We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data...

58
We may keep the corals but lose the reefs

Transcript of We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data...

Page 1: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200

We may keep the corals but lose the reefs

Page 2: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 3: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 4: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 5: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 6: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 7: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 8: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 9: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 10: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 11: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 12: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 13: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 14: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 15: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 16: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 17: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 18: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 19: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 20: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 21: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 22: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 23: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 24: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 25: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 26: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 27: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200

Hughes and Tanner 2000

Gardner et al. 2003

Page 28: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 29: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 30: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 31: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 32: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 33: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 34: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 35: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 36: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 37: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 38: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 39: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 40: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 41: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 42: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 43: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 44: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 45: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 46: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 47: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 48: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200

Gladfelter 1982

Page 49: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 50: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 51: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 52: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 53: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 54: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 55: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200

Tomascik et al. 1996 Coral Reefs 15: 169-175

1991 - 1996

Page 56: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 57: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200
Page 58: We may keep the corals but lose the reefs...RC02 30 25 20 15 10 -600 Effect of Smoothing 13C Data RC02 stnd smoothed —O— RC02 ô13C raw (mean) data -500 -400 -300 Time (my) -200