7/29/2019 Revisiting the Age Old Case of Diagnostic Confusion
1/4
Revisiting the Age Old Case of Diagnostic Confusion: Sociopath vs. Psychopath
by Daniel Linder
As Robert Hare had indicated in an article written in 1996, "The distinction between
psychopathy and anti-social personality disorders is of considerable significance to
the mental health and criminal justice systems. Unfortunately, it is a distinction that is
often blurred, not only in the minds of many clinicians but in the latest edition ofDSM-IV."
The DSM-IV has both disorders; psychopath and sociopath lumped together under
301.7: Antisocial Personality.
There is a pervasive pattern of disregard for and violation of the rights of others
occurring since the age 15 years, as indicated by three (or more of the following:
1-failure to conform to social norms with respect to lawful behaviors as indicated by
repeatedly performing acts that are grounds for arrest
2-deceitfulness, as indicated by repeated lying, use of aliases, or conning others for
personal profit or pleasure3-impulsivity or failure to plan ahead
4-irritability and aggressiveness, as indicated by repeated physical fights or assaults
5-reckless disregard for safety of self or others
6-consistent irresponsibility, as indicated by repeated failure to sustain consistent
work behavior or honor financial obligations
While the DSM's diagnostic criteria are accurate and valid to the extent that they
apply to both psychopathy and sociopathy, the failure to not provide additional
criteria that would enable the clinician to more clearly distinguish between the two
has unfortunate treatment implications.
There is obviously some overlap. For both sociopath and psychopath, lack of remorse,
being extremely dangerous, deep, longstanding and pervasive characterological
disturbance, significant family of origin dysfunction, an extremely poor prognosis,
living on the fringes, alienated existences apply.
However, they are quite divergent in a number of ways. Let's think in terms of general
tendencies like appearance, socio-economic status, level of intelligence and education,
modus operandi, motivation and criminal history.
Appearance
A sociopath (ASPD) is known to appear as if it is immediatly apparent that he is
either in some kind of trouble or he's about to make trouble for someone else. S/heappears to be a non-conformist or someone who was never able to conform. S/he
usually conjures up a 'tough guy' image that fits the DSM description, "failure to
conform to social norms with respect to lawful behaviors as indicated by repeatedly
performing acts that are grounds for arrest, irritability and aggressiveness, as indicated
by repeated physical fights or assaults." Chances are you would not be inclined to
trust this person.
The psychopath is known to appear to be just like anyone else. S/he could be you or
me. There are no distinguishing features that call attention to differences associated
with any kind of danger. His or her dress is conventional, business-like or casual.
Chances are, there would be no reason not to trust this person.
7/29/2019 Revisiting the Age Old Case of Diagnostic Confusion
2/4
Socio-economic status
Their disparate appearance tendencies have socio-economic implications. Sociopaths
generally appear 'rougher' looking or street-wise, perhaps more unkempt and as if they
come from blue-collar, poorer, disadvantaged backgrounds. They are more likely to
appear as if they live on the fringes of society.
We might think of the psychopath's general appearance, on the other hand, to beassociated with being more clean-cut, polished and a white-collar, middle-upper-class
background. It's more likely that psychopaths are working and not resorting to crime
to survive.
Level of intelligence and education
Continuing in an effort to flesh out sociological distinctions between the two, we may
also expect the sociopaths to be less educated because of their disadvantaged
background, and also be less verbal - having less command of the English language.
Having been raised in a poor, urban, drug-infested, gang and crime-ridden
environment is a far cry from what it's like in middle-upper class suburbia. Sociopaths
might also be less intelligent as measured by traditional intelligence testinginstruments.
Psychopaths, in contrast, are known to often present as articulate, charming and
charismatic.
Style/ Modus-operandi (MO)
There is a dramatic contrast between how the sociopath and psychopath operate in the
world. We often see the sociopath acting out in public with 'reckless disregard for
safety of self or others.' We can say the sociopath's anti-social behavior tends to be
overt, impulsive and without forethought.
The MO of the psychopath, on the other hand is much more covertly deceptive, and is
extremely calculated and sophisticated in his or her planning. S/he does not act
impulsively and carefully plans ahead as to who s/he will prey on, how s/he will go
about it and what they are going to do to the one preyed on.
Motivation
As previously stated, the sociopath's behavior is described as acting with blatant
disregard for who is around, overtly, impulsively, that is, without fore thought,
without remorse, in ways commonly associated with anti-social behavior. It is the way
they have learned to survive in the world. If they want something, they will just take
it. If they want sex, they will rape someone, someone easy or in close proximity. If
angry, they will become violent, they operate without any internal controls.As previously stated, the psychopath operates covertly, is careful and methodical and
selects his prey with an elaborate plan in mind. The psychopath's motivations appear
to be power driven. S/he gets off on control, manipulation, humiliation, and is a
master at reading and exploiting other people's vulnerability. Their crimes tend to be
more ritualistic and involve torture. Compared to sociopaths, psychopaths are masters
of deception while sociopaths are known to lack that kind of sophistication.
Criminal History
We'd expect sociopaths to have extensive criminal histories filled with assaults,
robberies, rapes and murders. The overwhelming majority has contributing
drug/alcohol problems, whether they are using, dealing or both. The sociopath'smodus operandi tends to be overt and care little about exposure.
7/29/2019 Revisiting the Age Old Case of Diagnostic Confusion
3/4
Psychopaths usually have shorter criminal records, as fewer people are aware of what
they are doing. Since their modus operandi is of a covert nature, it's less likely they'd
be arrested. They are not going to get caught as quickly. They operate covertly,
making sure they cannot be seen or exposed.
Are these distinctions adequate enough to make two separate diagnoses or are they tobe treated as two distinct disorders?
It would seem that there are profound treatment and diagnostic implications. While it
appears that there is some overlap, there are as many, if not more differences between
the two, that they are not one and the same.
As Hare stated, "An unfortunate consequence of the ambiguity inherent in the DSM-
IV is likely to be a court case in which one clinician says the defendant meets the
DSM-IV definition of ASPD, another clinician say he does not, and both are right!
The first clinician uses only the formal diagnostic criteria whereas the second agrees
that the defendant meets the formal criteria but argues that he or she dos not have thepersonality traits described in the 'Associated Features' section of the DSM-IV text.
The failure to differentiate between psychopathy and ASPD can have serious
consequences for clinicians, psychiatric patients and society as well."
"Perhaps this situation, an unfortunate and unnecessary one in my view, will be
rectified in the DSM-V. Meanwhile, it is worth noting that interpersonal and affective
traits are more discriminating of the construct of psychopathy than they are the
socially deviant behaviors reflected in the DSM-IV criteria for ASPD."(Cooke)
Psychopath
By Daniel Linder
In the mirror above the masses
Faces of predators mask
Diabolical malevolence
One driven by insatiable need
To exploit and humiliate
Seduce and trap
In his torture chamber
There's no escaping
His merciless snare
No defense againstAn unknown enemy.
Only the miracle of happenstance
Keeps this menace away.
A mutated soul
Allegedly a human being
Who can never change
Will never change enough
Can't rehabilitate
No chance for redemption
No room for risk
Or compromiseThe threat he poses
7/29/2019 Revisiting the Age Old Case of Diagnostic Confusion
4/4
Must be removed
He must be caught.
Taken away,
Be kept at bay
Locked away
Permanently and foreverOr be executed.
Top Related