Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the...

37
Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R. Bosch Director, FHWA Aerodynamics Laboratory 2 nd Workshop on Wind-Induced Vibrations of Cable-Stayed Bridges St. Louis, MO April 25-27, 2006

Transcript of Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the...

Page 1: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States

H.R. BoschDirector, FHWA Aerodynamics Laboratory

2nd Workshop on Wind-Induced Vibrations of Cable-Stayed Bridges

St. Louis, MO

April 25-27, 2006

Page 2: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

US Cable-Stayed Bridges

Page 3: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Luling Bridge

Overview

Bridge monitoredsince opening (1984)

Comprehensivecable inspectionunderway (2006)

Occasional cablevibrations observed

Page 4: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Luling Bridge

Stays and Cross-Girders

Stays in groups of 2 or 4

Stays are grouted

Smooth PE pipe, nohelical fillet

Page 5: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Luling Bridge

Neoprene Washer

Black HDPE pipe

Covered with white tapewhile in service

Neoprene washer at cross-girder

No internal neoprene bushings

Page 6: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Fred Hartman Bridge

Overview

Vibrations duringconstruction

Cross-ties later removeddue to failure

Cross-ties added shortlyafter opening

Dampers recently added

Page 7: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Fred Hartman Bridge

Original Cross Ties

Figure “8” Configuration

Stays grouted

Covered with yellow tape

Smooth surface

Page 8: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Fred Hartman Bridge

Wire Failures Guide Pipe Failures

Page 9: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Fred Hartman Bridge

Dampers

Page 10: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Veteran’s Memorial Bridge

Overview

Stays grouted

Vibrations observedin service

Smooth surface

Covered with yellowtape

Page 11: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Veteran’s Memorial Bridge

Dampers

Aerodynamic rings anddampers evaluated

Recently retrofit withdampers

Page 12: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Burlington Bridge

Overview

Stays grouted

Vibrations observedduring construction

Cross-ties added 1995(1 year after opening)

Smooth surface

Page 13: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Burlington Bridge

Cross-Ties – Two Lines

Cross-ties not anchored to deck

Page 14: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Burlington Bridge

Cross-Ties – Three Lines

Cross-ties not anchored to deck

Page 15: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Burlington Bridge

Cross Tie Configuration – Figure “8”

Page 16: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Weirton-Steubenville Bridge

Overview

Stays grouted

Smooth surface

Covered with whitetape

Vibrations observedduring construction

Page 17: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Weirton-Steubenville Bridge

Damper Assembly – Behind Facia Panel

Retrofit with dampers(2004)

Dampers at upper end

Two dampers per cable

Page 18: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

East Huntington Bridge

Overview

Stays grouted

Smooth surface

Covered with whitetape

Vibrations observedin service

Page 19: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

East Huntington Bridge

Damper Assembly – Behind Facia Panel

Retrofit with dampers

Dampers at upper end

Single damper per cable

Page 20: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

East Huntington Bridge

Damper Array – Looking Up Tower

Page 21: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Clark Bridge

Overview

Stays grouted

Smooth surface

Vibrations observedduring construction

Page 22: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Clark Bridge

Cross-Ties – Two Lines

Cross-ties anchored to deck

Page 23: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Clark Bridge

Cross-Ties – Two Lines

Cross-ties anchored to deck

Page 24: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Talmadge Bridge

Overview

Stays grouted

Smooth surface

Covered with whitetape

Occasional vibrationsobserved in service

Page 25: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Talmadge Bridge

Concrete spalling and cracked guide pipe

Page 26: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Cochrane Bridge

Overview

Cables retrofit withdampers

Significant vibrationsobserved in service

Page 27: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Cochrane Bridge

Damper

Page 28: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Charles River Bridge

Overview

Ungrouted stays

HDPE pipe withhelical fillet

Cross-ties

Elastomeric dampers

Included in design:

Page 29: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Charles River Bridge

Cross Tie and Deck Anchorage

Single line of cross-tiesanchored to deck

Page 30: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Charles River Bridge

Cross Ties and Aerodynamic Surface

In-line configuration

Page 31: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Charles River Bridge

Elastomeric Damper

During Installation

Page 32: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Cape Girardeau Bridge

Overview

Stays are grouted

HDPE pipe withhelical fillet

Page 33: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Cape Girardeau Bridge

Cross Tie and Aerodynamic Surface

Four lines of cross-ties

Aerodynamic surface

In-line configuration

Included in design:

Page 34: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Cape Girardeau Bridge

Cross Tie Deck Anchorage

Each cross-tie line anchored to edge girder

Page 35: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Cooper River Bridge

Overview

Helical fillet

Several types of dampers

Provisions for futurecross-ties

Included in design:

Page 36: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Cooper River Bridge

Provisions for Future Wind Ties

Helical filletWind tie fitting

Page 37: Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the …contribute.modot.mo.gov/csb/documents/02-ReviewofBridgeCable... · Wind-Induced Vibration of Bridge Cables in the United States H.R.

Cooper River Bridge

Dampers

Internal External