'*+,$ *&$ -$ @(7$ *,2#()*(,'$ '+$ <+.8('*'*6(,(&&$ -,)$ '3-'$

*,$ +#)(#$ 0+#$ -$ <+.8('*'*+,$ -"'3+#*'7$ '+$ <-##7$ +"'$ *'&$.-,)-'(5$ '3($ #*23'$

*,&'*'"'*+,&i$ *,0#-&'#"<'"#(_$ '#-,&8+#'-'*+,i$ F>i$ '3($ #*23'$.-<#+4(<+,+.*<$

(,6*#+,.(,'i$3".-,$#(&+"#<(&_$()"<-'*+,$-,)$&@*11&i$(0%<*(,<7_$ 1+:(&'$

<+&'$8#+)"<()$97$<+.8('*'*+,$*&$#(L"*#()=

>3($ #*<3$ ,-'*+,&$ -#($ 0#(($ '#-)(#&$ :3(,$ *'$ &"*'&$ '3(.$ -,)$ &(1(<'*6(17$

8#+'(<'*+,*&'$:3(,$*'$&"*'&$'3(.5$&3($,+'()5$<*'*,2$-,'*4)".8*,25$&"9&*)*(&$

-,)$ '-#*00&$ -&$(/-.81(&=$ F,$MNNN5$ '3($CY$8#+6*)()$pdOP$ 0+#$ (-<3$<+:$

-,)$p^$'+$(-<3$&"94B-3-#-,$G0#*<-,=$q$;+'$'+$9($+"')+,(5$'3($YB$&8(,'$

pON=X$.*11*+,$-$)-7$+,$<+''+,$-,)$pP=O$.*11*+,$-$)-7$+,$-11$-*)$ '+$&"94

B-3-#-,$G0#*<-=$$>3($8#*+#*'*(&$&3+:,$3(#($-#($+9&<(,(=

>3($%23'$*,$'3($<+.8('*'*+,$-#(,-$*&$-2-*,&'$:+#1)$-,)$(/8+#'$<-#'(1&5$'3($

)*&<+6(#7$+0$8(+81($-,)$)+<".(,'&$97$'3($<+.8('*'*+,$-"'3+#*'*(&$*,$'3($

3+.($&'-'($+0$'3($<-#'(1*&'&=$n"8<3-,5$*,$3*&$2#-,)$6*&*+,$+0$0+#(*2,$8+1*<75$

&"22(&'&$'3-'$*,$;+$!,(e&$K+#1)5$:($."&'$:+#@$'+:-#)&$-$.+#($*,<1"&*6($

21+9-1$ +#)(#5$ <"1'*6-'*,2$ #(&8(<'$ 0+#$ )*00(#(,'$ <3+*<(&$ ,-'*+,&$.-@(=$ F,$

'3($21+9-1$:+#1)$ +0$ <+.8('*'*+,5$ -,$G0#*<-,$ 6+*<($(.(#2(&$ 0#+.$<#+&&4

0(#'*1*&-'*+,5$-&$*,$G?Hi$-$6-1"($+0$*,<1"&*6(,(&&5$-,)$#(&8(<'$0+#$<3+*<(&5$

:3*1($,")2*,2$'3($:+#1)$'+:-#)&$2#(-'(#$<+3(#(,<(=”

J$')#Z-0(->#!!

“>3($;-??$A+*,()$3-,)&$:*'3$'3($#(&'$+0$'3($:+#1)$*,$<(1(9#-'*,2$'3($'3*#)$

K+#1)$?+.8('*'*+,$S-75$:3*<3$*&$<+..(.+#-'()$-,,"-117$+,$'3($f'3$+0$

S(<(.9(#i$ '3($ )-7$ )()*<-'()$ '+$ '3($ '3(.($ ZF.8-<'$ +0$ ?-#'(1&$ +,$ '3($

\++#[=$?-#'(1&$-#($-,7$<+11"&*6($<+,)"<'$'3-'$0#"&'#-'(&$'3($0#(($&8*#*'$+0$

<+.8('*'*+,$*,$-,7$.-#@('$81-<($-,)$)*#(<'17$*.8-<'&$+,$'3($8++#$'3#+"23$

-#'*%<*-1$8#*<($*,<#(-&(&$-,)$#(&'#*<'*,2$+0$<+,&'#-*,*,2$<3+*<($+0$8#+)"<'&$

0+#$<+,&".(#&=$F'$<#(-'(&$:3-'$:($<-11$-$:(10-#($1+&&$*,$-,7$(<+,+.7$-,)$

0#"&'#-'(&$(00+#'&$+0$ '3($&.-11$81-7(#&$ '3#+"23$.-#@('$)+.*,-,<($ *,$-,$

(<+,+.7$'+$.(-,*,20"117$<+,'#*9"'($'+$'3($(<+,+.7=

>3*&$7(-#e&$'3(.(5$'3($F.8-<'$+0$?-#'(1&$+,$'3($\++#5$3*231*23'&$'3($,(()$'+$

#(k(<'$+,$.(-&"#(&$'+$8#+'(<'$<+,&".(#&$0#+.$<-#'(1&5$-,)$&3-#8(,$&"<3$

.(-&"#(&$'+$'3($2#(-'(&'$(/'(,'$8+&&*91(=$>3($<"1'"#($+0$<+.8('*'*+,$ *&$

L"*'($:(-@$*,$.-,7$<+",'#*(&$-,)$<+,&".(#&$3-6($1*.*'()$",)(#&'-,)*,2$

-9+"'$'3($3-#.0"1$(00(<'&$+0$<-#'(1&=$>3"&5$K+#1)$?+.8('*'*+,$S-7$-11+:&$

-$&<+8($0+#$2#(-'(#$)*&<"&&*+,&$-,)$)*&&(.*,-'*+,$+0$'3($9(,(%<*-1$(00(<'&$

+0$<+.8('*'*+,$+,$'3($-6(#-2($<+,&".(#$r$(*'3(#$)*#(<'17$+#$*,)*#(<'17=$F,$

(00(<'5$*'$*&$(/8(<'()$'+$#(&"1'$*,$2#(-'(#$8"91*<$",)(#&'-,)*,2$-,)$&"88+#'$

+,$'3($,(()$'+$<#-<@$)+:,$<-#'(1&=$

B*,<($ *'&$ 1-",<3$ +,$ d$ S(<(.9(#$ MNNd5$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,$ 3-&$ 9((,$

+8(#-'*+,-117$ &'#+,25$ :*'3$ -$ )*&'*,<'$ <+#8+#-'($ 9#-,)*,2$ :*'3$ -$

8#+0(&&*+,-117$1-*)$+"'$*,0#-&'#"<'"#($-'$'3($+0%<(=$

K($-#($'3(#(0+#($0"117$(&'-91*&3()$-,)$:($-#($,+:$8+&*'*+,*,2$+"#&(16(&$

+,$ &'#(,2'3(,*,2$ +"#$ -)6+<-<7$ '+$ +"#$ &'-@(3+1)(#&$ -,)$ '+$ (00(<'$

<+.8('*'*+,$ (,0+#<(.(,'=$ >3($ ?+..*&&*+,$ #(<+2,*&(&$ '3-'$ '3($ .+&'$

*.8+#'-,'$ &'#-'(2*<$ <3-11(,2($ 0+#$ MNOP$ *&$ '+$ (,&"#($ (00(<'*6($ 8"91*<$

+"'#(-<3$'3+"23$*'&$6*&*9*1*'7$-,)$<+..",*<-'*+,$(00+#'&=$>3($?+..*&&*+,$

3-&$)(6(1+8()$-$<+#8+#-'($*)(,'*'7$-,)$*'&$:(9&*'($I:::=,-<<=<+.=,-J=$

H+#$ '3($ 7(-#$ MNOP5$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,$ -*.&$ '+$ (,&"#($ '3-'$ '3($ <-#'(1$

*,6(&'*2-'*+,&$-#($'+$9($'3($-#(-$+0$0+<"&$*,$1*23'$+0$'3($?+#8+#-'($V(,*(,<7$

\+1*<7$'3-'$2#-,'&$*..",*'7$'+$9"&*,(&&(&$'3-'$<+.($0+#:-#)$'+$#(8+#'$+,$

-,'*4<+.8('*'*6($8#-<'*<(&=$K($3-6($-$<+.8('*'*+,$#(&(-#<3$-2(,)-$'3-'$

*&$+,($7(-#$+1)$9"'$:($3-6($-$&'#+,2$)*6*&*+,$'3-'$ *&$#(-)7$-,)$-91($'+$

-''(,)$'+$'3($#(&(-#<3$.-''(#&$:3*<3$-#($0-#$#-,2*,2$*,$'3($(<+,+.7=$

K($:+"1)$-1&+$#(6*&($+"#$G<'$'+$(,&"#($(,-91*,2$8#+6*&*+,&$*,$1*,($:*'3$

)(6(1+8.(,'&$ +,$ <+.8('*'*+,$ 8+1*<7$ -,)$ 1-:$ *,$ '3($ 7(-#$ MNOP=$ >3($

<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,$8#+6*&*+,&$,+$)+"9'$-#($<1(-#17$ '+$9($ *,<1")()$&+$

'3-'$ *,$ '3($:+#)&$ +0$ '3($ ,(:$D*,*&'(#$ +0$>#-)($ -,)$ F,)"&'#75$D#$?-11($

B<31('':(*,5$:($ ,(()$ '+$ -<<(,'"-'($ '3($ 1*,@$ 9(':((,$ <+.8('*'*+,$ -,)$

<+,&".(#$8#+'(<'*+,=

F,$1*,($:*'3$#(2"1-'+#7$<+,&*&'(,<7$:*'3$+"#$&(<'+#-1$#(2"1-'+#&5$'3($G,'*4

?+##"8'*+,$ ?+..*&&*+,$ -,)$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,5$ +,$ X$ S(<(.9(#$ MNOM5$

&*2,()$-$.(.+#-,)".$+0$",)(#&'-,)*,2$ '+$(00(<'*6(17$<++#)*,-'($ '3(*#$

#(&8(<'*6($&(<'+#-1$0",<'*+,&$:*'3$#(&8(<'$'+$9"&*,(&&$<+##"8'*+,=”

2,0%)#"0#L@#8),):-")%#5/0(#0=)/#CT#;0.*"/$)%#$*#?5/$;-<#/)+/)%)*"$*:#"')$/#

/)%+);"$=)#;0(+)"$"$0*#-."'0/$"$)%<#:-"')/)8#50/#"')#&0/9%'0+#"0#8$%;.%%#

"')#;0(+)"$"$0*#/)%)-/;'#-:)*8-#"'-"#$*;,.8)%#%);"0/%#"0#-:/))#0*#;/0%%I

>0/8)/#;0*"$*)*"-,#$*=)%"$:-"$0*#-*8#[0$*"#;-+-;$"1#8)=),0+()*"#)550/"%6

Page 12: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

OM NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION

R')#J$*$%")/#05#R/-8)#-*8#!*8.%"/1<#\0*0./->,)#2-,,)#M;',)""&)$*<#

-;;0(+-*$)8# >1# "')# (-*-:)()*"# 05# "')# J$*$%"/13%# 20*%.()/#

E/0");"$0*# ]*$"<# =$%$")8# "')# O-($>$-*# 20(+)"$"$0*# 20(($%%$0*#

0*#SA#B-*.-/1#C@AS# "0# 5-($,$-/$%)#'$(%),5#&$"'# $"%#0+)/-"$0*%#-*8#

())"#"')#+/05)%%$0*-,%#&'0#&0/9#"$/),)%%#"0#(-9)#"')#$*%"$"."$0*#-#

50/($8->,)#50/;)#"0#/);90*#&$"'#$*#"')#);0*0($;#%);"0/6#

>3($D*,*&'(#$ ,+'()$ '3-'$ <+.8('*'*+,$ *,$ '3($ (<+,+.*<$ %(1)$ *&$ )#*6(,$ 97$

.+,(7$-,)$+"'4<+.8('*,2$+'3(#&$0+#$'3($&-.($#(&+"#<(=$>3($?+..*&&*+,$

&.++'3&$'3($#+"23$()2(&$+0$<+.8('*'*+,$-,)$-&$-$#(2"1-'+#$(,&"#(&$'3-'$

#"1(&$+0$<+.8('*'*+,$-#($0-*#$-,)$-1&+$-<'&$-&$-$'#-)($0-<*1*'-'+#=$ZK($."&'$

&'#*6($ '+$<++#)*,-'($ '3($)*00(#(,'$.-,)-'(&$:*'3*,$ '3($D*,*&'#7$+0$>#-)($

-,)$F,)"&'#7=$F'$*&$+,17$'3(,$'3-'$'3($D*,*&'#7$<-,$#+11$+"'$*'&$0"11$.-,)-'(5$

*,<1"&*6($+0$:(-1'3$<#(-'*+,=$K(-1'3$."&'$9($(6(,17$<#(-'()=$V('$"&$'#7$'+$

-<3*(6($'3($.+&'$:*'3$'3($1*''1($#(&+"#<(&$-'$+"#$)*&8+&-15[$3($&-*)=$

G'$'3($+<<-&*+,5$'3($<3-*#8(#&+,$+0$'3($;-??$U+-#)$+0$?+..*&&*+,(#&5$

D#$V"<*"&$D"#+#"-5$9*)$0-#(:(11$'+$'3($?+..*&&*+,$-&$3*&$'(,"#($(,)()$

+,$PO$W-,"-#7$MNOP$-0'(#$'3#(($7(-#&$+0$&(#6*,2$'3($?+..*&&*+,$*,$'3*&$

<-8-<*'7=$>3($?3-*#.-,$2#(('()$ '3($.(('*,2$:*'3$ '3($:+#)&$+0$-$:*&($

.-,_$ ZG&$ &"#($ -&$ ,*23'$ 0+11+:&$ )-75$ '3(#($ <+.(&$ -$ '*.($ *,$ -$ 1(-)(#e&$

1*0($:3(,$'3(7$-#($-'$'3($#(<(*6*,2$(,)5$+#$-'$'3($8-&&*,2$+,$(,)$+0$'3($

1(-)(#&3*8$9-'+,=[$T-6*,2$:*',(&&()$ '3($2#+:'3$+0$ '3($;-??$&*,<($ *'&$

*,<(8'*+,$ *,$ MNNd5$D"#+#"-$ &-*)$ '3-'$ *'$ :-&$ -$ 8#+")$.+.(,'$ '+$ 3-6($

:*',(&&()$:3(,$'3($?+..*&&*+,$:-&$,+.*,-'()$-&$+,($+0$'3($'+8$'3#(($

9(&'$2+6(#,()$<+.8('*'*+,$-"'3+#*'*(&$*,$G0#*<-$97$'3($?+..+,:(-1'3=

H"#'3(#$&8#(-)*,2$*'&$:*,2&$-,)$9#+-)(,*,2$*'&$3+#*]+,&5$'3($?+..*&&*+,$

3-&$(,'(#()$*,'+$6-#*+"&$.(.+#-,)-$+0$",)(#&'-,)*,2$ID+Y&J$'+$(,&"#($

2++)$<++8(#-'*+,$-,)$<+,0+#.*'7$:*'3$<+4#(2"1-'+#&$:3*1($.-*,'-*,*,2$*'&$

&'-'"'+#7$ *,)(8(,)(,<(=$>3($?+..*&&*+,$ &*2,()$D+Y&$:*'3$ '3($U-,@$

+0$;-.*9*-$-,)$'3($G,'*4?+##"8'*+,$?+..*&&*+,$*,$MNOM$-,)$<+,'*,"(&$

'+$8"#&"($<++8(#-'*+,$9+'3$1+<-117$-,)$*,'(#,-'*+,-117=$D"#+#"-$&-*)$'3-'$

3($8-&&(&$ '3($9-'+,$ '+$-$,(:$<3-*#8(#&+,$:*'3$<+.0+#'$-,)$&(<"#($ *,$

3*&$ @,+:1()2($ '3-'$ :*'3$ '3($ <+,'*,"()$ &"88+#'$ +0$ '3($?+..*&&*+,(#&5$

B(<#('-#*-'5$ .-,-2(.(,'$ -,)$ '3($ &'-005$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,$ :*11$ #(-<3$

2#(-'(#$3(*23'&=

>3($?C!$-,)$B(<#('-#7$'+$'3($?+..*&&*+,5$D*3($E-+.-9$FF5$*,0+#.()$

'3($D*,*&'(#$'3-'$:3(,$'3($?+..*&&*+,$:-&$(&'-91*&3()$*,$MNNd5$3($:-&$

'3($&+1($(.81+7((5$9"'$'+)-7$'3($*,&'*'"'*+,$3-&$+6(#$Mf$&'-00$.(.9(#&$

-,)$ <+.8#*&(&$ )*00(#(,'$ )(8-#'.(,'&5$ -&&*2,()$ :*'3$ &8(<*-1*&()$ #+1(&$

-,)$ 0",<'*+,&=$ >3($ &'#"<'"#($ +0$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,$ *&$ 8#*.-#*17$ *,0+#.()$

97$ '3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$ M$ +0$ MNNP5$ 9-&()$ +,$ 0",<'*+,&$ -,)$ +9A(<'*6(&=$

T($ 0"#'3(#$ ,+'()$ '3-'$ '3($ ?+..*&&*+,e&$ .-*,$ 0",<'*+,$ *&$ '+$ 8#+.+'($

<+.8('*'*6($.-#@('$<+,)*'*+,&$'3#+"23$'3($*,6(&'*2-'*+,$-,)$8#+&(<"'*+,$

+0$-,'*4<+.8('*'*6($8#-<'*<(&$-&$:(11$-&$ '+$#(6*(:$-,)$-,-17&($.(#2(#&$

-,)$-<L"*&*'*+,&$-00(<'*,2$'3($;-.*9*-,$.-#@('=$

>3($ ?+..*&&*+,$ <+,'*,"(&$ '+$ 2#+:$ -,)$ -0%#.$ *'&$ 0++'3+1)$ :*'3$ '3($

;-.*9*-,$(<+,+.75$'3(#(97$.-@*,2$-$&*2,*%<-,'$*.8-<'$*,$&+<*('7=

MINISTER OF TRADE AND INDUSTRY VISITS

THE COMMISSION

ZK(-1'3$."&'$9($(6(,17$<#(-'()=$V('$"&$'#7$

'+$-<3*(6($'3($.+&'$:*'3$'3($1*''1($#(&+"#<(&$

-'$+"#$)*&8+&-1=[

Page 13: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION 13

NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION AND

ANTI-CORRUPTION COMMISSION SIGNS MOU

R')# O-($>$-*# 20(+)"$"$0*# 20(($%%$0*# VO-22W# -*8# "')# ?*"$I

20//.+"$0*# 20(($%%$0*# V?22W# 0*# F/$8-1<# ^# U);)(>)/# C@AC<#

%$:*)8#-#J)(0/-*8.(#05#]*8)/%"-*8$*:#VJ0]W#-$()8#-"#+/0=$8$*:#

-# 5/-()&0/9# &$"'$*# &'$;'# "')# "&0# 20(($%%$0*%# ;-*# 8)=),0+#

-*8# .*8)/"-9)# ;0,,->0/-"$=)# -;"$=$"$)%# -*8# +/0[);"%<# )%"->,$%'# -#

+/0:/-(()#05# ");'*$;-,# ;00+)/-"$0*<# -*8# 8$%%)($*-")# -%#&),,# -%#

%'-/)# 9*0&,)8:)# $*# "')# 4),8%# 05# ;0(+)"$"$0*# ,-&# -*8# +0,$;1# -*8#

-*"$I;0//.+"$0*6#

>3($;-??$*&$.-,)-'()$97$'3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'$M$+0$MNNP$'+$&-0(2"-#)$

-,)$ 8#+.+'($ <+.8('*'*+,$ *,$ '3($ ;-.*9*-,$ .-#@('5$ :3(#(-&$ '3($ G,'*4

?+##"8'*+,$ ?+..*&&*+,$ *&$ .-,)-'()$ ",)(#$ '3($ G,'*4?+##"8'*+,$ G<'$ ^$

+0$ MNNP$ '+$ 8#+6*)($ 0+#$ '3($ 8#(6(,'*+,$ -,)$ 8",*&3.(,'$ +0$ <+##"8'*+,$ *,$

;-.*9*-=$

F,$ #(-1*&*,2$ *'&$.-,)-'(5$ '3($;-??$ *&$ 2"*)()$ 97$ '3($ 8#+6*&*+,&$ +0$ '3($

?+.8('*'*+,$ G<'5$ :*'3$ &8(<*%<$ 8#+6*&*+,&$ '3(#(*,$ 8#+.+'*,2$ -$ <"1'"#($

+0$ <+11-9+#-'*+,$ :*'3$ 6-#*+"&$ *,&'*'"'*+,&$ *,$ +#)(#$ '+$ <++#)*,-'($ -,)$

3-#.+,*&($A"#*&)*<'*+,$+6(#$<+.8('*'*+,$.-''(#&=$

\-"1"&$;+-5$S*#(<'+#$+0$'3($G,'*4?+##"8'*+,$?+..*&&*+,$IG??J5$&-*)$'3-'$

-&$8-#'$+0$ *'&$.-,)-'(5$ '3($G??$ *&$ '+$ *,6(&'*2-'($<+,)"<'$ '3-'$.-7$9($

<+,,(<'()$:*'3$+#$<+,)"<*6($0+#$<+##"8'$8#-<'*<(&$-,)$#(8+#'$'3(#(+,=$

>3(#($-#($6-#*+"&$-,'*4<+.8('*'*6($8#-<'*<(&$'3-'$9+#)(#$+,$<+##"8'*+,$-&$

(,6*&-2()$*,$'3($G,'*4?+##"8'*+,$G<'$I;+=$^$+0$MNNPJ=$$!,($&"<3$(/-.81($

*&$9*)$#*22*,2$-,)$<+11"&*6($'(,)(#*,2=$

U*)$ #*22*,2$ *,6+16(&$ <+.8-,*(&$ <+,&8*#*,2$ '+$ #-*&($8#*<(&$+#$ 1+:(#$ '3($

L"-1*'7$+0$2++)&$+#$&(#6*<(&$+00(#()$*,$8"91*<$'(,)(#&=$G1'3+"23$*11(2-15$9*)$

#*22*,2$*&$-$8#+91(.$'3-'$81-2"(&$2+6(#,.(,'$8#+<"#(.(,'&$-#+",)$'3($

:+#1)$-,)$<+&'&$'-/8-7(#&$9*11*+,&$+0$)+11-#&$(6(#7$7(-#=$>(,)(#$#*22*,2$*&$

&8(<*%<-117$-))#(&&()$*,$?3-8'(#$Q$+0$'3($G??$G<'=$

K*'3$'3*&$D+Y5$'3($':+$*,&'*'"'*+,&$:*11$<++8(#-'($-2-*,&'$9*)$#*22*,2$-,)$

<+11"&*6($ '(,)(#*,2$ 97$ &3-#*,2$ *,0+#.-'*+,5$ 0-<*1*'-'*,2$ *,6(&'*2-'*+,&5$

<+11-9+#-'*,2$ +,$ #(&(-#<3$ -,)$ -,-17&*,2$ I:3(#($ -88#+8#*-'(J$ -,)$

(,2-2*,2$*,$A+*,'$'#-*,*,2$-,)$-)6+<-<7=$

D*3($E-+.-9$FF5$?C!$-,)$B(<#('-#7$'+$'3($;-??5$,+'()$'3-'$<+##"8'*+,$

*&$ -$ :+#1):*)($ 83(,+.(,+,$ -,)$ *&$ ,+:$ #(<+2,*&()$ '+$ 9($ +,($ +0$ '3($

:+#1)e&$ 2#(-'(&'$ <3-11(,2(&=$ ZF'$ *&$ -$ .-A+#$ 3*,)(#-,<($ '+$ &"&'-*,-91($

)(6(1+8.(,'5$:*'3$-$)*&8#+8+#'*+,-'($*.8-<'$+,$'3($8++#$-,)$*&$<+##+&*6($

'+$ '3($ 6(#7$ 0-9#*<$ +0$ &+<*('7=$ >3($ *.8-<'$ +,$ '3($ 8#*6-'($ &(<'+#$ *&$ -1&+$

<+,&*)(#-91($ -&$ *'$ *.8()(&$ (<+,+.*<$ 2#+:'35$ )*&'+#'&$ <+.8('*'*+,$ -,)$

#(8#(&(,'&$&(#*+"&$1(2-1$-,)$#(8"'-'*+,-1$#*&@&5[$3($-))()=

>3#+"23$'3($&*2,*,2$+0$'3*&$-2#((.(,'5$'3($;-??$-0%#.&$*'&$<+..*'.(,'$

'+:-#)&$A+*,'17$%23'*,2$<+##"8'*+,5$9*)$#*22*,2$-,)$'(,)(#$<+11"&*+,$*,$1*,($

:*'3$*'&$.-,)-'($+,$<+.8('*'*+,$1-:=$

E-+.-9$FF$(1-9+#-'()$'3-'$'3*&$D+Y$:*11$8#+6*)($-$0#-.(:+#@$:*'3*,$:3*<3$

'3($ ':+$ -"'3+#*'*(&$ <-,$ ",)(#'-@($ <+11-9+#-'*6($ -<'*6*'*(&$ -,)$ 8#+A(<'&$

-,)$*&$,(<(&&-#7$0+#$'3($(00(<'*6($-881*<-'*+,$+0$'3($;-??e&$(,0+#<(.(,'$

8+:(#&$",)(#$?3-8'(#$P$+0$'3($?+.8('*'*+,$G<'=

>3($D+Y$-1&+$*,6+16(&$-,$-<'*+,$81-,$:3*<3$:*11$*,<1")($-$A+*,'$:+#@*,2$

<+..*''(($0#+.$9+'3$'3($G??$-,)$'3($;-??$'+$(,&"#($'3-'$'3($-2#((.(,'$

)+(&$,+'$2-'3(#$)"&'5$9"'$*&$*.81(.(,'()$-,)$*'&$+9A(<'*6(&$#(-1*&()=$

R')#JN]#$%#$*")*8)8#"0<#$*")/#-,$-Q#

s$ C&'-91*&3$-$&"&'-*,-91($-,)$(00(<'*6($<+11-9+#-'*+,$-,)$8-#',(#&3*8$

9(':((,$;-??$-,)$'3($G??$'+$<+.9-'$<+##"8'*+,$*,$;-.*9*-i$

s$ C,3-,<($8#(6(,'*+,$-,)$()"<-'*+,$-&$ 0",<'*+,&$+0$-,'*4<+##"8'*+,$

'3#+"23$-$8-#'*<*8-'+#7$-88#+-<3$0#+.$'3($;-??i

s$ ?-8-<*'7$ 9"*1)*,2$ *,*'*-'*6(&5$ 8+&&*917$ *,<1")*,2$ +,4'3(4A+9$ '#-*,*,2$

-<'*6*'*(&$0+#$*)(,'*%()$;-??$8(#&+,,(1i$

s$ C/<3-,2($+0$'(<3,*<-1$*,0+#.-'*+,$-&$0-#$-&$8(#.*&&*91($97$1-:i$

s$ B3-#*,2$ +0$ *,'(11*2(,<($ -,)$ (/8(#'*&($ *,$ *,6(&'*2-'*+,&$ -&$ 0-#$ -&$

8(#.*&&*91($97$1-:i$

s$ G&&*&'-,<($*,$'3($<+,)"<'*,2$+0$*,6(&'*2-'*+,&i$

s$ !#2-,*&($ A+*,'$;-'*+,-15$b(2*+,-1$-,)$ *,'(#,-'*+,-1$&(.*,-#&5$ 0+#-$

-,)$&7.8+&*-i$

s$ W+*,'$*)(,'*%<-'*+,$+0$<+##"8'*+,$+88+#'",*'*(&$-,)$#(6*(:$+0$&7&'(.&$

'+$9"*1'$<+##"8'*+,$#(&*&'-,<(i$

s$ b(0(##-1&$'+$G??$+0$-,7$-<'$+0$<+##"8'*+,$&"&8(<'()$97$'3($;-??$*,$

'3($(/(#<*&($+0$*'&$0",<'*+,&i$-,)

s$ F,<#(-&($ '3($ 1(6(1$ -,)$ #(-<3$ +0$ -,'*4<+##"8'*+,$ -,)$ <+##"8'*+,$

-:-#(,(&&$8#+2#-..(&=

B*,<($'3($*,-"2"#-'*+,$+0$'3($;-??$*,$S(<(.9(#$MNNd5$'3($?+..*&&*+,$

3-&$.-,-2()$'+$&*2,$-,)$&"<<(&&0"117$ *.81(.(,'$ '3#(($.(.+#-,)-$+0$

-2#((.(,'$:*'3$<+4#(2"1-'+#&$-,)$*&$&('$'+$&*2,$-$0"#'3(#$'3#(($*,$MNOP=$

>3($&*2,*,2$+0$'3($-2#((.(,'$.-#@()$'3($&(<+,)$D+Y$0+#$'3($;-??$*,$

MNOM5$'3($%#&'$9(*,2$&*2,()$:*'3$'3($U-,@$+0$;-.*9*-$(-#1*(#$'3-'$7(-#=$

ZG&$8-#'$+0$*'&$.-,)-'(5$'3($G??$*&$'+$

*,6(&'*2-'($<+,)"<'$'3-'$.-7$9($<+,,(<'()$

:*'3$+#$<+,)"<*6($0+#$<+##"8'$8#-<'*<(&$-,)$

#(8+#'$'3(#(+,=[

Page 14: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

14 NAMIBIAN COMPETITION COMMISSION

VISIT BY TECHNICAL EXPERT FROM

BUNDESKARTELLAMT

R')# O-($>$-*# 20(+)"$"$0*# 20(($%%$0*<# $*# $"%# %"/$=)# "0# >.$,8#

;-+-;$"1<# )*:-:)%# )G+)/"%# 5/0(# 0."%$8)# "')# >0/8)/%# 05# O-($>$-#

"0# /)*8)/# ");'*$;-,# %.++0/"# "0# "')# ;0/)# 8$=$%$0*%# I#J)/:)/%# -*8#

?;X.$%$"$0*%<# -*8# K)%"/$;"$=)# D.%$*)%%# E/-;"$;)%# I# "0# )*%./)#

-*# )55);"$=)# )G);."$0*# 05# "')# 20(($%%$0*3%# (-*8-")6# ?%# %.;'<#

Director of Restrictive Business Practices, Vivienne Katjiuongua

$-%&'!3*-"&*4'5'$'/!1$*/6"&%,'/!$*7',-*8$*94',-*8:"(("&2

;'&"#,/&*/<*9#/!/0'#$*%!4*="#,/&*>"$"%&#-?*;&*8'#-%"(*

@:0%5'!4:?*$-%&"$*-'$*4'5'$'/!1$*$,&%,"3)*7',-*8$*8:"(("&2

;'&"#,/&*/<*8"&3"&$*A*B#C:'$','/!$?*D',%('$*E4%('F/F:("?*

sketching a brief overview of his division.

8$*94',-*8:"(("&*6%'4*%*#/:&,"$)*#%((*,/*,-"*.9G2

H8$"'# J-/$-# J.),,)/<# -# ");'*$;-,# )G+)/"# $*# ()/:)/# -*-,1%$%<#

-*"$I"/.%"# ;-%)%# -*8# ;-/"),# +/0%);."$0*<# -(0*:%"# 0"')/%<# 5/0(#

D.*8)%9-/"),,-("<# Z)/(-*1<# '-%# >))*# ;0(($%%$0*)8# 50/# -# "&0I

&))9#+)/$08#VA_IC_#F)>/.-/1#C@ASW#"0#%'-/)#')/#)G+)/"$%)#&$"'#"')#

");'*$;-,#8$=$%$0*%6#

Page 15: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

STAFFRETREAT

Page 16: EDITION 01 – DECEMBER 2011 - Competition Commission...NaCC makes Determination on E-MED/ISOS Proposed Merger .....8 African Competition Authorities Deliberate on Research Skills

Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed in this newsletter are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the Competition Commission.

Any unauthorised reproduction in part or whole will constitute copyright infringement.

Design & Layout: !2*167$;-.*9*-