AGILE vs SAM
26
A.D.D.I.E vs. S.A.M Which is better for learning? And why it shouldn’t have to be a fight? Presented by: Amy P. McIntosh a my.p.mcintosh@gmail. com 803-403-5170
-
Upload
amy-mcintosh -
Category
Documents
-
view
601 -
download
0
Transcript of AGILE vs SAM
A.D.D.I.E vs. S.A.MWhich is better for learning?
And why it shouldn’t have to be a fight?
Presented by:Amy P. [email protected]
So Why Are YOU Here?
What is ADDIE?AnalysisDesignDevelopment ImplementationEvaluation
What People Are Saying?Comprehensive analysis up front is unrealistic
Analysis often overlook essential success factors
Specs and storyboards miscommunicate
Creativity becomes a nuisance to the schedule
Downstream insights are faults that become trouble
Performance outcomes are rarely measured
Post tests are insensitive measures but become outcome targets
Have YOU Experienced This?
What is ADDIE?RigidOldLinearJust OLD
What is ADDIE?PracticalMore FlexibleCircularStill Just OLD
What is ADDIE?
BeHonest
Moving ForwardWhat Are Some Limitations?
The order of the phases
The lack of practical strategies
The lack of collaborative design
Limited manageability
What is SAM?SuccessiveApproximationModel
Savvy Start
What is SAM Savvy Start?
What People Are Saying?Teams are collaborating a lot more between Intructional Designers and Multimedia
Clients are enjoying getting to see the work much earlier in the process
Clients are loving the opportunity to provide input
What’s So Different About It?
• Information gathering, get background information
Preparation Phase
• Savvy start• Project planning• Additional design
Iterative Design Phase
• Design proof• Alpha• Beta• Gold
Iterative Development Phase
ADDIE
12 3 12 3 12 3
SAM SAM SAM1
What’s So Different About It?
What’s So Different About It?
Analysis Design Development
So, Is It a Fight?How Do YOU Choose?What is the criteria for picking the right process?
Do the products you create meet the satisfaction of your customers within the constraints?
Are the products delivered on time?
Are the products delivered within budget?Is the design team happy with the end result?
Does it makes sense to your customer?
Thoughts? / Questions?No Fighting
Resources / Links• www.bottomlineperformance.com• www.alleninteractions.com• Leaving ADDIE for SAM Slide Share by Michael Allen• The Death of ADDIE by Tim Reiker• Agile vs. ADDIE, which is better for learning
Contact Info:Amy McIntosh
Instructional [email protected]
803.403.5170
