Download - Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

Transcript
Page 1: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2012 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 1

Outside the Box in Habitat

Restoration for Hazardous

Remediation

J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz, D. Partridge,

L. deMarffy and C. Brachfeld

Imagine the result

Page 2: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 2

• Introduction

•Permit Requirements

•Examples

•Conclusions

Agenda

Page 3: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 3

• Replacement to original

grades

• 80% survival of planted

species

• Planting spacing

• Cook Book

• 5 yr of monitoring

Permit Conditions

Page 4: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 4

• Increase $$$$$

•Can we save $$$$$$

• What are the big dollar items

• T & E impacts

Issues

Page 5: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 5

• Examples of methods

• Create problems when

implemented

• Do not work in all cases

• Are not specific to on site

conditions

Cook Books

Page 6: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 6

Vernal Pool Habitats

• Depressions in uplands

• Periodic dry down

• No fish

• Important habitat that is being lost

Page 7: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 7

Vernal Pool Habitat

Issues: •Removal of contaminated soils in

wetland

•Regrade to original grades

•80% survival of planted plants

•5 years of monitoring

Page 8: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 8

Vernal Pool Habitat

2005

Remedial Work Completed

Page 9: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 9

Vernal Pool Habitat

August 2010

State & Federally Approved

Diversity of Habitats

vernal pool

wet meadow

Page 10: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 10

Habitat Diversity

June 2006

Page 11: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 11

Habitat Diversity

May 2010

Floodplain

Intermittent Stream Corridor

Vernal Pools

Pond

Page 12: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 12

Habitat Diversity

August 2010

Page 13: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 13

Habitat Diversity

October 2012

State and Federal Approval

Page 14: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 14

September 2009

Page 15: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 15

May 2011

RipRap Cap

Page 16: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 16

August 2011

Sand Covered RipRap Cap

Page 17: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 17

June 2013

Page 18: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 18

Phragmites

1997

Page 19: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 19

Phragmites

Page 20: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 20

Phragmites

•No seeding

•Monitoring of vegetation

•Adaptive Management

Page 21: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 21

Phragmites

Page 22: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 22

Phragmites

Tidal Salt Marsh

Page 23: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2013 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 23

$10K vs $250K to $400K per ac

0.0

2.0

4.0

6.0

8.0

10.0

0%

25%

50%

75%

100%

1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

Ro

de

Us

e (

gall

on

s)

Ha

bit

at

Co

ve

r (%

)

Sampling/Treatment Year

Phragmites

Low Marsh

High Marsh

Total Salt Marsh Habitat

Rodeo® Use

ATV

Hand Application

Success

Page 24: Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous ...€¦ · 1 9 August 2013 © 2012 ARCADIS Outside the Box in Habitat Restoration for Hazardous Remediation J. Shisler, G. Markiewicz,

© 2012 ARCADIS 9 August 2013 24

Imagine the result

•Thinking outside the box

•Decease Project Costs

•Increase Habitat Diversity

• Adaptive Management