Download - Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Transcript
Page 1: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Sustainable power zoning code amendments

Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts

Planning Commission

Sept. 22, 2017

Page 2: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Introduction

– History of wind turbine permitting in Saint Paul

– Types of wind turbines

– Research

– Impact

– Applications

– Examples

– Recommendation

– Questions

Page 3: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

History

– Approval of determination of similar use – Macalester College, 2002

– Approval of determination of similar use – 1010 N. Dale, 2011

– Denial of determination of similar use – Metropolitan State, 2012

– City council decision upon neighborhood appeal of Planning Commission decision

Page 4: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Types of wind turbines

Vertical axis wind turbines

Horizontal axis wind turbines

Page 5: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Research

– Practical applications

– Land use impacts

– Other cities

– Code considerations

Page 6: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Recommendation

– Wind energy regulated as an accessory use

– As are solar installations

– Understood to be permitted in all districts

– Standards/conditions express where/how

– Not listed in a use table – convention has been to list accessory uses in use tables only when they are exceptions

– Regulated similar to surrounding communities

– Code language allows for changes in technology

Page 7: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Residential roof-mounted systems 500W wind turbines

Page 8: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Residential roof-mounted systems 500W wind turbines

Page 9: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

9th Street Lofts 4kW wind turbines

Page 10: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

CHS Field 4kW wind turbines

Page 11: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

CHS Field 4kW wind turbines

Page 12: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Hybrid lamppost 300w (shown at West Side Flats)

Page 13: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Hybrid lamppost 300w (shown at West Side Flats)

Page 14: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Capitol Lien 1010 N. Dale

1.5 kW roof-mounted

3 kW free-standing

Existing determination of similar use approved in 2011.

Page 15: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Capitol Lien 1010 N. Dale

1.5 kW roof-mounted

3 kW free-standing

Existing determination of similar use approved in 2011.

Page 16: Sustainable power zoning code amendments Root/Planning & Economic Development...power zoning code amendments Recommended changes to allow for wind energy systems in all districts .

Questions

Jake Reilly

Senior City Planner

651-266-6618

[email protected]