The Future of Universities in Europe and
beyond
Stefano PaleariRector of the University of Bergamo
President of the Conference of Italian University Rectors (CRUI)
Pavia, 21 Aprile 2015
2015 Pavia PhD Workshop on:
«Perspectives for the European Universities:
the Role of PhD Research in Society»
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Agenda
• Be clear at the beginning
• Where we are: a call and a commitment
• Where we won to be
• Which model, which University
• A simple story: Higher Education in UK and in Italy
• A more general reflection
• What about the future of University:
o Key messages for policy makers… and questions
o Key messages and questions for universities
2
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Be clear at the beginning
• Universities need to adapt to the society they belong to
o Efficiency and sustainability are main issues
• In order to participate to the birth of a new university, we need
to acknowledge that we are in a context that has dramatically
changed in the last years
3
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Where we are: a call and a commitment
• A call to earth for our policy makers, for our colleagues and for
our mass media
• A commitment: if we don’t know we don’t talk
• We often use to talk about science without a scientific
approach
4
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
European Higher Education in a nutshell
State Total € 2014Share of
GDP 2013
Inflation adj var%
(2008-2014)
France 20.120** 0,99** +3,9**
Germany 26.800* 0,98* +23*
Netherlands 3.295 0,54* -0,6
Spain 7.405 0,73* -15
Italy 6.576 0,42* -21
5
Source: EUA public funding observatory.
*2013 (2014 n.a.) **2012 (2013 n.a.)
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Public budget breakdown of European countries
6
Data in % - Year 2011
General services Defence Public order
& safety Economy Environ. House Health Culture & entert. Education Welfare
Austria 13.1 1.4 2.9 10.5 1.0 1.2 15.3 2.0 11.0 41.6Belgium 15.0 1.8 3.4 12.3 1.4 0.7 14.8 2.4 11.6 36.6France 11.5 3.2 3.1 6.3 1.9 3.4 14.7 2.5 10.8 42.6Germany 13.6 2.4 3.5 7.8 1.5 1.2 15.5 1.8 9.4 43.3Greece 24.6 4.6 3.3 6.2 1.0 0.4 11.6 1.2 7.9 39.3Ireland 11.4 0.9 3.7 16.4 2.1 1.3 15.6 1.8 10.9 35.9Italy 17.3 3.0 4.0 7.1 1.8 1.4 14.7 1.1 8.5 41.0Luxemburg 11.4 1.0 2.5 9.9 2.8 1.8 11.4 4.0 12.1 43.2Netherlands 11.2 2.7 4.2 10.9 3.3 1.2 17.0 3.5 11.6 34.5Norway 9.7 3.6 2.2 9.6 1.5 1.6 16.5 2.9 12.6 39.8Spain 12.5 2.3 4.8 11.6 2.1 1.3 14.1 3.3 10.5 37.4Sweden 14.4 2.9 2.7 8.2 0.7 1.5 13.7 2.2 13.3 40.5Switzerland 9.9 2.9 5.0 13.7 2.3 0.6 6.1 2.6 17.9 39.0U.K. 11.6 5.1 5.3 5.3 2.0 1.8 16.5 2.1 13.4 36.8U.S.A. 12.4 11.7 5.5 9.4 0.0 2.1 21.4 0.7 15.5 21.3OCSE 13.6 3.6 3.9 10.5 1.6 1.6 14.5 2.7 12.5 35.6
Source: Il Sole 24 Ore, 15 novembre 2013
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Diverging funding policies on HE
7
Source: Donina et al. (2014). Reprocessing EUA’s Public Funding Observatory and Word Bank Statistics
Country Funding 2012 - (mln €)
Population 2011 ('000)
Funding per citizen
Change 2008-2012
Change 2008-2012 Inflation-adjusted
Norway 3.621 4.953 731 22,0% 21,0%Sweden 6.235 9.449 660 22,0% 21,0%Germany 24.900 81.798 304 23,0% 20,0%France 19.800 65.434 303 8,8% 6,4%Iceland 87 319 273 13,0% 7,2%Ireland 1.236 4.576 270 -20,0% -21,0%Austria 2.169 8.424 257 15,0% 13,0%Netherland 3.232 16.693 194 10,0% 7,5%Spain* 7.258 46.175 157 -9,5% -11,0%UK 9.815 62.744 156 -10,0% -13,0%Italy 6.633 60.724 109 -12,0% -14,0%Croatia 369 4.403 84 5,3% 1,8%Slovakia 447 5.398 83 2,1% -1,5%Poland* 3.015 38.534 78 12,0% 8,6%Czech Republic 802 10.496 76 -14,0% -17,0%Lithuania 189 3.030 62 -19,0% -22,0%Portugal 602 10.557 57 -1,5% -4,1%Hungary 542 9.972 54 -20,0% -24,0%Greece 200 11.300 18 -25,0% -25,0%Belgium - French Community 585 n.a. 0 19,0% 16,0%
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
What are the public funding modalities?
8
Source: Estermann (2014),
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Massification of HE
10
Population share that attained tertiary education by age (2011)Source: OECD, Education at a glance, 2013
• The share of youth who attain HE is increased worldwide
Korea
Japa
n
Canad
a
Irela
nd
Unite
d Kin
gdom
Norway
Luxe
mbo
urg
New Z
eala
nd
Israe
l
Austra
lia
Unite
d St
ates
Fran
ce
Swed
en
Belgi
umChi
le
Switz
erla
nd
Nethe
rland
s
Finla
nd
Icela
nd
Pola
nd
Spai
n
Esto
nia
OECD a
vera
ge
Denm
ark
EU21
ave
rage
Slov
enia
Greec
e
Hunga
ry
Germ
any
Portu
gal
Slov
ak R
epub
lic
Czech
Rep
ublic
Mexico
Austri
aIta
ly
Turk
ey0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
50.0
60.0
70.0
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
“The world is going to university” (Economist,
March 2015)
11
• The global tertiary-enrolment ratio—the share of the student-
age population at university—went up from 14% to 32% in the
two decades to 2012
• University enrolment is growing faster even than demand for
that ultimate consumer good, the car
• The hunger for degrees is understandable: these days they are
a requirement for a decent job and an entry ticket to the
middle class
Source: Economist, March 28th, 2015
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
The world is asking research and top universities
12
Nowadays policymakers are increasingly focusing public
resources on a few privileged institutions, intensifying the
competition to create world-class universities
“Everyone wants one [world class university],
no one knows what it is,
and no one knows how to get one”
Philip AltbachDirector of the Center for International Higher Education
in the Lynch School of Education at Boston College
The Future of HE in Europe15.04.2023
Politicians love the university rankings
We would maximize the competitive position of a group of leading Russian universities in the global research and education market through the “Project 5-100” (a campaign to help propel 5 Russian institutions into the top 100 of the global rankings)
Alexander Povalko,
Deputy Minister of Education and Science of the Russian Federation
It is time to transform Japanese universities to world universities so they can be placed within the top ranking
Hakubun Shimomura,
Minister of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology of Japan
Our universities are also climbing up the international rankings. Four French institutions are among the top 100 in the Shanghai Ranking and we’re told there will soon be five. These rankings matter, of course.
François Hollande,
President of the French Republic
13
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Satisfying the demand: EU or US model?
15
European model
• The leading approach is that of state funding and provision, in
which most institutions have equal resources and status.
Anglosaxon model
• A more market-based model, of mixed private-public funding
and provision, with brilliant, well-funded institutions at the top
and poorer ones at the bottom
The world is moving toward the Anglosaxon model: Is it worth?
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Higher education is only research?
Research side:
• In 2014, 19 of the 20 universities in the world that produced
the most highly cited research papers were American.
Education side:
• American graduates score poorly in international numeracy
and literacy rankings, and are worsening. 45% of American
students made no gains in their first two years of university
• Tuition fees have nearly doubled, in real terms, in 20 years
• Student debt, at nearly $1.2 trillion, has surpassed credit-card
debt and car loans
The dark side of «rankings»…
16
The Future of HE in Europe15.04.2023
Are University rankings a ruin?
We need to start with a rich and credible data system before we leap into some sort of artificial ranking system that, frankly, would have all kinds of unintended consequences.
Margaret Spellings, U.S. Secretary of Education
The system of evaluating professors and academic institutions creates perverse incentives which undermine the quality of education and encourage and enable fraud.
Wu Se-hwa 吳思華 , Ministry of Education of Taiwan
Forget ranking; serious education issues deserve more attention. Youth are growing up without practical life skills.
Gaylod Avedi, Chairman of Vihiga County Education Board
17
The Future of HE in Europe15.04.2023
Is this a sustainable model?
18
University of California (Berkeley)
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
A simple story: Higher Education in UK and in Italy
19
HE a.y. 2012/13 Italy (€) UK (£)
Total income (mln) 12.894,7 29.001,3
Total expenditure (mln) 12.145,0 27.941,5
Sources: ANVUR (2014) HESA website
The UK system cost three times the Italian one: please stop operating on a shoestring
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Italy vs Uk: number of Universities
20
2012/13 Italy UK
Total 96 161
Public 67 160
Private (excluding telematic universities) 18 1
Telematic universities 11 (private) 1 (public)
Are there in Italy too many Universities?
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Italy vs. UK: institutional size
21
UK a.y. 2012/13 Public Private Long-distance
Learning (Public)
Total 160 1 1
Mega univ 1 1
Big univ 42
Medium univ 56
Small univ 61 1
Italy a.y. 2012/13 Atenei Statali Atenei non Statali
TradizionaliLong-distance
Learning (Private)
Total 66 18 11
Mega univ 11
Big univ 17 1
Medium univ 17 1 1
Small univ 21 16 10
Mega univ:
Students > 40.000;
Big univ:
20.000<students< 40.000;
Medium univ:
10.000<students< 20.000;
Small univ:
Students < 10.000
Fonte: Elaborazione su dati Statistica MIUR
Fonte: HESA websiteAre the Italian Universities too small?
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Italy vs. UK: funding system
22
Can Italy and Europe afford the UK trend?
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Is the “dual” society coming?
• We are moving towards a so-called “dual” society
• Using the words of Marc Augé:
24
on the one
hand an
oligarchy
of powe
ran
oligarchy
of mon
eyan
oligarchy
of kno
wledge
and on the
other a
mass of
“excluded
”
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Dual society or free lunch society? 1/3
• Dual Society (1% Society)
o Competitiveness based solely on excellence
o An intensive logic: Resources concentrated on few people and few
initiatives
o A diverging HE system: a system for the genes or the elects on the
one side; and a less-qualified system for the others
o A compassionate system of charity emulating an accessibility
system
25
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Dual society or free lunch society? 2/3
• The “free-lunch” Society
o Society based exclusively on rights and not on duties
o An “artificially-equal” system: equal from the legal point of view,
but not substantially
o Final result is that the average quality decreases
26
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Dual society or free lunch society? 3/3
• Is Knowledge Society coherent with the Dual Society model?
• Is the “free-lunch” Society sustainable from an economic and
an anthropologic point of view?
• Is a more realistic approach feasible?
27
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
What about the future of University
28
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Key messages for policy makers (1/2)
• Be clear about aims and purposes
• Evaluate which aims can be best achieved through which
measure
• Consult on the choice of indicators/objectives
• Minimise administrative effort for the measurement and
generation/collection of data
o Time spent for administrative and bureaucratic jobs is without
value added
29
Source: Estermann (2014),
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Which goal has to be persuited?
30
Source: Estermann (2014), EUA funding forum Bergamo.
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Key messages for policy makers (2/2)
• Watch out for conflicting goals and indicators
• Avoid indicators on which HEIs have little influence
• Be careful for possible unintended consequences and
impacts of policy choices
31
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Does HE decrease Social inequalities?
• In some cases, are new HE funding policies increasing social
inequalities?
o In some countries as the US, the new model is forcing students to
run up huge debts to afford to obtain an academic qualification
˗ What will it happen in countries which are on the same path (i.e., UK)?
o Are we going towards a society that the philosopher Marc Augé
called ‘dual society’, or that we can call ‘1% society’?
˗ Competitiveness based solely on excellence
˗ An intensive logic: Resources concentrated on few people and few
initiatives
˗ A diverging HE system: a system for the genes or the elects on the one
side; and a less-qualified system for the others
˗ A compassionate system of charity emulating an accessibility system
32
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
A new model of university?
• Who should bear the cost of higher education?
o New funding models for the sustainability of the system
o A variety of funding models would facilitate the creation of an
university “ecosystem”
Evolution of higher education institutions to be more responsive to the
needs of different stakeholders
Possible response to the increased cost of higher education
33
'Classic' State University 80% 20%
Private model (teaching) 20% 50% - - 30%
Hybrid Model 50% 50%
Overheads Contracts
Sources Public funding StudentsOverhead EU
projects“Fund raising”
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
…bring to new issues: Who pays for whom?
• International students are precious assets for European
universities
• BUT is it worthy that EU taxpayers in some EU countries are
funding
o Non-EU student’s education
o EU students that will work in a non-EU country
• Some issues for the European policy makers
o Are they aware of the problem?
o Are current national welfare state compatible with a global market
for HE?
34
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Key messages for universities 1/2
• To the policy makers: no input, no output
35
Source: Estermann (2014)
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Key messages for universities 2/2
• Get involved in the design of the funding scheme
• Identify their own priorities and develop an institutional
strategy
• Establish strong internal QA mechanisms and foster quality
culture
• Set up internal funding allocation schemes based on
institutional priorities (may differ from the external one)
• If applicable, try to align the performance contract with your
institutional priorities
36
Source: Estermann (2014)
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Open issues and proposals: Changing status
• Is this new idea of society still compatible with the idea of
public servants/employees?
o Being paid by the government does not make an employee a public
servant!
• Support the average quality and excellence at the same time
• Is the current legal status coherent with the goals of
sustainability and diversification of university funding sources?
37
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
Open issues: specialties and commodities
• What are commodities and specialties in HE?
˗ Undergraduates are "commodity" and graduates are "specialty"?
˗ Frontal lessons are speciality or commodity? The role of Moocs
• Can commodities be outsourced?
o Why do universities pay for tutors, teaching how to solve very
standard exercises that can easily be found on the web?
o Can this resources be used to augment scholarships?
o Can this resources be used to invest in a course that provides high
value added?
38
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
Stefano Paleari
The Future of Universities in Europe and beyond
• The Universities are the new “wealth of Nations”
• The model of University is also the model of society that we
won to build up: excellence and/or average quality
• The landscape will change (mobility, resource scarsity, high skill
workers, ecc.) and we have to change with it
• My best wishes to the Rectors for the forthcoming years……..
39
Top Related