7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
1/59
Fordham International Law Journal
Volume 32, Issue 6 2008 Article 6
The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South
Ossetia: Deciding the Question of
Independence on the Merits and International
Law
Ronald Thomas
Copyright c2008 by the authors. Fordham International Law Journal is produced by The Berke-
ley Electronic Press (bepress). http://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/ilj
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
2/59
The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South
Ossetia: Deciding the Question of
Independence on the Merits and International
Law
Ronald Thomas
Abstract
The cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia provide two opportunities for the community of na-
tions to reconcile the rights of Serbia and Georgia with the rights of the peoples within their
borders. Instead of doing so, other countries used these cases for ideological and political postur-
ing and continued to do so as of the end of 2008. This Note will review Kosovo and South Ossetia
and attempt to take the politics out of an inherently political decision-whether or not to recognize
them as independent states. Part I of this Note will review how the United Nations has approached
the issues of autonomy, borders, secession, and minorities. It will also provide background on
the doctrines of self-determination and the rights of states. Part II will set out the facts-as they
are generally accepted-of Kosovo and South Ossetia and consider the differing opinions regard-
ing independence of the two areas. Part III will review those opinions in light of the goals and
doctrines of the United Nations and how it has approached these issues in the past. The Note con-
cludes that recognition of independence of the states should be driven by legal arguments ratherthan political or social alliances and that the goals of the United Nations are best served by being
steadfast in promoting multi-ethnicity within political entities; Kosovo and South Ossetia should
be recognized as autonomous regions within Serbia and Georgia, respectively. The Note also con-
cludes that domestic as well as international legal structures must be in place to make autonomy
workable.
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
3/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
4/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
5/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
6/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
7/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
8/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
9/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
10/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
11/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
12/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
13/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
14/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
15/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
16/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
17/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
18/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
19/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
20/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
21/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
22/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
23/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
24/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
25/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
26/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
27/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
28/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
29/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
30/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
31/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
32/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
33/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
34/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
35/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
36/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
37/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
38/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
39/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
40/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
41/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
42/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
43/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
44/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
45/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
46/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
47/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
48/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
49/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
50/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
51/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
52/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
53/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
54/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
55/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
56/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
57/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
58/59
7/31/2019 The Distinct Cases of Kosovo and South Ossetia
59/59
Top Related