Download - On the Metamorphoses of Maxwell’s Equations During …emts2016.org/data/uploads/espoohehlmetamorph_03.pdf · & Hammond, Kovetz, Russer, Lindell, H. & Obukhov; ... • A. Favaro:

On the Metamorphoses of Maxwell’s EquationsDuring the Last 150 Years — spotlights on the

history of classical electrodynamics —Alberto Favaro∗, Friedrich W. Hehl†, and Jonathan Lux‡

∗Imperial College, London, UK; e-mail: [email protected]†Univ. of Cologne, Germany, and Univ. of Missouri-Colombia,USA; e-mail: [email protected]

‡Univ. of Cologne, Germany; e-mail: [email protected]

Abstract—We outline Maxwell’s five decisive papers on hisequations governing electrodynamics (1862-1868). We study themetamorphoses of these equations and find essentially twelvedifferent versions of them. We express our preference for theso-called premetric version of the Maxwell equations, which isparticularly useful in understanding the structure of electrody-namics. Some selected applications are discussed.

The twelve different versions of the Maxwell equations,which we will discuss chronologically, are the following:

1. In components: Maxwell 1862-65.2. In quaternions (Hamilton 1843): Maxwell 1865, 1873.3. In symbolic vector calculus: Heaviside 1885-88, Foppl

1894, Gibbs 1901.4. In components (compact, without vector potential A):

Hertz 1890, including ansatz for moving bodies.5. In components a la Maxwell-Hertzplus Lorentz trans-

formations: Einstein 1905.6. In 4d calculus (components and symbolic) for special

relativity: Minkowski 1907-08.gravity=⇒ 7. In 4d generally covariant tensor calculus: Einstein 1916

(shortly after establishing general relativity).8. In premetric/integral formulation up to about 1960:

(Maxwell 1868, Murnaghan 1920) Kottler 1922, Car-tan 1923-24 (in differential forms), van Dantzig,Schrodinger, Schouten, Truesdell-Toupin 1961, Post1962.

9. In spinor calculus (after Pauli 1927 and Dirac 1928and commencing in 1929): Fock & Ivanenko, London,Weyl, Infeld & van der Waerden, Corson⇒ reviewedby Penrose & Rindler 1984 in the context of generalrelativity.

10. In 4d Clifford algebra formalism, including quaternionsand octonions: Riesz 1958⇒ Lounesto 1997, Baylis1999, ... , Hitzer 2012.

11. In algebraic (discrete) formulation in terms of (co)chains⇒ Bossavit, Tonti (“Algebraic formulation of physicalfields”) ⇒ “Maxwell in chains,” direct implementationby means of algebraic computer code.

12. In 3d and 4d exterior calculus (premetric topologicalform of Maxwell’s equations): Kiehn, Post; Baldomir& Hammond, Kovetz, Russer, Lindell, H. & Obukhov;

Fig. 1. Maxwell Monument in Edinburgh, Scotland.

signatureof the 4d Lorentz metric linked to the Lenzrule and to the sign of the energy density⇒ Obukhov,Itin, Friedman, H..

We invite comments and critical remarks to our findings,particularly to the 12-fold way, which we presented, see ouremail addresses above.

Fig. 2. The Maxwell-Heaviside equations on the monument.

FURTHER READING

• B. Auchmann and S. Kurz,Observers and Splitting Structures in Relativis-tic Electrodynamics,J. Phys. A47, 435202 (2014) [arXiv:1411.0837].

• D. Baldomir and P. Hammond,Geometry of Electromagnetic Systems,Clarendon Press, Oxford, UK (1996).

• A. Bossavit,Computational Electromagnetism: Variational Formulations,Complementarity, Edge Elements,Academic Press, San Diego, CA (1998).

• O. Darrigol,Electrodynamics from Ampere to Einstein,Oxford Univ. Press,Oxford, UK (2000).

• D. H. Delphenich, Pre-metric Electromagnetism,electronic book, 410pages, http://www.neo-classical-physics.info/ (2009).

• C. W. F. Everitt,James Clerk Maxwell,Physicist and Natural Philosopher,Scribners, NY (1975).

• A. Favaro: Recent Advances in Classical Electromagnetic Theory,Ph.D.thesis, Imperial Coll. London (2012).

• A. Favaro, F. W. Hehl, J. Lux,On the Metamorphoses of Maxwell’sEquations...,European Physical J. H, invited contribution (in preparation).

• F. Gronwald, F. W. Hehl and J. Nitsch,Axiomatics of ClassicalElectrodynamics and its Relation to Gauge Field Theory,(2005)[arXiv:physics/0506219].

• F. W. Hehl & Yu. N. Obukhov,Foundations of Classical Electrodynamics:Charge, Flux, and Metric,Birkhauser, Boston, MA (2003).

• Y. Itin and Y. Friedman,Backwards on Minkowski’s Road. From 4D to 3DMaxwellian Electromagnetism,Annalen Phys. (Berlin)17, 769–786 (2008)[arXiv.org:0807.2625].

• Y. Itin and F. W. Hehl,Is the Lorentz Signature of the Metric of Space-Time Electromagnetic in Origin?,Annals Phys. (NY)312, 60–83 (2004)[arXiv:gr-qc/0401016].

• K. Kupfmuller, W. Mathis, A. Reibiger,Theoretische Elektrotechnik,19thed., Springer Vieweg, Berlin (2013).

• I. Lindell: Long History of Electricity(in Finnish), Gaudeamus, Helsinki(2009).

• I. V. Lindell, Multiforms, Dyadics, and Electromagnetic Media,Wiley,Hoboken, NJ [and IEEE Press] (2015).

• P. Lounesto,Clifford Algebras and Spinors,2nd ed., Cambridge UniversityPress, Cambridge, UK (2001).

• T. Matsushita,Electricity and Magnetism: New Formulation by Introductionof Superconductivity,Springer, Tokyo (2014).

• W.-T. Ni, Spacetime Structure and Asymmetric Metric from the PremetricFormulation of Electromagnetism,Phys. Lett. A379, 1297–1303 (2015)[arXiv.org:1411.0460].

• Y. N. Obukhov,Electromagnetic Energy and Momentum in Moving Media,Annalen Phys. (Berlin)17, 830–851 (2008) [arXiv:0808.1967].

• P. Russer,Electromagnetics, Microwave Circuit and Antenna Design forCommunications Engineering,2nd ed., Artech House, Norwood, MA(2006).

• A. Serdyukov, I. Semchenko, S. Tretyakov, and A. Sihvola,Electromag-netics of Bi-anisotropic Materials,Theory and Applications, Gordon andBreach, Amsterdam (2001).

• A. Sihvola and I. V. Lindell,Perfect Electromagnetic Conductor Medium,Annalen Phys. (Berlin)17, 787–802 (2008).

• K. Simonyi, A Cultural History of Physics,CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL(2012).

• E. Tonti,The Mathematical Structure of Classical and Relativistic Physics:a General Classification Diagram,Birkhauser/Springer, New York (2013).

• E. Whittaker, A History of the Theories of Aether and Electricity,2volumes, Humanities Press, NY (1973) [originally 1951].