VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD...
Transcript of VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD...
![Page 1: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATION
Janet Schirm and Alexander Glaser56th INMM Meeting, Indian Wells, California, July 2015
![Page 2: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
BACKGROUND
2
PASSIVE GAMMA SPECTROMETRY FOR WARHEAD VERIFICATION
Characterize the potential (capabilities and limits) of gamma spectrometry for verification applications (using the template-approach)
Use simulated spectra for a basic test item with simple “diversion” scenarios
Identify possible areas of future research
THIS PAPER …
However, gamma spectrometry (alone) is not suited to determine fissile material mass due to self shielding effects; strictly speaking also not suited to confirm identityof any two items
Source: U.S. Department of Energy (photo); K. Seager et al., “Trusted Radiation Identification System,” 42nd INMM Meeting, 2001 (quote)
Successfully demonstrated as a verification technology “to confirm the identities of treaty accountable items” — both with attribute and template approaches (e.g. TRIS and TRADS developed at Sandia)
![Page 3: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
COMPUTER MODELAND BENCHMARK WITH EXPERIMENTAL DATA
![Page 4: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
MODEL EXPERIMENTAL SETUP
4
OF PLUTONIUM SOURCE (BeRP BALL) AND HIGH-PURITY GERMANIUM DETECTOR
John Mattingly, Polyethylene-Reflected Plutonium Metal Sphere: Subcritical Neutron and Gamma Measurements SAND2009-5804 Revision 1 (Unclassified Unlimited Release), November 2009
See also J. Mattingly and D. J. Mitchell, Applied Radiation and Isotopes, 70 (2012), 1136–1140
![Page 5: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
DISTRIBUTING N POINTS ON A SPHERE
5
Helmut Vogel, “A Better Way to Construct the Sunflower Head,” Mathematical Biosciences, 44 (3–4), June 1979, pp. 179–189 See blog.marmakoide.org/?p=1 for Python implementations in 2D and 3D
(1000 IDENTICAL DETECTORS TO INCREASE EFFICIENCY OF MCNP CALCULATIONS)
![Page 6: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
ENERGY BROADENING
6
FWHM1(E) ⇡ 0.00125qE(MeV) + 0.00090
�E(MeV)
�2
FWHM2(E) ⇡ 0.05086qE(MeV) + 0.30486
�E(MeV)
�2
USING BENCHMARK DATA FROM SINBAD (FOR HPGE DETECTOR) AND OWN MEASUREMENTS (FOR NAI DETECTOR) TO “BLUR” MCNP TALLIES
ESTIMATED FULL-WIDTH HALF-MAXIMUM FOR HPGE DETECTOR USED IN SINBAD EXERCISE
ESTIMATED FULL-WIDTH HALF-MAXIMUM FOR NAI DETECTOR (CANBERRA MODEL 802)
These numerical values can be used directly in the GEB card for the MCNP F8 tally
Alternatively, the F8 tally data can be energy-broadened post simulation (using these expressions) providing much more flexibility (one MCNP run, many detectors); thanks to John Mattingly for this hint
![Page 7: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
MEASURED AND SIMULATED HIGH-RESOLUTION SPECTRA OF THE BeRP BAL
7
Measured spectrum (SINBAD) Simulated spectrum
![Page 8: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
SCENARIOS AND RESULTS
![Page 9: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
SIMULATED SPECTRA
9
WEAPON-GRADE VS REACTOR-GRADE PLUTONIUM BALL, HPGE DETECTOR
Hypothetical RPu BeRP ball Standard (WPu) BeRP ball
![Page 10: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
SIMULATED SPECTRA
10
WEAPON-GRADE VS REACTOR-GRADE PLUTONIUM, NaI DETECTOR
Hypothetical RPu BeRP ball Standard (WPu) BeRP ball
![Page 11: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
THIS IS APPARENTLY TOO EASY
![Page 12: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
NOTIONAL DIVERSION SCENARIOS
12
FOR THE 4484-GRAM BERP BALL
Δ∆ = 20 mm (9% surface increase)
Δ∆ = 15 mm (23% surface increase)
Δ∆ = 10 mm (57% surface increase)
SCENARIO TYPE B: MASS UNCHANGED; INCREASING OUTER DIAMETER
Total count rate increases (essentially linearly) with surface area of item; straightforward to detect NOT FURTHER DISCUSSED HERE
BeRP Ball
![Page 13: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
NOTIONAL DIVERSION SCENARIOS
13
FOR THE 4484-GRAM BERP BALL
Δ∆ = 7.8 mm (50% of Pu removed)
Δ∆ = 5.9 mm (60% of Pu removed)
Δ∆ = 4.3 mm (70% of Pu removed)
SCENARIO TYPE A: OUTER DIAMETER UNCHANGED; REMOVING MATERIAL FROM THE INSIDE
BeRP Ball
![Page 14: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
300–700 keV RANGE
14
INTERPRET GAMMA SPECTRUM AS PROBABILITY DENSITY FUNCTION
![Page 15: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
CUMULATIVE DISTRIBUTION FUNCTION
15
300–700 KeV, REACTOR-GRADE VS WEAPON-GRADE PLUTONIUM
WPu
RPuDKS
![Page 16: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
ARE TWO OBJECTS (CONSIDERED) EQUIVALENT?
16
RESULTS OF A KOLMOGOROV-SMIRNOV TEST COMPARING RADIATION SPECTRA OF ORIGINAL BERP AGAINST MODIFIED BERP (300–700 keV RANGE)
HPGe
![Page 17: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
ARE TWO OBJECTS (CONSIDERED) EQUIVALENT?
17
RESULTS OF A KOLMOGOROV-SMIRNOV TEST COMPARING RADIATION SPECTRA OF ORIGINAL BERP AGAINST MODIFIED BERP (300–700 keV RANGE)
HPGeNaI
![Page 18: VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING NUCLEAR WARHEAD VERIFICATIONaglaser/CP053-Glaser-2015-INMM... · 2015-08-10 · VIRTUAL GAMMA-RAY SPECTROMETRY FOR TEMPLATE-MATCHING](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022040909/5e82a171a5abf5484a0a92e0/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
J. Schirm and A. Glaser, INMM, 2015
CONCLUSION
18
SUMMARY AND FINDINGS
Propose and agree on “universal test objects” (and their respective gamma spectra) for computational and experimental benchmarks
AREAS OF POSSIBLE FUTURE WORK
• Notional diversion scenarios using template-matching approach • Items with different surface areas, straightforward • Items with same outside dimensions, more challenging • Difficult/impossible for thick objects • Sensitivity of NaI and HPGe not too different for template matching
Propose and agree on reference match/diversion scenarios to further develop and validate algorithms (for example: Item should pass if age within ±10 years of template age)
Photo: Joint U.S.-U.K. Report on Technical Cooperation for Arms Control, U.S. Department of Energy, Washington, DC, 2015