VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse...

22
VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk RATING REPORT Faysal Bank Limited REPORT DATE: June 29, 2020 RATING ANALYSTS: Narendar Shankar Lal [email protected] COMPANY INFORMATION Established in 1994 External auditors: A.F. Ferguson & Co. Chartered Accountants Public Limited Company Chairman of the Board: Mr. Farooq Rahmatullah Key Shareholders (with stake 5% or more): CEO: Mr. Yousaf Hussain Ithmaar Bank B.S.C – 48.06% Faisal Finance (Luxemborg) S.A. – 8.55% MFAI (Jersey) Limited – 5. 89% State Life Insurance Corporation of Pakistan 5.30% General Public – 14.6% RATING DETAILS Rating Category Latest Rating Previous Rating Long- term Short- term Long- term Short- term Entity Rating AA A-1+ AA A-1+ Outlook Stable Stable Date June 29, ‘20 June 27, ‘19 APPLICABLE METHODOLOGY(IES) Commercial Banks (March 2018): https://www.vis.com.pk/kc-meth.aspx

Transcript of VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse...

Page 1: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

RATING REPORT

Faysal Bank Limited

REPORT DATE:

June 29, 2020 RATING ANALYSTS:

Narendar Shankar Lal [email protected]

COMPANY INFORMATION

Established in 1994 External auditors: A.F. Ferguson & Co. Chartered Accountants

Public Limited Company Chairman of the Board: Mr. Farooq Rahmatullah

Key Shareholders (with stake 5% or more): CEO: Mr. Yousaf Hussain

Ithmaar Bank B.S.C – 48.06%

Faisal Finance (Luxemborg) S.A. – 8.55%

MFAI (Jersey) Limited – 5. 89%

State Life Insurance Corporation of Pakistan – 5.30%

General Public – 14.6%

RATING DETAILS

Rating Category

Latest Rating Previous Rating

Long-term

Short-term

Long-term

Short-term

Entity Rating AA A-1+ AA A-1+

Outlook Stable Stable

Date June 29, ‘20 June 27, ‘19

APPLICABLE METHODOLOGY(IES) Commercial Banks (March 2018): https://www.vis.com.pk/kc-meth.aspx

Page 2: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

2 | P a g e

Faysal Bank Limited

OVERVIEW OF THE

INSTITUTION RATING RATIONALE

Ithmaar Bank B.S.C (IB), a Islamic Retail Bank in Bahrain and Kuwait, is the parent bank of Faysal Bank

Limited, holding directly and indirectly,

66.8% of FBL’s shares.

FBL has a branch network of 555

branches (2018: 455); including 413 Islamic branches (2018: 254)

and 1 Islamic sub-branch (2018: 1) in

Pakistan.

Profile of Chairman

Mr. Farooq Rahmatullah is a

seasoned professional with a diverse

experience in several roles in different

organizations. He is a Law graduate and is currently serving on

Board of three other organizations.

Profile of CEO

Mr. Yousaf Hussain has over 25 years of

professional experience, primarily at ABN AMRO

Bank where he held multiple senior managerial positions including those

within the Corporate / Credit and Transaction Banking functions. He has been affiliated with

Faysal Bank since August 2008, with a significant

contribution to the franchise in his previous

positions as Chief Risk Officer.

FBL is a mid-sized bank engaged in provision of conventional and Islamic Corporate, Commercial and Consumer banking services. The bank has a market share of 4.1% (2018: 4.1%) and 3.1% (2018: 3.1%) in domestic advances and domestic deposits, respectively. Long term strategic vision of the bank entails transformation of the business model from a Conventional bank offering Islamic banking services to a full-fledged Islamic bank. An asset led conversion model has been adopted by the management in this regard. At end Q1’20, total Sharia compliant deposits as proportion of total deposits were reported at 27.5%, while Islamic advances represented 41.1% of total financing portfolio. Management expects to completely transform into an Islamic bank by end-2023.

Rating Rationale

Gross financing portfolio witnessed moderate growth but asset quality indicators declined slightly during 2019 (due to industry-wide defaults of a few borrowers). In the long run, asset quality indicators are expected to decrease further in line with the banking sector given the negative impact of COVID-19 on repayment capacity of many borrowers

Gross financing portfolio of FBL depicted modest growth of 4.2% to increase to Rs. 333.8b (2018: Rs. 320.3b) at end-2019. With conversion of conventional loans to Islamic loans and booking of new loans under Islamic mode of financing, Islamic financing and related assets registered increase to Rs. 116.1b (2018: Rs. 79.0b) at end-2019. Corporate advances continue to remain the mainstay of the bank as the same constituted more than three-fourth of the total advances portfolio. Going forward, focus will continue to remain on corporate segment with selective growth in commercial, SME and consumer segments. Government’s decision to enhance limits of SME borrowers in the wake of COVID-19 pandemic provides additional incentive to the bank to cater to this segment. Client wise concentration in advances witnessed slight decrease as funded exposures of top-20 clients accounted for 37.4% (2018: 39.0%) of total portfolio. Gross advances portfolio was reported at Rs. 331.7b at end-Q1’20.

Asset quality indicators of the bank declined slightly due to greater increase in quantum of NPLs vis-à-vis the increase in gross financing portfolio. Resultantly, gross and net infection ratios were reported higher at 9.1% (2018: 8.3%) and 2.2% (2018: 1.2%), respectively. Recent economic slowdown due to COVID-19 is expected to negatively impact repayment capacity of many borrowers; hence, asset quality indicators may witness pressure in the long run in line with the overall banking industry. In 2020, minimum impact will be observed on fresh NPLs as SBP has allowed banks to defer clients’ payment of principal on loan obligations by one year and also relaxed regulatory criteria for restructured/rescheduled loans for borrowers who require relief beyond the extension of principal repayment for one year. Maintaining assets quality indicators in line with rating benchmarks is considered an important rating driver going forward.

Credit and market risk emanating from the investment portfolio is considered low

Value of the investment portfolio was reported at Rs. 215.9b (2019: Rs. 204.1b; 2018: Rs. 214.2b) at end-Q1’20. Credit risk emanating from the portfolio is considered low as approximately 70% of the investment portfolio was deployed in government portfolio. Market risk is also considered low as investment in equity securities constituted less than 5%

Page 3: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

3 | P a g e

of overall investment portfolio during 2019 and Q1’20.

Overall liquidity profile of the bank is considered adequate in view of sizeable liquid assets in relation to deposits and borrowings; however, room for improvement in deposit granularity exists

Deposit base of the bank depicted double digit growth during 2019. CASA of the bank was reported higher at 70.1% (2018 67.4%). In terms of total quantum, saving accounts registered the largest growth as management offered special rates in both conventional and Islamic saving accounts to mobilize deposits and maintain Advances to Deposits (ADR) ratio of the bank. However, the management has converted these special rate saving accounts to rack rate accounts during 2020 in a bid to rationalize cost of deposits. Concentration in deposit base observed slight decrease vis-à-vis the preceding year, with top 20 and top 50 depositors accounting for 17.2% (2018: 18.8%) and 25.2% (2018: 27.1%) of total deposits at end-2019. However, further room for improvement exists in this regard. Growth in liquid assets was greater than growth observed in deposits and borrowings. Consequently, liquid assets in relation to deposits and borrowings were reported higher at 45.1% (2018: 40.8%). Going forward, management’s strategy is to focus on attracting low cost deposits rather than aiming for higher volume. However, economic slowdown due to COVID-19 is expected to present challenges in mobilizing low cost deposits.

Increasing interest rates contributed to improvement in profitability profile during the period under review; however, profitability is expected to remain under pressure in medium to long term in view of decreasing interest rate scenario and client repayment capacity being affected due to economic slowdown

Profit after tax of FBL was reported higher at Rs. 6.0b (2018: Rs. 4.8b) in 2019. Profitability of the bank registered sizeable growth during the outgoing year on the back of improvement in markup income along with controlled growth in expenses. Increasing interest rates were a key factor contributing to higher profitability. Net markup income increased owing to volumetric increase in average earning assets and improvement in spreads. Administrative expenses registered double digit growth on account of increase registered in compensation related expenses primarily due to branch expansion. However, with greater increase in recurring income vis-à-vis the growth in operating expenses, efficiency ratio (cost to income) of the bank improved to 59.9% (2018: 66.0%). Going forward, the COVID-19 crisis and its impact on the economy and the financial sector would make the operating dynamics of the banks in general challenging. SBP has announced regulatory relaxations to manage the asset quality of the banks’ portfolio which along with the relief package provided by the Federal Government is expected to provide certain respite to the banks in the short term. Profitability of FBL will be further supported during 2020 on account of lag in re-pricing of loan portfolio and efforts by the management to reduce the cost of deposits by mobilizing low cost deposits and reducing operational expenses to compensate for decrease in interest rates. However, the impact of curtailment of economic activity due to COVID-19 and lower lending rate scenario may cause NIM compression, thereby impacting the profitability of the bank in the medium to long term. Moreover, impairment charges due to adverse impact of economic slowdown on client’s repayment capacity are expected to put further downward pressure on profitability. Maintaining conservative lending strategy to maintain asset quality and cost efficiencies would be important rating drivers going forward.

Capitalization indicators are expected to remain sound Equity (excluding revaluation surplus) depicted increase on timeline basis due to profit retention. Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) and leverage ratio were reported at 19.1% (2018: 16.8%) and 5.9% (2018: 4.9%) respectively. Going forward, capitalization indicators of the bank are expected to demonstrate comfortable cushion over the regulatory requirements after accounting for projected growth in advances.

Page 4: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

4 | P a g e

Corporate Profile

Incorporated in 1994 as a public listed company,

Faysal Bank Limited (FBL) is engaged in provision

of Conventional and Islamic Corporate,

Commercial and Consumer banking services. The

shares of the bank are listed and traded on

Pakistan Stock Exchange (PSX). At end-2019, the

bank’s branch network included 555 branches

(2018: 455); including 413 Islamic branches (2018:

254) and 1 Islamic sub-branch (2018: 1) in

Pakistan.

Majority shareholding of FBL, either directly or

indirectly, is vested with Ithmaar Bank and its

subsidiaries (2019: 66.8%; 2018: 66.8%). No

significant change was witnessed in the

shareholding pattern during the outgoing year.

The following table presents the shareholding

pattern of the bank as at end-2019:

Figure 1: Shareholding Pattern of FBL

%

Ithmaar Bank & Subsidiaries 66.8%

- Ithmaar Bank (IB Bank B.S.C) 48.1%

- Faisal Finance (Luxembourg) 8.6%

- MFAI (Jersey) Limited 5.9%

- DMI (Jersey) Limited 4.2%

State Life Insurance Corporation of Pakistan

5.3%

General Public 14.6%

Foreign Investors 2.1%

Public Sector Companies & Corporations

0.01%

Banks and FIs 6.5%

Mutual Funds 1.5%

Others 3.2%

Total 100.0%

In May 2020, the Board of Directors (BoD) at

FBL was reconstituted and 11 members were

elected for a period of 3 years. Mr. Mohsin Tariq

replaced Mr. Fuad Azam Khan on the Board,

while Ms. Fatima Asad was also inducted on the

Board. New members inducted on the Board have

sound experience. Composition of the Board is

line with best practices as independent directors

constitute more than one-third of the total Board

members and a female director has been

appointed on the Board.

Figure 2: BoD composition

Names of Directors Position

Mr. Farooq Rahmatullah

Khan

Chairman/Non-Executive

Director

Mr. Ahmed Abdulrahim

Mohamed Abdulla Bucheery

Vice Chairman/ Non-Executive

Director

Mr. Yousaf Hussain President & CEO/Executive

Director

Mian Muhammad Younis Independent Director

Mr. Imtiaz Ahmad Pervez Non-Executive Director

Mr. Juma Hasan Ali Abul Non-Executive Director

Mr. Abdulelah Ebrahim

Mohamed AlQasimi Non-Executive Director

Mr. Abdulla Abdulaziz Ali

Taleb Non-Executive Director

Mr. Ali Munir Independent Director

Mr. Mohsin Tariq Independent Director

Ms. Fatima Asad Khan Independent Director

Six BoD meetings were held in 2019. Attendance

during BoD meetings is considered satisfactory.

Nature of the Board oversight is considered

comprehensive as depicted by detailed discussions

documented in Board minutes. Discussions in the

Board meetings pertained to Business

Transformation Plan (BTP), growth strategy,

regulatory approvals, branch expansion plan,

macroeconomic developments, bank’s

performance in terms of advances portfolio,

deposits, profitability profile and capitalization

indicators. Qualitative aspects such as review of

internal audit report and areas of improvement for

internal control environment are also thoroughly

covered.

In order to ensure effective oversight, five

committees exist at Board level. These include

Board Audit & Corporate Governance Committee

(BACGC), Board Risk Management Committee

(BRMC), Board Recruitment Nomination and

Remuneration Committee (BRNRC), Board

Page 5: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

5 | P a g e

Strategy Committee (BSC) and Board IT

Committee (BITC). With reconstitution of the

BoD, the committees will also be re-constituted.

The following table presents the composition of

Board committees prior to reconstitution of the

BoD:

Figure 3: Composition of Board Committees

Name BAC

GC

BR

MC

BR

NR

C

BSC BIT

C

Mr. Farooq

Rahmatullah C

Mr. Ahmed Abdul

Rahim Mohamed

Abdulla Bucheery

C M

Mr. Yousaf Hussain M M M

Mian Muhammad

Younis C M

Mr. Imtiaz Ahmad

Pervez C

Mr. Juma Hasan Ali

Abul M M M

Mr. Abdulelah

Ebrahim Mohamed

AlQasimi

M M

Mr. Abdulla Abdul-

Aziz Ali Taleb M M

Mr. Ali Munir M M C

Mr. Fuad Azim

Hashmi M M

BACGC is chaired by an independent director in

line with best practices. The composition of the

BRNRC is in line with the Revised Guidelines on

Remuneration Practices 2017 issued by the State

Bank of Pakistan which allows a non-executive

director to be the Chairman in case the majority

members of the committee are independent

directors.

The management team at FBL is led by Mr.

Yousaf Hussain, who has been serving as the

President and Chief Executive Officer (CEO) of

the bank since 2017. Mr. Yousaf has around 26

years of diverse local & international professional

experience. He is a seasoned banker with previous

experience in senior positions at ABN AMRO

Bank, Samba Bank and Mashreq bank, UAE. He

has been affiliated with FBL since 2008 and holds

MBA degree from the Lahore University of

Management Sciences.

One major change has been observed in the

senior management team since last review:

Mr. Muhammad Arif has been appointed

as Chief Digital Officer to initiate and

oversee implementation of digital

initiatives. Mr. Mohammad Arif has over

38 years of diversified experience in the

field of Fintech, Digital Banking, Islamic

Banking and Technology & Operations.

Prior to joining Faysal Bank in 2019, he

has worked with Bill & Melinda Gates

Foundation, Standard Chartered Bank

(Malaysia & Pakistan) and GBS –

Malaysia.

Detailed profiles of senior management team at

FBL are presented in Annexure I.

Eight committees are present at management

level. These include Senior Management

Committee, Asset & Liability Committee,

Conversion to Islamic Committee, Compliance

Committee, IT Steering Committee, Investment

Committee, Enterprise Risk Management

Committee and Country Credit Committee. All

the management level committees are chaired by

the CEO.

A Shariah Board is also in place to maintain

oversight of Islamic Banking operations of FBL.

No changes were witnessed in the composition of

the Shariah Board during 2019. The following

table depicts the composition of Shariah Board:

Figure 4: Shariah Board composition

Name Position

Mufti Muhammad Mohib ul Haq Siddiqui Chairman

Dr. Mufti Khalil Ahmad Aazami Member

Mufti Muhammad Abdullah Member

Page 6: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

6 | P a g e

Total staff strength of the bank was reported at

6,938 (2018: 6,141) at end-2019. Out of total

headcount, permanent employee headcount stood

at 6,916 (2018: 6,118).

Business Transformation Plan (BTP)

The management’s strategy to transform the bank

into a full-fledged Shariah compliant Islamic Bank

remains intact. The management is targeting full

conversion by end-2023. The bank is following an

‘asset-led’ conversion model under which

preservation of franchise value, commercial

considerations, profitability and availability of

deployment avenues for liabilities drive the pace

of conversion.

During 2019, the bank converted Rs. 37b

conventional loans to Islamic mode of financing

and the management has undertaken decision that

all new Auto and house loans will be issued under

Islamic mode to facilitate the conversion process.

Moreover, the bank successfully launched Tijarah

and disbursed its first Islamic personal finance

staff loan based on Tawarruq during 2019. The

management has established the following targets

for 2020 under BTP:

Launch of Musawamah and Dollar Bai

Salam facilities to augment its product

suite.

Soft launch of Islamic credit card.

Branch network

At end-2019, total branch network included 555

branches (2018: 455). The bank opened 100 new

Islamic branches and converted 59 conventional

branches to Islamic branches in 2019. Resultantly,

number of total Islamic branches stood at 413

(2018: 254), while 1 Islamic sub-branch (2018: 1)

was also operational. Islamic branches constituted

three-fourth of total branch network. In 2020, the

management plans to open 50 new Islamic

branches and convert existing conventional

branches to Islamic such that 90% of total branch

network constitutes Islamic branches at end-2020.

The bank converts branches in a single cutover

using its technology solution as per SBP and

Shariah guidelines.

Internal controls

External audit of the bank was conducted by M/s

A.F. Ferguson & Co. Chartered Accountants in

2019. The same auditors will continue to render

their services for the bank in 2020.

Internal Audit (IA) function at FBL is segregated

into five sub-divisions, namely Operational Risk

Review (ORR), IT Audit, Management Audit,

Shariah Audit and Credit Risk Review (CRR).

A risk based audit methodology is followed in all

audits including branches and management

functions. Overall ratings are assigned as

‘acceptable’, ‘needs improvement’ and ‘weak’. The

‘acceptable’ category represents strong control

environment and ‘weak’ represents unacceptable

control environment. Weak rated

functions/branches are audited every year, while

the audits with ‘acceptable’ control environment

are audited at least once in every three years.

Scope of the internal audit department is defined

by the Internal Audit plan which is approved by

the BoD. Audit activities comprise audit of all the

bank’s businesses, products, processes, entities

and technology platform systems.

The compliance department at FBL functions

under the stewardship of Mr. Abadullah, who

serves as the Chief Compliance Officer (CCO).

The compliance department is primarily

responsible for ensuring that the bank complies

with all the regulatory requirements. The Shariah

compliance division reports directly to the Shariah

board with a dotted line reporting to CCO.

Overall internal control framework at the bank is

considered sound with the bank ensuring that

satisfactory policies to govern various procedures

Page 7: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

7 | P a g e

are in place. One major instance of fraud

amounting to Rs. 19.8m was noted in the outgoing

year. A branch manager in Lahore branch forged

signatures of a corporate customer to withdraw

funds. Remedial legal actions have been

undertaken against the involved staff and the

customer was compensated for the required

amount.

Information Technology

IT department at FBL is further segregated into

separate sub-divisions, which include software

development & infrastructure (SD&I), IT

operations, IT development, IT governance, IT

technology solutions and project management

(TPMO). Mr. Syed Hasan Jafri serves as the Head

of Information Technology department. He has

over 34 years of diversified experience in both

financial and non-financial sectors. He holds a

Masters in Information Technology degree from

PIMSAT, Karachi.

At present, the bank is currently using two core

banking systems in order to manage its loan

portfolio. These include Symbols (Corporate-

conventional/Islamic and Consumer-Islamic) and

TCSS (Consumer-Conventional).

The bank’s Disaster Recovery Production Site

(DRPS) is located in Lahore. FBL also has a

comprehensive Business Continuity Plan (BCP) in

place. During 2019, key initiatives undertaken by

the management to improve IT infrastructure

included upgrading servers and enterprise storage

facilities in both primary data center located in

Karachi and in the alternate data center situated in

Lahore. New digital channels were also added

which enable the account holders to download

and use mobile and Internet Banking applications.

For the convenience of account holders and staff,

mobile based biometric verification application

was also introduced.

Financial Analysis

Figure 5: Asset Mix

(Rs. in billions) 2018 % 2019 % Q1'20 %

Cash and balances with treasury banks

43.2 7.2 60.4 9.6 44.5 7.1

Balances with other banks

1.8 0.3 2.8 0.5 1.6 0.3

Lending to FIs 3.0 0.5 - - - -

Investments 214.2 35.7 204.1 32.4 215.9 34.5

Advances 296.4 49.4 309.6 49.2 307.1 49.1

Fixed Assets 11.6 1.9 24.2 3.8 24.2 3.9

Intangible Assets 1.3 0.2 1.5 0.2 1.4 0.2

Deferred tax Assets 0.2 0.0 - 0.0 - -

Other Assets 28.1 4.7 27.3 4.3 30.6 4.9

Total Assets 599.9 100 629.9 100 625.4 100

Total asset base of the bank increased to Rs.

629.9b (2018: Rs. 599.9b) at end-2019. Increase

was primarily manifested in advances and cash and

bank balances with treasury banks. Given the

vision of transforming to an Islamic bank, growth

in Islamic financing portfolio was major focus of

the management. Growth in asset base was

funded by higher deposit base, while borrowings

decreased during the outgoing year.

At end-Q1’2020, asset base decreased to Rs.

625.4b (2019: Rs. 629.9b). Decline in the asset

base was primarily a function of lower cash and

bank balances as the bank deployed additional

liquidity into more profitable avenues. Decrease in

the asset base was accompanied by decrease in

repo borrowings on the liabilities side.

Credit Risk

Gross financing portfolio of FBL depicted a

growth of 4.2% and amounted to Rs. 333.8b

(2018: Rs. 320.3b) at end-2019. During 2019, the

bank converted Rs. 37b conventional loans to

Islamic portfolio. Gross Islamic financing and

related assets stood higher at Rs. 116.1b (2018: Rs.

79.0b). Given the impact of COVID 19 on

various industries, the management is targeting

cautious growth in gross advances portfolio.

Page 8: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

8 | P a g e

Figure 6: Segment wise advances and infection ratios

(Rs. in billions)

Gross Advances

Gross Infection (%)

Net Infection

(%)

2018 2019 2018 2019 2018 2019

Corporate 246.5 260.5 6.7 7.8 0.5 1.9

SME 15.7 14.1 34.0 35.7 9.0 9.1

Agriculture 8.1 4.8 17.0 28.8 6.3 11.8

Consumer 30.6 32.4 7.9 8.7 1.7 2.1

Commercial 16.4 18.1 4.9 3.8 2.4 2.1

Staff Loans 3.0 3.8 5.7 0.8 2.0 0.7

Total 320.3 333.8 8.3 9.1 1.2 2.2

Corporate financing continues to remain the forte

of the bank as it constitutes the largest proportion

of total lending portfolio. Growth in overall

portfolio was primarily driven by higher corporate

lending. Net infection increased in all segments

barring the commercial and staff loans. In order to

mitigate the impact of COVID-19, the State Bank

of Pakistan has increased the regulatory limit for

extension of credit to SMEs by 44% to Rs. 180m.

Hence, selective growth may be observed in this

segment depending on risk profile of clients.

Similar selective disbursement strategy is in place

for growth in consumer and commercial

portfolios. Corporate segment is expected to

remain mainstay of the bank.

Client wise concentration in advances witnessed

slight decrease in 2019 as top-20 funded

exposures accounted for 37.4% (2018: 39.0%) of

the gross portfolio at end-2019. Top 5 exposures

of the bank constituted public sector exposures.

Exposure to public sector entities constituted 22.7

% (2018: 22.6%) of the total gross advances

portfolio. In order to ensure that credit risk

remains manageable, the bank closely monitors a

list of watch-list clients. Average Obligor Risk

Rating (ORR) of the bank’s portfolio was reported

at 4.4 (2019: 4.4; 2018: 4.3) at end-March 2020.

Figure 7: Sectoral composition of advances

(Rs. in billions) Gross Advances

Sectors 2018 % 2019 %

Agriculture, forestry, hunting and fishing

39.8 12.4% 37.7 11.3%

Mining and Quarrying

7.4 2.3% 10.6 3.2%

Textile 37.1 11.6% 33.2 9.9%

Chemical and Pharmaceuticals

8.7 2.7% 10.1 3.0%

Cement 8.3 2.6% 6.3 1.9%

Sugar 9.6 3.0% 10.6 3.2%

Footwear and leather garments

1.5 0.5% 1.6 0.5%

Automobile and transportation equipment

3.8 1.2% 8.6 2.6%

Electronics and electrical appliances

7.9 2.5% 6.2 1.8%

Construction 6.3 2.0% 2.1 0.6%

Power (electricity), gas, water, sanitary

52.6 16.4% 57.5 17.2%

Wholesale and retail trade

11.5 3.6% 11.6 3.5%

Exports/imports 2.0 0.6% - 0.0%

Transport, storage and communication

21.0 6.5% 4.0 1.2%

Financial 4.7 1.5% 3.9 1.2%

Insurance 0.0 0.0% 0.0 0.0%

Services 18.0 5.6% 15.1 4.5%

Individuals 33.5 10.5% 36.2 10.8%

Others 46.6 14.5% 78.6 23.6%

Total 320.3 333.8

Overall lending increased during 2019 due to

increase in lending to power, and iron & steel

sectors. Sector-wise exposures depict considerable

diversification as no particular sector accounts for

more than 20% of total gross advances portfolio.

With slowdown in economic activity due to

COVID-19, management team conducted rapid

portfolio reviews to ascertain the industries most

impacted by the situation; certain high risk

industries were identified which are being closely

Page 9: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

9 | P a g e

monitored. Management will continue to monitor

sector wise lending in order to minimize its risk.

Figure 8: Sectoral infection ratios

Gross Infection Net Infection

2018 2019 2018 2019

Agriculture, forestry, hunting and fishing

3.5% 3.7% 1.2% 1.3%

Mining and Quarrying

0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%

Textile 25.5% 26.2% 2.1% 1.1%

Chemical and Pharmaceuticals

8.7% 7.1% 1.5% 1.1%

Cement 0.7% 0.7% 0.0% 0.0%

Sugar 0.2% 12.2% 0.2% 8.0%

Footwear and leather garments

34.1% 27.2% 15.2% 10.2%

Automobile and transportation equipment

4.9% 4.1% 0.5% 0.3%

Electronics and electrical appliances

17.2% 17.8% 1.1% 1.3%

Construction 6.2% 15.4% 0.0% 0.5%

Power (electricity), gas, water, sanitary

6.0% 8.2% 0.4% 2.8%

Wholesale and retail trade

15.6% 21.9% 3.7% 8.3%

Exports/imports 28.5% - 5.8% -

Transport, storage and communication

0.5% 6.2% 0.1% 2.7%

Financial 1.1% 1.3% 0.0% 0.0%

Insurance - 0.0% - 0.0%

Services 4.0% 3.1% 0.4% 0.6%

Individuals 7.7% 7.9% 1.7% 1.4%

Others 7.7% 6.6% 1.9% 2.7%

Total 8.3% 9.1% 1.2% 2.2%

As per management, overall gross infection

increased in 2019 primarily due to industry-wide

classification pertaining to companies belonging to

a single group. The companies include two sugar

mills, a power company and two companies

engaged in food production. Resultantly, gross

infection ratios are higher in sugar and power

segments. With increasing circular debt,

management must closely monitor its exposures in

the power sector. With regards to future growth,

the management has adopted a prudent lending

strategy by assigning higher priority to low risk

sectors such as food, FMCGs, etc. which are

expected to post sound profitability despite

slowdown in economic activity due to COVID-19.

Figure 9: Consumer portfolio

Gross Advances (PKR in millions)

Gross Infection

(%)

Net Infection

(%)

2018 2019 2018 2019 2018 2019

Credit Card

5,518 6,357 7.9 8.6 0.1 0.3

Auto Loan 16,316 16,702 1.7 2.3 0.5 0.7

Consumer Durable

1 1 88.9 88.9 - -

Mortgage loans

3,873 3,650 24.6 24.4 9.0 6.5

Personal Loans

4,863 5,729 15.7 17.5 2.4 2.7

Total 30,572 32,439 7.9 8.7 1.7 1.5

Consumer loan portfolio depicted growth of 6.1%

during 2019; growth was observed in credit cards,

auto loans and personal loans. Infection ratio is on

the higher side in mortgage portfolio, compared to

the rest of the products, because it primarily

comprises legacy portfolio. However, the same is

decreasing on a timeline basis on account of

delinquent account closures. Management is not

aggressively targeting growth in housing loans

given already high infection ratio in this segment.

Growth momentum in overall consumer portfolio

continued during first two months of 2020 but

with onset of COVID-19, consumer lending was

halted in the next two months given unsecured

nature of many consumer products. Management

has re-initiated cautious lending approach in this

segment in the fifth month of the ongoing year.

Going forward, auto loans, personal loans and

credit cards will continue to remain major drivers

of growth. Soft launch Islamic credit card is

expected during 2020.

Page 10: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

10 | P a g e

Asset Quality

Figure 10: Asset quality indicators

(Rs. in millions) 2018 2019

NPLs 26,687.6 30,409.3

Gross advances 320,258.3 333,810.7

Specific provisioning 23,135.3 23,475.7

General provisioning 678.2 762.0

Gross infection 8.3% 9.1%

Net infection 1.2% 2.2%

Provisioning coverage 89.2% 79.7%

Net NPLs to Tier I Equity 9.5% 15.8%

Asset quality indicators of the bank declined due

to greater increase in quantum of NPLs vis-à-vis

the increase in gross financing portfolio.

Resultantly, gross and net infection ratios were

reported higher at end-2019 in comparison to the

preceding year. As recent slowdown in economic

activity due to COVID-19 is expected to

negatively impact repayment capacity of many

individuals and organizations, asset quality

indicators may witness pressure in the long run in

line with the overall banking sector. In the short

run, minimum impact will be observed on fresh

NPLs as SBP has allowed banks to defer clients’

payment of principal on loan obligations by one

year and also relaxed regulatory criteria for

restructured/rescheduled loans for borrowers who

require relief beyond the extension of principal

repayment for one year. Resultantly, NPLs are

expected to remain at existing levels at end-2020.

At end-May 2020, FBL has already received

request for deferral of principal payment

amounting to Rs. 87.6b for one year.

Investments

Figure 11: Investment portfolio

(Rs. in billions) 2018 2019

Rs. % Rs. %

Government Securities

Market Treasury Bills 173.2 80.8% 118.7 58.2%

PIBs 3.8 1.8% 10.7 5.2%

Ijara Sukuk Bonds 5.9 2.8% 5.9 2.9%

Other Government

Securities 1.6 0.7% 1.6 0.8%

Total 184.4 86.1% 136.9 67.1%

Corporate Debt Instruments

Sukuks - Listed 1.1 0.5% 40.3 19.7%

- Unlisted 20.8 9.7% 18.8 9.2%

Total 21.9 10.2% 59.1 28.9%

Total Debt Portfolio 206.3 96.3% 196.0 96.0%

Equities

Ordinary - Listed 7.1 3.3% 7.4 3.6%

- Unlisted 0.1 0.0% 0.1 0.0%

Preference - Listed - - - -

- Unlisted - - - -

Total 7.2 3.4% 7.5 3.7%

Strategic Investment

Subsidiary 0.6 0.3% 0.6 0.3%

Total 0.6 0.3% 0.6 0.3%

Total Investment Portfolio

214.2 100.0% 204.1 100.0%

Investment portfolio decreased by 4.7% to Rs.

204.1b (2018: Rs. 214.2b) due to maturity of T-

bills. As majority (67.1%) of the bank’s portfolio is

deployed in GoP securities, credit risk emanating

from the portfolio is considered to be on the

lower side. Counterparty risk on Sukuks is

considered nominal due to sound credit quality of

Sukuk portfolio. Most of the risky/non-

performing exposures have already been provided

for by the management.

Given the uncertainty with regards to interest

rates during the last year, short tenor instruments

such as t-bills remained the preferred fixed income

Page 11: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

11 | P a g e

investment avenue by the management. Portfolio

duration was reported at 0.16 years (2018: 0.09

years) at end-2019.

Management has cautious investment strategy

with regards to equities given the volatile nature of

the equity market. Management strictly follows the

equity exposure limits defined in prudential

regulations. Overall exposure to market risk is

limited as equity investments constituted

approximately 13.5% (2018: 16.6%) of bank’s total

equity

At end-Q1’20, total market value of the

investment portfolio was reported at Rs. 215.9b,

with government securities constituting 69.3% of

total portfolio.

Liquidity

Overall liquidity profile of the bank is considered

adequate. While granularity in deposit base depicts

room for improvement, presence of sizeable liquid

assets in relation to deposits and borrowings

provides comfort to the liquidity profile of the

bank. The bank also maintains considerable

cushion over the regulatory requirements of

Liquidity Coverage Ratio (LCR) and Net Stable

Funding Ratio (NSFR).

Figure 12: Deposit Mix

(Rs. in millions) 2018 % 2019 % Q1'2

0 %

Customers

Current accounts-

Remunerative 4.1 1.0 12.4 2.7 11.2 2.4

Current accounts

- Non-remunerative

126.9 31.0 134.6 29.4 133.0 28.8

Savings Deposits 125.9 30.7 153.2 33.5 155.3 33.7

Term Deposits 120.4 29.4 127.7 27.9 140.0 30.4

Margin deposits 2.8 0.7 2.7 0.6 2.9 0.6

Total 380.1 92.8 430.5 94.0 442.4 96.0

FIs

Current Deposits 1.2 0.3 1.2 0.3 0.8 0.2

Savings Deposits 21.0 5.1 19.6 4.3 10.5 2.3

Term Deposits 7.2 1.8 6.5 1.4 7.3 1.6

Total 29.3 7.2 27.3 6.0 18.6 4.0

Cumulative Total 409.4 100 457.8 100 461.0 100

CASA 68.2% 70.1% 67.4%

Deposit base of the bank witnessed growth of

11.8% in 2019 on account of increase in current

accounts, saving accounts and term deposits.

CASA of the bank was reported slightly higher at

70.1% (2018 67.4%). As per management, one

major reason for increase in saving accounts was

that many consumers shifted from conventional

current accounts to Islamic saving accounts which

offered higher earnings as well as Shariah

compliance. Moreover, management offered

special rates in both conventional and Islamic

saving accounts to mobilize deposits and maintain

Advances to Deposits (ADR) ratio of the bank.

During the ongoing year, the management has

focused on converting these special rate saving

accounts to rack rates in a bid to rationalize cost

of deposits.

Growth in overall deposit base of FBL in 2019

was in line with the average growth in industry

deposits, as market share of the bank remained at

Page 12: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

12 | P a g e

3.1% (2018: 3.1%) at end-2019. At end-2019,

Islamic branches represented 75% of total branch

network but deposits maintained at Islamic

branches represented only 27.5% (2019: 26%) of

total deposit base at end-Q1’2020. It is important

for management to channel their efforts for

mobilization of deposits in Islamic branches to

comply with BTP targets.

Going forward, the deposit mobilization strategy

will focus on attracting low cost deposits.

However, given the current slowdown in economy

due to COVID-19, low cost deposit mobilization

may present challenges. Continuation of branch

led SME model yielded positive results in terms of

deposit mobilization during 2019 and will

continue to remain a key component of future

deposit mobilization strategy. Moreover, opening

of 50 new branches will aid growth in deposit base

from untapped locations.

Concentration in deposit base observed slight

decrease vis-à-vis the preceding year, with top 20

and top 50 depositors accounting for 17.2%

(2018: 18.8%) and 25.2% (2018: 27.1%) of total

deposits, respectively. However, the same still

depicts room for further improvement. As per

management, one key reason for lower deposit

granularity is higher return offered by other

investment avenues such as mutual funds. Going

forward, management is focusing on reducing

depositor concentration by increasing its deposit

base.

Size-wise breakup of deposits also indicates that

deposits over Rs 10m or more, which represent

only 0.8% of the total number of depositors

(2018: 0.7%), accounted for 63.3% (2018: 61.4%)

of the total deposit base.

Figure 13: Size-wise breakup of deposits

Size of Accounts

(Rs.)

end-Dec'18 end-Dec'19

No. of Account

s

Amount (in Rs.

m)

No. of Account

s

Amount (in Rs.

m)

Less than 5,000

377,850 326 373,033 330

5,000 to 40,000

133,521 2,182 143,510 2,434

40,000 to 90,000

49,808 2,977 52,887 3,185

90,000 to 500,000

85,777 19,452 89,189 20,315

500,000 to 1,000,000

25,301 18,247 25,955 18,767

1,000,000 to 6,000,000

35,172 84,105 36,481 88,353

6,000,000 to

10,000,000 3,927 30,886 4,349 34,767

10,000,000 and above

4,804 251,209 5,555 289,638

Total 716,160 409,384 730,959 457,789

Branch wise concentration continued to increase

despite expansion in branch during the outgoing

year. Top 10, 20 and 50 branches represented

34.2% (2018: 32.8%), 45.5% (2018: 45.5%) and

64.7% (2018: 64.2%) of the total deposit base,

respectively. This is largely due to the gestation

period required for new branches to mobilize

sizeable deposits.

Total borrowings of the bank depicted sizeable

decrease to Rs. 72.8b (2018: Rs. 98.4b) at end-

2019. The decrease was manifested in repo

borrowings which stood lower at Rs. 21.7b (2018:

59.0b). Remaining borrowings have largely been

mobilized from State Bank of Pakistan under

various schemes and also include unsecured call

borrowings and musharaka acceptances.

Trend of reduction in repo borrowing continued

in Q1’20, which decreased to Rs. 6.9b (2019: Rs.

21.7b). Resultantly, quantum of total borrowings

was reported lower at Rs. 61.3b (2019: Rs. 72.7b)

at end-Q1’2020.

Page 13: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

13 | P a g e

Liquid assets (adjusted for assets given as

collateral) amounted to Rs. 247.8b (2018: Rs.

240.7b). Growth in liquid assets was greater than

growth observed in deposits and borrowings.

Consequently, liquid assets in relation to deposits

and borrowings were reported higher at 45.1%

(2018: 40.8%). The bank remained comfortably

above the minimum regulatory requirements of

Liquidity Coverage Ratio (LCR) and Net Stable

Funding Ratio as the same stood at 141.6% (2018:

145.2%) and 135.6% (2018: 130.7%), respectively

at end-2019. Although advances to deposits ratio

of the bank registered improvement by decreasing

to 68.1% (2018: 73.6%), the same is still

considered to be on the higher side vis-à-vis peers.

Going forward, the management must closely

monitor the impact of payment deferrals granted

by SBP on liquidity profile of the bank.

Profitability

Operating profitability of the bank registered

sizeable growth during 2019 and Q1’20 vis-à-vis

corresponding periods in the previous year. This

improvement was achieved on the back of higher

markup income and controlled growth in

expenses. Increasing interest rates were a key

factor contributing to higher topline.

Improvement was also noted in spreads.

Figure 14: Profitability snapshot

(Rs. in billions) 2018 2019

Mark-up/ return/ interest earned 35.2 58.4

Mark-up/ return/ interest expensed 18.9 37.3

Net-markup/ interest income 16.3 21.1

Fee and commission income 3.9 4.1

Dividend income 0.2 0.4

Foreign exchange income 2.0 2.8

Income/ (loss) from derivatives 0.1 0.2

Gain/(Loss) on securities 0.1 (0.6)

Other income 0.4 0.3

Total non-mark-up/interest income 6.6 7.2

Total income 22.9 28.4

Operating expenses 14.8 17.1

Workers Welfare Fund 0.2 0.23

Other charges 0.1 0.03

Total non-markup/interest expenses 15.1 17.3

Profit before provisions 7.8 11.0

Provision/(reversals of provision) and recoveries

(0.4) 0.8

Profit Before Tax 8.2 10.2

Tax 3.4 4.2

Profit After tax 4.8 6.0

Markup up income of the bank registered growth

of 65.9% in 2019 on account of increase in the

quantum of advances and higher yield on earning

assets. Yield on advances increased on account of

higher prevailing interest rates vis-à-vis the

preceding year. Higher yielding short term t-bills

also contributed to higher average return on

earning assets. Cost of deposits also registered

increase due to higher interest rates and special

rates offered by the management to mobilize

deposits. However, increase in the cost of deposits

was lower than increase in average return on

earning assets, thereby resulting in improvement

in spreads.

Figure 15: Spreads

2018 2019 1Q'20

Avg. Return on Financing 8.11% 12.00% 13.24%

Avg. Return on Investment 6.80% 11.28% 12.76%

Avg. Return on earning assets

7.70% 11.79% 13.10%

Cost of Deposits 3.82% 6.83% 7.61%

Cost of Funds 4.40% 7.90% 8.50%

Spreads 3.30% 3.89% 4.60%

Non markup income also registered notable

growth due to higher fee, commission and

brokerage income, dividend income and foreign

exchange income. Fee, commission and brokerage

income registered growth mainly on account of

Page 14: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

14 | P a g e

improvement depicted by consumer finance

products of the bank, which include higher credit

card fees and processing of loan and early

redemption fees. Home remittances commission

also increased considerably vis-à-vis the preceding

year.

Figure 16: Composition of fee, commission and

brokerage income

(Rs. in millions) 2018 2019

Branch banking customer fees 652.9 710.1

Consumer finance related fees 298.3 366.8

Card Related fees (debit and credit)

1,273.8 1,675.9

Credit related fees 144.1 99.4

Investment banking fees 270.3 237.6

Commission on trade 289.8 275.7

Commission on guarantees 98.0 126.9

Commission on cash management 94.8 59.2

Commission on remittances (including home remittances)

40.6 119.3

Commission on bancassurance 349.4 412.4

Others 35.3 29.4

Total 3,547.4 4,112.6

Administrative expenses of the bank grew by

15.2% primarily on account of employee

compensation expense. Compensation expense

witnessed an increase due to higher average

headcount of employees along with inflationary

growth in managerial remuneration. Headcount

increased by 797 employees primarily due to

opening of 100 new branches, thereby

contributing Rs. 1.3 billion to compensation

expense. Currency devaluation resulted in higher

Information Technology expenses.

Figure 17: Breakup of operating expenses

(Rs. in millions) 2018 2019

Total compensation expense 5,287.8 6,507.2

Property Expense 3,667.0 3,940.2

Information Technology expenses

1,706.4 2,432.5

Other operating expenses 3,831.0 4,187.8

Total operating expenses 14,492.3 17,067.7

With greater increase in recurring income vis-à-vis

the growth in operating expenses, operating profit

of the bank was reported higher at Rs. 11.4b

(2018: Rs. 7.5b). Resultantly, efficiency ratio of the

bank improved to 59.9% (2018: 66.5%).

Profit before tax of the bank was reported higher

at Rs. 10.2b (2018: Rs. 8.2b). Post impact of

taxation, net profit of the bank amounted to Rs.

6.0b (2018: Rs. 4.8b). Tax incidence was higher in

2019 due to higher profit before tax and prior tax

charge of Rs. 258.9m due to implementation of

super tax on income of the year 2017.

In Q1’20, the bank posted higher profit after tax

of Rs. 2.1b (Q1’19: Rs. 1.6b), thereby depicting a

growth of 29.3% in profit after tax over the

corresponding period of previous year. The

growth was mainly attributable to increase in net

markup income due to low cost deposit

mobilization strategy and higher markup rates.

Going forward, VIS expects the operating

profitability of the bank to decrease in the

medium to long term due to considerable decrease

in the interest rates on account of COVID-19.

Moreover, slowdown in economy is also expected

to adversely affect the repayment ability of clients,

thereby resulting in higher provision/impairment

charges, which will erode profitability of the bank.

In the short run, the management is confident of

achieving its budgeted profitability target, which is

greater than 2019 profit after tax. Loan re-pricing

due to lower interest rates will be undertaken over

a period of 3 to 6 months, which will provide

ample room to the management to lower the

costs. Deposits will be re-priced earlier which will

lower the cost of deposits. Moreover, in current

scenario, the management is focused on acquiring

low costs deposits instead of focusing on higher

volumes. Furthermore, the management has also

converted a sizeable amount of special rate

deposits mobilized earlier to rack rate deposits.

Such measures are expected to improve deposit

profiling, which will further lower the cost of

Page 15: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

15 | P a g e

deposits. Management has also conducted a

thorough exercise to identify specific measures

through which operating costs can be lowered to

support profitability. One such measure includes

re-negotiation of branch rents with owners, while

decrease in fuel prices will automatically lower

many operating costs.

Capitalization

Figure 18: Capitalization indicators

(Rs. in billions) 2018 2019 Q1’20

Issued, subscribed and paid up capital

15.2 15.2 15.2

Equity (excluding revaluation deficit/surplus)

38.4 44.5 46.6

Revaluation Surplus 5.1 10.7 10.7

Equity (including revaluation surplus)

43.5 55.3 57.2

Tier I CAR (%) 14.81% 15.53% 15.73%

CAR (%) 16.80% 19.14% 19.20%

Leverage Ratio 4.85% 5.86% 6.23%

Net Stable Funding Ratio (NSFR)

130.67%

135.60%

143.75%

Equity (excluding revaluation surplus) depicted

increase on timeline basis due to profit retention.

The bank did not pay any dividend in 2019 and

Q1’20.

In order to encourage banks to extend further

credit to borrowers to facilitate economic

recovery, SBP has reduced Capital Conservation

Buffer (CCB) requirement to 1.5%, thereby

resulting in overall CAR requirement of 11.5%.

Presently, CAR of the bank remains comfortably

above the mandated regulatory requirement. Even

with projected growth in Risk Weighted Assets

(RWAs) during 2020, CAR of the bank is

expected to remain comfortable. The bank also

has sufficient cushion to meet any adverse

movement in credit, market and operational risks.

Page 16: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

16 | P a g e

Profile of Senior Management Team Annexure I

Names and Designations Profiles

Mr. Yousaf Hussain (President & CEO)

Mr. Yousaf Hussain has over 26 years of professional experience, primarily at ABN AMRO Bank where he held multiple senior managerial positions including those within the Corporate / Credit and Transaction Banking functions. He has been with Faysal Bank since August 2008, with a significant contribution to the franchise in his previous positions as Chief Risk Officer, Regional Corporate Banking Head-North and Head of Special Assets Management Group. His experience also includes a senior role with Samba Bank and earlier assignments with Mashreq Bank and Mobilink / Motorola. Yousaf has a Bachelor’s of Science degree in Electrical Engineering and has done his MBA from Lahore University of Management Sciences.

Mr. Raheel Ijaz (Chief Operating Officer)

Mr. Raheel Ijaz has more than 40 years of work experience. Before assuming this position, he accumulated a rich banking experience in institutions like MCB Bank Limited as Group Head Compliance and Controls, Country Head Sri Lanka, Head Corporate North & Public Sector, United Bank Limited as Regional Chief Executive North and also held key positions in Faysal Bank, Prime Commercial Bank, and Emirates Bank International. His last role with Faysal Bank Limited was as Head Compliance. Mr. Raheel holds an MBA degree from Quaid-e-Azam International University.

Mr. Salman Ahmed Usmani (Head, Treasury & ECM)

Mr. Salman Usmani has a rich experience of over three decades in the local as well as multinational banking sector. His broad expertise covers Treasury and Risk Management, Asset and Liability Management, Strategic Planning, Corporate Restructuring, Strategic Negotiations, Acquisitions and Strategic Alliances and International Operations. His vast skill set has been instrumental in the design and implementation of the in-house developed Treasury System which is capable of meeting front, middle and back office business requirements and generates a host of MIS while retaining the flexibility to adapt to an evolving product suite. Prior to joining Faysal Bank Limited, he was associated with MCB Bank Limited as Global Treasurer and Head Investment Banking Group. His past experience has been with organizations such as ANZ Grindlays, American Express, Bank of America, Mashreq Bank, United Bank Limited & MCB Bank Limited. He holds an MBA Degree from Grand Valley State University, USA.

Syed Majid Ali (Chief Financial Officer)

Syed Majid Ali is a fellow member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Pakistan and has over 30 years of experience in the field of accounts and finance disciplines of banking with exposure in IT and HR activities. He has been associated as CFO at Saudi Pak Commercial Bank Limited (now Silk Bank Limited) and Emirates Bank International PJSC (Pakistan operations). He has also served as Partner in KPMG Taseer Hadi & Co, Chartered Accountants. Mr. Majid has rich experience in Banking Finance amid mergers and acquisitions. He has also supervised Strategy, Technology and Administration Functions at Faysal Bank Limited.

Mr. Nasir Islam (Head, Internal Audit)

Mr. Nasir Islam is a qualified Chartered Accountant with over 26 years of multifaceted experience. His first assignment was as Manager Finance in ANZ Grindlays (Karachi), after which he was posted at the ANZ HO (Melbourne, Australia), as Manager Commercial Banking System (CBS) Project. He returned to Pakistan in 1997 as Manager Audit, joined ABN AMRO Pakistan as Audit Manager in 2000, and was appointed as Country

Page 17: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

17 | P a g e

Head of Compliance in 2004. He has been associated with Faysal Bank Limited since 2008.

Mr. Tahir Yaqoob Bhatti (Head, Retail Banking)

Mr. Tahir Yaqoob Bhatti has over 32 years of diverse experience in Retail, Commercial, Corporate, Operations, Special Assets Management and Digital Banking. He has previously been associated mainly with Allied Bank, Askari Bank and National Bank of Pakistan. Prior to joining Faysal Bank Limited, his last assignment was Business Head – Wholesale and Private Banking at JS Bank. Mr. Tahir holds an MBA Finance from IBA, Lahore and a Masters in Commerce from Hailey College. He is also qualified DCMA and holds a Banking Diploma from the Institute of Bankers in Pakistan.

Mr. Abadullah (Head, Chief Compliance Officer)

Mr. Abadullah brings with him over 30 years of diversified experience of Branch banking, Trade, Operations and Compliance. Prior to joining Faysal Bank Limited in 2005, he has been associated with Standard Chartered, ANZ Grindlays and United Bank Limited. His last assignment with SCB was as Head Corporate Service Delivery. Prior to his current appointment as Chief Compliance Officer, he has also held the position of Head Operations at Faysal Bank. Mr. Abadullah has been instrumental in implementing various projects and had led teams which migrated core banking systems in Faysal bank. He is a certified GRC professional from GRCP International and diploma holder from Institute of Bankers in Pakistan. Mr. Abad is a certified director from ICMA Pakistan and also holds MBA (Finance) degree from IBA Punjab.

Mr. Ali Waqar (Head, Corporate & Investment Banking)

Mr. Ali Waqar has over 17 years of professional experience, primarily in the field of Corporate & Investment Banking, and Commercial Banking. Throughout his professional career, he has been instrumental in driving the organization’s profitability through a diverse mix of transactions including Structured Finance, Project Finance, Mergers & Acquisitions and Derivatives. He has served at key positions in leading multinationals as well as local organizations including ABN AMRO Bank N.V., Barclays Bank Plc. and Faysal Bank Limited. Prior to his current assignment, Mr. Ali Waqar spearheaded Faysal Bank’s Regional Corporate Banking franchise for 9 years as the ‘Corporate Head-Central’ where he contributed significantly towards sustainable portfolio and revenue growth. Mr. Ali holds an M.Sc degree in Economics and Finance from Lahore School of Economics.

Mr. Mian Salman Ali (Chief Risk Officer)

Mian Salman Ali brings with him a banking experience of over 16 years in large local and multinational banks. During his career, he has held various leadership / supervisory roles in business and control functions. He has a diversified experience in the field of Corporate Banking, Commercial / SME Banking & Credit / Risk Management. Prior to joining Faysal Bank Limited, he has been associated with ABN AMRO Pakistan and Allied Bank Limited. Mian Salman holds a Master of Business Administration degree from Lahore School of Economics. He is also a certified Islamic Banking Professional from NIBAF.

Mr. Bashir Ahmed Sheikh (Head, Special Assets Management)

Mr. Bashir Ahmed Sheikh has over 49 years of diversified domestic as well as international banking experience of Operations, Corporate Banking, Commercial/Retail Banking, Investment and Risk Management with a proven record of superior performance throughout his career. He has strong skills in Syndications, Advisory Services, Acquisitions, Mergers, Privatizations, Agriculture Financing, Remedial Management, Compliance and dealing with the Regulators and other relevant agencies. Before joining Faysal Bank Limited in 2018, he has been associated with United Bank Limited, Union National Bank, BCCI, Indus Bank, Askari Bank, Faysal Bank Limited and Bank Alfalah. His last assignment was Group Head

Page 18: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

18 | P a g e

Special Assets Management at Bank Alfalah. Mr. Bashir Ahmed Sheikh holds a graduation degree from University of Punjab. He is also a Graduate of Executive Development Program, Johnson Graduate School of Management, USA.

Syed Muhammad Fraz Zaidi (Head, Strategy)

Syed Muhammad Fraz Zaidi brings with him over 15 years of experience in the financial services sector, where he has held leadership roles in Finance, Risk Advisory and Strategy. Prior to joining Faysal Bank Limited, he has been associated with organizations such as H & H Exchange Co. (Pvt.), A. F. Ferguson & Co. and United Bank Limited. His last assignment was Head Operational Risk & Basel-II Division at United Bank Limited. Mr. Fraz Zaidi is a Chartered Accountant from the Institute of Chartered Accountants, Pakistan.

Mr. Monis Mirza (Head, Human Resources)

Mr. Monis Mirza has over 23 years of leadership experience in Human Capital Management, Mergers & Acquisitions, Cultural Integration and Business Growth in multiple geographies. During his career, he has held key positions in Procter and Gamble (P&G), Standard Chartered Bank in Pakistan and Tenova Canada. He remained Director of Human Resources and a Management Committee member for SCB Pakistan for over a decade, and helped the bank manage organic and inorganic business growth, drive productivity through engagement and organizational design efficiencies. His last assignment was with HRS Global as Chief Executive Officer – Recruiting. Monis Mirza acquired his B.E. Electrical Engineering degree from University of Buffalo, USA and MBA degree in Human Resources from Institute of Business Administration, Karachi. He has also completed an advance diploma in Human Resources from McMaster University, Canada.

Mr. Aneeq Malik (Head, Operations)

Mr. Aneeq Malik is a solutions-focused banker with over 18 years of rich experience overseeing the compliance function and branch operations. Prior to joining Faysal Bank Limited, Mr. Aneeq was associated with banks like ABN AMRO and MCB. Mr. Aneeq is recognized for being both reactive to developments in the regulatory and governance environment and proactive in areas related to compliance education and training. Highly adept in identifying gaps and / or risk exposure in operations as well as developing and implementing strong systems of check and balances. Mr. Aneeq holds a graduation degree from Punjab University, Lahore. He is a certified expert in Corporate Governance & Leadership Skills from Pakistan Institute of Corporate Governance (PICG). He is also certified from NIBAF in Islamic Banking. He is on the board of directors of M/s. 1Link (Guarantee) Ltd as a nominee director from Faysal Bank Limited as well.

Syed Hasan Jafri (Head, Information Technology)

Syed Hasan Jafri brings with him over 34 years of diversified experience in both financial and non-financial sectors. Mr. Hasan is an accomplished technology professional having experience in Networking, Software design, Product development, Information security, Internet and Telecommunication technologies. Prior to joining Faysal Bank, he has been associated with organizations such as Shahnawaz Limited, Karachi Stock Exchange, Arif Habib Corporation, Summit Bank and Allied Bank Limited. His last assignment was Group Head Information Technology at Allied Bank Limited. Mr. Hasan holds a Masters of Information Technology degree from PIMSAT, Karachi.

Mr. Muhammad Faisal Shaikh (Head Islamic Banking)

Mr. Muhammad Faisal Shaikh is a graduate of Institute of Business Administration (IBA), Karachi with over 18 years of experience in the field of Shariah Structuring and Shariah Compliant Product Development. Prior to joining Faysal Bank Limited, he was associated with BankIslami Pakistan Limited and Meezan Bank Limited. He has been instrumental in the development of various pioneering Islamic Corporate & Consumer

Page 19: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

19 | P a g e

Banking Products and Sukuk structures in Pakistan including Islamic Export Refinance Scheme of State Bank of Pakistan and Pakistan’s inaugural sovereign International Sukuk. He led the team which converted conventional assets and liabilities of KASB Bank Limited after its acquisition by BankIslami Pakistan Limited. Prior to this, his team structured acquisition and conversion of Citibank’s conventional housing finance portfolio by BankIslami Pakistan Limited. He was an active member of the team responsible for conversion and merger of Pakistan operations of Societe Generale into Meezan Bank Limited. He has also served as a member of different advisory committees of State Bank of Pakistan on Islamic Banking.

Mr. Muhammad Aurangzeb Amin (Company Secretary & Head, Legal)

Mr. Aurangzeb Amin brings with him over 23 years of experience in the Financial Sector and Legal Consultancies both in Pakistan and in the USA. During his career he has worked with NIB Bank and Pak-Kuwait Investment Co. as Company Secretary and Head Legal. He has also worked with law firms locally and internationally, namely Orr, Dignam & Co. and Surridge & Beecheno. He has a Masters of Laws degree from Temple University, USA.

Mohammad Arif (Chief Digital Officer)

Mr. Mohammad Arif has over 38 years of diversified experience in the field of Fintech, Digital Banking, Islamic Banking and Technology & Operations. Prior to joining Faysal Bank in 2019, he has worked with Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, Standard Chartered Bank (Malaysia & Pakistan) and GBS – Malaysia. During his tenure at previous organizations, he has been responsible for strategic planning of technology initiatives, system developments, core banking solutions, digital banking migration of channels, E-pay initiatives and managed investments in technology & operations.

Page 20: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

20 | P a g e

Faysal Bank Limited

FINANCIAL SUMMARY Appendix I BALANCE SHEET (Figures in PKR Billions unless

stated otherwise) DEC 31, 2017 DEC 31, 2018 DEC 31, 2019

Investments 180 214 204

Advances 232 296 310

Total Assets 495 600 630

Borrowings 55 98 73

Deposits & other accounts 372 409 458

Subordinated Loans (in PKR millions) - - -

Issued, subscribed and paid up capital 13 15 15

Tier-1 Equity 33 37 43

Net Worth 39 43 55

INCOME STATEMENT (Figures in PKR millions)

DEC 31, 2017 DEC 31, 2018 DEC 31, 2019

Net Mark-up Income 13,935 16,275 21,120

Net Provisioning/(Reversal) (492) (422) 843

Non-Markup Income 5,639 6,584 7,247

Operating Expenses 12,608 14,816 17,068

Profit Before Tax 7,292 8,202 10,192

Profit After Tax 4,530 4,837 6,041

RATIO ANALYSIS DEC 31, 2017 DEC 31, 2018 DEC 31, 2019

Market Share (Advances) (%) 3.9% 4.1% 4.1%

Market Share (Deposits) (%) 3.0% 3.1% 3.1%

Gross Infection (%) 10.7% 8.3% 9.1%

Provisioning Coverage (%) 88.9% 89.2% 79.7%

Net Infection (%) 1.5% 1.2% 2.2%

Cost of funds (%) 3.6% 4.4% 7.9%

Net NPLs to Tier-1 Capital (%) 10.8% 9.5% 15.8%

Capital Adequacy Ratio (C.A.R (%)) 15.9% 16.8% 19.1%

Markup Spreads (%) 2.8% 3.3% 3.9%

Efficiency (%) 67.9% 66.5% 59.9%

Basic* ROAA (%) 1.3% 1.4% 1.9%

ROAA (%) 1.0% 0.9% 1.0%

ROAE (%) 14.2% 13.4% 14.6%

Liquid Assets to Deposits & Borrowings (%) 45.1% 40.8% 45.1%

* Recurring Income – Administration Expenses

Page 21: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

21 | P a g e

ISSUE/ISSUER RATING SCALE & DEFINITIONS Appendix II

Page 22: VIS Credit Rating Company Limited€¦ · Rahmatullah is a seasoned professional with a diverse experience in several roles in different organizations. He is a Law graduate and is

VIS Credit Rating Company Limited www.vis.com.pk

22 | P a g e

REGULATORY DISCLOSURES Appendix III

Name of Rated Entity Faysal Bank Limited

Sector Commercial Banks

Type of Relationship Solicited

Purpose of Rating Entity Rating

Rating History Rating Date

Medium to Long Term

Short Term Rating

Outlook Rating Action

RATING TYPE: Entity 29-Jun-20 AA Stable A-1+ Reaffirmed

27-Jun-19 AA Stable A-1+ Reaffirmed 29-Jun-18 AA Stable A-1+ Reaffirmed

30-Jun-17 AA Stable A-1+ Reaffirmed 28-Jun-16 AA Stable A-1+ Reaffirmed

30-Jun-15 AA Stable A-1+ Reaffirmed 30-Jun-14 AA Stable A-1+ Reaffirmed

26-Jun-13 AA Stable A-1+ Reaffirmed 02-Jul-12 AA Stable A-1+ Reaffirmed

28-Jun-11 AA Stable A-1+ Reaffirmed 24-Feb-11 AA Stable A-1+ Rating Watch Removed

01-Jun-10 AA A-1+ Rating Watch - Developing

Instrument Structure N/A

Statement by the Rating Team

VIS, the analysts involved in the rating process and members of its rating committee do not have any conflict of interest relating to the credit rating(s) mentioned herein. This rating is an opinion on credit quality only and is not a recommendation to buy or sell any securities.

Probability of Default VIS ratings opinions express ordinal ranking of risk, from strongest to weakest, within a universe of credit risk. Ratings are not intended as guarantees of credit quality or as exact measures of the probability that a particular issuer or particular debt issue will default.

Disclaimer Information herein was obtained from sources believed to be accurate and reliable; however, VIS does not guarantee the accuracy, adequacy or completeness of any information and is not responsible for any errors or omissions or for the results obtained from the use of such information. VIS is not an NRSRO and its ratings are not NRSRO credit ratings. For conducting this assignment, analyst did not deem necessary to contact external auditors or creditors given the unqualified nature of audited accounts and diversified creditor profile. Copyright 2020 VIS Credit Rating Company Limited. All rights reserved. Contents may be used by news media with credit to VIS.

Due Diligence Meetings Conducted

S.No Name Designation Date

1 Mr. Tahir Yaqoob Bhatti Head of Retail

Banking May 21, 2020

2 Mian Salman Ali Chief Risk

Officer May 21, 2020

3 Syed Majid Ali CFO May 21, 2020