8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
1/267
"# $%& '"(')"$ '*)($ +*( ,*#$-*,&(. '*)#$./ ,0(.10#2
33333333333333333333333333334
55
6(&$$ 7",6&(1"# 55
89:;>/ 55
?@ 5 ';?;9 #A@ BCDEFF5
00(*# G017&(/ &$ 01 55
2H>H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
2/267
"# $%& '"(')"$ '*)($ +*( ,*#$-*,&(. '*)#$./ ,0(.10#2
333333333333333333333333333345
56(&$$ 7",6&(1"# 5
589:;>/ 5
5?@ 5 ';?;9 #A@ BCDEFF
500(*# G017&(/ &$ 01 5
52H>H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
3/267
"#2&a
8:OH
*[H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
4/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
4
8 ( * ' & & 2 " # - V
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 33 >LA\ MHP=HLI:M =A LH?;P;= 33 AL =A
LHIA PA\H \ALH LHPH:LJT A< =TH E3QDS ;PPNH@ " I;I IA PA\H
;PPNH/ : ,:LM9:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
5/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
5
[LHPH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
6/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
6
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 .ANL TA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
7/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
7
AN= ;< =TH T:99c:M@
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 V;L/ " c:P J:99HI ;< >LA : OL:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
8/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
8
33 UN= ;= c:P : VH?H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
9/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
9
N
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
10/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
10
$%& '*)($5 .HP/ PNLH@
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 ,L@ 0KU:L THLH c;PTHP =A I;PH@ "e\
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
11/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
11
:[[H:9 =T:= " J:< \:KH c;=T =TH fNLM =T:= \M :==AL
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
12/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
12
[NLPNH A =A ,L@ 7;\UHL9; MAN c:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
13/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
13
$%& '*)($5 GH99/ MH:T/ :P 9A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
14/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
14
;=eP AL T;\ H;=THL/ PA cHe99 JLAPP =T:= UL;IOH ;>
cH OH= =A ;=@ $T:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
15/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
15
J:PH@ "= ;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
16/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
16
OH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
17/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
17
=TH >HIHL:9 fNIOH =T:= PH@ .AN
K
;\\;OL:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
18/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
18
0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
19/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
19
V=:=HP@ VTH c:P QY@ GTH< PTH =NLN9 K;IPk =THMeLH U:JK =THLH@ .ANe99 OH= =A
\HH= A =TH\ ;< : \;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
20/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
20
PHH\HI =A UH OH==;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
21/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
21
VH=T 099H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
22/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
22
cT:=eP T:[[H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
23/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
23
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 .ANL TA JANL=@
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
24/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
24
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 *UfHJ=;A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
25/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
25
$%& '*)($5 0[[:LH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
26/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
26
$%& '*)($5 " I;I:\;9M@
$%& '*)($5 VNP=:;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
27/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
28/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
29/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
29
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 *UfHJ=;A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
30/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
30
L;OT=@ VA cTAeP =TH fNIOHd
)#"2$"+"&2 +&,01&5 "e\
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
31/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
31
AUPHL?:=;A< P:MP =T:= ;> MAN c:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
32/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
33/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
33
=T:= >LHHIA\ :c:M >LA\ NP/ UN= =TH =H\[=:=;A< =A IA PA c;99
:9c:MP UH =THLH/ :LHHIA\P >AL =TH;L JA\>AL=@ 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
34/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
34
I;P[APH A> UA=T A> =TAPH J:PHP := =T:= [A;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
35/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
35
UHP;IHP PT:LH :L=;J9HP =T:= :LH cL;==H< UM A=THL [HA[9Hd %H T:P
[LA?;IHI MAN c;=T T;\/ :9:=@ GH K
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
36/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
36
7;\UHL9;< : 33 UHJ:NPH ;> cH P=:L=
c;=T : c;=
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
37/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
37
MAN OA AN=P;IH =A OH= =A =TH J:>H=HL;:/ UN= ;> MAN c:;LP= c;= ;< =T;P J:PH/ PTHeP
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
38/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
38
:UAN= =TH T:L\@ VTHeP UHH< UN99;HI AN= A> =cA PJTAA9P UHJ:NPH
A> =TH =T; ;=eP :< AN=3A>3JANL= P=:=H\H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
39/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
39
$%& '*)($5 6N= cT:= ;P =TH PHONHd %Ac IAHP ;=
JA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
40/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
40
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 VTH \:M T;\d
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 "e\ cT:= =THM P:;I A< =TH "
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
41/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
41
"e\ TH:L;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
42/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
42
$%& '*)($5 GT:=eP =TH PHONHd %Ac J:< MAN [LA?H =T:=
cT:= T:[[H 33 "e\ NP; =cA
PJTAA9P/ ;> PTH PN>>HLHI AN= A> =cA PJTAA9P UHJ:NPH A> [HA[9H
OA;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
43/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
43
$%& '*)($5 VTHeP M =T:= MAN
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
44/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
44
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 #A@ " c:LA : fNLM :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
45/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
45
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 GH99/ PTH c;=H IA/ :H :J=@
$%& '*)($5 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
46/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
46
>;=P A> IH[LHPP;A< 33
$%& '*)($5 VTH J:H =L;HI =A JA\\;= PN;J;IH ;< >LA THL@ VTH J: 33
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
48/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
48
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 .ANL TA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
49/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
49
PTHeP OA;M =A/ PTHeP LA\ : 9HO:9 [A; ?;Hc@ 0 9:M c;= MANL
JT:L:J=HL 33
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 GH99/ ;=eP 33 \M LH[N=:=;A< ;P :=
;PPNH@
$%& '*)($5 GH99/ UN= 33 MAN IAALH MAN =:KH =TH P=:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
50/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
50
LN9HP@ 'T:L:J=HL 33 ;> MAN cHLH :99AcHI =A IA cT:= MAN c:H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
51/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
51
IAHPAL ;=@
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 *K:M@
6'% '*#+&('&
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 "eI 9;KH =A J:99 0:LA< G:9KHL@
)#"2$"+"&2 ,01&5 0:LA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
52/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
52
l GT:= c:P MANL 9:P= 33 [LH?;ANP H\[9AM\H =TH ,NT:\\:I U9AO/ cT:=
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
53/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
53
l VA =T:= ,NT:\\:I U9AO/ :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
54/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
54
l 0:\;9;:L =T:= A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
55/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
55
LHJALI@ .AN T:I IHJ;IHI =A >;9H : 33 MAN T:I >;9HI : \A=;A< 33
: PNU[AH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
56/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
56
l ':< MAN 33 I;I MAN =H99 [HA[9H A< =T:= U9AO PA\H=T;;J:99M PA =THM cAN9I JT:PH :
OTAP=@
l VA 33
0 VA =T:= ;> =THLH c:P :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
57/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
57
0 6:P;J:99M 33 MAN T:?H =A N
P[HHJT@ $THM =TLH:=HAL H4:\[9H/ V:9\:< (NPTI;H >AL T:?;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
58/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
58
LH:9;gHI 33 =THLHeP =AA \:;LP=d
$%& '*)($5 VNLH@
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 1AAK := ;= >;LP=@ 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
59/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
59
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 *K:M@ "> TH J:< 33 ;=eP
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
60/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
60
^NHP=;A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
61/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
61
[AL=;A< ;< MH99Ac 33
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 6N= MANL TA ;=eP
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
62/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
62
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 *UfHJ=;A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
63/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
63
l *K:M@ VA/ := JANL= =T:= I:M/ :>=HL =TH TH:L; MAN
JTAAPH =A IA PA/ P;L@
,(@ G017&(5 *K:M@
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
64/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
64
0 "e99 P:M ;< OH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
65/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
65
P;=N:=;A< AN=@ .AN T:?H 33 :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
66/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
66
THE COURT: Well, he hasnt offered.
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 33 AK:M@ VALLM@
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l 33 =T;P ;P : [NU9;J IAJN\HLA\ =TH [A9;JH
IH[:L=\H>HL;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
67/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
67
0 33 ALH 33 \M
H4T;U;=d
THE COURT: Whats=TH =T:= H4T;U;=/ P;Ld
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 &4T;U;= S :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
68/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
69/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
69
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 " AUfHJ=@
$%& '*)($5 #H4= ^NHP=;AL:\H MAN >AL : JL;\Hd
0 " T:I P;\[9M [A;=H< P:;I MAN [LAU:U9M
fNP= >:KHI =TH cTA9H ;Hc PH9HJ=HI P=;99P >LA\ : >N99
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
70/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
71/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
71
33
$%& '*)($5 GH99/ =TH c;=LHPT@
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 *K:M@
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l 2;I MAN 33 I;I MAN cL;=H : 9H==HL =A MANL PN[HL?;PAL
AL =A MANL %(d
0 " T:?H cL;==H< 9A=P A> 9H==HLP =A =TH\@ 6H \ALH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
72/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
72
P[HJ;>;J@
l $T;P [:L=;JN9:L 9H==HLd
0 0\ " UH;HJ=@
l 0;HJ=;?H9M A< =TH
E=T 33 PALLM 33 MHP/ ]:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
73/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
73
;= c:P OA;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
74/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
75/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
75
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l GHLH MAN H?HL 33 cHLH MAN H?HL U:;HL ,AT:\\HI := 8"+'*d
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 *UfHJ=;A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
76/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
76
UN99d
0 .HP@
l 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
77/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
77
leave me alone, many times. Can you tell me how many times Ive
:PKHI MAN =A 9H:?H \H :9A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
78/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
78
[HIA[T;9Hd
0 .HP@
l %:?H [NU9;PTHI =cHH=P =T:= J:99 \H : [HIA[T;9Hd
0 0O:;< U:PHI A< =TH ;AL\:=;A< " T:?H/ " T:?H J:99HI
MAN :< [HIA[T;9H@
l %Ac \:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
79/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
79
l Yes. Now are you aware that Im director of a
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
80/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
80
0 " :\
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
81/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
81
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 GH99 33
,(@ G017&(5 2A MAN c: =TH A>>HL; 9HO:9 >;9;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
82/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
82
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l 099 ANL PN;=P/ [H:JH ALIHLP/ JL;\;;9HI : JAN[9H A> [:[HLP ;HLH =T:= 33
0 "= c:P I;P\;PPHI@
l 33 9:cPN;=d 2;P\;PPHI@ 2A MAN K
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
84/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
85/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
85
0 " UH9;H?H =THLH ;P JNLLH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
86/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
86
33 ;< \M [:L=;JN9:L J:PH " A>=H< NPH ;= =A [LA\A=H U9AO [AP=P
Ive written.
l .AN NPH $c;==HL =A OH= \ALH =L:>>;J =A MANL cHUP;=Hd
0 Well, its a way people keep track of what people are
cL;=;:JH PN[HL;\[APHI A< ;=d
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
87/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
87
0 .HP@
l *K:M@ %Ac \:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
88/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
89/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
89
MR. WALKER: Some of them dont 33 I dont see a clear
I:=H@ " J:< 9AAK := =TH\ : " J:< >;ONLH ;= AN=@
,(@ %*-&5 "= \;OT= UH A< =TH UA==A\ =THLH@
,(@ G017&(5 ,:MUH@
,(@ %*-&5 6N= : 9A= A> =TH\ J:\H :>=HLc:LIP/ MANL
TA;LP= A> :99/
cTM IA MAN PA \:>HL =T;Pd
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 GH99/ 9;KH MAN P:;I 33
$%& '*)($5 GH99/ cH J:< =:KH =TH\ AN= 9:=HL@
,(@ %*-&5 *K:M/ MANL TA;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
90/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
90
l VA MAN T:I =THPH [NU9;PTHI IH[;J=;A
\H ;< =TH
8HIAUH:L OL:[T;J A< \N9=;[9H AJJ:P;A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
91/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
91
=T:< A =TH OL:[T;Jd
0 GT:= ;P cL:[[HId GT:= ;P ;=d
l Im asking you to identify that. Is that something
A>> 33
0 As far as I can tell, thats like somebody has cut and
pasted this image over and over again. Im not sure how that
OA= JLH:=HI@
l And you dont know who made this?
0 " I;I
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
92/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
92
:LH \M >L;H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
93/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
93
0 Well, its on my blog. I tweet it out, they follow my
$c;==HL@ $THM PHH H?HLM=T; " c:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
94/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
94
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l " N
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
95/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
96/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
96
=HH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
97/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
97
=A9I =TH\@
$%& '*)($5 VNP=:;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
98/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
98
,:LM9: ,:LM9: :99/ c:P " H?HL JT:LOHI c;=T PH4N:9
:UNPH A> :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
99/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
99
PTAc =T:= " :\ : [HIA[T;9Hd
0 GH99/ " IA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
100/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
100
l ':< MAN ;IHM ;= >;LP=/ [9H:PHd
0 *K:M/ =TH =;=9H ;P ULH:K;:;9HI =A T:?H T;P c;>H ;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
101/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
101
$%& '*)($5 $T:= cAN9I UH 9:cMHL 33
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l .AN :LH : W;LO;;9HI : \A=;A< =A JA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
102/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
102
c:P 33 A< UHT:9> A> MANL JT;9ILH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
103/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
103
0 0O:;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
104/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
104
LAA\@ #Ac/ OH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
105/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
105
N =TH \H\UHLP A> =TH fNLM/ PA cH T:?H =A \A?H
=T;P :9A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
106/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
106
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 ]NP= c:; =TAPH JT:LOHP cHLHd
0 "< cT:= PH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
107/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
108/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
109/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
110/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
110
MANeLH : =HLLAL;P=@
$%& '*)($5 GT:= ;P ;=d
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 "=eP : [:L= A> =TH U9AO 33
$%& '*)($5 $THPH :LH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
111/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
111
l 33 := :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
112/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
113/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
113
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l 0;9H@
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 *UfHJ=;A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
114/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
114
IH>HN
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
115/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
115
0 " UH9;H?H 33
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 *UfHJ=;AHL;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
116/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
116
P=:=H\H>HL;;LP=/ 9H= T;\ ;IHM ;=@
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 *K:M@
$%& '*)($5 "> ;=eP T;P P=:=H\H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
117/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
118/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
118
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 VTH 33
$%& '*)($5 .ANeLH =HH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
119/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
119
=T:=@
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 099 L;OT=@
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l #Ac/ MAN P=:L=HI := 33 MAN cHLH ;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
120/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
120
0 So I said to them, I can't ask you to do it 33
l %Ac \:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
121/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
121
called Maryland is for Stalkers?
0 " I;I
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
122/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
123/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
123
$%& '*)($5 GT:= :LH =TAPH IAJN\H =THPH T:?H UHH< \:LKHI
:9LH:IM@
$%& '*)($5 33 :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
124/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
124
PA\H=T;HLHI [LA UA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
125/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
126/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
126
0 33 :H@ 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
127/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
127
'AN
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
128/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
128
=;\HP/ =TH [A9;JH IAc< ;< ,:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
129/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
129
$%& '*)($5 *K:M@ .AN J:< P=H[ IAc
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
130/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
130
9:UH9 MANLPH9>d
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 *UfHJ=;A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
131/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
131
0 " 33 :J=N:99M/ ;=eP J:99HI =TH =;[ f:L/ UN= MHP@
l (;OT=@ $;[ ]:L@ )T3TNT@ *K:M@ 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
132/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
132
0 " 33 T:?H LA\@ "
T:?H PHH< =T:= =THLH c:P : U9AOOHL cTA/ >AL : PTAL= =;\H/ c:P 33
T:I A< 2:gg9H/ cT;JT ;P A =TH "
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
133/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
133
THLH@ .AN J:99HI \H : [HIA[T;9H A< MANL U9AO/ T:?HHc
=T;LA\ U9AO [AP=P@ " IA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
134/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
134
l ':< MAN :N=TH PA\H=T;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
135/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
135
$%& '*)($5 %:?H ;= \:LKHI@
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 099 L;OT=@
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l ,L@ %AOH/ T:?H MAN H?HL J:99HI \H : [HIA[T;9H A< MANL
U9AOd 1H=eP fNP= :PPN\H =T:= 33
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 .ANL TA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
136/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
136
l 2A MAN K
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
137/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
137
$%& '*)($5 .AN J:< :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
138/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
138
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l 2;I MAN P=A[ =T:= IH>HN
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
139/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
139
[AP= "e?H H?HL =:KH< IAc=HL =TAPH JT:LOHP cHLH =TAPH
JT:LOHP/ :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
140/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
140
l GHLH MAN H?HL LH^NHP=HI =A LH\A?H =T:= IAJN\H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
141/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
141
JT:LOHP =T:= " JA\\;==HI PA\H K; JL;\H@ .AN K;9HI :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
142/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
142
$%& '*)($5 VNP=:;AL \N9=;[9H ?;A9:=;A : [H:JH ALIHL@
l VA/ BFY JL;\;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
143/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
143
LH[AL=HL@ %H cLA=H : P=ALM@
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 " AUfHJ=;A :J=;AAL PA\HA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
144/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
144
0 " T:?H LH[AL=HI =TH >:J= =T:= MAN T:?H UHH< JT:LOHI
c;=T =T;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
145/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
145
ALIHL OA;ALc:LI@ "> " c:P OA;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
146/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
146
l .ANe?H UHH< =A H?H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
147/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
147
;=eP MAN JAN9I LHI;LHJ=/ :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
148/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
148
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l ,L@ 0KU:L/ T:?H MAN H?HL UHH< JA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
149/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
150/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
150
l *K:M@
0 "e?H UHH< ?A=HI ;< UM : UA:LI A> :c:LI c;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
151/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
151
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 $T;P ;P &4T;U;= #A@ RQ@
$%& '*)($5 099 L;OT=@ ':< MAN ;IHM =T:=/ P;Ld
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 .AN J:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
152/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
152
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 " AUfHJ=@ " *UfHJ=@
,(@ 0760(5 33 cHe?H L:;PHI \A \A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
153/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
153
0 (:;PHI =A IH>H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
154/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
154
$%& '*)($5 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
155/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
155
l So we've uncovered Brett Kimberlin's big secret.
%HeP : [HIA[T;9H c;=T A=THL [HIA[T;9HP :LAN
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
156/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
156
$%& '*)($5 33 =T:= I;I MAN T:?H H?;IH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
157/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
157
$%& '*)($5 0 =TH [9:;>/ T:?;;LP= IN9M PcAL
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
158/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
158
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 GH99/ ,L@ ,J':;< 33
$%& '*)($5 $TH VAN=THL< 8A?HL=M 1:c 'H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
159/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
159
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 (;OT=@ 6HJ:NPH =TH VAN=THL< 8A?HL=M
1:c 'H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
160/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
160
l +;LP= A> :99/ J:< MAN LH:I =TH =;=9Hd
0 The title is How to -H= : ,;99;A< %;=P A< .ANL 69AO
;< 1HPP $T:< : .ear.
l VA 9H=eP fNP= JN= =A =TH JT:PH THLH@ 8A;ANL@ ,:KH PA\H H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
161/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
161
l " fNP= T;OT9;OT=HI PA\H =T; MAN
JAN9I LH:I =TAPH =A =TH fNLMd
0 *K:M@ 1H= \H PHH THLH@ "P =T;P >LA\ =TH P:\H =T;N< ;IH: A> 9:M;HLHI
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
162/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
162
N[ : JA\\H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
163/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
163
?:9?H =A \:KH PNLH cH IA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
164/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
164
0 &?HLMUAIM 9A?HP : [LH==M O;L9@
l .H:T@
0 'TL;P=;L;H:\;9M@ #H:9
(:NT:NPHL@ GTA ;P #H:9 (:NT:NPHLd
l " IA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
165/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
165
0 .AN P:M@
l .AN JHL=:;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
166/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
166
0 " IA TH cLA=H =T:= =cHH=/
:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
167/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
167
l 2;I MAN cL;=H =T:= =cHH=d ]NP= =T:= =cHH=d
0 #A@ $T:=eP >HLH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
168/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
168
l GH99/ ;> " cHLH =A :PK MAN =A 9AAK := =THPH 33
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 0LH =THPH :99 A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
169/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
169
:JJNL:=H9M@
l *K:M@
0 6N= "e\ =H99;ANL [AP=P 33 =TH
TH:I9;ANL [AP=P =T:= " cLA=H :UAN=
MANL :PPAJ;:=H #H:9 (:NT:NPHL@
l %:?H MAN =;HI \H =A A=THL [HA[9H/ 9;KH ,L@ %AOH T:P :
I:;9M [AP= J:99HI $H:\ 7;\UHL9;< 8AP= A> =TH I:M/ cTHLH TH P:MP
=T:= =THLHeP 33 fA;< : =H:\ AN= =THLH@ "=eP 33
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 *UfHJ=;A =A #H:9 (:NT:NPHL@ .AN =A9I :
,:LM9:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
170/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
170
,(@ ,''0"#5 ':< " :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
171/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
172/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
172
$%& '*)($5 GH99 33
,(@ ,''0"#5 *J=AUHL 33
$%& '*)($5 33 MAN OH= : JT:M@ 0PK
:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
173/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
174/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
174
)#"2$"+"&2 +&,01&5 $T:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
175/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
175
$%& '*)($5 GH99/ MAN J:< =HP=;>M :UAN= =T:=@
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 GH99/ " \:M M@ " IAM@
$%& '*)($5 6N= "e\
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
176/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
176
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
177/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
177
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 33 >L;H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
178/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
178
$%& '*)($5 GH99/ UN= =T:=eP PA\H=T;>HL A> cT:= PTHeP OA;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
179/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
179
cTA9H U:P;P 33 >AL J:99;>
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
180/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
180
:99 =TH =;\H :UAN= JT;9ILH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
181/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
181
\HLJ;9HPP9M A< 33 c;=T : U9AO [AP= 33
$%& '*)($5 6N= =THLHeP :99/ =TH >;LP= A:9PH P=:=H\H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
182/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
182
$%& '*)($5 "e\ :>HL; =THM [AL=L:M \H :P : U:I >:=THL/
cT;JT =THMe?H IA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
183/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
183
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 "> =THM [AL=L:M \H :P :< N;= >:=THL
cTAeP :UNP;H/ " \H:M =T:= "e?H
H@
$%& '*)($5 VTH J:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
184/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
184
H?;IH MAN OH= N[ A< =TH c;=
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
185/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
186/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
186
[LA?;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
187/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
187
$%& '*)($5 *
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
188/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
188
$%& '*)($5 #Ac cT:= JAN=d
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 $TLHH :ANL@
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 $TLHH :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
189/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
189
;IHM ;=/ =TH< ;= J:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
190/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
190
X(HJALI;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
191/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
192/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
192
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 *K:M@
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
0 *K:M@ ,M [NL[APH/ ;> MANeLH :PK;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
193/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
193
c;99 ;= H?HL UH@ #A TAAL =TH G:PT;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
194/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
195/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
195
$%& '*)($5 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
196/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
196
$%& '*)($5 GH99/ :PPAJ;:=;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
197/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
197
l 0 TH :PKHI T;\
=A IH>;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
198/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
198
LH9:=HI =A ,L@ 7;\UHL9;< =T:= TH T:P
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
199/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
199
K T;\/ TH c:P :=
=TH UA==A\ A> : UA==9H@ 0< :9JATA9;J@ 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
200/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
201/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
201
OA;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
202/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
202
OH= ;= ;> =:9K;;LP= :\H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
203/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
203
"= IAHP
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
204/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
204
;< ALIHL =A \:KH =TH [A;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
205/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
205
people have read, they might use the word pedophile, and
cTH=THL AL
9:c@ 6N= =THM I;I cTA9H J9A=T/ P;L@
$THLH :LH >:J=P ;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
206/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
206
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l 2;I MAN 9;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
207/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
207
l .H:T@ &4:J=9M@
0 *K:M@
l .AN T:?H : 9A= \ALH =L:>>;J =T:< =TH\@ $TH;L U9AOP@
0 "e?H OA= \ALH =L:>>;J =T:< MANL cHUP;=H@
l "e\ >;J =T:< MANL
cHUP;=H@
l GT:=H?HL@ "e\
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
208/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
208
$%& '*)($5 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
209/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
209
$%& '*)($5 .AN T:?H =A T:?H ;= \:LKHI@ 0 MAN
c:;LP=d
$%& '*)($5 VNLH@ GH99/ 9H= T;\ \:LK ;= >;LP=@
,(@ 0760(5 *K:M@
$%& '*)($5 $TH J9HLK KANL=HH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
210/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
210
l %Ac \:ANL =;\HP/ JHL=:;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
211/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
211
cT:= THeP =:9K;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
212/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
212
6. ,(@ 0760(
0 #A@
l VA H?HLMA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
213/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
213
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 " T:?H : JAN[9H A> ^NHP=;AHLH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
214/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
214
0 " IA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
215/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
216/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
216
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 "e99 J:99 \M I:NOT=HL@
$%& '*)($5 "P PTH MANL 9:P= c;=
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
217/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
217
l VA/ :LH MAN JA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
218/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
218
l %:L\A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
219/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
219
,V@ 7",6&(1"#5 .HP@ *K:M@ VALLM@
$%& '*)($5 099 L;OT=@ $T:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
220/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
220
0 #A= >LA\ =TH ;H@ (;OT=d
0 .HP@
l 0=H< IA MAN P[H 33 TA9I A< : PHJAL;H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
221/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
221
(APH/ :L;H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
222/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
223/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
223
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
0 " IA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
224/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
224
$%& '*)($5 VNP=:; UN99M; :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
225/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
225
TAH =T;P ^NHP=;A< =T:= cT:= c:P cL;==H:\HI \H :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
228/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
228
0 2:I/ \A\/ \H/ \M P;P=HL 33
$%& '*)($5 $THMeLH OA;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
229/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
229
[;J=NLHP >;LP=@
,V@ 7",6&(1"#5 " =THM P:M 33
$%& '*)($5 "e\ PALLM 33
MS. KIMBERLIN: If they say objection, I can't
:9;4@ GT:=eP =T:=
PTAc MAN c:=JTd
,V@ 7",6&(1"#5 2LA[ 2H:I 2;?:@
,(@ 0760(5 .ANL TA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
230/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
230
0 ,M P;P=HL@
l %Ac A9I ;P PTHd
0 VTHeP QD@
l "P PTH ;< =TH [TA=Ad
0 .H:T@
l GTHLHd
0 (;OT= =THLH@
l 0
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
231/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
231
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 0\ " A>>HL;
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
232/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
233/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
233
l 2A cH T:?H PHJNL;=M ^NHP=;A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
234/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
234
MAN
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
235/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
235
6. ,(@ 7",6&(1"#
l 2A MAN K
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
236/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
237/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
237
$%& '*)($5 .AN
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
238/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
238
$%& '*)($5 2AHP =T:= \H:< =TH [9:;> LHP=Pd
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 " UH9;H?H =TH [9:;> LHP=P@
$%& '*)($5 099 L;OT=@
,(@ *V$(*#"'5 .ANL TA
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
239/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
239
>;9Hd
,(@ 0760(5 " =T;eP 33
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 " T:?H LA\ 33
$%& '*)($5 .ANL TAeP
J:PH@ GT:= cH T:?H:\:=;A< JT:LOH AL =TH >:9PH 9;OT=
JT:LOH/ cT;JT ;P LH^N;LHI :P :< H9H\H =TH =AL=/ :AL ,L@ ,J':;:J=/ ;> :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
240/267
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
241/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
241
MAN T:?H IH>:\:=;A< [HL PH/ MAN IA;J
I:\:OHP@ 2:\:OHP :LH [LHPN\HI/ : =T;P 33 ;:9PH/ ;=
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
243/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
243
GT:= H?;IH =T:=d VHH/ cH NPH H?;IHH:9PH/ =T:= =THM I;I ;= \:9;J;ANP9M/ :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
244/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
244
^NHP=;A< =A MAN 33 cH99/ 9H= \H :PK MAN ::9PHd " NLA\ MANL \;J@
MR. KIMBERLIN: Its 33 \:MUH " J:< PTAc ;= =A MAN@
iN
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
245/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
245
:>=HL =TH JT:LOHP cHLH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
246/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
246
MR. KIMBERLIN: Because its a crime. Pedophilia is a
crime. Theyre saying IJA\\;==HI : JL;\H@
THE COURT: WhereP =TH \:9;JHd
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 $TH \:9;JH ;P 33
$%& '*)($5 G;=T LHP[HJ= =A H:JT IH>H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
247/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
247
and see Brett Kimberlin and all of the sudden Im a pedophile.
And its a crime. Pedophilia is, like, one of the most heinous
JL;\HP A< H:L=T@ Im talking about 33
$%& '*)($5 "=s not a crime. Child abuse is a crime.
VH4N:9 JT;9I :UNPH 33 PH4N:9 A>>H>H 0[[H:9P/ :P 9:=H :P RDDY@
MR. KIMBERLIN: Thats in Shapiro v. Massengill, too.
And thats what it basically means off of it.
$%& '*)($5 VA cT:= 33 :LH :99 =TH H9H\H =TAPH >:J=ALP =LNHd "< =T;P J:PHd 2A cH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
248/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
248
T:?H 33
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 GH T:?H =TH IH>:\:=ALM JA\\N;HI =A ;=d
$%& '*)($5 .HP@
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 "> MAN OA A< c;=T ,:PPH : P=:=H\H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
249/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
249
what to tell you. Youre asking me to prove a negative. I mean
33
THE COURT: Im not asking you to prove anything. Im
:PK;:9PHd
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 GTA P:;I ;= c:P >:9PHd $THM 33
$%& '*)($5 2;I MAN c:
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
250/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
250
theres no evidence of that 33 thereby discouraging others in
=TH JA\\NLA\ T:?;LA\ :PPAJ;:=;>HLHId
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 #A/ =T:= ANL >:\;9M T:I PN>>HLHI@
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
251/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
251
$T:= " T:I PN>>HLHI@
THE COURT: Look, youre the only party;< =T;P J:PH@
MR. KIMBERLIN: I understand, but youre asking me if
:;HI :UAN= [NU9;J PJAL
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
252/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
252
K
they come back and say oh, the statement was 33 he didnt show
the statement was false then thats their purview. $T:= =TH
IH>H
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
253/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
253
And theres a reckless disregard for the truth here. .AN KHH>HANL=T IHOLHH PH4 A>>H>HH
L:[H@ $T;LI IHOLHH PH4 A>>HH
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
254/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
254
THE COURT: You dont have to apologize, you were
doing the best you could, you dont have to apologize.
MR. KIMBERLIN: But theres a lot of case lac AN=
there where people are called a pedophile and theyve called
=T;P [HL PH IH>:\:=;A
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
255/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
RD
RQ
RR
RB
RS
R_
255
THE COURT: No one said you werent. What evidence is
=THLH =T:= 33
,(@ 7",6&(1"#5 33 :
8/11/2019 Kimberlin v. Walker, et al Transcript (Day 2)
256/267
Q
R
B
S
_
F
Y
C
E
QD
QR
QB
QS
Q_
QF
QY
QC
QE
Top Related