XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30...
-
Upload
robert-gates -
Category
Documents
-
view
219 -
download
0
Transcript of XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30...
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
1/55
"# $%&'()(*&+(,-. &-/01234(3-*3
Throughout the U.S., ERM
provides full-service NEPA
support to private sector clients,
federal agencies, and state
agencies with NEPA-equivalent
programs.
One thing that sets ERM apart
from our competition is our
abilitytothinkoutsideofthebox.Foreveryproject,wetailor our approach to meet
specific goals and unique
challenges.
Our experience in both private
and public sector work sets ERM
apart from other consultancies
and gives us key insights into
emerging private sector issues and
practical knowledge of publicagency procedures and
requirements.
NEPA Requirements"#$%& #'()%*+ (,#( ,#-. (,. /%(.*()#0 (% #11.'( (,. ,23#*
.*-)&%*3.*( #*4 (,#( )*-%0-. 1.4. 12*4)*5 %& &.62)&.
# /.&3)( %& %(,.& #2(,%&)7#()%* 1&%3 # 1.4. #5.*'8
#&. +29$.'( (% (,. &.62)&.3.*(+ %1 (,. :#()%*#0
;*-)&%*3.*(#0 ?@? A:;
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
2/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
ERM specialist teams have been
involved in the successfulcompletion of some of the most
complex NEPA projects in the
United States.
ERM has conducted NEPA
projects in 46 of the 50 states.
NEPA and other FederalRegulationsO,)0. .#', :;
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
3/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
Third Party and ApplicantPrepared NEPA ProcessesJ* # ()()%*#0 :;\\ :;
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
4/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
$'1'6%'7 389 23,4 3:;'-*'
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
5/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
'%//.& 3.(#0E #*4 '%*'.*((.+ %1 *)'M.0E '%9#0(E
/#00#4)23E /0#()*23E #*4 5%04 1&%3 (,&.. %/.* /)(+C
Y,.
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
6/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
+2//08 '%3.+ 1&%3 (,. P.+(.&* DCKC #*4 P.+(.&*
R#*#4)#* +%2&'.+ (,#( +.&-. *#(2 5#+ 4.3#*4 )* (,.
&.5)%*C /&%/%+.4
'%*+(&2'()*5 #*4 %/.()*5 .W(.*+)%*+ (% )(+ .W)+()*5*#(2 5#+ /)/.0)*. +8+(.3 (% 3..( (,. *..4+ %1 )(+
+29+'&)9.&+ 98 /&%-)4)*5 # &.0)#90. #*4 ()3.08 +2//08 %1
*#(2 5#+C Y,.+. .W(.*+)%*+ P%204 +.&-. (,. 5&%P)*5
4.3#*4 1%& &.+)4.*()#0 #*4 )*42+(&)#0 2+.+ )*
+%2(,.#+(.&* ")**.+%(#E J%P#E #*4 *%&(,.#+(.&*
:.9+M#C
Y,. %-. /&%$.'( #*4 +8+(.3 .W/#*+)%* )*'024.4 1%2&
'%3/%*.*(+C Y,. a.*(2 :%&(, /%&()%* %1 (,. /&%$.'(
)*'024.4 )*+(#00)*5 #9%2( > 3)0. %1 # L@Q)*', 3#)* 0)*.
.W(.*+)%* )* *%&(,'.*( J%P#C Y,. b#'&%++.QY%3#,
/%&()%* %1 (,. /&%$.'( )*'024.4 )*+(#00)*5 #03%+( ^ 3)0.+%1 1&%3 @Q)*', 0%%/ 0)*.+ 2/ (% L@Q)*', 3#)* 0)*.+ )*
+%2(,.#+(.&* ")**.+%(# #*4 *%&(,'.*( J%P#C Y,.
;#+( b.5 /%&()%* %1 (,. /&%$.'( )*'024.4 )*+(#00)*5 #9%2(
c 3)0.+ %1 @Q)*', 0%%/ 0)*.+E cQ)*', 9*', 0)*.+E #*4 2/
(% L@Q)*', 3#)* 0)*.+ )* *%&(,'.*( #*4 '.*( J%P#C
Y,. O.+( b.5 /%&()%* %1 (,. /&%$.'( )*'024.4 )*+(#00)*5
#9%2( >H 3)0.+ %1 cQ)*', 9*', 0)*.+ #*4 2/ (% L\Q)*',
3#)* 0)*.+ )* P.+(.&* J%P# #*4 *%&(,.#+(.&* :.9+M#C
ERM was part of the team that conducted the fieldwork forand prepared the four Federal Energy Regulatory
Commission (FERC) Prior Notice permit packages for the
overall project.
Y,)+ /&%$.'( P#+ '%*42'(.4 2*4.& #* .W(&.3.08 1#+(Q
('M +',.420. 9.'#2+. ,#4 (% 9.5)*
'%*+(&2'()%* )* (,. +/&)*5 %1 H\\c (% 3..( )(+ '%*('(2#0
%90)5#()%*+ P)(, )(+ +29+'&)9.&+C ]2& '%*('( P#+ *%(
+)5*.4 2*()0 (,. .*4 %1 ]'(%9.& H\\dE .++.*()#008 #( (,.
.*4 %1 (,. 1).04P%&M +.#+%*E #*4 P%&M 9.5#* )*:%-.39.&C Y.#3+ P.&. 62)'M08 3%9)0)7.4 %-.& # HQ
P..M /.&)%4E 1).04P%&M P#+ '%3/0.(.4 /&)%& (%
Y,#*M+5)-)*5E #*4 (,. 1)&+( +.( %1 4( &.+%2&'. &./%&(+
P.&. +293)((.4 98 I.'.39.& >^C Y,. &.3#)*)*5 4(
+.(+ %1 V.+%2&'. V./%&(+ P.&. /&./#&.4 #*4 +293)((.4
(% (,&%25,%2( e#*2#&8 #*4 N.9&2#&8E
'%3/0.()*5 (,.3 )* %*08 ` 3%*(,+ A(8/)'#008 # @Q3%*(,
/&%'.++ (% '%3/0.(. $2+( %*. +.( %1 &./%&(+BC
;V" -)+)(.4 (,. K(#(. Z)+(%&)'
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
7/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
;V" /&./#&.4 (,. P#(.& 2+. #*4 62#0)(8G 1)+,E P)040)1.E
#*4 -.5.(#()%*G '20(2 &.+%2&'.+G 0#*4 2+.E &.'&.#()%*E
#*4 #.+(,.()'+G #*4 (,. #)& 62#0)(8 #*4 *%)+. V.+%2&'.
V./%&(+ 1%&
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
8/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
;V" #0+% +.&-.4 #+ (,. Y
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
9/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; !"
?@ %(;/*#.#+ $ %(;/0#-13# >2310(2;#2.$*
D;/$%. ?#31#' M>D?N9 '&1%& 1- $ -.$.#F*#3#* >D=
#K)13$*#2.9 .( %&$0$%.#01O# 0#-()0%#- $2+ $--(%1$.#+1;/$%.-7 >?@ 123#2.(01#+ 2$.)0$* $2+ -(%1$*
0#-()0%#-9 %(2+)%.126 0#-#$0%& $2+ ,1#*+ $2+ $#01$*
$--#--;#2.- (, '#.*$2+-9 -.0#$;- $2+ ,*((+/*$12-9
'1*+*1,#9 6#(*(64 $2+ -(1*-9 60()2+'$.#0 $2+ '#**-9
&1-.(01% %)*.)0$* 0#-()0%#-9 $#-..1%-9 2(1-#9 2$.)0$*
0#-()0%# $0#$-9 $2+ -(%1(#%(2(;1% ,$%.(0-7
>?@ $*-( 1+#2.1,1#+ 0#-()0%# 1;/$%.- $2+ +#3#*(/#+
;1.16$.1(2 ;#$-)0#- .( ,$%1*1.$.# /#0;1. $//0(3$*-7 >?@
/0(31+#+ /#0;1. %((0+12$.1(29 $//*1%$.1(29 $2+ ,(**('F
)/ $%.131.1#- '1.& =.$.# $2+ *(%$* $6#2%1#-9 12%*)+126 .
@1%&16$2 P)5*1% =#031%#- C(;;1--1(29 @Q>R9 $2+ .
=.$.# S1-.(01% P0#-#03$.1(2 T,,1%#7 >?@ $*-( /0(31+#+
#L/#0. '1.2#-- -#031%#- 12 -#3#0$* %(2.#-.#+ %$-#
$0126- .( -)//(0. . ,12+126- (, . >D?7
A multi-team approach was used to expedite field
assessments along the entire 70-mile long corridor in a
shortened timeframe.
>2310(2;#2.$* /#0;1.- $2+ %*#$0$2%#- '#0# -)%%#--,)**4
(5.$12#+ ,0(; $** $6#2%1#- .( $**(' %(2-.0)%.1(2 (, .
-(). &$*, (, . /1/#*12#7 P#0;1.- $2+ $//0(3$*-
(5.$12#+ 12%*)+#+ @P=C C#0.1,1%$.# (, P)5*1%
C(23#21#2%# $2+ U#%#--1.49 @Q>R '#.*$2+ $2+ -.0#$;
%0(--1269 @QU? .&0#$.#2#+ $2+ #2+$26#0#+ -/#%1#-
%*#$0$2%#9 ;)*.1F%()2.4 -(1* $2+ -#+1;#2.$.1(2 %(2.0(*
$2+ +0$12 %0(--126 /#0;1.-9 $2+ UPQ>= +1-%&$06#
/#0;1.- ,(0 -.(0;'$.#0 $2+ &4+0(-.$.1% .#-. '$.#07
E -(). -#6;#2. '$- -)%%#--,)**4 %(2-.0)%.#+ '1.&
>?@ -.$,, /0(31+126 ,)** .1;# (2 -1.# #2310(2;#2.$*
12-/#%.1(27 >?@ /0(31+#+ (2F-1.# %#0.1,1#+ 12-/#%.(0- .(
#2-)0# %(2.0$%.(0 %(;/*1$2%# '1.& '#.*$2+9 -(1*
#0(-1(2V-#+1;#2.$.1(2 %(2.0(*9 -.0#$; $2+ +0$12
%0(--1269 $2+ (. #2310(2;#2.$* /0(.#%.1(29 ;1.16$.1(2
$2+ 0#-.(0$.1(2 ;#$-)0#-7 E 2(0. &$*, (, .
/1/#*12# %(001+(0 '$- 0#31-#+ .( $%%(;;(+$.# @P=C
0().126 %(2%#02-9 $2+ -1;1*$0 /#0;1.- '#0# -)%%#--,)**4
(5.$12#+ ,(0 . 0#31-#+ 0().#7
#$%&'($)*$+,- 788*88)*$+5'(0(8*4 9:;?@
$*-( #3$*)$.#+ . #,,#%.- (, . 12%0#$-#+ -(0.1#- $.
#2310(2;#2.$* 0#-()0%#- 12 . @E?-9 @T
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
11/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; FG
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
12/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; F;
?C ?@ /0(31+#+ *1%#2-1269 #2310(2;#2.$*9 #2612##01269
#%(2(;1%9 $2+ /#0;1..126 -)//(0. ,(0 $ X7` "CWQ _U[
1;/(0. .#0;12$* (2 . Q#*$'$0# ?13#0 12 -(). U#'
a#0-#4 ,(0 7 >?@ '$- 0#-/(2-15*# . #2.10#
>2310(2;#2.$* ?#-()0%# ?#/(0.9 12%*)+126 %((0+12$.1(2
'1.& . %04(6#21% $2+ %($-.$* +#-162 #2612##0-7 >?@
%(2+)%.#+ $ +#.$1*#+ $*.#02$.13#- $2$*4-1- .( -)//(0.
,$%1*1.4 -1.126 $2+ +#-1629 /0#/$0#+ . /0(B#%. S#$*.&$2+ =$,#.4 P*$27 >?@ %((0+12$.#+ '1.& . 87=7 C($-.
[)$0+ 0#6$0+126 . _#..#0 (, D2.#2. $2+ P0(B#%.
T/#0$.1(2- P*$29 $2+ '$- $*-( 0#-/(2-15*# ,(0 -#%)0126
$** 2#%#--$04 /#0;1.- ,0(; U#' a#0-#4 $2+ Q#*$'$0#7
?+(',6* 9,1&-&+L
E /0(/(-#+ .(
%(2-.0)%. $2+ (/#0$.# $ 6$- -.(0$6# ,$%1*1.4 12 @$0.12
C()2.49 W*(01+$9 %$/$5*# (, %(23#0.126 2$.)0$* 6$- .(
_U[ ,(0 (2-1.# -.(0$6# $2+ 0#6$-1,4126 . _U[ ,(0
+#*13#04 12 =().$-.#02 W*(01+$ +)0126 /#01(+- (, /#$A
+#;$2+ '1.&(). -#031%# 12.#00)/.1(2- 12 . /1/#*12#-7
!"# %&' ()* +),-./0&-(1 234(-&2(3- %3-5,46 %,()
7!"8 (3 9*-:3-; &4 *4?@ /0(31+#+ '#.*$2+ $--#--;#2.9 +#*12#$.1(29 $2+
/#0;1..126 -#031%#- .( ,(0 /1/#*12#12-.$**$.1(2-9 0#/*$%#;#2.-9 $2+ ;$12.#2$2%# $%.131.1#-7
>?@ -#%)0#+ 12+131+)$* '#.*$2+ /#0;1.- ,(0 /1/#*12#
12-.$**$.1(2 $2+ 0#/*$%#;#2. $%.131.1#- ,(0
.&0()6&(). %#2.0$* @$04*$2+ $2+ #$-.#02 P#22-4*3$21$7
>?@ '(0A#+ %*(-#*4 '1.& . 87=7 2612##0- 12 IHH: .( #L/#+1.# . '#.*$2+ /#0;1. 0#31#'
/0(%#-- -( .&$. %()*+ ;121;1O# /1/#*12# *(-- (,
-#031%# (2 /1/#*12#- .&$. 0#K)10#+ ;$12.#2$2%# '1.&12
0#6)*$.#+ '#.*$2+-7
#/? ?*'%&1*8 @('
>?@ %(;/*#.#+ $** -#031%#- 2#%#--$04 ,(0 .
#2310(2;#2.$* /#0;1..126 (, $ G7JF;1*# 2$.)0$* 6$-
/1/#*12# .( -)//*4 $ 2#' \:H @Z ;#0%&$2. #*#%.01%$*
6#2#0$.126 ,$%1*1.47 < %(;/*#.# #2310(2;#2.$* 1;/$%.
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
13/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; F!
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
14/55
!" $%&'()* +),(-./( 01-2&%3 $/01
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; !!
/'(' , 4)1?(.+
.1240(+/1& 4()/1' 16 +-( 6/)*+ J%,)+() KLMN< 1) O 21&+-*
6)12 4)141*,0 *%92/++,0D "#$ /* 4)(4,)(' +1 .122/+ +1
+-/* *.-('%0( *%9?(.+ +1 .()+,/& .1&'/+/1&* '(*.)/9('
below regarding factors outside of ERMs control.
P18(>()< +-( "#$ C)1?(.+ +(,2 4)141*(* , 4)1?(.+
*.-('%0( +-,+ 8/00 )(*%0+ /& .1240(+/1& 16 +-( C)1?(.+
8/+-/& +-/* +/2(6),2(D "#$ /* .122/++(' +1 ,001.,+/&7
+-( &(.(**,)= )(*1%).(* ,&' 2,&,7( +-( C)1?(.+ +1 2((+
+-( +,*Q 2/0(*+1&(* '(*.)/9(' /& +-( ,++,.-(' *.-('%0( /&
1)'() +1 ')/>( +-( C)1?(.+ +1 +-( (34(.+(' .1240(+/1&
',+(D
"#$ /* .%))(&+0= 81)Q/&7 1& +-)(( ";:*R S%.Q(=(< ,
8/&' 6,)2 4)1?(.+ /& T-/1 61) +-( U:HE:V W1)+-$(+< ,
.144() ,&' &/.Q(0 2/&( /& $/&&(*1+, 61) +-( U:XG"V
,&' ,& W"CX I1.%2(&+ 61) $1&Q :(,0 -,9/+,+ /&
P,8,// 61) WTXXD
F-(*( 4)1?(.+* ,)( 9(/&7 2,&,7(' 1%+ 16 1%) X&&,410/*/'( +-( I(4,)+2(&+ 8/+- , *+)1&7
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
15/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; !"
(014 , )(*1%).(501,'(' *.-('%0( +-,+ .1>()* +-(
(&+/)( 0/6( 16 +-( C)1?(.+D ;& *1 '1/&7< 8( -,>( 9((& ,90(
+1 ,&+/./4,+( 8-,+ *Q/00* 8/00 9( &(('(' ,&' 8-(& +-(=
8/00 9( &(('('< ,0018/&7 %* +1 40,& 61) .-,&7(* /& *+,66
01,'/&7 1>() +-( .1%)*( 16 +-( C)1?(.+D "#$ 8/00 4)1>/'(
, '),6+ *.-('%0( 61) )(>/(8 ,+ +-( @/.Q5166 $((+/&7D
:12( Q(= 2/0(*+1&(* +-,+ 8/00 /&61)2 +-( :";: )(>/(84)1.(** ,)( &1+ =(+ Q&18&V +-(*( /&.0%'( +-( )(*%0+* 16
&(8 6/(0' *+%'/(* ,01&7 +-( )(>/*(' )1%+( ,&' +-( WI"\
(>,0%,+/1& )(41)+ ,&' 4()2/+D "#$ %&'()*+,&'* +-(
&((' 61) *.-('%0( 60(3/9/0/+= ,&' 81)Q/&7 8/+- +-(
I(4,)+2(&+ 8/00 ,'?%*+ +-( *.-('%0( ,* &(('(' +1
,..1221',+( 4)1?(.+ ,&' 4)1.(** .-,&7(*D
Schedule Control"#$ %*(* 4)1?(.+ 40,&&/&7 *16+8,)( *%.- ,* $/.)1*16+
C)1?(.+ ,* &(('(' +1 -(04 *.-('%0( .1&+)10D U*/&7
$/.)1*16+ C)1?(.+ "#$ 8/00 '(>(014 , )(*1%).(501,'('
*.-('%0( +-,+ .1>()* +-( (&+/)( 0/6( 16 +-( C)1?(.+D ;& *1
'1/&7< 8( -,>( 9((& ,90( +1 ,&+/./4,+( 8-,+ *Q/00* 8/00
9( &(('(' ,&' 8-(& +-(= 8/00 9( &(('('< ,0018/&7 %* +1
40,& 61) .-,&7(* /& *+,66 01,'/&7 1>() +-( .1%)*( 16 +-(
C)1?(.+D
:+(>( @1*+()< ,* C)1?(.+ $,&,7()< 8/00 9( )(*41&*/90( 61)
40,&&/&7< *.-('%0/&7< ,&' 4)17)(** +),.Q/&7 .1&*/*+/&7
16 *+,)+%4 40,&&/&7 61) (,.- +,*QV )(7%0,) 4)1?(.+ +(,2
2((+/&7* +1 4)1>/'( )(,05+/2( %4',+( 16 4)1?(.+ *+,+%*
,&' +1 6,./0/+,+( .122%&/.,+/1& )(7,)'/&7 .-,&7(* /&
*.-('%0(< *+),+(7=< 1) 4)1?(.+ '(*/7&V '(+,/0(' 4)1?(.+
40,&&/&7 ,&' 61.%*/&7 1& .)/+/.,0 4,+- /+(2* ,&'
'(0/>(),90(*V ,&' /&'/>/'%,0 +,*Q 4)17)(** )(>/(8 ,&'
)(41)+*D F-/* 0(>(0 16 4)1?(.+ 40,&&/&7 8/00 9( , &(.(**/+=
7/>(& +-( 6,*+ +),.Q 0(,'/&7 +1 +-( *%92/++,0 16 CI:";: +1
+-( I(4,)+2(&+ 1& I,= OLD
Organizational Policy andStructure"#$ -,* , 8(005(*+,90/*-(' 4,)+&()*-/4 21'(0 +-,+
61)2* +-( 61%&',+/1& 16 1%) 1)7,&/Z,+/1&,0 410/.= ,&'
*+)%.+%)( 81)0'8/'(D E( 2,/&+,/& , ),+/1 16
,44)13/2,+(0= 1&( 4,)+&() 4() ML (2401=((*< ,&' ,
partner is assigned to every project. ERMs pa)+&()5
4)1?(.+ 2,&,7() 21'(0 ,0018* (,.- 4,)+&() +1 *+,=
(&7,7(' 8/+- 1%) .0/(&+*< *+,= /& +1%.- 8/+- 9,.Q017 ,&'
-/)/&7 &(('*< ,&' 4)1>/'( \X]\G 1& ,00 4)141*,0* ,&'
'(0/>(),90(*D "#$ -,* 7)18& 1)7,&/.,00=< ,&' 1%)1)7,&/Z,+/1&,0 4,)+&()*-/4 21'(0 -,* 9((& /&+,.+ 61)
1>() N^ =(,)*D
ERM stresses a flat organizational structure based on
+-( 4,)+&()*-/4 21'(0 '(*.)/9(' ,91>(< ,&'
.100,91),+/1& 9(+8((& 166/.(* /* (&.1%),7(' ,&'
/&.(&+/>/Z('D F-( 0,.Q 16 01.,0 4)16/+ .(&+()* (&*%)(* +-,+
8( ,.+ /& 1%) .0/(&+* 9(*+ /&+()(*+ )(7,)'0(** 16 4)1?(.+
01.,+/1&D E( )(.17&/Z( +-( /241)+,&.( 16 -,>/&7
(34()/(&.(' 4)1?(.+ 2,&,7()* +-,+ ,)( '('/.,+(' +1 1%)
4)1?(.+* ,+ *+),+(7/. 01.,+/1&*< *%441)+(' 9= 01.,0 *+,66
,&' *%9.1&+),.+1)* +1 2/&/2/Z( +),>(0< .1*+*< ,&',**1./,+(' (&>/)1&2(&+,0 /24,.+* Y/D(D< 7)((&-1%*(
7,*(*[D
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
16/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; !#
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
17/55
The worlds leading sustainability consultancy
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; !$
/)1&2(&+,0 #(*1%).(* $,&,7(2(&+ NN 41/&+* /& +-(
C)1?(.+< /&.0%'/&7 )(>/(8 16 ,00 '(0/>(),90(* 4)/1) +1
*%92/++,0D F-( )(*%0+ /* , *(+ 16 .1&*/*+(&+ 4)1?(.+
2,&,7(2(&+ 9(-,>/1)* 61) +-( (&+/)( 4)1?(.+ +(,2D
CommunicationsG0(,) 0/&(* 16 ,..1%&+,9/0/+= ,&' )(41)+/&7 ,)( .)/+/.,0 +1
*%..(**6%0 4)1?(.+ 2,&,7(2(&+ ,&' .122%&/.,+/1&*D
T%) 1)7,&/Z,+/1&,0 .-,)+< /& :(.+/1& N< *%22,)/Z(* )10(*
,&' 0/&(* 16 )(41)+/&7 61) +-( C)1?(.+D @(= 4()*1&&(0.122%&/.,+( ,021*+ .1&+/&%1%*0= ,91%+ *.14(('
/24)14)/(+=< /&,44)14)/,+( %*( 16 .1&6/'(&+/,0 /&61)2,+/1&< 1) +-( 4().(4+/1& +-,+ "#$ -,* .)(,+(' , .1&60/.+ 9(+8((&
'%+/(* 18(' +1 '/66()(&+ .0/(&+*D F18,)' +-,+ (&'< 8( -,>( '(>(014(' , 4)1.('%)( +1 /'(&+/6= .0/(&+ )(4)(*(&+,+/1&
/**%(* ,)/*/&7 1%+ 16 41+(&+/,00= *(&*/+/>( .0/(&+ (&7,7(2(&+*D F-/* 4)1.('%)( -,* 9((& 610018(' +1 (&*%)( +-,+ "#$
-,* &1 .1&60/.+ 8/+- +-( 4)141*(' @(=*+1&( AB C/4(0/&( C)1?(.+D
+*(? FG ;&+()&,0 #(*(,).- +-( F,)7(+ G124,&= 16 +-/* G#G 5 ,* 2%.- /&61)2,+/1& ,* 41**/90( /* (*+,90/*-(' ,91%+
+-( F,)7(+ G124,&= ,&' .1&+(3+ 61) +-( 4)1?(.+D `019,0 ,&' @(= G0/(&+* 0/*+* ,)( )(>/(8(' ,* 8(00 ,* 1+-() /&+()&,0*,0(* +110 )(*1%).(* +1 *(( 8-,+ 81)Q Y/6 ,&=[ -,* 9((& '1&( 1) /* 1&71/&7 8/+- +-( F,)7(+ G124,&=D
+*(? HGX G#G (2,/0 /&J%/)= /* *(&+ +1 Q(= 9%*/&(** %&/+ 0(,'()*< 4),.+/.( 0(,'()*< ,&' 1+-() ,44)14)/,+( Q(=
4()*1&&(0 +-)1%7-1%+ "#$D +*(? IGResponders (a) check ERMs client databases, (b) confidentially check ERMs institutional knowledge of
+-( 4,)+/.%0,) .124,&=< ,&' Y.[ )(*41&' 8/+- /&61)2,+/1& )(7,)'/&7 8-,+ 81)Q "#$ -,* '1&(< 1) /* '1/&7< 8/+-+-( .124,&=D
+*(? JGFollow up communications with ERM staff are completed as needed and any additional research is
4()61)2('D
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
22/55
ATTACHMENT C
OCI ONGOING OBLIGATIONS CERTIFICATION
I recognize that OCI is an ongoing obligation. Should I or my organization become aware of any actual or
potential OCIs during performance of this contract, I or my organization will advise the Department of State and
(Contractor/Applicant Name) and propose mitigation or explain why none is needed. I provide a description of
internal controls for ensuring OCI does not arise during the Project on the attached page(s).
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; ":
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
23/55
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; ";
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
24/55
7. What percentage of your total income for the current and preceding fiscal years resulted from arrangements with anyof the entities identified in Question 6 above?
--_0_% For the current fiscal year from _____________ to ____________.
_0_% --For the preceding fiscal year from _____________to ._____________
_0_% --For the second preceding fiscal year from _____________to ._____________
8. Do you (or your organization) currently have or have you had during the last 6 years any arrangements (for example,contracts and cooperative agreements) awarded, administered, or funded -- wholly or partly -- by the Department ofState or any other Federal agency which relate to the proposed Statement of Work?(X) No.
( ) Yes. A full disclosure and discussion is given on the attached pages.
9. Do you (or your organization) have or have you ever had any contracts, agreements, special clauses, or otherarrangements which prohibit you (or your organization) from proposing work to be performed in this solicitation orany portion thereof?(X) No.
( ) Yes. A full disclosure and discussion is given on the attached pages.
10. Do you (or your organization) have any involvement with or interest (direct or indirect) in technologies which are ormay be subjects of the contract, or which may be substitutable for such technologies?
(X) No.( ) Yes. A full disclosure and discussion is given on the attached pages.
11. Could you (or your organization) in either your private or Federal Government business pursuits use informationacquired in the performance of the proposed work; such as:(a) Data generated under the contract?
(b) Information concerning Department plans and programs?
(c) Confidential and proprietary data of others?
(X) No.
( ) Yes. A full disclosure and discussion is given on the attached pages.
12. Under the proposed work, will you (or your organization) evaluate or inspect your own services or products, or theservices or products of any other entity that has a relationship (such as client, organizational, financial, or other) with
you (or your organization)? This could include evaluating or inspecting a competitor's goods and services.(X) No.
( ) Yes. A full disclosure and discussion is given on the attached pages.
13. To avoid what you perceive as a possible organizational conflict of interest, do you (or your organization) propose to:exclude portions of the proposed work; employ special clauses; or take other measures?(X) No.
( ) Yes. A full discussion is given on the attached pages.
( ) No possibility of an organizational conflict of interest is perceived. This answer is briefly justified on theattached pages.
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; "!
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
25/55
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; ""
(& '/66()(&+ 9%*/&(** ,)(,*< =(+ ,00 6,00 %&'() , 7(&(),0 -(,'/&7 16 (&>/)1&2(&+,0 *()>/.(*D "#$
4)1>/'(* (&>/)1&2(&+,0 *()>/.(* /& +-( 4)/>,+( ,&' 4%90/. 1/0 ,&' &,+%),0 7,* /&'%*+)= /& %4*+)(,2< 2/'5*+)(,2
,&' '18&*+)(,2 *(.+1)*D
F-( 2,?1) 9%*/&(** ,)(,* 61) "#$ /&.0%'(R
;24,.+ X**(**2(&+ C),.+/.( Y+-( 4)141*(' +-/)'54,)+= I(4,)+2(&+ :";: 81%0' 6,00 %&'() +-/* 4),.+/.(,)(,< ,0+-1%7- *4(./,0/*+* 81%0' 9( '),8& 6)12 1+-() 4),.+/.( ,)(,* /& '(>(014/&7 +-( 4)141*(' :";:[V
:%*+,/&,9/0/+= ,&' G0/2,+( G-,&7( C),.+/.(V
#/*Q $,&,7(2(&+ C),.+/.(V
C()61)2,&.( X**%),&.( C),.+/.(V
G1&+,2/&,+(' :/+( $,&,7(2(&+ C),.+/.(V X/) \%,0/+= ,&' W1/*( C),.+/.(V
F),&*,.+/1& :()>/.(* C),.+/.(D
X''/+/1&,0 /&61)2,+/1& 1& "#$ 9%*/&(** 4),.+/.( ,)(,* .,& 9( 4)1>/'(' +1 +-( I(4,)+2(&+ %41& )(J%(*+D
M.(7*:&1 I 5(7?&17(
All of ERMs affiliates conduct work similar to that described in the response to Question 2. The names and
*+)%.+%)( 16 "#$ ,&' /+* ,66/0/,+(* ,)( ,++,.-(' ,* H/7%)( M 1& +-( 610018/&7 4,7(D
M.(7*:&1 J 5(7?&17(
"#$ *+,66 8/00 9( /&>10>(' /& 4()61)2/&7 +-( W"CX 81)Q ,* *4(./6/(' /& +-( *10/./+,+/1&D
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
26/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
27/55
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; "$
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
28/55
"# $%&'(%&
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; !"
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
29/55
!"#$%& ($)$%* +%,)-$.%"$ /0 ($)$%123 45678968 3):% ; !#
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
30/55
Delivering sustainable solutions in a more competitive world
!"#$#% '( )*+"#,- .(/(
Project Manager
"#$%$ &'(#$) *+( ,')$ #*+- ./ 0$+)( '1 $23$)4$-5$ 4-
$-%4)'-,$-#+6 4,3+5# +(($((,$-#7 3$),4##4-87 +-9
4,3+5# ,4#48+#4'- 1') '46 +-9 8+( 3)':$5#(;
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
31/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
32/55
!"#$%& ()%*+,-&.,)
Deputy Project Manager/Cultural Resources
"#$ %&'#() *+(,-./)0.+ +0 - 1#/2(34 "-&-5(# -&' 6(&+/#
78,48#-, 9(0/8#3(0 6:(3+-,+04 )+4; ?(-#0 /@(A:(#+(&3($ B( ;-0
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
33/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
34/55
"#$%& '( )*#+#, -./0
NEPA Specialists
"#$ %&'(' (') *+ ,-'#) ./ -01-#2-34- 23 -352#.36-37'& 261'47
'))-))6-378 3'79#'& '3: 49&79#'& #-).9#4- 6'3';-6-378 '3:
&'3: 1&'3323; /.# &.4'&8 )7'7-8 #-;2.3'&8 '3: /-:-#'& ;.5-#36-37)
23 7(- 2)7.#24 D#-)-#5'72.3 E478 '3:C0-49725- I#:-#) /.# ?-7&'3:)8 /&..:1&'23)8 '3: -352#.36-37'&
J9)724-$ >- (') -07-3)25- -01-#2-34- 23 69&72K6-:2' 1-#627723;
./ &'#;- LMNGO2&&2.3P '3: ./7-3 4.37#.5-#)2'& 23/#')7#9479#-
1#.J-47)$ =1-42'& -01-#72)- 23 -5'&9'723; -3-#;,8 62323;8
62&27'#,8 ?'7-# #-).9#4-8 7-&-4.669324'72.38 7#'3)1.#7'72.38
'3: &'3: 9)- 1#.J-47)$
Professional Affiliaions & Registration
E6-#24'3 Q3)72797- ./ R-#72/2-: D&'33-#)8 GSTH E6-#24'3 D&'3323; E)).42'72.3 E6-#24'3 U'7-# V-).9#4-) E)).42'72.3 B'72.3'& E)).42'72.3 ./ C352#.36-37'& D#./-))2.3'&)Fields of Competence
C352#.36-37'& 261'47 '))-))6-37 /.# ' ?2:- 5'#2-7, ./1#.J-47) 234&9:23; 121-&23-)8 62&27'#, .1-#'72.3)8 62323;8
'2#1.#7)8 #-)-#5.2#)8 6'#23')8 (,:#.-&-47#24 1.?-# 1#.J-47)8
WBX 261.#7 7-#623'&)8 ;') 121-&23-)8 (2;(?',)8 7#'3)278
(.9)23;8 1'#Y)8 '3: 23:9)7#2'& :-5-&.16-37$
U'7-# #-).9#4-)8 234&9:23; ?'7-# )911&, 1&'3323; '3: ?'7-#A9'&27, 6'3';-6-37$ E3'&,)-) ./ ).9#4-)8 A9'37272-)8 7,1-)8
7#'3)1.#78 '3: /'7- ./ 1.&&97'37)$ =Y2&&-: 23 7(- :-5-&.16-37
./ ?'7-#)(-: '3: ?-&&(-': 1#.7-472.3 1&'3) /.# )9#/'4- '3:
;#.93:?'7-# )911&2-) '3: 4.61#-(-3)25- #25-# O')23 )79:2-)$
U-7&'3: -4.&.;,8 234&9:23; ?-7&'3: :-&23-'72.38 /93472.3'&'))-))6-37)8 6272;'72.3 :-)2;38 1-#627723;8 '3: 1#.7-472.3
1&'3323;$
Delivering sustainable solutions in a more competitive world.
Education
"')7-# ./ C352#.36-37'& "'3';-6-378 Z9Y-
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
35/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
36/55
!"#$$"%%" '(#$)
Wetlands, Terrestrial Vegetation, Wildlife
"#$%%#& '$( )* +#$,( -. #/0#,1#%2# $( $ 31-4-51(&6 $%72-8041$%2# $%7 0#,81&&1%5 (0#21$41(& .-, 894&1:71(21041%$,+ 0,-;#2&( &',-95'-9&
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
37/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
38/55
!"#$ &' ()$)*
NEPA Specialists
"#$ %&'&( &) * +,'&(# -(')./0*'0 &' 01, 234*506)),))3,'0 *'7 8/*''&'9 4#*50&5, *0 :;"$
Credentials
V,0/*'7 L,/&',*0&(' W#*&'&'9 IXYO1(.#)JC V,0/*'7W#*&'&'9 2')0&0.0,C 2'5$C STUT
%:;- H*0.#*/ Z*) 8&4,/&', :'D('3,'0*/-(34/&*'5, W#*&'&'9C %:;-C STT[ *'7 =YY=
:86 -(.#), S[>$>\
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
39/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
40/55
!"#$% '( )*"+"#, -()(
Hydrogeologist
"#$ %&'() *$ +#&,&' -) & ./0(# 1-/, *2" &03 4&)(3 -0/,(
"#$ +#&,&' ,&) 56(# 78 9() 5: (;? =5'&/-50 &03#('(3-&/-50 5: 5-@ &03 >&) :&=-@-/-() A('(0/ 5: :(3(#&@? )/&/(? 'B0-=- &03 "&0B:&=/B#-0>Publications
.#()(0/&/-50) &03
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
41/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
42/55
"#$%#$& '($#)*
Soils and Geology
"#$ %'() *)+ ,-'# ./ 0')#+ ,1 '23'#&'45' &4 6'+&74&478
5,4695:&478 )46 ;)4)7&47 ;))#68 M,>) G:):'F4&-'#+&:08 QRST$
Key Projects
Delivering sustainable solutions in a more competitive world.
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
43/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
44/55
Delivering sustainable solutions in a more competitive world
"#$%&' "( )*+,&*+%
Wetlands, Terrestrial Vegetation, Wildlife
"#$ %&'()&'* '+, -./# 01 2/+#, /34/#)/5&/ ,/#.)56)578,*#29 4#).+*/ :8,)5/,,/, +57 6-./#5;/5* :+,/7&()/5*, )5 7/()./#)56 4#-5-?(/76/ #/(+*/7*- /5.)#-5;/5*+( +57 #/68(+*-#2 &-;4()+5&/$ @/ '+,4#-.)7/7 + ?)7/ #+56/ -= &-5,8(*)56 ,/#.)&/, )5&(87)56ABCD &-;4()+5&/ =-# ;8(*)4(/ :8,)5/,, ,/&*-#,)5&(87)56 -)( +57 6+,9 4-?/#9 +57 4)4/()5/ +(( )5,844-#* -= *'/ BDEBF% 4#-&/,,/,$
G./# *'/ 4+,* */5 2/+#, "#$ %&'()&'* '+, ;+5+6/74#-(+'-;+9 D(+:+;+ +57 ")&')6+5$
Fields of Competence
Y)-(-6)&+( ;-5)*-#)56 HBIJ KL&M ABCD LBD +57 BF% U/./(-4;/5*M C/#;)**)56 LS%DJB Z[Z9 %/&*)-5 0[9 JPD Z[0M B5.)#-5;/5*+( +,,/,,;/5*, ACUB% 4/#;)**)56 V'#/+*/5/7 +57 B57+56/#/7 %4/&)/, %*87)/, \
%/&*)-5 K B%D &-;4()+5&/
P/*(+57, 7/*/#;)5+*)-5 +57 7/()5/+*)-5 ,*87)/,Education
Y%9 Y)-(-629 V/3+, V/&' S5)./#,)*29 0]][Professional Affiliations
P/*(+57 V#+)5)56 F5,*)*8*/ T+(./,*-5 Y+2 B,*8+#)/, C#-6#+; V^ J-#4-#+*/ P/*(+57, I/,*-#+*)-5 C+#*5/#,')4_
J-+,*+( D;/#)&+
V/3+, J'+4*/# -= *'/ D;/#)&+5 H),'/#)/, %-&)/*2 T+(./,*-5 Y+2 H-857+*)-5Training and Certifications
V/3+, D`" B3*/5,)-5 C#-6#+; _ C(+5* F7/5*)=)&+*)-5J(+,,
P/*(+57, U/()5/+*)-5 T/5/#+( %)*/ V#+)5)56 I/a8)#/7 :2 G%@D O] JHI
0]0[$0O[
J-5*#+&*-#, %+=/*2 J-85&)( Y+,)& C(8, V#+)5)56 J-5*#+&*-#, %+=/*2 J-85&)( %)*/ %4/&)=)& _ G32
F56(/,)7/ %)*/
J-;4(/*/7 H/7/#+( B5/#62 I/68(+*-#2 J-;;),,)-5B5.)#-5;/5*+( J-;4()+5&/ +57 B5.)#-5;/5*+(I/4-#* C#/4+#+*)-5 %/;)5+#
S%DJB P/*(+57 C/#;)**)56 %/;)5+#
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
45/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
46/55
Delivering sustainable solutions in a more competitive world
"#$%&'($ )*++'&$, -./0
Socioeconomics and Land Use
"#$ %&' ()**+,' -* , ./'*)01,'1 2-13 45" 6,*&7 -'$ 8& 3,* +/#& 13,' 13-#1&&' 9&,#*: &;'$ 8&3,* J#,'* %#/2'D-&07* N/0-.9 ,'7 #&*&,#.3 L&/>#,
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
47/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
48/55
Delivering sustainable solutions in a more competitive world
!"#$ &'()*$+
Senior Fisheries Scientist
"#$ %#&'()* +#,*(- ./)# 01 2)3#- .4 )*/,#.*5)*637)89)#,)*:) 6. 377 .4 ;,- 9#.)- ,*53*3(,*( ,*6)#',-:,97,*3#2 )*/,#.*5)*637 9#.(#35-3*' ')-,(*,*( 3*' :.*'&:6,*( 4,)7' -6&',)-$ =) ;3-+#.3' )89)#,)*:) ?,6; -636) 3*' 4)')#37 #)(&736,.*-,*:7&',*( 6;) @36,.*37 A*/,#.*5)*637 B.7,:2 C:6D@ABCEF A*'3*()#)' G9):,)- C:6F "3#,*) "35537
B#.6):6,.* C:6F A--)*6,37 H,-; =3+,636 )/37&36,.*-F I7)3*J36)# C:6F ",(#36.#2 K,#' G9):,)- C:6F G636) .4 C73-L3H,-; 3*' M35) N)(&736,.*- 3*' G636) .4 C73-L3 J36)#O&37,62 N)(&736,.*-$ =) ;3- ')-,(*)' 3*' ,597)5)*6)'9#.(#35- 4.# 4,-; )/37&36,.*- 37.*( 6;) PQQ 5,7) %CBG9,9)7,*)F 53*3()' 6)35- .4 -:,)*6,-6- :.77):6,*( +3-)7,*)4,-;F +)*6;,:F 973*L6.*F -)',5)*6 3*' 9;2-,:37 #,/)#,)*;3+,636 93#35)6)#- 4.# 3 /3#,)62 .4 9#.
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
49/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
50/55
"#$$ %&''&()*
Fisheries and Aquatic Habitat
+,- %&''&()* .(* /0#, 12 3#(,* /$ #45#,C# &6 8.#
(9:(8&7 ;&/'/5#7&('8* &67':=# $'= (**#**)#68*? 5#,)&88&6 V*#, O(5(;&'&8* &6 >:55/,8 /$K(8:,(' I#*/:,7# +(6(7D&*8* +&7.&
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
51/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
52/55
Delivering sustainable solutions in a more competitive world
Pipeline Risk/Failure Analysis
!"#$%& () *"+",-$./0 1)2)
"#$%&'()%*+ ,-.-/%*+ -.* $-&0(1($-0%* (. -))%)),%.0)-.* &%,%*(-0(2. $&23%10) (. 04% 5.(0%* "0-0%)+ 6#&2$%+-.* 7-0(. 8,%&(1- 92& :; (&%10?< (.'2?'%* @(042.A)(0% &%)02&-0(2. 29 /&2#.* @-0%&+ )#&9-1% @-0%& -.* )2(?#0(?(B(./ (.0%/&-0%* %.'(&2.,%.0-? %C#($,%.0 )
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
53/55
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
54/55
"#$%& '()$* +,-,
Greenhouse Gas, Air Quality, and Noise
"#$ %&'( )* +," ,-.)'(/0 1-23()2/0 4)*2)50)(- 6-/7 &'#/2'8*9)2* :/*-7 )( $ ;)(
-
8/12/2019 XCLUSIVE State Dept. Hid Contractor's Ties to Keystone XL Pipeline Company Start at Page 30 Unredacted-keysto
55/55