Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe...

61
Building Better Box Beam Bridges

Transcript of Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe...

Page 1: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Building Better

Box Beam Bridges

Page 2: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize
Page 3: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Report Focus

1. Describe the state of the practice.

2. Report on lessons learned.

3. Provide guidelines for better performance.

Page 4: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Issues

Leaking Joints

Reflective DeckCracking

Page 5: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Adjacent

Member

Bridges

Page 6: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

AASHTO Box Beams

AASHTO Slab Beams

Types of Sections

Page 7: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Box Beams

Slab Beams

Types of Sections

Page 8: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Double Tees

Deck Bulb Tees

Types of Sections

Page 9: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

• 50,000 adjacent box bridges

(more than 8%)

• 9,000 spread box bridges

• 60 Years

Box Beam Bridges

Page 10: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Spread Box Beam Bridges

NOT considered adjacent member bridges

Page 11: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Non-Composite Superstructure

Page 12: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Non-Composite Superstructure

Page 13: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Non-Composite Superstructure

Page 14: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Non-Composite Superstructure

Page 15: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Non-Composite Superstructure

Page 16: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Composite Superstructure

Page 17: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Composite Superstructure

Page 18: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Composite Superstructure

Page 19: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Continuity

Page 20: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Continuity

Page 21: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Longitudinal

Joints

Page 22: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Shear Key – Partial Depth

Page 23: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Shear Key – Full Depth

Page 24: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Shear Key - TxDOT

Page 25: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Shear Key - TxDOT

Page 26: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Transverse Tie Rods

Page 27: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Transverse Tie Rods

Page 28: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Transverse Tie Rods

Page 29: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Design

Page 30: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Non-Composite

Vs.

Composite

Design

Page 31: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Design

Page 32: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Structural Overlay

OR

“Sufficiently connected to act as a unit”

EQUALS

Better Distribution between Beams

Live Load Distribution per AASHTO LRFD

Page 33: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Live Load Distribution per AASHTO LRFD

Page 34: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Shear Transfer Joints

Vs.

Shear-Flexure Transfer Joints“Sufficiently connected to act as a unit”

Transverse Connection per AASHTO LRFD

Page 35: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Transverse prestress amount

determined by strip method

or two-dimensional analysis

“…shall not be less than 0.25 ksi

through the key.”

Transverse Connection per AASHTO LRFD

Page 36: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Bearings

Page 37: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Bearings

Page 38: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Inspection and

Maintenance

Page 39: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Michigan Study

Page 40: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Michigan Study

Page 41: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Michigan Inspection Handbook

Michigan Study

Page 42: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Michigan Study

Page 43: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Survey of

Current

Practice

Page 44: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Data Collection

Page 45: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

A. General

B. Deck Slabs and Overlays

C. Box Beam Construction

D. Keyways

E. Prestressing

F. Bearings

G. Experience

Data Collection

Page 46: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Questionnaire Response

Page 47: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Case Studies

Summary

Page 48: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

• TxDOT 9-Day Bridge

• Colorado Weekend Bridge

• Ohio 19-Day Box Girder Bridge

• BNSF Railway over Route 160,

Springfield, MO

• MoDOT Route 100 over I-44,

Gray Summit, MO

Case Studies

Page 49: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Original Bridge

Route 100 over I-44

Page 50: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Original Steel Design Layout

Route 100 over I-44

Page 51: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

VE Proposal – Adjacent Box Beams

Route 100 over I-44

Page 52: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Route 100 over I-44

Page 53: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

BNSF over Route 160

Page 54: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

BNSF over Route 160

Page 55: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

Conclusions

Page 56: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

• Minimize Longitudinal Cracking

– Water Penetration

– De-Icing Chemicals

• Ensure Long-Term Performance

Conclusions

Page 57: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

• Larger Shear Keys, Full Depth

• Increased Post-Tensioning Force

• Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck

Design

Conclusions

Page 58: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

• Minimize Skew if Possible

• Three or Four Point Bearing System

• Increase Concrete Cover

Design

Conclusions

Page 59: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

• Use Polystyrene Forms for Voids

• Properly Anchor Voids

• Use of High Performance Concrete, Corrosion Inhibitors

Fabrication

Conclusions

Page 60: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize

• Sandblast Shear Keys ImmediatelyPrior to Grouting

• Use Non-Shrink Epoxy Grout

• PT Layout and Sequence

Construction

Conclusions

Page 61: Building Better Box Beam Bridges - Missouri … Better Box Beam Bridges. Report Focus 1. Describe the state of ... •Composite Reinforced Concrete Deck Design Conclusions •Minimize