1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
Transcript of 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
1/27
Swedbank Analyses the Swedish and Baltic Economies April 22, 2010
April 22, 2010 1
Swedbank Economic Outlook
Glimmers of light in the tunnelGlobal development
Worldwidestimulusmeasuresandnancialsectorsupporthaveboosted
condence,andglobalgrowthstrengthens.However,thereboundisnot
convincingyetinmanyoftheindustrializedeconomies.
Weraiseourglobalgrowthoutlookto3.9%in2010and3.6%in2011.
Theunwindingofthestimuluspackageswillbefeltprimarilyin2011.In
particular, Europe will lag behind, while the emerging markets will be themainengineofgrowthintheworld.
Sweden
Economicactivityunexpectedlyfellbackinthelastquarterof2009,but
stronglabourmarketdevelopmentsandpublicnancessuggestthatthe
economyhasreachedrmerground.
Welowerourrealgrowthforecaststo1.8%in2010and2.4%in
2011.Despiteresilienthouseholdconsumption,externaldemandand
investmentsareexpectedtolagbehind.Theeconomicpolicystancewill
remainexpansive,howevernotsufciently,withthereporatereaching
1.75%atend-2011.
Estonia
Positivequarterlygrowthratesattheendof2009suggestthatthe
bottomofthedownturnhaspassed.Furthermore,dataindicatethatthe
Maastricht-criteriaforeuroadoptionhavebeenmet,andthatimproves
theprospectsofEstoniabecomingthe17thmemberofEMU.
Weexpectpositivegrowthratesof1.5%and4.5%in2010and2011,
respectively.Exportswillinitiallydrivetherecovery,withdomestic
demand, boosted by increased foreign investments, taking over toward
theendoftheforecastperiod.
Latvia
Theeconomicslowdownabatedattheendof2009,whiledomestic
costadjustmentcontinuedatfullspeed.Springof2010broughtsignsof
stabilisationinthelabourmarket. The recession is likely to be over in early 2010 driven by export growth,
buttherecoverywillbebumpyandgrowthfragile.Weexpectthe
economytocontractby2.5%in2010duetonegativecarry-overeffects
beforeincreasingby4%in2011.Fiscalconsolidationcontinuesas
planned, but window of opportunities to carry out structural reforms
mustbeusedmoreintensively.Lithuania
ThedeeprecessioninLithuaniawasmitigatedattheendof2009by
strongerthanexpectedexportperformance.Unemployment,however,
continuedtoincreaseandwagesfell,dampeningdomesticdemand.
GDPisexpectedtofalloverallby2%in2010,withsteadyrecovery
startinginthesecondhalfoftheyear.In2011,weexpectrealgrowthto
reach3%.Exportswillrecover,whileprivateconsumptionwillimprove
onlymodestly.Thescalsituationhasstabilizedbutremainschallenging.
Table of Content:
Introduction:Fromcrisis
to recovery conditions for
growth slowly improve 2
Global:Globalgrowth-but
Europeislaggingbehind 4
Sweden:Exportmarketsfalter
-yethousholddemandpicks
up 6
Estonia:Economicprospects
improve 11
Latvia:Recessiontobeover
earlierthanexpected 16
Lithuania:Fiscalconsolidation
is rewarded 21
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
2/27
2 April 22, 2010
Swedbank Economic Outlook
environment.Thedirectionoftradeisshiftingtowardsfaster-growing
emerging markets, but it takes time
to change the geographical structure
ofexports.Commongoalsfor
companies in our region to enhance
competitiveness are increased
productivity, lower costs, a product
structure in demand, and higher
value added in production through
investmentsinR&D.
Swedenseconomyisalsocharac-
terized by polarization as exports
falteranddomesticdemandpicksup.
Comparedwithlastyearsfall,the
economyisnowrecovering.Contrary
to what normally drives the economy
in an upturn, households are the main
growth engine, supported by a slow
recovery in the labour market and
stimulusmeasures.Astheeconomy
unexpectedly shrank in the last quarter
of2009,negativecarry-overeffectswill
causeGDPduring2010togrowslower
than previously foreseen, and reach1.8%incalendar-adjustedterms.Net
exports will contribute marginally to
growth, and support will instead come
from private consumption and from
companiesstartingtorestock.As
industrialcapacityisstilllow,invest-
ment growth will remain negative this
year, but then slowly turn positive
during2011.Netexportswillthen
contribute negatively to growth as
importsincreasefasterthanexports.
Domesticdemandwillpickupeven
furtherandGDPisexpectedtogrow
by2.4%.Inationpressuresarelikely
tobesubdued,andtheRiksbankcan
increase the policy rate slower than
previouslyforeseen.Attheendof
2011,itwillhavereached1.75%.Also,
eventhoughscalpolicywillremain
expansive, the general government
budgetdecitwillnotexceed2%of
GDP.
The Baltic countries have also reached
a phase of recovery after shrinkingbysome15-25%in2008-2009.The
overall sentiment towards the region
highlevels.GlobalGDPisthereforeforeseen as growing slower in 2011,
by3.6%.
The polarization between industrial
countries and emerging markets
regarding growth, is mirrored equally
inthedifferentprospectsforination.
Capacityutilisationwillstaylowin
mostindustrialcountries,andination
pressuresremainweak.Asscal
policy also becomes more restrictive,
central banks are expected to move
theirpolicyratesupwardsonlyslowly.Intheemergingmarkets,meanwhile,
capacity is becoming more constrained
and price pressures are building
up, including the effects from rising
commodity prices and large capital
inows.
ForEuropeSwedensandthe
Baltic countries most important
export markets there is a need
toimprovethescalsituationwhile
avoiding anaemic growth and strainsintheeurozonecooperation.The
European export market remain crucial
to Swedish and Baltic companies
in volume terms, and therefore it is
important not to lose market share
in this prevailing weak economic
Worldwide stimulus measures andnancialsectorsupporthaveboosted
condenceamonghouseholds,
companies,andnancialmarkets.As
global growth strengthens, a recovery
in Sweden and the Baltic countries is
takinghold.Theconditionsforgrowth
have improved, but many challenges
remain,bothintheshort-andlong-
termperspective.
The global economic environment has
become brighter, and during this year
globalGDPissettogrowby3.9%dueto inventory adjustments, improved
condence,andlargestimulus
measures from central banks and
governments.Whilemanyemerging
markets are growing strongly, industrial
countries especially the European
ones-arelaggingbehind.Theneed
to deleverage in the private and
nancialsectors,aswellasmounting
debts in the public sector with an
accompanying risk of increasing
nancialturbulence,isposinggreatchallenges.Alreadybynextyeara
number of countries will have raised
taxes and lowered public expenditures,
thusweakeningdomesticdemand.
Labour markets will improve, but
unemployment will still remain at
Introduction
Fromcrisistorecoveryconditionsforgrowthslowly improve
Macro economic indicators, 2008- 20112008 2009 2010f 2011f
RealGDPgrowth,annualchangein%
Sweden (calender adjusted) -0.5 -4.7 1.8 2.4Estonia -3.6 -14.1 1.5 4.5
Latvia -4.6 -18.0 -2.5 4.0Lithuania 2.8 -15.0 -2.0 3.0
Unemploymentrate,%oflabourforce
Sweden 6.2 8.3 9.3 9.2Estonia 5.5 13.8 14.0 11.5Latvia 7.5 16.9 21.5 19.5Lithuania 5.8 13.7 16.0 15.5
Consumerpriceindex,annualchangein%
Sweden 3.4 -0.3 1.4 2.2Estonia 10.4 -0.1 0.5 1.8Latvia 15.4 3.5 -3.0 0.0Lithuania 10.9 4.5 1.0 1.0
Currentandcapitalaccountbalance,%ofGDP
Sweden (current account) 9.6 7.2 6.2 6.5
Estonia -8.4 7.4 8.5 8.0Latvia -11.5 11.8 12.4 9.7Lithuania -10.1 7.2 4.2 3.0
Sources:NationalstatisticsauthoritiesandSwedbank
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
3/27
April 22, 2010 3
Swedbank Economic OutlookIntroduction
fromnancialmarkets,international
organisations, and rating institutes has
improved.Thepoliticalenvironment
in each country has supported the
process of budget consolidation
anddeleveraging.Theprospects
of maintaining the exchange rates
xedtotheeurohavestrengthened,
and Estonia is expected to join the
eurozonein2011.Theobjectives
of Latvia and Lithuania are to follow
suitin2014.Withaglobalrecovery
and these countries adherence to
scalconsolidationandreforms,
the prospects for achieving these
objectiveswillimprove.
Estonias economy is expected to grow
by1.5%thisyear,and4.5%thenext.Initially,netexportswillcontributeto
growth, but slowly domestic demand
will take over as the growth engine, in
particular due to inventory adjustment
andEU-fundedinvestments.The
expected euro membership may also
enhanceforeigndirectinvestments.
Private consumption will remain
sluggish but gradually pick up in 2011
inthelightofimprovedcondence,
lower unemployment, and slightly
higherwages.ThisimpliesashortdeationperiodinthecaseofEstonia,
and, with increasing labour costs,
thechallengeistocreatesufcient
competitiveness by enhancing
productivity so that the export sector
developspositivelyalsoinalonger-
termperspective.Fiscalpolicyis
expected to remain prudent, but
increasingly the government will need
toworkonlong-termissues,including
efciencyofthepublicsector,thetax
system, and the level of ambition for
publicservices.
Latvias recession seems to be over,
but the recovery is expected to be slow
andfragile.GDPwillstarttopickup,
but in annual terms it will shrink by
2.5%thisyearduetocarryovereffects.
Then, higher exports will gradually
strengthen investments and inventory
build-up,thusgeneratinggrowthof
4%in2011.Competitivenesshas
increased as unit labour costs have
declinedbymorethan20%overthe
last year, and the adjustment is set
tocontinue,althoughmoreslowly.
The unemployment rate seems to
have peaked in April, but the decline
willbeslow.Thescalsituationis
developing according to plan, and the
budgetdecitwillsqueezeinbelowthe
targetof8.5%ofGDPthisyear.Atotalconsolidationofsome7%ofGDPis
stillnecessarytocutthedecittothe
2012targetof3%ofGDP,inorderto
achieve the goal of euro adoption in
2014.
Lithuanias recession became less
deep during last year due to stronger
exportgrowththanexpected.Going
forward, the carryover effects will result
inanegativegrowthrateof2%this
year despite quarterly improvements,but a more robust annual growth of
3%willensuein2011.Netexports
will contribute positively to growth
both years, and gradually domestic
demand will strengthen as prospects
for investments improve, mainly
duetoEUstructuralfunds.The
internal devaluation is set to continue
aswageswilldecreasefurther.
Unemploymentwillstabiliseonahigh
level, thus encouraging a new wave
ofemigrationamongtheyoung.We
do not foresee any strong rebound of
consumer spending during the forecast
period.Publicnanceshavebeen
stabilised, and the government has
agreed to a plan with the European
Commissiontoreachadecitof3
%ofGDPin2012.Asthedecitis
seenat8%thisyear,theroadtoeuro
adoptionin2014isstilllong,butnot
unachievable.
Forecastrisksarebalancedasthe
possibilities of reaching higher growth
in Sweden and the Baltic countries
are more or less equal to the risks
ofexperiencinglowergrowth.The
main areas of uncertainty include the
globalrecovery.Eveniftheriskfor
a double dip has decreased, it has
nottotallydisappeared.Commodityprices, exchange rates, interest rates,
and equity prices are just a few of the
factorsthatcouldinuencegrowth
andinationprospectsinourhome
markets.Domestically,risksare
geared towards the labour market
andthescalsituation,aswellas
balance sheets of households and
companies.Therisksseenapartdo
not seem serious as such, but together
they could change the forecast
substantially.
Remainingchallengesinourregion
aremany,notleastinthemedium-and
long-termperspective.Globalisation
is continuing, increasing competition
and at the same time providing new
growthopportunities.Demographywill
lead to a decrease in labour supply,
putting pressures on the welfare
systems.Swedenspotentialgrowth
ratewillbedifculttomaintain,unless
productivity is enhanced by structural
reforms.TheBalticcountriesmust
work hard on the reform agenda to
continue their convergence with the
restoftheEU,asthenancialcrisis
andrecessionhaveslowedgrowth.In
particular, investments must again be
able to strengthen without dependence
onEUstructuralfunds.Avoidingtax
evasionintheregionisanotherissue.
Developingataxsystemthatisboth
efcientandeffectiveismuchneeded
toensurethatpublicnancesbecome
sustainable and are in line with welfaregoals.
CeciliaHermansson
Export volumes (change in %)
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
Sw eden Estonia Latvia Lithuania
2008 2009 2010 2011
Sources:NationalstatisticsauthoritiesandSw edbank.
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
4/27
4 April 22, 2010
Swedbank Economic OutlookGlobal
Globalgrowth-butEuropeislaggingbehind
The global economy has moved from
a stage of crisis to one of recovery,
but, despite stimulus measures,
the rebound isnt convincing yet in
manyoftheindustrialcountries.
The major growth engines at themoment are the emerging markets,
and,increasingly,NorthAmericaand
Japan.Europe,ontheotherhand,
is lagging behind, as production has
stagnated and the region is crippled
with downside risks from mounting
sovereign debt and weak domestic
demand.Monetarypolicyisexpected
toremainexpansionary,butscal
policy is becoming restrictive later in
theforecastperiod.
We have revised upwards our growth
outlook for the global economy from
ourJanuaryforecast.GlobalGDP
isnowexpectedtogrowby3.9%
thisyearand3.6%in2011,and
again3.9%in2012.Thephaseout
of stimulus packages will have the
biggestimpactnextyear.Despite
thecurrentreboundintheUS,the
recovery from the second half of this
year will be slower due to lingering
problems with unemployment,
deleveraging, and weak real estatemarkets.Also,Japanwillgrowfaster
in the short term, but somewhat slower
nextyear,asmosttradingpartners--
exceptChinaandIndia,wherethe
outlookcontinuestobebright--
are contemplating contractionary
measures.Thegrowthoutlookfor
the euro zone has been reviseddownwardsfrom1.1%to0.9%this
year,andfrom1.6%to1.3%next
year.Themainreasonsarebudget
consolidation, and still rather low
condence,aswellasprevailing
weaknesses in production, labour
marketsandthenancialsector.
Downsiderisksintheshorttermare
most important for industrial countries,
as emerging markets are seen as
holding up well in the next couple of
years.Debtproblemsintheprivate,
nancial,andpublicsectorswill
result in deleveraging and budget
consolidation, creating uncertainties
regarding timingofscalmeasures,
nancialstability,andgrowth.Commoditypricesareincreasing,
andanoilpriceaboveUS$100per
barrel would cause negative effects on
growthandinationinmanycountries.
Thenancialmarketsarefacedwith
uncertainties regarding the sovereign
debt crises and euro zone cooperation;
the main risks include a Greek default
and subsequent spreading of problems
to other euro countries, such as Spain
andPortugal.
GDP forecast 2010 - 2012 (annual percentage change) 1/
April January
2009 2010 2011 2012 2010 2011
US -2.4 2.8 2.2 2.5 2.2 2.5
EMUcountries -4.0 0.9 1.3 1.9 1.1 1.6
Ofwhich: Germany -5.0 1.3 1.5 2.0 1.5 1.8
France -2.2 1.5 1.8 2.2 1.6 2.0
Italy -4.9 0.6 1.0 1.5 0.7 1.2
Spain -3.6 -0.5 0.7 1.7 -0.1 1.3
UK -4.8 1.1 1.6 2.2 1.0 1.9
Japan -5.3 2.0 1.4 1.5 1.2 1.5
China 8.6 9.5 8.8 8.0 8.5 7.8
India 6.5 7.5 7.8 8.0 7.0 7.5
Brazil -0.4 4.7 4.5 5.7 3.5 4.5
Russia -7.9 4.3 4.5 5.0 4.3 4.5
GlobalGDP -0.9 3.9 3.6 3.9 3.3 3.5
Sources:NationalStatisticalauthoritiesandSwedbank1/Countriesrepresentingaround70%oftheglobaleconomy.TheWorldBank'sweightsfrom2008(purchasingpowerparity,PPP)havebeenused.
Industrial production (index 2000=100)
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
220
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Total
Euro Zone
Emerging Markets
Source:CPB
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
5/27
April22,2010 5
Swedbank Economic OutlookGlobal
Inaddition,medium-andlong-term
sovereign debt concerns are building
up with regard to larger economies
suchastheUS,Japan,andtheUK,
with consequences for the political
situation,growth,ination,andinterestrates.Protectionismthreatsremain,
and the currency dispute between
theUSandChinahasnotyetbeen
resolved.Also,theeffectsongrowth
duetore-regulationofthenancial
sector constitute forecast risks in
theyearstocome.Evenifgrowthis
becoming better balanced between
theUSandAsia,rebalancingglobal
growthremainsalong-termchallenge.
FiscalpolicyisalreadyrestrictiveinIreland,Greece,Spain,andPortugal.
AftertheelectioninearlyMay,theUK
government is also expected to start
budgetconsolidation.During2011,
many other industrial countries will
follow,includingtheUS,Japan,and
Germany.Acombinationofhigher
taxes and lower public expenditures
will dampen growth, especially private
andpublicconsumption.
Although monetary policy is expected
to remain expansive over the next two
years, the degree of expansion will
abatesomewhat.Inationpressures
will be weak in most industrial
countries and strong in many of the
emerging markets where domestic
growth is higher and stimulus
measuresexpansive.TheUSFederal
ReserveandtheBankofEnglandwill
start raising their policy rates towards
the end of the year, bringing them
upto2.25%bytheendof2011.The
EuropeanCentralBankwill wait till
thersthalfof2011beforeraising
the policy rate, and then slowly make
furtherhikes,reaching1.75%bytheendofnextyear.Weforeseethatrising
GDPgrowthandsomewhathigher
inationwillplaceupwardpressure
onthelong-termbonds.Inaddition,
concern about public debt and the
phasing out of quantitative easing
mayraisebondratesevenmore.The
wider spreads between Germany and
euro countries with large imbalances
will narrow somewhat as risks come
down and subsidized loan packages
are provided, but they will remain widerthanbeforethenancialcrisisstarted.
WeforeseethattheUSdollarwill
strengthen against the euro and
the yen during the forecast period,
astheUSeconomyisexpectedto
grow more strongly and interest rates
areraisedearlier.Inaddition,the
turbulence within the euro zone will
weaken the euro further, while the yen
will be affected negatively by weaker
nancesandtherevivalofitsstatus
asafundingcurrencyforcarrytrades.Already this year, or in the beginning
ofthenext,theChineseadministration
will return to a policy involving the slow
appreciationoftherenminbi.
Our assumption of an average oil price
ofUS$75forthisyearandUS$80
for 2011 is based on an expectation
of a stronger dollar, and then slower
growth after the initial rebound in the
rsthalfofthisyear.However,therisks
are skewed towards the upside, and
higher oil and other commodity prices
cannotbeexcluded.Housepricesare
pickingupfromlowlevelsintheUSandtheUK,butcommercialrealestate
markets are lagging and may still pose
downsidegrowthrisks.Especially,the
combination of weak regional banks
and falling commercial property prices
intheUScouldweakentheoutlook.
As many countries are starting to exit
from their stimulus measures, there is
a need to focus more on improving the
functioningoftheeconomies.Industrial
countries will feel that competition isincreasing from emerging markets
where economic policy and the
nancialsectorwillbesupporting
growthintheyearstocome.Inthe
EuropeanUnion,theintegration
processshouldcontinue,nancial
sector regulation must be cleverly
designed, and structural reforms
shouldfocusonenhancinggrowth.In
particular, reforming the labour markets
makingthemmoreexible,and
improving the climate for innovation
andentrepreneurshipareimportant.Thereisapotentialforbenetingmore
from an increased division of labour
and specialisation within the region,
and thus improving the possibilities
for competing with growing emerging
marketsaroundtheworld.
CeciliaHermansson
Interest and exchange rate assumptions
Outcome Forecast
20 apr 2010 30 Jun 2010 31 dec 2010 30 Jun 2011 31 dec 2011
Policy rates
FederalReserve,USA 0.25 0.25 0.50 1.50 2.25
EuropeanCentralBank 1.00 1.00 1.00 1.25 1.75
Bank of England 0.50 0.50 0.75 1.25 2.25
Bank of Japan 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10 0.10
Exchange rates
EUR/USD 1.34 1.32 1.24 1.20 1.20
RMB/USD 6.83 6.83 6.83 6.60 6.40
USD/JPY 93 98 105 112 115
Sources:ReutersEcowinandSwedbank
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
6/27
6 April 22, 2010
Sweden Swedbank Economic Outlook
Sweden:Exportmarketsfalter-yethousehold
demand picks up
The decline in economic activity in
Sweden unexpectedly deepened
inthelastquarterof2009,andtheeconomy contracted in real terms
byalmost5%annually.Someofthe
momentum of the recovery was lost,
and we are revising downwards our
economicgrowthforecastto1.8%for
2010.Inparticular,domesticdemand
waslowerthanexpected.Thesharp
contraction of investments continued
while household consumption did not
provideasmuchsupportasexpected.
Labour market dynamics improved,
however, and trend employment levels
areedgingup.Positiveeconomic
growth is expected continue in 2011,
but due to a slowdown of quarterly
growthrates,itwillnotexceed2%.
We do not expect a recuperation of
thelossestorealGDPcausedbythe
globalnancialcrisisuntil2012.
The overall global economic
environment is set to improve over the
nexttwoyears.However,Swedens
main export markets, in particular the
eurozoneandtheU.K.,areexpectedto lag amidst prevailing imbalances
anderodingcondence.Furthermore,
the composition of Swedish exports,
with a predominance of investment
and capital goods, will hamper exportgrowth as investments are lagging
inmostdevelopedcountries.Thus,
despite positive growth rates of
export volumes, the recovery in 2010
is expected to be slower than we
earlieranticipated.Withexpanding
domestic demand fuelling imports, the
contribution of net exports to growth
has been revised downwards by more
thanpercentagepointofGDP.
We expect the policy stance to remain
expansive for most of the forecast
period.Thescaloutcomefor2009
was strong, with an estimated budget
decitoflessthan1%ofGDP.In
particular, tax revenues surprisedontheupside.With2010beingan
electionyear,weexpectthedecitto
continue to grow, but posing no threat
tomacroeconomicstability.Webelieve
thattheRiksbankwillstartraisingthe
policy rate in July, but that the path
to normalised rates will be somewhat
slowerthanwepreviouslyanticipated.
Forend-2011,therateisexpectedto
havereached1.75%.Consumerswill
continuetobenetfromgrowingreal
disposable incomes and ample credit
availability, which will underpin the
recovery.
Key Economic Indicators, 2008 - 2011 1/
2008 2009 2010f 2011f
RealGDP(calendaradjusted) -0.5 -4.7 1.8 2.4
Industrialproduction 3.3 -15.5 3.8 5.2
CPIindex,average 3.4 -0.3 1.4 2.2
CPI,endofperiod 0.9 0.9 1.7 2.3
CPIF,average2/ 2.7 1.9 2.1 1.4
CPIF,endofperiod 1.6 2.7 1.5 1.6
Labourforce(15-74) 1.2 0.2 0.7 0.3
Unemploymentrate(15-74),%oflaborforce 6.2 8.3 9.3 9.2
Employment(15-74) 1.1 -2.1 -0.3 0.3
Nominalhourlywagewholeeconomy,average 4.3 3.4 1.8 2.2
Nominalhourlywageindustry,average 4.4 2.9 1.6 2.0
Savingsratio(households),% 11.6 13.9 12.7 11.5
Realdisposableincome(households) 2.7 2.1 1.0 1.5
Currentaccountbalance,%ofGDP 9.6 7.2 6.2 6.5
Generalgovernmentbudgetbalance,%ofGDP3/ 2.6 -0.8 -1.9 -1.7
Generalgovernmentdebt,%ofGDP4/ 38.3 42.3 42.8 42.8
Sources:StatisticsSwedenandSwedbank.1/Annualpercentagegrowth,unlessotherwiseindicated.
2/CPIwithxedinterestrates.
3/Asmeasuredbygeneralgovernmentnetlending.
4/AccordingtotheMaastrichtcritera.
Impact from crisis
80
90
100
110
120
130
140
150
160
170
180
1985
1987
1989
1991
1993
1995
1997
1999
2001
2003
2005
2007
2009
2011
Trend grow th
Sources:StatisticsSw edenandSw edbankcalculations.
RealGDP-level(1985=100)
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
7/27
April22,2010 7
Sweden Swedbank Economic Outlook
Swedbanks GDP Forecast Sweden
competitorontheexportmarket.This
is mainly the result of weak productivity
developments.
Inourglobaloutlook,weforeseean
export market growth for Swedish
exportersof4%in2010,whichis
more or less unchanged from January
despiteastrongerglobalgrowth.
A weaker growth in Europe, which
accountsformorethan70%of
Swedish exports, is compensated forby a stronger export market growth
in emerging countries, Japan and the
US.Fornextyear,weexpectamarket
growthof5%,drivenbyfurtherstrong
demand from the emerging markets
and despite a weaker growth outlook
inEuropethanweearlierexpected.
Duetoanunfavourabledemand
composition and a stronger krona
against the euro, we expect Sweden
to continue to lose market share (in
contrasttoourJanuaryforecast).We
have, thus, revised downwards the
volume increase in total exports to
closeto4%in2010andcloseto5%
in2011.Thenegativeoutlookcould
be mitigated by lower production
costs, which would enable Swedish
companies to lower prices and regain
marketshares.
Weak domestic demand and industrial
productionsignicantlysloweddown
growthinSwedishimportsin2009.In2010and2011,importvolumeis
expectedtogrowby4.4%and5.9%,
respectively, as industrial production
starts to recover and domestic demand
strengthens.Thecontributionfrom
netexportstoGDPisexpectedtobe
signicantlysmallerduring2010than
weexpectedinJanuary.Fornextyear
we foresee a negative contribution to
GDPduetostrongerdomesticdemand
andalimitedexportperformance.
The main downside risks to our
forecasts are external and relate to
the rising uncertainties concerning
sovereignsolvencyandnancial
marketturbulence.Ifrealized,this
would have a further negative impact
on Swedish growth, and on the labour
market.Thehighcreditgrowthand
increasingly indebted households may
pose a risk to private consumtion when
interest rates increase, and could also
affecthousepricesnegatively.
Weaker export performanceSwedens export performance
unexpectedly continued to worsen in
thenalquarterlastyear.Despitea
global recovery and growing import
demand from the euro area, Swedens
exportvolumedecreasedfurther.This
wasthefthconsecutivequarterwith
fallingexports.However,whileexports
of goods had a sharp drop, the decline
inserviceswaslesspronounced.
Swedish exports contracted more
thanthefallonthegloballevel.An
unfavourable demand composition,
particularlyforinvestmentandinter-
mediate goods, which are the bulk
of Swedish exports, is the major
reason why Sweden lost market
share.However,asthiswasthefth
consecutive year with decreasing
market share, competitiveness is also
anissue.Since2007,theincreasein
Swedens unit labour cost has beenstrong and has exceeded, for example,
Germanys, which is Swedens major
Changesinvolume,% 2008 2009 2010f 1/ 2011f1/
Households'consumptionexpenditure -0.2 -0.8 (-0.6) 2.4 (2.2) 2.8 (2.5)
Government consumption expenditure 1.4 2.1 (2.0) 1.6 (1.5) 0.6 (0.4)
Grossxedcapitalformation 2.6 -15.3 (-13.4) -2.0 (-3.2) 4.0 (3.5)
private,excl.housing 4.6 -19.0 (-16.1) -4.4 (-5.9) 3.4 (3.0)public 2.8 6.9 (7.6) 3.2 (3.0) 2.2 (1.7)
housing -5.2 -20.5 (-22.5) 1.2 (1.0) 8.7 (8.0)
Changeininventories2/ -0.6 -1.5 (-1.4) 0.8 (0.5) 0.4 (0.3)
Exports, goods and services 1.8 -12.5 (-12.5) 3.8 (4.6) 4.8 (6.0)
Imports,goodsandservices 3.0 -13.4 (-13.4) 4.4 (3.5) 5.9 (6.2)
GDP -0.2 -4.9 (-4.3) 2.1 (2.3) 2.4 (2.6)
GDP,calendaradjusted -0.5 -4.7 (-4.2) 1.8 (2.0) 2.4 (2.6)
Domesticdemand2/ 0.8 -3.0 (-2.6) 1.3 (1.0) 2.2 (2.0)
Netexports2/ -0.4 -0.5 (-0.5) 0.1 (0.8) -0.1 (0.4)
Sources:StatisticsSwedenandSwedbank.
1/TheguresfromourforecastinJanuary2010aregiveninbrackets.
2/ContributiontoGDPgrowth.
Export performance
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 2011
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
Sources:StatisticsSwedenandSwedbank'scalculations.
Exportgrowthinvolumein%
Changeinmarketsharein%(rs)
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
8/27
8 April 22, 2010
Sweden Swedbank Economic Outlook
Investments are slowlyrecoveringThe downward trend in gross
xedinvestmentscontinuedinlast
yearsnalquarter.Asinvestments
decreasedby15.3%in2009,theratioofinvestmenttoGDPfellto17%,the
lowestlevelsince2005.Housingand
the private business sector account
for the largest reductions, while public
investments increased due to stimulus
directedtoinfrastructure.
We foresee a continued decline this
year,althoughataslowerrate.We
expect total investments to fall by
2%,mainlydrivenbythelowcapacity
utilisation rate in the business sectorandthefragileglobaloutlook.A
gradually better global outlook and
a stronger domestic demand will
lead to a modest recovery in the
business sector in 2011, but for export
goodstherecoverywillbesmaller.
Instead,therewillbeashifttomore
domestic-orientedbranches.Aless
negative labour market outlook and
a stronger purchasing power among
households will increase the demand
fornewhouses.Publicallyfunded
infrastructure investments will continue
togrow.Totalinvestmentswillthus
increaseby4%in2011.
Stabilisation of the labourmarket within reachThe sharp deterioration of the labour
market levelled out late last year, but
overall employment levels still took
asignicantbeatinganddecreased
bymorethan2%onaverage.The
number of hours worked decreased
evenmoreasmanyrmsreduced
working hours in line with falling
demandandproduction.Theaverage
unemployment level rose by more than
2percentagepointsto8.3%in2009,
and reached, in seasonally adjusted
terms,9.0%ofthelabourforceatend-2009.Netoffull-timestudentslooking
for jobs, the unemployment rate was
6.5%ofthelabourforce,compared
with4.6%in2008.
Recentmonthshaveseensome
indications of a stabilisation of the
labourmarket.Thenumberoflayoff
noticationshasdroppedsharply
while the number of advertised
positionshasrisen.Furthermore,
anincreasingnumberofrmsinthemanufacturing sector have stopped
sheddinglabour,andforward-looking
surveys suggest a growing number
ofrmsareplanningtoincreasetheir
hiring.Theemploymentlevelsinthe
services sectors, meanwhile, have
heldupsignicantlybetter.Seasonally
adjusted, overall employment levels
edgedupinearly2010.
Duetothestabilisationofthelabour
market dynamics, employment is
expected to start recovering over
theforecastperiod.However,asthe
responsiveness of the labour market
to real economic activity seems to
have decreased (employment rose
inthelastquarterof2009despitea
contractionofrealGDP),weexpect
employmenttogrowslowly.Atthe
same time, labour supply is positively
affected by the fewer discouraged
workers, as well as by demographic
factors.Thereformsofthesickness
benetsystemwillpushanincreasing
number of people into the labour
market.Puttogether,weexpectthe
unemploymentratetoreach9.3%
in 2010 before declining slightly in
2011.Thisimpliesthatweexpect
total employment to decrease by acumulativeof95,000over2009-11,
comparedto170,000inourJanuary
forecast.
The cost competitiveness of Swedish
production is expected to improve
following the latest rounds of wage
negotiations.Thecollectivebargaining
process, involving more than 3 million
employees, is coming to an end, and
in general the agreements came in at
relatively modest levels (in the paperindustry and among electricians no
agreements have been made and
strikesareongoing).Theservices
sector agreements, in particular
in retail, exceeded those of the
manufacturingindustries.Ingeneral,
the agreements were considerably
back-loaded,andweexpectthat
wages for the overall economy will
increasenominallyby1.8%in2010,
beforereachingto2.2%in2011.
Productivity levels will rebound
gradually.Aperiodofeconomic
downturns normally leads to weaker
productivity growth as companies often
delay laying off personnel when faced
withfallingdemand.Aseconomic
growth rates turn positive, the opposite
effectcanoftenbeobserved.Thus,
with a stable employment outlook
and a relatively slow real economic
recovery, we expect productivity to
grow by about 2 percent in 2010,
beforelevellingoffin2011.Unitlabour
Unemployment rate, 15-74 (% of labour force)
0.01.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
9.0
10.0
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Sources:StatisticsSw edenandSw edbankcalculations.
Full-timestudents
Households' expectations
-75
-50
-25
0
25
50
75
100
2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010
Netbalance
Own economy
Source:NIER
Unemployment
Swedish economy
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
9/27
April22,2010 9
Sweden Swedbank Economic Outlook
costs will decrease, although more
slowly than we expected in January,
following some years of increased
levels.
Wide-rangingreformsinrecentyears can be expected to improve
the functioning of the labour market
over the medium term and reduce the
equilibriumrateofunemployment.In
particular,reducedwork-relatedtaxes
(including the lowering of the social
contributionratesforpeople25years
or younger), lower replacement rates
in unemployment insurance, and
alimittosickbenetscanimprove
incentives to seek employment, not
only among those already in thelabour force but also among those who
areoutside.Ithasbeenestimatedthat
the equilibrium unemployment rate has
increased by 3 percentage points since
theearly1980stoapproximately6%
ofthelabourforce.1 With the recent
labour market reforms, this rate could
decline.
Consumerpriceshaveincreased
somewhat faster at the beginning of
thisyearthanweexpectedinJanuary.
The most important explanation is
higher electricity prices, due both to
strongerweather-relateddemand
andweakersupply.Wehavethus
raised our forecast for this year, both
regarding the consumer price index
(CPI)andCPI-F(withxedinterest
rates)by0.5and0.8percentage
points,respectively.Althoughprices
will increase somewhat during this
year, the developments during 2011
are revised downwards marginally,
as it will take longer to close theoutput gap, the price pressures from
the labour market are restrained and
external prices pressures will be kept
down.Theinationtargetof2%will
not be met in the medium term as
theCPI-Fwillfallto1.4%nextyear,
although, including the effects of
monetarypolicy,theCPIwillreach
2.3%towardstheendof2011.
1See,forexample,AndersForslund,Densvenskajmviktsarbetslsheten,IFAU2008.
Households to increasespendingAftervequartersoffallingprivate
consumption, Swedish households
increased spending in annual terms
inthelastquarterof2009.Taking
into account the stronger purchasing
power, when real disposable income
grewby2.1%,householdswere
cautiouslastyear.Asconsumptionfell
by0.8%,thesavingsratioincreasedto
13.9%(and8.3%,excludingpension
fundreserves).Itisthehighestsavings
ratio2onrecordsince1994,i.e.,since
thelastnancialcrisis.
Labour market developments have
been negative, but not to the extentpreviouslyprojected.Thus,real
disposable income can continue to
grow this year, but as savings and
condencearehigh,weexpect
consumption growth to be even
strongerat2.4%(2.2%inJanuary).In
2011, households will use more of their
savings, as the unemployment rate
stabilises and household expectations
remainoptimistic.Privateconsumption
willincreaseby2.8%andwillaccount
for more than half of total growth, thus
representing the main growth engine in
theeconomy.
Duringtheforecasthorizon,risks
will be balanced, as there are upside
and downside risks facing labour
andhousing.Swedbankshousing
affordability index signals rising house
prices during this year, and possibly
astabilisationduringnextyear.Atthe
moment, house prices are increasing
in line with the high credit growth of
2Thesavingsratioisdenedashouseholdsavingsinrelationtodisposableincome.
some9%.Ourinterestrateprojection,
which has been lowered, supports the
positive developments for retail trade,
housing,andcarregistration.
However,therisksaretiltedtowardsthedownsidefor2012andonwards.
The debt ratio will then have risen to
almost200%andtheinterestratio
tocloseto6%,andthusmoreofthe
disposable income will be used for
interestratepayments.Consumption
growth of goods and services,
including vacation expenditures, will
thendampen.Weforeseeincreasing
tensions regarding the households
within a couple of years, and the
risks include a much higher repo rate,highermortgageratesduetonancial
regulation, and a worsening of the
labour market, as well as falling house
prices.
The Riksbank starts hiking but at a slower paceTheRiksbankhaskeptthereporate
at0.25%sinceJuly2009andhas
alsoprovidedbankswiththreexed-
interest rate loans that will mature in
June,August,andOctoberthisyear.
Asweforeseenonewloanswithxed
interest rates, the main policy tool
going forward is the adjustment of the
reporate.InJanuary,wereiterated
ourexpectationofthersthikein
September, but now July looks more
likelyforseveralreasons:1)The
Riksbankhassignalledthatanearlier
hike may be needed as the signs of
an economic recovery have become
clearer; 2) the labour market is viewed
as being less gloomy; and 3) the
nancialmarketisfunctioningbetter.The strong credit expansion towards
Interest rate and currency outlook
Outcome Forecast
2010 2010 2010 2011 2011
20 Apr 30 Jun 31Dec 30 Jun 31Dec
Interestrates
Policy rate 0.25 0.25 1.25 1.25 1.75
10-yr.gvtbond 3.2 3.3 3.3 3.2 3.4
Exchange rates
EUR/SEK 9.6 9.6 9.5 9.4 9.3
USD/SEK 7.1 7.2 7.7 7.8 7.8
TCW(SEK)1/ 129 129 129 128 128
Sources:ReutersEcowinandSwedbank.1/TotalCompetitivenessWeights.Trade-weightedexchangerateindexforSEK.
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
10/27
10 April 22, 2010
Sweden Swedbank Economic Outlook
households may also signal a need to
slowly adjust monetary policy to more
normalconditions.Bytheendof2010,
thereporatewillhavereached1.25%.
During2011,however,GDPgrowthin quarterly terms will start to dampen
again, as Swedens main export
marketsslowdown.Inaddition,
nancialregulationstocurbthecredit
expansion towards households may
create expectations of wider interest
rate spreads, thus contributing to a
less expansionary monetary policy
stance.Resourceutilisationwillbe
weak and labour costs lower than
normal.Theunderlyinginationrate
(CPI-F)isexpectedtodecrease.These developments will provide
arguments for adjusting monetary
policymoreslowlyduringnextyear.
As many households have variable
interest rates and are highly indebted,
a slower hike of the repo rate may
increase the likelihood of a more stable
consumption and housing market in
theyearstocome.Attheendof2011,
thereporatewillbe1.75%,thus1.25
percentage points lower than in our
previousforecast.
The Swedish krona is expected to
strengthen against the euro during
theforecastperiod.Inthenearterm,
theRiksbankwillraisetherepo
ratefasterthanECB,buttowards
the end of 2011, the policy spread
willhavedisappeared.Stronger
economic growth in Sweden and
better fundamentals compared to the
Eurozoneshouldsupportthekrona.
However,intermsofatrade-weighted
exchangerate(TCW),thekronaappreciates marginally as the dollar
strengthens against both the euro and
thekrona.
More room for scal policyStrong tax revenues led to a
signicantlybetterthanexpectedscaloutcomein2009.Thegeneral
government balance is estimated at
-0.8%ofGDP,comparedwithawidely
expecteddecitofmorethan2%of
GDP.Surprisingly,indirecttaxation,
mainlyvalue-addedtax(VAT),
increased, as did consumer spending,
asashareofGDP.Growinghousehold
incomesupporteddirecttaxation.
On the expenditure side, spending
related to unemployment shot up and,
together with increased investmentand consumption spending, led to a
hikeof3percentagepointsofGDP.
IncontrasttomanyotherEuropean
economies,thescalstancein
Swedenisonlymildlyexpansionary.
Variouscalculationsindicateanimpact
fromscalpolicyontheeconomy
during2009ofbetweenand1
percentagepointofGDP,including
the effects of the automatic stabilisers
anddiscretionarypolicies.Theoutput
gap is still substantial, and there is,
thus,roomforfurtherscalexpansion
with no threat to macroeconomic
stability.Indeed,thegovernmenthas
already signalled that the tax rate on
pensions will be lowered again, and
that spending on infrastructure will be
broughtforward.
Against this background, and taking
into account the general elections in
2010,weexpectthebudgetdecit
to continue to widen in 2010 beforedecliningin2011.Thespringbudget
bill amounted to an expansion of about
SEK5billion,includingincreased
child allowances and spending on
infrastructure.For2011,weanticipate
additionalscalmeasuresofSEK
35billion(about1%ofGDP).Notonly lower tax rates on pensions, but
also increased spending on public
service.However,followingthestrong
performancein2009,itislikelythat
thedecitremainsbelow2%ofGDP
in 2010 and improves slightly in 2011,
duetoimprovedrealgrowth.
Also, the projected path for general
government debt has been revised
downwards.TheMaastrichtdebt
increasedto42.3%ofGDPin2009,lowerthanexpectedduetolargeone-
offtransactionsandabetterscal
outcome.Thegrowingdecitin2010
will add on to the debt before the
recovering economy stabilises the debt
ratiobelow43%ofGDPin2011.
The main challenges over the
medium term will be to reverse the
underlyingimbalances.Weestimate
that the surplus in the public sectors
netsavingsneedtobeabout1%of
GDPover2011-14inordertoreachthe surplus target (calculated over a
7-yearbusinesscycle).Thereductions
of tax rates are permanent measures
thatwillbedifculttoundoinfullfor
whichevergovernmenttakesofce
inlate2010.Thismeansthatthe
bulk of the adjustment will have to
befoundontheexpenditureside.
Part of the reductions will come from
falling spending on labour market
policies as the economy turns, and
from the reforms of the sicknessbenetsystem.However,itislikely
that additional savings will have to be
foundelsewhere.Notaneasyfeat
when the unemployment rates remain
atelevatedlevels.
CeciliaHermansson
JrgenKennemar
Magnus Alvesson
Public sector fiscal balance (% of GDP)
40
42
44
46
48
50
52
54
56
2003 2005 2007 2009 2011
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
Sources:StatisticsSw edenandSw edbankcalculations.
Expenditures
Revenues
Balance (rs)
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
11/27
April 22, 2010 11
Swedbank Economic OutlookEstonia
Estonia Economic prospects improve
After a period of contraction, Estonia
reportedstrong2.5%quarterly
economic growth in the fourth quarter
of2009,whichindicatesthatthe
bottomofthecyclehaspassed.
Annually,thedeclinewas9.5%,
and the full year contraction was
14.1%,consistentwithourprevious
forecast.Overalldevelopmentsintheeconomyattheendof2009andin
early 2010 have been according to our
expectations, indicating a stabilisation
of the economy and a start of the
recovery.Netexportsandinventory
increase were the main contributors
to growth, while other components
continuedtheirdownwardtrend.
We keep our previous growth
forecast,expecting1.5%growth
thisyearand4.5%growthin2011.
Even though the outlook for Estonias
most important export markets have
somewhat worsened, the outcome for
the domestic market is expected to
improve.Withstrongerthanexpected
retail sales, together with increased
condenceaboutemploymentand
future developments in the economy,
households will start to increase
spending.Inaddition,weexpect
that at the end of 2010 there may
be a onetime jump in consumption
caused by the fear of a possible priceincrease accompanying the euro
cashchangeover.TheexpectedEMU
membershipandbetter-than-expected
outcomeofthe2009budgetwill
have a positive effect on economic
developments in 2010 and 2011;
however,thesearedifculttoestimate.
The main assumption in our forecast is
thatEstoniahasfullledtheMaastrichtcriteriaandwillbecomethe17th
memberofEMU.Theformalprocess,
however, will take several months, and
thenaldecisionwillbeannouncedin
thebeginningofJuly.Estoniahasso
farmaintainedaprudentscalpolicy,
and the Estonian government has
committed itself to working towards a
balanced budget in the medium term
aswell.
The growing public sector debtinmanyEUcountriesmaycause
turbulence that could increase the
probability of negative risks for
growthprospectsinEstoniaaswell.
However,inbecomingamemberof
EMU,Estoniamaybenetfroma
more stable environment and lower
interestrateswithintheeurozone.
Other possible risks for our scenario
stemfromhouseholdspending-savingpreferences and foreign investors
strategies.Theprivatesectorsavings
reached an unprecedented level in
2009andthisisabouttoincrease
in 2010 before starting to decline in
2011.However,ifthesavinglevelwere
to remain high for a long time, it will
dampeneconomicgrowthprospects.
WhileEMUmembershipandthe
accompanying decline in currency
risk may encourage investments, the
uncertainties in the euro area maydiminishthisexpectedpositiveeffect.
Key Economic Indicators, 2009 - 2011 1/
2008 2009 2010f 2011f
RealGDP -3.6 -14.1 1.5 4.5GDP,mlneuro 16073 13730 13700 14700
Consumerprices(average) 10.4 -0.1 0.5 1.8
Unemploymentlevel,%oflabourforce 5.5 13.8 14.0 11.5
Realgrossmonthlywage 3.2 -5.2 -5.3 1.5
Exports of goods and services (nominal) 6.9 -19.9 8.0 7.0
Importsofgoodsandservices(nominal) -2.8 -30.6 6.0 7.0
Tradeandservicesbalance,%ofGDP -4.3 5.9 8.0 8.0
Currentandcapitalaccount,%ofGDP -8.4 7.4 8.5 8.0
FDIinow,%ofGDP 8.2 8.8 4.5 8.0
Grossforeigndebt,%ofGDP 118.5 126.8 121.0 115.0
Generalgovernmentbudget,%ofGDP -2.7 -1.7 -1.4 -1.0
Generalgovernmentdebt,%ofGDP 4.6 7.2 10.0 12.5
Sources:StatisticsEstoniaandSwedbank.1/Annualpercentagegrowth,unlessotherwiseindicated.
Contributions to GDP Growth
-30%
-20%
-10%
0%
10%
20%
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010f 2011f
Households Government Investments
Netexports GDP Sources:SE,Sw edbankforecast
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
12/27
12 April 22, 2010
Swedbank Economic OutlookEstonia
Economic growth founded on
external demandThe main contributor to growth in
2010 will be net exports as export
growth will strengthen while import
developmentswilllag.In2011the
largest contributions will come from
domesticdemand.Investments
(including inventories) will already start
to grow in 2010, although a decline in
some quarters is possible due to high
uctuationsandone-offfactorsthat
arehardtopredict.TheEUstructural
funds will support public and private
sectorinvestments.Government
spending is set to decline in 2010
asbudgetconsolidationcontinues.
Householdconsumptionwillalso
continuetodecline,atleastintherst
half of 2010, and growth in the second
halfof2010willbesluggish.For
2011, the growth contributions have
shifted compared with our January
expectations, and we are forecasting
stronger support from household
consumption and slightly less from
inventorybuild-up.
Exports strengthen butimports remain weakRealexportgrowthwillbe4%in2010
and5.5%in2011;realimportgrowth
2%and5.5%.Wechangedourforeign
trade forecast due to the price and
exchange rate movements, domestic
and external demand patterns, and
companies abilities to reach export
markets.
AlthoughforEUcountriesthegrowth
outlook has weakened for 2010, we
project a comparatively good outcome
for Estonia based on the change of
geographicalandproductstructure.
Nevertheless,exportgrowthwill
beslowerthanweexpected.While
the general structure of Estonian
merchandise exports has been well
diversied,theproblemwellseen
inlate2008andearly2009is
that Estonian companies are highly
dependent on economic developments
inafewcountries.Thesharpdecline
of industrial production in Sweden
andFinlandhadthemostdevastating
effectonEstonianproducers.TheimportanceofFinlandandSweden
will remain high, but will diminish
somewhat because Estonian
producers are looking for other
markets(e.g.,non-EUcountries).We
are of the opinion that this tendency
willdeepen.
Services exports will continue to
show good results as the opening of
EUsservicesmarketandstronger
price competitiveness will increase
the possibilities for Estonian
producers.Theserviceswillbe
providednotonlyinEstonia(e.g.,
tourism,IT,andbusinessservices)
but also in the destination countries
(e.g.,construction).Thetransport
and logistic services are about to
recover, but this recovery might not
be very rapid due to weak economic
developments in neighbouring
countries.Theeuroadoptionmay
encourage tourism from the euro
zone,particularlyfromFinland,as
price comparisons will become more
transparent and currency exchange
costs will disappear after euro adoptionin2011.
Weak domestic demand for imported
goods in 2010 will restrain the growth
ofimports.Householdsconsumption
structure has been shifting not only
more towards domestically produced
goods and services (food, housing),
butalsotowardscheaperproducts.
Price movements and euro
depreciation have affected exports
and imports more than we assumed
Swedbanks GDP Forecast Estonia
Changesinvolume,% 2008 2009 2010f1/ 2011f1/
Householdconsumption -4.7 -18.5 (-18.5) -4.0 (-6.0) 4.0 (2.0)
Government consumption 4.1 -0.5 (-0.8) -1.5 (-1.8) 0.4 (1.0)
Investments -16.6 -44.9 (-45.0) 13.0 (13.0) 12.5 (20.0)
Gross capital formation -12.1 -34.3 (-32.0) 0.0 (4.0) 10.0 (10.0)
Changesofinventories/GDP(currentprices) 0.4 -2.5 (-3.0) 1.0 (0.2) 2.0 (0.7)
Domesticdemand -7.4 -24.8 (-25.0) 0.5 (-0.5) 5.5 (6.5)
Exports -0.7 -11.3 (-10.5) 3.5 (8.0) 5.5 (5.5)
Imports -8.7 -26.8 (-27.0) 2.0 (4.0) 5.5 (6.0)
Netexports,contributiontoGDPgrowth 9.0 17.7 (18.5) 1.5 (3.5) -0.1 (-0.5)
GDP -3.6 -14.1 (-14.0) 1.5 (1.5) 4.5 (4.5)
Sources:StatisticsEstoniaandSwedbank.
1/Theseareaveragesoftheforecastranges,whichareca.2percentagepointswide.Roundingandvaryingforecastsoftheerrortermexplainswhysomeofthecomponentsdonotalwaysaddup.TheguresfromourforecastinJanuaryaregiveninbrackets.
Export Structure by Destination Country
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
2004-2006 2007 2008 2009
Other
OtherCIS
Russia
OtherEU
Germany
Sweden
Latvia&
LithuaniaFinland
Sources:SE,Swedbankcalculations
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
13/27
April 22, 2010 13
Swedbank Economic OutlookEstonia
in previous Swedbank Economic
Outlooks.Importsbecame
substantially more expensive last
winter due to price increase of oil
products, which means that less
import is consumed domestically,and, at the same time, the price of
exported products will also rise in
time.
The turnaround of the foreign trade
balanceduring2008-2009was
largerthanweexpected.Thecurrent
and capital account surplus will,
according to our forecast, continue
to increase this year, after which
gradualdeclinewillfollow.Wealso
expectthenancialaccounttoshowabigdecitin2010thatwillbegin
to decrease substantially already in
2011.
Foreigndirectinvestments(FDI)
inowin2010willbesmallerthan
in2009duetotheprivatisationof
EstonianTelekomattheendof2009.
Excludingthis,weexpectFDI
inowtogrowin2010and2011as
the economic situation and growth
outlookimproves.Reducedrisk
estimates and the elimination of
devaluation fears through the euro
adoption will also be encouraging
factors.Weexpectthattheongoing
productiontransferprocess(e.g.,
outsourcing) will intensify, thus
creatingexportsandemployment.
FDIoutowswillremainrelatively
high due to the need to recapitalize
loss-makingcompaniesanddue
to Estonian companies investing in
LatviaandLithuania.
Investments growth supportedby EU fundsWe expect investments (including
inventories)togrowbyabout13%
in2010andby12%in2011,thus
keeping the outlook for this yearanddowngradingitforthenext.
According to our estimation, the
economy is moving from inventory
cuts to increases in inventories during
2010, and the growth rates will be
verystrongatrst.Afterwards,asthe
economic turnaround ends, inventory
growthwillslowin2011.
In2010,weexpectinvestmentgrowth
to be affected by the increased
inowofdifferentEUfunds.In2011,weforecastfewerEU-funded
investments, yet other investments
areabouttoshowmodestgrowth.
We have lowered our expectations
because we see that in 2010 and
2011FDIiscomposedmostlyofM&A,
and of loan payments, and less of
productiondevelopment.Theexcess
capacities will be a strong obstacle
forinvestmentsinnewtechnology.
ManyFDIinvestmentsaretargeting
cheap production in Estonia, which
also means that investment growth
willbenotverystrong.Thesituation
will hopefully change towards
the production of goods at higher
technological levels in the years
beyondourforecastrange.
Householdinvestmentswillremain
low; however the harsh winter might
have encouraged people to pay
moreattentiontoenergyefciency,
which,togetherwithstate-supported
programmes, may increase housing
renovationinvestments.Therstnew
residential real estate construction
may start already in the second half of
2010;however,thenon-residentialreal
estate sector will remain in a stressful
position throughout 2010, and maybeinto2011aswell.
Labour market stabilizingWe expect unemployment to reach its
highest level in 2010, and the peak
willbeinthersthalfoftheyear.By
the end of the year, seasonal factors
and the economic recovery will
graduallypushemploymentup.Still,
job creation will be slow as companies
continue to increase the workload
of existing workers (who so far areworkingpart-time)atrendthatwas
already present in the second half of
2009.Wealsoexpectthatthelabour
supplywilldeclinebutafterone-two
yearsstartgrowingagain.Atthesame
time the amount of active jobseekers
will decline due to aging that may be
accounted as one of the major risks
forEstonianeconomyinthelongrun.
We are of the opinion, however, that
theshareoflong-termunemployed
and the structural problems on labour
marketwillincrease.
The private sector had already made
downward adjustments in employment
in2008and2009,whilethepublic
sector started mostly at the end of
2009.Itispossiblethattherewillbe
additional layoffs in the second half of
2010 in the public sector as the budget
situationdeteriorates(seebelow).
Hence,thenegativeeffectofbudget
cutting will be felt on the labour market
alsointhersthalfof2010,andtoa
Export of Goods and Services, 1Q 2004=100
90
110
130
150
170
190
210
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Total Goods Services
Sources:EP,Swedbankcalculations
Labour Market Indicators
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Employment, yoy Gross w age, real yoyUnemploymentrate Source:SE
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
14/27
14 April 22, 2010
Swedbank Economic OutlookEstonia
lesserextentafterwards.
The decline of average real monthly
wagewillbe5-5.5%in2010,butwe
expectittogrowby1.5%in2011.Total
wagepaymentswilldropby1-2%thisyearbeforegrowingby5-6%in2011.
The difference between the average
and total growth in wage payments is
explained by the change in working
hours:whilein2009theydropped
(hence cutting incomes more than the
average wage, which is calculated for
full-timeemployment),in2010theywill
increase.
Ination to accelerate due to
world market pricesThedeationperiodwillbeshortinEstonia:after0.1%CPIdeclinein
2009,weexpectconsumerpricesto
growbyabout0.5%in2010and1.8%
in2011.Thepricegrowthisprompted
by increases in tax rates (latest
was in January), tariffs (electricity,
heating, and natural gas) and global
prices(mostofallenergy).However,
weak household demand will limit
price pressures, and most of the
unregulated prices will continue to
declineorremainstable.Householdswill also continue to shift towards
cheaper products and services; hence,
theconsumptiondeatorwillremain
negativeforthisyear.Thegrowthof
oil prices in the world will continue to
have a strong effect on consumption
offuelsinEstonia.1 Similarly, the price
growth of other products in the world
1 Of course, there are other factors as well,
such as an increase in fuel excises, and
growing unemployment (less demand for
everydaytravelling).
market has affected consumption
(and therefore the amount of imported
goods).
Household consumption
continuously weakHouseholdconsumptionwillremain
comparatively weak throughout 2010
-weforecasta4%decline-butwill
recoverin2011,showinga4%growth.
The higher forecast is the result of the
stronger developments in the retail
sectorobservedattheendof2009
andbeginningof2010.Besides,the
optimism of households has been
strengthenednotably.Still,withstrong
seasonal spending growth on heating
due to the unusually cold weather, asetback cannot be ruled out, which
means that the risk of a lower outcome
isrelativelystrong.Theotherreasons
for upgrading the consumption
forecast for this year and next is
related to euro adoption and increased
assuredness about employment, which
seemstobeencouragingcondence
and, hence, may trigger additional
spending.Still,aswementioned
above, the savings rate in the private
sector is very high, partly because
of deleveraging, and this might not
changesubstantiallyin2010-11,even
thoughspendingwillslowlyincrease.
Also, there is a possibility of a onetime
increase in consumption at the end
of this year due to households fear
of price increases after the euro cash
changeoverin2011.
According to our observations,
households have shifted their spending
towardscheaperproducts.The
share of the shadow economy may
have increased, while people prefer
to buy goods and services directly
from producers or provide them by
themselves.Thegrowthoftheinformal
economy may therefore underestimate
currentdevelopments.
Tight scal policy continuesWe expect that the public sector
decitwilldeclinefrom1.7%ofGDP
in2009to1.4%in2010andto1%in
2011.Thepublicsectordebtlevelwill
reach12.5%ofGDPattheendofthe
forecastperiod.
The Estonian government cut budget
spending and increased revenues
throughout2009,thusendingtheyearwithapublicsectordecitof
only1.7%ofGDP.Thebudget-
tightening measures included some
one-offitems(e.g.,theincreased
dividendpaymentsfromstate-owned
companies), and several decisions that
affect the budget over several years
(e.g.,thestoppageofpaymentsinto
the compulsory pension scheme and
the smaller increase in pensions than
the law stipulates lowered costs, but
the promises to make compensations
in 2011 and onwards will increase
spending).Expenditureswerelowered
more by cutting costs and increasing
efciency,andlessbycuttingservices
provided.Weurgethatthisefciency-
increasing approach continue and
widen to areas that so far have been
relativelyuntouched(e.g.,tomany
municipalities),andamorecase-by-
case approach should be introduced
insteadoftheone-measure-for-all
approach, which was widespread in
2009.
Price Indices and Deflators
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
CPI deflator PI goods
deflator
PI goods
deflator
Consumption Exports Imports
2008 2009 Source:SE
Confidence Indices, s.a.
-50
-40
-30
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
IndustryConsumerTotal economy Source:EKI,Swedbankcalculations
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
15/27
April22,2010 15
Swedbank Economic OutlookEstonia
Despitestrongbudgetcuts,their
direct negative effect on economic
growthremainedrelativelymodest:
governmentconsumptionfellby0.5%
in2009,althoughinthesecondhalfof
the year the annual decline reached
1%.Thisrelativelymodestoutcome
could be explained by increased use of
EUfunds(particularlystartinginMay-
June), and not so much decrease of
theservicesprovided.Additionally,the
outcome was affected by the increase
in social services due to the sharp rise
inunemployment.
Government budget spending will
remain tight in 2010 and 2011, and we
expect spending cuts to take place, but
mostly in the municipalities that were
not very eager to cut spending prior to
thelocalelectionsinOctober2009and
thushavinglargeproblemsafterwards.
Hence,thestrongertighteningof
spending started there in the fourth
quarter, and this is about to continue
throughout2010.Themunicipalities
budgets remain one of the major risks
inourbudgetforecast.
We are of the opinion that the central
government will continue its existing
budgetary policy and will reduce
the central government budgetdecitin2010-2011.However,the
municipalities situation is about to
worsen, we cannot expect a strong
improvement in the public sector
balance (although it may happen,
depending on how the budgetary
problems at the local levels will be
solved).In2011,severaldecisionstakenin2009willleadtoraised
spending,e.g.oncompulsory
pensioninsurance-whiledeclining
unemploymentwillleadtoareduction.
Although the government plans to
reach a budget surplus after a few
years,wearescepticalaboutthis.We
are of the opinion that the government
willbeforcedtoworkonlong-term
development issues, particularly those
affectingsocialservices(e.g.,the
labour market and health system), orotherwise the Estonian economy will
faceanothercrisisin10years.The
efciencyofthepublicsectorshould
be improved, and access to public
servicesaswell.Thetaxsystemmay
need some stronger adjustments
to ensure that social systems will
continue to work properly when, after
ve-sevenyears,theworking-age
populationdropssharply.
Maris Lauri
Annika Paabut
General Government Finances, % of GDP
-4%
-2%
0%
2%
4%
6%8%
10%
12%
14%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010f 2011f
Debt Budget balance Source:SE
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
16/27
16 April 22, 2010
Swedbank Economic OutlookLatvia
Latvia:RecessiontobeoverearlierthanexpectedKey Economic Indicators, 2008 - 2011 1/
The recession in Latvia is likely to
beoveralreadyintherstquarterof
2010duetoexportgrowthandbetter-
than-expectedprivateconsumption
developments.However,therecovery
path will be bumpy, and the growth
willbefragileinthebeginning.
The economy has become quite
heterogeneous, with developments
differing across sectors, and thus it is
hard to forecast how they will interact
inaparticularquarter.
The seasonally adjusted quarterly
GDPfallslowedto2.9%inthe
fourthquarterof2009duetoslower
household consumption decline and
strongerexportgrowth.Last-quarter
developmentshighlyinuencethe2010 forecasts due to substantial
carryover effects (more negative
for investments, less negative for
consumption and imports, and more
positiveforexportsvis--visour
previousforecast).Forinstance,
assuming that seasonally adjusted
GDPisatthroughouttheyear(i.e.,
the same as the fourth quarter of
2009level),theeconomywouldfallby
4.3%in2010.WeforeseethatGDP
will grow during the year mostly on
account of exports, and thus the fall
of2-3%willbeduesolelytocarryover
effects.Astrongerreboundisexpected
in2011,withGDPgrowingbyabout
4%,supportedbyrecoveringdomestic
demand.Strongerexportsand
restocking will stimulate investments
and,thus,importsin2011.
The job seekers rate is forecast to
peakbymid-2010atabout23%and
start to diminish gradually afterwards,
rstduetoemigrationandrising
inactivity, and in 2011 also due to
slowjobcreation.However,thejob
seekers rate will remain high for years
tocome.Deationisinfullswing,with
theannualconsumerpriceindex(CPI)
declinereaching3.9%inMarch2010,
and it will continue during 2010 and
early2011.Thesmalldecitintradeofgoodsandservicesin2009willturn
intosurplusesin2010-2011,drivenby
exportgrowth.
Domesticpositivesurprisesinterms
ofGDPandsectoraldevelopments
seem to have become more likely
thantherealizationofnegativerisks.
However,theupcomingparliament
elections in October pose risks of
delay in implementing structural
reforms.Theriskofworseningtax
collection may force the government
to revise its 2010 budget to squeeze
belowthedecitcapof8.5%ofGDP
and thus compress domestic demand
evenfurther.Exportsmightbeweaker
if competiveness gains do not become
cleverer,i.e.,ifproductivitygrowth
ispoor.Theglobaloutlookisstillfavourable, although certain risks have
2008 2009 2010f 2011f
Economic growth -4.6 -18.0 -2.5 4.0
GDP,mlneuro 21952 18067 16444 16859
GrowthofGDPdeator,% 15.4 0.3 -6.7 -1.4
Consumerprices(average) 15.4 3.5 -3.0 0.0
Harmonisedunemploymentlevel,%oflabourforce 7.5 16.9 21.5 19.5
Realnetmonthlywage(average) 6.3 -5.9 -8.0 2.0
Exports of goods and services (nominal) 10.6 -17.8 10.0 14.0
Importsofgoodsandservices(nominal) -1.7 -37.6 0.0 15.0
Balanceofgoodsandservices,%ofGDP -13.6 -0.3 4.3 4.3
Currentaccountbalance,%ofGDP -13.0 9.4 9.0 6.5
Currentandcapitalaccountbalance,%ofGDP -11.5 11.8 12.4 9.7
NetFDI,%ofGDP 3.0 0.4 0.4 0.8
Externalgrossdebt,%ofGDP 129 155 167 158
Generalgovernmentbudget(accrualbasis),%ofGDP -4.1 -9.0 -8.5 -6.0
Generalgovernmentdebt,%ofGDP 19.5 36.1 59.0 66.0
Sources:CSBLandSwedbank.
1/Annualpercentagechangeunlessotherwiseindicated.
Seasonally adjusted quarterly real GDP (in %)
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
1Q05 1Q06 1Q07 1Q08 1Q09
GDP ExportsPrivate consumption Grossfixedcapitalform.
Source:CSBL.
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
17/27
April22,2010 17
Swedbank Economic OutlookLatvia
becomemorevisible.Iftrade-partner
countries see weaker growth than
currently expected, it would slow the
recoveryinLatvia.
Export growth stronger andbroaderAlthough economic growth is expected
to slow in the second half of 2010, the
globaloutlookisstillfavourable.The
forecast of weaker demand in euro
zone countries will be compensated
for by stronger growth in some other
EuropeancountriesandRussia,as
well as by a weaker euro against
theU.S.dollar.This,togetherwith
improving competitiveness (seebelow) and the growing market shares
of Latvian exporters, continues to
supportgrowth.Themarketshares
ofLatvianexportersintheEU27and
Russiawererisingduringallof2009.
Although we expect faster real export
growth due to carryover effects, we are
keeping our nominal export forecast
atabout10%for2010and12-14%for
2011duetoslowerdeatorgrowth.
Whileinlate2008-early2009,the
fall in nominal goods exports was
counteracted by services exports,
by the end of last year goods
exportsbecamethedriverofgrowth.
Manufacturing growth is very fragile
so far, and industry developments
werequitedisappointingintherst
twomonthsof2010.Nevertheless,
manufacturingcondenceindicators
continue to improve, suggesting that
manufacturing growth is likely to gain
strengthlaterthisyear.
The situation also differs substantially
acrossindustries.Forinstance,the
wood industry has become the growth
engine both for manufacturing and
exportsin2009,butthisgrowthis
expected to slow somewhat in 2010
with external competition for marketsharesincreasing.Theoutlookfor
food, metal, and chemical industries
is quite favourable, while on a clearly
negative trend are still the textile
industry and the manufacturing of
transportvehiclesandtheirparts.
Regardingservices,tourismprospects
remain relatively positive, due to a
decreaseinvalue-addedtax(VAT)for
accommodation services and several
large-scaleprojectsannouncedfortouristattractioninRiga.Business
services developments have been
alsorelativelygoodsofar.Incontrast,
freight transportation started to decline
inthesecondhalfof2009andremains
underseverecompetitionregionally.
The fall in imports slowed substantially
and goods imports were quite stable
inthesecondhalfof2009.However,
imports are still constrained by the
substitution effect due to the growing
difference between prices of locally
produced and imported goods (see
below)andbyfallingincomes.The
part of imports used for domestic
demand will thus continue to fall,
albeit more slowly, but the growingneed for imports of exporting sectors
willoutweighthiseffect.Realimports
will still fall in 2010, but we forecast
nominalimportstobestable.A
rebound is expected to follow in 2011
both in real and nominal terms due to
growing investments and consumption,
aswellrestocking.
The growing trade surplus will also
keep the current account surplus
highin2010atabout9%,butthiswilldiminishto5-7%in2011dueto
strongerimportgrowth.Theincome
account surplus will still persist in
2010 because of continuing foreign
direct investment losses, but it will be
substantially smaller than last year
andwillcontinuetodeclinein2011.
Currentandcapitaltransferaccounts
willalsobeimprovedbyEUfunds
inows.Emigrantremittancesarealso
likely to increase, thus raising income
andcurrenttransferaccountsurpluses.
Swedbanks GDP Forecast Latvia
Changesinvolume,% 2008 2009 2010f 1 2011f1
GDP -4.6 -18.0 (-18.0) -2.5 (-3.0) 4.0 (4.0)
Householdconsumption -5.5 -22.4 (-23.5) -9.0 (-12.0) 2.0 (1.5)
General government consumption 1.5 -9.2 (-8.0) -7.4 (-3.0) -3.0 (-2.0)Grossxedcapitalformation -15.6 -37.7 (-36.0) -27.0 (-17.0) 7.0 (5.0)
Exports of goods and services -1.3 -13.9 (-15.0) 6.0 (5.0) 8.0 (7.0)
Importsofgoodsandservices -13.6 -34.2 (-34.0) -8.0 (-7.0) 8.5 (6.0)
NetexportcontributiontoGDP 8.5 14.4 (13.8) 6.6 (5.6) 0.1 (0.6)
Sources:CSBLandSwedbank.1/Theseareaveragesoftheforecastranges,whichareca.2percentagepointswide.Roundingandvaryingforecastsoftheerrortermexplainswhysomeofthecomponentsdonotalwaysaddup.TheguresfromourforecastinJanuaryaregiveninbrackets.
Exports by main product groups, millions of lats
0
20
40
60
80
Foodandagricultural
products
Wood, etc Machines
and
equipment
Metal etc Chemicalproducts
Mineral
products
Transport Text iles,
w earing,
leather etc
Jan.-Dec.2009 Jan.-Feb.2010 Source:CSBL.
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
18/27
18 April 22, 2010
Swedbank Economic OutlookLatvia
Investments to grow in 2011The largest fall in investments is over
now,asgrossxedcapitalformation
is60%downfromitspeakinthe
secondquarterof2007.However,
investments will remain weak in 2010due to continuing deleveraging, spare
capacity,andexpensiveandhard-to-
obtainnancing.
On account of a steep fall in gross
xedcapitalformationduring2009,
there are huge negative carryover
effectsforthisyear(-23%).Despitean
expected stabilisation in the middle of
the year and gradual growth afterwards
duetoincreasingcondence,attractive
assetprices,aninowofEUfunds,and lessening spare capacity, gross
xedcapitalformationisforecast
tofallby25-29%in2010,almost
solelyduetothecarryovereffect.A
rebound is then expected in 2011, with
grossxedcapitalformationgrowth
reachingabout7%,mostlyowingto
theexportingsectors.Investments
conancedbyEUfundsareestimated
toconstituteupto7%ofGDPin2010
andremainat5-6%ofGDPin2011.
Spare capacity in manufacturing is
stilllarge,at42%,comparedwith27%
onaveragein2005-2007.Thegrowth
in capacity utilisation accelerated
at the beginning of 2010, and the
rate is expected to rise further, but,
as elsewhere in the economy, the
differencebetweenexporting-and
domesticdemand-orientedsectors
isbecomingmoreandmorevisible.
Facinggrowingdemand,exporting
sectors need to rebuild their stocks in
2010, increasing their production, and,
as spare capacity gets exhausted,
theirdemandforinvestmentswillrise.
Forinstance,thecapacityutilisation
rate in wood, food, and chemical
industriesisalreadyclosetopre-crisislevels, although it might be temporary,
as the rebound in demand is likely to
slowlateron.Incontrast,destocking
indomesticdemand-orientedsectors
will continue, and the necessary
deleveraging provides additional
pressure.
Unemployment will peak soonAlthough unemployment growth has
stopped, the situation in the labour
marketremainsdifcult.Sofar,competitiveness gains have been
achieved mostly through labour cost
reduction.1 The progress is remarkable
bytheendof2009unitlabour
costshaddeclinedby21%since
thefourthquarterof2008.Butthe
competitiveness adjustment should
stillcontinue.Inordertoreducethe
pressure on the labour market and
the rising negative domestic demand
effects, further competitiveness
gainsneedtocomeviaproductivity-
enhancing structural reforms driving
outputgrowth.
Reviseddatashowedaslower
increase in the job seekers rate, and
itreached20.3%inDecember2009.
Preliminary data show that registered
unemployment rate seems to have
peakedattheendofMarch.We
1 See our Swedbank Analysis for more
details:CompetitivenessadjustmentinLatvia:nopainnogain?Availableathttp://
www.swedbank.lv/eng/docs/materiali.php
thus keep our forecast that the job
seekersratewillpeakatabout23%,
stabilizingduringthespring-summer
and start falling very slowly later in the
year due to emigration and a rising
inactivityrate.Economicgrowthisexpected to be productivity driven;
thus, employment growth starting in
2011willbeweak.Furthermore,the
rsttogainfromrecoverywillbethose
currentlyworkingpart-timewhowill
shifttofull-timeemployment.This
means that structural policies must be
devised to support job creation and
reducethenegativeeffectsoflong-
term unemployment on the quality and
sizeofthelabourforce.
Surveys show that majority of
businesses are revising their
remuneration packages in the
beginningoftheyear.Therefore,
the relatively small wage cuts in the
private sector thus far most likely
intensiedintherstquarterof2010
asunemploymentisalreadyveryhigh.
Furtherdevelopmentswilldepend
on how strong productivity growth
willbe.Currently,weexpectwages
to stabilize by the end of the year
andstartgrowingslowlyin2011.Although government spending cuts
will continue, most of the wage cuts in
the public sector most likely are over
intherstquarterof2010.Netwages
will also be reduced by the personal
incometaxrisefrom23%to26%asof
January2010,butdeationwilllessen
thefallinrealincomes.Consequently,
we forecast average net real wage to
decreasebyabout8%in2010and
growmarginallyin2011.
Industry indicators, s.a.
60
70
80
90
100
110
120
Jan/06 Jul/06 Jan/07 Jul/07 Jan/08 Jul/08 Jan/09 Jul/09 Jan/10
-60
-45
-30
-15
0
15
30
Manufacturingoutput,2005=100
Production expectations f or the months ahead, pts
Sources:ReutersEcoWin,CSBL.
Wage bill, productivity and job seekers (%)
-50
-25
0
25
50
1Q06 1Q07 1Q08 1Q09
-20
-10
0
10
20
Wage bill, yoy Nominalgrossw age,yoy
FTEproductivity,yoy Job seekers' rate (rs)
Source:CSBL.
-
8/6/2019 1271924546 Swedbank Economic Outlook April 2010
19/27
April22,2010 19
Swedbank Economic OutlookLatvia
Deation in local goods andservices to continueMonthlyconsumerpricedeation
eased in early 2010 mostly due to
seasonal factors, but also owing to
importedpriceincreases.Higherglobalprices are raising consumer prices in
Latvia, but this is expected to slow in
thesecondhalfof2010.Nevertheless,
higher global oil prices will lead to
increased gas and heating tariffs in
Latviainthesecondhalfoftheyear.
Localdeationarypressureremains,
supported by a weak labour market
andcontinuingdeleveraging.Wethus
forecasta3%averagedeationin
2010andaby-and-largestableCPIin
2011.
Deleveragingisbecomingmore
prevalent,anddeationismakingthe
processmoredifcult.Fallingwages
and employment make debt servicing
increasingly tough a situation that is
reectedinrisenloanoverduesinthe
market.Sincelate2009,thepipelineof
new overdues is gradually drying up,
suggestingacertainstabilisation.Also,
real estate prices, and thus collateral
values,havingdroppedabout70%
fromtheirpeakinmid-2007,are
startingtoshowsometentativegrowth.
Creditstockisslowlyfalling,asthe
amount of newly issued loans cannot
compensate for the amortization of
existingloans.However,thedebt
service burden is increasing both
for households and businesses as
incomesaredecliningfaster.This,in
turn, is weighing down on consumption
andinvestments.
Deationalsoraisestherealinterest
rate,thusmakingnancingmore
expensive.Inaddition,europolicy
rates are expected to start increasing
inthersthalfof2011.Deleveraging
is unavoidable and it will take time global experience shows that this
processtakesyears.Banksarestill
cautious to lend, although mortgage
lending is about to pick up as housing
affordability has improved more than
threefold since the real estate price
peak,mainlyduetolowerprices.
According to our estimations, currently
one monthly average net wage buys
1squaremeter,comparedwithto0.3
squaremeterin2007.
Household consumption tostabilise earlier than expectedHouseholdconsumptionwillremain
weak in 2010 due to falling incomes
andcontinuousdeleveragingpressure.
Theincreaseinconsumercondence
sincethesecondhalfof2009does
not immediately translate into robust
economicactivity.However,recent
retail trade turnover developments
suggest that private consumption
might have increased or at least been
stableintherstquarterof2010(partly due to unusually cold and
snowywinter).Weforecasthousehold
consumptiontofallbyabout9%in
2010, almost fully due to the negative
carryover effect, and grow by about
2%in2011.Duetocontinuing
deleveraging pressure, household
consumption will fall more than total
incomes(i.e.,thewagebillplus
pensions) in 2010 and grow less than
latterin2011.
The surprisingly strong retail trade
performance in early 2010, together
with some stabilisation in household
deposits and the continuing fall in
taxrevenuesasapercentofGDP
(see below), suggests that theshareofenvelopeincome(i.e.,
thegreyeconomy)hasincreased.
Forinstance,TheStateLabour
Inspectorateestimatesthatnearly
one-fthofofciallyregistered
unemployedactuallyareworking.This
increases the forecast error for private
consumptionfortheupcomingyears.
As the consumption side seems to
better measure the economic activity
than the income side, true incomes
might actually fall less than our
forecastsuggests.
Tax collection to be improvedDespiteaslightslipinscaldiscipline
attheyearsveryend,the2009
budgetdecitstoodat9%ofGDP
(accrualbasis),i.e.,belowthe10%
target.Thecurrentg