CREATING SHAREHOLDER ALUE - FEI Canada Chapter...M&A International – the world's leading M&A...
Transcript of CREATING SHAREHOLDER ALUE - FEI Canada Chapter...M&A International – the world's leading M&A...
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Getting Top Dollar for a Family Business
CREATING SHAREHOLDER VALUE February 2012
Howard E. Johnson
MBA, FCA, FCMA, CBV, CPA, CFA, ASA, CF, C.DIR
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Speaker
Howard E. Johnson MBA, FCA, FCMA, CBV, CPA, CFA, ASA, C.Dir Managing Director, Veracap Corporate Finance Limited (416) 597-4500; [email protected] Howard is a Managing Director of Veracap Corporate Finance and its affiliate, Campbell Valuation Partners Limited. Howard has been involved in business valuation, acquisition, divestiture, and related assignments for corporations throughout North America. He is the author of several texts on the subjects of business valuation and corporate finance, and has acted as an expert witness on complex valuation matters before the courts.
2
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
About Veracap
Veracap Corporate Finance Limited helps business owners and executives to maximize shareholder value through acquisitions, divestitures, private equity financing and strategic value advisory services. Veracap is an affiliate of Campbell Valuation Partners, Canada’s longest established independent business valuation firm. Veracap is a member of M&A International, the world’s leading affiliation of M&A advisors, with over 500 professionals in 40 countries.
www.veracap.com 3
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Disclaimer
This material is for educational purposes only. It deals with technical matters which have broad application and may not be applicable to a particular set of circumstances and facts. As well, the course material and references contained therein reflect laws and practices which are subject to change. For these reasons, the course material should not be relied upon as a substitute for specialized advice in connection with any particular matter. Although the course material has been carefully prepared, the author does not accept any legal responsibility for its contents or for any consequences arising from its use. © Howard E. Johnson, 2012
4
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
The Shareholder Value Curve™
5
Value Realization
Intangible Value
Value MeasurementTangible Net Worth
Time
Sh
areh
old
er V
alu
e
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Shareholder Value and Beyond
6
EBITDA 10,000$
Multiple 5.0x
Enterprise Value 50,000$
Debt 20,000$
Shareholder Value 30,000$
Tangible Net Worth 30,000$ 10,000$
Intangible Value -$ 20,000$
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
The Determinants of Shareholder Value
7
Cash RiskFlow Profile
Deduct: Debt Outstanding
Equals: Shareholder Value
Deduct: Tangible Net Worth
Equals Intangible Value
Enterprise Value
InvestedCapital
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Drivers of Shareholder Value
• Cash Flow – Discretionary cash flow
• Risk Profile – Differentiated product and service offerings – Diverse base of repeat customers – Strong and committed management team
• Invested Capital – Capital investment and working capital – Management compensation considerations
Creating a Competitive Advantage
8
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Competitive Advantage Examples
9
Value Driver Competitive Advantage
Increase Cash Flow • Premium pricing • Cost advantage
Reduced risk • Customer exit barriers • Diversification
Capital efficiency • Working capital mgmt • Capacity utilization
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Creating a Competitive Advantage
• Must be sustainable and transferable • Sustainability requires continuous innovation
and adaptability – Company culture and business philosophy
• Transferability – Legal rights – Customers & employees
• Must result in return on capital > cost of capital
10
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Cost of Capital
• Why Important? – Value is created where return on capital > cost of capital
• Cost of Capital for public companies – Determinable based on market prices, analyst reports – Possible issues for small-cap public companies
• Cost of Capital for private companies – More subjective – “Build-up” approach is common
• Liquidity is a key driver • Segregate 2 Components – Operating risk (unlevered return on equity) – Financial risk (capital structure)
11
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Competitive Advantage & Intangible Value
12
Competitive Advantage
Cash Flow Risk Profile Invested Capital
Return on InvestedCapital Cost of Capital
Intangible Value
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Value vs. Growth
• Growth only leads to value where the return on
capital exceeds the cost of capital • One of Three Avenues – Operating efficiencies (cash flow) – Risk reduction – Capital efficiency
13
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Value vs. Growth
14
BeforeExpansion No added Operating Risk Capital
Value Efficiency Reduction Efficiency
EBITDA 10,000$ 12,000$ 13,000$ 12,000$ 12,000$
Multiple 5.0x 5.0x 5.0x 5.5x 5.0x
Enterprise Value 50,000$ 60,000$ 65,000$ 66,000$ 60,000$
Expansion Cost 10,000-$ 10,000-$ 10,000-$ 5,000-$
Net Value 50,000$ 55,000$ 56,000$ 55,000$
Value Created -$ 5,000$ 6,000$ 5,000$
After Expansion
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Acquisitions and Shareholder Value
• Growth vs. value (again) • 3 Ways to Create Value: - Realize more synergies than what are paid for - Effective negotiation - Deal structuring
• Importance of strategic fit • Integration is key • Due diligence requirements • Beware “Transition Risk”
15
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
The Magic of Financial Leverage
16
No ModerateLeverage Leverage
Earnings Before Interest and Taxes (EBIT) 10,000$ 10,000$
Interest expense (5%) -$ 1,000$ Pretax income 10,000$ 9,000$
Income taxes (25%) 2,500$ 2,160$ After-tax income 7,500$ 6,840$
Invested CapitalDebt -$ 20,000$ Equity 50,000$ 30,000$
50,000$ 50,000$
Return on Equity 15.0% 22.8%
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Financial Risk
17
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
45%
0:100 10:90 20:80 30:70 40:60 50:50 60:40 70:30 80:20
Leve
red
Cos
t of
Eq
uit
y
Debt to Equity Ratio
Financial Risk Premium
Unlevered Cost of Equity
Levered Cost of Equity
Conclusion: Using debt MAY lead to a higher return on equity BUT the shareholder is exposed to higher risk
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Avenues to Value Realization
18
Initial Public Offering
Strategic BuyerPotential Reward Financial Buyer
Management Buyout
Family Succession
Transactions with Existing Shareholders
Recapitalization
Dividends / Share Buyback
Liquidation
Risk
ShareholderDistributions
Related PartyTransactions
Transactions withThird Parties
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Deciding When To Sell
Preparing For the Sale
The Search For Buyers
Estimating Value and Price
Preliminary Due Diligence
PLA
NN
ING
PH
AS
E
E
XEC
UTI
ON
PH
AS
E
Negotiations Deal Structuring Closing
V A
L U
E
E N
H A
N C
E M
E N
T
Building Deal Momentum
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Keys to Realizing Maximum Value
• Create alternatives – Liquidity is key
• The “Platform Buyer” – Leveraging your people, products, customers
• Pre-transaction planning – 3 parties to every deal
• More than a numbers game – Negotiations and deal structuring are key
20
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Final Thoughts
• Value Measurement – Knowing your cost of capital – Measuring intangible value
• Value Creation – Cash flow, risk, invested capital – Competitive advantage (sustainable, transferable) – Return on capital > cost of capital – Focus on building intangible value
• Value Realization – Process management – Alternatives – Liquidity
21
M&A International™ – the world's leading M&A alliance
Resources available at www.veracap.com
22