3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 )...

30

Transcript of 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 )...

Page 1: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

����������� ������� ����� � ��������� �!"�#��� $%���& �'�����(���������)�*�+��$-,.��/�*�102�2� �)�3���)� 4356, 0"7���8�:9

;(<%=>=@?BAC<ED FHGJIKD@LM?ONP<RQBS"F!<%=@AT<�UWVXL#<%YM<RZ['\^]@_a`�b�c�d�]Mef]gb#_ah>ikjl]Mcnma]o_/pTq#_!r�_fmasutvhgb�w�xycnma]Mwzw{sz|�]McvhM]�}�~*�vwumas{b�|�]Mcnm��%�Re�ma]M`!eP\�_aq��v�K}�������R�g��� �Eb�b#_a�R_���vh>��]McB}X\^]o_a`�b#cn�n�� j�b)_acv]M|�sz]H~*]Mwzwzq�c*�^cvsz��]@_aefszmy�n}Rd�q��Xq�maszhMe�x�cEe�maszma�Rma]�}v��sumfmaef�v�R_a|�iB}v�3�Er/���� ~�b�szw��X�%wz�vefh>iX�3�RpC�%s�� �R]�}R��b)masJb��^hMeM� hM`��B� ]g�E�

�3 >¡£¢E¤�¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§�¤

­¯® <EDa=l°�<n±a²RYoAJ=aVP²R³¨´#Qv=@´�Y@µ¨YoATD>´�D�L)²EQv=@ACQvIB´�=@²P²RµO´#YM<n=o´�ACQ!=@?¨´^µ¨?WVXD>ATL#<RGR¶^²RYoGCS¸·�SX²EAJQB¹º IBD@ACQ¨´�DoD�<ED�IBD@IB<%G�· º I¨=�AJQKL)Yo´�<RD@ACQ¨¹RGCV�<RS¨²RµX=�=o?¨´ »fQv=@´�Y@QB´)=�ACQ�´ ® ´#YoV<RD@µO´�Lg=�²R³¼=@?¨´�AJYº IBD@ACQ¨´�DoDH²RµO´#YM<n=oAJ²EQBD#½O»fQv=@´�Y@Q¨´#=>¾ º <RD@´�S6L)²W²RYMSXACQB<n=oAJ²EQ6<RQBSkL#²RGCGC< º ²EYo<%=@AC²RQ º ´)=a¶^´#´�QD@I¨µ¨µ¨GCV�LM?B<%ACQ�µB<%Y@=@QB´#YMD:ACDP´)¿XµO´�L)=@´�S�=@²2L#Y@´�<n=@´�Q¨´#¶ ® <%GCI¨´<RQBS�ACQBL)Yo´�<ED>´H=o?¨´�µ¨Yo²%¾SXIBL)=@A ® A{=aV(<RQBS(´#À�L#AJ´�QBL)V�²R³ º ²R=@?ÁSXAC¹RAJ=o<%G�<%QKS(µ¨?WVXD>ATL#<RGµBY@²XSXIBL)=HL#²R°�µB<RQ¨AJ´�D#½¼Ã²S¨<%=@´R·�=o?¨´3»fQv=@´#YoQ¨´#=�?K<RD�<%GCY@´�<RSXV!L#Y@´�<n=@´�S�<�L)²E°*µBGJ´#=@´^´#GC´�Lg=oY@²EQ¨ATL�´�L)²RQB²R°�V!¶:?BACLM?ACDYM<%µ¨ATSXGCV�¹EY@²n¶:ACQ¨¹ <RQBS�L)²E°�µ¨Y@ATD@AJQ¨¹K·#ACQ�µB<RY>=oACL#I¨GC<RY�·�<%Q!²EµK´�Q<%QKSH¹RGC² º <RGJGCV�<EL#L#´�DoD>A º GC´Q¨´#=a¶�²EY@ÄE´�SH´#Q ® ACY@²EQ¨°�´#Qv=�Å�AJQv=@´�YoL#²RQ¨QB´�Lg=o´�S!´�GJ´�Lg=oY@²EQ¨ACL�°�<%YoÄR´)=MD#·�²RQ¨GCACQ¨´�L#²RQBD@I¨°�´#YMD#·µ¨Yo²XSXIBL)´�YoD�·¨<%QKS2´�GJ´�Lg=@Yo²RQBACL�ACQE=o´#Yo°�´�SXAT<%YoAJ´�D#ÅX<RQBS�GJ´�¹E<%G¸<RQBS"µK²EGJATL)V�³�YM<%°�´�¶�²EY@ÄXD�½»fQv=@´�Y@°�´�S¨AC<RY@AC´�D*ACQ¯=o?¨´�»fQv=@´�Y@Q¨´#=�´�L)²EQ¨²R°VƵ¨Yo² ® ATSX´�°�<%YoÄR´#=>¾�°�<RÄR´�YD@´#Y ® ATL)´�D#·

SX²E°�<RAJQÇ´#¿WµO´#Y@=@ATD@´R·�=oY@IBD>=�· ® ACD@A º AJGCA{=aVE·�<RDoD@I¨Yo<RQBL)´E·�<%QBSÇL)´�Y>=oA{ÈOL#<n=oAJ²EQÉ=@?B<%=2´#QB< º GC´º I¨VE´#YMDl=@²!LM?¨²W²ED@´:D>´�GJGC´#YMD�<%QKS�µ¨Yo²XSXIBL)=oD�½%Ã3?¨´#V*<%GTD>²�µ¨Yo² ® ATSX´^=@?B´ D>´�<%YMLM?¸·�Y@´#=@YoAJ´ ® <RGy·<%QKSÆ<%¹R¹EY@´�¹E<%=@AC²RQ6D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D�=o?B<n=�GC²n¶^´#Y!²RQBGJACQ¨´�=oYo<RQBD@<ELg=oAJ²EQÁL#²ED>=oDH³�²EY º IBD@ACQ¨´�DoD>´�D#½Ê¸ACÄR´PAJQv=o´#Yo°*´�SXAT<%YoAJ´�D�AJQ'=@?¨´Pµ¨?WVWD@ATL#<%GK´�L#²RQ¨²E°�VR·EAJQv=o´#GCGJAC¹R´�QE=^°�ACS¨S¨GJ´#¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD�L#<RQ º ´L)²EQBD@ACSX´�Y@´�SH<RD¸´�GJ´�Lg=oY@²EQ¨ACL�ACQv=@´�Y@°�´�S¨AC<RY@AC´�D�ACQ!=o?¨´�SXAC¹RAJ=o<RGR´�L#²RQ¨²E°�V�Ë Ì�Í�½�Ã3?¨´�D@´�<%¹E´#Qv=oDµ¨Yo² ® ACSX´:°�´�<%QBD�²R³O°�´�<%Q¨ACQ¨¹%³�IBGJGCVL#²v²EYoS¨AJQB<%=@ACQ¨¹!<RL)=@A ® AJ=@AC´�D�<%°�²RQ¨¹�<R¹R´�QE=�µ¨Yo² ® ACS¨´#YMD<%QKS(Yo´�ÎvI¨´�D>=@´�YoDP²%³^D>´�Y ® ATL)´�DÏ�ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQ¸·¼¹R²W²XS¨D#·O²RY�´)¿XµO´#Y@=@ATD>´�Ð ACQ(=o?¨´*»fQE=o´#YoQ¨´)=Ë ÑnÍ�½¼Ã3?B´#ACY�°�<RAJQk=o<RD@Ä�ATD/=o²"GC²XL#<%=@´<RQBSkL#²RQ¨QB´�Lg=�=@?B´*IBG{=oAJ°�<n=o´*D@´#Y ® ACL#´�µ¨Yo² ® ACS¨´#YMD¶:AJ=@?(=o?¨´*I¨G{=oAJ°�<%=@´�Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=o´#YMD ACQ(²RµO´#Q6´#Q ® AJYo²RQB°*´�Qv=oD�·¨=@?K<n=PATD/=@²"<Rµ¨µ¨Yo²Rµ¨YoAT<n=@´�GJVL)²EµK´!¶:AJ=@?�=o?¨´�L)²EQ¨Q¨´�L)=@AC²RQ�µ¨Yo² º GC´#°�½Ò�<%YoAC²RIBD!SXATD>=@YoA º I¨=@´�SÁ<RQBSÁL)´#Qv=oYo<RGJACÓ#´�S6D@´)=@=@ACQ¨¹EDH´#¿WATD>=!=@²(D@²RG ® ´=@?¨ATD�µ¨Yo² º GJ´�°�½

»fQÔ¹E´#Q¨´�Yo<RGy·¸¶^´�Yo²RI¨¹E?¨GJVÕSXATDa=oAJQ¨¹EI¨ATD>?Æ=o?¨Yo´#´2<R¹R´#Qv=�L�<n=@´�¹R²EY@AC´�D�·¸D>´�Y ® ATL)´�µ¨Yo² ® ACS¨´#YMDÏ×Ö�¾�<R¹R´�QE=MDoÐ)·�D>´�Y ® ATL)´*Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=@´#Y�Ï×Ø:¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MDoÐ)·¼<RQBS6°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�½�Ã3?¨´ º <RD@ATL�µ¨Yo²%¾L)´�D@DP²%³�L�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=aVv¾ º <ED>´�S�°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ º V�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD/?B<RD/=@?¨´�³�²RGCGJ²n¶:ACQ¨¹�³�²EY@°�ÙÏaÚ�Ð Ö�¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD <RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD>´�=@?¨´�AJY�L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D/=@²2°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�·ÂÏ�ÛRÐ °*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oDD>=@²RYo´=@?¨´�D>´'<ES ® ´�Y>=oACD@´#°�´#Qv=MD#·�Ï×ÜvÐP<�Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=!<RD@ÄWDHD@²R°�´*°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=H=@²�GC²WL�<n=o´<%QKSÔL)²EQ¨Q¨´�L)=�=o²kÖ�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD!¶:AJ=@?¯SX´�D@AJYo´�SÝL#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D�¶:?¨ATLM?Ô°�<�V6ACQBL)GCIBSX´�L)²E°¾µ¨GC´)=o´H=@YM<%QBDo<RL)=@AC²RQ2ACQv=@´�Y@°�´�S¨AC<%=@AC²RQ"<RQBS"²%=@?B´#Y ® <%GCI¨´)¾f<RSBSX´�S�D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D#·W<%QBSÕÏ�ÌWÐ�=@?¨´Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=@A ® ´�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=�µ¨Y@²XL#´�DoD>´�D/=o?¨ATD!Y@´�ÎvI¨´�D>=�<%¹E<RAJQKDa=!AJ=oD!ÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´²EQÆL#<n¾µB< º AJGCAJ=@AC´�D²%³ Yo´#¹RATD>=@´#Yo´�SÆÖ�¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD�<%QKSÆY@´#=@I¨YoQBD�=@?¨´"Y@´�D>I¨GJ=�½�Ã3?¨´"Y@´�D>I¨GJ=°�<�V º ´´#AJ=@?B´#YP<2D>I º D>´#=/²%³�=@?B´�Da=o²RYo´�S�<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD@´#°�´#Qv=oD ¶:A{=o?�QB<%°�´�D/²%³�Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=@A ® ´!µBY@² ® AJ¾

Page 2: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| �SX´�YoDÂ=@²HL)²EQv=o<RL)=�·�²RYÂ=@?B´�Yo´�D@I¨GJ=l²R³¨=@?¨´:L#²R°�µ¨GC´)=@´�=@YM<%QKD@<ELg=@AC²RQ�³�²RYl=@?¨´^°�²ED>=�D@I¨AJ=o< º GJ´D@´#Y ® ATL)´E½àá?¨ACGJ´H=o?¨ATD µ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD3<n=:ÈBYMD>= ¹RGT<%QBL#´HD@´#´�°�D ® ´#YoV2D@AJ°�µ¨GC´R·BA{= ATD L)²E°�µ¨GJATL#<%=@´�S º V

=@?B´�³×<ELg=�=@?K<n=�=@?¨´3»fQv=@´�Y@QB´)=�L)²EQBD>ATSX´�Y@´�S�<RD�<RQ�²RµO´#Q�D@²WL#AC<RGy·�ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQ¸·n<%QBS º IBD@A{¾Q¨´�D@Dl´#Q ® ACY@²EQ¨°�´#Qv=�ATDÂACQ�<PL)²RQv=oAJQWIB<RGvLM?B<RQ¨¹R´E½�Ã3?B´�SXYoA ® ACQ¨¹ ³�²EYoL#´�¶:?¨ATLM?�µ¨Yo´�L#AJµBA{=M<n=@´²RYÂSX´#°�<%QKS!LM?B<%Q¨¹E´�°�<�V�<%YoACD@´�<%QWVW¶:?¨´#Yo´�<n=�<RQWV =@AC°�´R½�â/VWQB<R°*ATL�LM?B<RQ¨¹R´�D�L)²EQBL)´�Y@Q¸·³�²RY^´)¿¨<R°*µBGJ´E·EGC²XL#<n=oAJ²EQ'<%QBS'?¨´)=o´#Yo²R¹R´�Q¨´#AJ=aV*²%³�< ® <%ACGC< º GC´ Y@´�D>²EI¨YML)´�D�<%QBS'L#²RQv=@´�Qv=^<RD¶^´#GCG3<ED�SXAJã¼´#Yo´#Qv=*IKD>´�Y*L#²R°�°�I¨QBA{=oAJ´�D<RQBSÔD@²WL#AJ´#=@AC´�D²%³P<R¹R´�QE=MD�´�<RLM?Ô²R³ ¶:?¨ACLM?ÝACDµ¨I¨YMD@I¨AJQB¹*AJ=oD3¹E²E<RGCD�=@?K<n=:°�<�V'L)²RQ¨äBACL)= ¶:A{=o?2=o?¨´!¹R²v<%GTD�²R³Â²R=@?¨´�YoD�½X»fQ�<ES¨SXAJ=@AC²RQ"=@?¨´QWI¨° º ´#Y/²%³lS¨A{ã¼´#Yo´#Qv= <%¹E´#Qv=oD:<RQBS2°I¨GJ=@AT<%¹R´�Qv=:D@VXDa=o´#°�D^=@?K<n=/<%Yo´ º ´�AJQ¨¹'S¨´ ® ´�GJ²EµK´�Sº V�SXA{ã¼´#Yo´#Qv=3¹RYo²RI¨µKD�<%QKS�²RYo¹E<RQ¨AJÓ�<n=oAJ²EQBD�D@AJ¹EQ¨A{ÈOL#<%Qv=oGJV*´)¿¨L#<RY º <n=@´�D�=o?¨´�L#²RQ¨QB´�Lg=oAJ²EQµ¨Yo² º GC´#°�½�Ã3?WIBD�·�=o?¨´�´�DoD>´�Qv=@AT<%G L#<RµB< º AJGCA{=oAJ´�D�²%³!<%QWVÔÄWACQBSɲ%³H°�ACS¨S¨GJ´#¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD�<%Yo´=@²�³×<EL)ACGJAJ=o<%=@´�=@?B´!AJQv=@´�Y@²EµK´�Yo< º ACGJAJ=aV�²%³�<%µ¨µBY@²Eµ¨Y@AT<n=o´�D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D�·X<%¹R´�Qv=oD3<%QBS�D@VXDa=o´#°�D#·º I¨ACGTSXAJQB¹!=@YoIBD>=�·RL#²RQXÈKS¨´#QBL#´3<RQBS�D>´�L)I¨YoAJ=aV�AJQ�<�äB´#¿XA º GC´:°�<%Q¨QB´#Y�·%<%QBS=@²�L#²R°�µ¨GCV!=@²Yo´#¹RIBGC<%=@²RYoV�<%QKS�GJ´�¹E<%GW³�YM<%°�´�¶�²EY@ÄXDl¶:?¨´#Q�< ® <%ACGT< º GC´R½RÃ3?BACD�S¨´#µO´#QBS¨D�²RQ*=@?¨´PD>µO´�L#A{ÈKLYo´�ÎvI¨ACY@´�°*´�Qv=oD AC°�µ¨GCAJ´�S º V"¹EA ® ´#QkD@µO´�L)AJÈKL<%µ¨µ¨GCATL#<n=oAJ²EQ¸·BACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQ¸·¼<%QBS�D@VXDa=o´#°´#Q ® ACY@²EQ¨°�´#Qv=�½�å�A ® ´�QÝ=o?¨´�³×<RL)=*=o?B<n=2S¨A{ã¼´#Yo´#Qv=�=aVWµK´�D�²%³�°*ATS¨SXGC´(<%¹E´#Qv=oD*µ¨Yo² ® ACS¨´SXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=^µO´#Y@³�²RYo°�<%QBL#´ =@YM<RS¨´)¾�²%ã�D�¶:?B<%=�=aVWµO´�D�²%³�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oD�<RY@´�<%µ¨µBY@²Eµ¨Y@AT<n=o´SX´�µK´�QBS¨D*²RQÆ=o?¨´"<Rµ¨µ¨GCACL�<n=oAJ²EQ¸½lÃ3?B´2² ® ´�Yo<RGJG�LM?B<%GCGJ´�Q¨¹R´2²%³P<�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv= º <ED>´�SD@²RGCIX=@AC²RQ(ATD:=o²'Ȩ=�AJQk¶:A{=o?�=@?¨´�L)²EQBD@ACSX´�Y@´�S�D>AJ=@IB<%=@AC²RQ(°�²vDa=/´#ãO´�Lg=oA ® ´#GCVR·O´)À'L)AC´#Qv=@GCV<%QKS"Yo´#GCAT< º GCVR½Ã3?¨´�D>=@YoIBLg=oI¨Y@´*²%³�=@?¨´�Yo´#°�<%ACQBSX´�YH²%³�=o?¨ACD�LM?B<%µX=o´#YHATD�<EDP³�²RGCGJ²n¶ D�½¸UW´�L)=@AC²RQÁѨ½uÛ

µ¨Yo² ® ACSX´�DH<2¹E´#Q¨´�Yo<RGlD@ÄWAJGCG{¾ º <ED>´�SkLM?B<RYo<ELg=@´�Y@ACÓ�<%=@AC²RQ�²R³�°�ACS¨S¨GJ´#¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD#½¼»fQÕµB<%Y@=@ATL)IX¾GT<%Y�·¨¶�´!¶:ACGCG¸¹RA ® ´�<�L#²R°�µB<RL)=:¹RI¨ATSX´H=@²'=@?¨´ º <ED>ATL!L)²EQBL)´�µX=oD ²%³�°�<%=oLM?¨°�<RÄvACQ¨¹�<%QKSº Yo²RÄE´#YoAJQ¨¹Õ³�²EY2L)²W²RYMSXACQB<n=oAJ²EQ¯²R³H<R¹R´�QE=2D@²XL)AC´)=oAJ´�D�AJQÇ=o?¨´�»fQv=@´�Y@Q¨´#= º VÝYo´�D@µK´�Lg=oA ® ´=aVWµK´�D�²R³¼°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�½EUW´�Lg=@AC²RQ�ÑB½ ÜH¹EA ® ´�D�´#¿X<R°�µ¨GJ´�D�²%³ º ²%=o?'L)²W²RYMSXACQB<n=oAJ²EQ=o´�LM?X¾Q¨ATÎvI¨´�D!<ED�=@?¨´�Vk<%Yo´*< ® <RAJGT< º GC´�ACQÆD>´ ® ´�Yo<RG°I¨G{=oAC<R¹R´�QE=�D@VXDa=o´#°�D�¶:?¨ACLM?Õ?B< ® ´ º ´#´�QSX´ ® ´#GC²RµO´�S º VkSXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=HYo´�D@´�<RYoLM?6GC< º DH<%QBSÕI¨QBA ® ´#YMD>AJ=@AC´�DHD@²2³×<RY�½¸ælACQB<%GCGJVE·�D@´�Lg=oAJ²EQѨ½ Ì�L)²EQBL)GCIBSX´�D^=@?¨ATD LM?B<RµX=@´�Y º V º Y@AC´)äKV2D>IB°*°�<RY@ACÓ#ACQ¨¹*=@?¨´!°�<RAJQ�Y@´�D>IBG{=MD#½

�3 yçéè6§3§�¦B©P¬>¤/êÂ¥¨¬>§�¤ë§�ì2íÇî�ï�¤�¥áð3§:«�¬aï�¥¨¬aïÂñÕò:¬>êôóõ¬@©/©/ö>ï¼÷�íÇî�ï�¤�¥Xñ

ø�ùTú¸ù×ûÇüþý×ÿlÿ������������� ��

Ã3?¨´ QB²%=@AC²RQKD�²%³¼°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD#·R°�<%=oLM?¨°�<RÄR´#YMD�· º Y@²EÄR´�YoD�·�³×<RL#AJGCA{=M<n=o²RYMD#·R<RQBS�°�´�SXAT<n¾=@²EYoD^<%Yo´ IBD@´�S�³�Y@´�´#GCV*ACQ'=o?¨´/GCAJ=@´#YM<n=oI¨Yo´/²RQ'=@?¨´�D>I º ±a´�Lg=3¶:AJ=@?¨²EIX=�Q¨´�L)´�D@Do<%YoAJGCV º ´�AJQ¨¹L)GC´�<RY@GCVS¨´)ÈBQ¨´�S�½R»fQ�=o?¨´:³�²EGJGC²n¶:AJQB¹�¶^´/<ES¨SXYo´�DoDl=@?¨ATD�=o´#Yo°*ACQ¨²EGJ²E¹RATL#<%GXATDoD>I¨´E½%»fQ�¹R´�Q¨´)¾YM<%G�·E°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oD^<%Yo´/<%¹E´#Qv=oD�=@?B<%=^?B´#GCµ'²%=o?¨´#YMD�=o²GC²XL#<%=@´P<RQBS'L#²RQ¨Q¨´�Lg=^=@²*<%¹R´�Qv=µ¨Yo² ® ACSX´�YoD�²R³¸D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D/Ë Ñ�Í�½EæBI¨Y@=@?¨´�Y@°�²RYo´R·E<%QWV�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=�L#<RQ º ´/LM?B<RYo<ELg=o´#YoAJÓ�´�Sº V2AJ=oD:L#²RYo´HD@ÄWAJGCGTD3²%³ÚE½3µ¨Y@² ® ATSXACQ¨¹ º <RD@ACL�°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ�D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D�=o²=o?¨´�L)²EQBD@ACSX´�Y@´�S"<R¹R´�QE= D@²XL)AC´)=aVR·Û¨½:L)²W²RYMSXACQB<n=oAJQ¨¹ =@?¨´�D>´^D>´�Y ® ATL)´�DÂ<RL�L)²RYMSXACQ¨¹3=@²P¹RA ® ´�Q!µ¨Y@²R=@²XL)²EGCD�·�L#²RQ ® ´�Qv=@AC²RQBD�·#<%QKSµK²EGJATL)AC´�D�·¨<%QBS

Page 3: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

� ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

ÜB½3´#QBD@I¨YoAJQ¨¹*Yo´#GCAC< º GJ´HD@´#Y ® ATL)´P°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ"ACQ2=o´#Yo°�D�²R³ÂGC´ ® ´#GC´�S2ÎvIB<RGJAJ=aV�²%³�D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D<RD:¶^´#GCGÂ<ED:=@YoIBD>=/°�<%QB<R¹R´�°*´�Qv= ¶:A{=o?¨AJQ6<%QBS�<EL)Yo²EDoD3°�I¨GJ=@AT<%¹E´#Qv=/D>VXD>=@´�°�D º ²EY>¾SX´#YMD#½

������� ý���ý � � ���� �WÿÂý�� �ý � �!�"� �#� ý�$%���Rù »fQɲRµO´#QÉAJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ¯<RQBSÝ=@YM<RSXACQ¨¹Õ´#QX¾® AJYo²RQB°*´�Qv=oD�ACQÝ=o?¨´�»fQv=@´#YoQ¨´#=2<6°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=*?K<RD*=@²Áµ¨Yo² ® ACS¨´ º <RD@ACL"°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQD@´#Y ® ATL)´�D^³�²RY3=o?¨´ÚE½3µ¨Y@²XL#´�DoD>ACQ¨¹*²%³�<%¹R´�Qv=3L�<%µB< º AJGCAJ=aV2<%QBS�D@´#Y ® ACL#´�SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=oAJ²EQBDÛ¨½:D>´�°�<RQv=@ATLPACQv=@´�Y@²EµK´�Yo<%=@AC²RQ º ´)=a¶^´#´�Q�<%¹R´�Qv=oD3<%QBS�D@VXDa=o´#°�D#·ÜB½3°�<RQB<%¹E´#°�´#Qv=:²%³�S¨<n=M<�<%QBS�ÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´R·X<%QBSÌK½:SXACD>=@YoA º IX=@´�S�ÎEIB´#YoV'µ¨Yo²WL#´�DoD>ACQ¨¹�<%QBS2=@YM<%QKD@<ELg=@AC²RQKD#½àÕ´"¶:ACGJG º YoAC´)äBVÆSXATD@L#IBDoD�´�<RLM?Ô²R³ =@?¨´�D>´�D@´#Y ® ATL)´'=aVvµO´�D*ACQÔ=o?¨´2³�²EGJGC²n¶:ACQ¨¹k<%QKS

µ¨Yo²RµO²ED@´�<6Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=@A ® ´�D>´�Y ® ATL)´#¾�²EY@AC´#Qv=@´�SÆL)GT<RDoD>AJÈKL�<n=@AC²RQݲ%³P°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oDAJQÇD@´�Lg¾=@AC²RQ�ÑB½ Û¨½ Û¨½

&('*)"+-,/.-./021�34)6587�3�,91;:<+-7�=;7%>902?@02:BA�7�1CD.9,9'/E�0�+-,FC�,/.9+9'/0 =:B0�)�1G.9H;I^<ED>ATL3Yo´�ÎvI¨ACY@´�°*´�Qv==@²�I¨QBSX´�YoD>=o<RQBS�<%QBS�<RIX=@²E°�<%=@ATL#<RGJGCV�µ¨Yo²XL)´�D@D�Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=MD�³�²RY�<RQBS�SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=@AC²RQKD�²%³�D>´�Y>¾® ACL#´�D:<RQBS"L�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D3²R³l<%¹E´#Qv=oD3ATD^=@?B´H<R¹RYo´#´�S'IBD@´H²%³�<�ÏyD>´#=:²%³oÐ3L#²R°�°�²RQ�<%¹R´�Qv=L#<RµB< º AJGCA{=aV�SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=oAJ²EQ(GC<RQ¨¹RIK<%¹R´D>IBLM?6<RD�Ê ­ Ø/F�UÔË ÌBÚ%·¼Ì�JnÍ�·LK^âPÊ-ËNM�Í�·O²EYPO�;(Ê�¾º <ED>´�S*D@´#Y ® ACL#´ SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQ³�Yo<R°�´#¶^²RYoÄWD�·nGCAJÄE´ Ø âPæ3Ï�U¨Ð)Ë Ü%ÌRÍK²RY�´�K�²�D>VXD>=@´�°RQ D�D@´#Y ® ´�Y<%QKSÕL#²R°�°�²RQ º IBD@ACQ¨´�DoD!GCA º YM<%YoVÝÏSK(I^ÊlÐH²%³3¹R´�Q¨´#YoATLDO�;(Ê SX²XL#I¨°�´#Qv=�°�²XSX´#GTDH³�²RY´)¾fL)²E°�°*´�YoL#´*ËJÚ#Ì%Í�½W»fQ�¹R´#QB´#YM<%G�·R=o?¨´H°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=3?B<RD�=@²�ACQ2Yo´�<RGK=oAJ°�´HµB<RYoD@´R· ® <%GCA{¾S¨<%=@´R·vI¨QBS¨´#YMDa=M<%QBS�<RQBS�Y@´�D>µO´�L)=@A ® ´�GJVµ¨Y@²XL#´�DoD�L#<RµB< º ACGCA{=aV�<%QBS�D@´#Y ® ACL#´ SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBDAJ=�Y@´�L)´#A ® ´�D#½�Ã3?¨ATD!ATDHAJQÁ²EYoSX´�Y�=@²�´)À'L)AC´#Qv=oGJVkS¨´)=@´�Y@°�ACQ¨´�¶:?¨ATLM?6²R³�=o?¨´�<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD>´�SD@´#Y ® ATL)´�D�<RQBS�L#<RµB< º AJGCA{=oAJ´�D�²R³BL)I¨YoYo´#Qv=@GCVPYo´#¹EACD>=@´�Y@´�S!Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD¸<RY@´�°*²vDa=�<%µ¨µBY@²Eµ¨Y@AT<n=o´³�²RYP<�¹RA ® ´#Q�Yo´�ÎvI¨´�D>= ²%³�<%Q�Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�½¨Ã3?B´�LM?¨²RATL)´H²%³�<�D@I¨A{=M< º GC´!°�<n=MLM?¨AJQB¹�°*´�LM?B<n¾Q¨ATD>°õL#´#Y@=o<RAJQ¨GCVÆSX´#µO´#QKS¨D*²RQÆ=o?¨´�D>=@YoIBL)=@I¨Yo´"<RQBSÝD@´#°�<%Qv=oACL�D�²R³:=@?¨´�SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBD=@² º ´�°�<n=oLM?B´�SÉ<RD*¶�´�GJG <ED*²RQ¯=@?¨´(SX´�D>ACYo´�SÔÄWACQBSÇ<%QBSÉÎvIB<%GCAJ=aVƲ%³/=o?¨´�²RI¨=oL)²E°�´²%³/=@?¨´�°�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹6µ¨Yo²WL#´�DoD#ÅlAJ=*°�<�VÁY@´�GJVE·l³�²RY*´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R·l²RQÉD>AC°�µ¨GJ´�ÄR´�VW¶�²EYoSÁ<%QKS® <%GCI¨´�°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹K·lIKD>´�²%³PSB<n=o<6Da=oY@IKLg=@IBY@´�<%QBSÔ=aVWµK´�AJQ¨³�´#Yo´#QBL#´�D�·�<RQBSUTn²RY�=o?¨´�IBD>´²%³3YM<n=@?B´#Y�L)²E°�µ¨GJ´#¿6Yo´�<ED>²EQ¨AJQB¹"°�´�LM?K<%Q¨ATD>°�D!D@IBLM?Á<RD�L#²RQBL#´#µX=�D@I º D@I¨°�µX=@AC²RQÆ<%QKSÈBQ¨AJ=@´6L)²RQKDa=oYo<RAJQv=�°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹K½�UW´#°�<%Qv=oACL�<%GCGJVÔ°�´�<%Q¨ACQ¨¹%³�IBG °�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹ÁYo´�ÎvI¨ACY@´�D*=@?¨´°�<n=MLM?¨AJQB¹�D>´�Y ® ATL)´^=@² º ´/Da=oY@²EQ¨¹RGCV!ACQE=o´#YoY@´�GC<%=@´�S�µB<RY>=oACL#I¨GT<%YoGJV�¶:AJ=@?*=o?¨´ L)GT<RDoD�²%³�D>´�Y>¾® ACL#´�D3´�QB< º GCACQ¨¹'D>´�°�<%Qv=@ATL�AJQv=@´�Y@²EµK´�Yo<%=@AC²RQ º ´#=a¶�´�´#Q�<%¹R´�Qv=oD�½Xà6´�SX´�D@L#Y@A º ´HD@´#GC´�L)=@´�S<%µBµ¨Y@²v<RLM?¨´�DH³�²RY*D>µO´�L#A{³�VWACQ¨¹k<RQBSÁ°�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹6L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=aVÁ<%QBSÔD@´#Y ® ACL#´'SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBD¶:AJ=@?�¹RA ® ´�Q"Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=MD3AJQ�°�²RYo´!SX´)=M<%ACG�AJQ�D@´�Lg=oAJ²EQ�ÑB½ Û¨½ ÜB½

V ,9W47�1;:B0�+X021U:S,9'*)�=;,9'*7�:B0�)�1�HZYPQ¨´�°�<%ACQk² º D>=o<RL#GJ´*²%³^<2°�´�<RQ¨ACQ¨¹%³�I¨G�ACQv=@´�Y@²EµK´�Yo<%¾=@AC²RQ�<%QKS'°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ2²R³ÂD>´�Y ® ATL)´�D�ATD�=@?¨´HD>VWQv=o<ELg=oACL�<%QBS"D>´�°�<%Qv=@ATL ?¨´#=@´�Y@²E¹R´#QB´#AJ=aV*²R³S¨<%=o<'<RQBS�ÄvQB²n¶:GJ´�SX¹R´H=o?¨´�°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=/S¨²v´�D/<EL#L)´�D@D/<%QBS�Yo´�L)´�A ® ´H³�Y@²E° °I¨GJ=@ACµ¨GJ´?¨´#=@´#Yo²R¹E´#Q¨´�²RIBD�<R¹R´�QE=MD#·nACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQ*D@VXDa=o´#°�D�<RQBS�D>²EI¨YoL#´�D�½%Ã3?¨´3³�I¨QBL)=@AC²RQB<RGBL#<RµB<n¾º ACGJAJ=aVH²%³B<R°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�=@²PY@´�D>²EG ® ´�D>IKLM?�Da=oY@IBL)=@I¨YM<%Gv<%QBS!D@´#°�<RQE=oACL�?¨´)=o´#Yo²R¹R´�Q¨´#AJ=@AC´�DYo´)³�´#YMD^=@²*=o?¨´!ÄWQ¨²n¶:GJ´�SX¹R´#¾ º <RD@´�S'µBY@²XL)´�D@D^²R³�D@´#°�<%Qv=oACL º Yo²RÄE´#YoAJQ¨¹�Ë Ü�[�Í�½

Page 4: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| \

]_^ 1�)�`a?b,-C93�,9c6>�7�.9,�CD'*,-+-)�1�+d02?e0�7�:B0�)�1f)g5ih;,d:j,9'*)*3�,91,902:�0�,d.9HE;(²ED>=�°*´#=@?¨²XS¨D�=@²HY@´�D>²EG ® ´D>´�°�<RQv=@ATL�?¨´#=@´�Y@²E¹R´#QB´#AJ=@AC´�D Yo´#GCV�²RQ6IBD>ACQ¨¹"µB<%Y@=@AT<%Gl²RY�¹RGC² º <RG²EQv=@²RGC²R¹EACL�<%G¸ÄWQ¨²n¶3¾GJ´�SX¹R´:¶:?¨ATLM?*°�<�V º ´ D@?B<%Yo´�S*<%°�²EQ¨¹/=o?¨´ <%¹E´#Qv=oD�½%Ã3?¨ATD�Y@´�ÎvI¨AJYo´�D�<�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv==@²�µ¨Y@² ® ATSX´�D@²R°�´�ÄvACQBS�²%³B²EQE=o²RGC²R¹EV�D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D�³�²RY�Da=M<n=@ATL#<RGJGCVH²RY�SXVWQB<%°�ATL#<RGJGCV�L)Yo´�<%¾=@ACQ¨¹B·KGJ²v<RSXACQ¨¹B·X°�<RQB<%¹EAJQ¨¹K·¨<%QBS�<%µBµ¨Y@²Eµ¨YoAC<%=@´#GCV'IBD@ACQ¨¹�¹RA ® ´#Q�SX²E°�<%ACQX¾�D@µO´�L)AJÈKL�²RYL)²R°�°�²RQ¨¾�D@´#QBD@´�²RQv=o²RGC²R¹RAC´�D!<ED�¶^´#GCG�<ED�ACQE=o´#Y@¾�²EQv=@²RGC²R¹EV�Y@´�GC<%=@AC²RQBD�¶:?¨´#QÔAJ=�µ¨Yo²%¾L)´�DoD@´�D�Yo´�ÎvI¨´�D>=oD�<RQBS�S¨<n=M<�³�Y@²E°ôSXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=�<%¹E´#Qv=oD�½n樲RY�´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R·�=o?¨´/<%¹EY@´�´�S�IBD>´²%³¸D>²E°�´/L)²E°*°�²EQ*°�´#=o<RSB<n=o<!L�<n=M<%GC²R¹RIB´ <%QBS�OP;kÊ�¾ º <RD@´�S*³�YM<%°�´#¶^²RYoÄXDlGJACÄR´/âPIX¾º GJACQkK�²RYo´P<RQBS"Ø/âPæ3ÏyUBÐ)Ë Ü%ÌEÍ�·XYo´�D@µK´�Lg=oA ® ´#GCVR·X<D>=o<RQBS¨<RYoSXACÓ#´�S'²EQE=o²RGC²R¹EV*´#¿¨LM?B<%Q¨¹E´GC<RQ¨¹RIB<R¹R´ÁÏBY8l�ÊÂÐD>IBLM?Ç<RD�OmY�Ê�Ë Ì�[�Í ²RYYP»aÊ�Ë Ü¨ÚMÍ/L#²RI¨GTS º ´�IBD@´�S º VÝSXAJãO´�Y@´�QE=<%¹R´�Qv=oD:ACQk<�°�IBG{=oAC<R¹R´#Qv=PD@VXDa=o´#° =@²'Yo´#µBY@´�D>´�QE=/<RQBS�´)¿¨LM?B<RQ¨¹R´!ACQBSXA ® ACSXIK<%G�²EQv=@²%¾GJ²E¹RATL#<%G�ÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�S¨¹R´�²%³Â¹EA ® ´#Q�SX²R°�<RAJQBD�½Ã3?¨´*=@YM<%QBD>³�²RYo°�<n=@AC²RQ6AJQv=o²�<�I¨Q¨AJÈB´�SkÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´Yo´#µBY@´�D>´�QE=M<n=oAJ²EQkD>IBµ¨µK²EY>=MD�=@?¨´°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=!=@²ÆÏy<EÐHI¨QKSX´#YMDa=M<%QBSk=@?B´'D>´�°�<RQv=@ATL#D!²R³^Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=MD!<%QBSÕ<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD>´�SL#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=aV�²EY�D>´�Y ® ATL)´:SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBD�AJ=�Yo´�L#´#A ® ´�D³�Yo²R°£?¨´)=o´#Yo²R¹R´�Q¨´#²EIBD�<%¹E´#Qv=oD�<%QKSÏ º Ð/=@²�Yo´�L)²EQBL)ACGC´SXATD@L#² ® ´�Y@´�S�D>´�°�<RQv=@ATL�?¨´#=@´�Y@²E¹R´#QB´#AJ=@AC´�D�½OÃ3?¨´=aVWµK´*²%³^<%µ¨µ¨GCATL#<n¾=@AC²RQÁ<%QBS6°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ6²R³�=@?B´*°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=o´�S6SX´)=o´#Yo°*ACQ¨´�DH¶:?¨ACLM?ÕÄWAJQKS²%³�²EQv=@²RGC²R¹EV�<%QBS6Y@´�L)²EQBL)ACGJAT<n=oAJ²EQkD@´#Y ® ATL)´*ATDP°�²vDa=�<%µBµ¨Y@²Eµ¨YoAC<%=@´R½ ­ L)²E°*µBY@´�?¨´#QX¾D>A ® ´'D@I¨Y ® ´#Vk²%³3°*´#=@?¨²XS¨D�<%QBS6=@´�LM?¨Q¨ATÎvI¨´�DH³�²EY�ÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´)¾ º <RD@´�SkY@´�D>²EGJIX=oAJ²EQ6²R³SXA{ã¼´#Yo´#Qv=:=aVWµO´�D:²R³Â?¨´#=@´#Yo²R¹E´#Q¨´�A{=oAJ´�D:L#<RQ º ´H³�²RI¨QKS�·X³�²RY:´#¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R·XACQÁËJÚRÚ)Í�½

]_n 1;:j,S3o'�7�:B0�)�1p)g5q021�5d)o'/WX7o:�0�)o1H ­ °�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=°�<�VÆL)Yo´�<n=o´"<RQBSÆ°�<%ACQv=o<%ACQÝ<RQAJQv=@´�¹RYM<n=o´�S�µB<RY>=oAC<RGJGCV�¹RGC² º <RG ® AC´#¶þ²EQk< ® <%ACGC< º GJ´�AJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ�³�²EYPACQv=@´#YoQB<RGµ¨Yo²%¾L)´�DoD@AJQ¨¹Á<%QKSÝYo´�D>=@YoACL)=@´�SÔACQBD>µO´�L)=@AC²RQ º VƲ%=o?¨´#Y'<R¹R´#Qv=MD*<RQBSÔIKD>´�YoD*²RQÇSX´�°�<RQBS�½UWIBLM?(<%Q�ACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQ�°*²XSX´�GlL�<%Q¸·¨³�²RY/´#¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R·X=M<%ÄR´�=@?¨´�D>=o<%=@ATLH³�²RYo°ë²%³�<*³�´)¾SX´#YM<n=o´�S(DoLM?¨´#°�<�ACQ6<�°I¨GJ=@ATS¨<n=M< º <ED>´�D@VXDa=o´#° Ë Ü�M�Í�²RYP<"SXVWQB<%°�ATL#<RGJGCV"IBµOS¨<%=@´�S<%QBS"L#<n=o´#¹E²RYoAJÓ�´�S�L)²EGJGC´�L)=@AC²RQ'²R³ÂL#<RµB< º AJGCA{=aV�<RQBS'D@´#Y ® ATL)´�SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBD^<%QBQ¨²%=M<n=@´�S¶:A{=o?*Yo´#GC´ ® <RQE=�²RQv=o²RGC²R¹RATL#<RGEACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQ¸½nÃ3?¨´3GC<%=>=o´#Y�L#<RQ º ´:Da=o²RYo´�S�·n°�<%ACQv=o<RAJQ¨´�S<%QBS�ÎvI¨´#YoAC´�S"GJACÄR´HACQRO�;(Ê�¾ º <ED>´�S"S¨<%=o<*¶3<%Yo´#?¨²EIBD>´�D#½rk7�1�793�,dW4,d1U:s)65PC%7o:S7�7�1�Cmto1)o`(?u,�C�3�,"H�I3<RD@ACL�ACQE=o´#YoQB<%G¨D@´#Y ® ACL#´�Dl²%³K=@?¨´:°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾

<%¹E´#Qv=!AJQKL)GCIBSX´�=@?B´�´)À'L)AC´#Qv=�D>=@²RYM<%¹E´*<RQBS6°�<RQB<%¹E´#°�´#Qv=!²%³:S¨<%=o<�<%QBSÕÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´< º ²RI¨=PAJ=oD@´#GJ³�<%QBS(²%=@?B´#YP<R¹R´�QE=MD#½¼UWIBLM?kSB<n=o<2<%Yo´R·¨³�²EYP´#¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R·KD@´)=MD/²R³�L#<RµB< º ACGCA{=aV<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD@´#°�´#Qv=oD�²%³¼Y@´�¹RATDa=o´#Yo´�S�Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�·nµB<RD>=�<%QKS�L)I¨YoY@´�Qv=�Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=oD�²R³OÄWQ¨²n¶:Q�Ø3¾<%¹E´#Qv=oD�·W²RQv=@²EGJ²E¹RATL#<RGBÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´�D@?B<%Yo´�S"<%°�²RQB¹<%¹E´#Qv=oD3<RQBS'²R=@?¨´�Y3<RIX¿XAJGCAT<%YoV'S¨<n=M<³�²RY^ACQE=o´#YoQB<%GKµ¨Yo²WL#´�DoD>ACQ¨¹K½EÃ3?¨´�L)²RYoYo´�D@µK²EQBSXACQ¨¹�S¨<n=M< º <ED>´�D#·EY@´�µK²vD>AJ=@²EY@AC´�D�<%QBS�ÄWQ¨²n¶3¾GC´�SX¹E´ º <RD@´P²R³Â<*°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=3°�<�V º ´HAJQKD>µO´�L)=@´�S º V'²%=o?¨´#Y:<R¹R´#Qv=MD�<RQBS2IKD>´�YoD�³�²RYSXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=�µ¨I¨YoµK²vD>´�D�D@IBLM?Æ<RD�·O³�²RY!´#¿X<R°�µ¨GJ´E·¼=@?¨´'D@µO´�L)AJÈKL�<n=@AC²RQÕ²%³3<%µ¨µBY@²Eµ¨Y@AT<n=o´Yo´)¾ÎvI¨´�D>=oD^ACQ2=o?¨´!SX²R°�<RAJQ"²RY^°*²EQ¨AJ=@²RYoACQ¨¹*<ELg=oA ® AJ=@AC´�D3<RL�L)²RYMSXACQ¨¹!=o²¹EA ® ´#Q ® <RGJATS2<EL#L)´�D@DYo´�D>=@YoACL)=@AC²RQBD:<RQBS"D@´�L#I¨YoA{=aV'µO²RGCATL)AC´�D�½

vw0x.-:B'/0�>9y :S,-Cz9y;,9'/A�='*)"+-,/.-./021�3{7o1C:�'*7o1G.97%+9:B0�)�1G.9HK»fQ(D@²R°�´�L#<ED>´�D^=@?¨´�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾<%¹E´#Qv=H?B<RD/=@²�µ¨IX=H³�²RYo¶3<%YMS(ÎvI¨´#YoAJ´�D =o²"°I¨GJ=@ACµ¨GJ´�Yo´#GC´ ® <%Qv=�´)¿W=@´�Y@QB<RGlSB<n=o< º <RD@´�DP²RY²%=o?¨´#Y:D@²RI¨YML)´�D�=o²¹v<n=o?¨´#Y3ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=@AC²RQ2²RQ º ´#?K<%GJ³Â²%³lA{=MD^Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=@´#YMD�½vÃ3?¨ATD3Yo´�ÎvI¨ACY@´�D=@?B´6°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv='=@²¯µK´�Y>³�²EY@° SXATDa=oY@A º IX=o´�S ÎvI¨´�Y@Vǵ¨GT<%QBQ¨AJQB¹¯<%QKSÇ´)¿X´�L#IX=@AC²RQ ²R³

Page 5: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

� ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

=@YM<%QKD@<ELg=@AC²RQKD�ACQ�L)²EGJGT< º ²RYM<n=oAJ²EQ2¶:AJ=@?�Y@´�D>µO´�L)=@A ® ´!D@VWD>=@´�°�D:<%QBS�<%¹E´#Qv=oD�½

| �L�U� ÿlý��Z� �ý � � �U��� �Wÿlý�� �ý � �}��� �#� ý�$����Rù Ã3?¨´L#²v²EYoS¨AJQB<%=@AC²RQ�²%³�°�´�SXAC<%=@AC²RQ º V<H°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=�Yo´�ÎvI¨ACY@´�D�AJQ�µK<%Y@=@ATL)I¨GT<%Y�AJ=oD�< º ACGJAJ=aV�=o²!°*´�<%Q¨ACQ¨¹R³�I¨GJGCVL#²R°�°�IBQ¨ACL�<n=o´¶:AJ=@? <R¹R´�QE=MD#·3D@VWD>=@´�°�D#·3<%QBS IBD>´�YoD"¶:?¨ATLM? <RY@´(ACQ ® ²EG ® ´�SÇACQ =@?B´6² ® ´#YM<%GCG/°�´�SXAT<n¾=@AC²RQ µ¨Y@²XL#´�DoD'<RL�L)²RYMSXACQ¨¹Õ=@²¯¹RA ® ´#Qǵ¨Yo²%=o²XL)²RGTD�·�L)²EQ ® ´#Qv=@AC²RQKD#·�<RQBSǵO²RGCACL#AJ´�D#½ ­ D�<º <ED>ATL:<RS¨S¨A{=oAJ²EQB<%GX°�´�<RQBD�<R¹R´#Qv=�QB<R°*ACQ¨¹�<RQBS*Y@´�¹RATDa=oYo<%=@AC²RQ�ATD�Q¨´�´�SX´�S=@²!´#QK< º GC´3=@?¨´°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=�=@²�GC²XL#<n=o´*<RQBS(ATSX´�QE=oA{³�VkA{=MDHµ¨Y@² ® ATSX´#YMD�<%QBSkY@´�ÎEIB´�D>=@´#YMDP¶:A{=o?¨AJQÁ<%QKS<RL#Y@²vD@D^°I¨G{=oAJµBGJ´�<R¹R´#Qv= D@²WL#AJ´#=@AC´�D�½

~ 3�,91;:L'�,B3%0x./:�'�7�:B0�)�1R7o1C�17�W�021�3�HEʸ²XL#<%=@AC²RQ�²R³KYo´#GC´ ® <%Qv=�<%¹E´#Qv=oD º V!=@?B´^°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾<%¹E´#Qv=/µ¨Yo´�D@I¨°�´�D =@?B<%=PAJ=oD�L)GCAJ´�Qv=oD�<%Yo´!Y@´�¹RATDa=o´#Yo´�S�<%QBSkL#<%Q º ´�QK<%°�´�S(<%=�<RQvV�ACQBDa¾=o<RQv=�Å�=@?¨ATDlAJ°�µ¨GCAC´�D�IX=oAJGCAJÓ�<n=oAJ²EQ�²%³ º <RD@ACL^D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D¸²%³O<%¹R´�Qv=ÂYo´#¹RATD>=@YM<n=@AC²RQ�<RQBS�QK<%°�AJQB¹³�²RY!´#¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´�<R¹R´�QE=HQB<R°*´'D@´#Y ® ´�YoDP¶:AJ=@?¨ACQÕ=@?¨´�Q¨´#=a¶�²EY@Ä�SX²E°�<%ACQÕL#² ® ´#Yo´�S º V�=@?¨´°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=�½�Ø:´#¹v<%YMSXACQ¨¹ÕDoL#<RGC< º ACGJAJ=aVÆ=@?B´�°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�°�<�VÝ<%GTD>²Á?B< ® ´2=o² º ´< º GJ´*=@²�SXVWQB<R°�ACL�<%GCGJV(L#Y@²vD@D�Yo´#¹RATD>=@´#YH<%¹E´#Qv=!L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D�³�Yo²R°é²EQ¨´�<%¹E´#Qv=HD@²XL)AC´)=aV=@²�<%QB²%=@?B´#Y!D>²�<RDP=@²�°�<%ACQv=o<%ACQk°�<%¿WAC°�IB°.<RL#L#´�DoD>A º ACGJAJ=aV�²%³�ACQ ® ²EG ® ´�S(D@²XL)AC´)=@AC´�D/=@²´�<ELM?�²%=o?¨´#Y"Q D�L#<RµB< º ACGCA{=oAJ´�D#½vØ3¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD�¶:AJ=@?¨ACQ2²EQ¨´/<%¹E´#Qv=�D@²WL#AJ´#=aV°�<�V º ´�Q¨´)ÈB=�³�Yo²R°D@´#Y ® ATL)´�DÂ<RQBS�SB<n=o<Pµ¨Yo² ® ACSX´�S º V�Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�AJQ�<%Q¨²R=@?¨´�Y²EQ¨´^¶:A{=o?¨²RIX= º ´#ACQ¨¹H<�¶^<RY@´�²R³=@?B´H³×<RLg=3=o?B<n=:´�<ELM?2²R³�=@?B´#° º ´#GC²RQB¹=o²�<SXAJã¼´#Yo´#Qv=:°�I¨GJ=@AT<%¹E´#Qv= D>VXD>=@´#°�½¨Ã3?¨ATD:L#<RQº ´H<ELM?¨AC´ ® ´�S º V*=@?¨´H°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=^¶:?¨ATLM?2ATD�ACQ¨AJ=@AT<%GCGJV'L#²RQv=o<ELg=o´�S º V�=@?B´HØ:¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MDº V'´)¿Xµ¨GC²RAJ=@ACQ¨¹*A{=MD:D>´�°�<%Qv=@ATL/ACQv=@´�Y@²EµK´�Yo<%=@AC²RQ2D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D3<%QBS"<%µ¨µBY@²Eµ¨Y@AT<n=o´PL#²RGCGC< º ²EYo<%¾=@AC²RQ¶:A{=o?�Yo´#GC´ ® <%Qv=°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�²%³B<%QKS!AJQv=o´#Yo²RµO´#YM<n=@²EYoD º ´#=a¶�´�´#Q�?¨´#=@´�Y@²E¹R´#QB´#²RIKD<%¹E´#Qv= D>²XL#AJ´#=@AC´�D!ËJÚ�Ü�Í�½

n 1U:S,9'/c6793�,91;:�021;:j,d'�7%+9:�0�)o1G.9H ­ QWVHL)²W²RYMSXACQB<n=o´�S�ACQE=o´#YM<RL)=@AC²RQ º ´)=a¶^´#´#QH=o?¨´�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾<%¹E´#Qv=�·:Yo´#¹EACD>=@´�Y@´�S Ø3¾6TnÖ�¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD"<RQBS-²%=o?¨´#Y�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oD º <RD@ATL#<%GCGCV Y@´�GJAC´�D�²EQ=@?B´<%¹EY@´�´�S"IBD@´�²%³�²RQB´�²RY °�²EY@´�D>=o<RQBS¨<RYoSXACÓ#´�S�<%¹R´�Qv=/L)²R°�°I¨Q¨ATL#<n=oAJ²EQ�GC<RQ¨¹RIB<R¹R´�DÏ ­ K^ÊlÐ:GCAJÄE´�æl»aÖ ­þ­ K^ÊƲRYPF���;(Ê�·¨¹RA ® ´�Q(L)²EQ ® ´#YMD@<%=@AC²RQ"µ¨Y@²R=@²XL)²EGCD�·B<RQBS�µK²EGJATL)AC´�DË Û%Ü�Í�½¼»fQ6L)²E°�°�I¨Q¨ATL#<%=@ACQ¨¹'ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQk<%°�²RQB¹"SXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=�<%¹E´#Qv=oDPAJ=PATDP´�D@D@´#Qv=oAC<RG¸=@²µ¨Yo´�D@´#Y ® ´H=o?¨´SX´�D>ACYo´�S�D@´#°�<%Qv=@ATL#D ²%³�IX=@=@´#YM<%QKL)´�D =@YM<%QBD@°�A{=@=@´�S ® AT<�°�´�DoDo<%¹R´�D:²%³�<RQ­ K^Ê�½ZI^²%=@?Á=o?¨´2ACQv=@´�QE=oAJ²EQƲ%³3=@?B´'°�´�DoD@<R¹R´'<RD�¶�´�GJG^<RD!AJ=oD*S¨<n=M<�L)²EQE=o´#Qv=�?B<EDH=@²º ´*IBQBSX´#YMD>=@²W²XS(L)²EY@Yo´�L)=@GCV º V�=@?B´°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=�<%QKS(AJ=oDHL)GCAJ´�Qv=oD/=@²�µK´�Y>³�²EY@°é<%QKSD@I¨µ¨µO²RY@= Y@´�ÎEIBAJYo´�S"D>´�Y ® ATL)´H°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ¸·XY@´�D>µO´�L)=@A ® ´�GJVE½

~ +�+-,d.-.-021�3m.9)�y '*+-,d.()g5�C%7o:S7F7o1C8021"5d)�'/W47�:B0�)�1H%»fQ�L#<ED>´�=o?¨´�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�?B<ED�=@²<RL�L)´�D@D^S¨<n=M< º <ED>´�D>VXD>=@´�°�D�·vÄvQB²n¶:GJ´�SX¹R´ º <RD@´�D�²RY^²%=o?¨´#Y:D@²RI¨YML)´�D�²%³ÂAJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ º VAJ=oD@´#GJ³lAJ=/L#<RQ�SX²�D@²�´#AJ=@?¨´�Y ® AT<�Da=M<%QBSB<%YMSXAJÓ�´�S ­ Ö�»aD3²EY3=@YM<%QBD@µB<RY@´�QE=3Yo´#°�²%=o´�<EL#L)´�D@D°�´)=o?¨²XS¨D'D@IBLM?á<RD4�vâmI�K�T%Y�â8I�KP·iY�FFI�K�Ë ÜvÛ�Í�·��v< ® <6Ø/;�»g·�<%QKS}K�Y�ØPI ­ ·�Y@´�Da¾µO´�Lg=oA ® ´#GCVR½W»fQ"<SXAJãO´�Y@´�QE=3<%µ¨µBY@²v<RLM?�=@?B´P°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=�°�<�V*Yo´)=oY@AC´ ® ´:=@?B´PYo´�ÎvI¨ACY@´�SS¨<%=o<*AJQ�L#²RGCGC< º ²EYo<%=@AC²RQ2¶:AJ=@?�D@²%¾fL#<RGJGC´�S2¶:Yo<Rµ¨µK´�Y:<%¹R´�Qv=oD^¶:?¨ATLM?�<RY@´�´#QKL#<%µKD>I¨GT<n=oAJQB¹=@?B´6Yo´#GC´ ® <%Qv=�D>VXD>=@´#°�D�<%QBS D>²EI¨YoL#´�D�½�Ã3?¨´Õ°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=2³�²RYo¶^<RYoS¨D"<%µ¨µBY@²Eµ¨Y@AT<n=o´D@I º ÎvI¨´�Y@AC´�D =@²2=@?¨´¶:Yo<Rµ¨µK´�YoD ´�<RLM?�²R³�¶:?¨ATLM?�=@YM<%QBD>³�²RYo°�AJQ¨¹�=o?¨´�Yo´�L#´#A ® ´�S�Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>==@²6<(ÎvI¨´#YoV6ACQÁ=@?B´2µ¨Yo²Rµ¨YoAC´)=o<RY@V6ÎEIB´#YoVkGT<%Q¨¹EIB<%¹E´�²%³3=@?¨´"µB<%Y@=@ATL)IBGC<RY�D>VXD>=@´#° <%QKS

Page 6: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| �

Yo´)=@IBY@QBD^=o?¨´HY@´�D>IBG{=:²%³lA{=MD3´)¿X´�L#IX=@AC²RQ�ACQ2=o?¨´�SX´�D@ACY@´�S�³�²RYo°�<n=3=@²=@?B´!°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�½Ã3?¨´"°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=!=@?B´#QÔ?B<ED!=o²(°�´#Yo¹R´2<RGJG�²%³3=@?¨´�D>´2µB<%Y@=@AT<%G�Y@´�D>I¨GJ=oD!³�²RY�³�IBY>=o?¨´#Yµ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD@AJQ¨¹K½OUWIKLM?6<2DoL)´�QB<%YoAC²�ACD�ACQkL)²E°*µBGJAT<%QBL#´�¶:AJ=@?k=@?¨´µB<%YM<RSXAC¹R°ë²%³^<'°�´�SXAT<n¾=@²EYl³�²RY�AJQv=o´#GCGJAC¹R´�QE=�ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=@AC²RQ*D>VXD>=@´�°�DlACQv=@Yo²WS¨IBL)´�S º V!àáAJ´�SX´#Yo?¨²EGCSAJQ"Ú����EÛ�Ë ÌEÜnÍ�½

n 1U:S,9'�5d7%+9021�3�`�02:2hXy�.d,9'-.9H�»fQ�<ES¨SXAJ=@AC²RQ�=o² =o?¨´�Yo´�ÎvI¨ACYo´#°�´#Qv=²R³B</°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=¸=@²<%µBµ¨Y@²Eµ¨YoAC<%=@´#GCV�L)²R°�°I¨Q¨ATL#<n=o´ ¶:AJ=@?2AJ=oD^L)GCAC´#Qv=oD^<%QBS'Y@´�GJ´ ® <RQv=�D>VXD>=@´�°�D�·vA{=^°�<�V�<%GTD@²µ¨Yo² ® ACSX´�ACQv=@´�Y>³×<EL)´�D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D�=@²(?WI¨°�<%QÁIBD@´#YMDH=o²�GJ´#=�=@?¨´�°�·¸³�²RY�´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R· º Y@²n¶ D@´< ® <%ACGC< º GC´�ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=@AC²RQ(=@?¨´�V(<%Yo´�ACQE=o´#Yo´�D>=@´�S(ACQ6D@IBLM?6<ED/µB<RY>=MD/²R³�<'GC²XL#<RG�S¨²R°�<%ACQ²RY�D@?B<%Yo´�SݹRGC² º <RG�²EQv=@²RGC²R¹EVR·�D>´#=oD�²R³P<RL)=@IB<RG3D@´#Y ® ACL#´�S¨´�DoL)YoAJµX=oAJ²EQBD�·l²EY�Y@´�¹RATDa=o´#Yo´�SD@´#Y ® ATL)´Hµ¨Yo² ® ACS¨´#YMD#½¨Ã3?¨´�D>´!ACQv=@´�Y>³×<EL)´!D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D3?B< ® ´�=@² º ´!Yo´�D>=@YoACL)=@´�S�<EL#L)²EYoS¨AJQ¨¹=@²¹RA ® ´�Q�D@´�L#I¨YoA{=aV'µO²RGCATL)AC´�D:<%QKS"Yo´�ÎvI¨ACYo´#°�´#Qv=oD�½

rk,-C�0�7�:B0�)�1q=�'*)�:j)�+-)o?N.D7�1�C�=;)�?@0�+90�,d.dH ­ QWV"<RL)=@A ® A{=oAJ´�D:Y@´�GC<%=@´�S2=o²'D>´�Y ® ATL)´H°�´�SXAT<n¾=@AC²RQk¶:A{=o?¨AJQ6<%Q(<%¹E´#Qv=/D@²WL#AJ´#=aV�L�<%Q º ´�²RYo¹E<RQ¨ACÓ#´�S�<RQBS�L)²W²RYMSXACQB<n=o´�S�<RL�L)²EYoSXACQ¨¹*=@²¹RA ® ´�Q'µ¨Yo²%=o²WL#²RGTD#·WL)²EQ ® ´#Qv=oAJ²EQBD#·v<%QBS2µK²EGJATL)AC´�D^²R³¸AJQv=@´�Yo<ELg=oAJ²EQ º ´#=a¶�´�´#Q�<%¹R´�Qv=oD�½vÃ3?¨´°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE= º V�SX´#ÈBQ¨AJ=@AC²RQ�µ¨GT<�VWD�<HL)´�Qv=@YM<%GWY@²EGJ´^²%³OAJQBA{=oAC<RGJACÓ#ACQ¨¹!<%QBS*L)²W²EYoSXACQB<%=@ACQ¨¹=@?B´ACQv=@´#YM<RL)=@AC²RQk<R°�²RQ¨¹�<%¹R´�Qv=oDPAJQÕL)²RGCGT< º ²RYM<n=@A ® ´!²EY�L#²R°�µO´)=@AJ=@A ® ´�D@´)=>=oAJQB¹ED�½O;�²vDa=L)²E°�°*²EQ�³�²RYo°�D:²%³�°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ�µ¨Yo²%=@²XL#²RGTD3AJQBL#GJIKSX´�°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄWACQ¨¹B· º Y@²EÄR´#YoACQ¨¹B·X<%QKS<%Y º AJ=@YM<n=oAJ²EQ2ACQ�QB´#¹R²R=@AT<n=oAJ²EQBD º ´#=a¶�´�´#Q�Ö�¾�<RQBS"Ø:¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD#·v³�²RY:´#¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R·¨<n= ® ACY>=oIB<%G°�<%YoÄR´#=@µ¨GT<RL#´�D�²EY�<RIBLg=oAJ²EQBD#½vÃ3?¨´/¹E´#Q¨´�Yo<RGBµ¨Yo²%=o²XL)²RGTD�³�²EY º Yo²RÄE´#YoAJQB¹�<%QBS�°�<%=oLM?¨°�<n¾ÄWAJQB¹'<%Yo´�SX´�D@L#Y@A º ´�S�AJQ�D@´�Lg=oAJ²EQ�Ѩ½uÛX½ Ü º ´#GC²n¶!½

� ���yý�� ��ý��yý� -� ��i� �vÿlý��G �ý � ��ù l�<ELM?�L#GJAC´#Qv=^Y@´�ÎEIBAJYo´�D�=@?¨´�L)²RQv=M<RLg=o´�S�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv==@² º ´Yo´#GCAC< º GC´ACQ(=o´#Yo°�DP²%³�=@YoIBDa=!<%QKSkÎvIB<%GCAJ=aV�²R³�D@´#Y ® ATL)´E½OÃ3?K<n=H°*´�<%QBDP=o?B<n=�=@?¨´°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=HD>?B²RI¨GTS�µO´#Y@³�²RYo°ëAJ=oDHSX´�D>AC¹RQK<n=@´�S�°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQkD@´#Y ® ATL)´�D/<%=�<%QWV�¹RA ® ´�QACQBDa=M<%Qv=PACQ6<'=@YoIBD>=a¶�²EY>=o?vV"°�<%Q¨Q¨´�Y�<RQBS�ACQkL)²E°�µ¨GJAT<%QKL)´�¶:AJ=@?6¹RA ® ´�Q(D>´�L)I¨YoA{=aV�<%QKSÎvIB<%GCAJ=aVPµO²RGCACL#AJ´�D¸²R³WACQBSXA ® ACS¨IB<%Gv<%¹R´�Qv=oD�²EY¸=@?B´�L)²EQBD>ATSX´�Y@´�S�<R¹R´�QE=lD>²XL)AC´)=aV�<RDÂ<:¶:?¨²RGC´R½Ã3?¨ATD�µK<%Y@=@ATL)I¨GT<%YoGJVY@´�ÎvI¨AJYo´�D�=@?¨´ °�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�=@²L)²RµO´ ¶:AJ=@?2S¨A{ã¼´#Yo´#Qv=�ÄWACQBS�²%³¸µO²%¾GCACL#AJ´�D:AJQ�<�L)²E?¨´#Yo´#Qv=:<%QBS�L#²RQBD@ACD>=@´�Qv=3°�<RQ¨Q¨´#Y�½

� y;7�?@02:BA�)g5w.d,9'/E"0�+�,"H ­ °�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=P?B<ED =o²�<ED@D@I¨Yo´!=@?B<%=H=@?¨´�S¨<n=M<'AJ=HD>=@²EY@´�D#·µ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD@´�D^<%QBS�µBY@² ® ATSX´�D�=@²�=@?¨´!<%¹E´#Qv=oD�AJQ2=@?¨´!D@²XL)AC´)=aV�L)²E°*µBGJV�¶:AJ=@?"S¨´�D@AJYo´�S"S¨<n=M<ÎvIB<%GCAJ=aV�Y@´�ÎEIBAJYo´#°�´#Qv=MD#·¼Da=M<%QBSB<%YMS¨D#·¼<%QKS(µO²RGCACL#AJ´�D#½�»fQk=@?¨ATD!L)²EQE=o´)¿W=�SB<n=o<"µO²RGCACL#V�ACD=@?B´!² ® ´#YM<%GCGOAJQv=@´�Qv=@AC²RQ�<%QBS�SXACY@´�Lg=oAJ²EQ"²R³�<RQ�<R¹R´#Qv=3¶:A{=o?�Y@´�D>µO´�L)=^=o²�ACDoD@I¨´�D:L#²RQBL#´#Y@¾Q¨ACQ¨¹�=@?B´�ÎvIB<%GCA{=aV2²%³�S¨<n=M<�µ¨Y@²XSXIKLg=oD:<RQBS�D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D3A{= ¶:ACGJGÂY@´�L)´�A ® ´P´�A{=o?¨´#Y:³�Yo²R° =@?¨´°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=^²RY�=@?¨´HYo´�D@µK´�Lg=oA ® ´PÖ�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�½EÃ3?B´�D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQ¸·v°�<%QB<R¹R´�°*´�Qv=^<%QKS´ ® <RGJIB<%=@AC²RQ�²%³�ÎvIB<%GCAJ=aV�²%³¼°�´�SXAT<n=o´�S�S¨<%=o<!<RQBS�D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D�°�<�V�³�²RGCGJ²n¶ÉL)²RYoYo´�D@µK²EQBSXACQ¨¹°�´)=o?¨²XS¨D#·nD>=o<RQBS¨<%YMS¨D¸<RQBS!°�´)=oY@ATL#D�IBD@´�SH³�²EYlS¨<%=o<:¶3<%Yo´#?B²RIBD@´�ÎvIB<%GCA{=aV�°�<%QB<R¹R´�°*´�Qv=ËJÚ�Ñ�ÍÂ<RQBS�D>²R³�=a¶^<RY@´PAJ°�µ¨GC´#°�´�QE=M<n=oAJ²EQ�ÎvIB<RGJAJ=aV2D@IBLM?�<RD^=@?B´!»>U;Y��BÚ�Û%[�D>=o<%QKS¨<%YMS�½Ø:´�¹E<%YMSXACQ¨¹�=o?¨´IKD@<R¹R´�²R³�°�´�SXAT<n=o´�S6D>´�Y ® ATL)´�DP<%QBS6S¨<n=M<¨·¼L)²E°*°�²EQ6ÎvIB<%GCAJ=aV�Yo´)¾

ÎvI¨ACY@´�°*´�Qv=oD <RY@´P=@?B<%=:=@?¨´�V"<RY@´!<RL�L)´�D@D@A º GJ´!<%QKS2IBD@´)³�IBG�=@²�=o?¨´�<%¹E´#Qv=oD3ACQ�=@´#Yo°�D3²%³a·³�²RY�´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R·%D@´�L#I¨Y@´:< ® <%ACGT< º ACGJAJ=aVR·nACQv=@´�Y@µ¨Yo´)=M< º ACGCA{=aV�<RQBS�=@AC°*´�GJACQ¨´�D@D�ACQ�²RYMSX´#Y�=o²!SX´)¾=@´�Lg=:LM?B<%QB¹R´�D�<%QBS2Y@´�<RD@²RQBD�³�²RY�=@?¨´�°�½;Y/=o?¨´#Y3ÎvIB<%GCA{=aV*³×<ELg=@²EYoD�AJQKL)GCIBSX´HL)²RYoYo´�Lg=oQ¨´�DoD�·

Page 7: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

L)²E°�µ¨GJ´#=@´�Q¨´�DoD#·ÂL)²RQKD>ATDa=o´#QBL#VR·¸<RQBSkYo´�S¨I¨QBS¨<RQBL)V(²R³3SB<n=o<�<EDH¶�´�GJG�<ED�³�I¨QBL)=@AC²RQB<RGJAJ=aVR·´)À'L#AJ´�QBL)VE·E°�<%ACQv=o<RAJQB< º ACGJAJ=aV�<%QBS�µO²RY@=o< º ACGJAJ=aV²R³�=@?¨´�AC°*µBGJ´�°*´�Qv=o<n=oAJ²EQ'²%³¸°�´�SXAC<%=@´�SD@´#Y ® ATL)´�D#½�Ê�<%=>=o´#Y*³×<RL)=@²RYMDµB<%Y@=@ATL)I¨GT<%YoGCVÁ<RGCD@²6L#²RQBL#´#YoQÆ=@?B´�ÎvIB<RGJAJ=aVƲ%³/=@?¨´�°�´�SXAT<n¾=@AC²RQ�D@´#Y ® ATL)´�D�²R³�=o?¨´H°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=3A{=MD>´�G{³a½¨æB²RY3´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R·W=o?¨´Hµ¨Yo² ® ATSX´�S�°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQD@?¨²RI¨GTS º ´P<RL�L)I¨YM<n=o´R·n³×<RI¨GJ=>¾�=@²RGC´#YM<%Qv=�=o²�µK²R=@´�QE=oAC<RGKD@´#Y ® ACL#´3³×<%ACGJI¨Yo´�D�·R<ES¨<%µX=oA ® ´R·R=@AC°*´<%QKS6Yo´�D@²RIBYoL#´´#À�L#AJ´�Qv=�·�<RQBSÁDa=M< º GC´R½¸»�=�<RGCD@²�Y@´�ÎvI¨AJYo´�DP=o?¨´�°�ACS¨S¨GJ´#¾�<R¹R´#Qv=!=o²�¹EIB<n¾YM<%Qv=@´�´�<R¹E<RAJQBD>=!GJ²vD@DH²R³3SB<n=o<�²EY!Y@´ ® ´#QWI¨´�<ED!<"Yo´�D@I¨GJ=�²%³^A{=MD!°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQÕ¶:?BACLM?ÁACQ=@IBY@Q¸·B°�<�V2AJQBL#Y@´�<RD@´/=o?¨´!GC´ ® ´�G�²%³l=@YoIBD>= AJQ�A{=MD:°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ�D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D�½

�G'/y�.-:iWX7o17�3�,9WX,91;:jHI^´�D@ACSX´�D3=@?B´�L)GCAJ´�Qv=>¾fD>ATSX´�S�SX´�°�<%QBS"=@²�=o?¨´�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=²%³ µBY@² ® ATSXAJQB¹kÎvIB<%GCA{=aVÁ²R³:D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D�=@?¨´�Y@´"ACD*<%GTD>²(=@?¨´"´�DoD>´�QE=oAC<RG�Yo´�ÎvI¨ACY@´�°�´#Qv=²R³/<°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=*=@² º ´#?B< ® ´2ACQ¯<k=@YoIBDa=a¶^²RY@=@?WVÕ°�<%Q¨Q¨´�Y*=@²ÕA{=MD*L#GJAC´#Qv=MDACQÔ=o´#Yo°�D²R³¹RIK<%YM<%Qv=@´�´#ACQ¨¹ÝSX´�D>ACY@´�S S¨<%=o<¯µ¨Y@A ® <RL#VR·3<%Q¨²EQvVW°�AJ=aVR·3<%QBS ® ´#YoA{ÈOL#<n=oAJ²EQ ²%³�L#GC<RAJ°�´�S<%¹E´#Qv='L#<RµB< º ACGCA{=oAJ´�D(Ë Ì��W·�Û�M�Í�½�»fQ¯=o?¨ATD2D@´#QBD@´R·�<Á°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=�<ELg=MD�<RD'<6=@YoIBD>=@´�SACQE=o´#Yo°�´�SXAT<%YoV"<R°*²EQ¨¹�=o?¨´�<%¹E´#Qv=oD/²%³�=@?B´�L)²EQBD>ATSX´�Y@´�S�<%¹R´�Qv=/D>²XL)AC´)=aV�<RL�L)²EYoSXACQ¨¹*=@²¹RA ® ´�Q2=oY@IKDa= µO²RGCACL#AJ´�D3²%³�AJQKSXA ® ATSXIB<RG¸<%¹R´�Qv=oD:<%QKS'=o?¨´!¶:?¨²RGC´!D>²XL#AJ´#=aVR½

I^²%=o?'AJQv=o´#YoQB<%G¼S¨<n=M<�<RQBS�ÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´ ²%³a·W<%QBS�=@?¨´HL)²E°*µBIX=o<%=@AC²RQB<RGBµ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD@´�D�²R³°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQÔ´)¿X´�L)IX=o´�S º V6=@?¨´"°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=D@?¨²RIBGCS º ´2Yo² º IKDa=�<%¹E<RAJQKDa=�´#¿v=o´#YoQB<%G°�<%Q¨ACµ¨I¨GT<n=oAJ²EQ"²EY:<n=>=M<RLMÄXD^²%³l°�<RGJATL)AC²RIKD:<%¹R´�Qv=oD�·WD@VXDa=o´#°�D�·v²EY3IBD>´�YoD�½UYPQ'=o?¨´!²%=o?¨´#Y?B<RQBS�·ÂL#GJAC´#Qv=MD�²%³ <�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=�D>?¨²EI¨GTSÁ?B< ® ´�Q¨²�ACQBL#´#Qv=@A ® ´�=o²�°�ACD@IBD@´2<%QWVkACQX¾³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQ'¶:?¨ATLM?'?B<RD º ´�´#Q"Y@´ ® ´�<RGJ´�S º V*=o?¨´/°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=^SXI¨YoACQ¨¹�°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ¸½v»fQ=@?BACD3Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=3°�²ED>=3L#²R°�°�²RQ'=oY@IKDa= <RL)=@AC²RQBD3<RY@´�<%IX=o?¨²RYoAJÓ�<n=oAJ²EQ2<%QBS ® ´�Y@AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQ'²R³L)Yo´�S¨´#Qv=@AT<%GTD3²%³�<%GCG¸µB<%Y@=@AC´�D3¶:?BACLM?�<%Yo´HAJQ ® ²EG ® ´�S2AJQ�=@?B´!°*´�SXAT<n=@AC²RQ�½Ã3?¨´�D>´3<RL)=@AC²RQBD�?B< ® ´�=o²P=M<%ÄE´^SXAJã¼´#Yo´#Qv=�=@YoIBDa=�Yo´#GT<n=oAJ²EQBD>?BAJµBDlACQv=@²H<RL#L#²RI¨Qv=�¶:?¨ATLM?

°�<�V!´)¿XATDa=�<%°�²RQB¹:=@?¨´:Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�·�°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�·�<%QBSH=o?¨´:Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�¶:A{=o?¨AJQ²RQ¨´^²RY°�²RYo´�L)²EQ¨Q¨´�L)=@´�S�<%¹R´�Qv=:D@²XL)AC´)=oAJ´�D#½K^<RQ(<�L)²EQE=M<RL)=@´�S�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=�·X³�²EY ´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R·º ´�=@YoIBDa=o´�S º VÔØ3¾�²RY�Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�=@²ÕQ¨²R=�Yo´�D@´#GCG!Ï�µB<RY>=MD�²%³oе¨YoA ® <%=@´�µ¨Yo²%ÈBGC´�AJQX³�²EY>¾°�<n=oAJ²EQ¸·¸L)²EµvVWYoAJ¹E?v=@´�SkS¨<n=M<¨·¸<%QKS6D@²2³�²EY>=o?¸·¼=@²�²R=@?¨´�Y�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�²RY!Ö�¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MDAJ=:L#²RGCGC< º ²EYo<%=@´�D�¶:AJ=@?�µK²R=@´�QE=oAC<RGJGCV'<RL#Y@²vD@D�°�I¨GJ=@AT<%¹E´#Qv=:D>VXD>=@´#°�D º ²RYMSX´#YMD��HØ:¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD<%GTD@² °�AJ¹E?E=l¶^<RQv=�=@² ® ´#YoAJ³�VHL#´#Y@=o<RAJQH³×<ELg=oDl< º ²RI¨=ÂYo´#GC´ ® <%Qv=ÂÖ�¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD º ´#³�²RYo´�L#²RQv=@YM<RL)¾=@ACQ¨¹�=o?¨´#° ´#AJ=@?¨´�Y º V'A{=MD>´�G{³�²RY3=o?¨´!°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE= <ED^<*=oY@IKDa=o´�S"AJQv=@´�Y@°�´�SXAC<RY@VE½»fQ�D>IB°*°�<RY@VE·n=@?¨´�Y@´:ATD�<RQ*² º ® AC²RIKD�Q¨´#´�S�³�²EY�<%GCGB<R¹R´#Qv=MD�AJQ ® ²EG ® ´�SAJQ*=o?¨´ °�´�SXAT<n¾

=@AC²RQ�µBY@²XL)´�D@Dl=o²!IBD@´ <%Q�<%µ¨µBY@²Eµ¨Y@AT<n=o´^=@YoIBDa=�°�²XSX´�GX=@²�<RQB<%GCVXD>´:<RQBS�<RDoD>´�D@Dl=o?¨´:Y@ATD@ÄWD²%³!<%QKSÝ°�´)=o?¨²XS¨D�=o²Æµ¨Y@´ ® ´�QE=�<%QKSÉL#²RI¨Qv=o´#YM<RLg=�<n=@=o<ELMÄWD�<R¹E<%ACQBD>=�=@?¨´�AJY'S¨<%=o<Á<%QKSÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´R½�;�²XSX´�GCD�·�°�´)=@?B²WSBD'<%QBSÝ=@´�LM?¨Q¨ATÎvI¨´�D�D@I¨µ¨µO²RY@=@ACQ¨¹Õ=@?¨´�´�Da=M< º GCATD>?¨°�´�QE=<%QKSk°�<%QK<%¹R´�°�´#Qv=�²R³�°�I¨=@IB<RG�=@YoIBDa= º ´)=a¶^´#´�QÕ<"°�ACS¨S¨GJ´#¾�<R¹R´#Qv=!<%QBSkA{=MD!L)GCAJ´�Qv=oDHACQ<%Q�²EµK´�Q"´�Q ® ACY@²EQ¨°�´#Qv=:AJQKL)GCIBSX´

] =@?¨´^IBD@´�²R³¨´)¿Xµ¨Yo´�DoD>A ® ´�=oY@IKDa=�´�D>=o< º GJATD@?¨°�´#Qv=lL#´#Y@=@AJÈKL#<%=@´�DÂIBD@´)³�I¨Gv³�²EY�·�´R½ ¹B½C· º AJQBS¨AJQ¨¹<%¹R´�Qv= ACSX´�Qv=@AJ=aV'=@²2µ¨I º GCACLHÄE´#V"AJQX³�YM<RD>=@YoIBL)=@I¨Yo´�D:D@IBLM?�<RD:»gl�Ã:æ(Q D/U¨Ö�FH»PËJÚ"�X·KÜ%�nÍ�·<%QBS�²%=o?¨´#YPDa=M<%QBS¨<RYoS�D@´�L)IBY@AJ=aV2°�´�LM?K<%Q¨ATD>°�D:<RQBS�µ¨Y@²R=@²XL)²EGCD�·W=@?B´�IBD@´!²%³�°*´�LM?B<n¾Q¨ACD@°�D�=@² º ACQBSÕ<%¹R´�Qv=�QB<R°�´�DP=@²"=@?¨´�AJY!?WI¨°�<RQ6SX´�µ¨GJ²nVE´#YMD#·¼D@²2=o?B<n=H=@?B´*?WI¨°�<RQ¶�²EI¨GCS º ´�<RY:Y@´�D>µO²RQBD@A º AJGCAJ=aV�AJQ�L#<ED>´H?¨ATD/T�?¨´�Y <%¹R´�Qv=^°�ATD º ´#?B< ® ´�D�½

] =@?¨´H³�²EY@°�<%G¸D@µO´�L)AJÈKL�<n=@AC²RQ�²%³�<%¹E´#Qv=3=@YoIBD>=3µO²RGCATL)AC´�D�·B<%QBS

Page 8: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| �

] =@?¨´HYo´�D@µK´�Lg=@A ® ´PI¨µ¼S¨<n=o´R·Xµ¨Yo²RµB<R¹E<%=@AC²RQ¸·v<%QBS'=@YM<%QBD@A{=oA ® ´/°�´#Yo¹R´P²%³¸=oY@IKDa=3°�<n=@YoATL)´�D=@²�L#<%GTL)IBGC<%=@´H<%Q2² ® ´#YM<%GCG¨=oY@IBD>=3Y@´�GC<%=@AC²RQBD@?¨ACµ�=@?B<%=3<EL#L#²RI¨Qv=oD�³�²RY^=o?¨´/=oY@IKDa= ® <%GCI¨´�DAJQá´�<RLM?á<%QBSÉ´ ® ´#YoVÔACQBSXA ® ACSXIK<%G:=oY@IBD>=2Yo´#GT<n=oAJ²EQBD>?BAJµÉ¶:?¨ATLM?áACD�Yo´#GC´ ® <RQE=�=o²Á=@?¨´L)²RQKD>ATSX´#Yo´�S*°�´�S¨AC<%=@AC²RQ�µ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD Ë Ûo[�Í�½ ­ Q�²RµX=oAJ²EQ�ACD�=@?¨´P<%µ¨µ¨GCATL#<n=oAJ²EQ�²%³�SXATDa=oY@A º IX¾=@´�S�?¨ATD>=@²RYoVv¾ º <RD@´�S'Yo´#µBIX=o<%=@AC²RQ�°*´�LM?B<%QBACD@°�D^=@²'<%¹E´#Qv=:D>²XL)AC´)=oAJ´�D!Ë Ì M�Í�½

ø�ùTú¸ùTú_�P������� �� üþýyÿÂÿZ�������q�U���� "�%��ü��vÿlý��G �U� ���s� ���U� � � �%���G�lÿü�� �$#� � � � � � �

âP´�LMÄR´�YP´#=H<RGy½�Ë Ñ�Í�AJQ ® ´�Da=oAJ¹v<n=o´�S�SXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=�Yo²RGC´�D/²%³�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oD ACQ(=o?¨´�D>²EGJIX=oAJ²EQD@µB<RL#´�²%³3=@?¨´"L)²RQBQ¨´�L)=@AC²RQÁµ¨Yo² º GC´#°1³�Y@²E°1=o?¨´2D>=o<%QKSXµK²EAJQv=�²R³^µBY@A ® <RL)VÕL)²EQBD>ATSX´�Yo<%¾=@AC²RQKD#½^Ã3?¨´(<%IX=o?¨²RYMD�µB<RY>=oACL#I¨GT<%YoGJVÔ´#¿¨<%°�AJQB´�SÉÄWQ¨²n¶:GJ´�SX¹R´(< º ²EIX=2Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv='µ¨Yo´)³�´)¾Yo´#QBL#´�D�·�<%QBSáÖ�¾�<R¹R´�QE='L�<%µB< º AJGCAJ=@AC´�D�Å�AJQÇ=o?¨ATD ® AJ´�¶éD>µO´�L#A{ÈKL�Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=MD'<%QKSÇY@´�µ¨GJAC´�D²RY!<ELg=@AC²RQKD/ACQ6D@´#Y ® ACL#´�²%³^<2Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=H<%Yo´ACQv=@´#Yoµ¨Yo´)=o´�S(<EDPACQBD>=o<RQBL)´�D/²R³�µ¨Yo´)³�´#Yo´#QKL)´�D²%³/Ø:¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD�<%QKSÔL#<RµB< º ACGCA{=oAJ´�D�²%³/Ö�¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD#·�Y@´�D>µO´�L)=@A ® ´#GCVR½ZI^²%=@?ݵ¨Y@´#³�´#Yo´#QBL#´2<%QKSL#<RµB< º AJGCA{=aVÝAJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ¯L�<%QÉAJQBA{=oAC<RGJGCV º ´�ÄR´#µ¨=�µBY@A ® <n=@´�<%=*=o?¨´�Ø3¾f<%¹R´�Qv=�· º ´�Yo´)¾® ´�<%GC´�S6=@²(D@²R°�´�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=�·�²RY º ´�ÄWQ¨²n¶:Q º V(=o?¨´2Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�½�Ã3?¨ATD�GC´�<ES¨D�=@²6<L#<%=@´�¹R²RYoACÓ�<n=oAJ²EQ2²R³lD@²R°�´H°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=:Y@²EGJ´�D3<RD:D@?¨²n¶:Q"ACQ�=@?¨´H³�²EGJGC²n¶:ACQ¨¹*=o< º GJ´E½Ö�Yo´)³�´�Y@´�QBL)´�D K^<%µB< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D3ACQ¨AJ=@AT<%GCGJV'ÄWQ¨²n¶:Q º VACQ¨A{=oAC<RGJGCV2ÄWQ¨²n¶:Q º V Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=^²EQ¨GCV Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv= Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=

� °�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv= � °�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=� Ø3¾�<R¹R´�QE=

Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=^²EQ¨GCV Ï�I^Y@²v<RS¨L�<RD>=@´#YgÐ �Eæ¨Yo²RQv=>¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�� ��´�GJGC²n¶3¾fÖ�<%¹R´�D#·;(<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄR´�Y

Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv= ­ Q¨²EQvVW°�ACÓ#´#Y I�Yo²RÄE´#Y Ø:´�L#²R°�°�´#QBSX´�Y� °�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=� °�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv= I^GC<ELMÄ º ²v<%YMS »fQv=@Yo²WS¨IBL)´�Y ­ Y º AJ=@YM<n=o²RY� Ö�¾�<R¹R´�QE=ÃÂ< º GC´�ÚRÙ¨;�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=:Y@²EGJ´�D^L�<n=o´#¹R²EY@ACÓ#´�S º V'ACQ¨AJ=@AT<%G¸µ¨YoA ® <EL)V2L#²RQBL#´#YoQBDHË Ñ%Í�½æ¨²EY:´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R·K< º Y@²EÄR´�Y <%¹R´�Qv=3IBQBSX´#YMD>=o<%QKS¨D º IX= µBY@²R=@´�L)=oD3=o?¨´�ACQ¨AJ=@AT<%G¸µ¨YoA ® <EL)V

²%³/L�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=aVÕ<RQBSÁµ¨Yo´)³�´�Y@´�QBL)´'ACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQƲ%³ º ²%=@?Ô=@?¨´�Ø3¾�<R¹R´�QE=�<RQBSÔÖ�¾�<R¹R´#Qv=�ÅQ¨´�A{=o?¨´#Y�=@?B´*Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=/Q¨²EY/=o?¨´Ö�¾�<R¹R´�QE=P´ ® ´�Y/ÄWQ¨²n¶ D�SXACY@´�Lg=@GCV�< º ²RIX=P=@?¨´*²%=o?¨´#Y�ACQ<�=oYo<RQBD@<ELg=oAJ²EQÕ¶:?BACLM?ÁATD�ACQE=o´#Yo°�´�SXAT<n=o´�S º Vk=o?¨´ º Yo²RÄE´#Y�<R¹R´#Qv=�½¸»fQÔL)²EQE=oYo<EDa=�·�<%QWVØ3¾f<%¹E´#Qv= L#<%Q�ÎvI¨´#YoV2L�<%µB< º AJGCAJ=aV�AJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ�²%³�Y@´�¹RATDa=o´#Yo´�S2Ö�¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD�<%=/<*°�<%=oLM?X¾°�<%ÄE´#Y�²EY�VR´�GJGC²n¶3¾�µK<%¹R´:D@´#Y ® ´�Y�D>IBLM?�=o?B<n=�=@?¨ATD�ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQ�ACD�Y@´ ® ´�<RGJ´�S�ACQ¨AJ=@AT<%GCGJV=@²º ²%=@?kY@´�ÎEIB´�D>=@´#YMD <RQBS�µ¨Yo² ® ATSX´�YoD�½;� ²n¶^´ ® ´#Y�·W=@?¨ATD�L#<n=o´#¹E²RYoAJÓ�<n=@AC²RQ�²%³�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=Yo²RGC´�D�SX²W´�D�QB²%=�Y@´#äB´�L)=�=@?¨´3µO²EDoD>A º ACGJAJ=aV�²R³KGC´�<RY@Q¨ACQ¨¹H²%³Oµ¨Yo´)³�´#Yo´#QKL)´�D�<RQBS�L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D² ® ´�Y^=@AC°*´E½»fQk<ES¨SXAJ=@AC²RQ�=o²'=@?BACD�µO´#YMD>µO´�L)=@A ® ´�²EQ(°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD Yo´�D>=@YoACL)=@´�S�=@²2ACQ¨AJ=@AT<%G�µ¨YoA{¾

® <RL#V�L#²RQBL#´#YoQBD�¶^´ µ¨Yo²RµO²ED@´/<!°�²EY@´P¹R´#QB´#YM<%GBD@ÄWAJGCG{¾ º <ED>´�S�·R°�´�<RQBD�D@´#Y ® ACL#´)¾�²RYoAJ´�Qv=@´�S¸·L)GT<RDoD@A{ÈKL�<n=oAJ²EQ�²%³�°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD#½OÃ3?¨ATD�L#GC<ED@D@AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQ�ACDPAC°*µBGJAC´�S º V�=o?¨´�´#¿v=o´#Qv=!<°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=3ATD�µ¨Yo² ® ACS¨AJQ¨¹°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ"D@´#Y ® ATL)´�D�<ED�=o?¨´#V'<RY@´�SX´�DoL)YoA º ´�S�AJQ�D@´�Lg=oAJ²EQ

Page 9: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

�/  ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

Ѩ½uÛX½CÚR½nælAC¹RI¨Yo´^ÑB½JÚ^D>IB°*°�<RY@ACÓ#´�D�=o?¨´�D@´3D>´�Y ® ATL)´3L)GT<RDoD>´�D¸³�²EYl°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oDlACQ¹E´#Q¨´�Yo<RG<%QKSH³�²RYlD>²E°*´^L)²E°*°�²EQH=aVvµO´�D²%³X°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oD¸ACQ�µB<RY>=oACL#I¨GT<%Y�·#QB<R°*´�GJV�°�´�SXAT<n=o²RYMD#·º Yo²RÄE´#YMD#·B<RQBS�°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄR´�YoD�½¨Ê�<%=>=o´#Y/ATD ACGCGJIBD>=@YM<n=o´�S º V�°*´�<%QBD ²%³�² º ±a´�Lg=@¾�²EY@AC´#Qv=o´�SACQ¨?¨´#YoAJ=o<%QKL)´3<%QBS!ACQBD>=o<RQE=oAC<%=@AC²RQ�²R³KD@´#Y ® ATL)´�L)GT<RDoD>´�D¸³�²EY´�<RLM?�²R³X=@?¨´3<%¹E´#Qv=oD�½�Ã3?B´^L#²RY@¾Yo´�D@µK²EQBSXACQ¨¹2L)GT<RDoD@A{ÈKL�<n=oAJ²EQ�°�<%=@YoA{¿ º <RD@´�S�²EQ�=@?¨´*SXAJãO´�Y@´�QBL)´�D/ACQ(D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D ATD ¹RA ® ´�QACQ"ÈK¹RI¨Yo´!Ѩ½uÛX½

Class Agt¡

_naming_regClass Agt_interaction• ACL_processing• int¢

eract_negotiatio£ n_pol¤ icies¥

Class Access_sources¡

Class ACDL_process• p¤ arse¦ _v§ alidate_ ¦ ACDL• m¨ atch_¦ ACD

©L

Class Sª

em_interop• ont« o¬ logy_serv­ ices• se­ mantic_¦ reco¬ nciliation• information_model

Class D®

ata_mgmt• data¯

_storage°

• data¯

_mgmt_± inspection

Class Query_processing• dist¯

rib_q² uery_³ p¤ lanning• tr´

ansaction_¦ services Matchmaker

Class Quality_of_service• QoS_data_usage• QoS_mediation

Class User_interface• secure_browse_queryClass Mediat

µion_pcl

• inter£ action_pa¤ tterns¶

Class Trust_mgmt• data_security• trust_policies• trust_metrics· ¸ ¹ º » ¼ ½ ¾ ¿ À Á

Â Ã Ä Å Æ Ç È É Ê

Ë Ì Í Î Ï Ð Ñ Ò Ó Ô Õ

Middle-AgentMediator

inÖ

fo:st× atic/integrated, globaldiØ

st_qp: f× ull, trÙ

ans:× intermediate

inÖ

t_pol:× wÚ rapper_cooperateiÖnt_pattern: b× rokerage

onlÛ y CÜ

lassesACÝ

DL_process, Data_mgmt;SÞ

em_Interop(ont_serv,sem_rec)

Broker

inÖ

fo: d× ynamic/collection,globaldiØ

st_qp: -× , transÙ

: i× ntermediatedatØ

a_s: D× W, repository

int_pol:× negotiation/subscribeint_pattern: brokerage

is-a

is-a¥

iÖnt_pattern: matchmaking

ß<àuáâ�ã;â2ä�â¨� ]o_asz��]g��ef]o_a�%s{ho]:hMw{b�efef]Me�q�p�`!]g�Rs{b#maq�_g}E�E_aq���]o_g}R`�b#mah>iv`�b#��]o_�b#|�]Mcnmae

»fQ =@?B´Æ³�²RGCGJ²n¶:ACQ¨¹á¶^´ º YoAJ´#äBV-S¨ACDoL)IBDoD�°�´�S¨AC<%=@²RY�· º Yo²RÄE´#Y(<RQBS °�<n=oLM?B°�<RÄR´�Y<%¹E´#Qv=oD/AJQ6¹R´�Q¨´#YM<%G�·¨=o?¨´#Q�³�²XL#IBD�²RQ(µB<RY>=oACL#I¨GT<%Y/´�QB< º GJACQ¨¹�=o´�LM?¨Q¨ATÎvI¨´�DP²%³ º Y@²EÄR´#YoACQ¨¹<%QKS"°�<%=oLM?¨°�<%ÄWACQ¨¹B·X<RQBS"ÈBQB<%GCGCV2D>IBY ® ´#V2D@²R°�´H²%³Â=@?¨´!µ¨Yo²R°�ACQ¨´#Qv=:´)¿¨<R°*µBGJ´�D#½ü��Wÿlý�� �;� ù ­ °�´�SXAT<n=o²RY^<%¹R´�Qv=�AJQ2A{=MD�²RYoAC¹RACQB<%GOSX´)ÈBQBA{=oAJ²EQ º VàáAC´�SX´�Y@?B²RGTS(ÏaÚ"�%�EÛEÐË ÌEÜ�͸ATD�S¨VvQK<%°�ACL�<%GCGJV'<RQBS'<ELg=@A ® ´�GJV�ACQv=@´#Y@³×<RL#AJQB¹�IBD@´#YMDHÏ×Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oDMÐ�=o²�Yo´#GC´ ® <%Qv=:S¨<n=M<<%QKS(ÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´�Y@´�D>²EI¨YML)´�D�½¨»fQk=@?¨ATDHL)²RQv=o´)¿W=�·K=@?¨´�=@´�Y@°åQ °�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQLQKACQBL#GJIBS¨´�DP=@?¨´µ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD@AJQ¨¹�Q¨´#´�SX´�S'=@²�°�<RÄR´:=o?¨´PACQv=@´�Y>³×<EL)´/¶^²RYoļ·%=o?¨´/ÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´/D>=@YoIBLg=oI¨Y@´�D�=o?B<n=SXYoA ® ´*=@?¨´�=oYo<RQBDa³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ(Q¨´�´�SX´�S6=@²�=@YM<%QBD>³�²RYo° =@?B´'S¨<n=M<'=o²�AJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ¸·�<%QKS<%QWVÕAJQv=o´#Yo°*´�SXAT<n=@´'D>=@²EYo<R¹R´�=o?B<n=�ATD�QB´#´�S¨´�S�½Â»fQÔ¹R´�Q¨´#YM<%G�·�<�°�´�SXAT<n=o²RY�³�²WL#IBD@´�D!²EQ=@?B´�µ¨Y@² ® ATD>AC²RQ¯²%³!D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D*S¨´ ® ²R=@´�SÔ=o²ÔD>´�°�<RQv=@ATL"ACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQ º Y@²EÄR´#YoACQ¨¹B½�Ã3?B<n=´#QKL)²R°�µB<ED@D@´�D:D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D^=o²(ÏaÚ�Ð3S¨VvQK<%°�ACL�<%GCGJV"SX´)=o´#Yo°*ACQ¨´!ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQ�D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D3<%QKSµ¨Yo²XSXIBLg=MD#Å�Ï�ÛRÐ�<%Y º AJ=@YM<n=o´ º ´)=a¶^´#´�QÕL#²RQBD@I¨°�´#Y!<%QKSkµ¨Yo² ® ACS¨´#YH<%¹R´�Qv=oD º V(°�´�<%QKDP²R³Yo´�D@²RG ® ACQ¨¹/S¨A{ã¼´#Yo´#Qv=�¶�²EY@GTSW¾ ® AC´#¶ D�Ï�ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQ�AJ°�µO´�S¨<RQBL)´�Ðg·n<%QKS'Ï×ÜvÐ�SXVWQB<R°�ACL�<%GCGJVL)Yo´�<%=@´ ²EY�L#²R°�µK²vD>´:ACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQ�µ¨Yo²WS¨IBLg=MD º V�L)²RYoYo´#GT<n=@ACQ¨¹H²RY^<RDoD>´�° º GCACQ¨¹�L)²E°*µO²%¾Q¨´�QE=MD <%QKS"D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D^³�Yo²R° ® <%YoAC²RIBD^µ¨Yo² ® ACSX´�YoD�½­ DP°�´#Qv=@AC²RQB´�Sk< º ² ® ´R·B=@?¨´*°�²ED>=�L)²E°�°*²EQkDoL)´#QK<%YoAJ²'²R³�<'°�´�S¨AC<%=@²RYPAJQÕ<%Q(ACQX¾

=@´�GJGCAC¹R´#Qv='ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQ¯D@VWD>=@´�°õATD*=@?B<%='A{=2<ELg=oD�<ED�<ÕL#´#Qv=@YM<%G3I¨QBA{=2L#²RGCGC< º ²EYo<%=@ACQ¨¹

Page 10: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| ���

Class ACDL_process• p¤ arse¦ _v§ alidate_ ¦ ACDL• m¨ atch_¦ ACD

©L

Class Sª

em_interop• ont« o¬ logy_serv­ ices

¥• se­ mantic_¦ reco¬ nciliation• info¢

rmaæ tion_model

Class Data_mgmt• data¯

_stora°

ge/m¨ gmt/± i¢nspecç t

Class Query_processing• dist¯

rib_q² uery_³ p¤ lanning• tr´

ansaction_¦ services

Class Agt¡

_interaction• int¢

eract_negotiatio£ n_pol¤ icies¥

Class Mediatµ

ion_pcl• inter£ action_pa¤ tterns¶

Matchmakerè

Brokeé

r Mediator

XêXê X

êXê X

êXê

Mediation Seè

rvices

wë rappercooperatiì on

brokeragí

ematchmaking brokeragí

e

registî er/matching onlyno negotiation

X Xê

Class Access_sources

X

XêX

datï

a warehouserepositî ory

static/integratedglð obal

XêX

dynamï

iccollectionì

federateddb/ï

repository

X

intermediate

XêX

intermediate

X

negotiationsubscribe, coop.

ß<àuáâ�ã;âbñGâ �R]o_a�%szhM] � q�_asz]Mcnma]g��hMw{b�efefsutWhMb#maszq�c'q�p¼`!]g�Es{b#maq#_g}v�R_aq���]@_g}v`�b)mah@iE`�b���]o_

¶:AJ=@?(<�D>´#= ²%³�¶:Yo<Rµ¨µO´#Y <%¹E´#Qv=oDHÏyÖ�¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oDMÐ�´�<RLM?�²%³�¶:?¨ATLM?"ATD:µ¨Yo² ® ACSXACQ¨¹�<RL�L)´�D@D�=@²<%QKS6S¨<%=o<"²%³�D@²R°�´�< ® <%ACGC< º GJ´AJQ¨³�²RYo°�<%=@AC²RQÕD>²EI¨YoL#´�ACQ6<�L)²E°*°�²EQ6S¨<%=o<"°*²XSX´�Gy½ ­°�´�SXAT<n=o²RY�ACD�L)Yo´�<n=oAJQB¹�<%QBS�°�<%QK<%¹RACQ¨¹�<!µK<%Y@=@AT<%G¨¹EGJ² º <%G¨ACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQ�°�²WS¨´#GB²EQ�=@?¨´´#Q ® ACY@²EQ¨°�´#Qv=3<RQBS"²%=@?B´#Y <%¹E´#Qv=oD�=@?BY@²EI¨¹R?�ÄWQ¨²n¶:GJ´�SX¹R´ º <RD@´�S"ACQE=o´#¹EYo<%=@AC²RQ'²R³ÂYo´�L)´�A{¾® ´�S�AJQ¨³�²RYo°�<%=@AC²RQ�³�Yo²R° S¨A{ã¼´#Yo´#Qv=PD@²RI¨YML)´�D#·¨<RQBS�²%ã¼´#YoACQ¨¹'SX²R°�<RAJQ�<%QKS�<%µ¨µ¨GCATL#<n=oAJ²EQD@µK´�L)AJÈKL ® <%GCI¨´)¾f<RSBSX´�SÁD@´#Y ® ATL)´�D#½�»�=�=o<RÄR´�DHYo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=MDH³�Yo²R°1IKD>´�Y�<%¹E´#Qv=oD'ÏyØ3¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oDMÐ<%QKSÝ<%QKD>¶^´#YMD!=o?¨´#°õ´�A{=o?¨´#Y�IBD@ACQ¨¹kAJ=oD*¹RGC² º <%G^AJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQÔ°�²XSX´#G3²EY�³�²EY@¶3<%YMSXACQ¨¹<%µBµ¨Y@²Eµ¨YoAC<%=@´/Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=MD�=@²*=@?¨´HYo´#GC´ ® <%Qv=3¶:Yo<Rµ¨µO´#Y:<%¹E´#Qv=oD º <ED>´�S'²RQ�Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=@A ® ´HSXATDa¾=@YoA º IX=@´�S�ÎvI¨´#YoV�µ¨GT<%QBQ¨AJQB¹�<%QBS*µ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD@AJQ¨¹K½n»fQ�=@?¨ATD�D@´#QBD@´:ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=@AC²RQ�ATD�¹E<%=@?¨´�Y@´�S³�²RGCGC²n¶:AJQ¨¹�<*µ¨I¨GCG¸°�´�LM?K<%Q¨ATD>° AJQ¨AJ=@AT<n=o´�S º V'=o?¨´!°�´�SXAT<n=o²RY3²RQ�SX´�°�<RQBS�½»fQ�L)²EQE=oYo<EDa=3=o² º Y@²EÄR´�Y3<R¹R´�QE=MD3°�´�SXAT<n=o²RYMD:SX²�Q¨²%=/D@AC°*µBGJV�L)²RGCGC´�Lg= ACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQ

³�Yo²R°.SXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=Pµ¨Yo² ® ACSX´�YoDPD>AC°�AJGT<%YP=@²�S¨<n=M<'¶3<%Yo´#?¨²EIBD@´�D º IX=�ACQv=@´�¹RYM<n=@´�=@?¨´�°éAJQv=@²<(¹EGJ² º <%G�AJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQÆ°�²XSX´#G º VÕYo´�D@²RG ® AJQB¹�AJQBL#²RQBD@ATDa=o´#QBL#AJ´�D�<%QKSÔL)²EQXäBATLg=oD�½ÂÃ3?BACD°�²XSX´#GHATD'=aVWµ¨ATL#<RGJGCV¯?BACS¨S¨´#Q ACQá=o?¨´6SX´#ÈBQ¨AJ=@AC²RQ ²%³!=@?B´k°�´�SXAT<n=o²RY�·^<RQBSÇATD2´�A{=o?¨´#YD>=o<n=oACL�<%GCGJVƲEY�SXVWQB<%°�ATL#<%GCGCVƹR´#QB´#YM<n=@´�S�½�»fQÉ<ES¨SXAJ=@AC²RQ¸·�< º Yo²RÄR´�Y*<R¹R´�QE=�IBD@IB<%GCGCVÆACDL)²EQBD@ACSX´�Y@´�S�Q¨²R=/=@² º ´*< º GC´�=o²"SX²�<%QWV�SXATDa=oY@A º IX=o´�S(ÎvI¨´�Y@V�µ¨GT<%Q¨QBAJQ¨¹"<%QBS�µBY@²XL)´�Da¾D@AJQ¨¹K½�l�¿X<R°�µ¨GJ´�D!²%³:°�´�S¨AC<%=@²RY@¾ º <RD@´�S6AJQ¨³�²RYo°�<%=@AC²RQÆD@VWD>=@´�°�D�<%Yo´�»fQX³�²E°�<EDa=o´#Y2ËJÚ�Û�Í�·Ã UW»a;(;(»>U6Ë �nÍ�·Y º D@´#Y ® ´�Y�Ë ÜRÑnÍ�·B;(»jO�Ë ÜB·BÛ%Ñ�Í�·B<%QKS�UX»a;kU;T ­ Y@AT<RS¨Q¨´�Ë{ÚgÍ�½

� �#�U� � � ù ­ º Yo²RÄE´#Y¸<R¹R´#Qv=¸°�<�VH<RLg=oA ® ´#GCV/ACQv=@´#Y@³×<RL#´�Ø3¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oD¼=o²/Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD º V�AJQv=@´�Y>¾°�´�SXAT<n=oAJQB¹�Yo´�ÎvI¨´�D>=@´�S'D@´#Y ® ATL)´ =@YM<%QBDo<RL)=@AC²RQBD�½ ­ GCG�L)²E°*°I¨Q¨ATL#<%=@AC²RQ º ´)=a¶^´#´#Q2µB<%ACY@´�SØ3¾�<%QBS�Ö�¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD�?B<RD�=@²�¹E²!=@?BY@²EI¨¹R?�=o?¨´ º Yo²RÄE´#Y�½%»�=�=aVWµ¨ATL#<RGJGCVL#²RQv=o<ELg=oDPÏ×<�D@´)=^²%³oÐ=@?B´�°�²ED>= Y@´�GJ´ ® <RQv=/Ö�¾f<%¹R´�Qv=�·WQ¨´#¹E²%=oAC<%=@´�D^³�²EY�·B´)¿X´�L#IX=@´�D <%QBS�L#²RQv=@Yo²RGTD:<%µ¨µBY@²Eµ¨Y@AT<n=o´=@YM<%QKD@<ELg=@AC²RQKD#·X<%QKS"Yo´)=oI¨YoQBD^=@?¨´!Yo´�D@I¨GJ=:²%³l=@?¨´�D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D�=@²*=@?B´�Ø3¾�<R¹R´�QE=�½

Page 11: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

�)� ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

Ã3?¨ATD�ATD�AJQ2L#²RQv=@YM<RD>=�=o²�=@?B´/³�I¨QKLg=@AC²RQK<%GCA{=aV�²%³�<�°�<n=oLM?B°�<RÄR´�Y�<%¹E´#Qv= º I¨=�ATD�D@I º ¾D@I¨°�´�S º V�=@?K<n=�²%³B< °�´�SXAC<%=@²EY�½#I^IX=lIBQ¨GJACÄR´�°�´�SXAT<n=o²RYMD#· º Yo²RÄR´�Y�<%¹E´#Qv=oD�=aVWµ¨ATL#<%GCGCV�SX²Q¨²R=lµ¨Yo² ® ACS¨´�< ¹EGJ² º <%G�·�D@´#°�<%Qv=oACL�<%GCGJV�AJQv=o´#¹RYM<n=o´�S�·�L)²EQBD>ATD>=@´#Qv=lAJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ�°�²XSX´#GE=@²=@?B´#ACYPL)GCAC´#Qv=oD º IX=�D>=@²EY@´�L#²RGCGJ´�Lg=o´�S�AJQ¨³�²RYo°�<%=@AC²RQ�°�<�V º ´!=o²R¹E´)=@?B´#Y ¶:AJ=@?k<ED@D@²XL)AT<n=o´�S²RQv=o²RGC²R¹RATL#<RG�<%Q¨Q¨²R=o<%=@AC²RQBD^ACQ�D@²R°�´HDa=M<%QBSB<%YMSXAJÓ�´�S�S¨<n=M<�Ï×D>=@YoIBLg=oI¨Y@´�Ð�³�²RYo°�<%=:AJQ�²RQB´Ï�²EYP°I¨GJ=@ACµ¨GJ´�Ð/<Rµ¨µ¨Yo²Rµ¨YoAT<n=@´!Yo´#µO²ED@AJ=@²RYoAC´�D GCACÄR´�ACQk<"S¨<n=M<'¶3<%Yo´#?¨²EIBD>´E½¨»fQk<ES¨SXAJ=@AC²RQ¸·< º Yo²RÄE´#Y3=aVWµ¨ATL#<%GCGCV"SX²W´�D Q¨²%=/?K< ® ´!<�L)²E°*µK<%YM< º GCV'´)¿W=o´#QBD@A ® ´�D>´#=/²%³ ® <%GCI¨´)¾f<RSBSXAJQB¹°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ2D@´#Y ® ATL)´�D�GCAJÄE´/<�°�´�SXAC<%=@²EY�ÅEAJQ�=o?¨ATD�Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=3< º Yo²RÄE´#Y�°�<�V*Y@´�GJV*²RQ2S¨A{ã¼´)¾Yo´#Qv=�=aVWµK´�D�²%³O=o<ED>Äv¾�²RYoAJ´�QE=o´�S<%¹R´�Qv=oD�AJ=�ACD�< º GC´^=@²�L)²EGJGT< º ²RYM<n=o´:<%QBSQ¨´#¹E²%=oAC<%=@´:¶:AJ=@?¸½I^Y@²EÄR´�Y�°�<�VD>I º D@L#Y@A º ´ =@²�L)´�Y>=M<%ACQ�Ö�¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oDlA{³�Q¨´�´�SX´�S�½�ò/Q¨GCAJÄE´ <H°*´�SXAT<n=@²EY�<%¹E´#Qv=�·=@?B´�ACQv=@´�Yo<ELg=@AC²RQ"²%³ º Y@²EÄR´#YMD�¶:AJ=@?�²%=o?¨´#Y:<R¹R´#Qv=MD�ATD^Q¨´#AJ=@?B´#Y3Y@´�Da=oY@ATLg=o´�S'=@²*¶:Yo<Rµ¨µK´�YoD²RY3°�´�S¨AC<%=@²RYMD^Q¨²RY:L#²R°�°�A{=@=@´�S2=@²�<�Ȩ¿X´�S"QWI¨° º ´#Y3²%³�<%¹E´#Qv=oD�½XÃ3?¨ACD3< º AJGCAJ=aV'ACD^µB<RY>¾=@ATL)IBGC<RY@GCV"IKD>´#³�I¨GlD@ACQBL)´ º Y@²EÄR´#YMD <RY@´!IBD@IB<RGJGCV�<ELg=oAJQ¨¹2AJQkS¨VvQK<%°�ACL�´#Q ® AJYo²RQ¨°�´�QE=MD:ACQ¶:?¨ATLM?Yo´�D@²RIBYoL#´�Dl<%QBS*<%¹E´#Qv=oDl°�<�V�L)²EQE=oAJQWIB<RGJGCV!´#Qv=o´#Y�<%QKS�GC´�< ® ´�=@?B´ <%¹R´�Qv=�D@²XL)AC´)=aVR½»fQÔD@IBLM?6´�Q ® ACYo²RQ¨°�´#Qv=MDHA{=!=oI¨Y@QKD!²RIX=!=o² º ´2AJQB<Rµ¨µ¨Yo²Rµ¨YoAT<n=@´=@²�°�<RAJQv=o<RAJQÆ<�D>=o<n=oACLµ¨Yo´)¾�AJQv=o´#¹RYM<n=o´�S!¹EGJ² º <%Gv°�²XSX´#GW¶:?¨ATLM?ATD ® <%GCACS�³�²RY�</YM<n=o?¨´#Y�L)GC²ED@´�SD>²XL#AJ´#=aV�²R³K<%¹E´#Qv=oD<%QKS�D@VXDa=o´#°�D�½

� ²n¶^´ ® ´#Y�·�A{=*ACD�Q¨²%=o´#¶^²RY@=@?WV�=o?B<n==@?¨´2D@´#°�<RQE=oACL�D!²%³:=o?¨´�=o´#Yo°�D�°�<n=oLM?B°�<RÄR´�Y<%QKS º Yo²RÄE´#Y:<RD^¶^´#GCG¸<RD3°�´�S¨AC<%=@²RY:<RQBS º Y@²EÄR´#Y:<RY@´�²%³�=o´#Q�IBD@´�S"AJQv=@´�YoLM?K<%Q¨¹E´�< º GJV�ACQ=@?B´�GJAJ=@´�Yo<%=@I¨Yo´RÅ º Y@²EÄR´#YMD�<%Yo´�<RGCD@²�²%³�=o´#QÆL#<RGJGC´�Sk³×<RL#AJGCA{=M<n=o²RYMD#½Ll�¿X<R°�µ¨GJ´�D�²%³ º Y@²EÄR´�Y<%¹E´#Qv=oD3<RQBS º Yo²RÄE´#Y@¾ º <RD@´�S�D@VWD>=@´�°�D�ACQBL#GJIBS¨´8O�;(Ê�¾ º <ED>´�S"åH;(âóI^Yo²RÄR´�Y�ËJÚ�[nÍ�·UYPQX¾=@²�I^Y@²EÄR´#Y!Ë ÜRÜ�Í�·BU � ­ â8l ·K<RQBS�K�YP»gôPUÕË ÛEÛ�Í�½

ü�� "$#� � � � � � ù ­ °�<n=oLM?B°�<RÄR´�Y�<%¹E´#Qv=:±aIBD>=µB<RAJYMD�Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�¶:A{=o?ÝÖ�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD º V°�´�<RQBD�²R³ °�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹6¹RA ® ´�QÆY@´�ÎEIB´�D>=oD�²R³PØ3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD!¶:AJ=@?É<%µ¨µBY@²Eµ¨Y@AT<n=o´'<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD>´�SD@´#Y ® ATL)´�DH²%³3Y@´�¹RATDa=o´#Yo´�SÕÖ�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�½¼»fQÔL)²RQv=oYo<EDa=�=@²�=o?¨´�³�I¨QBL)=@AC²RQB<RGJAJ=aVk²R³ º ²%=o?Á=@?¨´º Yo²RÄE´#Y!<%QBS6°�´�SXAT<n=o²RYHAJ=!D@AC°*µBGJV6Y@´#=@I¨YoQBDH<�Yo<RQ¨ÄR´�S�GJATD>=�²%³�Yo´#GC´ ® <RQE=!Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD/=@²=@?B´/Yo´�ÎvI¨´�D>=@ACQ¨¹�<R¹R´#Qv=�½ ­ D�<�L)²EQBD@´�ÎvI¨´#QKL)´:=o?¨´/Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�?B<ED�=@²*L)²RQv=M<RLg=�<RQBS�Q¨´�¹R²%¾=@AT<n=o´H¶:A{=o?"=o?¨´HY@´�GJ´ ® <%Qv=3Ö�¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD�AJ=oD@´#GJ³�³�²EY:¹R´#=>=@ACQ¨¹=@?¨´!D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D^A{= SX´�D>ACYo´�D�½WÃ3?BACDSXACY@´�Lg= ACQv=@´#YM<RL)=@AC²RQ º ´)=a¶^´#´#Q�Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv= <%QBS�D@´#GC´�L)=@´�S�Ö�¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD�ATD µO´#Y@³�²RYo°�´�S"AJQKSX´)¾µO´#QBSX´�Qv=@GCV6³�Yo²R° =@?B´2°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄR´�Y�½�»�=< ® ²EACS¨D�·�³�²EY�´)¿¨<R°*µBGJ´E·ÂS¨<%=o<�=oYo<RQBD>°�ATD@D@AC²RQº ²%=>=oGJ´�Q¨´�LMÄXD:²EY D>ACQ¨¹EGJ´HµO²RACQE= ²R³Â³×<RAJGCI¨Yo´!<n=:=@?B´!°�<%=oLM?¨°�<RÄR´#Y º IX= AJQKL)Yo´�<RD@´�D3SXACYo´�Lg=L)²E°�°�I¨Q¨ATL#<%=@AC²RQ�² ® ´�Y@?¨´�<RS º ´#=a¶�´�´#Q�°�<%=oLM?¨´�S�Ø3¾gT%Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�½

YPQ¨´'L#²RI¨GTSÁL)²RQKD>ATSX´#Y!°�<%=oLM?¨°�<%ÄWACQ¨¹(<RD�D>I º D>I¨°�´�S º V º Y@²EÄR´�Y@ACQ¨¹ º IX=�AJ=<%GTD@²´)¿W=o´#QBS¨D�AJ=�ACQ�=@?¨´HD@´#QBD@´ ²%³¸¹EA ® ACQ¨¹!=o?¨´PØ3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�=o?¨´ ³�I¨GCG¼LM?¨²RATL)´ ²R³�D>´�GJ´�Lg=oAJQ¨¹*<'Ï×D@´)=²%³MÐ�Ö�¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oD*<n¾�µK²vDa=o´#YoAJ²EY@A�²RIX=�²%³/=@?¨´�Yo´�D@I¨GJ=*²R³�D@´#Y ® ATL)´"°�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹K½�»fQ¯D@´)=@=@ACQ¨¹ED¶:AJ=@? º Yo²RÄE´#YMD�AJQKDa=o´�<RS¸·�<%QWVÉØ3¾�<R¹R´�QE=2LM?B²RATL)´(<n¾�µ¨YoAJ²EY@A º VÇD>µO´�L#A{³�VWACQ¨¹ÔYo´�D@µK´�Lg=oA ® ´L)²EQBD>=@YM<%ACQE=MD�ACQ'AJ=oD�Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=�³�²RY3D>´�Y ® ATL)´3=o²�=@?B´ º Yo²RÄE´#Y�½�l�¿¨<R°*µBGJ´�D�²%³¸°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄE´#Y@¾º <ED>´�S!°�I¨GJ=@AT<%¹E´#Qv=lD@VXDa=o´#°�Dl<%QBS!µBGC<%=>³�²RYo°�D�ACQBL#GJIBS¨´�»a;(Ö ­ K^ÃáË Û�Í�·�»fQX³�²vUWGC´#I¨=@?"Ë Ü%JnÍ�·<%QKS�ØPl�à UW»gô ­ TnÊ ­ Ø F�U6Ë ÌBÚ%·¨Ì�J�Í�´�<RLM?�²%³Â¶:?BACLM?�ATD:SX´�DoL)YoA º ´�S"ACQ�D@´�L)=@AC²RQ�Ѩ½ ܨ½

Page 12: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| �g�ø�ùTú¸ùuõ | �ö�;� ÿlý��Z� �ý � �÷�(��$#�Z�Âý�ø�ù���� �S�U� üþý×ÿlÿZ�������q�U���� ������ ���;� � � ý����ú�;�Âÿ

ü�� �$#� � � � ý����Ã3?¨´:L)²W²EYoSXACQB<%=@AC²RQ!²%³O°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ<RL)=@A ® A{=oAJ´�D¶:AJ=@?BAJQ*<%QBS<RL)Yo²EDoDl<%¹R´�Qv=lD@²WL#AJ´#=@AC´�D�L#<RQº ´ µK´�Y>³�²EY@°�´�S º V*<P°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�·n³�²EY�´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R· ® AT< º Yo²RÄE´#YoAJQ¨¹�²RY�°�<%=oLM?¨°�<%ÄWACQ¨¹B½I^²%=o?6=aVWµO´�D�²%³3°*´�SXAT<n=@AC²RQÁAC°�µ¨GJVÁSXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=�Y@´�ÎEIBAJYo´#°�´#Qv=MD!<%QBSÁµ¨Yo²%=o²XL)²RGTDP³�²RY�ACQX¾=@´�Yo<ELg=oAJ²EQ'<%°�²RQ¨¹<%¹R´�Qv=oD�¶:?BACLM?'<RY@´ ACQ ® ²EG ® ´�S*AJQ2A{=�½ ­ L#L#²RYMSXAJQB¹H=@²�=o?¨´PD@ÄWAJGCGJ¾ º <ED>´�SL)GT<RDoD@A{ÈKL�<n=oAJ²EQ�²%³�°�ACS¨S¨GJ´#¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD/<RDPSX´�DoL)YoA º ´�S�AJQ(D@´�L)=@AC²RQkÑB½ Û¨½JÚ�<RQWV"°�´)=o?¨²XS(<%QKS=@´�LM?¨Q¨ATÎvI¨´�³�²EYPL#<RµB< º AJGCA{=aV�<%QKS(D>´�Y ® ATL)´!°�<n=MLM?¨ACQ¨¹2L#<RQ º ´*IX=oAJGCAJÓ�´�S�³�²EY/AC°�µ¨GJ´�°�´#QX¾=@ACQ¨¹ º ²R=@?2=@?¨´ º Yo²RÄR´�Y@ACQ¨¹�<RQBS�°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄWAJQB¹B½v»fQ2<RS¨S¨A{=oAJ²EQ¸·W²RQv=@²EGJ²E¹RVD@´#Y ® ACL#´�D�<%Yo´=aVWµ¨ATL#<%GCGCV*IKD>´�S�=@²µK´�Y>³�²EY@° °�´�<%QBAJQ¨¹R³�I¨G¼<%IX=o²R°�<n=o´�S�Yo´�<RD@²RQBAJQ¨¹�²RQ'L#<RµB< º AJGCA{=aV�<%QKSD@´#Y ® ATL)´!SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=oAJ²EQBD:D>µO´�L#A{ÈK´�S"AJQ�<�¹RA ® ´�Q ­ K^â�Ê�½»fQ�=@?B´�³�²RGCGC²n¶:AJQ¨¹�¶^´ º YoAJ´#äBV�D>I¨°�°�<%YoACÓ#´H=@?B´�?¨AC¹R?X¾�GC´ ® ´�G¸ACQE=o´#YM<RL)=@AC²RQ�µB<n=@=@´�Y@QBD

³�²RY º ²%=o?*=@?¨´:°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄWACQ¨¹!<%QBS�=@?¨´ º Y@²EÄR´#YoACQ¨¹/µ¨Yo²%=o²XL)²RG�½ ­ SBSXA{=oAJ²EQB<%GCGCV�¶�´ <ESX²Rµ¨==@?B´*<Rµ¨µ¨Yo²E<RLM? º V�àÕ²RQ¨¹�<%QBS6UWVXL#<%YM<(Ë ÌRÌnÍ�=o²2¹RA ® ´*<�³�²EY@°�<%G�D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQ(²R³�=@?¨´Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=@A ® ´3µ¨Yo²%=o²XL)²RGTD º V�°�´�<%QKD�²%³OD>=o<%=@´#¾y=oYo<RQBD>AJ=@AC²RQY@´�GC<%=@AC²RQ º <RD@´�S�AJQBµ¨IX=/Tn²RIX=oµ¨IX=Ï�»*YHÐ�<%IX=o²R°�<n=M<ÆË Û���Í�½ ­ QÆ»*Y <%I¨=@²R°�<%=@²RQÁµO´#Y@³�²RYo°�D�<%QÆ<ELg=@AC²RQÆACQÔ<�¹RA ® ´�QÆDa=M<n=@´D@IBLM?Æ=@?K<n=�A{=*°�<�V6=@YM<%QKD>AJ=@AC²RQÆ=o²6<kQ¨´#¶�D>=o<%=@´"<EL#L#²RYMSXAJQB¹�=@²6<k¹RA ® ´�QÁ=@YM<%QBD@A{=oAJ²EQYo´#GT<n=@AC²RQ�½�Ã3?¨ATD2Yo´#GT<n=oAJ²EQáACD"SX´�DoL)YoA º ´�SáAJQ <Ƶ¨Yo´�L)²EQBSXAJ=@AC²RQX¾f<RL)=@AC²RQX¾�´)ã¼´�L)=2Da=aVWGC´�=@²D@µK´�L)AJ³�V=o?¨´/LM?B<RQ¨¹R´�D�=@?K<n=�²XL#L#I¨Y�<ED�<HYo´�D@I¨G{=�²%³¸<%Q'<ELg=@AC²RQ�ACQ�=@?¨´/³�²RYo°ô²R³�<�D>AC°�µ¨GJ´µBD@´#IBS¨²%¾fL)²XSX´P=@?B<%=3ATD3<%µ¨µBGJAC´�S2=@²�<µ¨Y@´#¾�D>=o<%=@´/=@²�VWAJ´�GCS�<%Q¨²R=@?¨´�Y^D>=o<%=@´E½Gl�<RLM?"<%¹R´�Qv=ATD:°�²WS¨´#GCGJ´�S�<ED:<*µ¨Y@²XL#´�DoD�¶:?BACLM?¸·BAJQ�=@IBY@Q¸·XATD D@µK´�L)AJÈB´�S�<ED:<%Q�»*Y <%I¨=@²R°�<%=@²RQ�½ü�� "$#� � � � ý��Z��ù àá?¨´#Q£< D>´�Y ® ATL)´#¾�µ¨Yo² ® ACS¨AJQ¨¹Ç<%¹E´#Qv=(Yo´#¹RATD>=@´#YMD�AJ=oD@´#GJ³'¶:A{=o? =@?¨´°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=�=o²R¹R´#=@?¨´�Y�¶:A{=o?É<ÕSX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQɲ%³�A{=MD�L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D�D@µK´�L)AJÈB´�S¯ACQÉ<RQ<%¹EY@´�´�S ­ K^âPÊ�·�AJ=2ACD2Da=o²RYo´�SÉ<RD�<%Qá<ES ® ´�Y>=oACD@´#°�´#Qv='<%QKSÉ<ES¨SX´�SÝ=o²Á=@?¨´�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾<%¹E´#Qv=�Q D�S¨<n=M< º <ED>´E½^Ã3?WIBD�·�¶:?B´#Q <RQ <R¹R´#Qv=2ACQ¨µ¨I¨=oD�<ÔYo´�ÎvI¨´�Da="³�²RY�D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D#·�=@?¨´°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=�D>´�<%YMLM?¨´�D:AJ=oDPS¨<n=M< º <ED>´�²%³�<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD>´�°�´#Qv=oD3³�²EYP<'D@´#Y ® ACL#´)¾�µ¨Yo² ® ATSXACQ¨¹<%¹E´#Qv=�=o?B<n=3L#<RQ�ÈBGCG¼D@IBLM?'<�Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=�½WØ:´�ÎvI¨´�Da=MD�<RY@´:ÈKGJGC´�S�¶:?B´#Q'=o?¨´/µBY@² ® ATSX´#Y"Q D�<RSW¾® ´�Y>=oACD@´#°�´�QE=�ACDPD>I¨À�L#AJ´�Qv=@GCV�D@AC°*ACGT<%YP=@²'=o?¨´S¨´�DoL)YoAJµX=oAJ²EQ�²%³�=o?¨´Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=o´�S�D@´#Y ® ACL#´Ï×D@´#Y ® ACL#´P°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹vÐ)½ ­ D3°�´#Qv=oAJ²EQ¨´�S"< º ² ® ´P=@?¨´HYo´�ÎvI¨´�D>=@ACQ¨¹�<%¹E´#Qv=^?K<RD�=@²�SXACY@´�Lg=@GCVACQE=o´#YM<RL)=P¶:AJ=@?(=o?¨´*Y@´�GJ´ ® <RQv=Pµ¨Yo² ® ACSX´�Y =o²2² º =o<%ACQ�=o?¨´*D@´#Y ® ACL#´<RQBS(S¨<%=o<'AJ=!SX´�D@AJYo´�DÏ×D@´#Y ® ACL#´ ¹E<%=@?¨´�Y@ACQ¨¹WÐg½RælAC¹RI¨Yo´/Ѩ½ ÜH¹RA ® ´�D�<%Q�² ® ´#Y ® AJ´�¶Ý²%³¼=o?¨´/ACQv=@´#YM<RL)=@AC²RQ�µB<%=>=@´�Y@Q�²R³=@?BACD3=a¶^²%¾�µB<RY>=o´�S'°�<%=oLM?¨°�<%ÄWACQ¨¹�µ¨Yo²WL#´�DoD#½­ L�L)²EYoSXACQ¨¹H=o²�=@?BACD�AJQv=o´#YM<RLg=oAJ²EQ�µB<n=@=@´#YoQ2<RQ�»*Y <RIX=@²E°�<n=@²EQ�³�²RY^<!°�<n=oLM?B°�<RÄR´�Y

<%¹E´#Qv= L#<RQ º ´�D>µO´�L#A{ÈK´�S�<RD^³�²EGJGC²n¶ D#½

û ��üs�lý� �ý � �-û Ù<ýBrk7�:j+�h WX7"t%,9'D7�y :j)�W47�:j)�1%þ

ÿ b#_as{b��Ew{]oe������������ ���������������������������������������������������� !�����"#�%$ ���&'�����("���$ �*)!b#_a]�R_>b�+�c _a]Mef�X]Mhomasz��]owz�ápJ_aq�` maiv]Õef]@m�q�p�� � b�cW� d � b#|�]Mcnm�sJ�ReM}:_a]�,n�v]Me�maeM} �R_a]opT]@_a]McvhM]oeM}hgb#�Wb��Eszw{sumy�Ý�E]Mefho_asz�Rmas{q�cveM}�ef]o_a�%szhM]��vb#_>b#`!]oma]o_aeM}�mf_>b�cEeab�homaszq�cÉs{�EeM}�b#cW�Ôb�cÝq�_>�R]o_a]g�Æwzs{e�mq�pef]o_a�%szhM] � _a]�,n�v]oe�m�`�b#mah>iv]oeM�.-�iv]kef]om�q#pe�m>b)ma]Me�b#cW�Çmaiv]kefsz|�cWb)ma�E_a]6q�pb��Rmaq�`�b#maq�c/ sze��R]Mcvq#ma]g�Ç�n�0�*$(�$ ����1 /32 b�cv�0��465&7��$ 8�����1 /!2 }�_a]Mef�X]Mh@mas{��]Mwu�n�9-�iv](ef]om"q�pb#homaszq�cve���$���1 /32 szcvhMwz�v�E]Me�_a]MhM]os{��]:1;"<�*5 2 })ef]Mcv��1;"<�*5 2 }#b#cW�P`�b)mah@i�1;=�>�}1;������������������������� 2 }�? 2 �E] �cvq#maszcv|�pT�vcEhomaszq�cEe^pTq#_3_a]MhM]Msz�%szcv|b�cv�'ef]ocW�EszcE|�`!]oefeab�|�]oe3q�p�m��R�X]A@ b��E��]@_fmas{ef] � hMb��Wb#�vszwzsum��7@z}@ _a]�,n�v]Me�m � pCq�_ � ef]o_a�%szhM]�@z}B@ _a]Mef�Ewum�@{}Ob�cv�2_a]oma�R_acvszcv|b*�R]Mho_a]gb#efszcv|�wu�"q�_>�R]o_a]g�"wzsze�m q�pC?'ma�E�vwz]Me

Page 13: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

�-� ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

Requester

Provider

Matchmaker

1: Request-for-Service

0:D

Advertise, Unadvertise Services

3: Request-for-Service

2: Reply-Provider-Agents-Names

4:E

Reply-Result-of-Service

F G H I J K GL M N O P Q R S T

U V W X Y Z V[ \ ] ^ _ ` a b

ß<àuáâ�ã;âdc;â x�cnma]o_>b�h@mas{q�cP�vb#mfma]o_ac q#pvhgb#�Wb#�vszwzszmy�/b�cv�/ef]o_a�%szhM]Â`�b#mah>iv`�b��%szcv|��X]@m(+�]o]Mc/b�|�]oc%mae

1�1e����������� �*���f������*� 2 }������� ������� 2 �E]ocvq�maszcE|�maiE]g?*�X]Me�m3`�b)mah@iEszcv|�� � b#|�]McnmaeB���������1h+�sumai*_a]Mef�X]Mh@mas{��]:hgb��vb��vszwzsum��*�E]Mefh@_as{�Rmaszq�ci�������������� 2 }R_a]Mef�X]Mhomasz��]owz�n�-�iv]Pef]om:q#pÂmf_>b#cvefsumaszq�cvej$ ����&��:1 /!2jk �*$(�$ ����1 /32ml ���$��:1%��4;5&7�$(8����1 /32�2ml �*$ ��$����:1 /!2 �Wr`!s{�v�Rw{] � b#|�]Mcnm��X]o_fpCq�_a`!e�b�homaszq�cve¸mf_as{|�|�]o_a]M���n�/sumaeÂszcE�v�Emn+�iEszh@i�mf_>b#cvefsumaszq�c / szcnmaq b^��b�wzs{�e�m>b#ma]/b#cW��R_aq%�E�EhM]:efq�`!]:q��Ema�v�Rmg�Rx�cv�E�Em�b#cW�*q��Ema�E�Em�b#_a] �R]otWcE]g�szc*ma]@_a`!e�q�p�`!]Mefeab#|�]m��R�X]Me�maiE]:`!s{�v�Ewz] � b#|�]Mcnm�hgb#c*_a]MhM]os{��] b�cW�ef]McW�¨}R_a]oef�X]Mhomasz��]Mwu�n�

�Rsz|�cWb#ma�R_a]��szcv�v�Rmg�o1�b��E��]o_fmaszef] � hgb��vb��vszwzsum��#1e�����������������f������������������ !����" 2�21T_a]�,n�v]Me�m � pTq#_ � ef]o_a�%s{ho]�1;����������������h����������? 2�2q��Rma�v�Emg� 1;"i�*5 2 }"<�*5�prq���8��*�*�����������4%s6t1T_a]Mef�vwumg1;"���$ �*) 2�2 }�"���$ �*)ruwvx1�1e����������=�� �����f�������� 2 }���������������� 2zy

�%m>b)ma]MeM�{ �����f�|��v�vb)m>b��vb�ef] q�p�hMb��Wb#�vszwzsum��*�E]Mefho_asz�Rmas{q�cveM�{ ��*?~}H�~,n�v]M�E]^q�p�b�h>�RcEq�+�w{]M�E|�]o`!]Mcnmae�hMq�cnm>b�szcEs{cE|Pma�E�vwz]Me91e���������*}%ef�EhMhM]Mefe��gp�b#s{w 2 ]gb�h>iq#pn+�ivszh>i�sze�szcv�Eszhgb#maszcE|�maiv]^_a]oef�vwum�q�p�b�c�b��E��]o_fmaszef]M`!]Mcnmg�{ =��sh}H��,%�E]M�v] q#pl�R]Mwz]M|�b)maszq�cve^hMq�cnm>b�szcEs{cE|!ma�v�vwz]Meg1;�������*}�1;������������������46&��8�$ 2�2 ]Mb�h>i�q�p+�iEszh@is{eÂ_a]M�E_a]Mef]oc%maszcE|Hb:_a]�,n�v]Me�mC+�iEszh@i�iWb#e�cvq�ml�n]om��X]o]Mc�R_aqnhM]Mefef]g���n�!maiv]�`!sJ�E�Ewz] �b#|�]Mcnmg�{ "���$ ��)�}!�n,%�E]M�v]�q#p^`�b)mah@iEs{cE|'�Wb�su_aeHq#p^d � ��� � b�|�]oc%maePhMq�cnm>b#s{cEszcv|'ma�v�vwz]Me�1�1e���������*}������� 2 }'1;�����%}:������� 2�2 +�sumai�����������=�szcv�Eszhgb#maszcE|�maiE]P� � b�|�]Mcnm�maivb#m��X]Me�m3`�b)mah@iE]Me�maiv]_a]�,%�E]Me�m������/q�p�d � b�|�]Mcnm��������*�-K_>b#cvefsumaszq�cveM�

_a]MhM]Msz��]:1�1�b��E��]@_fmas{ef] � hMb��Wb#�vszwzsum��#1e����������� �����f������������������ !�����" 2�2�2��_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK� ��n� ]Mhomg�~�*���f�|!� uáb��v�o1;�*���f�|!}o1e����������� �����f������������������ !�����" 2�2��

Page 14: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| � \sup�b��v��1;�����f�|�}o1e����������� �*���f������*����������� !����" 2�2 ef�EhMhM]M]g�RemaiE]Mc���*?~}H� uÇb��E�X]McW�o1;���*?~}H}o1e���������*} ef�EhMhM]Mefe 2�2 ]Mwzef]��*?~}H� u3b��E�X]McW�o1;���*?~}H}�1e���������*} pTb�szw 2�2ef]McW�o1;"<�*5X}���������� 2��_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK�WiE]gb��o1;���?�} 2 uw1e������������"<�*5 2 }�n� ]Mhomg�~���?�}H� u�m>b#szw%1;��*?~} 2 �_a]MhM]Msz��]:1T_a]�,%�E]Me�m � pTq#_ � ef]@_a�RszhM]�1;���������(������;������� 2�2��_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK� ��n� ]Mhomg�~=��sh}H� uÇb��v�X]ocW��1;=��sh}H}71;������������������������� 2�2 �`�b#mah>i'1;�*���f�|!}71;������;��������� ������� 2 }~? 2��_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK�WiE]gb��o1;=��sh} 2 u�1;��������� ������;������� 2 ��n� ]Mhomg�~=��sh}H� u¯m>b�szw61;=��s�} 2��"���$ ��)�}!� uÇb#�v�X]Mcv��1;"���$(��)�}H}

1;�������*}R`�b#mah>i'1;�����f�|�}o1;����������������� ������� 2 }~? 2�2�2 �ef]McW�o1�1T_a]Mef�vwum.1;"���$(��) 2�2 }�������� 2��_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK�WiE]gb��o1;"���$ �*)�} 2 u�1;�������*}�"���$ �*) 2�n� ]Mhomg�~"���$(��)�}H� u¯m>b�szw61;"���$ �*)�} 2��

�� �#�U� � � ý��Z�Âù I3<RD@´�Sk²RQk=@?¨´³�I¨QBL)=@AC²RQB<RG�L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=aV�²%³ º Y@²EÄR´#YH<%¹E´#Qv=oDPACQX³�²RYo°�<%GCGJVSX´�D@L#Y@A º ´�SÝACQÇD>´�Lg=@AC²RQÉѨ½uÛX½uÛ�=o?¨´�AJQv=@´�Yo<ELg=oAJ²EQݵB<%=>=@´�Y@Q¯²%³ º Y@²EÄR´�Y@ACQ¨¹kATD�D>?B²n¶:QÝACQÈB¹EI¨Y@´!ÑB½ Ì º ´#GC²n¶!½

Requester

Provider

Broker

1: Request-for-Service

0:D

Advertise, Unadvertise Services

3: Request-for-Service/Transaction

5:�

Reply-Result-of-Services

4: Transmit Result-of-Service

ß<àuáâ�ã;âx�Uâ x�cnma]o_>b�h@mas{q�c��Wb)mfma]o_ac*q#p�hgb#�Wb��Eszw{sumy��b#cW�*ef]o_a�%szhM]:�R_aq���]o_aszcE|H�X]om(+l]M]Mc*b�|�]oc%mae

­ L�L)²EYoSXACQ¨¹�=@²�=o?¨ATD º <RD@ATLACQv=@´�Yo<ELg=@AC²RQÕµB<%=>=@´�Y@QÆ<RQÕ»*Y�<%IX=o²R°�<n=o²RQ6³�²RY�< º Yo²%¾ÄR´�YP<R¹R´#Qv=PL�<%Q º ´SX´#ÈBQ¨´�S(<RD ³�²RGCGJ²n¶ D�½KâPI¨´�=o²"D@µB<RL#´�L)²EQBD>=@YM<%ACQE=MD:¶^´�²R°�AJ=>=@´�S�=@²ACQBL)GCIBSX´�=@?¨´�²EµX=@AC²RQ�²R³�=@?¨´ º Y@²EÄR´�Y3=@²'ACQBSXA ® ACSXIK<%GCGJV�Q¨´#¹E²%=oAC<%=@´�D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D:´#¿W´�L)IX=oAJ²EQ

Page 15: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

�g� ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

¶:AJ=@?�=@?¨´!Yo´#GC´ ® <RQE= Ö�¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD�²EQ º ´#?K<%GJ³l²R³lAJ=oD L#GJAC´#Qv=MD#½

û ��üs�lý� �ý � � ú Ù<ý%��'�)�t�,d'w7oy :S)oWX7o:S)o1oþ

�R]o]��E]@tWcvsumaszq�c � pCq�_��E]@tWcvsumaszq�c6q�p^e�m>b#ma]MeM}Â��b)_as{b��vwz]MeM}lb�h@mas{q�cveM}Â`!]Mefeab�|�]*m��R�X]MeM��xycb��E�Esumaszq�cB}Â��b#_as{b#�vwz]MeA46&���8�$o}B�!����8fsd$ �.�f��������46����}���b#_a]��R_>b�+�ckpJ_aq�` maiE]*ef]om!q#p:szcv�E�Emaecv]o]g�E]g��pTq�_^ef]o_a�%szhM] ]*�R]MhM�Emaszq�cveM}v_a]oef�vwumae�maiE]o��|�]McE]o_>b#ma]�}¨b�cv�*szc%ma]o|�]o_g}E_a]Mef�X]Mhomasz��]Mwu�n��-�iv]`!]Mefeab#|�]�m��R�X]!@ �E_aq���]o_>b�|�] � d3�¸�f@nb�cv��@ �X]o_fpTq#_a` � � � @�szcW�Rs{hMb#ma]�maiWb#m¸maiE]�`!s{�E�Ewz] � b�|�]McnmÂivb�emaq��R_aq���]o_:maiE]�_a]�,n�v]oe�m:pTq�_/ef]o_a�%szhM]�}Ob�cv�2maivb#m ]gb#h@i�q#p�maiv]�hMq�cnm>b�h@ma]g��� � b�|�]oc%mae ivb�e:maq�X]o_fpCq�_a`£_a]�,%�E]Me�ma]g��ef]o_a�%szhM]/]*�R]MhM�Emaszq�c�1Tmf_>b#cveab#homaszq�c 2 |�sz��]Mc�maiv] s{�B}Bb#cW���R_a]opT]o_a]ocvhM]Me^q�pmaiv]�_a]�,%�E]Me�maszcv|:d � b�|�]oc%mg}#_a]Mef�X]Mh@mas{��]Mwu�n��x×mÂszeÂb�efef�E`!]g�PmaiWb)m¸maiv]�b��E�Esumaszq�cvb�wvszcE�v�Em�cE]M]g�E]M�pTq#_ szc%ma]@_a`!]g�Es{b#maszq�c2q#plmf_>b#cveab�h@mas{q�cve�1�ef�Eh@i2b�e:�vbM�E`!]oc%m�szcEpCq�_a`�b#maszq�c 2 sze3�%cvq�+�c�maq�maiv]�E_aq���]o_Âb�|�]Mcnmg��-�iE]�e�m>b)ma]MeÂb#_a]�`!]gb#c%m¸maq3�X]�szc!b��v�Rszmaszq�cHmaq^maiv]�e�m>b)ma]Melb#wu_a]gb��%�!�E]oefho_asz�X]g�szc��E]@tWcvsumaszq�c � ��Rsz|�cWb#ma�R_a]��

szcv�v�Rmg�o1�b��E��]o_fmaszef] � hgb��vb��vszwzsum��#1e�����������������f������������������ !����" 2�21��E_aq���]o_>b�|�] � d3�¸�#1;���������(������h����������46&���8�$*��? 2�21T_a]Mef�vwumg16�!����8fsd$��.�f�n������4%�*�:� $ ���&'��� 2�2q��Rma�v�Emg�o1;"i��5 2 }�"i��5�p<q���8�����������������4%s6t1��X]o_fpTq#_a` � � � 1�1;�������h��������� 46&��8�$ 2 }����������z$ ���&'��� 2�21T_a]Mef�vwumg16�!����8fsd$��.�f�n������4%�*�:������� 2�2

�%m>b)ma]MeM�{ / ����&7�*�!��������4;$@�Eef]@m�q#p¸ma�v�vwz]Me.1T_a]�,nx � }Emf_>b#cvefx � 2 s{cv�Eszhgb)mas{cE|HmaiWb)m�maiE]:`!s{�v�Ewz] � b#|�]Mcnmsze�e�maszwzw�+�b�sumaszcv|�pTq#_�maiv]¸_a]Mef�vwum�q#pvmaiv]¸mf_>b�cEeab�homaszq�cPmf_>b�cEefx � maq��X]Âef]McnmOmaq�maiv]Â_a]oef�X]Mhomasz��]_a]�,%�E]Me�ma]o_�_a]�,nx � �{ ������}!��,n�E]M�v]�q�p�ef]o_a�%szhM]3]��E]ohM�Emaszq�c#1Tmf_>b�cEeab�homaszq�c 2 _a]Mef�vwumae�hMq�c%m>b#szcvszcv|�ma�E�vwz]Me91;�������*}�3����8fs�$��.�f�n������46����}�$(���&���� 2 ]gb#h@i�q�p�+�ivszh>i�szcEhMwz�W�E]oelmaiv]�_a]Mef�vwum�q#pKmaiE]�mf_>b#cveab#homaszq�c$(���&����-_a]gb��%�!maqH�X]^mf_>b#cvef`!sumfma]g�!maqPmaiv]�_a]Mef�X]Mhomasz��]3d � b�|�]Mcnmm�������*�Ref]om�q�p¼ma�E�vwz]Me1;�������($ ����&���� 2 ]gb�h>i!q�p7+�iEs{h>i��E]McEq�ma]Me¸maiv]�`�b#�v�vszcE|3q�pKb^_a]�,n�v]oe�mÂmaq:sumaeÂmf_>b#cveab#homaszq�cs{�¨�-K_>b#cvefsumaszq�cveM�

_a]MhM]Msz��]:1�1�b��E��]@_fmas{ef] � hMb��Wb#�vszwzsum��#1e����������� �����f������������������ !�����" 2�2�2��_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK� ��n� ]Mhomg�~�*���f�|!� uáb��v�o1;�*���f�|!}o1e����������� �����f������������������ !�����" 2�2��sup�b��v��1;�����f�|�}o1e����������� �*���f������*����������� !����" 2�2 ef�EhMhM]M]g�RemaiE]Mc���*?~}H� uÇb��E�X]McW�o1;���*?~}H}o1e���������*} ef�EhMhM]Mefe 2�2]ow{ef].���?�}H� uÇb��v�X]ocW��1;��*?~}H}�1e���������*} p�b#szw 2�2ef]McW�o1;"<�*5f����������� 2��_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK�WiE]gb��o1;���?�} 2 uw1e������������"<�*5 2�n� ]Mhomg�~���?�}H� uÉm>b#s{w61;���?�} 2 �_a]MhM]Msz��]:1��R_aq���]@_>b�|�] � dj�¸��1;���������(������;��������� ? 2�2��_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK� ��n� ]Mhomg�~=��sh}H� uÇb��v�X]ocW��1;=��sh}H}71;������������������������� 2�2 }��E� u!? �`�b#mah>i'1;�*���f�|!}71;������;��������� ������� 2 }~? 2��_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK�WiE]gb��o1;=��sh} 2 u�1;��������� ������;������� 2 ��n� ]Mhomg�~=��sh}H� u¯m>b�szw61;=��s�} 2��"���$ ��)�}!� uÇb#�v�X]Mcv��1;"���$(��)�}H}

1;�������*}R`�b#mah>i'1;�����f�|�}o1;����������������� ������� 2 }~? 2�2�2 �ef]McW�o1��X]o_fpTq#_a` � � � 1�1;������;���������(4%&��8~$ 2 }~���������($ ���&���� 2 }���������� 2

Page 16: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| � ���_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK�WiE]gb��o1;"���$ �*)�} 2 u1;�������*}ovo1�1e�����������(�*���f������*� 2 }��������(������� 2Byn2�� ���  �n� ]Mhomg�~"���$(��)�}H� u¯m>b�szw61;"���$ �*)�} 2�� ��� �/ ����&7�*�!��������4;$@� u / ���&7���!�������4;$7�iq�1;��������� $ ���&������(����� 2 t �_a]MhM]Msz��]:1�1T_a]oef�vwumg16�!����8�sd$��.�f�n������46�*���($ ����&���� 2�2 }���������� 2��_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK� ��n� ]Mhomg�~������}H� uÇb��E�X]McW�o1;������}H}1;�����������!����8fsd$ �.�f�n������46���:� $(���&���� 2�2��/ ����&7�*�!��������4;$@� u / ���&7���!�������4;$7��q1;���������($ ����&������ ����� 2 t �� �P� u � � �iq�1h$ ���&'����������� 2 tef]McW�o1�1T_a]Mef�vwum.16�!����8fsd$ �.�f��������46���:������� 2 }�������� 2��_a]MhMq�cW�Rszmaszq�cK�WiE]gb��o1;������} 2 uw1;�����������!����8fsd$ �.�f�n������46���:� $(���&���� 2��1h$(���&������ ����� 2 p � ��n� ]Mhomg� / ���&7���!�������4;$o� u / ����&7�*�!��������4;$f��q1;��������� $(���&���� 2 t �� �P� u � � ��q1h$(���&������������ 2 t �������}!� u¯m>b#s{w61;������} 2 �

¡

�3 z¢¤£¦¥:êC§©¨�öaï�ñƧ�ì�è6§3§�¦B©P¬>¤ êl¥¨¬a§�¤ ò ¬>ê ð^︦¨ò:¬@«¼ï-óõêÂ¥¨«�ªg§ êC«3¬@¤ îê�¤/©­¬Á¦¨§�«�︦B¬@¤ î

»fQ"=@?¨´�³�²RGCGC²n¶:AJQ¨¹*¶^´HS¨´�DoL)YoA º ´PµBY@²E°*ACQ¨´�QE=3´)¿¨<R°*µBGJ´�D3²%³�AC°�µ¨GJ´�°�´#Qv=@´�S"°I¨GJ=@AT<%¹R´�Qv=D@VWD>=@´�°�D�<RQBS(µBGC<%=>³�²RYo°�D/¶:?BACLM?Õ<%Yo´L)²W²EYoSXACQB<%=@´�S º V�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD ® AC<2=@?¨´*°�´)¾SXAT<n=oAJ²EQɵBY@²R=@²XL)²EGCD*³�²EY2D>´�Y ® ATL)´�°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄWAJQB¹Ô<%QBS º Yo²RÄE´#YoAJQ¨¹K½�Ã3?¨´�D@´�´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´�D<%Yo´*»a;(Ö ­ K^ÃH·�Ø�l�à UW»gô ­ T%Ê ­ Ø/F�U¼·�<%QBSk»fQX³�²vUWGC´#I¨=@?¸·�Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=oA ® ´#GCVR½öY/=@?¨´�YPYo´#GT<n¾=@´�S�¶�²EY@Ä'ATD:D@I¨Y ® ´#VE´�S'ACQ�D>´�Lg=oAJ²EQ�ÑB½ ÜB½ ÌK½»�=�ACD�QB²%=@´�¶�²EY>=o?WVH=@?B<%=�°�´�SXAC<%=@AC²RQ�<RL#Y@²vD@D°�I¨GJ=@AT<%¹E´#Qv=�D>VXD>=@´�°�D º ²RIBQBS¨<%YoAC´�Dl?B<RD

D>=@ACGJG�Q¨²R=^Yo´�L#´#A ® ´�S�°�IBLM?�<n=@=@´#Qv=oAJ²EQ�=@?¨²EI¨¹R?"A{=:ATD3<�L)YoIBL#AC<RGOATDoD>I¨´PAJQ�²RµO´#Q"´#Q ® AJYo²RQ¨¾°�´#Qv=oD�GJACÄR´*=o?¨´'»fQv=@´�Y@Q¨´#=�½�ælACYoD>=�D>=@´#µKD!AJQÁ=o?¨ATD�SXACY@´�Lg=@AC²RQÁACQBL)GCIBSX´�=o?¨´2Ø�l�à UW»gô ­ACQE=o´#Yo²RµO´#YM<n=o²RY3Ë{Ú�Ü�Í º ´)=a¶^´#´#Q*?¨´#=@´#Yo²R¹E´#Q¨´�²RIBDl<%¹E´#Qv=�D>²XL)AC´)=oAJ´�D�<%QBS°�IBG{=oA{¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�D@VXDa¾=@´�°�D#½

ø�ùuõ�ù×û¯®d� �S�n° ����ùö "�»fQX³�²WUWGJ´�IX=@? Ë Ü�J�ÍP?K<RD º ´#´�Q SX´ ® ´#GC²RµO´�S º VÇ; K�K »fQBLR½�ACQ ­ IBD>=@ACQ¸·:ô)¿¨<RD�·�òPU ­ ½»�=�ATD!<%QÆ<%¹E´#Qv=>¾ º <RD@´�SkD>VXD>=@´#°.=@?B<%=�L#<%Q º ´'L)²RQ¨ÈB¹RI¨Yo´�S(=@²�µO´#Y@³�²RYo°1SXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=HACQX¾³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQ¯°�<%QK<%¹R´�°�´#Qv=�<ELg=oA ® AJ=@AC´�D�ACQÉSXATD>=@YoA º I¨=@´�SÇ<Rµ¨µ¨GCACL�<n=@AC²RQKD*D@IBLM?Ç<RD*ACQÉ<RQ´ ® ACY@²EQ¨°�´#Qv=o<RG�SB<n=o<Ý´)¿¨LM?B<RQ¨¹R´(QB´)=a¶^²RYoÄÇ<RQBS L#²R°�µK´#=@AJ=@A ® ´ÕAJQv=o´#GCGJAC¹R´�QBL)´ÕD>VXD>=@´#°�½»fQX³�²WUWGJ´�IX=@?�²RãO´�YoD3<�D@´)=:²%³ ® <%YoAJ²EIBD3<%¹E´#Qv=oD3¶:AJ=@?�SXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=3Yo²RGC´�D:<ED^³�²RGCGJ²n¶ D�½

ò/D@´#Y!<R¹R´#Qv=MD�<ELg=H²RQ º ´�?B<%GJ³�²R³�IBD@´#YMDH<%QBS6AJQv=o´#Y@³×<RL)´=@?B´#°é=o²"=o?¨´�Y@´�Da=H²%³�=@?¨´<%¹E´#Qv=ÂD@VXDa=o´#°�·#Yo´�D@²RI¨YML)´�<R¹R´#Qv=MD�¶:Yo<Rµ�<%QBS!<ELg=oA ® <n=o´�S¨<%=o< º <RD@´�D�<%QKS!²%=o?¨´#Y¸ACQX³�²EY@°�<n¾=@AC²RQ�D@²RI¨YML)´�D#ÅG� º Yo²RÄR´�Y^<R¹R´�QE=MD*�µO´#Y@³�²RYo° D@VvQv=M<RLg=oACLH<RQBS�D>´�°�<RQv=@ATLP°�<%=oLM?¨°�<%ÄWACQ¨¹BŲRQv=o²RGC²R¹RV6<%¹R´�Qv=oD!L)²EGJGC´�L)=@A ® ´�GJV6°�<RAJQv=M<%ACQÁ<�ÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�S¨¹R´ º <ED>´�²R³�=o?¨´2SXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=�²RQX¾=@²EGJ²E¹RAC´�D�IBD>´�SƳ�²EYD@µK´�L)AJ³�VvACQ¨¹ÕY@´�ÎvI¨´�D>=oD<%QBSÆYo´)=oI¨YoQÔ²RQv=@²EGJ²E¹RATL#<RG�AJQ¨³�²RYo°�<%=@AC²RQƲEQ

Page 17: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

� Þ ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

SX´�°�<RQBS�Å�°�IBG{=oA{¾�Y@´�D>²EI¨YML)´'<%¹E´#Qv=oDµ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD�L#²R°�µ¨GC´)¿ÔÎvI¨´#YoAC´�D!=o?B<n=�D@µB<%QÔ°I¨GJ=@ACµ¨GJ´?¨´#=@´#Yo²R¹E´#Q¨´�²RIBD�Yo´�D@²RIBYoL#´�D�·�D@µO´�L)AJÈB´�S�AJQ*=@´�Y@°�D�²R³¼D@²R°�´ SX²E°�<%ACQ*²EQv=@²RGC²R¹EVR½næ¨IBY>=o?¨´#Y<%¹E´#Qv=�Yo²RGC´�D�L)²EQBL)´�Y@Q�=M<RD@Ä�µ¨GC<RQ¨Q¨ACQ¨¹<RQBS'´#¿X´�L)I¨=@AC²RQ¸·v°�²RQ¨AJ=@²EY@ACQ¨¹�²R³�S¨<n=M<�D>=@Yo´�<R°�D<%QKS�D@VXDa=o´#°�²EµK´�Yo<%=@AC²RQBD�·X<%QBS�²R=@?¨´�Y D>µO´�L#AC<RGJACÓ#´�S'³�I¨QKLg=@AC²RQKD#½­ QWV�Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�ACQ2<�¹EA ® ´#Q'»fQ¨³�²vUWGC´#IX=o?"D@VXDa=o´#° <%Q¨QB²RI¨QBL#´�D�A{=MD>´�G{³¸=o²�²EQ¨´/²EY�°�IBG{¾

=@ACµ¨GC´�°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄR´�Y <%¹E´#Qv=oD�ÏyL#<RGJGC´�S{� º Y@²EÄR´#Y <R¹R´�QE=MD*�vÐ º V�<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD>ACQ¨¹*=@²2A{=�·BIBD@AJQB¹=@?B´/=o´#Yo°�D^<%QKS'<n=@=@YoA º I¨=@´�D^SX´�D@L#Y@A º ´�S�ACQ2<�L#²R°�°�²RQ'D@?B<%Yo´�S�²EQE=o²RGC²R¹EV�ÏyL#<%GCGC´�S��RAJQX¾³�²ED@GC´#IX=o?Ô²RQv=@²EGJ²E¹RV �EÐ�<%=>=@YoA º IX=@´�D�<RQBSÆL)²EQBDa=oYo<RAJQv=MD!²RQÁ=o?¨´ ® <%GCI¨´�D�²%³3=o?¨²ED@´2<n=@=@YoA{¾º IX=o´�D�½:Ã3?¨ACD�D@µK´�L)AT<%GH²RQv=o²RGC²R¹RVÉATD"D@?B<%Yo´�S º V <RGJGH<%¹E´#Qv=oD2=@²¯IBD@´k³�²EY�D@µK´�L)AJ³�VWAJQ¨¹<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD@´#°�´#Qv=oDH<RQBSkYo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=MD#½¼»�=�L#²RQv=o<RAJQBDHL#²RQBL#´#µX=MDHIBD>´#³�I¨G�=@²(S¨´)ÈBQ¨´�Ïy<EÐP¶:?B<n=ÄWAJQKS�²%³�L)²EQv=@´#Qv=/ATD/<EL#L#´�DoD>A º GC´ º V�<%Q(<R¹R´�QE=�·ÂÏ º Ð:¶:?B<%=PD@´#Y ® ATL)´�D <%Q(<R¹R´�QE=�L#<%Q�SX²³�²RYP¶:?¨²R°�·�ÏyL�Ð ¶:?B<n=/<RY@´H=o?¨´�ACQE=o´#Y@³×<RL#´�D3=o²�=@?¨²vD>´�D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D�·�Ï×SKÐ3?¨²n¶ ¶�´�GJGÂL#<%Q�<RQ<%¹E´#Qv=PµO´#Y@³�²RYo°ë=@?¨²vD>´�D@´#Y ® ATL)´�D/<%=P=o?¨´°�²E°*´�Qv=�·¼<%QBS¯Ï�´�Ð/²%=o?¨´#Y�µ¨Yo²RµO´#Y@=@AC´�DP²%³�<RQ<%¹E´#Qv= D>IKLM?�<ED3GJ²XL#<%=@AC²RQ¸·XIKD>´�S�L#²R°�°�IBQ¨ACL�<n=oAJ²EQ"µ¨Yo²%=o²XL)²RGTD�·v´#=oLR½­ ¹E´#Qv= L#<RµB< º ACGCA{=oAJ´�D:<%Yo´�Yo´#µBY@´�D>´�QE=o´�S2AJQ�»fQX³�²WUWGJ´�IX=@?�<%=:³�²RGCGJ²n¶:ACQ¨¹*³�²RI¨Y:GC´ ® ´#GTD#ÙÚE½^=@?¨´H<%¹E´#Qv=�L)²EQ ® ´#YMDo<n=@AC²RQKD�=@?B<%=^<RY@´PIBD>´�S�=@²*L)²E°*°I¨Q¨ATL#<%=@´P< º ²EIX=�=o?¨´HD>´�Y ® ATL)´R·Û¨½^=@?¨´!ACQv=@´#Y@³×<RL#´�=@²*=@?¨´�D@´#Y ® ACL#´R·ÜB½^=@?¨´!ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQ�<�D@´#Y ® ATL)´H²EµK´�Yo<%=@´�D^² ® ´#Y�·W<RQBSÌK½^=@?¨´�D@´#°�<%Qv=oACL�D3²%³Â¶:?K<n=:=@?B´�D>´�Y ® ATL)´HSX²W´�D�½ælAJ¹EI¨Yo´2Ѩ½N�(D@?¨²n¶ D�<RQÆ´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´2²R³:=@?¨´�D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQƲ%³�<�µB<%ACY*²%³ °�<n=MLM?¨AJQB¹

ÎvI¨´#YoV2<RQBS�L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=aV'SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=@AC²RQ�ACQ�»fQ¨³�²vUWGC´#IX=o?(<RSX²EµX=@´�S'³�Yo²R° Ë [%Í�½

Advertisementcapability env-subscriptionontol± ogy conversatiì on cl² ass conversation slot³ conversation-type in

´ {subscribe}

slot³ language in {kqml}ontol± ogy sqlontol± ogy services class data-response slot³ language in

´ { tuple-format}

slot³ delivery in´

{http,inline} cl² ass subscription slot³ computation in {direct}ontol± ogy environmµ ent cl² ass site slot³ contaminant slot³ remedial-response slot³ city slot³ state in {Texas}

Qu¶

erycapability subscribe-to-capabilityontol± ogy conversatiì on cl² ass conversation slot³ conversation-type in

´ {subscribe}

slot³ language in {kqml}ontol± ogy sqlontol± ogy services class data-response slot³ language in

´ { tuple-format}

slot³ delivery in´

{inl ine} cl² ass subscription slot³ computation in {direct}ontol± ogy environmµ ent cl² ass site slot³ contaminant slot³ city in {A ustin} slot³ state in {Texas}

ß<àuáâ�ã;âd·GâB� �Eb�`!�Ewz]3q�p�,n�E]o_f�b�cW��hgb��vb��Es{wzsum��*�E]oefho_asz�Emaszq�cEe�szc*xycEpCqn�Rwz]M�Rmai

»fQ�=o?¨ACD�´#¿X<R°�µ¨GJ´*<'Yo´�D@²RI¨YML)´�<R¹R´�QE=�QB<%°�´�SúQ =@¿W¾�´�Q ® ¾�Y@´�D>²EI¨YML)´%QBACD�< º GC´�=o²2µ¨Yo²%¾® ACS¨´�´�Q ® ACYo²RQ¨°�´#Qv=M<%G¼L)²RQv=M<%°�AJQK<n=@AC²RQ2AJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ2Yo´#GT<n=o´�S'=@²�L)²EQE=M<%°�ACQB<n=o´�S'D@A{=o´�D

Page 18: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| � �

ACQ(Ã�´#¿X<ED#½B»fQ�=@?¨ATD Yo´�D@µK´�Lg= AJ=P<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD@´�D3¹R´�Q¨´#YoATL!L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D/D>IBLM?�<ED3=@?¨´*< º ACGCA{=aV=@² º ´�°�²EQ¨A{=o²RYo´�S�·¨=@² º ´�ÎvI¨´#YoAJ´�S�<%QBS�D@I º DoL)YoA º ´�S�=o²B½BÊÂ<n=>=o´#Y/L�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=aV"L#²RQBD@ACD>=oD²%³�<D>´#=�²%³¸Yo´#GT<n=o´�S�²EQE=o²RGC²R¹EV�³�YM<%¹R°�´�QE=MD�<EL#L)²EYoS¨AJQ¨¹H=o²�=o?¨´/GC´ ® ´#GTD�²%³�L�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=aVYo´)¾µ¨Yo´�D@´#Qv=o<%=@AC²RQBD^°�´#Qv=oAJ²EQ¨´�S"< º ² ® ´RÙv=o?¨´!L)²RQ ® ´#YMD@<%=@AC²RQ�²RQv=o²RGC²R¹RV*³�YM<%¹E°*´�Qv=^D@µK´�L)AJÈB´�D=@?K<n=�=o?¨´P<R¹R´�QE=�<EL#L#´#µX=MD�L)²EQ ® ´#YMDo<n=@AC²RQKD�²%³¼=@?¨´/³�²RYo°£IKD>´�S º V�D@I º DoL)YoAJµX=oAJ²EQBD�·RIBD@AJQB¹=@?B´:GC<RQ¨¹RIB<R¹R´^F���;(Ê�½nÃ3?¨´:D@ÎvGW²RQv=@²EGJ²E¹RV�³�YM<%¹R°�´�QE=�D@µK´�L)AJÈB´�DÂ=o?B<n=�ÎvI¨´�Y@AC´�Dl?B< ® ´�=@²º ´ D>µO´�L#A{ÈB´�S*AJQ*=@?B´:Y@´�GC<%=@AC²RQB<RGWSB<n=o< º <RD@´:ÎvI¨´#YoV!GC<RQ¨¹RIK<%¹R´:U;��Ê�½RÃ3?¨´3´#Q ® AJYo²RQB°*´�Qv=²RQv=o²RGC²R¹RV�³�Yo<R¹R°�´#Qv=�D@µK´�L)AJÈB´�D�L)GT<RDoD>´�D�<%QBS�D@GC²%=oD�¶:?¨ATLM?'L)²RQv=M<%ACQ�SB<n=o<HACQ�=o?¨´/<%¹E´#Qv=�½ælAJQK<%GCGJVE·X=@?¨´!D@´#Y ® ACL#´P²EQE=o²RGC²R¹EV�³�Yo<R¹R°�´#Qv=:D>µO´�L#A{ÈB´�D^=@?B<%=:=@?¨´!<ES ® ´�Y>=oACD@´�S"D>´�Y ® ATL)´�ACD<RL�L)´�D@D@´�S"GJ²XL�<%GCGJV'¶:AJ=@?BAJQ�=@?B´�<%¹R´�Qv=:<ED3¶�´�GJG¸<ED3²%=o?¨´#Y:µ¨Yo²RµO´#Y@=@AC´�D�½Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�³�²EY@°I¨GT<n=@´:Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=�³�²RY�D@´#Y ® ACL#´�D�GCACÄR´:=o?¨´/²EQ¨´/D@?¨²n¶:Q�AJQ�=o?¨´/´#¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´

< º ² ® ´�ACQÉ=@´#Yo°�D�²%³P=@?¨´kAJQX³�²vD>GC´#I¨=@?DzRQv=@²EGJ²E¹RVE½�Ã3?B´�°�<%=oLM?¨°�<RÄR´#Y*=o?¨´#Qá°�<n=MLM?¨´�D=@?B´�Yo´�ÎvI¨´�D>= =o²2Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD3¶:?¨²vD>´<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD>´�°*´�Qv=oD L#²RYoY@´�D>µO²RQBS"=o²�=@?¨´*L)²EQBDa=oYo<RAJQv=MDD@µK´�L)AJÈB´�SkAJQ�=o?¨´*Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=�·¼<%QBS�Yo´)=oI¨YoQBDP<2Y@´�L)²E°*°�´�QBS¨<n=oAJ²EQ(L)²EQE=M<%ACQ¨ACQ¨¹�=@?B²ED@´Ö�¾<%¹E´#Qv=oD�=@²/=@?¨´3Ø3¾f<%¹E´#Qv=�½�Ø:´�D@²RI¨YML)´^<%¹E´#Qv=oD�¶:?¨²ED@´�S¨<%=o< º <RD@´�DÂSX²/Q¨²R=l°�<RAJQv=o<RAJQS¨<n=M<ACQ(=@´�Y@°�DP²%³�=o?¨´L#²R°�°�²RQ(²EQE=o²RGC²R¹EV"<RL�L)´�D@DPD>µO´�L#AC<RG°�<%µBµ¨AJQB¹"<%¹E´#Qv=oD =@²"µK´�Y>³�²EY@°<%µBµ¨Y@²Eµ¨YoAC<%=@´�²RQv=@²EGJ²E¹RV�°�<%µ¨µBAJQ¨¹�<ELg=@AC²RQKD#½å�A ® ´#Q"<�ÎvI¨´#YoV�² ® ´�Y�<�D@ACQ¨¹RGC´PSX²E°�<%ACQX¾�D@µO´�L)AJÈKL/²RQv=@²EGJ²E¹RVR·v<�ÎvI¨´�Y@V�<%¹E´#Qv=^L#²W²RY@¾

SXACQB<n=o´�DÂ=@?B´�µ¨Yo²XL)´�D@D@AJQB¹ ²%³¨=o?¨´^Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>= º V'Ï×<vиL)²EGJGT< º ²RYM<n=oAJQB¹ ¶:A{=o?�²EQ¨´�²EY°I¨GJ=@ACµ¨GJ´°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄR´�YoDl=o²!ACS¨´#Qv=@AJ³�VYo´#GC´ ® <RQE=�Yo´�D@²RI¨YML)´:<R¹R´#Qv=MD#·¨Ï º Ð�SX´�L)²R°�µO²ED@AJQB¹P=o?¨´/ÎvI¨´�Y@VACQE=o²�<L#²RGCGJ´�Lg=@AC²RQ"²%³�D>I º ÎvI¨´#YoAC´�D^´�<ELM?"<RSBSXY@´�D@D@´�S'=@²*=@?B´�D@´H<R¹R´�QE=MD#·W<%QKS6ÏyL�Ð�³�IBD@AJQ¨¹=@?B´�D@I º ÎvI¨´#YoV�Y@´�D>I¨GJ=oD�ACQv=@²"<RQkACQv=@´#¹EYo<%=@´�S(<%QBD@¶^´#Y =o²2=o?¨´�²RYoAJ¹EAJQK<%G�¹EGJ² º <%G�ÎvI¨´#YoVR½»aDoD>I¨´�Dl²%³OD@I º ÎvI¨´#YoVH=@YM<%QBD@GT<n=@AC²RQ<%QBS´)¿X´�L#IX=@AC²RQ º ´�AJQB¹P´�QBL#<RµBD>IBGC<%=@´�S�¶:A{=o?�=o?¨´3Y@´�Da¾µO´�Lg=oA ® ´!Y@´�D>²EI¨YML)´H<%¹R´�Qv=�½¨Ã3?¨´!Yo´�D@²RI¨YML)´!<R¹R´#Qv=MD�°�<�V2L#²RQv=@ACQWIB<%GCGCV'´#Qv=@´�Y/<%QKS"GC´�< ® ´=@?B´HD@VXDa=o´#°�·XD>IKLM?'=@?K<n=3=@?¨´HÎvI¨´#YoV'<%¹E´#Qv=^S¨²v´�D^Q¨²%=:L)Yo´�<%=@´H<%QBS2°�<RAJQv=M<%ACQ"<�¹EGJ² º <%GACQE=o´#¹EYo<%=@´�S�ACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQ�°*²XSX´�GK²R³¼=@?¨´�<%¹R´�Qv=�D>²XL)AC´)=aVE½R»fQ'D@I¨°�°�<%YoVR·RACQ'»fQX³�²WUWGC´#IX=o?=@?B´�ÎEIB´#YoV2<%¹E´#Qv=3<RQBS2=@?¨´�� º Y@²EÄR´�Y���<R¹R´�QE= <ELg=oD:<ED3< º Y@²EÄR´#Y:<RQBS"<*°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄE´#Y�·Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=@A ® ´�GJVE½

ò Q¨³�²RY@=@I¨QB<%=@´�GJVE·�=@?¨´�´#¿X<ELg='<%QKS¯L#²R°�µ¨GC´)=@´�µ¨Yo²XL)´�D@D*²%³HÎvI¨´#YoVÝSX´�L)²R°�µO²ED@A{=oAJ²EQ³�²RY3¹E´#Q¨´�Yo<RGOÎvI¨´�Y@AC´�D�Ï�Q¨²R=±aIKDa= S¨<%=o< º <RD@´PÎvI¨´�Y@AC´�DMÐ�²EY�=o?¨´�µ¨Y@²XL#´�DoD�²R³�°�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹*ACQ=@?B´»fQX³�²WUWGC´#IX=o?ÕD@VXDa=o´#° ?B<RDPQ¨²R=�VE´)= º ´#´�QkYo´ ® ´�<%GC´�S�ACQ(=o?¨´*GJAJ=@´�Yo<%=@I¨Yo´R½�� ²n¶^´ ® ´#Y�·¶:?B<%=�ACD�ÄvQB²n¶:Q³�Yo²R°ô=@?¨´/GJAJ=@´�Yo<%=@I¨Yo´:ACD�=@?B<%=�D>´�Y ® ATL)´:°�<n=MLM?¨ACQ¨¹!²XL#L)IBYoD�<%=�SXAJãO´�Y@´�QE=GC´ ® ´�GCD�ÙvUXVvQv=M<RLg=oACLR·ED@´#°�<%Qv=oACLR·E<%QKS�µ¨Yo<R¹R°�<n=oACL3°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹B½E»fQ'»fQX³�²WUWGJ´�IX=@?�·vD@VWQE=M<RL)=@ATL°�<n=MLM?¨AJQB¹�Yo´)³�´�YoDÂ=o²P=o?¨´3µ¨Yo²WL#´�DoDl²%³K°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹�Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=oDl²RQ=@?¨´ º <RD@ACDl²%³K=@?¨´:D@VWQE=M<n¿²%³¸ACQBL#²R°�AJQB¹�°�´�DoD@<R¹R´�D�¶:?¨ATLM?'¶:Yo<Rµ�=@?B´PÎvI¨´#YoV¼ÅvD@´#°�<RQE=oACL °�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹Y@´#³�´#YMD�=@²�=@?¨´µ¨Yo²XL)´�DoDH²%³^°�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹�=o?¨´�AJQv=@´�Y@QK<%G�S¨<%=o<�Da=oY@IKLg=@IBY@´�DP²R³3<RQBSÕL)²RQKDa=oYo<RAJQv=oD�IBD@´�S6ACQYo´�ÎvI¨´�D>=P<RQBS�L#<RµB< º ACGCA{=aV�SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBD�Ũµ¨YM<%¹E°�<n=@ATLH°�<n=MLM?¨AJQB¹'AJQKL)GCIBSX´�DPL)²EQBD>ATSX´�Yo<%¾=@AC²RQKD�D@IBLM?Ô<RDH=o?¨´'µO´#Y@³�²RYo°�<%QBL#´�²%³3=@?¨´2°�<ELM?¨ACQ¨´�=@?¨´�<%¹E´#Qv=�ACD�Y@I¨QBQ¨AJQB¹(²RQÆ<%QKSD@´�L)IBY@AJ=aV'Yo´�ÎvI¨ACY@´�°*´�Qv=oD�½

ø�ùuõ�ùTú¸®)ü � � | �

Ã3?¨´�»a;kÖ ­ K^ÃôÏ�»fQv=o´#YM<RLg=oA ® ´!;(<%YoVWGC<RQBS"Ö�GC<%=>³�²EY@° ³�²EY ­ ¹E´#Qv=oD8K�²RGCGC< º ²EYo<%=@ACQ¨¹*ò%¾¹R´#=@?¨´�YMÐPµ¨GT<n=@³�²RYo°õË Û¨·�Ú#M�Í�?K<RD º ´#´#QÁSX´ ® ´#GC²RµO´�S6<n=H=@?B´Xò/Q¨A ® ´#YMD@A{=aV�²R³^;(<RY@VWGT<%QBS�·

Page 19: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

��  ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

K�²RGCGC´#¹R´*Ö�<%Yoļ·;òPU ­ ½¼»�=HD@I¨µ¨µO²RY@=oDP°�I¨GJ=@AT<%¹E´#Qv=PACQv=@´�Yo<ELg=@AC²RQKD/<%QKSk<%¹E´#Qv=/ACQv=@´#Yo²RµO´)¾YM< º ACGJAJ=aVÆACQÉ<RQ¯<%µBµ¨GJATL#<%=@AC²RQ¯AJQBS¨´#µO´#QBSX´�Qv=�°�<RQ¨Q¨´#Y�½�樲EY=o?¨ATD�µ¨I¨YoµK²vD>´�»a;(Ö ­ K^õ¨Yo² ® ACSX´�D^³�²RGCGJ²n¶:ACQ¨¹�D>´#= ²%³�L)²RQBQ¨´�L)=@´�S�D@´#Y ® ´�YoD�ÙÚE½º¹U,d?2?u)�`�cu=;793�,/.�.9,9'/E#,9'�µO´#Y@³�²RYo°�D º <ED>ATL�°�<%=oLM?¨°�<RÄvACQ¨¹H<%°�²RQB¹PØ3¾�<RQBS�Ö�¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MDº <RD@´�S�²RQ�=a¶^²�¶�´�AJ¹E?E=o´�S�?¨AC´#YM<%YMLM?¨AC´�D^A{=P°�<RAJQv=M<%ACQBD^¾�< ® ´�Y º <%QKS�<�QB²RI¨Q�?¨AC´)¾Yo<RYoLM?WVƲ%³�D@VWQ¨²RQWVW°�D*¾*<%QKS¯Yo´)=oY@AC´ ® <RG/<%GC¹R²EY@AJ=@?¨°�D*=o²ÔL)²R°�µ¨I¨=@´kD@AJ°�ACGC<RY@AJ=@AC´�Dº ´#=a¶�´�´#Q�¹RA ® ´#Q�D@´#Y ® ATL)´!D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQBD�·Û¨½�'*,S3o0x./:B'*7�:B0�)�14.9,9'/E#,9'�³�²EYl<R¹R´#Qv=lY@´�¹RATDa=oYo<%=@AC²RQ�<%QKS!°�<%ACQE=M<%ACQ¨ACQ¨¹P<RQ<%¹E´#Qv=ÂD@´#Y ® ACL#´AJQBS¨´)¿"IKD>´�S º V'=o?¨´HVR´�GJGC²n¶3¾�µK<%¹R´�D�D@´#Y ® ´�Y�·ÜB½�:�A�=;,8.9,d'/E�,9'�°�<%ACQE=M<%ACQBD^<�?¨AC´#YM<%YMLM?¨ATL#<%GK²RQv=@²EGJ²E¹RV*²%³�D>=o<RQBS¨<%YMS'S¨<%=o<�=aVvµO´�D^<%QKSL)²RQKL)´#µ¨=oD�·¨<RD3¶^´#GCG¸<RDÌK½:<ú:2h;,/.97oy '/y�.!<RQBSÆ< h y WX7o1 021U:S,9'�5d7%+-,*<%GCGC²n¶:AJQ¨¹(<k?WI¨°�<%QÁ=@²Õ<RL�L)´�DoD�<RGJG�=@?¨´< º ² ® ´HD>´�Y ® ´#YMD�ACQ�<%Q�»a;(Ö ­ K^à D@VXDa=o´#°�½Ã3?¨´�»a;(Ö ­ K^ãD>²R³�=a¶^<RY@´µ¨Y@² ® ATSX´�DP=o?¨´�AJQX³�YM<RD>=@YoIBL)=@I¨Yo´�I¨µK²EQ6¶:?BACLM?ÁSXAJãO´�Y@´�QE=

»a;(Ö ­ K^à <%¹R´�Qv=oD^°�<�V�AJQv=@´�Yo<ELg=�Åv°I¨GJ=@ACµ¨GJ´�L#²Rµ¨AC´�D^²R³ÂAJ=3°�<�V º ´!Y@´�µ¨GCACL�<n=@´�S2<EL)Yo²EDoD=@?B´!Q¨´)=a¶^²RYoÄ2<%QKS2¹E´)= D>VWQBLM?BY@²EQ¨AJÓ�´�S"¶:?¨´#Q�Q¨´�´�SX´�S�½­ QWVHD>´�Y ® ATL)´�µ¨Yo² ® ACS¨´�S º V�<RQ!»a;(Ö ­ K^Ã6<R¹R´�QE=ÂACDÂD>µO´�L#A{ÈB´�SHAJQ�</D>µO´�L#AC<RGR°�<%YoÄWI¨µ

D@´#Y ® ATL)´SX´�DoL)YoAJµ¨=@AC²RQ�GT<%Q¨¹EIB<%¹E´R½ ­ D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQ(L)²EQBD@ACD>=oD/²%³ Ï×<vÐ <'D@´#Y ® ACL#´QB<R°*´*ACQk=o´#Yo°�D�²R³�< ® ´#Y º ¾�Q¨²RI¨QÂÏ�Q¨²EI¨QKÐ:´#¿Xµ¨Y@´�D@D@AC²RQkD@IBLM?6<ED�Y@´�QE=�Ù L�<%Y�Ï��v<%µB<RQ¨´�D@´�Ð)·Ï º Ð�=aVWµO´�S ACQ¨µ¨I¨=�<RQBSá²RI¨=@µ¨IX= ® <%YoAC< º GC´�D�·�<%QKSþÏ×L�Ð'<n=@=@YoA º IX=@´�D"²R³�D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D2D@IBLM?<RD�IBDo<%¹E´L#²ED>=�·�< ® ´�Yo<R¹R´!Yo´�D@µK²EQBD>´�=@AC°�´=o²"Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=MD ³�²EY�=@?B<%=�µB<RY>=oACL#I¨GT<%YHD>´�Y ® ATL)´R·´)=ML%½¼UW´#Y ® ACL#´�D3°�<�V º ´!´#AJ=@?¨´�Y/°�<%QKS¨<n=o²RYoV�²RY/SXATDoL)Yo´)=@AC²RQK<%YoVR½ ­ ¹E´#Qv=oD:°�<�V"Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=D@´#Y ® ATL)´�D3AJQ�²RQB´!²%³�=o?¨´H³�²RGCGC²n¶:AJQ¨¹*³�²EY@°�D�½] t�cj1�,�7o'*,d.-:�1,90e3"h;>�)o'�'*,-z9y;,/./:�ÙvælACQBS'=o?¨´HÄv¾�Q¨´�<%Yo´�D>=^D@´#Y ® ACL#´PQB<R°�´�DHÏ�µB<RAJYMD^²%³ ® ´#Y º<%QBS�Q¨²EI¨Q�=@´�Y@°'Ð3D@IBLM?�=@?B<%=:=@?¨´�Y@´!´#¿WATD>=oD <RQ�<R¹R´�QE=:¶:?¨²�µBY@² ® ATSX´�D^=o?B<n=/D@´#Y ® ACL#´<%QBS�ATSX´#Qv=@AJ³�V'=o?¨ATD <%¹E´#Qv=

] C�cj'*7o1�3�,F.9,-7�'*+-hWÙOælAJQBS�<RGJG¸D@´#Y ® ACL#´�QK<%°�´�D3¶:AJ=@?¨ACQ�<�D>µO´�L#A{ÈK´�S�SXACD>=o<RQBL)´�S¸½UW´�<%YMLM?¨AJQB¹�²%³Â<Rµ¨µ¨Yo²Rµ¨YoAT<n=@´PD>´�Y ® ATL)´�D�AJQ"»a;(Ö ­ K^ÃÇ´�DoD@´#Qv=@AT<%GCGJV�Yo´#GCAJ´�D�²EQ'=@?B´P´#¿v¾

µ¨GC²RAJ=o<%=@AC²RQ�²%³�¹EA ® ´#Q�¶�´�AJ¹E?v=@´�S ® ´#Y º ?BAJ´�Yo<RYoLM?WV�<%QKS�Q¨²RI¨Q�?BAJ´�Yo<RYoLM?WV!´�<ELM?�²%³¼¶:?¨ATLM?<%Yo´�D@µK´�L)AT<%GvL#<RD@´�D¸²%³W=@?¨´�¹R´�Q¨´#YM<%GRL#²RQBL#´#µX=²%³B<3=o´#Yo° ?¨AC´#YM<%YMLM?WVR½#UWAC°�AJGT<%YoAJ=aV º ´)=a¶^´#´�Q® ´�Y º D�<%QBSÕQ¨²EI¨QBD!ACQÁ=@?B´ ® ´�Y º <%QKS6QB²RI¨QÁ?¨AC´#YM<%YMLM?WVR·�Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=@A ® ´�GJVE·¸ATD�L)²E°*µBIX=@´�S® AC<�<H¹RA ® ´#Q�SXATD>=o<%QKL)´3³�I¨QBL)=@AC²RQ'²EQ�µB<n=o?BD�²R³¼¶^´#AC¹R?v=o´�S*´�SX¹E´�D�ACQ�=@?B´ ?¨AC´#YM<%YMLM?¨AJ´�D#½ ­L)²E°�µK²vD>AJ=@´HSXATDa=M<%QBL#´/³�I¨QKLg=@AC²RQ"=@?B´#Q"L#²R° º AJQB´�D º ²R=@?�SXATDa=M<%QBL#´ ³�I¨QBL)=@AC²RQBD^=o²*L�<%GTL)IX¾GT<n=@´�=@?¨´*L)²E° º ACQ¨´�S�D@AC°*ACGT<%YoA{=aV ® <RGJIB´�³�²RY/=a¶�²2¶�²EYoS�µB<RAJYMD�Ï ® ´#Y º · Q¨²RIBQKÐ3²%³�D@´#Y ® ACL#´QB<R°*´�D#½WÃ3?¨´H<%IX=o?¨²RYMD�D@I¨¹E¹R´�D>=�=o²�=M<%ÄR´�<RS¨S¨A{=oAJ²EQ2<RD^L)²E°*µO²ED@AJ=@´PS¨ACD>=o<RQBL)´P³�I¨QBL)=@AC²RQ¸½»�³�<Á¶�²EYoSÉL#<RQ¨Q¨²R= º ´�³�²EI¨QBSÇACQÉ=@?¨´(Yo´�D@µO´�Lg=oA ® ´�?¨AC´#YM<%YMLM?vVÔ<ÆD@VWQ¨²RQWVW°õ¶:ACGJG º ´D@´�<%YMLM?¨´�S'ACQ"=o?¨´H=@?B´�Do<%I¨YoIBD3ACQBDa=o´�<ES�½ælAJ¹EI¨Yo´�ÑB½ [�¹EA ® ´�DH<%QÁ´)¿¨<R°*µBGJ´�²%³�=@?¨´'SB<n=o<�D>=@YoIBL)=@I¨Yo´�DHIBD@´�S6ACQÕ»a;kÖ ­ K^à =@²

µ¨Yo²XL)´�DoDHYo´�ÎvI¨´�D>=oD�½¸Ø:´�¹E<%YMSXACQ¨¹"=@?¨´�D>´�´#¿X<R°�µ¨GJ´�S¨<%=o<�D>=@YoIBLg=oI¨Yo´�D!<�Y@´�ÎvI¨´�D>=��RælAJQKSÏz»½¼HÐ�Û�Q¨´�<RY@´�Da=�<R¹R´#Qv=MD�=@?B<%=�µ¨Yo² ® ATSX´'<�D@´#Y ® ACL#´�Ï×Y@´�Qv=�·ÂL�<%Y�ÏyÐ@Ð�²%³:Y@´�Qv=@ACQ¨¹(L#<RYoD��¶:ACGJG º ´!µ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD@´�S�<RD^³�²RGCGC²n¶ D#½ælAJYMD>=@GCVR·�<%Q�<R¹R´#Qv=Â=o< º GJ´�ACD�D@´�<%YMLM?¨´�S�=@² ÈKQBS�<%=°�²ED>=�ÛP<%¹E´#Qv=oD¸=@?B<%=lµ¨Yo² ® ACS¨´�=@?¨´

´)¿¨<ELg=�D@´#Y ® ACL#´�Ï�Yo´#Qv=�·vL#<%Y�ÏyÐ@Ðg½WUWAJQKL)´:=o?¨ACD�D>´�<%YMLM?�Y@´#=@I¨YoQBD�=o?¨´/´�°*µ¨=aV*D@´)=�=o?¨´/D@´#Y ® ACL#´

Page 20: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| �%�

(Service) Agent Table

Verb Hierarchy Noun Hierarchy

{seek, search}

provi¾ de {explore,investigate} ...

rent sell hire

5¿ 2

3 2À 2

vehiÁ cle()

{car(), automobile()} van() ...

Car(AÂ

merican) car(Japanese)

chevy() ì Dodge() ... Honda() Mazda() Nissan() ...

Verb NounTerm Agentrent car(Japanese) ag1 îrent car(American) ag3rent vehicle() ag6hiÃ

re Honda() ag4rent car(Japanese) ag2îsell Mazda() ag2rent vehicle() ag3

ThesaurusWord SynonymsÄvehiÁ cle() car,carrier,van, ...car(Ameriì can) chevy,neon,dodge,...car(Japanese) Hì onda,Mazda,Nissan,..Seek search,lookupprovi¾ de supply,hand-overrent î hire,lease.... ....

ß<àuáâ�ã;âdÅGâB� �Eb�`!�Ewz]3q�p¸�Eb#m>b�e�mf_a�Ehoma�E_a]oe��Eef]g��pCq�_�ef]o_a�%szhM]:`�b#mah>iv`�b#�RszcE|Pszc*x�~��¨r�jC-

Yo´#GT<n=@´�Sk¶^²RYMS6µB<%ACY�Ï�Yo´#Qv=�·�L�<%Y�ÏyÐ@Ð/ATD!Q¨²n¶ôY@´�GC<%¿W´�S(=o²ÆÏ�Yo´#Qv=�· ® ´#?¨ATL)GC´EÏ�Ð>Ð º V�=M<%ÄWAJQB¹<%Q�AC°�°*´�SXAT<n=@´!QB´#AC¹R? º ²EY:²%³l=@?¨´ ® ´#Y º Q Yo´#Qv=�QB<RQBS"=@?¨´!QB²RI¨Q Q L#<%Y"QXACQ"=o?¨´ ® ´�Y º <%QKSQ¨²EI¨Q"?BAJ´�Yo<RYoLM?WVR·WYo´�D@µK´�Lg=oA ® ´#GCVR½XÃ3?¨´�=aVWµK´�L�<%Y�ÏyÐ�ACD3Q¨²n¶ AJQKDa=M<%Qv=@AT<n=o´�S"IBD>ACQ¨¹ ® <%GCI¨´�DD@µK´�L)AJÈB´�S�ACQ�=@?¨´�S¨<%=o<*=aVWµO´!?¨AJ´�Yo<RYoLM?WV�²R³Â=o?¨´!»a;(Ö ­ K^à =aVvµO´�D@´#Y ® ´#Y3¶:?¨ATLM?�GJ´�<RS¨DACQ=o?¨ATD�´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´^=@²HQ¨²RIBQ=o´#Yo°�D�L#<%Y�Ï��v<%µK<%Q¨´�D>´�и<%QKSL�<%Y�Ï ­ °�´�Y@ATL#<RQKÐg½ ­ D�<%Q*AJQv=@´�Y>¾°�´�SXAT<n=o´PYo´�D@I¨GJ=^¶^´/¹E´)=^=@?¨´P³�²RGCGC²n¶:AJQ¨¹GJATD>=^²R³�AJQ¨³�²RYo°�<%=@AC²RQ"²RQ'Yo´#GC´ ® <%Qv=3D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D�ACQ=@?B´!³�²RYo° Ï@Ï ® ´�Y º · Q¨²EI¨QKÐ)· L#²R°�µK²vD>AJ=@´SXACD>=o<RQBL)´�ÐgÙ�Ï@Ï�Yo´#Qv=�·OL#<RY�Ï��E<RµB<%Q¨´�D>´�Ðg·�Ú�Ðg·�Ï@Ï�Yo´#Qv=�·L#<RY�Ï ­ °�´#YoATL#<%QOÐ>Ðg·�Ú�Ðg·¸Ï@Ï�µ¨Yo² ® ACSX´E·¨L#<RY�Ï�Ð>Ðg·¨ÜvÐg½KUX´�<%YMLM?¨ACQ¨¹�=o?¨´�<%¹E´#Qv=3=o< º GJ´�³�²EY:´)¿¨<RL)=°�<n=MLM?¨AJQB¹D@´#Y ® ATL)´PQB<%°�´�D�Yo´#Qv=�Ù ® ´�?¨ATL)GC´EÏyÐ�<%QBS2Y@´�Qv=�Ù L#<%Y�Ï��v<%µK<%Q¨´�D>´�ÐlACD3D@IBL#L#´�DoDa³�I¨GOACQ=@?BACD:´#¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´H<RQBS�Y@´#=@I¨YoQBD:<R¹R´#Qv=-[<RQBS"<R¹R´�QE=�Ú!<RD3Yo´#GC´ ® <%Qv=:Ö�¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oD�½

ø�ùuõ�ùuõ ��Æ � ° ®�Ç��¦ÈoÉ�� �#Ê�°Ã3?¨´!Ø�l�à UW»gô ­ Ï×Ø ´#IBDo< º GC´!ÃÂ<ED>Ä2UW=@YoIBLg=oI¨Y@´#¾ º <RD@´�S'»fQv=o´#GCGJAC¹R´�QE=�ô/´)=a¶^²RYoÄ ­ ¹R´�QE=MDoÐË ÌvÛW·�Ü���Í�°I¨G{=oAC<R¹R´�QE=!ACQX³�YM<RD>=@YoIBLg=oI¨Y@´�?B<ED º ´�´#QÆSX´ ® ´#GC²RµO´�SÕ<n=H=o?¨´qK^<%YoQ¨´#¹EAJ´�;�´�G{¾GC²RQkò/Q¨A ® ´#YMD>AJ=aV�AJQkÖ�A{=@=oD º I¨Yo¹R?¸·òPU ­ ½K»�=HL)²EQBD>ATD>=oD ²R³�<'D@VWD>=@´�° ²%³�=@?BY@´�´�SXAJãO´�Y@´�QE=Yo´#IBDo< º GC´"<R¹R´�QE==aVWµK´�D�=o?B<n=�L#<RQ º ´�<ES¨<%µX=o´�SÁ=o²Õ<ES¨SXYo´�DoD�< ® <%YoAJ´#=aV6²R³PSXAJãO´�Y@´�QE=SX²E°�<RAJQ¨¾�D@µK´�L)AJÈKL�µ¨Yo² º GC´#°�D�½»fQv=@´�Y>³×<EL)´(<%¹E´#Qv=oD'AJQv=@´�Yo<ELg=2¶:AJ=@?Ç=o?¨´kIKD>´�Y�·�Y@´�L)´#A ® ´�IKD>´�Y'AJQBµ¨IX=�<RQBSáSXATD>µBGC<�V

Yo´�D@I¨G{=MD#½�Ãl<RD@ÄÝ<R¹R´#Qv=MD?B´#GCµ¯IBD@´#YMD�µO´#Y@³�²RYo° =o<ED>ÄXD º VƳ�²RYo°�I¨GT<n=oAJQB¹6µ¨Yo² º GJ´�° D>²EG{¾® AJQB¹6µ¨GT<%QKD<RQBSÝL�<%YoY@VWACQ¨¹(²RI¨=�=@?B´�D@´"µ¨GT<%QKD�=o?¨Yo²RI¨¹E?ÝÎvI¨´#YoVWAJQ¨¹6<%QBSÝ´)¿¨LM?B<%QB¹RACQ¨¹ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=@AC²RQ2¶:A{=o?2²%=o?¨´#Y^D>²R³�=a¶^<RY@´P<%¹R´�Qv=oD�½R»fQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQT�Yo´�D@²RIBYoL#´3<R¹R´�QE=MD�µ¨Yo² ® ACS¨´ACQE=o´#GCGJAC¹R´�Qv=/<RL#L#´�DoD�=@²'<*?¨´)=o´#Yo²R¹E´#Q¨´�²RIBD3L)²EGJGC´�L)=@AC²RQ�²%³lAJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ�D>²EI¨YoL#´�D�½­ L#²RGCGJ´�Lg=@AC²RQ�²R³�ØPl�à UW»gô ­ <%¹E´#Qv=oDl³�²EY@°�D�<RQ*²EµK´�Q'D>²XL#AJ´#=aV�²%³�Yo´#IBDo< º GJ´:<%¹E´#Qv=oD

=@?K<n=^D@´#GJ³�¾�²RYo¹E<%QBAJÓ�´3<RQBS�L)²W²EµK´�Yo<%=@´:ACQ�Y@´�D>µO²RQBD@´3=@²�=o<RD@Ä*Y@´�ÎEIBAJYo´#°�´#Qv=MD#½RÃ3?B´/Ø�l�Ã^¾

Page 21: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

��� ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

UW»gô ­ ³�YM<%°�´#¶^²RYoÄ*?B<RD º ´�´#Q'AC°�µ¨GC´#°�´#Qv=@´�S'ACQq�v< ® <�<%QBS'ACD º ´�AJQB¹IBD@´�S�=@²S¨´ ® ´�GJ²EµSXATDa=oY@A º IX=o´�S�L#²RGCGJ´�Lg=@AC²RQKD�²%³�ACQE=o´#GCGJAC¹R´�Qv=�D>²R³�=a¶^<RY@´:<%¹E´#Qv=oDl=o?B<n=^L)²W²RµO´#YM<n=o´ <RD@VvQKLM?¨Y@²R¾Q¨²EIBD>GCV=@²!µO´#Y@³�²RYo°£¹E²E<%GJ¾fSXAJYo´�L)=@´�S�ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=@AC²RQ�Yo´)=oY@AC´ ® <RGXAJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ�ACQE=o´#¹EYo<%=@AC²RQ<%QKS"µBGC<RQ¨Q¨ACQ¨¹*=o<RD@ÄXD3AJQ�D@I¨µ¨µO²RY@=:²%³�< ® <RY@AC´)=aV'²R³lSX´�L)ATD>AC²RQ�°�<%ÄWACQ¨¹*=o<RD@ÄXD#½UWAC°�AJGT<%Y:=o²�=@?B´�»fQX³�²vUXGJ´�IX=@?kD@VXDa=o´#° °*´�SXAT<n=@AC²RQ�ACQ�=@?B´Ø�l�à UW»gô ­ °I¨GJ=@AT<%¹R´�Qv=

D@VWD>=@´�°�D º <RD@ACL�<%GCGJV�Yo´#GCAJ´�D�²RQ6D@´#Y ® ACL#´�°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄWACQ¨¹B½�� ²n¶^´ ® ´#Y�·B=o?¨´�D>µO´�L#A{ÈOL#<n=oAJ²EQ²%³¸L�<%µB< º AJGCAJ=aV<%QKS�D>´�Y ® ATL)´:SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBD�SXA{ã¼´#Y�½EÃ3?B´ ­ K^âPÊkSX´ ® ´#GC²RµO´�S*³�²RY�°�<%=oLM?X¾°�<%ÄWACQ¨¹ÝACQ Ø�l�à UW»gô ­ ACD�L#<RGJGC´�S Ê ­ Ø/F�U Ï×ÊÂ<%Q¨¹EIB<%¹E´�³�²RY ­ S ® ´#Y@=@ATD>´�°�´#Qv="<%QKSØ:´�ÎEIB´�D>=�³�²RY�FHQB²n¶:GJ´�SX¹R´ UW?B<RY@ACQ¨¹WÐ)Ë ÌBÚgÍ�½ ­ µ¨µ¨GCACL�<n=@AC²RQ�SX²E°�<%ACQ�ÄvQB²n¶:GJ´�SX¹R´3ACQ'<%¹R´�Qv=<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD@´#°�´#Qv=oD2<%QBSÇYo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=MD'L#<RQ º ´kL#I¨YoY@´�QE=oGJVÉD>µO´�L#A{ÈK´�Sá<RD2GJ²XL�<%G ²EQE=o²RGC²R¹EAJ´�D¶:YoA{=@=@´#Q-ACQ <ÉD>µO´�L#A{ÈKLÁL#²RQBL#´#µX=�GC<RQ¨¹RIK<%¹R´k»aÃ:Ê£²EY º VáIBD@ACQ¨¹¯àÕ²RYMSGô/´)=�½3»fQ =@?¨´Ê ­ Ø F�U"<%µ¨µ¨Yo²E<ELM?2<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD@´#°�´#Qv=oD^<%QKS2Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=MD�<RY@´�´)¿Xµ¨Yo´�DoD>´�S�IBD@AJQB¹=o?¨´!D@<R°�´GT<%Q¨¹EIB<%¹E´R½l»�=*ATD<ED@D@I¨°�´�SÔ=@?B<%=*´ ® ´�Y@VÁÊ ­ Ø F�UÔD@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQ¯ACD¶:Yo<Rµ¨µO´�SÔIBµÝACQ<%QÉ<%µ¨µBY@²Eµ¨Y@AT<n=o´"FF��;(Ê�¾�GCAJÄE´'°�´�DoD@<R¹R´ º VÁ=o?¨´�D@´#QKSXAJQB¹Õ<R¹R´#Qv=*AJQBS¨ACL�<n=@ACQ¨¹ÕA{³P=@?¨´°�´�DoD@<R¹R´!L)²EQv=@´#Qv=:ATD^=@² º ´H=@Yo´�<n=o´�S�<RD:<*Yo´�ÎvI¨´�D>=:²RY <RQ�<ES ® ´�Y>=oACD@´#°�´#Qv=�½­ D@´#Y ® ATL)´�D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQÕAJQÆÊ ­ Ø F�U6ATD!<2³�YM<%°�´'L#²R°�µ¨YoACD@´�S6²%³�=@?¨´�³�²EGJGC²n¶:AJQB¹

D@GJ²R=oD�ÙÚE½iË�)o1;:j,�Ì�:�Ù¨FH´#VW¶^²RYMS¨D3SX´#Q¨²R=@ACQ¨¹*=@?¨´�S¨²R°�<%ACQ"²R³Â=o?¨´�SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=@AC²RQ�·Û¨½� A�=;,/.gÙ;òPD>´�Y>¾fSX´#ÈBQ¨´�S�S¨<%=o<*=aVWµK´�D^³�²RI¨QKS"ACQ�=@?¨´�D@AC¹RQB<%=@I¨Yo´�S¨´)ÈBQ¨AJ=@AC²RQKD#·ÜB½ n 1�=�y :O<RQBSÎÍay :e=y :�ÙE»fQ¨µBIX=3<RQBS'²EIX=@µBIX=^µK<%YM<%°�´)=o´#Y�S¨´�L)GT<%YM<n=oAJ²EQBD�S¨´)ÈBQ¨ACQ¨¹=@?¨´D>AC¹RQB<%=@I¨Yo´�²%³l=@?¨´!²EµK´�Yo<%=@AC²RQ¸·ÌK½ n 1�Ë<)o1G./:�'�7�021;:�./<%QKSÏÍay :�Ë<)o1G./:�'�7�021;:�.gÙOÊ�²R¹EACL�<%G�L)²RQKDa=oYo<RAJQv=oDP²RQ6AJQBµ¨IX=/Tn²RIX=oµ¨IX=® <RY@AT< º GJ´�D�Ï×µ¨Yo´)¾6T�µO²ED>=:L#²RQBS¨A{=oAJ²EQBDoÐ)·

�¨½iË�)o1+�vD,d.9+d'/0 =�:�0�)o1G.gÙRâP´�DoL)YoAJµ¨=@AC²RQBD²%³BIKD>´�S�µO²%=@´�Qv=@AT<%GCGJV�SXATDo<%° º AJ¹EIB<n=oAJQ¨¹P¶�²EYoSBDAJQ�=@´�Y@°�D3²R³Â=o?¨´�L)²EQBL)´�µX=:GC<RQ¨¹RIB<R¹R´�»aÃ:Ê�·¨²EY3ÄR´#VW¶^²RYMS'µ¨?BYo<ED>´E·¨<%QBS

[B½�;,*Ì�:xv�,/.9+9'/0 =:B0�)�1KÙ ­ ³�Y@´�´�=@´)¿W=/SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=oAJ²EQ"²R³Â=o?¨´�<%¹E´#Qv=�Q D3L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D�½Ãl< º GC´PÛ!D@?¨²n¶ D�<RQ�´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´ ²R³ º ²R=@?2<!Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=^<%QBS�°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹�L�<%µB< º AJGCAJ=aV*SX´�Da¾

L)YoACµX=@AC²RQ¸½B»fQ"=o?¨ATD:´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´�<�Ö�¾f<%¹E´#Qv=3<ES ® ´�Y>=oACD@´�D3AJ=oD/L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=aV�=o²�µ¨Y@² ® ATSX´H<�GJATDa=²%³lSX´#µ¨GC²nVR´�S ­ à ­ KÇ<%ACY�L#²R° º <n=�°�ATD@D@AC²RQBD�¶:?¨ATLM?'?B< ® ´ º ´�´#Q2GT<%IBQBLM?¨´�S'AJQ�<�¹RA ® ´�Q=@AC°�´PACQv=@´�Y ® <%G�½WÃ3?¨ACD3<ES ® ´�Y>=oACD@´#°�´#Qv=�°�<%=oLM?¨´�D�¶:AJ=@?2=@?¨´HD>?B²n¶:Q'Y@´�ÎvI¨´�D>=�³�²RY3<%¹E´#Qv=oD=@?K<n=^<RY@´ L�<%µB< º GC´ ²%³�µ¨Yo² ® ACSXACQ¨¹!ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQ*²EQ'<%QWV�ÄWACQBS�²R³�<RAJY�L)²R° º <n=�°*ATDoD>AC²RQBDGT<%I¨QBLM?B´�S�AJQ(<�¹EA ® ´#Q"=@AC°�´�AJQv=o´#Y ® <RGy½KÃ3?¨´!Y@´�ÎvI¨´�D>= ACD/<%GTD>²*³�²RYo°�IBGC<%=@´�S�ACQ�Ê ­ Ø/F�Uº V*D@AC°*µBGJV�D@µK´�L)AJ³�VvACQ¨¹�<�SX´�D@AJYo´�S�<R¹R´�QE=�L�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=aVR½ K�²RQBD>=@YM<%ACQv=oD�²EQ�=@?¨´ ACQ¨µ¨I¨=^<%QKS²RI¨=@µ¨IX=!²R³�<2L�<%µB< º AJGCAJ=aV(SX´�DoL)YoAJµ¨=@AC²RQ(²EYPYo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=!<%Yo´D@µK´�L)AJÈB´�S6<RD�L)²EQn±aI¨QBL)=@AC²RQk²R³ÈBQ¨AJ=@´X� ²EY@Q6L)GT<%IBD@´�D�½I^²R=@?�=o?¨´Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=�<%QBS6<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD>´�°*´�Qv=PL)²EQE=M<%ACQ�²RQv=@²EGJ²E¹RATL#<RG<%QBQ¨²%=M<n=@AC²RQKD!²%³:SXATD@<R° º AC¹RIB<%=@ACQ¨¹�¶^²RYMS Q ;�ATD@D@AJ²EQLQ º V6=@?¨´2L#²RQBL#´#µX=MD4Q ­ ACYo;�ATDoD>AC²RQLQ<%QKS ­ à ­ K�¾ ­ ACYo;(ACDoD>AC²RQöQJ·¼Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=@A ® ´�GJVE·�´�<ELM?6²R³�¶:?¨ATLM?ÁACD!SX´#ÈBQ¨´�S6ACQÕ=@?¨´qK�²EQBLg¾âP´�DoL)YoAJµX=oAJ²EQBD�D@GJ²R=�AJQÁ=o´#Yo°�DH²%³ <�L)²R°�°�²RQÆF!ʸ¾gY8ôml Ë ��Í�GJACÄR´'L#²RQBL#´#µX=�GT<%Q¨¹EIB<%¹E´º <ED>´�S2²EQ�<�D@?B<%Yo´�S"°�AJQBAJ°�<%G ® ²XL#< º I¨GC<RY@VE½Ê ­ Ø F�UÝACD*³×<RAJYoGJVÝ´)¿Xµ¨Yo´�DoD>A ® ´�<%QBSÉL#<RµB< º GC´�²%³HD>I¨µBµK²EY>=oAJQ¨¹Á<%I¨=@²R°�<%=@´�S¯ACQX³�´)¾

Yo´#QBL#´�D�½ Ã3?¨´ÆAJ°�µ¨GC´#°�´�QE=o´�S-°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄWAJQB¹¯µ¨Yo²XL)´�D@D"³�²RY(Ê ­ Ø F�U-D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQBD´#°�µ¨GC²nVXD�SXA{ã¼´#Yo´#Qv=�=@´�LM?¨Q¨ATÎvI¨´�D�³�Yo²R° ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=oAJ²EQ Yo´)=@YoAC´ ® <%G�· ­ »g· <%QKS D@²%³�=a¶3<%Yo´´#QB¹RACQ¨´#´�Y@ACQ¨¹(=o²6L#²R°�µ¨IX=o´'=@?B´�D@VWQE=M<RL)=@ATL#<%G3<%QKSÔD>´�°�<%Qv=@ATL2D@AJ°�ACGC<RY@AJ=aVÁ<%°�²RQ¨¹Õ<RSW¾® ´�Y>=oACD@´�S¯<%QBSÝY@´�ÎvI¨´�D>=@´�SÝ<%¹E´#Qv=*L�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=aVÔSX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBD�½�Ã3?¨´�°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹Õ´#Q¨¹EAJQB´

Page 22: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| ���L)²EQv=o<%ACQBD2È ® ´ÁSXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv="ÈBGJ=@´�YoD"³�²EYÕÏ>Ú�Ð"ÄR´�Vv¶^²RYMSW¾ º <RD@´�SÇL#²RQv=@´#¿v=�°�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹K·!ÏyÛRÐÃ:æ¾�»aâ�æ º <RD@´�S*µ¨Yo²%ÈKGJ´ L#²R°�µB<%YoATD>²EQ¸·¨Ï×ÜvÐ�L)²EQBL)´�µX=>¾ º <RD@´�S�D@AJ°�ACGC<RY@AJ=aV�°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹B·KÏ�ÌvÐ=aVWµK´#¾�ACQX³�´�Y@´�QBL)´:YoI¨GC´)¾ º <RD@´�S*D>AC¹RQK<n=@IBY@´3°�<n=MLM?¨AJQB¹B·R<RQBS"ÏB�RÐl=o?¨´)=M<n¾fD>I º D>IB°*µ¨=@AC²RQ º <n¾D@´�SÉL)²RQKDa=oYo<RAJQv=°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹Õ²%³ ÈBQBA{=o´{�/²RYoQ¯L#GC<RIBD>´�D#½ ­ QWVÔIKD>´�Y*°�<�VÁACQBSXA ® ATSXIB<RGJGCVL)²EQXÈB¹EI¨Y@´2=@?¨´�D>´"ÈBGJ=@´�YoD�=@²Á<RLM?¨AC´ ® ´'=o?¨´�S¨´�D@AJYo´�SÁ=oYo<ESX´#²Rã º ´)=a¶^´#´�QݵO´#Y@³�²RYo°�<%QBL#´<%QKS�°�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹�ÎvIB<%GCA{=aVE½K»fQk=@?¨´�³�²RGCGJ²n¶:ACQ¨¹"¶�´ º Y@AC´)äBV�D@I¨°�°�<%YoAJÓ�´�´�<ELM?�²%³�=o?¨´�ÈKG{¾=@´�YoD�²%³�=o?¨´'µ¨Yo²RµO²ED@´�S6Ê ­ Ø F�U6°�<%=oLM?¨°�<RÄvACQ¨¹�µ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD�Å�A{=�ATD!SX´�DoL)YoA º ´�S6ACQÁ°�²RYo´SX´#=o<%ACG¸ACQÆË Ì�J�Í�½

Ð�Ñ�Ò�Ó�Ô�Õ�ÖrÔ�×�×�Ô6Ø�Ù�×Ú�Û�Ü:Ý�Þ�ß:Ý r�mfm>b#h@�X}v~*szefefszq�c7à)r�su_@~*szefefszq�cá:â�ã Þä � b#ma]guw1�`!`��%xyc%mg}E�E�B�Rx�cnmg}%�%�B�Rxyc%m 2 }

� ]M�vwzqg�n]g�v~*szefefs{q�c�uå sze�m�æ�p 1�`A-¸�E�X]��W�nmf_aszcv|E}E`!x � � �nmf_aszcv|�ç>x�cnm 2

è Ü ã�é Ý ea�B� � b#ma]�}E]g�¨� � b)ma]ê é Ý ã:é Ý `!s{efefszq�cveM�W~*s{efefszq�cè ÜÚ:Û�Ü~ä�Ý:ë�ì�í�Ü�Ý�ä ea�#îjuÉ]g�B�ê é Ý:Ú�Û�Ü~ä�Ý�ëì�í�Ü�Ýä �E]M�Ew{qg�n]M��1�`!x � 2 }nw{b��vcEh@iE]g�vr�pCma]o_�1�`!x � } ea� 2 }wJb#�vcEh@iE]g�vßl]@pTq�_a]�1�`!x � } ]g� 2 �Ú�Û�Ü�ï�ðÞä:ï�ë�í ã Ý�í�Û�Ü~ä r�su_@~*szefefs{q�c�u1�b�cW�*~*szefefs{q�cñ1�b#mawz]gb#e�m � ivb�e � b�su_a�EwJb#cv] 21�b�wzwKivb�e � b�su_a�EwJb#cv]/r�su_a�EwJb#cv] 2 1�b#w{wBiWb#e � ~*s{efefszq�c�-��R�X]b�ef]om�1�r�ò2r�j�} j�r^�¼} � j�r } ó ÿ r^r 2�2�2á Þ�ß�Ý�ðÞä:ï�ë�í ã Ý�í�Û�Ü hgb��vb��vwz]:q#p¸�E_aq)�%sJ�Rszcv|�szcRpTq�_a`�b)maszq�c�q�c

�E]M�Ew{qg�n]M�*b�su_�hMq�`��Wb)m�`!szefefs{q�cve�w{b��Ecvh>iv]g��s{c�b|�sz��]Mc*masz`!]�s{cnma]o_a��b�w

Ó.ô!Ógõ�öhÓ�ÔhÕ�Ö<Ôh×�×�Ô;Ø�Ù�×Ú�Û�Ü:Ý�Þ�ß:Ý jlq�`P�Wb)mg}W~*szefefszq�cfà#r�ò2r�j � r�su_@~*szefefszq�cá:â�ã Þä � b)ma].u�1�`!`��%x�cnmg}E�v�B�Rxyc%mg}%�%�¨�Rx�cnm 2

� ]M�Ewzq)��]g�W~*szefefszq�cruå sze�m�æ�p(1�`Pmg�v�%mf_aszcv|R}v`!s{�¨� �nmf_aszcv|�ç>x�cnmg}`��%m>b)_fmg� � b#ma]�}E` � cW�B� � b#ma] 2

è Ü ã�é Ý e�m>b#_fmg� � b)ma]�}v]ocW�B� � b)ma]ê é Ý ã:é Ý `!szefefszq�cveM� � ]M�Ewzq)��]g�W~*szefefszq�c �è ÜÚ:Û�Ü~ä�Ý:ë�ì�í�Ü�Ý�ä e�m>b#_fm.îjuÉ]Mcv�B�ê é Ý:Ú�Û�Ü~ä�Ý�ëì�í�Ü�Ýä �E]o�vwzqg�n]g��1�`!x � 2 }n`/m�uár�ò2r�j�}w{b��Ecvh>iv]g�Er�pCma]@_�1�`!sJ�¨} `��%m>b#_fm 2 }w{b��Ecvh>iv]g�Eßl]opTq#_a]:1�`!x � } ` � cW� 2 �Ú�Û�Ü�ï�ðÞä:ï�ë�í ã Ý�í�Û�Ü~ä r�ò2r�j � r�su_@~*szefefszq�c�u1�b�cv�*r�sz_@~*szefefszq�cñ1�b)mawz]gb�e�m � iWb#e � b�su_a�vw{b�cE] 21�b#ma`!q�e�m � iWb#e � b�su_a�vw{b�cE] 2 1�b�wzwOivb�e � b�su_a�EwJb#cv]b�ef]@m�1 �¸��� 2�2�2á Þ�ß�Ý�ðÞä:ï�ë�í ã Ý�í�Û�Ü hgb#�Wb��Ewz]:q�p¸�E_aq)�%s{�Eszcv|Pwzs{e�mae�q�p

�E]o�vwzqg�n]g�*roò2r�jÆb#sz_�hMq�`��vb#m�`!szefefszq�cve�w{b��Ecvh>iv]g�szc*efq�`!]:|�sz��]Mc�mas{`!]^s{cnma]o_a��b�w

Ãl< º GC´�ÛXÙGl�¿¨<R°*µBGJ´H²%³�<%Q�<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD@´�S2<RQBS�Y@´�ÎvI¨´�D>=@´�S"<R¹R´#Qv=:L#<RµB< º ACGCA{=aVS¨´�DoL)YoAJµX=oAJ²EQ"ACQ�Ê ­ Ø F�U¼½

Page 23: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

�9� ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

Ã3?¨´+-)�1U:S,*Ì�:<W47�:j+�h 021�3�L#²RQBD@ATDa=MD�²R³Â=a¶^²�L)²EQBD>´�L)IX=oA ® ´!Da=o´#µBD�ÙÚE½:樲RY�´ ® ´#YoV¯µK<%ACY"²R³�¶�²EYoSBD�÷ùø�úɹRA ® ´�Q AJQ =@?¨´üûfý�þ�ÿ�����ÿ¯D@GJ²R=oD�L)²E°*µBIX=@´6=@?¨´Y@´�<%GJ¾ ® <%GCI¨´�SÁ¶�²EYoSÆSXATD>=o<%QKL)´�D����3Ï%÷Bø�úWÐ���Ë JB·JÚ#Í�½�âP´)=@´�Y@°�ACQ¨´"=@?¨´"°*²vDa=�D>AC°�AJGT<%Y°�<%=oLM?¨´�D�³�²EY^<RQvV*¶^²RYMSi÷ º V�D>´�GJ´�Lg=oAJQ¨¹�¶�²EYoS¨D�ú�¶:A{=o?�=@?¨´�°�AJQBAJ°I¨° SXACD>=o<RQBL)´® <RGJIB´��3Ï6÷ùø�úXÐg½BÃ3?B´�D@´�SXACD>=o<RQBL)´�D3°�IBD>=:Q¨²%= ´#¿¨L)´#´�S"<*¹EA ® ´#Q"=@?¨Yo´�D@?¨²RGTS�½Û¨½:樲RYP´ ® ´#YoV2µB<RAJYP²%³�°�²ED>=PD>AC°�AJGT<%YP°�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹2¶�²EYoS¨D�·BLM?¨´�LMÄ'=o?B<n=P=@?¨´*D>´�°�<RQv=@ATLSXACD>=o<RQBL)´ <R°�²RQ¨¹H=o?¨´/<n=@=o<ELM?¨´�S�L)²EQBL)´�µX=oD�SX²W´�D�Q¨²R=�´)¿¨L#´#´�S�<H¹EA ® ´#Q*=@?¨Yo´�D@?¨²EGCS�½Ã3?¨´ +-)�WP=G7o'/0x.9)�1 )65{:2h;,D='�)��<?u,/.*²%³!Ê ­ Ø/F�UÝD@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQBD=oY@´�<n=@´�S¯<ED�SX²%¾

L)IB°*´�Qv=oD�Y@´�GJAC´�DP²RQ6<2D>=o<%QKS¨<%YMS�=@´�LM?¨Q¨ATÎvI¨´�³�Yo²R°ë=o?¨´ACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQ(Yo´)=@YoAC´ ® <%G�<%Yo´�<B·L#<RGJGC´�S2=@´�Y@°*¾�³�Y@´�ÎvI¨´#QBL#Vv¾�ACQ ® ´#YMD@´PSX²XL)IB°*´�Qv=^³�Yo´�ÎvI¨´�QBL)V2¶�´�AJ¹E?E=oAJQB¹�ÏyÃ:æ¾�»aâ�æ�Ðg½BÃ3?¨´D@AJ°�ACGC<RY@AJ=aV �����vÏ�������ø����WÐ�²%³�<ÆYo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=������Á<%QKS <%Q <ES ® ´�Y>=oACD@´#°�´#Qv=����ÝI¨QKSX´#YL)²EQBD@ACSX´�Yo<%=@AC²RQ"ACD3=o?¨´#Q�L�<%GTL)I¨GT<n=o´�S º VkÙ

�����vÏ������ø ���WÐ�¼ ����"!#���$ ����� $&%$ ��� $

¶:?¨´�Y@´'����(!���/S¨´#Q¨²R=@´�D¸=@?¨´�AJQBQ¨´#Yµ¨Y@²XSXIKLg=²R³X=@?¨´�¶�´�AJ¹E?v=@´�SHÄE´#VW¶^²RYMS ® ´�L)=@²RYMD�½»�³^=@?¨´ ® <%GCI¨´)�����vÏ������ø ���vÐ�SX²W´�DH´)¿¨L)´�´�SÁ<�¹RA ® ´#Qk=@?¨Yo´�D@?¨²EGCS+*,� � º ²R=@?ÁSX²XL)IX¾°�´#Qv=oDPµB<ED@D/=@?¨´µ¨Yo²%ÈBGC´!ÈBGJ=@´�Y�½¼æ¨²EYP´#¿X<R°�µ¨GJ´E·¨=o?¨´�µ¨Yo²%ÈKGJ´�D/²R³ º ²%=o?6D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQBDACQ"=o?¨´!´)¿¨<R°*µBGJ´!<%Yo´!D>AC°�AJGT<%Y:¶:AJ=@?�SX´�¹RYo´#´�J¨½ [��¨½Ã3?¨´°�<%=oLM?¨°�<RÄR´#Y =@?¨´�QkLM?¨´�LMÄXD/A{³�=o?¨´SX´�L)GT<%YM<n=oAJ²EQBD <%QKS(L)²EQBDa=oYo<RAJQv=MD:²%³ º ²%=o?

D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQBD�³�²RY3<�Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=3<%QBS"<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD>´�°�´#Qv=^<RY@´�D>IXÀ'L#AJ´�QE=oGJV�D@AJ°�ACGC<RY�½XÃ3?¨ATD�ACDSX²EQ¨´ º V�<�µB<%ACYo¶:ACD@´�L)²E°*µK<%YoACD@²RQ�²%³�SX´�L)GT<%YM<n=oAJ²EQBD <%QKS�L)²RQKDa=oYo<RAJQv=oD AJQ�=a¶^²'D>=@´#µKD#ÙUWAC°�AJGT<%YoA{=aV"<%QBS�D@AJ¹EQB<n=oI¨Y@´�°�<n=MLM?¨AJQB¹B½

V 02W�02?b7o'/02:�A WX7o:S+-h�021�3ÕY@´�GJAC´�D"²RQ <ÝL)²E° º ACQB<%=@AC²RQ ²R³�SXACD>=o<RQBL)´ ® <%GCI¨´�D�<RD�L#<RG{¾L)IBGC<%=@´�Sɳ�²EY'µB<RAJYMD�²%³!ACQ¨µ¨IX="<RQBSɲRIX=oµ¨IX="S¨´�L)GT<%YM<n=oAJ²EQBD�·�<%QBSÉACQ¨µ¨IX="<RQBSDzRI¨=@µ¨IX=L)²EQBD>=@YM<%ACQE=MD#½�l�<RLM?Õ²%³^=@?B´�D@´2SXATDa=M<%QBL#´ ® <RGJIB´�D�ATD�L#²R°�µ¨IX=o´�SÁACQÁ=@´#Yo°�D!²%³3=o?¨´2SXATDa¾=o<RQBL)´ º ´)=a¶^´#´�Q�L)²RQKL)´#µ¨=oD�<RQBS*¶�²EYoS¨DÂ=o?B<n=�²XL�L)I¨Y�ACQ*=@?¨´�AJY�Yo´�D@µO´�Lg=oA ® ´ D>µO´�L#A{ÈOL#<n=oAJ²EQD@´�Lg=oAJ²EQ¸½¸Ã3?¨´�D>´ ® <%GCI¨´�D!<RY@´�L)²E°�µ¨IX=@´�SÁ<n=H=@?¨´�=oAJ°�´�²%³:<RS ® ´#Y@=@ATD@´#°�´#Qv=!D>I º °*AJ=>=M<%G<%QKS�Da=o²RYo´�S�AJQ�=o?¨´�°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄR´�Y S¨<n=M< º <ED>´E½BÃ3?¨´�² ® ´#YM<%GCG�D>AC°�AJGT<%YoA{=aV ® <%GCI¨´�<%°�²RQB¹=a¶^²�D@µO´�L)AJÈKL�<n=@AC²RQKD3AJQ�Ê ­ Ø F�U2ACD:L#²R°�µ¨IX=o´�S�<RD^=o?¨´�< ® ´�Yo<R¹R´ ²R³Â=o?¨´!D>I¨° ²%³�D>AC°�A{¾GT<%YoA{=aV2L#²R°�µ¨IX=M<n=oAJ²EQBD:<%°�²RQB¹�<RGJG�µK<%ACYoD^²%³�SX´�L)GT<%YM<n=@AC²RQKD^<RQBS�L)²RQKDa=oYo<RAJQv=oD�½Ã3?¨´8./0e3o1�7�:By '*,-�<?@:j,d'�ÈBYMDa=�L)²EQBD@ACSX´�YoDÂ=o?¨´:SX´�L#GC<RYo<%=@AC²RQ�µK<%Y@=oD�²%³K=@?¨´:Yo´�ÎvI¨´�Da=�<%QKS

=@?B´3<ES ® ´�Y>=oACD@´#°�´�QE=�·�<RQBS�SX´#=@´�Y@°�ACQ¨´�DlµB<RAJYo¶:ACD@´�AJ³B=o?¨´#ACY�D>AC¹RQB<%=@I¨Yo´�D�²%³¨=o?¨´HÏ�ACQ¨µ¨IX=�²RY²RI¨=@µ¨IX=gÐ ® <RY@AT< º GC´3=aVWµK´�D�°�<n=MLM?2<RL�L)²EYoSXACQ¨¹�=@²<!¹RA ® ´�Q'D>´#=�²%³�=aVWµO´ AJQ¨³�´#Yo´#QBL#´/YoI¨GJ´�D#½I^²%=o?(ÈBGJ=@´�YoD�·¼=@?¨´�D@AJ°�ACGC<RY@AJ=aV(<%QBS6D>AC¹RQK<n=@IBY@´°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹�<%Yo´�IBD@´�S(=@²�SX´)=o´#Yo°�AJQ¨´�AJ³L)²EQBD@ACSX´�Y@´�S"Ê ­ Ø F�U�D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQBD:D@VWQv=o<RL)=@ATL#<RGJGCV�°�<n=oLM?�½ælAJQK<%GCGJVE·W=@?¨´!°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄE´#Y3LM?¨´�LMÄXD^A{³ º ²%=@?�D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQBD8.9,9WX7o1;:B0�+�7o?2?@A�W47�:j+�h

ACQ�=@´#Yo°�D º ²EY@Yo²n¶^´�S!³�Yo²R°ô=@?¨´ D@²%³�=a¶3<%Yo´3´#Q¨¹EAJQB´#´#YoACQ¨¹�<RY@´�<¨½ ­ D@²%³�=a¶3<%Yo´^L#²R°�µO²RQ¨´�QE=SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=@AC²RQ/. Z Q D>´�°�<%Qv=@ATL#<RGJGCVHµ¨GJIB¹%¾�AJQ°�<%=oLM?¨´�D9Qn<RQ¨²%=o?¨´#Y�L)²E°*µO²RQB´#Qv=�S¨´�DoL)YoAJµX=oAJ²EQ. N AJ³¸ÏaÚ�Ð�=@?¨´�AJYlD>AC¹RQK<n=@IBY@´�D�°�<n=oLM?�·EÏyÛEÐO=@?B´�D@´)=�²R³WACQ¨µ¨I¨=lL)²EQBD>=@YM<%ACQE=MD�²%³�. N GC²R¹EACL�<%GCGJVAC°*µBGJAC´�D/=@?B<%=P²R³'. Z ·O<RQBSÔÏyÜEÐ D@´)=�²%³�²RI¨=@µ¨IX=!L)²EQBD>=@YM<%ACQE=MD:²%³'. Z GJ²E¹RATL#<%GCGCV2AC°*µBGJAC´�D=@?K<n=�²%³0. N ½%»fQ�²EI¨Y�L#<ED>´�=@?¨´:GC²R¹EACL�<%GXAC°�µ¨GJATL#<%=@AC²RQ�<%°�²EQ¨¹�L#²RQBD>=@YM<%ACQv=oDlATD�L)²E°*µBIX=@´�SIBD@AJQB¹�µK²EGJVWQ¨²E°*AT<%G¸<RQBS�D>²EI¨QBS21n¾�D@I º D@I¨°�µX=oAJ²EQ�LM?B´�LMÄWAJQB¹�³�²EYP� ²EY@Q�L)GT<%IBD@´�DHË Ûo��Í�½

Page 24: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| � \

ø�ùuõ�ù4365X ��Z� � � �Z� ��� �G$#�����4 � ��� �#� ý�$���ÿ����"$ � ý��Z �ý � �÷�G�lÿ � �G �$#�Âý����Y/=@?B´#Y/<Rµ¨µ¨Yo²E<RLM?B´�D^²RQÁÏ×<RQ¨Q¨²%=M<n=o´�SBÐ3D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQ�<%QKS"°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹�²%³�SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBD²%³/L�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D<%QBSÆD@´#Y ® ACL#´�D ® AT<(Da=M<%QBSB<%YMSXAJÓ�´�SÁ°�<%YoÄWI¨µÆGT<%Q¨¹EIB<%¹E´�D�·�²RQv=@²EGJ²E¹RAC´�D�·<%QKSÕ<R¹R´�QE=�L�<%µB< º AJGCAJ=aV6SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=@AC²RQÕGT<%Q¨¹EIB<%¹E´�D�AJQKL)GCIBSX´2U ��Y8l Ë Û%ÌnÍ�·sYPQE=o²�I^Yo²RÄR´�YË ÜRÜ�Í�·mY�D>ACYoA{¿þËJÚ�J�Í�·/åH;(â OP;kÊ!I^Yo²RÄE´#Y6ËJÚ�[nÍ�· ;�»jO Ë Ü�Í�·:´#K�²ÇD>VXD>=@´#° ËJÚ#Ì%Í�·:<%QKS� ­ ÃPT%K^â�ÊáË M�Í�·¨Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=oA ® ´#GCVR½7 ����È | û É ù Ã3?¨´ L�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=aV�SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=@AC²RQ�GT<%Q¨¹EIB<%¹E´�ÏSK^âPÊlÐ:ËNM�ÍK?B<ED º ´�´#Q�SX´ ® ´#GC²%¾µO´�S(<%=:=@?¨´�IBQ¨A ® ´#YMD>AJ=aV2²R³sl�SXACQ º I¨Y@¹E?¸½K^<RµB< º ACGCA{=oAJ´�D:²%³�<%QKS�Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=oD^³�²RY�D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D<%Yo´'SX´�D@L#Y@A º ´�SÕAJQ K^â�Êá´#AJ=@?¨´�Y�ACQÁ=@´#Yo°�D!²%³:<RLM?BAJ´ ® < º GC´�² º ±a´�Lg=@A ® ´�DH²RY�<EDHµK´�Y>³�²EY>¾°�< º GC´H<RLg=oAJ²EQBD�½vælAC¹RI¨Yo´PÑB½NM º ´#GC²n¶ D@?¨²n¶ D�<RQ'´)¿¨<R°*µBGJ´P²%³Â<�Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=^D@µK´�L)AJÈB´�S"<RD^<=o<ED>Ä�S¨´�DoL)YoAJµX=oAJ²EQ<RQBS<�L#<RµB< º AJGCA{=aV!SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=oAJ²EQ�ACQ4K^â�Ê�½%Ã3?¨´3GT<n=@=@´#Y�SX´�D@L#Y@A º ´�DÂ=@?¨´L#<RµB< º AJGCA{=aVk²%³^<�?¨²vD>µBA{=M<%Gl=@²�°�² ® ´*µB<n=oAJ´�Qv=oD�=@²�AJ=oD!GC²XL#<%=@AC²RQ ® AT<�<%° º I¨GC<RQBL)´�<%QKS=@Yo´�<%=�=@?B´#° <RD�ACQn±aI¨Yo´�SÁµO´#YMD@²RQBD�½�Ã3?¨´2<R¹R´�QE=�¶:?B²(ACD�Y@´�µ¨Yo´�D@´#Qv=@ACQ¨¹�=@?¨ATD?¨²ED@µ¨AJ=o<%G<%GTD@²*<ES ® ´�Y>=oACD@´�D�=@?K<n=:A{=MD3µ¨Yo² º GC´#°*¾fD>²EG ® ACQ¨¹ º ´#?B< ® AC²RY3ATD:L)²R°�µ¨GC´)=o´H¶:A{=o?�Yo´�D@µO´�Lg=^=@²=@?BACD�L#<RµB< º ACGCA{=aVE·BA�½ ´E½¨=@?K<n=�·OAJ³�=@?¨´�Y@´�ATD�<'D>²EGJI¨=@AC²RQ�=@²"<�µ¨Yo² º GC´#°ëA{=�¶:AJGCG¸ÈKQBS�AJ=�½O»fQ=@?B´L)²EQv=@´)¿W=/²R³�=@?¨´�µK<%Y@=@ATL)I¨GT<%Y/L�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=aV2ACQ�=@?B´�´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´!=o?¨ACD/AJ°�µ¨GCAC´�D:=o?B<n=P=@?¨´?¨²vD>µ¨AJ=o<RG�¶:AJGCG¸¹E´)= ²RQBGJV'ACQn±aI¨Yo´�S�µO´#²Eµ¨GJ´E½­ Yo´�ÎvI¨´�D>=�²%³�D>´�Y ® ATL)´^ACD�D@µK´�L)AJÈB´�S*ACQK^âPÊ�<RD�<P=M<RD@Ä�SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQ¸Å�³�²EY�´)¿¨<%°�µ¨GC´R·

=@?B´�Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=@´�SÕL#<RµB< º AJGCA{=aV(S¨´)ÈBQ¨´�SÕAJQ6=@?¨´�=M<RD@ÄkSX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=@AC²RQÕD>?B²n¶:Q6ACQÕÈB¹RI¨Yo´�Ѩ½@MATD:D>I º D>I¨°�´�S º V�=@?B´�L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=aV�²%³�=@?¨´H?¨²vD>µ¨AJ=o<RG¸<%¹E´#Qv=3S¨´�DoL)YoA º ´�S"< º ² ® ´R½XæB²RY^=@?¨´µ¨I¨YoµO²ED@´�²R³�<RIX=@²E°�<%=@´�SÝGC²R¹EACL)¾ º <ED>´�SÆYo´�<RD@²RQBAJQ¨¹6²RQÇL#<RµB< º ACGCA{=aVÔSX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=oAJ²EQBD*=@?¨´D>=o<n=o´#°�´#Qv=MD�<%Yo´3³�²RYo°�<%GCGJV*D>µO´�L#A{ÈK´�S�ACQ'<�ÈBYoD>=>¾�²RYMSX´�Y�µ¨Y@´�SXATL#<n=o´:GJ²E¹RATL º <RD@´�S*³�²EY@°�<%=GCAJÄE´�FH»aæ Ë Û¨ÚgÍ�½

Advertisement:

(capability:isa m8 ove

:properties (complete)

:state-language fopl

:input

((To Hospital2)(Ambulance ?a))

:input-constraints

((elt ?thing Person)

(Is ?thing Injured) )

)

Query:

(task:isa m8 ove

:properties (complete)

:state-language fopl

:input

((Thing JohnSmith)

(From PowerPlant)

(To Hospital2)

:input-constraints

((elt JohnSmith Person)

(Is JohnSmith Injured) )

)

ß<àuáâ�ã;â:9 âB� �Eb�`!�Ewz]3q�p¸b#c�b��R��]o_fmaszef]g��hgb��vb��vszwzsum����E]Mefho_asz�Rmas{q�c�b�cv��,n�v]@_f�szc�j �9å

Page 25: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

��� ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

ʸ²E¹RATLg¾ º <RD@´�S�Yo´�<ED>²EQ¨ACQ¨¹�² ® ´�Y�SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=oAJ²EQBD�ACQfK^âPÊ6ACD º <ED>´�S�²RQ2=@?¨´HQ¨²R=@AC²RQ'²R³L#<RµB< º AJGCA{=aV6D>I º D>I¨°�µX=oAJ²EQ6²EY�=@?¨Yo²RI¨¹E?kACQBD>=o<%Qv=oAC<%=@AC²RQ¸½9Ë<7�=;7%>902?@02:BA�./y;>/./y WP=:B0�)�1�ACQK^â�ÊÝYo´)³�´�YoD/=@²"=@?¨´�ÎvI¨´�D>=@AC²RQk¶:?¨´)=o?¨´#Y!<2L�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=aV�SX´�DoL)YoAJµ¨=@AC²RQkL�<%Q º ´*IBD>´�S�=@²D@²RG ® ´�<2µ¨Y@² º GC´#° SX´�DoL)YoA º ´�S º V�<�¹EA ® ´#Q�=M<RD@Ä�S¨´�DoL)YoAJµX=oAJ²EQ�AJQ K^âPÊ�Ù ­ L#<RµB< º ACGCA{=aVK D>I º D>I¨°�´�D:<*=o<RD@Ä2à A{³ÚE½3AJQÆ=o?¨´�Y@´�D>I¨GJ=²R³ µK´�Y>³�²EY@°�ACQ¨¹ K <RGJG^²RI¨=@µ¨IX=�L)²EQBD>=@YM<%ACQE=MD�²R³/à <%Yo´"Do<n=@ATD>ÈB´�S�·°*´�<%QBD�A{³¼=@?B´ L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=aVXKÝ<RLM?BAJ´ ® ´�Dl=o?¨´/SX´�D>ACYo´�S�Da=M<n=o´ <RD�D@µK´�L)AJÈB´�S*ACQ'ÃH·R<%QKSÛ¨½3A{³!ACQ¯=o?¨´kD@A{=oIB<n=oAJ²EQÉ=@?B<%='µ¨Y@´�L)´�SX´�D�=o?¨´�Yo´�D@I¨G{='²R³!µK´�Y>³�²EY@°�ACQ¨¹ KP·�<%GCG ACQ¨µ¨IX=L)²RQKDa=oYo<RAJQv=oD^²R³<K <%Yo´HDo<n=oACD>ÈB´�S�·X°�´�<%QKD^=@?B<%=/L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=aVRK ACD:<Rµ¨µ¨GCACL�< º GC´R½»�=/ATD/<ED@D@I¨°�´�S"=@?K<n= =o?¨´#Yo´�ATD <�°�²XSX´#GJ¾y=o?¨´#²EY@´#=@ATL!D>´�°�<%Qv=@ATL#D S¨´)ÈBQ¨´�S�³�²RY ´ ® ´�Y@V

D>=o<n=o´PGT<%QB¹RIB<R¹R´/IKD>´�S�=@²*´)¿Xµ¨Yo´�DoD^L)²RQKDa=oYo<RAJQv=oD�ACQ�K^â�Ê6S¨´�DoL)YoAJµX=oAJ²EQBD�½WÃ3?BACD^AC°*µBGJAC´�D=@?K<n=�Yo´�<RD@²RQBAJQ¨¹�Yo´#GCAJ´�DH²RQ÷WX)"C%,9?@c6>-7#.9,-C +�)o1G./:B'*7�021U:�.97�:B0x.�5d7%+9:�0�)o1B½ ­ L)²RQKDa=oYo<RAJQv=HACDDo<n=@ATD>ÈB´�SHACQ�<:D>AJ=@IK<n=@AC²RQHAJ³X=@?¨´�°*²XSX´�GEL#²RYoY@´�D>µO²RQBS¨AJQ¨¹�=@² =@?¨´�D@AJ=@IB<%=@AC²RQHACDÂ<3°�²WS¨´#GR²R³=@?B´�´#¿WµBY@´�D@D@AJ²EQ�Yo´#µ¨Yo´�D@´#Qv=@ACQ¨¹:=o?¨´3L)²RQKDa=oYo<RAJQv=�½�Ø:´�¹E<%YMSXACQ¨¹/L�<%µB< º AJGCAJ=aVHD@I º D@I¨°�µX=oAJ²EQ=@?BACD�°�´�<RQBD=@?B<%=�=@?¨´�ACQ¨µ¨IX='L)²EQBD>=@YM<%ACQE=MD�²R³P<k=o<RD@ÄÔSX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=@AC²RQÉÃ�SX´#ÈBQ¨´�<6D@´)=²%³3°�²XSX´#GTD#·�²RQ¨´�²%³^¶:?¨ATLM?ÕATD�L#²RYoY@´�D>µO²RQBS¨AJQ¨¹2=@²�=o?¨´'<RL)=@IB<RG�D>AJ=@IB<%=@AC²RQ º ´#³�²RYo´�=@?¨´L#<RµB< º AJGCA{=aVPACD¸=@² º ´�<%µBµ¨GJAC´�S¸½�UWAC°�AJGT<%YoGJVE·g=@?B´�²RIX=oµ¨IX=ÂL#²RQBD>=@YM<%ACQv=oD¼²R³XÃÁSX´#ÈBQ¨´�< D@´)=¸²R³°�²XSX´#GTD#·W<%GCGB²R³¸¶:?¨ATLM?'L)²RYoYo´�D@µK²EQBS=@²D@AJ=@IB<%=@AC²RQBD�AJQ�¶:?¨ATLM?�=o?¨´/² º ±a´�L)=@A ® ´ ?B<ED º ´#´�Q<RLM?BAJ´ ® ´�S¸½OÃ3?¨´�Y@´#³�²RYo´<"L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=aVkK D@I º D@I¨°�´�DH<�=M<RD@Ä�à Ï×<EÐ/AJ³�´ ® ´#YoV"°�²XSX´�Gl²R³Ã�Q DÂACQ¨µ¨I¨=�L#²RQBD>=@YM<%ACQv=oD¸ATDl<%GTD>²�< °�²XSX´#Gv²%³¨=o?¨´aKmQ DlAJQBµ¨IX=�L)²RQKDa=oYo<RAJQv=oD�Ï�ACQ¨µ¨IX=�°�<n=MLM?L)²EQBSXAJ=@AC²RQKÐ)·E<RQBS"Ï º Ð�AJ³�´ ® ´�Y@V!°�²XSX´�GB²%³öKmQ D�²RIX=oµ¨IX=�L#²RQBD>=@YM<%ACQv=oD�ATD�<%GTD>²H<H°�²XSX´#G¨²R³Ã�Q DH²RIX=oµ¨IX=�L)²EQBDa=oYo<RAJQv=MD#½¼Ã3?¨ATD�S¨´)ÈBQ¨AJ=@AC²RQÕ²%³3L#<RµB< º ACGCA{=aV(D@I º D@I¨°�µX=@AC²RQ6Y@´�D>´�° º GC´�D=@?K<n='²%³HD>´�°�<%Qv=@ATL�µ¨GJIB¹%¾�AJQÉ°�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹Á²R³�Ê ­ Ø F�UÉSX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBD�<ED�SX´�DoL)YoA º ´�S¯ACQD@´�Lg=oAJ²EQ�Ѩ½ ܨ½ Ü< º ² ® ´R½

I^²%=o?=o?¨´8K^â�Ê�<%QBS=o?¨´ µ¨Yo²RµO²ED@´�S°�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹!²R³LK^â�Ê�SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=@AC²RQKD�?B< ® ´ º ´#´�QAC°*µBGJ´�°*´�Qv=@´�S6ACQ �v< ® <2<%QKS(=o´�D>=@´�SkAJQÁD@´#GC´�Lg=o´�SÕ<%µ¨µBGJATL#<%=@AC²RQkDoL)´�QB<%YoAJ²vD ³�²EY º Y@²EÄR´#¾YoAJQ¨¹�ACQ�°�IBG{=oAC<R¹R´#Qv=/D@VXDa=o´#°�D/SX´ ® ´�GJ²EµK´�S"ACQf� ­ à Ï��E< ® < ­ ¹E´#Qv=Pô#°�µ¨GT<n=o´�Ð)ËJÚ��nÍ�½K»fQD@I¨°�°�<RY@VE·�K^âPÊÇATD�=@²�D@²R°�´�´)¿W=@´�Qv=!D@AC°*ACGT<%YH=@²�Ê ­ Ø F�U º IX=!=o?¨´�°�<n=oLM?BAJQ¨¹�°�´)¾=@?B²WSBDPµBY@²EµK²vD>´�S�³�²RY�´�<ELM?(²%³�=o?¨´�GC<RQ¨¹RIB<R¹R´�D SXAJãO´�YHD@AC¹RQ¨AJÈKL#<RQv=@GCV�ACQ(=o´#Yo°�D/²R³�=@?¨´µ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD:<%QKS"ÎvIB<RGJAJ=aV'²%³�Yo´�<RD@²RQBAJQ¨¹K½� | � | ��É/ù Ã3?B´�´#K�²'D@VXDa=o´#°{Q D�ËJÚ#Ì%Í�L)²E°*°�²EQ º IBD@AJQ¨´�D@D/GJA º YM<%YoV6ÏSK(I^ÊlÐ L#²RQBD@ACD>=oD²%³ º IBD@AJQ¨´�D@D�SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=oAJ²EQBD<RQBSƳ�²EY@°�DY@´�µ¨Yo´�D@´#Qv=@´�SÆAJQÉ<%Q¯´)¿W=@´�QBD>A º GC´R·�µ¨I º GJATL"D@´)=²%³mOP;(Ê º I¨ACGCS¨AJQ¨¹ º GC²XLMÄWD�=@?K<n=�D>´�Y ® ATL)´2µBY@² ® ATSX´#YMD�ACQÔ=o?¨´�S¨²R°�<%ACQÔ²%³P´#GC´�Lg=oY@²EQ¨ATLL)²E°�°*´�YoL#´"L�<%Q¯L#IBD>=@²R°�ACÓ#´�<%QBSÝ<RDoD>´�° º GC´R½�UW´#°�<RQE=oACL�D*²%³ =o?¨´�K(I3Ê-<%Yo´"SX´�Y@A ® ´�S=@?BY@²EI¨¹R?2<RQB<%GCVXD>ATD�²R³¸AJQBS¨IBDa=oY@V�D>=o<RQBS¨<%YMS¨D�·ED@IBLM?'<RDil�âP»�O�Ú�Û%Ñ��%J�³�²RY3D>µO´�L#A{ÈOL#<n=oAJ²EQ²%³�µ¨IBYoLM?B<ED>´!²EYoS¨´#YMD#½¨Ã3?¨ATD GC´�S�=o²2< º <ED>´�D@´)=P²%³�L)²E°*°�²EQ"=o´#Yo°�D#·B=@´#Yo°ë°�<Rµ¨µ¨ACQ¨¹EDACQ�=@?¨´�SX²E°�<%ACQ�²R³l´#¾�L#²R°�°�´#YML)´E·¨<%QBS�L)²EY@Yo´�D@µO²RQBSXACQ¨¹�OP;(ÊÆSB<n=o<�´�GJ´�°�´#Qv=oD�·B<n=@=@YoA{¾º IX=o´�D�·O<RQBS�¹R´�Q¨´#YoATLFOP;(ʯSX²XL)I¨°�´�QE=/=aVvµO´S¨´)ÈBQ¨AJ=@AC²RQKDÏyâPÃ:âHÐg½ ­ QWV�Y@´�ÎvI¨´�D>= ³�²RY<ÁD>´�Y ® ATL)´"ACD*=oYo<RQBDa³�²EY@°�´�SÁ=@²Æ<%QÉ<%µ¨µBY@²Eµ¨Y@AT<n=o´"D>=o<RQBS¨<%YMSÔâ�Ã:âé¶:?¨ATLM?Ô=o?¨´#QáL#<RQ´#AJ=@?B´#Y º ´�IBD@´�SÔ=@²6ÈBQBSÝD@AC°*ACGT<%Y�âPÃ:â�D*²%³P< ® <%ACGT< º GC´"D@´#Y ® ACL#´2SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBD²RY=@²µ¨Yo²XSXIBL)´!<�D>=@Yo´�<R° ²%³�AJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ�´ ® ´�Qv=oD^Y@²EIX=@´�S'=o²'<%QBS"µ¨Yo²XL)´�DoD@´�S º V º IBD@AJQ¨´�D@D<%µBµ¨GJATL#<%=@AC²RQBD�½

Page 26: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| � �

°<; � û¦Æ �G�lÿ | 5r®�Ç ° ù Ã3?¨´HU � ­ âmlÉ<%QKSRK�YP»gôPUkË ÛEÛ�Í�<%Yo´/°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄR´�YoD º <n¾D@´�S(²EQ6FF��;(Ê�½�Ã3?¨´�L)²EQv=@´#Qv=HGC<RQ¨¹RIK<%¹R´²%³aK�YP»gô�U(<RGJGC²n¶ D ³�²EY�³�Y@´�´�=o´)¿W=HD@µO´�L)AJȨ¾L#<%=@AC²RQÕ²%³3D>´�Y ® ATL)´�DH<RQBS(AJ=oD!°�<%=oLM?¨ACQ¨¹�<%GC¹R²RYoAJ=@?¨°éIX=oAJGCACÓ#´�D�=o?¨´�=>³�¾�ATSW³^ACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQYo´)=@YoAC´ ® <%G¼°�´)=o?¨²XS�½BÃ3?¨´!L)²EQv=@´#Qv=3GC<RQ¨¹RIK<%¹R´�²%³Â=@?¨´�U � ­ â8lÇ°�<n=oLM?B°�<RÄR´�Y^L#²RQBD@ACD>=oD²%³¼=a¶^²HµB<%Y@=oD�·%²RQB´:ACD�<!D@I º D@´)=�²R³K=o?¨´ ÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´3AJQv=@´�YoLM?K<%Q¨¹E´�³�²EY@°�<%=/Ï×FH»aæ�Ðg·R<RQ¨²%¾=@?B´#Y^ACD3<�D>=@YoIBLg=oI¨Yo´�S�GC²R¹EACL/Y@´�µ¨Y@´�D>´�Qv=o<n=oAJ²EQ�L#<%GCGC´�S'; ­ O�½X; ­ O IBD@´�D�GC²R¹RATL3³�YM<%°�´�D=@²!SX´�L)GT<%YM<n=oA ® ´#GCVHD>=@²EY@´�=@?¨´3ÄWQ¨²n¶:GC´�SX¹E´R½%U � ­ â8l6IKD>´�Dl<P³�YM<%°�´^GJACÄR´^Y@´�µ¨Yo´�D@´#Qv=o<%=@AC²RQ<%QKS2=o?¨´!°�<n=MLM?¨´#Y:IBD@´�D:<*µ¨Yo²RGC²R¹*GCAJÄE´�IBQ¨A{ÈK´#Y�½5X "��� � ���$#�Z�Âý�ø�ù����8�G�Âÿ �S�;��� �;�×ý�� � � � ����� "�vÿ � $%� �s� ��ý��yý� -�kÿZ���"$ � ý��� �ý � ���EùÃ3?¨´�µ¨Yo² º GC´#° ²%³PL�<%µB< º ACGJAJ=aVÕ<RQBSÔD@´#Y ® ACL#´2SX´�DoL)YoACµX=@AC²RQBD*L#<RQ º ´"=o<ELMÄWGJ´�SÔ<n=*GJ´�<RD>=³�Yo²R°�=o?¨´H³�²RGCGC²n¶:AJQ¨¹�SXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv=/<%µ¨µ¨Yo²E<ELM?¨´�D�½ÚE½ V )g5-:B`�7�'�,F.B=;,�+90 �i+-7o:�0�)o1 :j,-+�h 1;0�z9y;,/.g½­ ¹R´�Qv=oD*<%Yo´2L)²E°*µBIX=@´�Y�µ¨Yo²R¹EYo<R°�D!=@?B<%=?B< ® ´2D>²E°�´2D>µO´�L#A{ÈOL2LM?B<RYo<ELg=@´�Y@ATD>=@ATL#D�½Ã3?¨´#Yo´P<RY@´ QWI¨°�´�Y@²EIBD�¶^²RYoÄXD�³�²RY3D>²R³�=a¶^<RY@´PD>µO´�L#A{ÈKL�<n=oAJ²EQBD�ACQ�³�²RYo°�<%GO°�´)=@?B²WSBD#·GJACÄR´*°�²WS¨´#GJ¾�²EY@AC´#Qv=@´�S(Ò�âP; <%QKS#=l·�²EY!<%GC¹R´ º Yo<RACL)¾�²EY@AC´#Qv=@´�S�Ê�<%YMLM?¸½ ­ GJ=@?B²RI¨¹E?=@?¨´�D>´�GT<%Q¨¹EIB<%¹E´�D�<%Yo´¹E²v²XS6<n=�SX´�DoL)YoA º AJQB¹�L#²R°�µ¨IX=o´#Y!µ¨Yo²R¹EYo<R°�D/AJQÁ<�µ¨Yo´�L)ATD@´¶^<�VE·E=o?¨´�D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQ�IBD>IK<%GCGJV'L#²RQv=o<RAJQBD^=o²W²*°IBLM?�SX´)=M<%ACG¼=@² º ´!²R³ÂACQv=@´#Yo´�D>=oD=@²H²%=o?¨´#Y�<%¹E´#Qv=oD�½�I^´�D@ACSX´�D#·�=o?¨²ED@´�´#¿XACD>=@ACQ¨¹HGC<RQ¨¹RIK<%¹R´�D�<RY@´3D>²HL)²E°�µ¨GJ´#¿�=@?K<n=�=@?¨´D>´�°�<RQv=@ATL�L)²E°�µB<%YoACD@²RQ º ´)=a¶^´#´�Q�=@?B´�D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQBDl<%µ¨µO´�<RYoD¸=@² º ´^AJ°�µO²EDoD>A º GC´R½Ã3?¨´�Y@´�<RSXACQ¨¹�<%QKSk¶:YoA{=oAJQB¹�²%³^=@?¨´�D>´'D@µK´�L)AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQBD!<RGCD@²�Y@´�ÎvI¨AJYo´�D>I º Da=M<%Qv=@AT<%G=@YM<%ACQ¨AJQB¹B½Û¨½ ~ +9:�0�)o1f'*,j='*,d.9,d1U:S7o:�0�)o1D5d)o'/WX7o?@0x./Ww.g½­ ¹R´�Qv="L#<RµB< º ACGCA{=aVÉL#<%Q º ´6D@´#´�Q <RD�=o?¨´6<ELg=oAJ²EQBD�=@?K<n=2=o?¨´6<R¹R´�QE=MD�µO´#Y@³�²RYo°�½Ã3?¨´#Yo´<RY@´*<'QWI¨° º ´#Y�²%³^<RLg=oAJ²EQ(Yo´#µ¨Yo´�D@´#Qv=o<%=@AC²RQ�³�²EY@°�<%GCATD>°�DPAJQ ­ »:µ¨GT<%Q¨QBAJQ¨¹GJACÄR´H=o?¨´�L)GT<RDoD@ACL�<%G�²RQB´�UXÃ:Ø:»aÖ�U�½BÃ3?¨´�<RL)=@AC²RQ�Yo´#µ¨Yo´�D@´#Qv=o<%=@AC²RQ"³�²RYo°�<%GCACD@°�D:<%Yo´AJQB<ESX´�ÎvIB<%=@´AJQ6²RI¨Y/=o<RD@Ä�AJQk=@?B<%=P=o?¨´#V�<RY@´µ¨Y@²EµK²vD>AJ=@AC²RQK<%GÂ<RQBS�Q¨²R=�ACQ ® ²EG ® ACQ¨¹S¨<n=M<�=aVWµO´�D�½ÜB½iË�)o1+-,j=:(?b7�1�3oy;7�3�,d.�5d)�'mto1)o`(?u,�C�3�,�'�,S=�'*,/.9,91;:j7�:B0�)�1K½Ã3?¨´#Yo´�<%Yo´ ® <RY@AC²RIKD¼=@´�Y@°�ACQ¨²RGC²R¹EACL�<%G�ÄWQ¨²n¶:GJ´�SX¹R´�Yo´#µ¨Yo´�D@´#Qv=M<n=@AC²RQ�GT<%Q¨¹EIB<%¹E´�D�½d� ²%¾¶�´ ® ´#Y�·X²RQv=o²RGC²R¹RV�AJ=oD@´#GJ³�SX²W´�D:QB²%=PSX´�D@L#Y@A º ´�L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D�½YPQ�=@?B´!²%=@?B´#Y ?B<RQBS�·²RQv=@²EGJ²E¹RATL#<%G�SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=oAJ²EQBDHµ¨Yo² ® ATSX´�<%I¨¿WACGCAC<RY@V(L#²RQBL#´#µX=MDH=@²(<ED@D@ACD>=H=@?¨´'D@µO´�L)AJȨ¾L#<n=oAJ²EQ"²R³Â=o?¨´�L#<RµB< º AJGCA{=oAJ´�D3²%³�<%¹R´�Qv=oD�½ÌK½�vD7o:S7�>�7�.9,Dz9y;,d'/A+-7-=G7�>d02?@02:BARC�,/.9+9'/0 =:B0�)�1K½Ã3?¨´*SB<n=o< º <RD@´�ÎvI¨´�Y@V�L#<RµB< º AJGCA{=aV�SX´�D@L#Y@ACµX=oAJ²EQ(=@´�LM?¨Q¨ATÎvI¨´�ATDHSX´ ® ´#GC²RµO´�S(<EDP<RQ<n=>=o´#°�µX=�=o²(SX´�DoL)YoA º ´�=o?¨´�AJQ¨³�²RYo°�<%=@AC²RQÆD@²RI¨YML)´�DP²EQÕ=@?¨´'»fQv=o´#YoQ¨´)=�·�D>IKLM?6=o?B<n=<%Q <%I¨=@²R°�<%=@´�SÇACQv=@´�¹RYM<n=@AC²RQɲ%³�ACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQÇACD2µK²vD@D@A º GJ´E½�»fQá=o?¨ACD"<%µ¨µBY@²v<RLM?=@?¨´ ACQX³�²EY@°�<n=oAJ²EQ'D>²EI¨YML)´:ATD�°�²XSX´#GC´�S�<ED�<!S¨<%=o< º <RD@´:¶:A{=o?'Y@´�Da=oY@ATLg=o´�S�ÎvI¨´#YoVWAJQB¹L#<%µK< º ACGJAJ=@AC´�D�½

�3 ?>1è6§�¤P«�ö>ªPñv¬>§�¤/ñ

Ã3?¨´�»fQv=o´#YoQ¨´)= ATD <%Q�²EµK´�Q�D@VXDa=o´#° ¶:?¨´#Yo´!?¨´)=o´#Yo²R¹E´#Q¨´�²RIBD3<%¹E´#Qv=oD:L�<%Q�<%µBµK´�<%Y <%QKSSXATD@<Rµ¨µO´�<%Y*SXVWQB<%°�ATL#<RGJGCVR½ ­ D�=o?¨´'QWI¨° º ´�Y�²%³/<R¹R´�QE=MD!²RQÁ=o?¨´'»fQv=@´�Y@QB´)=ACQBL#Y@´�<RD@´�D�·

Page 27: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

� Þ ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

=@?B´#Yo´6ATD"<ÝQ¨´#´�SÇ=@²ÉSX´)ÈKQ¨´6°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD'=@²É?¨´#GCµ <%¹E´#Qv=oD2GJ²XL�<n=@´6²%=o?¨´#YMD'=o?B<n=µ¨Yo² ® ACSX´2Y@´�ÎEIB´�D>=@´�SÆSB<n=o<6<%QBSÝD>´�Y ® ATL)´�D�½¸»fQÆ=o?¨ATD*LM?K<%µX=o´#Y�¶^´'ACQv=@Yo²WS¨IBL)´�SÔD>´ ® ´�Yo<RGSXAJãO´�Y@´�Qv="L)GT<RDoD>´�D�²%³ º <ED>ATL�D>´�Y ® ATL)´�D�<%QWVÝ°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=�QB´#´�SBD�=@²Ô<Rµ¨µ¨Yo²Rµ¨YoAT<n=@´�GJVACQBDa=M<%Qv=@AT<n=o´�=o²PµO´#Y@³�²RYo° </°�´�<%Q¨ACQ¨¹%³�IBGy·�´)ã¼´�L)=@A ® ´E·�<RQBS!Yo´#GCAC< º GC´�°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ º ´)=a¶^´#´�Q<%¹E´#Qv=oD3¶:AJ=@?BAJQ�<%QKS�<EL)Yo²EDoD�°I¨GJ=@ACµ¨GJ´�<R¹R´�QE= D@²XL)AC´)=@AC´�D�½àÕ´�?B< ® ´!µBY@²EµK²vD>´�S�<2L)GT<RDoD>AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQ�²%³�°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD:¶:AJ=@?(Yo´�D@µK´�Lg=:=o²�=@?¨´�D>´

D@´#Y ® ATL)´HL)GT<RDoD@´�D�·Eµ¨Yo´�D@´#Qv=o´�S�<L#²R°�µB<RL)=3S¨´�DoL)YoAJµX=oAJ²EQ2²R³lD@´#Y ® ATL)´�°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄWAJQB¹<%QKSº Yo²RÄE´#YoAJQ¨¹K·%<%QBS¸·%ÈBQB<RGJGCVR·ED>I¨Y ® ´�VR´�S*D@²R°�´:µ¨Yo²R°�ACQ¨´#Qv=�´#¿X<R°�µ¨GJ´�D�²%³�°I¨G{=oAC<R¹R´�QE=�D@VXDa¾=@´�°�D^<RQBS�µ¨GT<n=@³�²RYo°�D�¶:?¨ATLM?2<RY@´/L#²W²RYMSXAJQK<n=@´�S º V�D>µO´�L#AC<RGKÄWACQBS¨D�²%³¸°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD#·QB<R°*´�GJV º Yo²RÄE´#Y�<%QBS�°�<%=oLM?¨°�<%ÄE´#Y�<%¹R´�Qv=oD�½ ­ L#²R°�µB<RYo<%=@A ® ´�² ® ´#Y ® AC´#¶-²%³�D@´#GC´�L)=@´�S°�<n=MLM?¨°�<%ÄR´�Y�· º Yo²RÄE´#Y�·O<RQBS6°*´�SXAT<n=@²EY!<%¹R´�Qv=oDH<RL�L)²RYMSXACQ¨¹'=o²�=@?¨´'D@´#Y ® ACL#´)¾�²RYoAJ´�QE=o´�SL)GT<RDoD@A{ÈKL�<n=oAJ²EQ"²R³Â°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD3ACD3¹EA ® ´#Q�AJQ�ÈB¹EI¨Yo´HÑB½ ÑB½

ACD@

L processing• ACDL descriptions• matching

SemA

antic interoperation• ontology services

• semantic reconciliation

• information model

Data management

QB

uery processing

• distributed query planning• transaction_services

A@

gent interaction

Mediation_protocol

IMPACT InfoSleuth RETSINA GMD MIX Broker Matchmaker Broker Mediator

Mediation Services

Access sources

k-C

nearestneD ighbor

HTML-l ike XMLLARKS frameframe

structuralmE atching

TF-IDF, plug-in,tFype inference,

coG nstraint match,coG ncept subsumption

veH rb/noun hierarchy,thF

esaurus

glI obal,coG llection

XJ

X coG ncept base,daK

tabases

XML dJ

atawaL rehouse,

XQL

WorM

dNet,ITL coN

ncepts

XML

glI obal,coG llection

glI obal,integrated

synonym, woL rd distance

inO

fosleuthontologyPsynonym,

vaH lue matching

synonym, woL rd distance,subsumption

DTDmE atching

glI obal,coG llection

XML sJ

chema,viH ews,BBQ

DTDmatching

(search bots) (wrapper)

pQ art. integratedcoG llection

XJ

ML namespaces

matchmaking matchmaking matchE making brR

okerage brokerage

wrL appercG ooperation

XJ

inO

termediateinO

termediate

searchbotscG ooperation

register,mE atching

register,mE atching

register,mE atching

ß<àuáâ�ãGâbã;â r ef]@_a�RszhM] � q#_asz]Mcnma]g�"hMq�`!�Wb)_as{efq�c�q#p�ef]Mwz]Mhoma]M��`�b#mah>iv`�b#��]o_g}X�R_aq���]o_:b�cW�'`!] ��Es{b)maq�_^b�|�]oc%mae

»aDoD>I¨´�D�³�²RYH³�IX=oI¨Yo´�Y@´�D>´�<%YMLM?kACQ6=o?¨´'SX²E°�<RAJQÕ²%³3°�´�SXAT<n=oAJ²EQ ® AT<�°*ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oDACQBL)GCIBSX´E·�³�²RY�´)¿¨<R°*µBGJ´E·�<Rµ¨µ¨Yo²E<ELM?¨´�D�=@²ÆL)²EµK´�¶:AJ=@?¯=@?¨´�µ¨Yo² º GJ´�°�D*²R³/=@YoIBD>=�´�D>=o<n¾º GCACD@?¨°�´#Qv=�<%QBSÕ°�<%QB<R¹R´�°*´�Qv= º VÕ°�ACSBSXGJ´#¾�<R¹R´�QE=MD#ÅÂD@L�<%GT< º ACGJAJ=aV(ACQÁ=@´�Y@°�D�²R³:AJQv=@´�Y>¾²RµO´#YM<n=oAJ²EQk<RL#Y@²vD@D/?¨´)=o´#Yo²R¹E´#Q¨´�²RIBDP<%¹R´�Qv=�D@²WL#AJ´#=@AC´�D�ÅO<2=@?B²RYo²RI¨¹E?(<%QB<RGJVXD@ACD�<%QBSkSX´)¾® ´�GJ²Eµ¨°�´#Qv=�²%³O´)À'L)AC´#Qv=�°�´)=@?B²WSBD�D>IBµ¨µK²EY>=oAJQB¹�SXATD>=@YoA º I¨=@´�S*Yo´�<RG{¾�=@AC°�´^L#²RGCGC< º ²EYo<%=@AC²RQº ´)=a¶^´#´#QÆSXAJã¼´#Yo´#Qv=!=aVWµK´�D!²%³3°�ACS¨S¨GJ´#¾�<R¹R´#Qv=MD�Ë Û%J�Í�ÅÂAJQ ® ´�D>=@AC¹E<n=oAJ²EQBD�AJQÆD@VXDa=o´#°1GC²E<ES

Page 28: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| � �

º <RGC<RQBL)ACQ¨¹�IBD@ACQ¨¹�°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹R´�Qv=oD�ÅED>=o<%QKS¨<%YMSXACÓ#´�S�L#²R°�µO²ED@A{=oAJ²EQB<%GOSX´�D@AJ¹EQ'²%³¸°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾<%¹E´#Qv=oD�<EL#L)²EYoS¨AJQ¨¹P=@²�=o?¨´3µ¨Y@²EµK²vD>´�S�D@´#Y ® ACL#´)¾�²RYoAJ´�QE=o´�S�L#GC<ED@D@AJÈKL#<%=@AC²RQ�´�QB< º GJACQ¨¹B·n´E½ ¹K½J·L)²E°�µK²EQ¨´#Qv=>¾ º <ED>´�S�Y@´#¾�IBD@´/<RQBS�µ¨Yo²%=@²R=aVWµ¨AJQB¹�²%³�D@IBLM?'<%¹E´#Qv=oD�³�²RY^SXA{ã¼´#Yo´#Qv=3<%µ¨µ¨GCATL#<n¾=@AC²RQ�DoL)´�QB<%YoAJ²vD#½;(<RAJQ�<%µ¨µBGJATL#<%=@AC²RQ"S¨²R°�<%ACQBD^²%³�<RDoD>ATDa=o´�S�L)²W²RYMSXACQB<n=oAJ²EQ'²%³l°�I¨GJ=@AT<%¹E´#Qv= D>VXD>=@´�°�D

º V"°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD:<RY@´!ACQv=@´#GCGCAJ¹E´#Qv=/L)²W²RµO´#YM<n=oA ® ´HAJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ�D>VXD>=@´�°�D/<%QBS�<%¹E´#Qv=>¾°�´�SXAT<n=o´�S�´�GJ´�Lg=oY@²EQ¨ACL º IBD>ACQ¨´�D@D/AJQ�=o?¨´�»fQv=@´�Y@QB´)=P<RQBS�à6´ º ½¼æB<%Y@=@?B´#Y/ACQ�=@?B´�³�IX=oI¨Y@´²RQB´PL)²EI¨GTS'AC°�<R¹RACQ¨´/°�ATS¨SXGC´)¾f<%¹E´#Qv=oD�L)²W²RYMSXACQB<n=oAJQ¨¹SXA{ã¼´#Yo´#Qv=:<%¹E´#Qv=�D@²WL#AJ´#=@AC´�D�¶:?¨ATLM?<%Yo´�AJQ ® ²EG ® ´�SÆACQ¸·�³�²EY´#¿X<R°�µ¨GJ´E·�AJQv=@´�Y>¾�µ¨GT<%Q¨´#=o<RY@VÁACQX³�²RYo°�<n=@AC²RQ¯Q¨´)=a¶^²RYoÄXD#·sò/;kà UL)´�GJGµ¨?¨²EQ¨´ ® ACS¨´#²XL)²EQX³�´#Yo´#QBL#´�D�·X=@YM<nÀ'L!°�<RQB<%¹E´#°�´#Qv=�·K<%QBS�Q¨´�¹R²R=@AT<n=@AC²RQ�²R³�L#²RQv=@´�Qv=µ¨Yo² ® ACSX´�S º V�S¨A{ã¼´#Yo´#Qv=�AJQX³�²EY@°�<%=@AC²RQ!µ¨Yo² ® ACSX´�YoD¸³�²RY´#° º ´�SBSX´�SS¨<n=M< º <ED>´�D¸ACQ�°�² º ACGJ´ACQX³�²RYo°�<n=@AC²RQ�<%µBµ¨GJAT<%QKL)´�D�½

�3 �SUTÇï¸ìM︦¨ï�¤P«¼ï�ñ

Page 29: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

�"  ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

Page 30: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

V�W

� �YX��Kr�_a]McveM}Oj��Or/�;�:cvq��vwzqnh@�X}Ob�cv��j��oó^ef�B�[Z^�v]o_f�'�R_aqnhM]Mefefszcv|�szc2maiv]��%xf~��2szcRpTq�_ �`�b#maszq�c�`!]g�Es{b#maq#_g��x�c�r��ve�maszcr-¼b)ma]�}X]g�Rszmaq#_g} Ó'\�]�^�Ù(_�Ñ`\badce^�Ù�Ù~ÔhÙgf2hfÑ�_ji�ÙfØkcxØ�f�l �Br^r�x��_a]MefeM} � �"� � �� �a�H�vr�_aszefiWb%}�-^� � suma]o_g}X�¨�%�3_>b��EeM}f�l��æYmMhgb#cK}Ed/�Rd�q�efeM}Xb#cW� ÿ � �¨� �R�E�E_>b#iv`�b�cEs{b�cK�¼x�` ��Wb#homg��xyc%ma]@_>b�homasz��]�`�b#_f�Rw{b�cv���vw{b#mfpCq�_a`�pTq#_�b�|�]Mcnmae�hMq�w{w{b#�Xq�_>b#maszcE|"maq�|�]omaiv]@_g�onqp<p<p

n ÙrzÑ�c:c Ôsf�Ñ�Ùr-tl�×jrzÑ u × } �-� 1 � 2 } �� " �  �� � j��Xßlb#_a�K}Wr/�W\^�v�Rm>bR}vß�� å �W�vb#efh@iE]o_g}Ed/�W~�b#_ahMs{b#cvqE}X��v��b��Wb#��q�cEe�m>b�cnmaszcvq��K}v��� ÿ ]ow{s ��%ivq)�X}Rb�cv� ÿ �EjliR�B��v�`!w � �vb�ef]g�!szcEpCq�_a`�b#maszq�c*`!]g�RsJb)maszq�cA+�szmai`!se�B�Kx�c Ógõ'Ö õ�Ø�ÙxwzyØ�ÙiÖ2^�Ù{^zf�Ñ uAÑ�Ù�r�Øqw}|�^�r�^)~?t n�� Ö��-|)� �����z��a�iÔ�ce^�\�Ñ�c ��iÔ�^�����tÓ } � ���"�R�

� �:r/�Wß�b#_a�vbR}¨r � ß���òÆiEs{cEe�maq�cB}Xb�cv�<�l�X^s{cB� ÿ b�wz�v]/b�cv���E_aq%�R�vhomasz�%sum��s{c�maiE] s{cnma]o_acE]om]MhMq�cvq�`P�n�-nqp<p-p õ�Ø�uY�{�grzÑ�Õ }¨~�bM� �� " �  �\n�3d � �R��ßÂ_>b�h>iv`�b#c(b�cW���E� \P�Â�%h@iE`!q�wemM]���r�c(q)��]o_a�%sz]*+ q#p�maiE]D� å¨� æY� � �%cEq�+�wz]g�R|�]_a]M�R_a]Mef]Mcnm>b#maszq�c*e��Ee�ma]o`�� õ�Ø�f�Ù�Ô�r;Ô�]�Ñ�t(_*Ô%Ñ�Ù{_�Ñ } �~1 � 2 } � � Þ \%�� �:r/�gj�b�efeab#cW�R_>b%} � �)j�b#efeab�cv�R_>bR}#b#cW� ~"�z��q%�Eszcv]��nj�b#�Wb��Eszw{sumy� � �vb�ef]g�:`�b#mah>iv`�b#�%s{cE|E�)xycÓ-f�Ñ�Ù�r;×�ö����k����õ�Ø�Ùxw�Ñ�Õ�Ñ�Ù{_�ÑgØ�Ù�Ó'�gr%Ø�ÙfØ�u�Ø��×3Ó-f�Ñ�Ù�r;×����}^�Õ`_�Ñ�cxØ�Ù(^ �Xr�j�~ �¸_a]oefeM} �9 " "  ��n� j �9å �Ej�b��Wb#�vszwzsum�� � ]Mefh@_as{�Rmaszq�c å b�cE|��vb�|�]��Einmfma�B� ����+m+m+:� b�s{b#s�� ]g�¨� b�h�� �v�~��q��vw{b�c��#hg�Rw��n�Þ �a�H� � ]oh@��]@_g}��H���%�Rhgb)_>bR}�b#cW�Ý~"�mòÆszwzw{s{b#`!efq�cK�þ~*sJ�E�Ewz] � b�|�]Mcnmae*pTq#_�maiv]2szcnma]o_acv]omg�x�c�n � õ'Ó n ö��g� n ÙrzÑ�Õ�Ù(^�r;Ô;Ø�Ù(^kc � Ø�ÔhÙ�r3õ�Ø�Ùxw�Ñ�Õ�Ñ�Ù{_�Ñ Ø�ÙiÓ�Õ r;Ô �-_*Ô?^kc n ÙrzÑ�c�c Ôsf�Ñ�Ù{_�Ñ �0��^zf:Ø�lk^��

� ^ ��^�Ù } � �"�#�n��%�!óP� \3b)_ahMs{b � ~*q�wzszcWb ]om b�w�� -�iv] -��Rx�~�~*xf� b�� ��E_aq�b�h>iÕmaq�`!]M�Es{b#maszq�cB� � b#m>b�`!q%�R]Mwze�b�cW�kw{b�cv|��Wb#|�]MeM�¯x�c ôiØ�Õ`��×qi~Ø �"� �<n h�t�ö������w r����  � (\�¡¢y�×�r�^�Ùxw�Ø�Õq\£yhÑ`\��� k�{��¡q gf�^�Õq_*Ô?^� �¤������� r;×�Ô�u�u Ôh×�ö?u�Øz\�Ñ�c ×�ö�ce^�Ùgf��^zf�Ñ�×xy ��× } � �"�"\%�

�/  �:d�b��Wb)_as ¥fb�q�cWb*]@m b�w��Pßl�vszw{�EszcE|�b�cv�2ef]Mb#_ah>ivszcv|*b�c�v:~ åB� �vb�ef]g�'hMq�_a�Xq#_>b#ma]H`!]o`!q�_f�n�nqp<p-p"n Ù�rzÑ�Õ�ÙfÑ r!õ�Ø�u}�{�gr;ÔhÙgf }X~�bg�������vcE] �� " �  �

��� �!òÇ�o�:sz` ]om�b�w��næ^c�_a]oefq�wz�%s{cE|Pefh>iv]o`�b#maszh^iE]oma]o_aq�|�]Mcv]oszmy�!szc`P�vwumas{�vb)m>b��Wb#ef]�e��Re�ma]M`!eM�|9Ô�×jr;Õ�Ô?¡��grzÑ`\/^�Ù{\�a¦^�Õq^kc�c�Ñ�c{|�^�r�^�¡�^�×*Ñ�× } � � � \ � � � �9�R} � ��� � �

�)� �/~"� d/�¼\^]McE]Mef]o_a]omaiB}¼r � ~"�U�:]Mwzwz]o_g}Ob�cW�¦æP� � �vefh>iv��bR�!xycEpCq�`�b�e�ma]@_g�Or�c�szcEpCq�_a`�b)mas{q�cszcnma]M|�_>b)mas{q�c�e��Re�ma]M`��¸x�c Ógõ'Ö§t n�� Ö��<| õ�Ø�Ùzw�Ñ�Õ�Ñ�Ù(_�Ñ }B~�bM� � ���#�%��g� ���E� r/�v\^s{b�`!�vb��vbR}E~"�R��b�q�wz�vhMhMs�}vb�cv�w�H�R�n�Rhgb#_>b%��r�|�]Mcnm�szcnma]o_aq��X]@_>b#maszq�c*b�ho_aq�efe�`P�vw �mas{b�|�]Mcnm�e��Re�ma]M` �Xq��vcv�vb)_as{]oeM�Kxyc Ó-f�Ñ�Ù�r;×�ö?�����k�iõ�Ø�Ùzw�Ñ�Õ�Ñ�Ù(_�ÑgØ�Ù Ó'�gr%Ø�ÙfØ�u�Ø��×mÓ-f�Ñ�Ùr;×��

�}^�Õq_�Ñ�cxØ�Ù(^ �Wr�j�~���_a]MefeM} �� " �  ��-� �:d � �R�n\^wz�vefiE��qE}��E� ~"�:-O]Mcv]ocR�vb��E`�})b�cv��ß���~*]Mwum�mM]o_g�vr�c�v:~ å pJ_>b�`!]*+lq�_a�:pTq#_Âb�|�]oc%m ��Wb#ef]g�*] � hMq�`!`!]o_ahM]�� õ�Ø�u�u���Ù~Ô?_�^�r;Ô6Ø�Ù~×.Øqw&r:i�Ñ3Ógõ'Ö } ��� 1 � 2 }¨~�b#_ah>i � �"�"�%�� \n� r/��ó^]@_�mM�X]o_a|E}kX���~�b�efeM}g�E�%~*s{ivb�]Mwzs�} � �k�3b#q�_g}nb#cW��XP��d�bg�Rs{�¨�Xr�hohM]Mefe�hMq�cnmf_aq�wv`!]M]omae�v�E�vwzszh���]o�!szcEpJ_>b�e�mf_a�vh@ma�E_a]�}Rq�_g�Er�efefs{|�cvszcv| _aq�wz]Me�maqPe�mf_>b�cE|�]o_aeM�Ox�c/nqp-p<p t�l�u}��Ø�×�Ô��guØ�Ù)t7Ñ`_��Õ�Ô�r�l�^�Ù(\�amÕ�Ô�]�^�_�l }W~�bg� �� � "  �

�g� �/\P�oó^�Eh@�X}B�¼���Wb�cE�Rivb��Eef]o_g};�H�Or��X]o_a]o_g}Kb�cv� � � �E���^]M�Eivq�w{�¨���]M�Es�� � �%mf_>b�homaszcE|�b�cv�e��Rcnmaiv]MefsemMszcv| szcEpCq�_a`�b)mas{q�c�pJ_aq�` maiv]�+�]M�B�Oxyc õ�Ø�Ùzw�Ñ�Õ�Ñ�Ù(_�Ñ.Ø�Ùºõ�Ø�Ø �~Ñ�Õq^�r;Ô�]�Ñ n Ùzw�Ø�Õjub^�ör;Ô6Ø�Ù)t�l�×�rzÑ u ×�õ�Ø�Øj� n t¨� ��© �vx �Â��� jlq�`!�v�Rma]o_��RqnhMsz]omy��¸_a]MefeM} � ��� Þ �

� �n�:xf~��¨r�jC-^�Kx�cnma]o_>b�h@mas{��]�~�b#_f�Rw{b�cv����w{b)mfpTq�_a` pCq�_Pr�|�]Mcnmae/jlq�wzw{b��Xq�_>b)maszcv|�-Oq�|�]omaiv]@_g�inmfma�K� ����+m+m+:� hMeM� �v`��B� ]g�R�f�)�E_aq¢¥�]Mhomae��)sz`!�Wb�h@m��%�

Page 31: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

��� ~"���:wz�vefh>i�b#cW���H�v�n�EhMb#_>b

� Þ �/~"����b)_a��]�}X~"� r ����]M�Ee�pT]Mw{�¨}Bj���Z^�vse�¨}�-^�B�R]MwzwzszeM}Bb�cv���¼� ÿ b�efefszwzsJb��EszeM�^~*]om>b��Eb#m>b�b�cv��vb)m>b +�b)_a]Mivq��vef]g,n�Wb�wzsum��n�lx�c'~"�{��b#_a��]�}B~"� å ]Mcmo]o_aszcvs�}XP� ÿ b�efefszwzs{q��K}¨b#cW���¼� ÿ b#efefs �wzs{b��EszeM}v]g�Esumaq�_aeM}(ª �Ù(\�^�uAÑ�Ùr�^�c ×gØqw�\�^�r�^[«-^�Õ�Ñ�i~Ø��×*Ñ�× �B�R�R_as{cE|�]o_g} �� � "  �� �%����r�-^�{��b)��bHr�|�]Mcnm�-O]M`!�Ew{b#ma]��Einmfma�K� ���)hg�R_g� e�m>b�cRpTq#_>�B� ]g�E����r�ß � ����bg��b�r�|�]Mcnmg� inma`!w����  �/�¨�z��iWb%})�¼�#jliWb#wJb#eab�cEs�}�æP�)�Riv]oivq�_f�n}Mb�cv�a�H�)�%�Rhgb)_>bR��r�pTq�_a`�b#w�mf_a]gb)ma`!]McnmKq#pW�Rsze�mf_as{�E� �ma]g�H`�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv|E�Wx�c �:Ù{\�õ�Ø�Ùzw�Ñ�Õ�Ñ�Ù(_�Ñ9Ø�Ù�Ó'�gr%Ø�Ù�Ø�u�Ø���×mÓ-f�Ñ�Ù�r;×�~hÓ<f�Ñ�Ùr;×���©x�z�dÖrÔhÙ�ö

Ù7Ñ`^ ��Ø�c Ôh×���Ö¬� }v~�bM� � �"� Þ ��%� ���:x �l�%�:cEq�+�wz]g�R|�] x�cnma]o_ah>iWb#cv|�]9�vq�_a`�b)mg�Ri%mfma�B� ���#wzq�|�szh�� e�m>b�cRpTq�_>�¨� ]g�E���#�%sup6�%���� � � ���:�Eq��%��b:b�cW� å �ó3b#_f_>b��vb%��æ^c��Eefs{cE| �~,n`!wRpTq�_�`�b#mah>iv`�b��%szcv|R�¨x�c õ n`­ Örö®����¯�Õ`\

õ�Ø�ÙxwzynØ�Ù n Ùzw�Ø�Õ u^�r;Ô6Ø�Ù2^�Ù{\ ­ Ù�Ø�«¦c�Ñ`\zf�Ñ!Ö�^�Ù(^zf�Ñ u�Ñ�Ùr �¨r�r^r�x���~*x(-Æ�¸_a]oefeM} � ���#\n���� �&X�� å b#�E_aq��K}f-^���¼szcvszcK}vb�cv��X��v�¼]Mcv|R��r�|�]Mcnm�hMq�`!`��vcEszhgb#maszq�cw{b�cv|��Wb#|�]MeM�7-�iE] hM�E_ �_a]Mcnm�w{b�cv�Eefhgb#�X]��¨nqp-p<p"n ÙrzÑ�c:c Ôsf�Ñ�Ùr-tl�×jrzÑ u × }B~�b#_ah>if�#r��E_aszw � ���"�R��9� �/�R]Mb�c å �v��]�} å ]M]��%�X]Mhomaq�_g} � bg�%s{�/d�b�|�]o_g}�b#cW����b�`!]Me�ó�]McW�Rw{]@_g��æ^cnmaq�w{q�|�� � �Wb#ef]g�g+l]M�b�|�]McnmaeM��x�c ¤�×jr n ÙrzÑ�Õ�Ù(^�r;Ô;Ø�Ù(^kcBõ�Ø�Ùzw�Ñ�Õ�Ñ�Ù(_�Ñ Ø�ÙiÓ'�gr%Ø�Ù�Ø�u�Ø��×3Ó<f�Ñ�Ùr;× } � ���#�n�� \n���P� å �RcEh@iB� |9Ôh×�r;Õ�Ô?¡��grzÑ`\/^kc f:Ø�Õ�Ô�r:igu × ��~*q#_a|�b#c4� b��EpC`�b�cB} � �"� � ���� � � � òÇ�X~�b�cvh>iWb#w{bR� ��� hMq�`!`!]o_aho]3mf_a�ve�m�`!]omf_aszhMe�b�cv��`!q%�E]MwzeM�'nqp<p<p°n ÙrzÑ�Õ�Ù7Ñ r9õ�Ø�u ö

�{�gr;ÔhÙ£f } � 1 � 2 }X~�b)_ah@i���r��E_aszw �9 " �  �� �n�&X��¼~�b�efePb�cv�ñæP�¼�Riv]oivq�_f�n� � s{e�mf_asz�E�Ema]g�"mf_a�Ee�m/s{c�q��X]Mc�`P�vwumas � b�|�]oc%m e��Re�ma]M`!eM��xyc

Ó'�gr%Ø�ÙfØ�u�Ø��× Ó-f�Ñ�Ù�r;×b�������üô�Ø�Õ���×qi~Øj�ÎØ�Ù±| Ñ`_�Ñ��{r;Ô6Ø�Ù� ª Õ`^���\2^�Ù(\�h�Õj��×�r!Ô�Ù¦Ó-f�Ñ�ÙrtfØz_*Ô6Ñ r;Ô%Ñ�×�� � �Ù7Ñ } �� � "  �

� Þ �:inmfma�K� ����+m+m+:� cv�Wb#hMs�� ]g�E��� � x�j � �)`!sx� � e��Re�ma]M`�� inma`!w��� �%�/�¨��~*�v|�|�wz]omaq�c¯b#cW� å � � ]�d�b�]M�Rmg�¯x�cW�R�vhomasz��]*w{q�|�szh2�E_aq�|#_>b�`!`!szcv|R�C-�iE]Mq�_f�Õb�cv�`!]omaiEq%�EeM�<² Ø�f�Ô�_&aCÕ�Ø�f�Õ`^�u�u Ô�Ùgf } ��1 ��  2 } � ��� � ��"  �/~"�{��q%�Eszcv]�}{�E�f�vq�+�w{]@_g}f-^���:efsz]xm@�E�X}vß��X�¼]@_f_f�n}X~"��-¼bM�Ewzq#_g}¨b�cv��r/�E�^cR_a�viK�Âr�homasz��]szcEpCq�_a`�b#maszq�c�|�b)maiv]o_aszcv|�s{c*x�cEpCqn�%w{]o�EmaiK� õ�Ø�Øj�~Ñ�Õ`^�r;Ô�]�Ñ n Ùxw�Ø�Õjub^�r;Ô;Ø�Ù�tl�×�rzÑ u × } ��1 � � � 2 }�� � "  �

�R� �gæ^x å ��æ^c%maq�wzq�|��x�cnma]o_ah>iWb#cv|�] å b#cv|��vb�|�]��Winmfma�K� ����+m+m+:� q�cnmaq��%cEq�+�wz]g�R|�]�� q#_a|��#q�szw��n���� �gæ(� ß�j���æ^�X]Mc��:cEq�+�w{]M�E|�]/ß�b#ef]/jlq�cEcv]Mhomasz�%sum��n�Einmfma�K� ����+m+m+:� b#s�� e�_as�� hMq�` ��q��R�Xh��%���� �gæ^cnmaq�ßÂ_aq���]o_��E_aq¢¥�]ohomg�vinmfma�B� ���#q�c%maq��E_aq���]o_g� b�supT�B� �vcvs � ��b#_awze�_a�viE]�� �E]��n���� �:d � �C1×� 2 ��v:~ å¨� �vb�ef]g�"d�]Mefq��E_ahM] � ]oefho_asz�Emaszq�c �E_>b#`!]*+�q#_a���%h@iE]M`�b��%�X]MhMsutWhMb#maszq�cB�inmfma�K� ����+m+m+:� + � � q�_a|:��-�d3��ò �^� _>�%p � efh@iE]M`�b:�n�� \n�:d � -��%x®�3r �Ri%mfma�B� ����+m+m+:� hMeM� hM`P�K� ]g�R�f��efq�pJm>b�|�]Mcnmae��)_a]omaefszcWb%� i%ma`!w����� � r/�n�RiE]omaiK} ÿ �#� b#efin�%b��B}nb�cv��-^� å sz`�b%�K�R]M`�b#c%maszh�szcEpCq�_a`�b#maszq�c��R_aq���]@_as{cE|E��ó^q�+Áhgb#cb `��vwumas � b�|�]Mcnm�b��E�E_aq�b�h>iiE]Mwz�(³!x�c~"�o�:wz�vefh>iK}~æP�E�RiE]Mivq#_f�n}%b�cv��\P��ò�]MszefeM}R]g�Esumaq#_aeM}

õ n Ó!öq¤k�k����ô�Ø�Õ`��×`i�Ø �<Ø�Ùrõ�Ø�Ø �~Ñ�Õq^�r;Ô�]�Ñ n Ùzw*Ø�Õ u^�r;Ô6Ø�Ù Ó<f�Ñ�Ùr;× }���q�wz�v`!] �M� \ � q#p�² ��Ó n>��R�R_aszcv|�]@_g} � �"�"�%�

� �n� r/���RiE]omaiÁb#cW�"�E� r/� å b)_aefq�cK�0�v]g�E]@_>b#ma]g�Æ�Eb#m>b��vb�ef]'e��Re�ma]M`!eM� Ógõ'Ö õ�Ø�u}�{�gr;ÔhÙgft�Õj]�Ñ l�× } ��� 1 � 2 } � �"�   �

� Þ � r/���%iv]omaiB} � ��~*]McvbR}�r/�)xyw{w{b)_>b�`!]Mcv�Es�}�b�cW� ÿ �9� b#efi%�nb��K�æ^�vef]o_a��]@_g��r�c�b#�v�R_aq�b�h>i pTq�_,n�v]o_f��E_aqnho]Mefefszcv|�s{c'|�w{q��Wb#w�s{cRpTq#_a`�b#maszq�c'e��Re�ma]M`!e��Wb�ef]M�'q�c�szc%ma]@_aq��X]o_>b)mas{q�c�b#ho_aq�efe�E_a] � ]��Esze�maszcv|�q�c%maq�wzq�|�sz]MeM�/xyc õ�Ø�Øj�~Ñ�Õ`^�r;Ô�]�Ñ n Ùzw*Ø�Õ u^�r;Ô6Ø�Ù2tl�×�rzÑ u ×�õ�Ø�Øj� n t�ö��£´ �Bx �����jlq�`!�E�Ema]o_��%qnhMsz]om����_a]MefeM} � �"� � �

� �%�/�E�L�:x��%sz`!�vwz]��¸�v�Ew{szh-�:]@�PxycEpJ_>b�e�mf_a�vh@ma�E_a]��#pCma�B� ���)pJma�K� sz]omfp�� q�_a|:�#szcnma]o_acv]@m � �%_>b#pJmae����R_>b)pCm �sz]omfp � ef�E�Rs � hM]o_fm � maiE]Mq�_f� �� �� � m��%mg��#  ���H���n�EhMb#_>bR}Â~"�L�:wz�Eefh@iB}��¨��òÁsJ�Rq � }¸b#cW���E� å �K� å b#_a�%eM� � �Rcvb�`!szh�`�b#mah>iv`�b��%szcv|b�`!q�cv|�iv]oma]@_aq�|�]ocv]Mq��ve3efq#pCm(+�b#_a]�b#|�]Mcnmae3szc2ho�R�X]o_aef�Wb#hM]�� Ó'�gr%Ø�ÙfØ�u�Ø��× Ó<f�Ñ�Ùr;×b^�Ù(\

Ö)��c r;Ô?^zf�Ñ�Ù�r�t�l�×�rzÑ u × }B~�b)_ah@i �� " %� ��E� ���H�¸�n�Rhgb#_>b%}0�E� å �K}�~"���:wz�vefh>iK}¼b�cW�(�X�'òÆs{�Rq � � � �Rcvb�`!szhHef]o_a�%szhM]�`�b#mah>iv`�b��%szcv|b�`!q�cv| b#|�]Mcnmaelszc!q��X]Mc!szcEpTq#_a`�b#maszq�c!]ocR�%su_aq�cE`!]McnmaeM� Ógõ'Öµt n�� Ö��<|�Ð�Ñ`_�Ø�Õ`\ } � �"�"�%��n� ���H�O�%�Rhgb)_>bb#cW� � ��¶¨]McE|E�Hjlqnq�_>�Rs{cvb#maszq�c�q�p�`P�vwumasz�vwz]Pszcnma]Mwzwzsz|�]Mcnm/efq�pJm(+�b)_a]�b�|�]McnmaeM�

õ�Ø�Ø �~Ñ�Õq^�r;Ô�]�Ñ n Ùxw�Ø�Õjub^�r;Ô6Ø�Ù�t�l�×�rzÑ u × } \�1 � � � 2 } � �"� � ���� �/\P�oòÆsz]g�E]o_aiEq�w{�B�*~*]g�Rs{b#maq�_ae/szc"maiE]�b#_ah>ivsuma]Mhoma�R_a]Hq�p�pC�Ema�E_a]�s{cRpTq#_a`�b#maszq�c�e��Re�ma]M`!eM�

nqp<p-p õ�Ø�uY�{�grzÑ�Õ�tl�×�rzÑ u × } � \�1 � 2 }X~�b#_ah>i � ��� � �

Page 32: 3 >¡£¢E¤ ¥X¦¨§:©/ªP«O¥¨¬a§softagents//papers/mm-broker-survey.pdf · / * 1022 ) 3 ) 4356, 0"7 8 :9;(=@?BAC

Þ ��ßÂ_aq���]o_aszcv|�b�cv��~�b)mah@iE`�b��%szcv| ����"� �9óP� j��fò�q�cv|�b#cW�4�H�B�n�EhMb#_>bR�^rÉm>b��Rq�cvq�`/��q#pl`!s{�v�Rwz] � b�|�]oc%mae�pTq#_3maiv] szcnma]o_acv]@mg�^xyc

Ó-f�Ñ�Ù�r;×�öq¤k�k���#õ�Ø�Ùxw�Ñ�Õ�Ñ�Ù{_�Ñ Ø�ÙiÓ'��r%Ø�ÙfØ�u Ø��×3Ó-f�Ñ�Ùr;× } � �"���R�� \n�9óP� j��~ò�q�cE|!b�cv�X�H�X�n�Rhgb#_>b%��r^�E�Eszcv|�ef]MhM�E_asumy��b#cW�mf_a�Ee�m�maq!`P�vwumas � b�|�]oc%m�e��Re�ma]M`!eM�x�c Ó'�gr%Ø�Ù�Ø�u�Ø��×BÓ<f�Ñ�Ùr;×'¤������iôiØ�Õ���×qi~Ø ��Ø�Ù�|gÑ`_�Ñ��r;Ô6Ø�Ù� ª Õq^���\���^�Ù(\bh�Õj�×�r�ÔhÙgÓ-f�Ñ�Ùr

tfØz_*Ô6Ñ r;Ô%Ñ�× }¨~�bM� � �"���R���� ��vjæ å ��æ^cnmaq�wzq�|#� � �Rh@ivb�cE|�] å b#cv|��Wb�|�]��Winmfma�B� ����+m+m+:� b�s�� e�_as�� hMq�` �)�v��b#_a�f���Rq�wd�%�� �n� ß��dXÂ�Æb�cv�Ý~"� �¼���%s{cE|�iB�-r efqnhMs{b#w/`!]oh@ivb�cvszef`.q�p/_a]M�E�Em>b#maszq�cÝ`�b#cWb#|�]M`!]Mcnm�szc]Mwz]Mhomf_aq�cvszh*hoq�`!`��Ecvsumasz]MeM��xyck~"�L�:wz�vefh>i6b#cW� å �L�:]@_aefh@i%�X]o_a|R}¸]g�Esumaq�_aeM} õ n Ó!ö?�������ô�Ø�Õ���×qi~Øj�¦Ø�Ùºõ�Ø�Ø �~Ñ�Õ`^�r;Ô�]�Ñ n Ùxw�Ø�Õjub^�r;Ô6Ø�Ù Ó-f�Ñ�Ù�r;× }v��q�wz�v`!] � Þ ��  q#p0² �jÓ n>�E�R�R_as{cE|�]o_g}�� � "  �