Alam-strategy & Imagination in a Mughal Story of Creation-ieshr2012
description
Transcript of Alam-strategy & Imagination in a Mughal Story of Creation-ieshr2012
-
http://ier.sagepub.com/Review
Indian Economic & Social History
http://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151The online version of this article can be found at:
DOI: 10.1177/001946461204900201
2012 49: 151Indian Economic Social History ReviewMuzaffar Alam
Strategy and imagination in a Mughal Sufi story of creation
Published by:
http://www.sagepublications.com
can be found at:Indian Economic & Social History ReviewAdditional services and information for
http://ier.sagepub.com/cgi/alertsEmail Alerts:
http://ier.sagepub.com/subscriptionsSubscriptions:
http://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.navReprints:
http://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.navPermissions:
http://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151.refs.htmlCitations:
What is This?
- Jun 18, 2012Version of Record >>
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151http://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151http://www.sagepublications.comhttp://www.sagepublications.comhttp://ier.sagepub.com/cgi/alertshttp://ier.sagepub.com/cgi/alertshttp://ier.sagepub.com/subscriptionshttp://ier.sagepub.com/subscriptionshttp://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.navhttp://www.sagepub.com/journalsReprints.navhttp://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.navhttp://www.sagepub.com/journalsPermissions.navhttp://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151.refs.htmlhttp://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151.refs.htmlhttp://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151.full.pdfhttp://ier.sagepub.com/content/49/2/151.full.pdfhttp://online.sagepub.com/site/sphelp/vorhelp.xhtmlhttp://online.sagepub.com/site/sphelp/vorhelp.xhtmlhttp://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
!"#$%#
& ! #
'()
!"#$"%
& ' ("')("
$" ""$"*+'"
!
!" "#$""%%##"&'('(")#'#)#"
( ,''- ."-$ #"/01"
'"#0#2''
)')"''+
1+3#'-"&'
#"4"5%678977:*+ ) *(#
/''(""&$0/'"$
#""2'*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
;J#"&-.
1("*9>%>GJ&
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
+(%@ (')"* ( ' 3')"$" )("
)" *
("2.%+(%#*&*&*.D &*.D" "#&2".) '" .%+(%0'")""*,'/*&*1D
"# ("))32 H "
GJ/#0&"2"*'1'($H2 (1)F
J" 424"* ("-'
42-*655G*&
'''
'"42*
)'2"" "')''" &2".
" 8/%".%(%.(*EH"4)'4*C#F-"*/=0& ''""
322"*H"="2"2
&2".*G@9%@>*5.DK*6*6>*.D2"'2'.%+(%
))
.DK*9*G:E*.D2'"2
"'3.' **.#$1(((*67G>*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
- ;
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
$'2 ''"
'2)")'*$)?
)''"2')""* "*''")" ' '""*
")&28 P, 0Q ") P'Q
+0*+2" ') 0 "'""'
*69+I"))"'"2'' )"6G****+",%.(2&22P '"' AQ &28)
#) 8" &" )
8)+****(+2"",%.6>
" ,% '' %*6@
69+2"*:990 %/'3"' (2"")+2"''&"**&2
8"28+2%/"++ "*"&2,D
(2K* 6 * 56%:7 ( / ' ) - 20"RF"' )"
")"2 "SIE?6G7/"'))) 0*
'*&28"28+2=% 1% ./0?.%"*&2"
2&2"+K*:*@@:%E9*#K*6>'
(""'0"3')I@6?@E*( '/)(" "$""""
'0*ID#&
"*6567/,/ * 96C%65* ,ID#&
I"+&
A .D ! !,/,3$$=*@@5%CG*
6G . )% (% ( % +*+
) B'"" '"""*I6@?9E"6@?9C*
6>$3)' "
) )"+2"%
"2")'*#'+2"",%.) '2)2"""+2*$" 2
%)'22'(%%'*
B) "',% +2%/
"*'*%/"++K*6*:%57*",%."''"'''')'))
'2)"'
0'T """'**"2
#"F/))"/)""*6>:5%/",%.) "'2 &22A)DK*6*97%96H 2H*.""*
,*,*&2K*(*GE%G5*6@.%+(%*9G:2J''",%.*GE%G5"
$"" "#"K" )''
)
)36'*K$%**C9G%G65G>%GC*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
;G9777*+")'"66>6&$)A"""""
>CG6/0 ****() 0 "
2".+*+")/ 2!""'"''" *F "2'")"%"2 '"" F"*P#2
Q!"'"" ')
"*6E
&2".2'2)''
('2&")"""
"' )'
$"*6C,#"))
2))""3"'2 " &"* 2 )
2"
'
3' )$"*$)"'"
'*$" "''" "2&"*./"
&0"'')&"*$)''
***")"'"&2&"*
.'""" +"))"'"
)"#0 *""#0 "2
))'"22!")"*
)'" +"%"""%)&")'")""F) *& /"&0)' "'"&" PKQ
'" .08"*.08""+ "
2' ''/)=
6E.%+(%*9>7*6C'*",%.*97%96*&''" (2&20"""2'
)" 3 " 2 ' "*+) )
' " **F(2&2
!-+%/K*9"*-U"2(2"*9CE%5E*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
.08"*('/"&0&""'""''$""0" /**+ 65)
'"*)' /)/"
'
0 22*+) '
$"&""'")"*+0
""*6:
$ """3"
)") '")F+2 $2$" "
" ")0'2# ?
"0)"2)')'
2'"'*$)"')
!"/")"" "'*+I'(""'0"3')97
" 0*()/@%/2' AF"0)"
"' *&"
A))2'"****(2
*+ # )"
" " ")"/''*+ /A) ""0')""*96
+&2".)"
'" '&"" " ('
65H"'.%&2".)'
%.+%/" +/"" """*.%+(%*9G52*
6:.%+(%*9>72*,//"/ ))
"2/"//"..$" "K
$%**G59%5G>97%9:EG6%>7*97%(.).
%+*I@6?@E*96.%+(%*9>6*+",%%%'"#3
(DDF"2&/%%%:%"*(/2
"".DD /*956J#"-%+%+ &%/*9G7*& #' I/@%/2&21.
2"*&'2/"-A2'
42A/"&2"""*#!A$:1-A2'42AK*N(K*6669*
- ;
-
!;!
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
$&2".2
')"%A''"))"
K")"# !"
A*$))""
2) 2 /
"*#'""")(%
"*# "#)) ' 1 " ( ) % + % ,% %%,1(/9@ )'"*(
("""''"'
22'2"'""( P Q"'*+
2""")"'/
*9E
&2" . ' " '))
"''" "A?
-A)
")
22
'*$
)
2 2 /+ )J ')
2
" "
*-A))")"
" "'2 &")"2
"")
2*(2
#,"F&P"*'69G7Q)?
8+,%()+0%)+
9@##"#?#)"'K)$%"
%%"'"#"2"11""'#J4".'$%*@G%@:6E6*&2
,D)11)'"'2 )
"'
"1%" "2)' " )'' " "
))'"'*0./!/"*#"&"/*G9CH *8"*8"#*65G*
9E.%+(%*9>72*&2".'?.
)' '#)" 2
2* ( '" # ' " "
2*+2""2'A
' ' &2".")#
") ) " 8/ .% (%.(* * ."'K A( " A")#'.'K
&2".B)
2))#'3*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
- ";
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
)
"'"'""
2 )""'*G6
&2". ))) 2&"2
2 ) 2 )" "
2"$""*A""
))'"2'""'" '2
2" S"""
-A))
2'"")
2
2")
2"DD " )
22
3" *&")
20 *#)
2'2)****+ )" " 2)" A "
")'"()
2
/ 0*
"'?
-A)
22)
2'
"")
2 ")
'*+)
2"
))
2" *" ''"2))
&"PQ*B)
2"" " ' )"*&'"
&")
2"$)
22"
0")
2"*B)"2)
2
" %*&" )
2" ))
2
"" $*+"&")
2"
F ")
2 )
'' " ")
'
"*B
'))
2)
*&")
'*$)
" )""
*&")
2""*,(/'')
2"')
'
)
%"*$)
'
'%)2'2*$)
" )'"'
)
22"")
2 )/.*-A ' &")
2" " ))
)*(
)
2)")" "
) )
') ' "
)')
2
"*+ )
G6.%+(%*9>9*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
- ;
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
'&2".*$2
)2 KG>%%" $% )
)K ''
) " "2 3" 2
#"# " *&2".
)?
#"#"P/0Q)2'
))" "12"
% "? '" 1 P " Q)')
%))
2")"")''" #0 "+"=)F)*+& )"' 2))"''''" !1*+'!1+)
2"2&"""'"*+)')
'2
"2'(+
1)
2''"22*()
"))
2*/0)
"
!1'"%*
- ;
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
'"*GC$
' "'" A ")
2
" ()
)"2"*+A)
"
*&
"")
2 )FB
*+)
)
"FFJ)
"
"*&"A)
2
'%,%)
0")
2"" "* +
)
2 " """0'"2/")"%*(
)""A'
)
'*!"
)
0")
'
" A " "'" " )*G5
)2"$"
9>%9@J&F&:, ;
%/!(%! %"*#$"##)#
K* 66 * E77* &2" . / '" % % /%*('"')"%%/"%!%*
G5.%+(%*9>@*G:.%+(%*9>@2*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
;6+'
/&2".)
'/"2
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
2 ) 2&" '''J
)')
)(%))
""* ) &2"
.""$"0
))')0'
$
'"/0 *& !")
"F8"
)"0',)"'
' * &2" . 2
)'"' ?('%"'"P"Q )'
')
*>9
+)2"2))' '
''2&2".K)"
"*$$"22 K)
* 8)"""')A
"'""'"
&2".
*(#"#
" '""" ')
A2 )"&"))"'
''')"?
#"#"?U))""2)"
&"J2"2"'"'
'*B
")""'
)"''S"?U"("
)""
"
)" %%*+
)2',+%%*B"'%""""""2")""S>G
&""")(''*,K
""? -")"") J "
)))# **%*B'"''2S>>K2''#"
#*$
2""")
' ''1""' )"
&"""'"*K'
'
>9.%+(%*9>@*>G.%+(%*9>E*>>.%+(%*9>E2*%22
4+,)'''" 2"2$)''"2)2!"*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
- ;
-
!;!
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
(K)"4"#)))
"'"2&"2 "*
))4"/) ""'
&""'" ("*"/&"
""$
" "2
2 2 " " *& " "
)2$"""&2".
) " 2 %% A" /&04"/"'/"
8""4"/"*+
$""))'()
)"''" A
$"3
'*+
22""'"A"'
)) " ' " *>C+
)"2))'4"/"A"
)'"")&")2
)2 "0")4"/
)" ' """ "1"*
&2".2 " 2K'
%%*K""'#"#)""0' &"
"'"*("''2 K
&2". ' $"" "
''3''))'"*(
"" &2".) ) 0"
K )""'"*+
'
'"#"
#"'1"""')"
)
'" ")" 7"FB
*#"# """"*+"
/0 )
"'"))
*0
)"3*>5#"/##"8""))2 ""
)
'" *"("
$""&""'"))2'
' '" "*1" 2"
"$""!"*K''"
*() 0' !"'"/*K
" "''
)?
>C&"#255*G:E%>95"
')'"*>5.%+(%*9>5*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
- ";
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
"/" "2 " ) !"*&")
"" "*/)" *$
" )" "" " *& A"
'2" )'"
" ''" *&2 "
.0A" ""
2'J""&""'")
"" " *+) )"2"*#"
'")"
"2"")"2'
(""" 0"2""P
'QI0"I2*F"2
&"2'" 0""1*&"")'"''
02 2"'")'""
"'"&"""'"*
+ "" " PQ 2"
)"'"'&""'"*B!"""
2'*+ )!""&
")$
)"$'")$"*@6
#
(2))".%!%&2". '3"'$"'
*
""'"""''
))"*+.%+(%'2"'") )
.%!%"')" '""2)" 2*+
)?
+("")''3
''")P3
1% Q*&)!"$ "")"""")
)""2
")2'2) !"*
/"")""
@6
%%%" /I6>?9C"@?6*.% +(%*9>:%9@7*&0A"2)'
22J
-
;G97777* "
")''
")6C95777)"*+
")677777*+"
'"")''
"%)69:E777)"*+")67777*+"
"'
"%)J"5E>777)"*+")6777*+"
")''
")>G9777)"*+"677*+)'
"/"%,%''%*+"""/0 J )*
B " " )' " / 0 '"
"2'")")*+'
""2'"B"#" %%*$"""*B
) " ) "
2 ''*()GE7""
'"J'""
'*B2'""""J'
)"")*+'
"%*+!"$ )$)"")'"
' ' 3' ) " " 2*+ P
("Q2)6777"2'
"*+ @7""*+("
")2 2 2
')2D"*@9
&2" . $" '' &"
) ' """"$3'''""'2''')
')'T)'"2")
2 2)T
2 .%+(%?
@9.%!%42*-*96E*9>>*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
, ') 0"'
)0"'217)G777 % ) - 2 3"''
"
F20P2)Q**&"*$ )" !"%%2"
2')" )% +2 '
%("'+*$)'2"""''")
22")))
2 "
")*
(" '"&" )'
)
2")3!"(%/)
" "'")) 2!")
20'
'0*#)
'%*& 2)
2"))
22")")
2'"2"!"$ *$)
''*!"
')
)'" "0
'0)
2'"*()
))
' '"' )
" "2 ("
')" '*+)! )
""$")
2HB*&
/)
''")"")
"
2'2""2 )
*
()
)
""
")
2' *1))
"
"
2 )
*,)")
2"
""" " )*& 2''")
))" %(%")
'
' +%/ )'*,))")
""2'
""
2 )
''
%/)%+'-)
)"%% ''"')PQ""")
' A" $
"
'2) %" *B'')""'"!"$ 2 2 ')""2*
+)2)'(%"?0/)')"J'" /)')''"J
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
;7*
#$%
&2".)# )3)
$")"2"")"('
*+'''"'" "3'*&2
#"#) '/ )'/ "' "F2) 2'(' (2"
*$" "$"2"
'2 " A" " ))
*#"#))3*$)
"2$" "."/2'
"")&2'")
)""
*#'"'"")3'
*@>#') 2"" ()
2''" '' "*@@ &2".
)"'
" #'/&''" '/
72 ")"$"*!"10
***K"'"2 "K#
"$
)""2'%" "'
@G.%!%42*-*96E*9>>%9>@2*@>*.*+"1GHIH9GJKL!2*6:5%99@J,''$
A*6:9%975*@@&.&1*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
)"K" ? ) " 3*#10""'
K""2""" '
'*
#/2!" "
# (2 " " " '* #"
#1" *$"(2)
" )
2 ")*@E&2".''
$")"2D '*
$"' $" ""
*(''72 "$")"7) 'I*
B'"')&2"..%+(%)'"*B)' $"S&"3&2".
"
''$"+% 3*&))
2) 0 &2"
. $") "
"'"&"*B)'"%)'")"'&2".
"""'$"'" )'" )
*+%) '"'') ' 7*) 2"A' '7)"2'' 2*BA'3
)3'"2'''*(''
)"2'''H3
'A'?
(657@,'B""3')"
A"' $%*+A"))B")" " 3') )"*+
A")B") (JA"' ") '"*$ '" ) ) ' "
2 % 1%% )'
"
' )' ")" B"*
@E,''$A*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
;:%@9*.' ' ' 3 " )'""'"2"'' H
(")
*6@6%@>*-'31$%""9)
$"2#.#&')''"''F
" &2*@5+)2)))*D';;'* ' 6> * CG:
%$%J'2
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
B'".%+(%"''' A(2 )&""
'' ))$"' *(
''"))""2&2".
)2)")*B
) 2)")""' "%*B"2"''''
")(''*&"'")2% "'' *+2&"
'A" "($*
+''"'
)"2 ')
22 "*/&"""$
)"2"
"))"*+$"")
"J$"!"'""3"*
+$"!"
" )
2")"&"*+'' 2&"*+
")""" 'K"
$"
' "?"
'&"
'"K'"'" *'
&"2&"""*+'
"*+)' )
'" 2
'"&" ''"2'")
"
"*('"'' " "'
""" )' 2*+
I7'"2%*+ '/ "I"" ' "'('3))"$"'*
&2".""'$"' ('
")
*$''A&2"
2&22
"')""'
I&2 8 2 8+2 " )'
'I/@%/$)I'"/*$'"""" 4"/) ))2
!" 0' " *" "4"/2
" )"")''"
&""'"("*
B)/"" "#"&)"
')''*+"&)"
"8$%'" 3":%
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
- ;
-
!;!
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
'' )"
PQ*+"' "'""""'
"" "2) )'F"*!"T23"T"?&*P$)Q""2
"P"Q
2'2 2 3'
)" *$'? $)'"'2)"'""'2
2')
*+ !"T23"T
'?
*#')
)"'2")"*#3' )2"
) P$Q2 "
*&$D(PQ,?
4;B"S
B2;(2 2)'
+ )" "$ ;$)'$"2'
"S
,';$(
PQ*
!"T$23"T"?58&8&$
'$) *A2'PQ")
)))"* ( ) " )
*+
)"" 2*4
(2''*#'32
(2**#'(2'
2")S
,"2"P2QP"Q)" "
'*$D"T!""'2T
) *$'? & ! .*$'23"2*!""?5&*B)"'22S+ ))" "'
' *+ )
")*""
*#'2)S$D
/)0$D"PQ'' ?
+"
)" '*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
- ";
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
22*&
))" 2 "2
1%&)"'1% ' # )
) ) S")
2) 2)#"A3S+
)"2 )' % '" 1%%) " /2 " " %%" # ) " "
3"2""'%%
"(J"'")'&2".)")"
") )('""'
*
%&%'((
H) '0' '""'
&2".) )2"2 )'
3)"""""'*+"2'"2
)"*+)
"') *()"
('" &2' J2 0
" " ) )' '"! "
.A")"2)
"" " 2(*EG''"
) ") ""
2('*('"'A
%%"2 #&2
,D 20' %%))2")")C777C")2''')"" / %%%*E>&2".2 "
'
""2'*+"')'
)") '".%+(%2
EG"++ "A('("-!
&*+)("'&2'2
)3)2 ("*#'
&2="&"2#:%1.%/""2**$K*9*6>E%>C*,"''3/"+& '
,('$ *,
''"(')
)"10F.D%&%"*"&.9%
)+%*GC%:C*&''" 3'+
/)3"'"
0''*
E>%%A#&2,D"'*65%6:*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
- ;
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
('!#?B''2
/2()"B"#" %% )''2 /2)2(""
' D*
-
;C*C7 ) %. + / %(% /
IC7?>*C6.%!%42**9>G%9>>*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
)"3 2'"2'"
('"2' *C9
B''"&2".)'"2
'' ("'"('""
)#"22")
)"*+#'2""
'2 "? " ("'' "2 "/"' "#"#'(' *B) &2".
) 2 )"&"*'
)#&"#"'"677777&"
"(2&2"B"#
" %%")"*CG
)()
+'23)'&2".
3"')"'"*B
""")"(""2"")"
""'2 '"'
"'2" "''*C>(&2".
"")" (" " " "" '
#2"') 2%" 12")')" 22""
)("*')2"
)
" 2"") "'
$" "'$""*
() '' " )) ""
12") "' ,( " " "*C@+)&2".
' ) 2
"" ,*B '" " ' "
'''"('2''2
''"*+ ''"'
" 2 "*
C9*/1 / #22 D*-* ,* 9>5 * >6J/%"+ 2/% !4/1))2DD
42&
* 6C5@*" 2 &2" =(% /1%!%/ !"*"#22 *C7E*
CG#&"#"+%K*9*>9%>>*C>&+ ##",&2F*6EE%CG*C@#&+"2)?' )"'
("*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
- ;
-
!;
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
"2)2 ''*B
')"'2)' '
S$2 )')'"
" "2""
')2
"
*C:
,&2".2''"
'%)')*U #"#"K
%"))2'"2 )*#'"''"2)' '' "
*$2)'""'
20'2 "!")
2*57
& &2" . ' ' 5J
$*!*1#"K*97%9EJ&*4*$("+"'?
#".0((*6*G9%GE*9E@%56J*/*#+"'*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
;@2%9>E*59- '"'!" K"AK
1+A$"3**
$$"*6C:%:6*
5GK))&;$*6>%6E6:%G@*5>.%+(%*9>E*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
!; !
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
+))
*A)!*5@&2"
. ''" .%+(%) *$) $" &""'" 2
' '")*
("" ) ' ' 0*
+") " '*5E
*+(%,
+'#&2"."! '
' '
")'' ' " ''* (
)"'
' """""
2"
)" ""
"""")'3 "
'' ("*$" ''')
''2""*'&"
22""?%(&2!"J!"$/'") '2/!"
*
") .%+(% " 22 $"" """
"'2 '2)""
"*+2")2'"'"'2)
) '2''
''"*B' ) ' &2"
. ) '* () " '
'))"
"
) 2 " '
(' "*
&2" . ' ) ' " '""
2 )" "*$"
5@B)&2".'" (""
'')')'*+
' (" A#''''
**8'4'#.2 2)#'"("
&3@G*9>C%EG*(''"(""!
" "' )""*,3#)"
A(
'"'A "A'
""*#8B2" 5*3$B * C:* # " '" (" " 'A "')""("*#AH*B
+F''(*96:*66999*5E.%+(%*9>:2*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
- !";
-
!;!
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
"''' ) 2)
$")"("*+"
3''" '3
*$)''*$""
2D(' ")"'"
*&0' )")&"'
)")""""&""
" *+H )" 2 '
'')"'" 1)
B"3 )" 2)"')"
'
' ""'' *+)"'"
20 H
" *55) &2" .
""' '"
$"))"")''"
)" &"H"2"2
32"")"*5:
( 2" ' 2'
' " '"'1)B"
2 *B"2"
2"'2).
""3"')
("''")'
) "
*B &2".) )
''("'2"2'
'")
"
'")"' ''
' *(')"
'2"""'3
)
') )*
#%
&222/""*2%!%?):%%+""&$&2""& 6:@>*1)F
6::C*
&2,D 220./!/#"&"/"* *& 977@JH *
$*#*8"*8"#*F
9775*
55&A "-
'3!&B#**67%6>9C%@EJ."VA WVY"W?4'NK( O' "
Y' '
'YY YYY
FY'Y&&*5:4 !.!*67:%977*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
!;*
TTT*+F2B?. 4)"A'
("."-$"F"B2""#*
&3'$4"9766*5%G:*
&D"#0#2*551)U9766*
&K))*;$F
6:5@*
"-.
1("A0"&0
!"$F
9779*9>%>G*
TTT**
&,"F*;+'%""*+6:E6*
TTT*/'%1K"*+6::>*
TTT*!%'%".D#/""*+977:*
"L&2" I" %/) "' 2+ $* #2
K*9+9776*
&2="&"2#*:%1.%/"*Y$
A6:76*
1%$%A2",D,D#(-('6@>>"(-('
>@9& "&'
' - " ("-'
'+
424"*
','*$A?&('K)$"!"#"#'
7A)$"("*,"
F6:::*6:9%975*
1$%)$" 2 #.#
*
F&$#0D*-%-.%4')655@J *'4)'1)U
6::9*
HB*"'*4)'41)U9779*
HY$*#$ &B-3"
6:7G*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
-
!;!
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
,1*.*&3*2&
2"977E*
,"I$"#*%/-%"*".D&K*6+
977:*
!"&*#&")."*1
#?.%4"
977E*G@7%E6*
$8*2345'6:@G*
$&$*/% &%/#""+2"*+6::9*
$%(-('6CCC&"&'
'-"("-'
'+424"*
$D.**;%&7;%'6:@5*
$&*4* ("+"'?#".0 ((*6*G9%GE$
*5K*96G6:C6*9E@%56*
(2&2F*!-+%/-U"*"2(2"
"A6:C9*
(.D* !3 & -# /'
9779*
8'2$*=+$O?*
"/"&2"*"*#!A$:1
-A2'42AK*N(K*A6:C7*
1$*!*#"K+/1
2#
"
&6C6:@@*97%9E*
-,''*8:%%?&"F""H
#&"&'#"2
-
!;5#22D*
#)F"2&2".*!!)%/"
("(2"*."6::C*
#)F"*%$%H 42#F A"
1)F
6:C7*
/ % "+ . /% ! 4/# * ,* 6C5@ 1))2
D
42& *
#"&@%C@*
KK" A* 1+ A K" AK "*
$"3**$$"
4')977@*6C:%:6*
K."'*A( " A"A*F*"
#'-"&'#"4"6:55*
K*$%**F
6::5*
-
!;!
&*">:99769?6@6%:@
BAH*+F''(B*$
"F"*4
"&$#=!4"6::6*96:%G5*="* &2". F*F "*1
&F
6:57*G@9%@>*
=&"2&2"*(%1%!%/ !"#22 "6:59*
by SUNIL KUMAR on April 6, 2014ier.sagepub.comDownloaded from
http://ier.sagepub.com/http://ier.sagepub.com/
/ColorImageDict > /JPEG2000ColorACSImageDict > /JPEG2000ColorImageDict > /AntiAliasGrayImages false /DownsampleGrayImages true /GrayImageDownsampleType /Bicubic /GrayImageResolution 300 /GrayImageDepth -1 /GrayImageDownsampleThreshold 1.50000 /EncodeGrayImages true /GrayImageFilter /DCTEncode /AutoFilterGrayImages true /GrayImageAutoFilterStrategy /JPEG /GrayACSImageDict > /GrayImageDict > /JPEG2000GrayACSImageDict > /JPEG2000GrayImageDict > /AntiAliasMonoImages false /DownsampleMonoImages true /MonoImageDownsampleType /Bicubic /MonoImageResolution 1200 /MonoImageDepth -1 /MonoImageDownsampleThreshold 1.50000 /EncodeMonoImages true /MonoImageFilter /CCITTFaxEncode /MonoImageDict > /AllowPSXObjects false /PDFX1aCheck false /PDFX3Check false /PDFXCompliantPDFOnly false /PDFXNoTrimBoxError true /PDFXTrimBoxToMediaBoxOffset [ 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 ] /PDFXSetBleedBoxToMediaBox true /PDFXBleedBoxToTrimBoxOffset [ 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 0.00000 ] /PDFXOutputIntentProfile () /PDFXOutputCondition () /PDFXRegistryName (http://www.color.org) /PDFXTrapped /Unknown
/Description >>> setdistillerparams> setpagedevice