0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’...

21
!"#$$%& ()** +&&, -./0 1/23.45 (67)* 8.92/5 :;5<2/=> :?)0 @)75A B C6** @)/467)D E;F0655.? 52> G/H E;5<./*)7?I J)/* K))9)*)I B L6** L.7=.7 E;F0655.? 27> M+NMON+&&,

Transcript of 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’...

Page 1: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

!"#$$%&'()**'+&&,'-./0'1/23.45'(67)*'8.92/5'

:;5<2/=>':?)0'@)75A'B'C6**'@)/467)D'

E;F0655.?'52>'G/H'E;5<./*)7?I'J)/*'K))9)*)I'B'L6**'L.7=.7'

E;F0655.?'27>'M+NMON+&&,'

Page 2: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

!"#$%&'(#)*%++,-.'

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

-<.'/.=;*5='2Q'5<6='=.0.=5./='P2/D')/.')'9/292=)*'52'4/.)5.'5<.'R)09;='E;=5)67)F6*65A'!75./9/6=.')5'@-[I')7'2/T)76])5627)*'4<)/5I')7?')'@E'1/23.45'?)5)F)=.H'-<.'2/T)76])5627)*'4<)/5'P6**'2;5*67.'5<.'Q;745627)*'=5/;45;/.'2Q'5<.'.75./9/6=.H'-<.'@E'1/23.45'?)5)F)=.'P6**'F.';=.?'52'9*)7'5<.'67656)*')456W656.='2Q'5<.'.75./9/6=.')7?'5/)4D'5<.'/.=;*5='2Q'5<.'P2/D'9./Q2/0.?'FA'5<.'.75./9/6=.'0.0F./=H'

Page 3: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

'

/0&-12%$&'10)

-<6='5./0'9/23.45'P)='4209*.5.?')='9)/5'2Q'5<.'!"#$$%&'#/)?;)5.'R2**2S;6;0'27'E;=5)67)F6*65AH'-<.'9/23.45'T2)*'P)='52'6742/92/)5.'5<.':4)?.064'U;)*65A'V09/2W.0.75'1/2T/)0'X:UV1Y'4)/F27'42;7567T'9/23.45'6752')7';7?./T/)?;)5.'=5;?.75'.75./9/6=.H'-2'F.55./'?.=4/6F.'=;=5)67)F6*65A'<./.'6=')'S;25)5627'Q/20'\6D69.?6)'^M_'`E;=5)67)F6*65A'6=')'4<)/)45./6=564'2Q')'9/24.=='2/'=5)5.'5<)5'4)7'F.'0)675)67.?')5')'4./5)67'*.W.*'67?.Q6765.*AH'-<.'5./0I'67'65='.7W6/270.75)*';=)T.I'/.Q./='52'5<.'925.756)*'*27T.W65A'2Q'W65)*'<;0)7'.42*2T64)*'=;992/5'=A=5.0=I'=;4<')='5<.'9*)7.5a='4*60)564'=A=5.0I'=A=5.0='2Q')T/64;*5;/.I'67?;=5/AI'Q2/.=5/AI')7?'Q6=<./6.=I')7?'<;0)7'4200;7656.='67'T.7./)*')7?'5<.'W)/62;='=A=5.0='27'P<64<'5<.A'?.9.7?Hb'@64<6T)7'-.4<'6='72P'9)/56469)567T'67'5<.':UV1'9/2T/)0'=2'65'6='.==.756)*'52';7?./=5)7?'<2P'@-[I':UV1I')7?'=;=5)67)F6*65A')/.'/.*)5.?H'

:UV1'6=')'7.P'0.5<2?'52'2F5)67')44/.?65)5627'5</2;T<'5<.'K6T<./'c.)/767T'R2006==627'XKcRY'2Q'5<.'"2/5<'R.75/)*':==246)5627'X"R:YH'-<6='7.P')44/.?65)5627'9/2T/)0')**2P='@64<6T)7'-.4<72*2T64)*'[76W./=65A'52'4<22=.'P<64<'9/23.45='52'=9.7?'027.A'27H'-<.=.'P6**'F.'9/23.45='5<)5')/.'427=6?./.?'52'F.'6092/5)75'FA'5<.';76W./=65A')7?'2Q'P<64<';7?./'5<.'2*?'0.5<2?'2Q')44/.?65)5627'0)A'725'<)W.'F..7')44.95)F*.'52'5<.'KcRH'':*5<2;T<'5<.'KcR'?2.='725'0)7?)5.')'9/23.45'52964I'2/'/.S;6/.'5<.6/')99/2W)*'2Q'5<.'9/23.45I'5<.A'?2'/.S;6/.'5<.'9/23.45='52';56*6].')'427567;2;='609/2W.0.75'9/24.==H'\65<'5<.')F6*65A'52'4<22=.'65='9/23.45='@64<6T)7'-.4<'<)='?.46?.?'52'Q24;='65='.QQ2/5=I'67'9)/5I'27'0)D67T'5<.'@-['4)09;='02/.'=;=5)67)F*.H''

'

3-145#+)6#7'0'&'10)

V7'5<.'Q)4.'2Q'T/2P67T'4274./7='/.T)/?67T'4*60)5.'4<)7T.I'T/..7<2;=.'T)='.06==627=I')7?'=;=5)67)F6*65AI'65'6='9/292=.?'52'.=5)F*6=<')'R)09;='E;=5)67)F6*65A'!75./9/6=.'XRE!YH'-<.'RE!'P6**'67656)**A'Q24;='27'.QQ2/5='52'/.?;4.'5<.'.42ZQ2259/675'2Q'@64<6T)7'-.4<72*2T64)*'[76W./=65A'X@-[YH'\65<'5<.=.'T2)*='67'067?'65'P)='7.4.==)/A'52'Q67?'2;5'<2P'52'4/.)5.'5<6='7.P'.75./9/6=.')7?'F;6*?'5<.'Q/)0.P2/D'Q2/'65'52'Q;745627')7?')??/.=='=;=5)67)F6*65A'6==;.=H''

'

899-1,$:)

-<.'Q6/=5'=5.9'P)='52'0..5'P65<'5<.'.75./9/6=.'9/2T/)0'?6/.452/I'@)/A'8)F./I'52'?6=4;=='5<.'9/24.=='Q2/'Q2/067T')'7.P'.75./9/6=.')5'@-[H'(/20'5<6='0..567T')'=.5'2Q'T;6?.*67.='P./.'2F5)67.?'Q2/'P/6567T')'9/292=)*'52'4/.)5.')'7.P'.75./9/6=.H'(2**2P67T'5<.=.'T;6?.*67.=')'?/)Q5'9/292=)*'P)='4/.)5.?')7?'=;F0655.?'52'5<.'*.)?./=<69'2Q'!"#$$%&'Q2/'/.W6.PH''

-2'2F5)67'679;5'Q/20'5<.'E;=5)67)F*.'(;5;/.='V7=565;5.'XE(VY'G6/.452/I'L2<7'E;5<./*)7?I')7?'T/)?;)5.'=5;?.75='P2/D67T'67'5<.'E(V'5P2'=.9)/)5.'0..567T='P.'2/T)76].?H':5'.)4<'2Q'5<.=.'0..567T='6?.)=I'

Page 4: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

/.S;6/.0.75=I')7?'9/292=.?'0.5<2?='P./.'9/.=.75.?'52'5<.'0.0F./='2Q'5.)0'MH':5'5<.'=.427?'0..567T')'/.W6.P'2Q'5<.'?/)Q5'9/292=)*'P)='9./Q2/0.?'P<64<'/.=;*5.?'67'.d4.**.75'Q..?F)4D')7?'T/.)5'9/2T/.=='Q2/P)/?H'E20.'2Q'5<.'=;TT.=5627='5<)5'P./.'/.4.6W.?'Q/20'5<.'0..567T'P./.'F/2)?.767T'5<.'=429.'2Q'5<.'9/292=)*'52'6742/92/)5.'=;=5)67)F6*65A'6==;.='F.A27?'5<.'4)/F27'Q2259/675'67656)56W.I'92==6F*.'=2;/4.='2Q'Q;7?67TI'F;?T.5)/A'T;6?.=I'.75./9/6=.'2/T)76])5627)*'0)5./6)*I')7?'5<.'9/29./'P2/?67T')7?'Q2/0)5567T'Q2/'5<.'675/2?;45627')7?'F)4DT/2;7?'=.45627='52'F.55./'=.**'5<.'6?.)='F.67T'9/.=.75.?H':Q5./'5<6='0..567T'=.W./)*'25<./'65./)5627='2Q'5<.'9/292=)*'P./.'4/.)5.?')7?'?6=5/6F;5.?'Q2/'/.W6.P'W6)'.0)6*H'

:='5<.'=.0.=5./'9/2T/.==.?'65'F.4)0.'2FW62;='5<)5')??65627)*'?24;0.75='P./.'7..?.?'52'?.Q67.'<2P'5<.'.75./9/6=.'P2;*?'F.'2/T)76].?')7?'52'9*)7'65=')456W656.='?;/67T'5<.'67656)*'=5)T.='2Q'65='.d6=5.74.H'-2'=)56=QA'5<.=.'7..?=')7'2/T)76])5627)*'4<)/5'P65<'/2*.=')7?'/.=927=6F6*656.='P./.'?.W.*29.?H'-2'=)56=QA'5<.'9*)7767T'7..?')'5)=D'*6=5'P)='T.7./)5.?')7?'609*.0.75.?'67'@64/2=2Q5'1/23.45H''e74.'5<.=.'?24;0.75='P./.'4/.)5.?'=.W./)*'65./)5627='2Q'5<.'9/292=)*I'2/T)76])5627)*'4<)/5I')7?'#)755'4<)/5'P./.'=.75'2;5'W6)'.0)6*'52'5<.'5.)0'0.0F./=')7?'E(V'?6/.452/'Q2/'/.W6.PH'(/20'5<.=.'/.W6.P'=.==627='0;4<'Q..?F)4D'P)='/.4.6W.?'/.T)/?67T'5<.'=5/;45;/.'2Q'5<.'2/T)76])5627)*'4<)/5I'0.0F./f='/2*.=')7?'/.=927=6F6*656.=I')7?'Q67)*'5P.)D67T'2Q'5<.'9/292=)*'?24;0.75H''

'

;#<%5&<)

-<.'/.=;*5='2Q'5<6='=.0.=5./='P2/D')/.')'9/292=)*'52'4/.)5.'5<.'R)09;='E;=5)67)F6*65A'!75./9/6=.')5'@-[I')7'2/T)76])5627)*'4<)/5'52'2;5*67.'5<.'Q;745627)*'=5/;45;/.'2Q'5<.'.75./9/6=.I')7?')'@E'1/23.45'?)5)F)=.H'1*.)=.'=..':99.7?6d':I'CI')7?'R'/.=9.456W.*A'Q2/'4296.='2Q'.)4<H''

[7?./'5<.'?6/.45627'2Q'5<.'E(V'?6/.452/'Q..?F)4D'6='F.67T'=2;T<5'Q/20'=.W./)*'25<./'D.A'67?6W6?;)*='27'5<.'.75./9/6=.'9/292=)*H':Q5./'5<6='Q..?F)4D'6='/.4.6W.?'5<.'9/292=)*'P6**'7..?'52'F.'=;F0655.?'52')7?')99/2W.?'FA'5<.'!75./9/6=.':?W6=2/A'C2)/?'F.Q2/.'5<.'.75./9/6=.'4)7'F.T67'2QQ646)*'29./)5627=H'-<.'2/T)76])5627)*'4<)/5'9/2W6?.='5<.'F)=64='Q2/'29./)5627'2Q'5<.'.75./9/6=.')7?'P6**'T;6?.'5<.'0.0F./=')='52'P<)5'5)=D='.)4<'5.)0')7?'92=65627'P6**'F.'/.=927=6F*.'Q2/H'-<.'@E'1/23.45'?)5)F)=.'4275)67='=.W./)*'D.A'.*.0.75='5<)5'P6**')==6=5'67'T;6?67T'5<.'.75./9/6=.H'\65<67'5<.'@E'1/23.45'?)5)F)=.'5<.'5)=D'?;/)5627=I'/.*)5627=<69=I')7?'?.)?*67.='P./.'.=5)F*6=<.?'52'9/2W6?.')'<6T<'*.W.*'9*)7'2Q'29./)5627='Q2/'5<.'Q6/=5'MH$'A.)/='2Q'5<.'.75./9/6=.H'

'

=%&%-#)>1-?)

V7'5<.'7.)/'Q;5;/.'5<.'?.W.*29.?'9/292=)*'P6**'7..?'52'F.'=;F0655.?'52'5<.'!75./9/6=.':?W6=2/A'C2)/?'Q2/')99/2W)*H'V5'6='.d9.45.?'5<)5'5<6='9/292=)*'P6**'F.')99/2W.?'P65<2;5'<.=65)5627')7?'2QQ646)*'29./)5627='4)7'F.T67H'E5;?.75'P2/D./='P6**'7..?'52'F.'Q2;7?'52'9./Q2/0'5)=D='2W./'5<.'=9/67T'+&&g'=.0.=5./H'''

Page 5: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

-<.'Q2**2P67T'6=')'F/6.Q'*6=5'2Q'6092/5)75'5)=D='Q2/'5<.'=9/67T'=.0.=5./H'

• G.W.*29'RE!'.?;4)5627)*'4;//64;*;0''

• e/T)76].'RE!'*.)?./=<69'

• R209*.5.'R:ZR1'02?.*'

• V?.756QA'V09/2W.0.75=')7?'/.Q67.0.75='52'5<.'02?.*'

• E5)/5'P2/D'27'4209;5./')7?'(-1'Q6*.'=52/)T.'

:**'2Q'5<.'5)=D='5<)5'P6**'7..?'52'F.'9./Q2/0.?'4)7'F.'Q2;7?'27'5<.'#)755'4<)/5'4/.)5.?'FA'5<.'@E'1/23.45'?)5)F)=.')7?')55)4<.?'52'5<6='?24;0.75H'

Page 6: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

>1-?<)@'&#2)

^M_'bE;=5)67)F6*65AHb'\6D69.?6)H'M%'G.4H'+&&,H'M%'G.4H'+&&,'h<559>NN.7HP6D69.?6)H2/TNP6D6NE;=5)67)F6*65Ai'

Page 7: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

899#02'")8)A)!0&#-9-'<#)3-1B#$&)3-191<,5)

)))))

@,+9%<)*%<&,'0,4'5'&.)!0&#-9-'<#)3-191<,5)

1/.9)/.?'FA>':?)0'@)75A'B'\6**6)0'@)/467)D''

()**'E.0.=5./'+&&,''

'

'

'

'

Page 8: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

C,$?D-1%02))V7'5<.'Q)4.'2Q'T/2P67T'4274./7='/.T)/?67T'4*60)5.'4<)7T.I'T/..7<2;=.'T)='.06==627=I')7?'=;=5)67)F6*65AI'65'6='9/292=.?'52'.=5)F*6=<')'R)09;='E;=5)67)F6*65A'!75./9/6=.'XRE!YH'-<.'RE!'P6**'67656)**A'Q24;='27'.QQ2/5='52'/.?;4.'5<.'.42ZQ2259/675'2Q'@64<6T)7'-.4<72*2T64)*'[76W./=65A'X@-[YH':UV1'6=')'7.P'0.5<2?'52'2F5)67')44/.?65)5627' 5</2;T<' 5<.'K6T<./' c.)/767T' R2006==627' XKcRY' 2Q' 5<.'"2/5<' R.75/)*' :==246)5627' X"R:YH'-<6='7.P')44/.?65)5627'9/2T/)0')**2P='@64<6T)7'-.4<72*2T64)*'[76W./=65A' 52'4<22=.'P<64<'9/23.45=' 52'=9.7?'027.A'27H'-<.=.'P6**'F.'9/23.45=' 5<)5')/.'427=6?./.?' 52'F.' 6092/5)75'FA' 5<.';76W./=65A')7?'2Q'P<64<';7?./'5<.'2*?'0.5<2?'2Q')44/.?65)5627'0)A'725'<)W.'F..7')44.95)F*.'52'5<.'KcRH'':*5<2;T<'5<.'KcR' ?2.=' 725'0)7?)5.' )' 9/23.45' 52964I' 2/' /.S;6/.' 5<.6/' )99/2W)*' 2Q' 5<.' 9/23.45I' 5<.A' ?2' /.S;6/.' 5<.'9/23.45='52';56*6].')'427567;2;=' 609/2W.0.75'9/24.==H'\65<'5<.')F6*65A'52'4<22=.' 65='9/23.45='@64<6T)7'-.4<' <)=' ?.46?.?' 52' Q24;=' 65=' .QQ2/5=I' 67' 9)/5I' 27' 0)D67T' 5<.' @-[' 4)09;=' 02/.' =;=5)67)F*.H' -<.'Q2**2P67T'6=')'F/6.Q'2;5*67.'2Q'5<.'<6=52/A'2Q'5<.':UV1')45627='/.*.W)75'52'RE!H'

'

• R*.)7' :6/ZR22*' 1*)7.5' XR:ZR1Y' R)09;=' R)/F27' R)*4;*)52/' W$H&' =.*.45.?' )=' 5<.' 67656)*' 522*' Q2/'S;)756QA67T'5<.')02;75'2Q'4)/F27'/.*.)=.?'FA'@-['

• E5;?.75'P2/D./='4;//.75*A'P2/D67T'52'929;*)5.'5<.'R:ZR1'522*'• -<.'*6065)5627=I')==;095627=I')7?'?)5)'Q/20'5<.'67656)*'R:ZR1'/.=;*5='P6**'Q2/0'5<.'F)=6='Q2/'5<.'

RE!'9/23.45=''

E'<<'10)*&,&#+#0&))-<.'R)09;='E;=5)67)F6*65A'!75./9/6=.'XRE!Y'P6**'?.W.*29'5<.')7)*A564)*'522*=')7?'D72P*.?T.'7.4.==)/A'52'=;992/5' =;=5)67)F6*65A' ?.46=627' 0)D67T' )7?' 52' ?.=6T7' )7?' 609*.0.75' =;=5)67)F*.' =2*;5627=' 27' 5<.'@64<6T)7'-.4<'4)09;=H''

'

6#(#519+#0&))V7656)**AI' 5<.' RE!'.75./9/6=.'P6**' Q24;=' 27' 6?.756QA67T' 5<.'02=5' =6T76Q64)75' =2;/4.=' 2Q' 4)/F27' .06==627='Q/20')**'4)09;=')456W656.=H'-<6='.QQ2/5I'=;992/5.?'P65<')W)6*)F*.'522*=MI'P6**'T;6?.'5<.'.75./9/6=.'5.)0'67'2;5*6767T'=9.46Q64'9/23.45='52'9/292=.'52'5<.'@-[')?0676=5/)5627H'@.0F./='2Q'5<.'RE!'5<.7'P6**'?.W.*29')7?'.d.4;5.'=2*;5627='P65<'5<.'T2)*'2Q'/.?;467T'5<.'4)/F27'Q2259/675'2Q'5<.'@-['4)09;=H'E5;?.75='P6**'7..?' 52' 427?;45' 67Z?.95<' )7)*A=6=I' .HTHI' 42=5ZF.7.Q65' )7)*A=6=I' 52' 9/2W6?.' 0./65' Q2/' 5<.6/' 9/292=.?'=2*;5627' 67'F/67T67T' 5<.'@-['4)09;='4*2=./' 52' =;=5)67)F*.' *.W.*='2Q'4)/F27';=.H' V7')??65627' 52'4)/F27'Q2259/675' /.?;45627'.QQ2/5=I' 65'P6**'F.'7.4.==)/A' 52'=..D'4)/F27'Q2259/675'02?.*67T' 609/2W.0.75=H'-<6='0)A'/.S;6/.'6?.756QA67T'02?.*67T'522*')*5./7)56W.='2/'?.W.*2967T')7'67Z<2;=.'02?.*'F.55./'=;65.?'52'5<.'7..?='2Q'@-[H'-<2;T<'5<.'67656)*'Q24;='6='27'5<.'4)09;='4)/F27'Q2259/675I'5<.'RE!'6='4200655.?'52'5<.'F/2)?./'?.Q6765627'2Q'=;=5)67)F6*65A')7?'P6**'=..D'P)A='52'0)D.'@-[')'=;=5)67)F*.'4)09;=H''

''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''1 Clean Air-Clean Planet, Version 5 http://www.cleanair-coolplanet.org/toolkit/content/view/43/124/

Page 9: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

F1,5<GH4B#$&'(#<)'

• #)5<./'?)5)I'9./Q2/0'02?.*'=.7=656W65A')7)*A=6=I')7?'4209*.5.'4)/F27'Q2259/675'02?.*67T'.QQ2/5'Q2/'5<.'@-['4)09;=''

• [=67T' 02?.*' /.=;*5=I' =.7=656W65A' )7)*A=6=I' )7?' 42=5' F.7.Q65' )7)*A=6=I' 6?.756QA' 925.756)*' 4)/F27'Q2259/675'/.?;45627'=5/)5.T6.='

• -.=5')7?'609*.0.75'4)/F27'Q2259/675'/.?;45627'=5/)5.T6.='27'5<.'@-['4)09;='• V?.756QA'609/2W.0.75='2/'/.Q67.0.75='52'4)/F27'Q2259/675'02?.*67T'0.5<2?=')7?'522*='• G.W.*29' )' 4)/F27' Q2259/675' /.?;45627' 0.5<2?2*2TA' 5<)5' 4)7' F.' )99*6.?' 52' 25<./' 4)09;=.=I'

67?;=5/6)*')/.)=I')7?'F;6*5'.7W6/270.75='• :99*A' 5<.' =;=5)67)F6*65A' F2?A' 2Q' D72P*.?T.' 52' 9/23.45=' Q2/' F25<' 675./7)*' X@-[Y' )7?' .d5./7)*'

X42/92/)5.I'"#eI'T2W./70.75)*Y'4*6.75='• @)/D.5')7?'?6==.067)5.'02?.*67T')7?'=;=5)67)F*.'=2*;5627='

'

31&#0&',5)=%02'0D)''

• @-['!75./9/6=.'1/2T/)0'• [HEH'!7./TA'E5)/'9/2T/)0'• V75.T/A=N[11Re'• :*;076'• j)/62;='(2;7?)5627='• 1.**)'\67?2P='

• G2P'R2/767T'• "E('X")5627)*'E46.74.'(2;7?)5627Y'• !75./9/6=.'(67)74.'-.)0'• [EG:'"8V'R209.5656W.'#/)75='• [E#E'• !1:'

'

!2%$,&'10,5)@1+910#0&)):/.)=' P65<67' 5<.' 02?.*' 42;*?' /.9/.=.75' )' 9/23.45' 5.)0' P65<67' 5<.' .75./9/6=.' )7?' 427=6=5' 2Q')99/2d60)5.*A'$'9.29*.'9./' 5.)0H':'9/292=.?'2/T)76])5627)*' =5/;45;/.' Q2/' 5<.'!75./9/6=.' 6=' =<2P7' 67':99.7?6d' :+H' :/.)=' /.9/.=.7567T' 9/23.45' 5.)0=' 42;*?' F.' )=' Q2**2P=>' .*.45/6465A' )7?' <.)567TI'5/)7=92/5)5627I')T/64;*5;/.I'=2*6?'P)=5.I')7?'/.Q/6T./)75=')7?'25<./'4<.064)*=H':=')'0.0F./'2Q')'9/23.45'5.)0' P65<67' 5<.' .75./9/6=.I' )' =5;?.75' P6**' F.' 67W2*W.?' P65<' =.W./)*' )/.)=' 674*;?67T' 02?.*' )7)*A=6=I'?.W.*2967T'=2*;5627=I'2F5)6767T';76W./=65A'X4*6.75Y'F)4D67T'52'5<.'9/292=.?'=2*;5627I')7?' 609*.0.7567T'5<.'?.W.*29.?'=2*;5627H' '-<.'P2/D'2Q'5<.'RE!'P6**'9/2W6?.'D72P*.?T.'7.4.==)/A'52')6?' 67'5<.'?.46=627Z0)D67T'.QQ2/5='67'=;992/5'2Q'=;=5)67)F6*65A'T2)*=H''e7.'2Q'5<.'02=5'Q/.S;.75'4<)**.7T.='Q)4.?'FA'=;=5)67)F6*65A'.QQ2/5='6='T.5567T'67?6W6?;)*='52'`F;A'6752k'2/')44.95' 5<.' 7..?.?' 4<)7T.=' )7?' =2*;5627=H' -<6=' .75./9/6=.' P2;*?' 9/2W6?.' 725' 27*A' 5<.' 7.4.==)/A'5.4<764)*' )7?' ?.46=627' 0)D67T' =D6**=I' F;5' 65' P2;*?' )*=2' 9/2W6?.' 5<.' =5;?.75=' P65<' )' 5<2/2;T<';7?./=5)7?67T' 2Q' 5<.' =246.5)*' 4<)**.7T.=' Q)4.?' P65<' P<.7' 5/A67T' 52' 609*.0.75' 5<.=.' =2*;5627=H' -<.'.75./9/6=.' P6**' )*=2' <2*?' 675./7)*' .?;4)5627' )7?' 9/2Q.==627)*' ?.W.*290.75' =.==627= 52' 9/2025.' 5<.'/.5.75627'2Q'D72P*.?T.'P65<67'5<.'.75./9/6=.')7?'52'Q;/5<./'65='0.0F./f='9/2Q.==627)*'?.W.*290.75H''

'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''2 RE!'e/T'R<)/5'X:99.7?6d':Y

Page 10: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

E5;?.75='*.)/767T'2;5420.='P6**'F.'0.)=;/.?'5</2;T<'=.W./)*'?6QQ./.75'0.5<2?='5</2;T<2;5'5<.'=.0.=5./H':55.7?)74.'P6**'F.'0)7?)52/A')5')**'.75./9/6=.'0..567T=H':='=;4<I'6Q'5<.'=5;?.75'06==.='02/.'5<)7'M'0..567T'P65<2;5')';76W./=65A'.d4;=.?')F=.74.'5<.6/'=.0.=5./'T/)?.'P6**'F.'/.?;4.?')442/?67T'52'5<.'92*64A'?.5./067.?'FA'5<.'.d.4;56W.'*.)?./=<69H':*=2I'5.)0'*.)?./='P6**'F.'/.=927=6F*.'Q2/'5)D67T')55.7?)74.')5'5.)0'0..567T=')7?'Q2/'.W)*;)567T'5<.'9./Q2/0)74.'2Q'.)4<'5.)0'0.0F./'2W./'5<.'42;/=.'2Q'5<.'=.0.=5./H'-<.'5.)0'*.)?./='P6**'F.'.W)*;)5.?'FA'5<.'j1'9./5)6767T'52'5<)5'P2/D'T/2;9I')7?'5<.'j1f='FA'5<.'.75./9/6=.'9/.=6?.75H''-<.'.75./9/6=.'9/.=6?.75'0)A'2/'0)A'725'F.'.W)*;)5.?'FA'5<.'Q)4;*5A')?W6=2/')*27T'P65<'5<.'Q)4;*5A')?W6=2/A'F2)/?I'5<6='P6**'?.9.7?'27'5<.'/.*)5627=<69'2Q'5<.'9/.=6?.75'P65<'5<.'Q)4;*5A')?W6=2/A'F2)/?H'!)4<'67?6W6?;)*'F.67T'T/)?.?'4)7')99.)*'5<.6/'T/)?.'52'5<.'0)7)T./'27.'*.W.*')F2W.'6Q'5<.A'Q..*'5<)5'5<.6/'T/)?.'?2.='725')44;/)5.*A'/.Q*.45'5<.6/'4275/6F;5627='Q2/'5<)5'=.0.=5./H''

'

:=')'T.7./)*'T;6?.*67.I'.)4<'0.0F./'5<)5'6='F.67T'T/)?.?'=<)**'F.'3;?T.?'27'5<.6/'9/2T/.=='52P)/?='5<.'=.0.=5./'T2)*='2Q'5<.'.75./9/6=.H'(2/'.d)09*.I')'5.)0'0.0F./'0)A'F.'/.=927=6F*.'Q2/')'?.=6T7'420927.75'2Q'27.'=2*;5627')7?'=<)**'F.'3;?T.?'27'5<.'9/2T/.==I'.QQ2/5I')7?'?/6W.'52P)/?='0..567T'5<.'T2)*=')7?'2F3.456W.='2Q'5<)5'5)=DH':'5.)0'*.)?./'0)A'F.'<.*?')442;75)F*.'Q2/'5<.'9/2T/.=='2Q'5<.6/'5.)0')=')'P<2*.'52P)/?='5<.'T2)*='=.5'Q2/5<'Q2/'5<)5'9)/564;*)/'5.)0H'-<.'=.0.=5./'=4<.?;*.')7?'T2)*='=<)**'F.'=.5')5'5<.'.7?'2Q'5<.'9/.4.?67T'=.0.=5./'2/'?;/67T'5<.'Q6/=5'P..D'2Q'5<.'4;//.75'5./0H'V79;5'52P)/?='5<.'=4<.?;*.'=<)**'F.'=2;T<5'Q/20'.)4<'5.)0'0.0F./')='P.**')='5.)0')7?'9/23.45'*.)?./=H':Q5./'5<.'=.0.=5./'=4<.?;*.')7?'T2)*='<)W.'F..7'?.46?.?';927'FA'5<.'5.)0'0.0F./=')7?'5.)0'*.)?./I'65'0;=5'5<.7'F.')99/2W.?'FA'5<.'j1'2Q'5<)5')/.)H'''

'

E;=5)67)F6*65A'6=')7'6==;.'5<)5')QQ.45='.W./A27.')7?')='=;4<I'5<6='.75./9/6=.'P6**'/.*A'27'5<.'=D6**=')7?'D72P*.?T.'F)=.'Q/20')'W./A'?6W./=.'T/2;9'2Q'67?6W6?;)*=H'-<6='.75./9/6=.'P6**'/.*A'27'F25<'5<.'5.4<764)*'=D6**='2Q'W)/62;='5A9.='2Q'.7T67../=')7?'=46.756=5=I')='P.**')='5<.'F;=67.==')7?'.4272064='=D6**='2Q'=5;?.75='Q/20'5<.'E4<22*'2Q'C;=67.==I'9;F*64'92*64A'=D6**='Q/20'5<.'E246)*'E46.74.='G.9)/50.75I'4200;764)5627'=D6**='Q/20'5<.'E46.756Q64')7?'-.4<764)*'R200;764)5627='9/2T/)0=I')7?')7A'25<./'675./.=5.?'9)/56.='725'0.75627.?'67'5<6='=<2/5I'674209*.5.'*6=5H'-<6='.75./9/6=.'=<2;*?'5/;*A'F.')**'.74209)==67T'2Q'5<.'?6W./=.')7?'W)/6.?'=D6**'=.5='2Q'@-['=5;?.75=H':7'6?.)*'7;0F./'2Q'=5;?.75='52'T.5'5<.'.75./9/6=.'/2**67T'67'65='Q6/=5')456W.'=.0.=5./'P2;*?'F.')99/2d60)5.*A'lZM&'?.?64)5.?')7?'9)==627)5.'=5;?.75=H''

'

'

'

))))

Page 11: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

='0,0$#<)'

/&#+) @1<&)

M'R209;5./' m+I&&&''

-/)W.*' mM+I&&&''

@6=4H'!S;690.75'X-CGY' mM&I&&&''

R200;764)5627=' mM&I&&&''

-.=5'C.?='Q2/'E2*;5627=' mM$I&&&''

1/2Q.==627)*'G.W.*290.75' m+I&&&''

-25)*' m$MI&&&''

'

:='*6=5.?'9/.W62;=*A';7?./'925.756)*'Q;7?67T'5<./.'6='5<.'92==6F6*65A'2Q'Q;7?67T'Q/20'P65<67'@-['5</2;T<'5<.'W)/62;='.d6=567T'4)09;='2/T)76])5627='/.*)5.?'52'=;=5)67)F6*65A'9/23.45=H'V5'0)A'F.'92==6F*.'Q2/'5<.'.75./9/6=.'52')4S;6/.'?.9)/50.75)*'Q;7?67T'6Q'4275/)45.?'FA')'=9.46Q64'?.9)/50.75'52'67W.=56T)5.')'=9.46Q64'9/2F*.0')/.)H'

'

@1+9%&'0D),02)*9,$#)@10<'2#-,&'10<))-<.' 4209;567T')7?' =9)4.'7..?='2Q' 5<.'RE!'P6**' *6D.*A'F.' /)5<./' *6065.?' 67' 65=' Q6/=5' A.)/'2Q'29./)5627=H'@2=5'2Q' 5<.'P2/D'P6**'F.'4.75./.?'27'4209;5./'02?.*67T' 5</2;T<' 5<.'R:ZR1'.06==627=' 522*'2/'25<./'4209)/)F*.' =2Q5P)/.I' F/)67=52/067T' =2*;5627=I' F.7.Q65Z42=5' /)562' )7)*A=6=' 2Q' 9/292=.?' =2*;5627=I' *6Q.'4A4*.')7)*A=6=I')7?'609*.0.75)5627'2Q'5<.'?.W.*29.?'=2*;5627H'e7.'1R'67')'=0)**'52'0.?6;0'=6].?'2QQ64.'2/'P2/D'=5)5627'.7W6/270.75'=<2;*?'=;QQ64.'Q2/'5<.'67656)*'7..?='2Q'5<.'RE!H':7A'7.4.==)/A'F.74<'*.W.*'5.=567T'4)7'*6D.*A'F.'4)//6.?'2;5'67'27.'2Q'5<.'*)F='2/'=<29='2Q'5<.'<20.'?.9)/50.75H'V5'P6**')*=2'F.'92==6F*.'Q2/'5<.'RE!'5.)0'0.0F./='52';56*6].'5<.6/'<20.'?.9)/50.75'4209;567T'Q)46*656.='?;/67T'560.='P<.7'5<.'RE!'2QQ64.'1R'6='F.67T';=.?'2/'P<.7')??65627)*'4209;567T'4)9)465A'6='7..?.?H''

C)=.?';927'5<.'=;44.==')7?'.d9)7=627'2Q'5<.'.75./9/6=.'65'0)A'F.'7.4.==)/A'Q2/'5<.'RE!'52'02W.'6752'*)/T./'S;)/5./='=20.560.'67'5<.'Q;5;/.H':5'5<)5'560.'65'P2;*?'F.'7.4.==)/A'52'=9.)D'P65<'5<.'<20.'?.9)/50.75'2Q'5<.'.75./9/6=.'52'*22D')5'92==6F*.'=2*;5627=')7?'295627='P65<67'5<)5'?.9)/50.75H':725<./'=2*;5627'P2;*?'F.'52'P2/D'P65<'5<.'.75./9/6=.'9/2T/)0'?6/.452/'52'Q67?')7'295627'<2;=.?'P65<67'5<.'.75./9/6=.'9/2T/)0')7?'4275/2**.?'F;6*?67T=')7?'/220=H''

'

Page 12: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

'

!0&#-9-'<#);155I1%&))V7' 2/?./' 52' T.5' 5<.' RE!' ;9' )7?' /;7767T' 67' ()**' +&&gI' =.W./)*' 5<67T=' P6**' F.' 4209*.5.?' 67' 5<.' E9/67T'=.0.=5./' 2Q' +&&gH' e7.' 2Q' 5<.' Q6/=5' 5<67T=' 5<)5' P6**' F.' )44209*6=<.?' 6=' 5<.' ?.W.*290.75' 2Q' 5<.' RE!'.?;4)5627)*'4;//64;*;0')7?'*.)?./=<69'<6./)/4<AH'E5;?.75='P6**'F.'<6/.?'Q2/'5<.'E9/67T'=.0.=5./I'P65<')7'2/6.75)5627'52'5<.'RE!'52'F.'=4<.?;*.?'Q2/'5<6='Q6/=5'T/2;9'2Q'=5;?.75=I'5<6='2/6.75)5627'P6**'9/2W6?.'5<.'2992/5;765A'52'=9*65'5<.'=5;?.75=';9'6752'T/2;9=')7?'5.)0=H'e74.'5<6='6='?27.'5<.'=5;?.75='P6**'F.'5)=D.?'P65<'Q6/=5'42**.4567T'5<.'7.4.==)/A'?)5)'67'2/?./'52'4209*.5.'5<.'R:ZR1'02?.*H'\<.7'5<.'02?.*'<)='F..7'4209*.5.?'5<.'02?.*'P6**'F.'/.W6.P.?'52'*22D'Q2/')/.)='Q2/'P<64<'65'4)7'F.'609/2W.?')7?'/.Q67.?H'\65<'5<6=' 609/2W.?' )7?' /.Q67.?'02?.*' 5<.' =5;?.75='P6**' 5<.7' 427?;45' )' =.7=656W65A' )7)*A=6=I' 5<6=' =.7=656W65A')7)*A=6='P6**'F.'5<.'F)=6=' Q2/'P<64<'4)/F27'/.?;45627'9/23.45='0)A'F.' 6?.756Q6.?H'-<.'9/23.45='5<)5')/.'?.Q67.?' Q2/' 5<.' 4)/F27' Q2259/675' /.?;45627'P6**' 5<.7' F.' 2;5*67.?' )*27T'P65<' 92==6F*.' )*5./7)56W.=H' ' :'5.75)56W.'#)755'4<)/5%'Q2/'5<.'RE!'42W./67T'5<.'7.d5'A.)/')7?')'<)*Q'<)='F..7'?.W.*29.?'P65<'02=5'5)=D='2Q'5<.'RE!'F.67T'2;5*67.?H''

'

'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''%'-.75)56W.'#)755'R<)/5''':99.7?6d'C

Page 13: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

)

899#02'")C)A)!0&#-9-'<#)H-D,0'J,&'10,5)@:,-&)

)

)

)

)

Page 14: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

!"#$%&'(&)*+),+-)."#/+

!"#$%&'()(*+,$'(&-(.+/(!"#$%&'0(1&,'"2(

3+$%(4/'%&5(6$77(8/(.+/(4/'%&5($5(9+,':/(&-(.+/(/5./'4'$%/(,5"('/%4&5%$87/(-&'(.+/(:'&;4<(3+/0(6$77(8/('/%4&5%$87/(-&'(.+/(,%%$:5$5:(&-(:',"/%(,5"(&.+/'(&--$9$,7(;5$#/'%$.0('/%4&5%$8$7$.$/%<(3+/0(%+&;7"(%//=(.&(,"#$%/(,5"(:;$"/(.+/(:'&;4(,5"(&#/'%//(.+/(4'/%$"/5.<(3+/0(6$77(,7%&(9+,$'(,5"(7/,"(.+/(,"#$%&'0(8&,'"(,5"("$'/9.(.+/>(,%(.&(.+/$'('&7/%(,5"('/%4&5%$8$7$.$/%<(

012&#)%3+4)5%1/+

3+$%(8&,'"(6$77(9&5%$%.(&-(-,9;7.0($5(.+/('/?;$'/"(,'/,(%4/9$,7.$/%<(3+/(5//"/"(,"#$%&'%(>,0(9+,5:/(8,%/"(&5(.+/(9;''/5.(4'&@/9.(.04/%(8;.(6$77(7$=/70($597;"/(,(-,9;7.0(%4/9$,7$A$5:($5(9&%.(8/5/-$.(,5,70%$%B(9&5%.';9.$&5(>,./'$,7%B(9,'8&5(9097$5:B(,5"C&'(/5#$'&5>/5.,7(/9&7&:0<(3+$%(./,>(%+&;7"(%/'#/(,%(,('/-/'/59/(.&(.+/(/5./'4'$%/(,5"(47,0(5&("$'/9.('&7/($5(.+/(9&5.'&7(&'(&':,5$A,.$&5(&-(.+/(/5./'4'$%/<(

6*("%'%&#"+7%"#&1"*(/+

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

((

87+),+9&*5*$"/+

3+/(IJ(&-(-$5,59/(6$77(8/($5(9+,':/(&-(,77($%%;/%('/7,./"(.&(8;":/.B(,99&;5.$5:B(-;5"K',$%$5:(-&'(.+/(/5./'4'$%/B(,5"(.+/($%%;$5:(&-(-;5"%(,%(5//"/"(-&'(/5./'4'$%/('/7,./"(4;'9+,%/%<(3+/(IJ(&-(F$5,59/(6$77(6&'=(6$.+(.+/(*&>>;5$9,.$&5%(3/,>(.&($"/5.$-0B(.,':/.B(,5"(&8.,$5(4'&@/9.(&'(/5./'4'$%/(%4&5%&'%(,5"(%,7/%<((

9&*5*$"+:"5;/+

L;44&'.(.+/('&7/(&-(IJ(&-(F$5,59/<(

87+),+<);;=*&$5(&)*#/+

3+/(IJ(&-(*&>>;5$9,.$&5%(6$77(8/($5(9+,':/(&-(,5"('/%4&5%$87/(-&'(,77(,9.$#$.$/%('/7,.$5:(.&(.+/(9&>>;5$9,.$&5%(./,><(3+/(9&>>;5$9,.$&5%(./,>(6$77(8/('/%4&5%$87/(-&'(>,$5.,$5$5:(%;9+(9&>>;5$9,.$&5(,%%/.%(,%(.+/(/5./'4'$%/(6/8%$./B(-.4(%.&',:/B(/5./'4'$%/(7$%.(%/'#/B(/5./'4'$%/(

Page 15: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

4;87$9,.$&5%B(&.+/'(>/"$,(.&(8/("/./'>$5/"(,5"(/--/9.$#/70(9&>>;5$9,.$5:(.+/(5//"%(,5"(,99&>47$%+>/5.%(&-(.+/(/5./'4'$%/<(3+/(9&>>;5$9,.$&5%(./,>(6$77(,7%&(7/,"(&5(9,>4;%('/9';$.>/5.(/--&'.%<(3+/(*&>>;5$9,.$&5%(3/,>(6$77(6&'=(6$.+(.+/(F$5,59/(3/,>(,5"(MCN(./,>(.&(&8.,$5(/5./'4'$%/(,5"(4'&@/9.(%4&5%&'%(,5"(%,7/%<((3+/(IJ(6$77(,7%&(8/(/G4/9./"(.&(,9.(,%(,(6&'=$5:(>/>8/'(&-(.+/(9&>>;5$9,.$&5%(./,><(

:>"+<);;=*&$5(&)*#+("5;/+

L;44&'.(.+/('&7/(&-(IJ(&-(*&>>;5$9,.$&5%<(

87+),+!"#&?*+5*1+@;'.";"*(5(&)*/+

3+/(I$9/(J'/%$"/5.(-&'(M/%$:5(,5"(N>47/>/5.,.$&5(6$77(7/,"(.+/(/--&'.(.&("/%$:5(,5"($>47/>/5.(9,'8&5K'/";9.$&5(./9+5&7&:0(&'(4&7$90(%&7;.$&5%(&5(.+/(O3P(9,>4;%<((3+/(MCN(3/,>(6$77(6&'=(6$.+(.+/(O&"/7$5:(3/,>(.&($"/5.$-0(4&./5.$,7(4'&@/9.%B(,5"(.+/5(6$77(&':,5$A/(J'&@/9.(H/,"/'%(,5"(J'&@/9.(3/,>%(.&("/#/7&4B(./%.(,5"($>47/>/5.(%&7;.$&5%<(QN.(6&;7"(8/(7$=/70(.+/(IJ(&-(MCN(6&;7"(6&'=(,%(,(4'&@/9.(./,>(>/>8/'(,%(6/77($-(5/9/%%,'0(.&(-$77(.+/$'(.$>/R(

!A@+("5;#+B7%)C"$(+("5;#D/+

L;44&'.(.+/('&7/(&-(IJ(&-(M/%$:5(,5"(N>47/>/5.,.$&5(

87+),+6$)*);&$+E+F=#(5&*5G&.&(3+0*5.3#&#/+

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

6$)*);&$+0*5.3#&#+:"5;/+

L;44&'.(.+/('&7/(&-(IJ(&-(S9&5&>$9(!5,70%$%<(

87+),+H)1".&*?/+

3+/(I$9/(J'/%$"/5.(-&'(O&"/7$5:(6$77(8/($5(9+,':/(&-(",.,(9&77/9.$&5B(>&"/7$5:B(>&"/7(%/5%$.$#$.0(,5,70%$%B(,5"(>&"/7($>4'&#/>/5.B('/-$5/>/5.(,5"("/#/7&4>/5.<((3+/(IJ(-&'(O&"/7$5:(6$77(6&'=(6$.+(.+/(IJ(-&'(M/%$:5(,5"(N>47/>/5.,.$&5(.&($"/5.$-0(4&./5.$,7(9,'8&5K'/";9.$&5(4'&@/9.%<(

(

Page 16: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

)

899#02'")@)A)E*)3-1B#$&)F,0&&)@:,-&)

Page 17: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

ID Task Name Duration Start Finish Predecessors

1 Enterprise Organization 172 days? Mon 1/14/08 Tue 9/9/082 Spring 2008 semester starts 0 days Mon 1/14/08 Mon 1/14/08

3 Develop CSE educational curriculum 5 days? Tue 1/15/08 Mon 1/21/08 2

4 Organize CSE leadership 1 day? Wed 1/16/08 Wed 1/16/08 2

5 Schedule the orientation for all enterprise members 3 days? Thu 9/4/08 Mon 9/8/08 22

6 Orientation of first registered student group 1 day? Tue 9/9/08 Tue 9/9/08 5

7 Organization of first registered students into groups and teams 1 day? Tue 9/9/08 Tue 9/9/08 6SS

8 Commence full and official operations of CSE 0 days Tue 9/9/08 Tue 9/9/08 7

9 Enterprise Work 337 days? Thu 1/17/08 Fri 5/1/0910 Complete preliminary data collection for Clean air-Cool Planet (CA-CP) model 14 days? Thu 1/17/08 Tue 2/5/08 4

11 Identify improvements and refinments for CA-CP model 16 days? Wed 2/6/08 Wed 2/27/08 10

12 Implement improvements and refinments for CA-CP model 6 days? Thu 2/28/08 Thu 3/6/08 11

13 Model complete 0 days Thu 3/6/08 Thu 3/6/08 12

14 Perform sensitivity analysis on CA-CP model results 21 days? Fri 3/7/08 Fri 4/4/08 13

15 Identify carbon reduction projects 7 days? Mon 4/7/08 Tue 4/15/08 14

16 Outline carbon reduction projects 5 days? Wed 4/16/08 Tue 4/22/08 15

17 Outline project alternatives 5 days? Wed 4/16/08 Tue 4/22/08 16SS

18 End of spring 2008 semester wrap up 8 days? Wed 4/23/08 Fri 5/2/08 46,17,16

19 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Initial 1 day? Thu 4/24/08 Thu 4/24/08 17

20 Spring 2008 semester ends 0 days Fri 5/2/08 Fri 5/2/08 18,19

21 Performe work over summer 2007 semester as able 70 days? Mon 5/12/08 Fri 8/15/08 20

22 Fall 2008 semester starts 0 days Tue 9/2/08 Tue 9/2/08 21

23 Perform economic and sustainability analysis of proposed projects & solutions 23 days? Wed 9/10/08 Fri 10/10/08 8

24 Choose project and solution method for reduction project 3 days? Mon 10/13/08 Wed 10/15/08 23

25 Project and Solution chosen 0 days Wed 10/15/08 Wed 10/15/08 24

26 Engineering design work of project solutions 37 days? Thu 10/16/08 Fri 12/5/08 25

27 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Mid 1 day? Mon 12/8/08 Mon 12/8/08 26

28 End of fall 2008 semester wrap up 6 days? Tue 12/9/08 Tue 12/16/08 27

29 Fall 2008 semester ends 0 days Fri 12/19/08 Fri 12/19/08 28

30 Spring 2009 semester starts 0 days Mon 1/12/09 Mon 1/12/09 29

31 Engineering bench level testing of developed project solutions 15 days? Mon 1/12/09 Fri 1/30/09 30

32 Implement project solution in test bed environment 21 days? Mon 2/2/09 Mon 3/2/09 31

33 Decide to procede with full scale implementation 4 days? Tue 3/3/09 Fri 3/6/09 32

34 Engineering work completed 0 days Fri 3/6/09 Fri 3/6/09 33

35 Implement full scale project solution 16 days? Mon 3/9/09 Mon 3/30/09 34

36 Monitor and track reuslts of implemented solution 13 days? Tue 3/31/09 Thu 4/16/09 35

37 Conclude result tracking 0 days Fri 4/17/09 Fri 4/17/09 36

38 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Final 1 day? Mon 4/20/09 Mon 4/20/09 37

39 Disseminate/Publish project results 5 days? Mon 4/20/09 Fri 4/24/09 38SS

40 End of spring 2009 wrap up 5 days? Mon 4/20/09 Fri 4/24/09 39SS

41 Spring 2009 semester ends 0 days Fri 5/1/09 Fri 5/1/09 40

42 Enterprise Financial Work 64 days? Tue 1/22/08 Fri 4/18/0843 Research funding opportunities 19 days? Tue 1/22/08 Fri 2/15/08 2

44 Identify funding opportunities 2 days? Mon 2/18/08 Tue 2/19/08 43

45 Write funding/grant proposals 38 days? Wed 2/20/08 Fri 4/11/08 44

46 Submitt funding and grant proposals 5 days? Mon 4/14/08 Fri 4/18/08 45

1/14

12/2 12/9 12/16 12/23 12/30 1/6 1/13 1/20 1/27ecember January Fe

Task

Split

Progress

Milestone

Summary

Project Summary

External Tasks

External Milestone

Deadline

Page 1

Project: CSE_initial_proposed_scheduDate: Fri 12/14/07

Page 18: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

ID Task Name

1 Enterprise Organization2 Spring 2008 semester starts

3 Develop CSE educational curriculum

4 Organize CSE leadership

5 Schedule the orientation for all enterprise members

6 Orientation of first registered student group

7 Organization of first registered students into groups and teams

8 Commence full and official operations of CSE

9 Enterprise Work10 Complete preliminary data collection for Clean air-Cool Planet (CA-CP) model

11 Identify improvements and refinments for CA-CP model

12 Implement improvements and refinments for CA-CP model

13 Model complete

14 Perform sensitivity analysis on CA-CP model results

15 Identify carbon reduction projects

16 Outline carbon reduction projects

17 Outline project alternatives

18 End of spring 2008 semester wrap up

19 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Initial

20 Spring 2008 semester ends

21 Performe work over summer 2007 semester as able

22 Fall 2008 semester starts

23 Perform economic and sustainability analysis of proposed projects & solutions

24 Choose project and solution method for reduction project

25 Project and Solution chosen

26 Engineering design work of project solutions

27 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Mid

28 End of fall 2008 semester wrap up

29 Fall 2008 semester ends

30 Spring 2009 semester starts

31 Engineering bench level testing of developed project solutions

32 Implement project solution in test bed environment

33 Decide to procede with full scale implementation

34 Engineering work completed

35 Implement full scale project solution

36 Monitor and track reuslts of implemented solution

37 Conclude result tracking

38 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Final

39 Disseminate/Publish project results

40 End of spring 2009 wrap up

41 Spring 2009 semester ends

42 Enterprise Financial Work43 Research funding opportunities

44 Identify funding opportunities

45 Write funding/grant proposals

46 Submitt funding and grant proposals

3/6

5/2

2/3 2/10 2/17 2/24 3/2 3/9 3/16 3/23 3/30 4/6 4/13 4/20 4/27 5/4 5/11 5/18 5/25bruary March April May

Task

Split

Progress

Milestone

Summary

Project Summary

External Tasks

External Milestone

Deadline

Page 2

Project: CSE_initial_proposed_scheduDate: Fri 12/14/07

Page 19: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

ID Task Name

1 Enterprise Organization2 Spring 2008 semester starts

3 Develop CSE educational curriculum

4 Organize CSE leadership

5 Schedule the orientation for all enterprise members

6 Orientation of first registered student group

7 Organization of first registered students into groups and teams

8 Commence full and official operations of CSE

9 Enterprise Work10 Complete preliminary data collection for Clean air-Cool Planet (CA-CP) model

11 Identify improvements and refinments for CA-CP model

12 Implement improvements and refinments for CA-CP model

13 Model complete

14 Perform sensitivity analysis on CA-CP model results

15 Identify carbon reduction projects

16 Outline carbon reduction projects

17 Outline project alternatives

18 End of spring 2008 semester wrap up

19 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Initial

20 Spring 2008 semester ends

21 Performe work over summer 2007 semester as able

22 Fall 2008 semester starts

23 Perform economic and sustainability analysis of proposed projects & solutions

24 Choose project and solution method for reduction project

25 Project and Solution chosen

26 Engineering design work of project solutions

27 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Mid

28 End of fall 2008 semester wrap up

29 Fall 2008 semester ends

30 Spring 2009 semester starts

31 Engineering bench level testing of developed project solutions

32 Implement project solution in test bed environment

33 Decide to procede with full scale implementation

34 Engineering work completed

35 Implement full scale project solution

36 Monitor and track reuslts of implemented solution

37 Conclude result tracking

38 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Final

39 Disseminate/Publish project results

40 End of spring 2009 wrap up

41 Spring 2009 semester ends

42 Enterprise Financial Work43 Research funding opportunities

44 Identify funding opportunities

45 Write funding/grant proposals

46 Submitt funding and grant proposals

9/9

9/2

6/1 6/8 6/15 6/22 6/29 7/6 7/13 7/20 7/27 8/3 8/10 8/17 8/24 8/31 9/7 9/14 9/21June July August September

Task

Split

Progress

Milestone

Summary

Project Summary

External Tasks

External Milestone

Deadline

Page 3

Project: CSE_initial_proposed_scheduDate: Fri 12/14/07

Page 20: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

ID Task Name

1 Enterprise Organization2 Spring 2008 semester starts

3 Develop CSE educational curriculum

4 Organize CSE leadership

5 Schedule the orientation for all enterprise members

6 Orientation of first registered student group

7 Organization of first registered students into groups and teams

8 Commence full and official operations of CSE

9 Enterprise Work10 Complete preliminary data collection for Clean air-Cool Planet (CA-CP) model

11 Identify improvements and refinments for CA-CP model

12 Implement improvements and refinments for CA-CP model

13 Model complete

14 Perform sensitivity analysis on CA-CP model results

15 Identify carbon reduction projects

16 Outline carbon reduction projects

17 Outline project alternatives

18 End of spring 2008 semester wrap up

19 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Initial

20 Spring 2008 semester ends

21 Performe work over summer 2007 semester as able

22 Fall 2008 semester starts

23 Perform economic and sustainability analysis of proposed projects & solutions

24 Choose project and solution method for reduction project

25 Project and Solution chosen

26 Engineering design work of project solutions

27 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Mid

28 End of fall 2008 semester wrap up

29 Fall 2008 semester ends

30 Spring 2009 semester starts

31 Engineering bench level testing of developed project solutions

32 Implement project solution in test bed environment

33 Decide to procede with full scale implementation

34 Engineering work completed

35 Implement full scale project solution

36 Monitor and track reuslts of implemented solution

37 Conclude result tracking

38 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Final

39 Disseminate/Publish project results

40 End of spring 2009 wrap up

41 Spring 2009 semester ends

42 Enterprise Financial Work43 Research funding opportunities

44 Identify funding opportunities

45 Write funding/grant proposals

46 Submitt funding and grant proposals

10/15

12/191/12

9/28 10/5 10/12 10/19 10/26 11/2 11/9 11/16 11/23 11/30 12/7 12/14 12/21 12/28 1/4 1/11 1/18October November December January

Task

Split

Progress

Milestone

Summary

Project Summary

External Tasks

External Milestone

Deadline

Page 4

Project: CSE_initial_proposed_scheduDate: Fri 12/14/07

Page 21: 0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)pages.mtu.edu/~jwsuther/colloquium/manty_marcinak_final.pdf0’1/23.45’(67)*’8.92/5 ’ :;5’:?)0’@)75A’B’C6**’@)

ID Task Name

1 Enterprise Organization2 Spring 2008 semester starts

3 Develop CSE educational curriculum

4 Organize CSE leadership

5 Schedule the orientation for all enterprise members

6 Orientation of first registered student group

7 Organization of first registered students into groups and teams

8 Commence full and official operations of CSE

9 Enterprise Work10 Complete preliminary data collection for Clean air-Cool Planet (CA-CP) model

11 Identify improvements and refinments for CA-CP model

12 Implement improvements and refinments for CA-CP model

13 Model complete

14 Perform sensitivity analysis on CA-CP model results

15 Identify carbon reduction projects

16 Outline carbon reduction projects

17 Outline project alternatives

18 End of spring 2008 semester wrap up

19 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Initial

20 Spring 2008 semester ends

21 Performe work over summer 2007 semester as able

22 Fall 2008 semester starts

23 Perform economic and sustainability analysis of proposed projects & solutions

24 Choose project and solution method for reduction project

25 Project and Solution chosen

26 Engineering design work of project solutions

27 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Mid

28 End of fall 2008 semester wrap up

29 Fall 2008 semester ends

30 Spring 2009 semester starts

31 Engineering bench level testing of developed project solutions

32 Implement project solution in test bed environment

33 Decide to procede with full scale implementation

34 Engineering work completed

35 Implement full scale project solution

36 Monitor and track reuslts of implemented solution

37 Conclude result tracking

38 Report on progress to client (AQIP) - Final

39 Disseminate/Publish project results

40 End of spring 2009 wrap up

41 Spring 2009 semester ends

42 Enterprise Financial Work43 Research funding opportunities

44 Identify funding opportunities

45 Write funding/grant proposals

46 Submitt funding and grant proposals

3/6

4/17

5/1

1/25 2/1 2/8 2/15 2/22 3/1 3/8 3/15 3/22 3/29 4/5 4/12 4/19 4/26 5/3 5/10 5/17February March April May

Task

Split

Progress

Milestone

Summary

Project Summary

External Tasks

External Milestone

Deadline

Page 5

Project: CSE_initial_proposed_scheduDate: Fri 12/14/07