September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 1
A preface to the political theory of A preface to the political theory of economic organizationeconomic organization
Positive and normative perspectives on corporate governancePositive and normative perspectives on corporate governance
J. (Hans) van OosterhoutRSM Erasmus University
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 2
Intro and agendaIntro and agenda
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 3
Intro and PreliminariesIntro and Preliminaries
• Associate professor, Department Business Society
Management, RSM Erasmus University
• Research interests:
– positive and normative theory of institutions and organizations
– comparative economic and political organization
– corporate governance
– corporate governance and corporate crime
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 4
AgendaAgenda
• Observations, diagnosis and proposal
• Basic framework for a political theory of
economic organization
• Applications
• Discussion
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 5
Observations, diagnosis and proposalObservations, diagnosis and proposal
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 6
Some observationsSome observations• Economic organization does not exist in societal vacuum
• Features of private enterprise organization at least partly
explained by (lack of) public and societal features
(institutions)
• Business has significant social side effects
• Corporations—and other business organizations—
‘naturally’ have ‘non-business’ functions, tasks and
features
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 7
My diagnosisMy diagnosis
• Dominant concepts and theories:
– Corporate Social Responsibility
– Stakeholder theory
– Corporate Citizenship
• Metaphorical rather than conceptual
• Lack of ‘theoretical’ and empirical content?
• Ideology?
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 8
My proposalMy proposal• Lets forget about these ‘concepts’ and ‘theories’
• Develop comprehensive conceptual framework to
answer the questions:
1. what explains the division of labor between
– markets and hierarchies
– public and private institutions in a globalizing economic order ?
2. what division of labor is desirable or justified?
3. what are the implications of 1 & 2 for corporate governance
more specifically?
• A political theory of economic organization
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 9
Why a Why a politicalpolitical theory? theory?• Concern with basic institutional order (facilitating human
coordination and cooperation)
– Polity: e.g. property rights, market vs. hierarchy
– Policy: what is the purpose of the firm?
• Both efficiency and legitimacy count in economic organization
• Methodological ecumenism
– positive and normative theory building
– conceptual and empirical research
– different levels of analysis
– behaviorism and phenomenology
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 10
The basic frameworkThe basic framework
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 11
Theoretical core propositionsTheoretical core propositions
1. Both states and firms are authority systems
(conceptual claim);
2. predicate on a similar general justificatory logic
(normative claim), yet;
3. they are different in terms of the specific conditions
and considerations that justify authority in each
(positive claim).
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 12
Two kinds of authority?Two kinds of authority?
PA
Ci Ci Ci
The State
Ow
Ma
Em
The public firm
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 13
A Hobessian view of corporate authorityA Hobessian view of corporate authority
PA
Ci Ci Ci
The State
Ow
Ma
Em
The public firm
?
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 14
PerspectivePerspective1. Corporate authority best seen as a continuation of
public authority by private means
• Adjudicative: ex post division of quasi rents
• Legislative: re-assignment of property rights
2. Embedded or federal structure of authority in society
3. What determines division of labor between levels?
• Competition: markets and jurisdictional competition
• Politics: the quest for legitimacy
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 15
ApplicationsApplications
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 16
4 applications, 1 example4 applications, 1 example
1. Political theory of enterprise organization
2. A theory of corporate purpose
3. Economic democracy?
• Workplace democracy?
• Shareholderdemocracy?
4. Corporate crime (and social cost)
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 17
Corporate crimeCorporate crime
• Certain crimes have a corporate dimension
• The problem of ‘many hands’
• Two gaps:
– retribution gap
– deterrence gap
• Corporate criminal liability (CCL)?
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 18
CCL in the USCCL in the US
• Extension of tort doctrine ‘respondeat superior’
• Corporations vicariously liable for the actions of their employees
when these:
– take place within normal scope of employment
– benefit the firm
• Economic rationale: firms more efficient monitors than public law
enforcement agencies (compare business judgment rule)
• Extra-territorial reach of CCL (e.g. SOx 2002, SEC rules)
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 19
Corporate policingCorporate policing
• FSG for Organizational Defendants
• Both ex ante prevention and ex post offence
cooperation pay! (reduction of fine)
– ex ante ethics programs, compliance officers
– ex post cooperation with prosecutors
• Strategic risk and blame shifting (scapegoating)
• Hence: corporate policing
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 20
Corporate policing and corporate governanceCorporate policing and corporate governance
• Corporate policing = private extension of public law enforcement
• Renegotiation of ‘the corporate contract’?
• Multilevel negotiations (beyond corporate constituencies)
– high or asymmetrical bargaining costs?
– Is competition on safeguards desirable?
– Jurisdictional issues (e.g. unlimited shareholder liability for corporate torts and
crimes?
• Both efficiency and other (e.g. retributivist, restorative justice)
considerations count in negotiating mutual safeguards
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 21
DiscussionDiscussion
September 16th 2005 ICCSR - Business Government and CSR 22
Conceptual progress?Conceptual progress?• Conceptual and theoretical clarity (more established concepts and
theories)
• Explanatory surplus
• Comprehensive perspective on corporate governance
– multilevel analysis (regimes)
– public and private ordering
– normative and positive analysis
– not just efficiency
• Separation of positive and normative claims
Top Related